Speaker:

Welcome to tax bytes for expats. The top tax tips

Speaker:

you want to know as an expat, the podcast is here to help

Speaker:

answer the common queries and concerns expats have when moving to

Speaker:

or from Ireland. Complex taxes explained

Speaker:

simply, we'll focus on the irish and international

Speaker:

tax issues to be aware of to ensure you save time,

Speaker:

money and stress hi

Speaker:

everyone, welcome. To this episode of Tax

Speaker:

Bites for expats. We had a little bit of a hiatus over the

Speaker:

summer, but we're back with a bang and today we're going to talk with

Speaker:

Mel Morgan of

Speaker:

ukstatepensionabroad.com. mel is one

Speaker:

part of a husband and wife team which have extensive business, banking

Speaker:

and compliance experience behind them. His wife Martha is a

Speaker:

qualified financial advisor with the Institute of Bankers since

Speaker:

2007. She's many years financial service experience across

Speaker:

both private and retail banking. Mel is a commercial and marketing

Speaker:

professional with a passion for excellent customer experience

Speaker:

developed in luxury goods and the sport businesses. He holds a BCom

Speaker:

and MBS in marketing and financial management from the University of

Speaker:

College, Galway and UCD. The Morgans have a simple goal which is to

Speaker:

help as many people as possible avail of what is rightfully theirs to

Speaker:

build for retirement. And to date they have assisted hundreds of

Speaker:

people from around the world in achieving a favorable beneficial

Speaker:

result from the Department of Work and Pensions and UK

Speaker:

revenue via their website ukstatepensionabroad.com.

Speaker:

but I'm not going to spend any more time telling you about him. I'm going

Speaker:

to let him speak for himself and welcome him to this episode.

Speaker:

Mel, thank you so much for joining us. I hope my intro did you justice.

Speaker:

You and Martha have a very interesting background. I'd like you

Speaker:

to tell our listeners a little bit about how you got into this line of

Speaker:

work. Yes, both Martha and I worked in the

Speaker:

UK in the late nineties

Speaker:

for five and a half years and

Speaker:

we moved back in early 2000 and continues to work here

Speaker:

in Ireland and different areas of expertise. But

Speaker:

it was really at the start of lockdown

Speaker:

in 2020. I came across my old national insurance

Speaker:

card from the UK and there was a number in the back so I dialed

Speaker:

it and I said look, I wonder if there are any benefits? And

Speaker:

the girl at the other end eventually answered. She said how many

Speaker:

years were you there? I said five and a half. Oh, I'm terribly sorry. You

Speaker:

need ten to get any benefit. So I almost hung the phone up and

Speaker:

she whispered in my ear, she said but you can buy back 18

Speaker:

years. I said tell me more and that's what started it.

Speaker:

I discovered that I could buy back 18 years of

Speaker:

uk state benefit, state pension benefit for

Speaker:

less than 3000 pounds, and so could my wife.

Speaker:

So we both invested in that and we continued to

Speaker:

pay class two, which is the less expensive version

Speaker:

of this, until we hit our retirement age. So in total, by the time we

Speaker:

hit our retirement, we will have paid probably 7000

Speaker:

pounds in total. But that will mean that each of us will

Speaker:

get approximately ten to 11,000 pounds a

Speaker:

year. So that's somewhere between 20 and 22,000 pounds

Speaker:

a year in uk state pension on our

Speaker:

retirement between us. And that's in addition to our irish

Speaker:

state pension benefit, even for the same years, because they're treated as

Speaker:

AVC's. So firstly, that's fantastic, and

Speaker:

I can only imagine how happy you were to take that call.

Speaker:

I think for people maybe who are listening to this and aren't familiar with

Speaker:

the way that the social insurance systems work

Speaker:

generally, what you've alluded to there is really interesting that, you know, both the

Speaker:

UK and Ireland pay state pensions with reference

Speaker:

to essentially what you've put into the system. And

Speaker:

your business ultimately is allowing people to put more

Speaker:

into the system on a voluntary basis than they otherwise may have because of

Speaker:

their work record. So I suppose today, people listening who have ever

Speaker:

worked in the UK are people who may be interested in this topic.

Speaker:

Is that fair to say that you have to have worked in the UK to

Speaker:

be in the cohort? Is that a criteria that must have been met? Yes,

Speaker:

it is. It is. Their official line is that you need to

Speaker:

have three years consecutive working time in the

Speaker:

United Kingdom, be that anywhere in the United Kingdom, including Northern Ireland.

Speaker:

Is there a time limit for that since a certain date or just at all?

Speaker:

No, no, there's no time limit. There are time limits in terms of the age

Speaker:

of the people, and we predominantly deal with people who are pre retirement age, which

Speaker:

is age 65 and under. The root is a little bit different from

Speaker:

people who are 66 plus. It's quite a bit

Speaker:

different. Broadly speaking, if men born

Speaker:

before 1951 April and women born before

Speaker:

1953 April, they have no entitlement to the benefit because they are

Speaker:

captured in the old UK state pitch. But generally,

Speaker:

to answer your question, there is no real time limit. You could have worked there

Speaker:

in the seventies, eighties, nineties, two thousands and

Speaker:

2010s. It's amazing, isn't it? So

Speaker:

tell us a little bit about the people that you are working

Speaker:

with or the process. What does the process

Speaker:

look like? If somebody's listening to this and they're just not sure

Speaker:

if maybe they even fall into the category. What does it look like to kind

Speaker:

of go through with this? Technically, there are two elements

Speaker:

of the UK government you need to deal with. It is a

Speaker:

requirement, it's not a hard requirement, but it's a requirement of UK revenue that you

Speaker:

get estate, pension, forecast from the Department of Work and

Speaker:

Pensions. So that's one element, and the other is the full application to

Speaker:

UK revenue to HMRC. And the full

Speaker:

application, it's very simple, but on too

Speaker:

strangely complex. For instance, the main central

Speaker:

form is only a two page form, but the leaflet that goes

Speaker:

with it online runs at 37 pages. So

Speaker:

I see a lot of people. You can do this yourself, of course. I see

Speaker:

a lot of people do this, but they don't know what that they need to

Speaker:

send an appendix with it. They don't understand

Speaker:

that the way you answer certain questions will determine whether you're

Speaker:

in either of the two classifications. Let me explain the

Speaker:

classifications. Class two, which is what we've been

Speaker:

very successful, we're getting 90% plus of the people that we

Speaker:

deal with through class two, which is the least expensive option,

Speaker:

which is paying back every year, buying back for

Speaker:

165 pounds a year. So that's where the

Speaker:

3000 pounds for the 18 years come from. But if you

Speaker:

fail to convince the people in UK

Speaker:

revenue that you are entitled at last to, they will

Speaker:

assess you at class three, which for the same period of time is closer

Speaker:

to 15,000 pounds, to buy back those years than three.

Speaker:

Now, there are a plethora of reasons as to why they would

Speaker:

disallow you. So I suppose having somebody help you

Speaker:

navigate it sounds helpful, because even though

Speaker:

the process is relatively straightforward, it sounds like there are various

Speaker:

conditions that need to be considered along the way. Yes.

Speaker:

And simply put, if somebody's.

Speaker:

The key elements are you have to leave the UK pretty

Speaker:

much immediately after you finish your employment. And from

Speaker:

2006 until now, some or all of

Speaker:

those years, you've had to be what they call insurably employed

Speaker:

overseas, in the irish terms, that would be paying posi

Speaker:

in various other jurisdictions. It's a really, when you're

Speaker:

employed and paying tax and insurance in that country. And

Speaker:

this is a very important point, you've alluded to it, it's

Speaker:

actually done in isolation, to considering whether or not you are

Speaker:

entitled to a pension in that foreign jurisdiction. So taking your

Speaker:

example, or any example for somebody who has worked in the UK

Speaker:

previously, you can get a full irish state pension and a full uk state

Speaker:

pension. And it sounds like they're not impacted by each other.

Speaker:

That's very possible for the people that you have helped. Yeah. I

Speaker:

can't speak to the various jurisdictions around the world because I

Speaker:

don't know the rules in relation to all the pension

Speaker:

arrangements. But I know we started our business

Speaker:

with other irish people and it took me a long time to get

Speaker:

the Department of Social Protection in Ireland

Speaker:

to give me something in writing to confirm

Speaker:

that buying your uk state pension

Speaker:

years, that it wouldn't impact your contributory

Speaker:

PRSI social insurance pension in Ireland, even though it's for the

Speaker:

same year. The first question my wife asked me, she said, look, you can't pay

Speaker:

three grand to the UK government if all you're doing is

Speaker:

substituting those years for the years you're going to get in Ireland and you end

Speaker:

up with no net benefit, but it's treated as an

Speaker:

additional voluntary contribution. So it's

Speaker:

impossible to get both. If you meet the conditions, you can voluntarily pay

Speaker:

into the UK system. And did the Department of Social Protection, were they

Speaker:

happy that it didn't impact the entitlement here? I mean, in theory, if you've

Speaker:

put into both systems and you're not having a means tested

Speaker:

pension, you'd imagine they're in isolation. They are in

Speaker:

isolation, yeah. That's fantastic. There are means by which

Speaker:

you can combine the two, but I don't get into that.

Speaker:

In some respects, it might, with the benefit that you can get on the uk

Speaker:

side is probably in some respects better to keep it simple. I

Speaker:

would agree. So I suppose on that point, we often have questions from

Speaker:

clients there and where you have a partial PRSI

Speaker:

record in Ireland, so in other words, you don't have full entitlement, and you

Speaker:

may also have a partial one in the UK, maybe, where somebody

Speaker:

doesn't have the means to voluntarily contribute. The protocol that was

Speaker:

signed into force when Brexit happened essentially means that

Speaker:

there is an aggregation of contributions, so that

Speaker:

normally, if you wouldn't make it past the post in Ireland, because you don't, for

Speaker:

example, have 520 contributions, for example, they will

Speaker:

look at the number you've got in the UK and pay you a partial irish

Speaker:

pension and a partial UK one. That's a slightly different

Speaker:

scenario. And that can happen globally, I suppose. Well, with

Speaker:

Ireland and other international countries such as the US, we do have

Speaker:

reciprocal agreements, but you hit on a very valid point. And one thing

Speaker:

that I think is also interesting, and I don't know if this comes up often,

Speaker:

I suppose, particularly because of Martha's line of work previously, it'll be something that

Speaker:

you're very aware of is, you know, the value of having an

Speaker:

annuity. Essentially a PRSI or a uk state

Speaker:

contribution or state pension is like an annuity. It's x amount

Speaker:

of money that you have for life. And they are, as I understand it, quite

Speaker:

expensive in the market currently to buy on the open market.

Speaker:

The value in actually being able to purchase this, it's quite

Speaker:

good value for money is basically what I'm trying to say. Is that something that

Speaker:

your clients tend to kind of understand

Speaker:

or see? Yes, it is. And sometimes I

Speaker:

have a difficulty in terms of if somebody gets the class two

Speaker:

designation, they're very quick and rightly so, to pay the

Speaker:

3000 pounds and buy that back, because what you're buying is you're buying

Speaker:

18 years, which effectively is

Speaker:

18 years of a pension. I don't have the numbers in front of me, but

Speaker:

I'm pretty close. Even if you had three plus

Speaker:

18 as 21, that'll get you about current value, about

Speaker:

7.58 thousand pounds a year. So effectively, it's a six month payback, not

Speaker:

accounting for any tax. Now, where I have an issue

Speaker:

sometimes is for people who, for whatever reason,

Speaker:

they are denying class two and they are faced with class

Speaker:

three. It seems awfully expensive when compared to

Speaker:

class two, but it's still probably some of the best

Speaker:

value you can get to buy an annuity. But it's very difficult for them to

Speaker:

see that when they're coming away from, instead of paying 165 pounds

Speaker:

a year to buy a year back, they're paying 825. But it's probably

Speaker:

about a two and a half year payback. But equally, I think if they also

Speaker:

walked into their local financial planner and

Speaker:

tried to buy an annuity of that value, they would get a very,

Speaker:

very big shock as to what it would actually cost them, even

Speaker:

if they were doing it via a pension. But I can understand, I can understand

Speaker:

how people who think they might be entitled to class two

Speaker:

if in roughly the eight to 10% of people that I deal

Speaker:

with who don't get class two, they say, oh my God, it's very expensive, but

Speaker:

it's not. And it takes me a while to actually get them to

Speaker:

understand that. It's still remarkable investment.

Speaker:

What does working with your team

Speaker:

look like? Talk us through, because there's going to be a cohort of people here

Speaker:

who may have questions, but there also will be people listening, thinking, this is

Speaker:

interesting. I have family members, for example,

Speaker:

who I think need your services. What does it look like working with. You

Speaker:

effectively, just in terms of the processes. It's pretty much all done

Speaker:

online. Happily. We set up a system at the outset

Speaker:

that gets us into a situation where we're not dealing

Speaker:

with amounts of paper that we would otherwise deal with. So

Speaker:

pretty much everything we do is operated on

Speaker:

our platform. We ask people to submit the information into

Speaker:

our platform and that allows us to pre populate all the forms that are

Speaker:

required. It allows me to interrogate every case.

Speaker:

Oh, Martha. And to then

Speaker:

check what I know to be the critical aspects

Speaker:

and any difficulties that might be in the

Speaker:

application, to check to see if they've been filled out

Speaker:

correctly or if we can adjust something to

Speaker:

make it more palatable for the HMRC. And

Speaker:

then everything is done pretty much by docusign

Speaker:

requiring e signatures. Then I require a

Speaker:

again online, some appendices from everybody

Speaker:

to get their work record from

Speaker:

2006 or whenever they left the UK to date. Sometimes

Speaker:

I'll ask them if they can get, in the irish context, a PRSI

Speaker:

year by year statement, which is easy to get online,

Speaker:

to go with that as a convincer. Effectively,

Speaker:

for the international caseworkers, our objective all the

Speaker:

time is to make it easy for the international caseworkers in Newcastle upon

Speaker:

Tynee to tick the box and say class two. Yes.

Speaker:

Yeah, we know how to optimize the applications for people. That's

Speaker:

the key to it. Yeah. Experience counts for a lot with these things,

Speaker:

doesn't it? When you've seen things come across your

Speaker:

desk. Do people go to the website if they want to initiate

Speaker:

an application? Yes, it's all done through the website. And the

Speaker:

website is the fee. Our fee is

Speaker:

550 euro, which includes VAT. And that's unashamedly taken

Speaker:

at the outset. And that allows us to just go

Speaker:

ahead and process everything in a very fast

Speaker:

manner. Stephanie, one of the things that, particularly in

Speaker:

Ireland, has changed in the past three months, there

Speaker:

was a few radio programs that scared

Speaker:

the life out of everybody in Ireland about this thing coming to a shuddering

Speaker:

halt. This entire opportunity finishes on the 5 April

Speaker:

2025. But some broadcasters

Speaker:

have looked at this and they said, well, HMRC are taking about

Speaker:

eight to ten months to come back to people, which is true. And theres seven

Speaker:

months left. So its almost too late. And thats leading people at

Speaker:

the present moment in time to throw their hands up and say, look, im not

Speaker:

going to bother with this because im too late. That is not true. Okay, theres

Speaker:

still time. The applications are open until the fifth, but its going to concertina

Speaker:

together because as you get close to the deadline, they'll accept the

Speaker:

applications and when they get to assess them, they'll give eight

Speaker:

weeks from the date of the statement to make the payment. Okay. So it's still

Speaker:

open, even though it is closing quite soon. But the

Speaker:

deadline is the deadline for applications. Okay? So

Speaker:

therefore, if you're listening to this in advance of

Speaker:

April 2025, you still have time to act,

Speaker:

and you should do so because it does sound like once the window

Speaker:

closes, it is shutting. I know there has been

Speaker:

extensions, but it doesn't appear like there's going to be any

Speaker:

further. And this is obviously at quite a large cost to the

Speaker:

exchequer in the UK, so it's not going to be. I've been

Speaker:

asked to estimate that. It would be nice to estimate what it costs,

Speaker:

but I also think we're all living longer.

Speaker:

We are in a cost of living crisis, really. This

Speaker:

does require the ability to have some cash

Speaker:

immediately, which not everybody has. But if they do, it

Speaker:

is definitely worth considering doing this because it is a, to some

Speaker:

extent, it's an opportunity that's not going to be around forever and it's definitely worth

Speaker:

considering. Mel, thank you so much for stepping us through. I feel like we could

Speaker:

probably spend a lot longer talking about this issue

Speaker:

generally, but I think even what you've explained has been massively helpful

Speaker:

and should really incentivize people to visit the

Speaker:

website ukstatepensionabroad.com where they

Speaker:

can initiate an application and I assume

Speaker:

can converse with your team directly if they

Speaker:

have questions about the process from there on in. Yes. Fantastic.

Speaker:

Well, one thing I'd just like to say, steph, just that although applications are open

Speaker:

until the 5 April technically, because the fact that

Speaker:

everything is going to concentrate together at the very end, we

Speaker:

will probably close applications sometime in early

Speaker:

November because we're a two person team. If we have hundreds

Speaker:

of applications going in and coming out and have a sensitive

Speaker:

timeline on them within eight week to make a payment, we need

Speaker:

to make sure we manage that process correctly for people at the very end. Okay.

Speaker:

And it's going to get very tight. And what we do actually is,

Speaker:

and you asked about the process, is when people get their statement,

Speaker:

you have to be very careful in dealing with HMRC. As you know, they have

Speaker:

about 45 million taxpayers and if you're paying

Speaker:

them the money, it has to be done in a certain way.

Speaker:

And there are very, very strict parameters about that and also

Speaker:

very strict protocols about looking for

Speaker:

assurance from them by way of receipts,

Speaker:

specifics to make sure that your account has

Speaker:

been updated. And I.

Speaker:

It just means that we're probably going to have to shut up shop for new

Speaker:

applications in about eight weeks time. Okay. Because

Speaker:

otherwise it just won't work for us at the end. There'll be too many people

Speaker:

together at the same time. Well, it's been able to, you know, if you've made

Speaker:

a commitment and charge people a fee, you're basically saying we want to be able

Speaker:

to honor our existing clients and the. Yes, okay, that's really interesting.

Speaker:

Well, we'll prioritize release of this podcast

Speaker:

so that our listeners have as much time as possible. But look, thank you so

Speaker:

much for coming on. I know you're not currently in Ireland at the moment,

Speaker:

and it was a stretch to kind of find a time that worked to record

Speaker:

this, but it's been absolutely fantastic to talk to you more about it and

Speaker:

to learn a bit more. So thank you for joining us, and

Speaker:

anybody who wants to go to the website

Speaker:

ukstatepensionabroad.com will find more information in the show notes.

Speaker:

Thanks for joining us now. Thanks very much. Steph. Thank you.

Speaker:

Thanks for listening to tax bites for expats. Please do leave a

Speaker:

rating or review wherever you listen to your podcast. And as always,

Speaker:

remember to take professional tax advice specific to your

Speaker:

personal circumstances before acting or refraining from action

Speaker:

in connection with the matters dealt with in this series. The material

Speaker:

in this podcast is intended to give general guidance only.