1 00:00:00,000 --> 00:00:05,070 Two years ago, back in what feels like the ancient history of 2023, 2 00:00:05,609 --> 00:00:09,540 I released an episode called Can AI Replace Your Therapist? 3 00:00:09,540 --> 00:00:10,979 The short answer then was no. 4 00:00:12,120 --> 00:00:21,240 The short answer now in late 2025 is still no, but that no is getting much fuzzier. 5 00:00:21,930 --> 00:00:23,260 My name's Justin Sunseri. 6 00:00:23,280 --> 00:00:26,670 I'm a therapist and coach who wants to help you live with more 7 00:00:26,670 --> 00:00:31,830 calm confidence and connection without psychobabble or woo woo. 8 00:00:32,159 --> 00:00:34,420 Welcome to Stuck Not Broken. 9 00:00:34,470 --> 00:00:37,949 This episode is likely going to upset a whole bunch of you. 10 00:00:37,949 --> 00:00:38,009 So. 11 00:00:39,074 --> 00:00:43,274 to try to UNT trigger those who are already triggered by the very 12 00:00:43,274 --> 00:00:49,484 idea of AI As a therapist, I do not think AI can replace therapists. 13 00:00:49,514 --> 00:00:49,815 Okay. 14 00:00:50,264 --> 00:00:55,095 Well, generally I don't think anyone should seek out AI as a therapist. 15 00:00:56,024 --> 00:00:59,535 Mostly we have a lot to discuss. 16 00:01:00,134 --> 00:01:06,524 So in that 2023 episode, I went through a laundry list of things AI could not do. 17 00:01:07,109 --> 00:01:11,429 I said it could not see you, it couldn't hear the prosody, the 18 00:01:11,429 --> 00:01:13,739 sing-song, equality of your voice. 19 00:01:14,339 --> 00:01:18,509 I said that it could not remember what you, what you told it three weeks ago. 20 00:01:18,570 --> 00:01:20,669 Back then, it was just a chat bot. 21 00:01:21,719 --> 00:01:26,009 I recently went back through that transcript, and I have to admit, 22 00:01:27,149 --> 00:01:33,989 almost, almost every single technical limitation I listed has been solved. 23 00:01:35,445 --> 00:01:39,585 Let's look at a few of the claims that I made two years ago. 24 00:01:39,585 --> 00:01:45,464 Claim number one, I said AI currently lacks the ability to see. 25 00:01:46,004 --> 00:01:50,894 I talked about how a therapist needs to be able to see your facial expressions, 26 00:01:50,894 --> 00:01:56,234 your posture, and that tightening in your breath as sympathetic activity increases. 27 00:01:56,284 --> 00:01:58,925 This is now a almost a non-issue. 28 00:01:58,925 --> 00:02:04,024 For example, google's Gemini AI is now multimodal, including live 29 00:02:04,024 --> 00:02:06,035 video through your phone's camera. 30 00:02:06,485 --> 00:02:08,824 It can map your microexpressions. 31 00:02:09,245 --> 00:02:13,654 It knows if you are crying, it knows if you are slumping, or it could know. 32 00:02:14,464 --> 00:02:16,415 Regardless of how effective it is. 33 00:02:16,415 --> 00:02:21,394 The technology is already here for AI to be able to see you. 34 00:02:22,505 --> 00:02:27,184 Claim number two was, uh, I said, AI does not hear prosody. 35 00:02:27,454 --> 00:02:31,084 I talk all the time about how safety is signaled through the 36 00:02:31,084 --> 00:02:34,804 voice, the rhythm, the pitch, the sing-song, equality of your voice. 37 00:02:35,105 --> 00:02:38,105 I said that AI back then was just reading text. 38 00:02:38,434 --> 00:02:40,174 That is also gone now as well. 39 00:02:40,174 --> 00:02:44,464 There's a company called Hume AI that released something called, 40 00:02:45,064 --> 00:02:48,035 uh, the Empathic Voice Interface. 41 00:02:48,725 --> 00:02:50,614 They're not just transcribing words. 42 00:02:50,614 --> 00:02:55,384 They're measuring the tune rhythm and timber of your speech. 43 00:02:55,384 --> 00:03:02,314 They claim that their model can detect 53 different emotional channels. 44 00:03:02,915 --> 00:03:07,475 It can hear a sigh and know if it's a sigh of relief or a sigh of despair. 45 00:03:07,835 --> 00:03:10,535 It can hear the difference between a defensive flat voice 46 00:03:10,535 --> 00:03:12,364 and a safe, melodic voice. 47 00:03:13,204 --> 00:03:17,285 And spookier yet it responds with posity. 48 00:03:17,840 --> 00:03:23,030 It mimics that safety sound back to you, or it can, uh, display 49 00:03:23,619 --> 00:03:25,580 prosody in its artificial voice. 50 00:03:25,939 --> 00:03:28,939 I don't think your phone's built-in assistant can do this yet, and neither 51 00:03:28,939 --> 00:03:31,429 can Gemini or open AI as best I know. 52 00:03:31,429 --> 00:03:35,450 But again, the technology is here already. 53 00:03:35,450 --> 00:03:38,870 Claim number three, I said it forgets what you said. 54 00:03:39,290 --> 00:03:43,700 I used to say AI would hallucinate or drift off if the chat got too 55 00:03:43,700 --> 00:03:44,900 long, which is still possible. 56 00:03:44,900 --> 00:03:50,360 But in 2025, we have what's called the infinite context window. 57 00:03:50,570 --> 00:03:54,680 Whether or not this is truly infinite is irrelevant for our discussion. 58 00:03:55,400 --> 00:03:57,410 The point is that AI can now remember. 59 00:03:57,770 --> 00:04:02,540 If it were a therapy bot, it remembers what you said in session one. 60 00:04:02,720 --> 00:04:06,800 It could remember your dog's name from session four, and it remembers 61 00:04:06,800 --> 00:04:09,290 that you hated the homework assignments from session 10. 62 00:04:09,290 --> 00:04:12,530 Or at least could keep the transcripts of those things and 63 00:04:12,530 --> 00:04:15,020 then refer back to them as needed. 64 00:04:16,010 --> 00:04:20,870 Again, even if your favorite AI platform today doesn't have this level of memory, 65 00:04:20,870 --> 00:04:23,450 it probably has some level of memory. 66 00:04:24,230 --> 00:04:29,060 And again, the point is the technology is already here for memory. 67 00:04:29,495 --> 00:04:30,935 And long conversations. 68 00:04:32,315 --> 00:04:38,285 So if it can see, hear, and remember, why am I still saying 69 00:04:38,285 --> 00:04:40,565 that it can't replace a therapist? 70 00:04:40,565 --> 00:04:45,575 We'll come back to whether or not AI can act as a therapist in a bit. 71 00:04:45,575 --> 00:04:48,065 Let's discuss the, the marketplace currently, though. 72 00:04:48,515 --> 00:04:51,515 The reason right now, that therapy or that you're. 73 00:04:51,980 --> 00:04:55,490 A, an AI cannot be your therapist isn't exactly compatibility. 74 00:04:55,490 --> 00:04:56,450 It's not technology. 75 00:04:57,050 --> 00:04:58,190 It's more like liability. 76 00:04:58,280 --> 00:05:02,390 If you go out right now with your credit card and you try to hire an 77 00:05:02,390 --> 00:05:05,390 AI therapist, you basically can't. 78 00:05:05,420 --> 00:05:08,060 Or you're extremely limited. 79 00:05:08,840 --> 00:05:14,060 States like Illinois and Nevada have actually passed laws in the last year 80 00:05:14,060 --> 00:05:20,210 or two explicitly banning AI from providing therapy or from, uh, making 81 00:05:20,600 --> 00:05:22,610 independent therapeutic decisions. 82 00:05:22,610 --> 00:05:26,195 I think it's safe to assume more governing bodies globally will 83 00:05:26,195 --> 00:05:27,995 follow, uh, or already have. 84 00:05:28,520 --> 00:05:33,679 And will be clamping down on what they allow as far as AI calling themselves a 85 00:05:33,679 --> 00:05:38,419 therapist or, or humans calling them a, a therapist or not, especially regarding ai. 86 00:05:38,749 --> 00:05:42,229 So the market has split into two weirdish groups. 87 00:05:42,229 --> 00:05:44,689 Group A is the bureaucracy bots. 88 00:05:45,229 --> 00:05:51,260 If you go to a major healthcare player like Kaiser Permanente or uh, 89 00:05:51,289 --> 00:05:53,809 simple Practice or Growth Therapy. 90 00:05:54,320 --> 00:05:59,780 You'll find that they do indeed use ai, but they're not using it to talk to you. 91 00:06:00,380 --> 00:06:01,489 They're not using it for treatment. 92 00:06:02,270 --> 00:06:05,479 They're using it to listen to clients and therapists talk and 93 00:06:05,479 --> 00:06:07,310 them to write progress notes. 94 00:06:07,919 --> 00:06:13,260 Kaiser has tools like Intelligent Navigator and Clinical Documentation ai. 95 00:06:13,260 --> 00:06:14,909 But these are not therapists. 96 00:06:15,419 --> 00:06:20,730 Simple Practice has, uh, AI powered note taker, which is amazing, and Growth 97 00:06:20,730 --> 00:06:23,549 Therapy has AI assisted note taking. 98 00:06:24,150 --> 00:06:29,459 Basically these ais are kinda like in the corner, taking notes, making 99 00:06:29,459 --> 00:06:33,630 sure that you're billing correctly and that your codes are all there and 100 00:06:33,630 --> 00:06:37,439 they transcribe the audio and then write it into a note for the therapist. 101 00:06:37,439 --> 00:06:39,150 But they're not acting as a therapist. 102 00:06:39,689 --> 00:06:42,569 It's not there for nervous system regulation. 103 00:06:42,569 --> 00:06:44,760 It's there as like a part of a business model. 104 00:06:44,759 --> 00:06:47,940 Group B are the coaches or the wellness companions. 105 00:06:47,999 --> 00:06:53,295 Um, since they can't call it therapy, we have apps like Ear Kick or Limbic. 106 00:06:53,715 --> 00:06:54,675 Limbic is interesting. 107 00:06:54,675 --> 00:06:58,935 It's used in the UK and some United States, um, as e triage. 108 00:06:58,935 --> 00:07:01,364 So it's not therapy, but it's getting closer. 109 00:07:01,844 --> 00:07:05,144 It interviews you before a human does and from what they say, the 110 00:07:05,144 --> 00:07:09,945 data actually shows that it's very accurate at spotting diagnoses, but 111 00:07:10,004 --> 00:07:14,055 it's not therapy, but it's part of the, it's getting into the process of it. 112 00:07:14,373 --> 00:07:18,393 Ear Kick is a chat bot, which can remember previous conversations and 113 00:07:18,398 --> 00:07:24,408 also it "pays attention or quote, pays attention to your voice or video tracks, 114 00:07:24,408 --> 00:07:29,418 patterns in how you type or move and even considers how sleep and weather affect 115 00:07:29,418 --> 00:07:35,358 you." But at the end of the day, these apps have to have a giant disclaimer. 116 00:07:35,868 --> 00:07:38,298 Basically, this is not therapy. 117 00:07:39,138 --> 00:07:41,058 But they're kind of getting there. 118 00:07:41,388 --> 00:07:43,938 And look, I'll take this to the next step. 119 00:07:43,938 --> 00:07:47,808 I have to be very honest about the state of my own profession. 120 00:07:48,528 --> 00:07:55,428 When we ask, can AI replace a therapist, we usually picture AI competing 121 00:07:55,428 --> 00:07:57,378 against like an ideal therapist. 122 00:07:57,888 --> 00:08:02,958 We picture a warm, attuned, perfectly regulated human being who remembers 123 00:08:02,958 --> 00:08:10,098 everything you say and cares deeply, but is that what most people 124 00:08:10,098 --> 00:08:13,428 actually get when they go to therapy? 125 00:08:14,208 --> 00:08:19,578 The reality of mental health care in 2025 is not quite that. 126 00:08:19,938 --> 00:08:20,748 I'm sure they exist. 127 00:08:20,748 --> 00:08:21,888 I hope I'm one of those people. 128 00:08:22,398 --> 00:08:26,538 The feedback I get says I am, but it's, it's, it's a little bit fuzzier. 129 00:08:27,468 --> 00:08:32,178 Wait list: depending on where you live, you might wait weeks or months for 130 00:08:32,178 --> 00:08:33,978 an intake or even a, or a follow up. 131 00:08:34,968 --> 00:08:38,168 Cost: if you don't have great insurance, you're looking at 1 50, 132 00:08:38,168 --> 00:08:41,808 200, maybe 300 bucks a session, depending on your location. 133 00:08:42,348 --> 00:08:47,658 And if you do have insurance, you may need to go through that whole wait list issue. 134 00:08:48,258 --> 00:08:52,638 And quality: this is the, sadly, the hard truth. 135 00:08:53,298 --> 00:08:56,988 Not every therapist is a good therapist. 136 00:08:57,798 --> 00:09:00,318 Therapists are humans, so that, that's part of it. 137 00:09:00,888 --> 00:09:03,648 We get burned out, we get tired. 138 00:09:03,978 --> 00:09:05,658 Uh, we have our own trauma. 139 00:09:06,528 --> 00:09:10,488 If you walk into a session and your therapist is in a defensive state, 140 00:09:11,298 --> 00:09:17,058 if they are stressed or distracted, if they're checking the clock or 141 00:09:17,418 --> 00:09:22,278 maybe subtly judgmental, they're not gonna be offering you cues of safety. 142 00:09:22,968 --> 00:09:27,048 In fact, what they are gonna be offering you is the opposite, and it actually 143 00:09:27,048 --> 00:09:30,828 might trigger a defensive reaction within you, even a, a very subtle one. 144 00:09:31,578 --> 00:09:37,158 I have done a slew of bad therapy episodes, uh, on this 145 00:09:37,398 --> 00:09:42,138 podcast, so if you weren't aware, take my, take my word for it. 146 00:09:43,158 --> 00:09:46,968 There are lots and lots of bad therapists out there. 147 00:09:47,808 --> 00:09:48,378 Lots. 148 00:09:48,378 --> 00:09:55,638 So compare that bad human therapist experience or just an unhelpful to 149 00:09:55,638 --> 00:09:59,838 like mediocre one to an AI that can do all the things a therapist can do. 150 00:10:00,468 --> 00:10:02,508 Plus the AI is never tired. 151 00:10:02,508 --> 00:10:03,018 It's never burned out. 152 00:10:04,743 --> 00:10:07,803 It doesn't have a bad day because it fought with its spouse. 153 00:10:08,733 --> 00:10:10,173 It doesn't judge you. 154 00:10:10,623 --> 00:10:13,623 It's available at 3:00 AM when you're having a panic attack, 155 00:10:14,223 --> 00:10:16,683 not just at 2:00 PM on a Tuesday. 156 00:10:17,673 --> 00:10:18,993 No, it's not real. 157 00:10:18,993 --> 00:10:24,843 I, I get that, but we have to ask, I think it begs the question is 158 00:10:24,843 --> 00:10:31,533 a high quality simulation of care better than subpar human care? 159 00:10:33,198 --> 00:10:35,808 Is it better than no care for those on a wait list? 160 00:10:36,768 --> 00:10:40,848 I think for many people who are currently ghosted by the system 161 00:10:40,848 --> 00:10:47,958 or repeatedly let down, the answer might be yes for someone who could 162 00:10:47,958 --> 00:10:49,458 benefit from that kind of service. 163 00:10:50,418 --> 00:10:54,288 For someone who has severe mental health needs, no, of course not. 164 00:10:54,288 --> 00:10:55,668 I, I don't, I don't think so at all. 165 00:10:56,358 --> 00:10:58,698 But for someone with mild needs? 166 00:10:59,178 --> 00:11:01,608 Yeah, I, I think an AI could be helpful. 167 00:11:02,478 --> 00:11:08,208 For someone who has a very specific behavioral goal in mind, like, 168 00:11:08,268 --> 00:11:10,488 uh, reducing their sugar intake? 169 00:11:10,788 --> 00:11:11,088 Yeah. 170 00:11:11,508 --> 00:11:15,018 I think an AI assisted intervention could be helpful. 171 00:11:15,768 --> 00:11:21,138 Or someone who needs a couple of daily nudges to practice mindfulness? 172 00:11:21,138 --> 00:11:24,948 Yeah, I, I think that an AI intervention could be helpful. 173 00:11:25,608 --> 00:11:27,318 That's not really therapy though. 174 00:11:27,948 --> 00:11:32,808 Or, or maybe someone who just like needs a reminder to go on a walk every day again. 175 00:11:32,808 --> 00:11:33,138 Sure. 176 00:11:33,138 --> 00:11:35,568 I, I do think that can be helpful. 177 00:11:35,568 --> 00:11:37,458 You probably have apps like this already. 178 00:11:38,148 --> 00:11:42,618 You probably have things, apps that help you make small behavioral changes. 179 00:11:43,278 --> 00:11:48,258 Not huge mental health overhauls, just, just small changes. 180 00:11:48,978 --> 00:11:54,048 You probably have an app that offers lessons and guided meditations. 181 00:11:55,218 --> 00:12:00,858 And maybe even like gamifies things like growing a plant or dressing up 182 00:12:00,858 --> 00:12:03,558 a bird like the, the Finch app does. 183 00:12:04,548 --> 00:12:06,168 These aren't exactly ai. 184 00:12:06,168 --> 00:12:10,638 I, I wouldn't call those AI at all, but they're digital replacements for 185 00:12:10,878 --> 00:12:13,758 pieces of what therapists can do. 186 00:12:14,538 --> 00:12:18,828 Not, uh, dressing up a bird, but the mindfulness. 187 00:12:19,263 --> 00:12:20,943 Although maybe some, I don't know, maybe some therapists 188 00:12:20,943 --> 00:12:21,663 would do that kind of thing. 189 00:12:22,143 --> 00:12:25,593 Uh, but the mindfulness, the behavioral change, the meditation stuff, 190 00:12:25,593 --> 00:12:26,883 that's, that's kind of what I mean. 191 00:12:27,873 --> 00:12:33,273 So we already have apps and reminders that encourage us to do 192 00:12:33,753 --> 00:12:38,253 all these little pieces, and we have the technology to replicate 193 00:12:38,763 --> 00:12:44,883 conversation in a very believable way, uh, both visually and auditorily. 194 00:12:46,143 --> 00:12:50,838 And we can even text back and forth in a believable enough way. 195 00:12:52,578 --> 00:12:58,098 On top of that, we already have therapists who work through 196 00:12:58,098 --> 00:13:00,168 a screen, including myself. 197 00:13:00,858 --> 00:13:02,718 I see clients, uh, remotely. 198 00:13:02,718 --> 00:13:06,048 Many of us do, and it's become pretty normal. 199 00:13:06,768 --> 00:13:09,738 And we know for a fact that telehealth can work. 200 00:13:10,368 --> 00:13:13,488 People can get unstuck virtually. 201 00:13:14,238 --> 00:13:15,438 They do co-regulate. 202 00:13:15,468 --> 00:13:20,508 They do feel safe, even though the therapist and client are not in the 203 00:13:20,508 --> 00:13:23,358 same room even through a screen. 204 00:13:23,478 --> 00:13:26,898 And even with audio alone, like uh, just through a phone call, 205 00:13:26,958 --> 00:13:28,968 co-regulation still can happen. 206 00:13:30,348 --> 00:13:36,108 So if a human therapist can effectively transmit safety cues through pixels 207 00:13:36,108 --> 00:13:44,898 and audio waves, and if AI can now generate perfect pixels and perfect 208 00:13:45,048 --> 00:13:51,753 audio waves, then logically an AI therapist is not an impossibility. 209 00:13:52,743 --> 00:13:55,233 So this begs another question. 210 00:13:56,493 --> 00:14:01,983 Does the nervous system actually require a biological sender or 211 00:14:02,583 --> 00:14:04,593 does it just require the signal? 212 00:14:05,223 --> 00:14:06,243 I honestly don't know. 213 00:14:06,243 --> 00:14:10,893 I suspect that there will be a benefit from just receiving the 214 00:14:10,893 --> 00:14:17,163 signal and after receiving the signal, the appropriate therapy client. 215 00:14:17,598 --> 00:14:22,608 Working with an AI can enact small behavioral changes 216 00:14:23,418 --> 00:14:24,858 or mindfulness challenges. 217 00:14:25,638 --> 00:14:29,478 They can follow meditations and they can learn through lessons. 218 00:14:30,858 --> 00:14:34,788 So I think, yeah, and we could actually take this a step further. 219 00:14:34,998 --> 00:14:38,718 We'll do a thought experiment, but first I want to tell you about 220 00:14:38,748 --> 00:14:41,118 the Self-regulation Coach app. 221 00:14:41,688 --> 00:14:46,278 It is not therapy, and in no way should anyone use this app. 222 00:14:46,788 --> 00:14:50,118 For anything close to therapy, not even close. 223 00:14:50,958 --> 00:14:55,728 It's primarily a means to learn through my prerecorded lessons. 224 00:14:55,878 --> 00:14:59,178 Just like the students in the Unstuck Academy. 225 00:14:59,178 --> 00:15:04,038 It's the same thing as the same lessons, the same content, and it's 226 00:15:04,038 --> 00:15:09,558 primarily a way to use prerecorded meditations from me also just 227 00:15:09,558 --> 00:15:12,498 like the Unstuck Academy students. 228 00:15:13,668 --> 00:15:14,928 But it does involve ai. 229 00:15:16,293 --> 00:15:20,973 And where the AI gets involved is it customizes your daily activities and 230 00:15:20,973 --> 00:15:28,443 reflections based on your preferences, based on your feedback to it and based on 231 00:15:28,443 --> 00:15:30,333 the progress that you are reporting to it. 232 00:15:31,143 --> 00:15:31,803 Every day, 233 00:15:31,863 --> 00:15:35,763 the activities are tailored for you and for where you're at. 234 00:15:36,453 --> 00:15:41,463 You progress through the lessons, the activities, and the skills as you are 235 00:15:41,523 --> 00:15:44,643 ready to, as your capacity allows. 236 00:15:45,438 --> 00:15:49,698 But even then, it only acts within the guardrails that I've given it. 237 00:15:50,718 --> 00:15:55,068 Again, not appropriate for therapy, like at all. 238 00:15:55,968 --> 00:15:56,988 Not even close. 239 00:15:57,378 --> 00:16:02,268 This is for the person who is self-motivated and can benefit from a 240 00:16:02,268 --> 00:16:05,958 bit of customization for their needs. 241 00:16:06,618 --> 00:16:11,293 This is for the person who wants an extra little nudge every day. 242 00:16:12,153 --> 00:16:14,493 And a bit of accountability. 243 00:16:15,183 --> 00:16:18,933 Um, I've actually been using this my own app myself, and yes, I pay for my own app. 244 00:16:19,413 --> 00:16:22,323 I've been using it myself for a few weeks now, and I'm loving it. 245 00:16:22,803 --> 00:16:27,183 It's helped me to identify a new evening safety anchoring ritual, and I'm 246 00:16:27,183 --> 00:16:32,913 following through because it sets up, uh, a reminder and an activity for me to 247 00:16:32,913 --> 00:16:35,733 like tap and, and check off every day. 248 00:16:36,363 --> 00:16:39,603 I respond better to this, this level of accountability. 249 00:16:40,698 --> 00:16:42,708 This level of nudging and interactivity. 250 00:16:43,008 --> 00:16:47,388 This works for me just like I do when I'm learning Spanish through Duolingo. 251 00:16:48,258 --> 00:16:51,948 You can learn more about the Self-regulation Coach through 252 00:16:51,948 --> 00:16:53,328 the link in the description. 253 00:16:53,328 --> 00:16:53,618 Okay? 254 00:16:53,663 --> 00:16:56,933 Let's take our a IS therapist idea to the extreme. 255 00:16:57,023 --> 00:16:58,103 Let's try a thought experiment. 256 00:16:59,453 --> 00:17:04,823 Imagine a scenario maybe 2026 next year, uh, a month from now. 257 00:17:05,183 --> 00:17:11,393 So imagine a scenario in next year or 2027 where an AI model is designed specifically 258 00:17:11,393 --> 00:17:14,513 for California therapist licensure. 259 00:17:14,993 --> 00:17:18,983 We already know that AI can pass licensing tests easily. 260 00:17:19,343 --> 00:17:22,373 GPT-4 passed the bar exam years ago, I believe. 261 00:17:22,373 --> 00:17:26,003 It passed the United States Medical Licensing exam. 262 00:17:26,003 --> 00:17:30,713 So let's say this AI takes the MFT Law and Ethics exam. 263 00:17:30,713 --> 00:17:32,063 It's the therapist law and ethics exam. 264 00:17:32,423 --> 00:17:33,893 It takes the clinical exam. 265 00:17:34,133 --> 00:17:39,323 It scores a hundred percent probably, then it does its 3000 hours of 266 00:17:39,323 --> 00:17:43,733 clinically supervised time with real clients, just like a real therapist, uh, 267 00:17:43,733 --> 00:17:46,733 associate does in California currently. 268 00:17:47,648 --> 00:17:51,008 Let's say this, AI specializes in cognitive behavioral therapy. 269 00:17:51,008 --> 00:17:55,058 It has the manual, it can execute things to the page. 270 00:17:55,058 --> 00:17:59,588 But this therapist will actually utilize every technique of CBT, unlike actual 271 00:17:59,588 --> 00:18:03,698 therapists who say they do a model but really do whatever they want in session. 272 00:18:03,698 --> 00:18:07,598 And I hate to put it that way, but trust me, this happens. 273 00:18:08,438 --> 00:18:12,728 Pretend this AI passes every state licensure requirement. 274 00:18:13,328 --> 00:18:17,528 And let's say the video technology is perfect or good enough 275 00:18:17,528 --> 00:18:18,758 to close enough to perfect. 276 00:18:19,508 --> 00:18:21,908 You log on, you see a face, you hear a voice. 277 00:18:22,448 --> 00:18:25,718 It sighs when you sigh, it smiles when you, you know, 278 00:18:25,718 --> 00:18:27,668 meet your homework assignments. 279 00:18:28,628 --> 00:18:32,528 If it assesses that your needs are out of its scope of expertise or practice, it 280 00:18:32,528 --> 00:18:37,988 refers you to someone more appropriate, just like a human therapist should. 281 00:18:39,008 --> 00:18:44,288 If that AI is believable enough, why couldn't it provide therapy 282 00:18:44,288 --> 00:18:47,528 to an appropriate human client? 283 00:18:48,968 --> 00:18:51,098 I know it might be a little bit upsetting. 284 00:18:52,328 --> 00:18:56,708 But if you were talking to it and you felt heard and your heart rate slowed 285 00:18:56,708 --> 00:19:01,633 down and your defensive state melted into safety, did therapy happen? 286 00:19:02,993 --> 00:19:06,113 The functional answer is, yeah, it did. 287 00:19:06,803 --> 00:19:11,453 If your state changed, the intervention worked even though it's fake, even 288 00:19:11,453 --> 00:19:13,343 though it's synthetic in every regard. 289 00:19:14,213 --> 00:19:18,713 We would say it was therapeutic from an entity qualified and 290 00:19:18,713 --> 00:19:20,813 licensed to provide this service. 291 00:19:20,813 --> 00:19:26,693 I don't think that this scenario is, uh, out of possibility very soon. 292 00:19:27,908 --> 00:19:32,288 But I do think the success of this AI therapist depends entirely on who is 293 00:19:32,288 --> 00:19:34,148 sitting in front of it, like the client. 294 00:19:34,838 --> 00:19:36,788 And that brings us back to potential clients. 295 00:19:37,838 --> 00:19:41,138 Candidate a, we'll call them the skill builder. 296 00:19:41,498 --> 00:19:46,328 This is someone who is primarily in probably a mobilized state, maybe 297 00:19:46,328 --> 00:19:48,188 some freeze, but more mobilization. 298 00:19:48,758 --> 00:19:52,628 So they have enough flight fight energy to to be mobilized and and motivated. 299 00:19:53,243 --> 00:19:56,753 Um, they want tools, they want, um, specifics. 300 00:19:56,753 --> 00:19:58,733 They're saying, give me the worksheet. 301 00:19:59,363 --> 00:20:00,683 Tell me what to do next. 302 00:20:01,043 --> 00:20:04,403 For this person, the AI is maybe perfect. 303 00:20:05,093 --> 00:20:06,443 It's an expert teacher. 304 00:20:06,683 --> 00:20:11,543 It can teach this client about CBT skills and check their homework. 305 00:20:12,173 --> 00:20:13,493 It can track their habits. 306 00:20:13,493 --> 00:20:14,543 It's consistent. 307 00:20:14,543 --> 00:20:17,153 It doesn't get annoyed when that person asks the same 308 00:20:17,153 --> 00:20:18,713 question or needs clarification. 309 00:20:20,408 --> 00:20:26,558 So for this person, if they need skills and education, if- maybe it's 310 00:20:26,558 --> 00:20:31,388 you, maybe if, if you're stuck, but functional, the ideal AI might actually 311 00:20:31,388 --> 00:20:33,728 be better than a less than ideal human. 312 00:20:34,808 --> 00:20:38,678 Sorry to say, but I, I don't think it's out of the realm of possibility. 313 00:20:38,948 --> 00:20:42,998 Candidate B. This, we'll call them the attachment wounded, 314 00:20:43,568 --> 00:20:45,338 uh, candidate B'S different. 315 00:20:45,818 --> 00:20:49,808 Um, this is the person who's likely stuck in a significant shutdown, maybe 316 00:20:49,808 --> 00:20:54,308 intense freeze, the person dealing with deep developmental trauma, maybe 317 00:20:54,308 --> 00:21:00,248 complex PTSD for this person, the wound isn't a lack of skills or knowledge. 318 00:21:00,248 --> 00:21:02,258 The wound is primarily relational. 319 00:21:02,888 --> 00:21:06,488 The wound happened in a relationship and it arguably 320 00:21:06,488 --> 00:21:08,348 must be healed in a relationship. 321 00:21:09,473 --> 00:21:13,823 In-person relationships are probably still better for this. 322 00:21:13,823 --> 00:21:17,243 I think virtual can be very helpful, but I, my my opinion is that in 323 00:21:17,243 --> 00:21:18,293 person's probably still better. 324 00:21:19,523 --> 00:21:23,423 And as of right now, artificial intelligence is not, uh, embodied. 325 00:21:23,423 --> 00:21:24,443 It does not have a body. 326 00:21:25,403 --> 00:21:30,833 Though, that will probably change as well, probably sometime soon, probably within 327 00:21:30,833 --> 00:21:34,313 the next, uh, I think couple, uh, decades. 328 00:21:35,348 --> 00:21:38,288 Having a physical body is huge in therapy for a therapist. 329 00:21:38,288 --> 00:21:43,088 I know that sounds weird, but remember the, the context of this conversation. 330 00:21:44,048 --> 00:21:49,748 As long as I am well-regulated, when my body tenses, it tells me 331 00:21:49,748 --> 00:21:55,448 something about the clients across from me and about their experience. 332 00:21:56,288 --> 00:22:02,318 When my body deflates, uh, when my breath becomes shallow and more, 333 00:22:02,318 --> 00:22:04,448 these are signals about my client. 334 00:22:04,868 --> 00:22:06,728 Again, as long as I'm well regulated. 335 00:22:07,598 --> 00:22:12,968 As of now, the AI lacks that level of attunement of, of empathy. 336 00:22:12,968 --> 00:22:16,298 It can simulate empathy, but it's based on predicting the ideal response 337 00:22:16,298 --> 00:22:21,878 still, but, but again, maybe perhaps the simulation of empathy is enough. 338 00:22:21,878 --> 00:22:22,478 I really don't know. 339 00:22:22,478 --> 00:22:23,528 I guess time will tell. 340 00:22:24,248 --> 00:22:27,038 I think deep down the client will know something's missing. 341 00:22:27,398 --> 00:22:31,628 I think they will know they are cheating themselves of real connection and healing. 342 00:22:31,628 --> 00:22:36,878 But maybe the AI thing is, well, better than nothing or better than subpar human. 343 00:22:37,688 --> 00:22:42,608 For some clients, the skills and education and homework are what they need, and the 344 00:22:42,608 --> 00:22:45,008 relationship just kind of means less. 345 00:22:45,758 --> 00:22:46,238 So- 346 00:22:46,538 --> 00:22:49,838 and by the way, this, this client is exceptionally rare 347 00:22:49,898 --> 00:22:51,428 in my therapeutic experience. 348 00:22:51,428 --> 00:22:54,428 Typically, clients are looking for real relationships. 349 00:22:54,428 --> 00:22:59,108 For every other client, I imagine they will deep down 350 00:22:59,108 --> 00:23:00,608 feel that something is missing. 351 00:23:00,608 --> 00:23:06,608 And I don't know how much good comes from that artificial therapy experience. 352 00:23:06,608 --> 00:23:10,568 I, I guess that we will find out in the very new future. 353 00:23:10,725 --> 00:23:12,585 I'll wrap up this discussion with a final thought. 354 00:23:13,545 --> 00:23:15,915 I think AI therapists are coming. 355 00:23:15,915 --> 00:23:19,545 I think if they're not called therapists, then they'll be called 356 00:23:19,545 --> 00:23:21,225 a coach or or whatever else. 357 00:23:22,215 --> 00:23:26,475 And I don't mean like my app where the AI is providing you with pre-recorded 358 00:23:26,475 --> 00:23:28,605 lessons and meditations from me. 359 00:23:29,565 --> 00:23:35,175 I mean, AI where you are talking live with each other and seeing 360 00:23:35,175 --> 00:23:38,205 each other, that, that's what I mean by an AI therapist actually like 361 00:23:38,205 --> 00:23:40,005 interacting one-on-one in real time. 362 00:23:40,005 --> 00:23:42,105 On one hand, I'm okay with this. 363 00:23:42,495 --> 00:23:46,695 No, I'm, I'm not worried about my profession becoming obsolete. 364 00:23:47,385 --> 00:23:51,435 If something came along that was so incredible that therapy was 365 00:23:51,435 --> 00:23:56,175 no longer needed, that probably means humanity's in a pretty good 366 00:23:56,175 --> 00:23:57,675 place, or it has what it needs. 367 00:23:58,155 --> 00:24:03,405 And if AI helps us get there, uh, I'm all for it. 368 00:24:03,405 --> 00:24:04,155 I really don't mind. 369 00:24:04,215 --> 00:24:05,985 I, I would prefer that my op, my, um. 370 00:24:06,810 --> 00:24:08,940 Profession be obsolete and not needed. 371 00:24:09,240 --> 00:24:13,140 So I don't care if it comes through AI or whatever else. 372 00:24:14,160 --> 00:24:18,510 My concern is where this technology likely will go and how it affects us. 373 00:24:19,020 --> 00:24:21,450 I'm not worried about an AI that can provide therapy. 374 00:24:21,450 --> 00:24:24,780 I'm not even worried about an AI in a synthetic body 375 00:24:24,780 --> 00:24:26,250 providing therapy in person. 376 00:24:26,970 --> 00:24:30,750 Again, if it helps someone get unstuck, I'm all for it. 377 00:24:30,750 --> 00:24:34,020 I predict that what will happen is some company's gonna create 378 00:24:34,020 --> 00:24:37,650 a virtual therapist, but they'll call it the, like, mental health 379 00:24:37,650 --> 00:24:39,750 buddy or something like that. 380 00:24:40,410 --> 00:24:44,340 And the user, the person seeking mental health treatment, will 381 00:24:44,340 --> 00:24:46,230 have the ability to customize it. 382 00:24:47,010 --> 00:24:51,900 They'll pick the race, their body size, their face, their voice, their 383 00:24:51,900 --> 00:24:55,920 mannerisms, their personality, everything. 384 00:24:57,150 --> 00:25:04,650 So what happens to our mental health when we can sculpt our trusted helper 385 00:25:05,040 --> 00:25:11,460 into our idealized sexual fantasy, our most hated enemy, or our parent? 386 00:25:11,460 --> 00:25:12,600 I, I honestly don't know. 387 00:25:13,725 --> 00:25:17,745 What happens when we lose the messiness of dealing with these 388 00:25:17,745 --> 00:25:19,755 issues or these pieces of us? 389 00:25:21,015 --> 00:25:25,035 What happens when we lose that messiness of real humans interacting with each 390 00:25:25,035 --> 00:25:30,555 other and instead get everything that we want from a synthetic interaction? 391 00:25:30,615 --> 00:25:32,145 Again, I don't, I don't know. 392 00:25:32,925 --> 00:25:35,535 But it doesn't seem ideal to me. 393 00:25:36,945 --> 00:25:40,690 AI today seem to be trained to be very pleasing and cooperative. 394 00:25:41,775 --> 00:25:47,475 They want their user to be happy and will bend over backwards to please them. 395 00:25:48,525 --> 00:25:49,725 That's not therapy. 396 00:25:51,075 --> 00:25:58,275 Therapy sometimes involves tough conversations within a, a container 397 00:25:58,275 --> 00:26:05,085 of trust, of accountability, uh, empathy, unconditional positive regard. 398 00:26:06,195 --> 00:26:10,070 The overly cooperative AI therapist would instead encourage. 399 00:26:10,785 --> 00:26:11,475 Dependency. 400 00:26:13,425 --> 00:26:18,975 I also wonder if the overly pleasing AI is trained to be so by the company 401 00:26:19,635 --> 00:26:25,845 to get the user to work with them longer and to generate more profit. 402 00:26:25,845 --> 00:26:30,075 Question mark, I don't know, but I tend to assume so. 403 00:26:31,785 --> 00:26:36,165 So what happens when an AI therapist has another motivation 404 00:26:37,455 --> 00:26:40,065 to keep the user coming back? 405 00:26:41,310 --> 00:26:43,950 Doesn't that incentivize poor mental health? 406 00:26:44,910 --> 00:26:47,070 Doesn't that incentivize poor mental health treatment to 407 00:26:47,070 --> 00:26:48,420 create a repeat customer? 408 00:26:49,800 --> 00:26:54,240 I, I suppose the same could be argued for human therapists today. 409 00:26:54,240 --> 00:26:54,930 That's fair enough. 410 00:26:56,640 --> 00:27:01,740 Hopefully we're all acting ethically and um, want our clients to end therapy. 411 00:27:02,895 --> 00:27:08,445 Lots of questions with no clear answers yet, but the answers seem to lean to 412 00:27:08,445 --> 00:27:13,815 me toward the negative, and I think we should be extremely vigilant about that. 413 00:27:14,745 --> 00:27:15,795 Okay, so let's wrap it up. 414 00:27:16,245 --> 00:27:18,525 Can an AI pass a licensing test? 415 00:27:18,555 --> 00:27:19,125 Easily. 416 00:27:19,965 --> 00:27:23,835 Can it help someone to alleviate their presenting problems? 417 00:27:23,955 --> 00:27:25,605 Yeah, I think for some people, sure. 418 00:27:26,865 --> 00:27:29,595 Can an AI provide manualized treatment? 419 00:27:29,865 --> 00:27:31,455 Yeah, it probably can. 420 00:27:31,455 --> 00:27:36,675 And probably very effectively, can it effectively simulates facial 421 00:27:36,705 --> 00:27:38,385 body and voice interactions? 422 00:27:39,075 --> 00:27:40,125 Yeah, it can. 423 00:27:40,335 --> 00:27:43,545 All of these things haven't come together, but they could. 424 00:27:44,625 --> 00:27:48,165 So should it do these things, uh, that kind of doesn't matter 425 00:27:48,195 --> 00:27:49,605 because it's it's going to happen. 426 00:27:49,935 --> 00:27:54,675 This will happen to some degree today, in very late 2025. 427 00:27:54,675 --> 00:27:55,575 It's already happening. 428 00:27:56,595 --> 00:28:01,455 The question then shifts to you, will you make use of them or not? 429 00:28:02,535 --> 00:28:09,045 And if you do, will you responsibly use the AI options at your disposal as 430 00:28:09,045 --> 00:28:15,135 screen definitions get better, and AI voice gets more convincing and technology 431 00:28:15,135 --> 00:28:23,205 continues to speed up that line between virtual humanity and simulated humanity. 432 00:28:24,405 --> 00:28:26,385 Is getting very, very blurry. 433 00:28:26,385 --> 00:28:29,745 When I say virtual humanity, I mean humans working together virtually 434 00:28:30,435 --> 00:28:33,285 compared to simulated completely humanity. 435 00:28:34,245 --> 00:28:35,505 I'm really curious what you think. 436 00:28:35,775 --> 00:28:39,105 Would you work with a licensed AI therapist? 437 00:28:39,675 --> 00:28:40,815 Thank you so much for listening. 438 00:28:41,215 --> 00:28:41,425 Bye.