1 00:00:01,040 --> 00:00:05,484 You're about to join Niels Kaastrup-Larsen on a raw and honest 2 00:00:05,484 --> 00:00:09,524 journey into the world of systematic investing and learn about 3 00:00:09,524 --> 00:00:13,160 the most dependable and consistent yet often overlooked investment 4 00:00:13,160 --> 00:00:15,988 strategy. Welcome to the Systematic Investor series. 5 00:01:12,800 --> 00:01:12,866 Hello everyone and welcome or welcome back to the Systematic Investor 6 00:01:12,866 --> 00:01:12,926 series on Top Traders Unplugged, where each week we have 7 00:01:12,926 --> 00:01:12,998 a look at the global markets through the lens of a rules-based 8 00:01:12,998 --> 00:01:13,010 in investor. HiNick. MynameisMoritzSeibertandtodayI'mstanding informyfriendNielsKaastrup-Larsen,whowouldnormallyrunthisshow, 9 00:00:39,235 --> 00:00:50,860 butatthisverymomenthe'sinroutetoCanadaandthereforeunableto get 10 00:00:50,860 --> 00:01:02,485 infrontof amic.JoiningmeforthisepisodeisNickBaltas fromGoldman 11 00:01:02,485 --> 00:01:13,335 Sachs,a regular guestonthis show,as manyof youwillsurelyknow. 12 00:00:22,960 --> 00:00:36,100 Today,NickandIwillfocusontheQISspace atlarge, 13 00:00:36,100 --> 00:00:53,620 discussingquestionssuchashow largeisthe globalQISbusiness?Isitgrowing?Whoare 14 00:00:53,620 --> 00:01:10,560 themain clients?Howmanyindicesareoutthere?What's theoutlookforthespace,andsoon?So,withthatasanintro,letmesayhellotoNickandwelcomehimtothe 15 00:01:10,560 --> 00:01:13,360 show. 16 00:01:13,920 --> 00:01:15,679 Hi, Moritz. Very good to be here. 17 00:01:16,160 --> 00:01:19,120 Good to have you here. How have you been doing recently? 18 00:01:20,160 --> 00:01:23,268 I've been doing well. It's been a busy period, I should say, 19 00:01:23,268 --> 00:01:26,894 and I spent a good amount of time with family over the last couple 20 00:01:26,894 --> 00:01:30,002 of days. I had my sons christening, so I had family and 21 00:01:30,002 --> 00:01:32,851 friends flying over from Greece. It was a nice occasion. So, 22 00:01:32,851 --> 00:01:36,477 that was like a small kind of break. But now I’m back in action, 23 00:01:36,477 --> 00:01:37,772 but I'm doing very well. 24 00:01:38,220 --> 00:01:40,300 Congratulations on that christening. 25 00:01:40,460 --> 00:01:41,100 Thank you so much. 26 00:01:41,100 --> 00:01:44,964 Anything else that's been top of your mind, on your radar? It's 27 00:01:44,964 --> 00:01:48,506 the question that Niels likes to bring up, market wise. Yesterday 28 00:01:48,506 --> 00:01:52,048 we've had a Fed decision. Maybe that has created some turbulence, 29 00:01:52,048 --> 00:01:53,014 I don't know. 30 00:01:53,420 --> 00:02:02,634 Yeah, I think what is on my mind – on the top of my mind, I would 31 00:02:02,634 --> 00:02:10,222 say this year has been pretty much like a bit of a debate between 32 00:02:10,222 --> 00:02:16,184 fragility and resilience. You kind of have events that you feel 33 00:02:16,184 --> 00:02:21,604 will turn against the overall market and the positive sentiment 34 00:02:21,604 --> 00:02:28,650 and the growth and then you have like no results, and so on, 35 00:02:28,650 --> 00:02:35,154 and so forth, kind of going against it. And the market seems 36 00:02:35,154 --> 00:02:41,658 to be quite resilient in terms of kind of absorbing this information 37 00:02:41,658 --> 00:02:44,368 and kind of consuming it. So,I would say if there's one thing 38 00:02:01,916 --> 00:02:16,784 that, you know, keeps me still awake and maybe kind of on my feet, 39 00:02:16,784 --> 00:02:30,590 as the days and months go past and we're kind of approaching November, 40 00:02:30,590 --> 00:02:42,272 it's this kind of pendulum between a fragile market versus a 41 00:02:42,272 --> 00:02:44,420 resilient one. Imean,I cannot call the shots, but you know, 42 00:02:06,840 --> 00:02:22,944 if this is one thing that, you know, probably entering the last 43 00:02:22,944 --> 00:02:41,732 phase of the year will be a memory of the year, that would be 44 00:02:41,732 --> 00:02:44,416 the one. 45 00:02:45,540 --> 00:02:50,160 Yes, I agree we cannot call the shots, and you know, personally 46 00:02:50,160 --> 00:02:54,395 I'm just, you know… Well, we're trading in a rules-based way, 47 00:02:54,395 --> 00:02:58,630 so we don't really care about equity valuations or anything like 48 00:02:58,630 --> 00:03:02,480 that. But to see equities performing so strongly again this 49 00:03:02,480 --> 00:03:06,715 year is really surprising. It's just nobody's able to beat the 50 00:03:06,715 --> 00:03:11,720 S&P 500. The Sharpe ratio of the S&P 500 has now decoupled from 51 00:03:11,720 --> 00:03:15,185 everything else. It's the best investment in the world. Untilit 52 00:03:05,306 --> 00:03:15,189 isn't. 53 00:03:15,430 --> 00:03:16,790 That is true. Until it isn't. 54 00:03:17,090 --> 00:03:17,210 Until it isn't. 55 00:03:17,570 --> 00:03:18,210 Fair, exactly. 56 00:03:18,290 --> 00:03:26,678 Yeah, so, maybe with that as a backdrop, it's a good opportunity 57 00:03:26,678 --> 00:03:35,066 to get through a bit of a performance update. These are numbers 58 00:03:35,066 --> 00:03:41,357 as of Wednesday evening, October 29th, so, month-to-date and 59 00:03:41,357 --> 00:03:48,347 year-to-date. The BTOP50 index 1.89% up month-to-date, and now positive 60 00:03:48,347 --> 00:03:56,735 2.35% year-to-date. SocGen CTA 1.7% for the month up, and just minus 61 00:03:56,735 --> 00:04:06,521 1% for the year. So, that is a good recovery, now in October. The 62 00:04:06,521 --> 00:04:14,909 Trend index plus 2.15% for this month and around flat for the 63 00:04:14,909 --> 00:04:22,598 year. The Short-Term Traders index from SocGen is up about 0.50% 64 00:04:22,598 --> 00:04:31,685 this month, and still down quite a bit - minus 4.6% for the 65 00:04:31,685 --> 00:04:32,384 year. Andas I've just mentioned with the equities, the 66 00:03:29,603 --> 00:03:44,687 MSCI World Index plus 2.8% this month, plus 22% this year. Aggregate 67 00:03:44,687 --> 00:03:58,514 Bond index plus 1.2% percent this month, plus 7.2% this year. 68 00:03:58,514 --> 00:04:14,855 And the S&P 500, the darling of everyone it seems, plus 3% yet 69 00:04:14,855 --> 00:04:32,453 again in October, and plus 18% and a bit this year. Isn't this amazing? 70 00:03:18,290 --> 00:04:32,458 Whobeats the equities? It's just tough, huh? 71 00:04:32,940 --> 00:04:41,740 It's phenomenal. It is phenomenal. And you know, it's not 72 00:04:41,740 --> 00:04:52,300 the first year we've seen that. I think, what was it, 2023? 73 00:04:52,300 --> 00:05:01,980 I remember everything was flashing red growth wise and we still 74 00:05:01,980 --> 00:05:06,380 had like rallying equity markets. So,to my earlier point 75 00:04:35,295 --> 00:04:40,947 I think we've been seeing this debate between, is the market going 76 00:04:40,947 --> 00:04:47,541 to continue going up in the way that it's doing it? And I think 77 00:04:47,541 --> 00:04:53,193 maybe the fixed income market is a bit more debated these days 78 00:04:53,193 --> 00:04:58,374 and obviously the place that bonds would hold in asset allocation 79 00:04:58,374 --> 00:05:04,026 portfolios. But I think when it comes to equities, they keep on 80 00:05:04,026 --> 00:05:06,381 surprising us in a way. 81 00:05:07,640 --> 00:05:11,111 Yeah, I mean it's kind of like you say, the equity risk premium 82 00:05:11,111 --> 00:05:14,315 where you expect to make 6%, 7%, 8%, something like that percent 83 00:05:14,315 --> 00:05:16,985 per year, that's like the long, long, long term historical 84 00:05:16,985 --> 00:05:20,456 average. But for the past five years that's not true. The past five 85 00:05:20,456 --> 00:05:23,927 years it's kind of like every year is between plus 15% and plus 86 00:05:23,927 --> 00:05:24,194 20%. 87 00:05:25,960 --> 00:05:27,560 Barring 2022, I guess. 88 00:05:27,960 --> 00:05:30,919 Yeah, I don't remember what… So, the COVID period you mean? 89 00:05:31,240 --> 00:05:36,244 No, no, 2022 was basically the inflation spike, and that was the 90 00:05:36,244 --> 00:05:39,580 time that both equities and rates sold off. 91 00:05:39,580 --> 00:05:41,614 Did the S&P have a negative year in 2022? 92 00:05:42,980 --> 00:05:46,340 I would think so, actually, quite negative, yeah. 93 00:05:46,740 --> 00:06:50,195 Okay. Okay. So maybe that's the exception. Butif they're up, 94 00:05:57,316 --> 00:06:31,688 if the equities are up, in my recent memory, it's always kind of 95 00:06:31,688 --> 00:06:50,196 like more than 15% in a year. Well,that is what it is. In terms 96 00:05:50,700 --> 00:05:56,640 of trend following, because that is a topic that's near and dear 97 00:05:56,640 --> 00:06:02,085 to our hearts, looking at October, it's been a great start 98 00:06:02,085 --> 00:06:08,520 to October. I mean I don't know the books of other CTAs but, 99 00:06:08,520 --> 00:06:14,460 as far as we're concerned, we've had a great time until around 100 00:06:14,460 --> 00:06:19,410 the mid-October, or the 20th of October, something like that, 101 00:06:19,410 --> 00:06:23,865 with long positions in precious metals, and long positions 102 00:06:23,865 --> 00:06:30,795 in livestock. It's just been a great month. And then a lot of give-back 103 00:06:30,795 --> 00:06:35,250 of open trade profits on exactly these markets; Palladium, 104 00:06:35,250 --> 00:06:39,705 gold, silver, platinum, you know, feeder cattle, live cattle, 105 00:06:39,705 --> 00:06:44,655 livestock, lean hogs. Those markets have been reversing and it's 106 00:06:44,655 --> 00:06:50,100 kind of like back to around flat to be quite honest. So,really 107 00:05:52,028 --> 00:06:18,468 just you turning their inconvenient give back of these open 108 00:06:18,468 --> 00:06:50,196 trade profits. But you know that is, it is what it is. 109 00:06:51,800 --> 00:06:55,688 I'm seeing similar things. On our side, it's kind of maybe still 110 00:06:55,688 --> 00:06:59,900 on the positive side for the month. Um, to your point, most of 111 00:06:59,900 --> 00:07:02,816 the return was driven initially by commodities and now 112 00:07:02,816 --> 00:07:05,732 they gave pretty much everything back. Equities are still 113 00:07:05,732 --> 00:07:09,944 kind of holding up there, and rates keep on being the same story 114 00:07:09,944 --> 00:07:13,508 for the year; keep on whipsawing, keep on losing on the 115 00:07:13,508 --> 00:07:17,072 trend side. And main drivers, yes, are pretty much equities, and 116 00:07:17,072 --> 00:07:21,608 then, I would say, some of the kind of long exposures in, in gold, 117 00:07:21,608 --> 00:07:25,172 aluminum, copper and good short on the sugar, kind of delivering 118 00:07:25,172 --> 00:07:26,792 some good performance so far. 119 00:07:26,840 --> 00:07:31,767 Yeah, sugar is a recent short entry that just continues to go down. 120 00:07:31,767 --> 00:07:35,557 Still, some of the grain markets still look relatively weak 121 00:07:35,557 --> 00:07:39,726 even though they've recovered a bit from their weakness in the 122 00:07:39,726 --> 00:07:45,032 past, say, 10 days or so. But I agree with you, the big whipsaw 123 00:07:45,032 --> 00:07:49,959 this year is the fixed income markets. It's on and off all the 124 00:07:49,959 --> 00:07:50,338 time. 125 00:07:50,920 --> 00:07:55,177 We were doing like an attribution analysis, somewhat like 126 00:07:55,177 --> 00:07:57,069 a straight line down. 127 00:07:57,800 --> 00:08:00,110 I’m not surprised. How's it looking for currencies for you guys 128 00:08:00,110 --> 00:08:01,160 when you do the attribution? 129 00:08:02,840 --> 00:08:14,761 So, I would say for the month it’s just flat pretty much, with 130 00:08:14,761 --> 00:08:23,931 the biggest kind of positive contributors being JPY and maybe 131 00:08:23,931 --> 00:08:34,018 on the other side is Aussie dollar and GBP. Year-to-date it's 132 00:08:34,018 --> 00:08:45,939 kind of the second worst past rates. You know, if there's one asset 133 00:08:45,939 --> 00:08:55,109 class that over the year has actually contributed positive, it's 134 00:08:55,109 --> 00:09:01,528 equities. No surprise again, right? No surprise. Andobviously 135 00:08:04,830 --> 00:08:19,755 the question then is how quick or slow the speed is to be able to 136 00:08:19,755 --> 00:08:30,700 sustain an exposure through April. So, get the recovery and then 137 00:08:30,700 --> 00:08:41,645 obviously work from then on or substantially degross at that point 138 00:08:41,645 --> 00:08:53,585 in time, and then missing some of the recovery and therefore building 139 00:08:53,585 --> 00:09:01,545 up again the exposure would take some time. So,it's a question 140 00:08:07,108 --> 00:08:18,845 of speed and volatility response are on the V shape. And 141 00:08:18,845 --> 00:08:31,649 I think that's the primary driver I would want to believe. Not 142 00:08:31,649 --> 00:08:46,587 that I have too much data to support it, but I think that's the 143 00:08:46,587 --> 00:08:59,391 main driver of dispersion that we've seen this year in the trend 144 00:08:59,391 --> 00:09:01,525 following space. 145 00:09:02,300 --> 00:09:07,892 I think that's true. It's the liberation day or the early April 146 00:09:07,892 --> 00:09:13,018 period sell-off. In our case it's not just been the equities. 147 00:09:13,018 --> 00:09:19,542 We got kicked out of some of the equities, but we also got kicked 148 00:09:19,542 --> 00:09:25,134 out of some of the currency positions that we had. And there 149 00:09:25,134 --> 00:09:31,658 were just a lot of positions, that we had on the books, that went 150 00:09:31,658 --> 00:09:36,318 to nothing or even reversed at that point in time. And,like you 151 00:09:04,916 --> 00:09:15,380 say, it's a function most likely of trading speed. Do you get 152 00:09:15,380 --> 00:09:25,844 back into these markets? Did you lose your position or not? And 153 00:09:25,844 --> 00:09:36,308 that very easily can make a difference of 10% for this year. 154 00:09:37,620 --> 00:09:44,412 I guess, quite interestingly, if you were to be very quick, you'd 155 00:09:44,412 --> 00:09:52,902 kind of capture some of the V shape at the time, but then the subsequent 156 00:09:52,902 --> 00:10:00,826 part of the year wouldn't work out in your favor. So, I think at 157 00:10:00,826 --> 00:10:06,486 the time we're just talking about the short-term traders actually 158 00:10:06,486 --> 00:10:14,410 doing well in the V shape. And that's I think part of the reason 159 00:10:14,410 --> 00:10:20,636 that you capture some of the first drawdown in deliberation day 160 00:10:20,636 --> 00:10:26,296 and then some of the recovery around the tariff pause. Ifyou're 161 00:09:38,936 --> 00:09:46,174 slower, you'll probably just stomach the whole V shape, and then 162 00:09:46,174 --> 00:09:54,070 recover with it, and then performing to this day, to your earlier 163 00:09:54,070 --> 00:10:00,650 numbers, basically capturing the equity trends. And I think there's 164 00:10:00,650 --> 00:10:08,546 some bitter spot, in between being too fast and too slow, whereby 165 00:10:08,546 --> 00:10:15,784 you just deliver, at the wrong time, that the market's eventually 166 00:10:15,784 --> 00:10:23,022 recovering. And it actually gave you a week to also crystallize 167 00:10:23,022 --> 00:10:26,312 the deleveraging of those exposures. 168 00:10:27,600 --> 00:10:38,072 There we go. Yes. If we could only know these types of things before, 169 00:10:38,072 --> 00:10:48,544 but we don't. So, we have to stick with our own systems and some 170 00:10:48,544 --> 00:10:57,520 of them are longer-term and some of them are medium or short-term, 171 00:10:57,520 --> 00:11:07,244 and that's what we do. In our case there are more longer-term but 172 00:11:07,244 --> 00:11:16,968 still we did get kicked out of some of these positions and then 173 00:11:16,968 --> 00:11:23,760 it really takes a while to get back on. Ithinkthere were just 174 00:10:30,465 --> 00:10:36,768 two or three equity markets, if I remember that correctly, where 175 00:10:36,768 --> 00:10:44,790 we didn't lose our position. I think one was the Hang Seng, I think 176 00:10:44,790 --> 00:10:51,093 the share price index, the Aussie index, and the South African 177 00:10:51,093 --> 00:10:57,969 equity index. Those three we kind of like capped, but all the 178 00:10:57,969 --> 00:11:04,845 other ones; TOPIX, S&P 500, NASDAQ, go down the list, all the 179 00:11:04,845 --> 00:11:11,721 European indices, we just lost all our own positions in April. And 180 00:11:11,721 --> 00:11:18,024 then it probably took until, I don't remember, July, August, something 181 00:11:18,024 --> 00:11:23,754 like that to get back in. Yeah, quite some time. 182 00:11:23,920 --> 00:11:27,660 And that's basically I guess some sort of threshold based criterion 183 00:11:27,660 --> 00:11:31,740 to keep or not the position. Because we have zero, flat zero. 184 00:11:32,210 --> 00:11:36,722 Yeah. We have our exits, you know, different types of exits. Some 185 00:11:36,722 --> 00:11:40,858 are trailing stops, some have other rules. But we're not forcing 186 00:11:40,858 --> 00:11:44,618 ourselves to reverse the position into shorts. There is a 187 00:11:44,618 --> 00:11:49,130 kind of like neutral segment or area, and that's what we've hit. 188 00:11:49,250 --> 00:11:50,210 No trade zone. 189 00:11:51,090 --> 00:12:13,730 Exactly, exactly. So QIS, look, this is an interesting business. 190 00:12:13,730 --> 00:12:47,690 It's also, in a way, I would say, a little bit opaque to the outside 191 00:12:47,690 --> 00:13:12,594 observer - like to most people, really. They know QIS means 192 00:13:12,594 --> 00:13:30,706 Quantitative Investment Strategies, it's a business and activity 193 00:13:30,706 --> 00:13:55,610 that pretty much all of the larger investment banks engage in 194 00:13:55,610 --> 00:14:18,250 these days. It's you know, focused on risk premium indices, 195 00:14:18,250 --> 00:14:40,890 advanced beta type of strategies, that type of stuff, designed 196 00:14:40,890 --> 00:14:52,210 and then sold to clients. Butit's kind of difficult for people 197 00:12:07,344 --> 00:12:37,530 to see how large it is, who the participants are, who the clients 198 00:12:37,530 --> 00:13:03,072 are, how these deals are transacted, how the exposure is transferred 199 00:13:03,072 --> 00:13:35,580 from a bank to a client, and these types of things. So, I thought 200 00:13:35,580 --> 00:14:08,088 with you on the show today, that would be a good topic to just 201 00:14:08,088 --> 00:14:33,630 speak about the QIS business, more from a macro perspective, at 202 00:14:33,630 --> 00:14:52,206 large and chat about how large it is. Andspeaking about the size 203 00:12:01,265 --> 00:12:25,685 of this space, there is a survey that was run by Albourne, 204 00:12:25,685 --> 00:12:44,000 the alternative investment advisory firm, in the first half 205 00:12:44,000 --> 00:13:08,420 year of 2025. So, that's a pretty recent survey. And they say 206 00:13:08,420 --> 00:13:30,805 that the total notional assets under management, they have hit a 207 00:13:30,805 --> 00:13:51,155 new all-time high at about US$1,300 billion. So, US$1,300 billion, 208 00:13:51,155 --> 00:14:13,540 and it's a new all-time high. Which means this space continues 209 00:14:13,540 --> 00:14:33,890 to grow, and the US$1,300 billion, they're split roughly 50/50 210 00:14:33,890 --> 00:14:52,205 between Bank QIS offerings and asset management QIS offerings. So,asset 211 00:11:57,030 --> 00:12:14,850 managers also have quantitative investment strategies. 212 00:12:14,850 --> 00:12:50,490 Some of you folks may know some risk premia UCITS funds or, 213 00:12:50,490 --> 00:13:20,190 you know, there are some asset management firms specializing in 214 00:13:20,190 --> 00:13:49,890 risk premia strategies that would kind of count towards that 215 00:13:49,890 --> 00:14:22,560 that 50%. But it's a relatively, I would say, large number, 216 00:14:22,560 --> 00:14:52,260 US$1,300 billion. And the largest part of that is equities. 217 00:11:51,090 --> 00:12:12,501 Equitiesis more than half of all the exposure, of all the strategies 218 00:12:12,501 --> 00:12:28,971 that are linked to equity type of strategies, equity long/short 219 00:12:28,971 --> 00:12:45,441 factor type of exposures, followed by multi asset class strategies, 220 00:12:45,441 --> 00:13:00,264 then commodities and quite surprisingly I was thinking that 221 00:13:00,264 --> 00:13:18,381 fixed income would have a much bigger footprint. But fixed income 222 00:13:18,381 --> 00:13:36,498 is only US$50 billion. Even though fixed income markets are gigantically 223 00:13:36,498 --> 00:13:56,262 large markets. But in QIS space, on a relative basis, it kind 224 00:13:56,262 --> 00:14:16,026 of seems to me that they're underrepresented, as is FX with only 225 00:14:16,026 --> 00:14:35,790 US$27 billion, and credit with US$13 billion. So that is a backdrop. 226 00:14:35,790 --> 00:14:52,260 Do you think these numbers make sense to you, Nick? 227 00:14:52,920 --> 00:18:26,256 Yeah. So, look, do the numbers make sense? There'sa reporting convention 228 00:15:07,632 --> 00:15:48,090 here that I believe different banks are utilizing, and maybe asset 229 00:15:48,090 --> 00:16:35,904 managers. I think on the asset manager side it’s a bit easier because 230 00:16:35,904 --> 00:17:12,684 that's the actual funded exposure. When you look into broker 231 00:17:12,684 --> 00:17:49,464 dealers, the way that QIS products are distributed is either 232 00:17:49,464 --> 00:18:26,244 via kind of unfunded swaps or via sometimes call options. So,the 233 00:15:00,970 --> 00:15:53,295 way that we can think of assets here can be debated. Do you 234 00:15:53,295 --> 00:16:37,570 do a look through leverage adjustment? Do you do delta adjustment, 235 00:16:37,570 --> 00:17:21,845 if that is an option? There are different conventions. It is 236 00:17:21,845 --> 00:17:58,070 unclear to me whether those conventions are properly utilized 237 00:17:58,070 --> 00:18:26,245 and uniformly applied across the reporting banks. ButI guess, 238 00:15:03,411 --> 00:15:52,369 in the grand scheme of things, if you just take at the minimum the 239 00:15:52,369 --> 00:16:30,836 broker dealer sum, which is close to the US$600 billion mark, 240 00:16:30,836 --> 00:17:12,800 I would say with some confidence of plus or minus 100 (I'm 241 00:17:12,800 --> 00:17:58,261 just making it up really. I don't really have hard data to support 242 00:17:58,261 --> 00:18:26,237 it), I think it's in the right ballpark. Now,if you take asset 243 00:15:09,585 --> 00:15:46,248 managers into the mix, maybe there is some double counting because 244 00:15:46,248 --> 00:16:22,911 obviously asset managers are very active in the QIS space and 245 00:16:22,911 --> 00:17:06,240 some of them do utilize QIS products. So, in the context of reporting, 246 00:17:06,240 --> 00:17:39,570 you might end up having both broker dealers reporting numbers 247 00:17:39,570 --> 00:18:09,567 for specific strategies which are eventually deployed by asset 248 00:18:09,567 --> 00:18:26,232 managers that also report numbers. So,there could be some 249 00:15:09,585 --> 00:15:39,582 double counting here, there could be some reporting conventions 250 00:15:39,582 --> 00:16:12,912 that are not necessarily uniformly applied on the broker dealer 251 00:16:12,912 --> 00:16:52,908 side. But broadly speaking, it is a business that has been growing 252 00:16:52,908 --> 00:17:29,571 over the years. There have been some winter periods that we 253 00:17:29,571 --> 00:18:06,234 can identify, maybe around 2018 and 2021, on the reasons that 254 00:18:06,234 --> 00:18:26,232 we can potentially discuss later on. Toyour question on the 255 00:15:10,995 --> 00:15:47,145 asset class split, it's interesting to see that the equity 256 00:15:47,145 --> 00:16:23,295 long-only space is by far dominating the asset manager world. 257 00:16:23,295 --> 00:17:10,290 And that's more like the smart beta of the world. So, anything that 258 00:17:10,290 --> 00:17:50,055 is quant enhanced and delivers an equity exposure that is supposed 259 00:17:50,055 --> 00:18:26,205 to outperform a typical benchmark would come into that pocket. 260 00:14:52,920 --> 00:15:49,050 It'sless so on the bank side. I think the bank, or the broker dealer 261 00:15:49,050 --> 00:16:26,470 asset class contribution is more evenly without that being even, 262 00:16:26,470 --> 00:17:11,374 but more evenly split between the asset classes. I would say part 263 00:17:11,374 --> 00:18:07,504 of the reason why you see less on the fixed income and FX side is 264 00:18:07,504 --> 00:18:26,214 that historically liquidity has improved. Ifyou move away from 265 00:15:08,840 --> 00:15:47,048 the Delta 1 space on the option side, which is typically the 266 00:15:47,048 --> 00:16:25,256 one that banks are much more focused on, is something that grew 267 00:16:25,256 --> 00:17:03,464 over the years. I think the equity space is more natural. That's 268 00:17:03,464 --> 00:17:35,304 the equity long/short and that's basically the genesis of the 269 00:17:35,304 --> 00:18:13,512 QIS businesses. So, it has grown over the years. I think commodities 270 00:18:13,512 --> 00:18:26,248 is the other one. Yougo back to those rolling futures and how 271 00:15:27,201 --> 00:16:09,100 you can indexify commodity exposure, both on the beta side as 272 00:16:09,100 --> 00:17:02,426 well as on the long/short side multi asset is again kind of a CTA 273 00:17:02,426 --> 00:17:55,752 type of a place. There is also a good amount of application in the 274 00:17:55,752 --> 00:18:26,260 retail space when it comes to multi asset. IthinkFX, fixed income 275 00:15:18,315 --> 00:16:34,500 are in their growth phase, if we were to say. And even if we look 276 00:16:34,500 --> 00:17:25,290 into kind of academic activity, it has been massively more 277 00:17:25,290 --> 00:18:26,238 on the equity side and less so on the other asset class. So,I think 278 00:15:12,918 --> 00:16:32,910 it's a combination, I guess, of features of the market. But I 279 00:16:32,910 --> 00:17:46,236 would certainly flag that all asset classes are now becoming part 280 00:17:46,236 --> 00:18:26,232 of the toolkit of broker dealers. 281 00:18:27,971 --> 00:18:52,736 I also now see a lot of multi QIS offerings in the way that banks 282 00:18:52,736 --> 00:19:07,595 would combine say their commodity carry strategy with their 283 00:19:07,595 --> 00:19:25,756 FX carry strategy and an equity carry strategy in order to 284 00:19:25,756 --> 00:19:43,917 create a cross asset carry basket that's also multi asset. But 285 00:19:43,917 --> 00:20:03,729 back to the numbers. I think just to put this in perspective, 286 00:20:03,729 --> 00:20:18,588 the numbers could be conservative, they could also be 287 00:20:18,588 --> 00:20:20,239 aggressive. Therecould be funds out there, asset managers, 288 00:18:41,579 --> 00:18:58,589 maybe hedge funds, just people trading risk premium strategies that 289 00:18:58,589 --> 00:19:17,300 are not reporting to that survey. Think about a hedge fund, 290 00:19:17,300 --> 00:19:39,413 maybe that hedge fund is not covered by that survey and they may 291 00:19:39,413 --> 00:19:58,124 run whatever, like a few hundred million in notion of exposure 292 00:19:58,124 --> 00:20:15,134 in risk premium type of strategies, but they're not factored 293 00:20:15,134 --> 00:20:20,237 into this survey. Andthen it could also be, on the other side, 294 00:18:47,671 --> 00:19:09,341 like you say, there could be double counting which could happen 295 00:19:09,341 --> 00:19:32,981 if, for instance, you swap exposure of a strategy to an asset 296 00:19:32,981 --> 00:19:54,651 management firm and the asset management firm then on sells it 297 00:19:54,651 --> 00:20:18,291 to their client. You report it and the asset management firm reports 298 00:20:18,291 --> 00:20:20,261 it. Andthen what you've mentioned, the delta adjustment or 299 00:18:44,810 --> 00:19:05,391 the leverage adjustment is, you know, if you're selling a call 300 00:19:05,391 --> 00:19:25,972 option linked exposure to one of these strategies, it may have 301 00:19:25,972 --> 00:19:50,295 an initial delta of 0.5. But the question is, do you report that 302 00:19:50,295 --> 00:20:12,747 delta adjusted exposure or do you report the full notional of the 303 00:20:12,747 --> 00:20:20,231 option to the survey? So,let's take these numbers with 304 00:18:38,027 --> 00:18:56,463 a pinch of salt. But the, I guess, overarching statement here 305 00:18:56,463 --> 00:19:19,927 is that that space is, I would say, pretty large now and it's growing. 306 00:19:19,927 --> 00:19:38,363 And there's a chart included in the survey where essentially these 307 00:19:38,363 --> 00:19:58,475 assets, with the exception of what you've called like one or two, 308 00:19:58,475 --> 00:20:16,911 three winter quartiles, like three months or so, but they're essentially 309 00:20:16,911 --> 00:20:20,263 going up. 310 00:20:20,841 --> 00:20:37,156 Yeah, I mean that's a fair statement. It is a space that has 311 00:20:37,156 --> 00:20:52,216 been evolving in a variety of ways. Maybe it's asset class allocations, 312 00:20:52,216 --> 00:21:07,276 maybe it's new markets that are traded, but also users on the 313 00:21:07,276 --> 00:21:21,081 client side have kind of increased over the years. You know, 314 00:21:21,081 --> 00:21:28,611 we can also discuss that part. Maybethe one thing that I would 315 00:20:24,180 --> 00:20:30,858 flag, the one last thing that I would flag and then happy to go 316 00:20:30,858 --> 00:20:37,059 to the client side, is that there is also an element of substitution, 317 00:20:37,059 --> 00:20:43,260 to your point. So, if today there is a, I don't know, US$100 318 00:20:43,260 --> 00:20:49,461 million exposure in a CTA that is now transferred into a QIS product, 319 00:20:49,461 --> 00:20:54,708 the market still consumes the same level of liquidity demand. It's 320 00:20:54,708 --> 00:21:00,432 just now marked under the QIS kind of badge and therefore would 321 00:21:00,432 --> 00:21:07,110 be seen as an increase in the multi asset pocket of a survey as 322 00:21:07,110 --> 00:21:12,357 such, when in reality just a substitution effect from what otherwise 323 00:21:12,357 --> 00:21:19,035 was like a funded exposure on a CTA. I'm just making that example 324 00:21:19,035 --> 00:21:23,805 whereby a substitution effect could also be present here, more 325 00:21:23,805 --> 00:21:28,575 so than just genuine growth - another asterisk for you. 326 00:21:29,431 --> 00:21:32,950 Yes, yes, there are many asterisks. You've mentioned clients, 327 00:21:32,950 --> 00:21:36,860 Nick, and I think you've mentioned that there's new clients 328 00:21:36,860 --> 00:21:41,552 coming in. So maybe let's talk about that. Who's interested in this? 329 00:21:41,552 --> 00:21:46,635 Who is your usual client and how has the spectrum of clients changed 330 00:21:46,635 --> 00:21:47,808 over the year? 331 00:21:48,231 --> 00:22:10,929 Yes, so the QIS space started maybe 15 years ago. We can point 332 00:22:10,929 --> 00:22:35,373 in a timeline as to where was the first, maybe, QIS trade. I would 333 00:22:35,373 --> 00:22:56,325 think of it either coming from the commodity space and those rolling 334 00:22:56,325 --> 00:23:13,785 futures indices that were built to deliver kind of economic 335 00:23:13,785 --> 00:23:29,499 exposure into commodities without having to hold physical commodities. 336 00:23:29,499 --> 00:23:50,451 So, that was one reason why those QIS teams initially were formed. 337 00:23:50,451 --> 00:24:13,149 And then the other space or the other place, if you like, that 338 00:24:13,149 --> 00:24:34,101 we saw origination of ideas and indices was post GFC, and some 339 00:24:34,101 --> 00:24:56,799 of the work done by some of the Nordic pensions to replace or 340 00:24:56,799 --> 00:25:14,259 maybe enhance their risk profile by risk factors, and kind 341 00:25:14,259 --> 00:25:28,227 of transitioning or repurposing how they think about 342 00:25:28,227 --> 00:25:47,433 diversification away from asset class mix into kind of a factor 343 00:25:47,433 --> 00:26:10,131 mix. And that was the time that some of the banks started working 344 00:26:10,131 --> 00:26:24,099 on equity market neutral strategies, some volatility carry 345 00:26:24,099 --> 00:26:38,067 strategies, you know, version 1 at the time. And,in this regard, 346 00:22:08,227 --> 00:23:08,215 the primary users in the early days were either asset owners… So, 347 00:23:08,215 --> 00:23:58,205 we can talk about large pension funds, sovereign wealth funds 348 00:23:58,205 --> 00:24:58,193 across the globe. You know, there are some regional kind of shifts, 349 00:24:58,193 --> 00:25:58,181 that happened over the years, and happy to go through that. And 350 00:25:58,181 --> 00:26:38,173 then asset managers, these are the primary users. Ifyou do kind 351 00:22:13,443 --> 00:23:29,079 of a fast forward to today, you can widen the spectrum quite 352 00:23:29,079 --> 00:24:38,412 substantially and you can go anywhere from private banks to hedge 353 00:24:38,412 --> 00:25:41,442 funds. So, the utilization of the technology and the utilization 354 00:25:41,442 --> 00:26:38,169 of this IP has massively expanded across the segment. Andone 355 00:21:55,217 --> 00:22:37,133 could think of a QIS as offering nothing more than, I guess 356 00:22:37,133 --> 00:23:22,542 in a good way, kind of a convenience store in the sense that 357 00:23:22,542 --> 00:23:57,472 there are various type of systematic exposures that can deliver 358 00:23:57,472 --> 00:24:28,909 performance, or various ways of delivering a defensive profile 359 00:24:28,909 --> 00:25:03,839 via, for example, rolling put options and being very thoughtful 360 00:25:03,839 --> 00:25:42,262 on which tenors and which strikes to utilize, whether the delta 361 00:25:42,262 --> 00:26:27,671 is hedged or not. All I'm just discussing is nothing more than a 362 00:26:27,671 --> 00:26:38,150 set of rules. Itis, to a certain extent, not too dissimilar 363 00:22:27,768 --> 00:23:24,877 to saying, look, if you really want to have the equity market, you 364 00:23:24,877 --> 00:24:21,986 need to find the 500 larger names and you need on a quarterly 365 00:24:21,986 --> 00:25:10,309 basis to reconstitute what those 500 names would be and allocate 366 00:25:10,309 --> 00:26:07,418 market cap weights to them. This is nothing more than a set of 367 00:26:07,418 --> 00:26:38,169 rules. And this is called S&P 500. Andonce upon a time there came 368 00:22:11,828 --> 00:22:48,909 a contract, that is called the futures contract, that delivers an 369 00:22:48,909 --> 00:23:22,619 unfunded exposure to the equator’s premium. So, that in itself 370 00:23:22,619 --> 00:23:56,329 facilitated whoever wanted to get equity exposure, to avoid going 371 00:23:56,329 --> 00:24:33,410 to the market and physically replicate 500 names into a portfolio 372 00:24:33,410 --> 00:25:10,491 of what the S&P will represent, and basically get on a 373 00:25:10,491 --> 00:25:44,201 contract nothing more than the performance of that construct that, 374 00:25:44,201 --> 00:26:28,024 in itself, can be put into a document and can be reflected into 375 00:26:28,024 --> 00:26:38,137 an index profile. So,if today we claim that volatility is rewarded 376 00:22:11,316 --> 00:22:36,966 and whoever is willing to sell insurance should be compensated, 377 00:22:36,966 --> 00:23:07,746 that in itself can be described with a set of rules by 378 00:23:07,746 --> 00:23:33,396 selling some options and trying to reduce the spot participation, 379 00:23:33,396 --> 00:24:06,741 the so called delta hedging, we can go back to the academic roots 380 00:24:06,741 --> 00:24:32,391 of the volatility risk premium. If somebody were to deliver 381 00:24:32,391 --> 00:25:03,171 ‘a futures contract’, in this regard that would be an OTC swap, 382 00:25:03,171 --> 00:25:33,951 then this allows the end investor to be exposed to the volatility 383 00:25:33,951 --> 00:25:59,601 risk premium not too dissimilar to being exposed to the 384 00:25:59,601 --> 00:26:22,686 equator's premium. And what sits underlying that investment is 385 00:26:22,686 --> 00:26:38,076 nothing more than a rules-based index. So,the way that 386 00:22:02,911 --> 00:22:50,621 I think about the QIS space is that it delivers different risk profiles 387 00:22:50,621 --> 00:23:27,321 in an accessible format and maybe reduces the operational burden 388 00:23:27,321 --> 00:24:07,691 and delivers this operational ease to the end investor. And there 389 00:24:07,691 --> 00:24:51,731 are other benefits, you know, cash efficiency, and so on, and so 390 00:24:51,731 --> 00:25:32,101 forth, that we can also discuss. But the primary reason why 391 00:25:32,101 --> 00:26:12,471 we now see this proliferation of this type of investing, nobody 392 00:26:12,471 --> 00:26:38,161 suddenly thought that systematic is the way. Butsystematic 393 00:21:55,861 --> 00:22:41,641 is the way to deliver into an index format what otherwise could 394 00:22:41,641 --> 00:23:23,606 be a cumbersome and tedious process. And the end allocator, being 395 00:23:23,606 --> 00:24:13,201 a private bank or being an asset manager or a hedge fund, would 396 00:24:13,201 --> 00:24:51,351 simply have that exposure and utilize their internal models on 397 00:24:51,351 --> 00:25:33,316 timing, utilize their internal models on sizing, focus more on kind 398 00:25:33,316 --> 00:26:19,096 of bringing their alpha, which is more of a timing element rather 399 00:26:19,096 --> 00:26:38,171 than of an implementation element. Sothat's a quick kind of… 400 00:22:39,393 --> 00:24:21,717 or maybe not as quick, but that's, I think, a quick overview 401 00:24:21,717 --> 00:26:12,568 as to how I think the space is evolving and the utilization across 402 00:26:12,568 --> 00:26:38,149 different client segments. 403 00:26:38,261 --> 00:26:59,942 Very good. And the observation that I personally made and maybe 404 00:26:59,942 --> 00:27:23,594 also many others, is that tying into what you said? You said, 405 00:27:23,594 --> 00:27:49,217 it's a technology. I think that's a good term to use and that 406 00:27:49,217 --> 00:27:59,072 comes along with operational efficiency. So,when you think about 407 00:26:44,576 --> 00:26:58,469 the early days of QIS, as you've mentioned, there's, you know, 408 00:26:58,469 --> 00:27:09,836 asset owners or insurance companies or large asset managers 409 00:27:09,836 --> 00:27:24,992 contracting with you. And maybe they wanted to have a new variation 410 00:27:24,992 --> 00:27:37,622 of equity value. Maybe it's something that they're doing in-house, 411 00:27:37,622 --> 00:27:52,778 and maybe it's just they want to have another source to diversify, 412 00:27:52,778 --> 00:27:59,093 and do something like that. Butit's not like high frequency, 413 00:26:46,079 --> 00:27:01,715 you know, it's kind of like, oh, you're running this daily or 414 00:27:01,715 --> 00:27:17,351 weekly or monthly or something like that. But then that has changed 415 00:27:17,351 --> 00:27:34,290 when most banks came up with, hey, we now offer intra-day vol or 416 00:27:34,290 --> 00:27:46,017 we offer intraday momentum trading, which is technology, which 417 00:27:46,017 --> 00:27:59,047 is an operational thing that not everybody can work with. AndI 418 00:26:40,911 --> 00:26:55,486 guess that's where the hedge fund clients come in, where they 419 00:26:55,486 --> 00:27:12,711 go like, well, look, if the bank can, every five minutes or whatever 420 00:27:12,711 --> 00:27:31,261 is, do a vol carry intra-day strategy on the S&P 500, then I might 421 00:27:31,261 --> 00:27:47,161 be better off just buying it from them as opposed to implementing 422 00:27:47,161 --> 00:27:59,086 that internally, myself, because it's difficult to do that. 423 00:28:01,131 --> 00:28:36,699 And you're right in this one. There's an element of IP that comes 424 00:28:36,699 --> 00:29:06,795 with the idea of designing a strategy that delivers some return 425 00:29:06,795 --> 00:29:34,155 profile that can be alpha enhancing, that can be defensive. 426 00:29:34,155 --> 00:30:06,987 But to your point, there is a massive, now, integration of technology. 427 00:28:01,131 --> 00:28:39,666 Theway I think about the QIS space, over the years, is as a combination 428 00:28:39,666 --> 00:29:07,925 of four main pillars in terms of product development. There's certainly 429 00:29:07,925 --> 00:29:31,046 research, industry, academic research that is evolving, you know, 430 00:29:31,046 --> 00:30:04,443 how we think of asset prices. And that is definitely a source of 431 00:30:04,443 --> 00:30:07,012 inspiration. Numbertwo is the entire client segment in terms of 432 00:28:12,171 --> 00:28:25,419 appetite. You know, it used to be either a hedge fund replacement 433 00:28:25,419 --> 00:28:36,459 or complement and it eventually became more of a specific 434 00:28:36,459 --> 00:28:49,707 economic outcome focus. I want something that is a bit more defensive 435 00:28:49,707 --> 00:29:05,163 and I'm happy to take on the negative cost of care. Or maybe I 436 00:29:05,163 --> 00:29:16,203 want something that is enhancing my yield, and I should 437 00:29:16,203 --> 00:29:29,451 be very focused on what is a spot contribution. Maybe now somebody's 438 00:29:29,451 --> 00:29:40,491 focusing on inflation, maybe the economic regime. So, there are 439 00:29:40,491 --> 00:29:50,427 different ways of us delivering product for specific economic 440 00:29:50,427 --> 00:30:01,467 outcomes. So that's the second pillar, how the client utilization 441 00:30:01,467 --> 00:30:07,031 of the product has shifted. Ithinkthe third one is technology. 442 00:28:10,308 --> 00:28:27,351 (There is no order by the way. These are just equally sharing the 443 00:28:27,351 --> 00:28:39,150 load of inspiration.) So, technology, to your point, being 444 00:28:39,150 --> 00:28:53,571 able to access markets, being able to trade markets, being able 445 00:28:53,571 --> 00:29:07,992 to trade faster markets, this is a massive enhancement that we 446 00:29:07,992 --> 00:29:25,035 have in our product offering. And then I would say the fourth is 447 00:29:25,035 --> 00:29:42,078 how markets evolve. Once upon a time you could not trade some of 448 00:29:42,078 --> 00:29:57,810 the frontier commodities. Now you can. Once upon a time there were 449 00:29:57,810 --> 00:30:06,987 no short aid options. Now there are. So,there's a variety 450 00:28:13,119 --> 00:28:46,086 of things that eventually happen around us allowing us to almost 451 00:28:46,086 --> 00:29:19,053 do out of sample testing on universes that otherwise would not 452 00:29:19,053 --> 00:30:07,005 be able to do so, at least back in the day, and not net of costs. 453 00:28:01,131 --> 00:29:02,046 So,I think if you were to ask me, these are the four pillars that 454 00:29:02,046 --> 00:29:38,595 over the years have been contributing to product: research, 455 00:29:38,595 --> 00:30:02,961 technology, client utilization, and market liquidity 456 00:30:02,961 --> 00:30:07,022 evolution. 457 00:30:08,521 --> 00:30:12,129 Got it. What do you think Nick, guesstimate, how many different 458 00:30:12,129 --> 00:30:16,065 QIS indices are out there, or not different, total number of QIS 459 00:30:16,065 --> 00:30:16,393 indices? 460 00:30:16,401 --> 00:30:16,959 Across all banks? 461 00:30:17,601 --> 00:30:18,001 Or maybe start with you. 462 00:30:18,361 --> 00:30:18,641 I mean certainly thousands. 463 00:30:19,601 --> 00:30:19,801 Yeah, it's thousands. It's thousands. 464 00:30:23,881 --> 00:30:51,055 Well, I mean, we can discuss the reason why that can be the case. 465 00:30:51,055 --> 00:31:10,465 And there is certainly an element of customization. So, for 466 00:31:10,465 --> 00:31:29,875 example, you mentioned equity value. You know, somebody can say 467 00:31:29,875 --> 00:31:51,226 look, I don't know what's the best equity value definition? Maybe 468 00:31:51,226 --> 00:32:12,577 it's, you know, book to price, maybe it's dividend yield, maybe 469 00:32:12,577 --> 00:32:18,400 it's a combination. So,there could be variations of the same product 470 00:30:34,960 --> 00:30:46,039 purely to reflect that different design choices could suit 471 00:30:46,039 --> 00:30:59,580 different investor needs. We can speak about CTAs, you know, if 472 00:30:59,580 --> 00:31:10,659 somebody would be willing to avoid having equity participation 473 00:31:10,659 --> 00:31:26,662 on the upside purely because they want to have more of a defensive 474 00:31:26,662 --> 00:31:40,203 profile. That's a different index. So, you know, the fact that 475 00:31:40,203 --> 00:31:56,206 we don't, and that a bank cannot act as an asset manager, and 476 00:31:56,206 --> 00:32:10,978 there is no fiduciary element, that in itself leads to the need 477 00:32:10,978 --> 00:32:18,364 of having a pallet of possibilities. Andwe can talk about 478 00:30:37,196 --> 00:31:06,489 an equity investment that is seen from a non-US investor that 479 00:31:06,489 --> 00:31:43,771 is exposed to withholding tax. So, that has to be a net total return 480 00:31:43,771 --> 00:32:13,064 implementation versus a gross total return. So that in itself is 481 00:32:13,064 --> 00:32:18,390 two indices. SoI think, because there's a lot of discussion 482 00:30:37,624 --> 00:30:57,475 as to how many indices, and data mining buys, and so on, and 483 00:30:57,475 --> 00:31:15,799 so forth, I think there's an aspect here that should be definitely 484 00:31:15,799 --> 00:31:32,596 mentioned, and that is purely the fact that any different implementation 485 00:31:32,596 --> 00:31:53,974 bid, for a specific client-ask or a specific need, has to be a different 486 00:31:53,974 --> 00:32:10,771 index. A client doesn't want to have ags in their commodities 487 00:32:10,771 --> 00:32:18,406 portfolio; that's a different index. So,there's a lot of customization 488 00:30:35,725 --> 00:31:01,387 that is purely driven by a specific need and less so of, “Oh, 489 00:31:01,387 --> 00:31:30,997 we found a better way of doing it. Let me just replace it now because 490 00:31:30,997 --> 00:31:52,711 I've just done my overfitting exercise.” This in itself has to 491 00:31:52,711 --> 00:32:18,373 be addressed, but this is, I guess, one way to address the magnitude. 492 00:32:18,411 --> 00:32:21,699 Why there are so many, and they all have their tickers, and 493 00:32:21,699 --> 00:32:24,987 they all run on the Bloomberg terminal, I presume. And you put 494 00:32:24,987 --> 00:32:28,549 them into Python code or whatever it is to run them. I guess, 495 00:32:28,549 --> 00:32:31,563 now, these days, in Europe you need an independent calculation agent 496 00:32:31,563 --> 00:32:32,385 - benchmark regulation. 497 00:32:32,711 --> 00:32:36,011 You do you have that internally, like Chinese Vault, or 498 00:32:36,011 --> 00:32:37,661 do you use external parties? 499 00:32:38,231 --> 00:32:47,135 There's a variety of models, as you say. You know, some banks 500 00:32:47,135 --> 00:32:53,071 utilize internal calculation agents that, obviously, are fenced. 501 00:32:53,071 --> 00:32:59,749 So, there's a lot of governance around this business. 502 00:32:38,231 --> 00:32:43,757 Someothers would be using external calculation agents. This 503 00:32:43,757 --> 00:32:50,511 is purely a business decision as long as, obviously, the governance 504 00:32:50,511 --> 00:32:58,493 is in place and the business overall is well run. But it's certainly 505 00:32:58,493 --> 00:32:59,721 the case. 506 00:33:00,791 --> 00:33:04,905 Looking at the types of exposures or products that your clients 507 00:33:04,905 --> 00:33:08,645 typically request, is most of the notional transacted in Delta 508 00:33:08,645 --> 00:33:14,629 1 space, linked to a swap or node, or is most of it kind of optionalized 509 00:33:14,629 --> 00:33:17,995 and therefore nonlinear index exposure, like somebody buying a 510 00:33:17,995 --> 00:33:19,865 call option on the index? 511 00:33:20,071 --> 00:33:58,291 Yeah, so, historically the vast majority has always been in 512 00:33:58,291 --> 00:34:51,799 kind of the Delta 1 space in the sense that they would do some 513 00:34:51,799 --> 00:35:45,307 form of a Delta 1 wrapper that can be typically a swap. That's what 514 00:35:45,307 --> 00:36:04,417 you see in the space. Obviously,there are other wrappers 515 00:33:38,331 --> 00:34:07,547 like certificates, notes, depending on the contractual relationship 516 00:34:07,547 --> 00:34:47,719 that a bank would have with a specific institution. More recently, 517 00:34:47,719 --> 00:35:24,239 and certainly for the insurance space, but also more recently 518 00:35:24,239 --> 00:35:53,455 we've seen, in the institutional space, some interest 519 00:35:53,455 --> 00:36:04,411 for option profiles. Andjust to be clear for the audience, we're 520 00:33:40,906 --> 00:34:04,056 not talking about the constituents of an index. The constituents 521 00:34:04,056 --> 00:34:36,466 can be Delta 1 or vol. You know, it can be a volatility carry, 522 00:34:36,466 --> 00:35:01,931 it can be a trend following strategy. We're just talking about 523 00:35:01,931 --> 00:35:27,396 their wrapper. So, your question is really how can I get 524 00:35:27,396 --> 00:35:57,491 access to a volatility carry trade, or how can I get access to 525 00:35:57,491 --> 00:36:04,436 a CTA profile? Thisis typically done, as I mentioned on 526 00:33:39,127 --> 00:34:10,093 a Delta 1 type of profile. But recently… And when I say recently, 527 00:34:10,093 --> 00:34:38,677 maybe the last two, three years, that we've seen a bit more 528 00:34:38,677 --> 00:35:07,261 interest in fixing a price and basically capping the loss; so, getting 529 00:35:07,261 --> 00:35:40,609 a call option on some of those indices. I would say it's a fraction, 530 00:35:40,609 --> 00:36:04,429 it's a small fraction, at least, of the executed trades. Thereis 531 00:33:28,089 --> 00:34:16,197 a philosophical question here, I guess, to be put in place. Let's 532 00:34:16,197 --> 00:34:56,287 say you're selling volatility to get a volatility carry profile 533 00:34:56,287 --> 00:35:48,404 and then you want to put an option on that profile. It's almost 534 00:35:48,404 --> 00:36:04,440 going in circles, right? So,the mere reason why you're supposed 535 00:33:39,909 --> 00:34:11,083 to be benefiting from a premium, when you sell options, is 536 00:34:11,083 --> 00:34:45,091 because you're willing to take on the risk. This thing is going 537 00:34:45,091 --> 00:35:13,431 to, at times, occasionally experience a vol spike. So, almost 538 00:35:13,431 --> 00:35:44,605 writing a call option to it, in itself, nullifies the existence 539 00:35:44,605 --> 00:36:04,443 of the premium in the first place. So,why would you have to 540 00:33:37,999 --> 00:34:07,879 get optionality on something that is dropping and still benefit 541 00:34:07,879 --> 00:34:43,735 from an upside, while the price for it should be the exact 542 00:34:43,735 --> 00:35:13,615 premium that you're benefiting from selling it? So, almost this 543 00:35:13,615 --> 00:35:46,483 viscous circle nullifies the value of pricing a call option on 544 00:35:46,483 --> 00:36:04,411 some of those negatively skewed profiles. Thereare still 545 00:33:27,217 --> 00:33:55,801 ways that we can think around that. But I guess the high-level 546 00:33:55,801 --> 00:34:22,003 answer to your question is that it's primarily on the Delta 547 00:34:22,003 --> 00:34:55,351 1 space. And when it comes to an option, there are types of transactions, 548 00:34:55,351 --> 00:35:26,317 maybe more on the underlying Delta 1 space and not on the option 549 00:35:26,317 --> 00:35:59,665 space. But rarely do we see that as frequently as we do the Delta 550 00:35:59,665 --> 00:36:04,429 1 transaction. 551 00:36:04,451 --> 00:36:13,295 When you do the Delta 1 transaction, it removes the requirement 552 00:36:13,295 --> 00:36:24,551 or the kind of motivation for you guys to have a vol target or 553 00:36:24,551 --> 00:36:35,807 vol cap. I mean, it may still have this as an intrinsic part of 554 00:36:35,807 --> 00:36:45,455 the strategy element, but I reckon, when you sell a call option, 555 00:36:45,455 --> 00:36:53,495 the underlying index will definitely be vol controlled or vol 556 00:36:53,495 --> 00:36:59,123 targeted to a certain type of level. So,there's a lot of that 557 00:36:09,743 --> 00:36:19,445 stuff that kind of slacks through the market as well. Because, 558 00:36:19,445 --> 00:36:29,147 you know, when somebody buys that call option, really the only 559 00:36:29,147 --> 00:36:41,495 party that will quote a price is you. They can't go to a… Well, 560 00:36:41,495 --> 00:36:52,079 they could potentially go to a different bank, but they're not going 561 00:36:52,079 --> 00:36:59,135 to get a good bid ask, if anything. So,you know, if you’re 562 00:36:12,736 --> 00:36:29,306 the source of liquidity and therefore you're protecting, I guess, 563 00:36:29,306 --> 00:36:49,190 your book by having this vol control in place and selling the 564 00:36:49,190 --> 00:36:59,132 option at a premium, that's amenable. 565 00:36:59,161 --> 00:37:09,457 That is fair. That is fair. It's certainly easier if you think 566 00:37:09,457 --> 00:37:18,037 about linear structures underlying it. So, when we talk about 567 00:37:18,037 --> 00:37:25,759 equity momentum, equity momentum, in itself, is vol targeted, 568 00:37:25,759 --> 00:37:34,339 and that in itself is helping equity momentum because negative 569 00:37:34,339 --> 00:37:43,777 skew and equity momentum can be moderated by vol targeting. So, 570 00:37:43,777 --> 00:37:54,931 that in itself, to your point, almost comes not even for free, but 571 00:37:54,931 --> 00:38:02,653 for a benefit of the performance while facilitating some 572 00:38:02,653 --> 00:38:07,801 option pricing to operate on top. So,I guess another way of kind 573 00:37:05,167 --> 00:37:16,321 of answering your question is that there are pockets of a QIS offering 574 00:37:16,321 --> 00:37:24,901 that are more accommodative for option pricing and some others 575 00:37:24,901 --> 00:37:36,055 that can become a bit more nuanced purely by the, I guess, the 576 00:37:36,055 --> 00:37:43,777 economic principle around the premium, but also mechanically. If 577 00:37:43,777 --> 00:37:54,073 you were to volatility target a strategy that is supposed to be 578 00:37:54,073 --> 00:38:01,795 reacting and recovering post the volatility spike, you're kind 579 00:38:01,795 --> 00:38:07,801 of acting against its ability to recover. So,then the whole question 580 00:37:08,966 --> 00:37:34,459 is, okay, fine, we can do the vol targeting, but then what you're 581 00:37:34,459 --> 00:37:56,030 ending up with is a suboptimal profile for the respective strategy. 582 00:37:56,030 --> 00:38:07,796 So, all these are important considerations. 583 00:38:09,261 --> 00:38:19,269 What do you think? By and large, would you build your business 584 00:38:19,269 --> 00:38:28,443 or the QIS business for massive scale, like an ETF provider 585 00:38:28,443 --> 00:38:35,949 would, where practically, theoretically, say, the AUM of an 586 00:38:35,949 --> 00:38:46,791 ETF are unlimited. It can grow to whatever size it wants to grow. 587 00:38:46,791 --> 00:38:55,131 Do you have that same thinking in the QIS space? Becauseone thing 588 00:38:11,517 --> 00:38:20,541 that I recognize is that, for instance, the CTA or trend offerings 589 00:38:20,541 --> 00:38:28,813 or some of the more popular offerings, they're not exposed to 590 00:38:28,813 --> 00:38:36,333 some of the smaller markets. They're really lacking from these 591 00:38:36,333 --> 00:38:46,109 type of indices that would more like be the super deep and liquid 592 00:38:46,109 --> 00:38:53,629 markets. Is that a fair statement, that you're building it 593 00:38:53,629 --> 00:38:55,133 for scale? 594 00:38:56,421 --> 00:39:20,478 Generally we build product for scale because that, in itself, is 595 00:39:20,478 --> 00:39:44,535 associated with how we can see the profitability of this business. 596 00:39:44,535 --> 00:40:10,779 At the same time, we are always exploring what are the pockets 597 00:40:10,779 --> 00:40:32,649 of the markets that can deliver some good performance, even 598 00:40:32,649 --> 00:41:01,080 if the scale cannot be at sizes of a much more liquid profile. 599 00:38:56,421 --> 00:39:12,360 So,we can spend time talking about frontier commodities or some 600 00:39:12,360 --> 00:39:26,850 of the non kind of benchmark commodities. Obviously, they don't 601 00:39:26,850 --> 00:39:45,687 have the liquidity that you'd expect to see in some of the larger 602 00:39:45,687 --> 00:40:00,177 markets. But certainly there could be variations, to your earlier 603 00:40:00,177 --> 00:40:17,565 point, there could be another index that simply has a broader set 604 00:40:17,565 --> 00:40:33,504 of assets as underlying. With the, I guess, consequence being that 605 00:40:33,504 --> 00:40:50,892 the overall capacity that this profile can support is now a fraction 606 00:40:50,892 --> 00:41:01,035 of what a subset of assets could. Sothat is, I guess, to answer 607 00:39:10,960 --> 00:39:35,884 your question in a different way, we try to solve for different 608 00:39:35,884 --> 00:40:02,885 scales. And if there is an argument to be had with regards to 609 00:40:02,885 --> 00:40:23,655 premia being more pronounced with lower liquidity or pockets of 610 00:40:23,655 --> 00:40:46,502 lower liquidity, if there is a liquidity premium to be harvested 611 00:40:46,502 --> 00:41:01,041 or illiquidity or whatever, it's worth it. We'realways keen 612 00:38:59,790 --> 00:39:13,266 to see what the enhancement can be, with the asterisk being that 613 00:39:13,266 --> 00:39:28,988 we cannot scale it as much as we could with a very liquid universe. 614 00:39:28,988 --> 00:39:41,341 So, we don't shy away from exploring those pockets of liquidity. 615 00:39:41,341 --> 00:39:53,694 But it's probably the most important thing when we design strategies, 616 00:39:53,694 --> 00:40:08,293 being very, very thoughtful on capacity. So, to put it into an extreme 617 00:40:08,293 --> 00:40:21,769 kind of statement, nothing is built for infinite scale, to be clear. 618 00:40:21,769 --> 00:40:35,245 Everything has to be done in a very prudent manner, very conscious 619 00:40:35,245 --> 00:40:47,598 of market liquidity, how much we transact, how much we consume, 620 00:40:47,598 --> 00:41:01,074 how much we roll, all that lot feeds into the product design. 621 00:41:01,811 --> 00:41:05,615 And that's also because you have the option to, at some point 622 00:41:05,615 --> 00:41:09,419 say, stop. If you wanted to stop selling an index, you could 623 00:41:09,419 --> 00:41:11,638 close it, whereas an ETF cannot. Right? 624 00:41:12,291 --> 00:41:21,459 And we do. I mean, at the end of the day, you need to protect the 625 00:41:21,459 --> 00:41:28,335 investors and you need to protect the market and you need to 626 00:41:28,335 --> 00:41:35,211 act in a prudent fashion when you transact and interact with the 627 00:41:35,211 --> 00:41:41,514 market. So, there are multiple cases whereby a specific design cannot 628 00:41:41,514 --> 00:41:46,671 sustain anymore without being market impactful. So, we're like, 629 00:41:46,671 --> 00:41:48,963 that's it for now. AndI think investors do appreciate that there 630 00:41:20,019 --> 00:41:30,645 is this scrutiny and there is this transparency. And existing investors 631 00:41:30,645 --> 00:41:45,135 also see that as a good thing, in a way, that we are basically the 632 00:41:45,135 --> 00:41:48,999 guardians of their exposures. 633 00:41:55,191 --> 00:42:03,375 Maybe two more things, one, this is just an observation. Every 634 00:42:03,375 --> 00:42:11,559 couple of weeks I receive emails from, it's not just banks, 635 00:42:11,559 --> 00:42:20,487 it's all sorts of like people offering product in that space and 636 00:42:20,487 --> 00:42:27,927 they come up with something new, something that here, therefore, 637 00:42:27,927 --> 00:42:36,111 has not, in their view, existed. It's kind of like, here's 638 00:42:36,111 --> 00:42:45,783 a new index, here's a new strategy or a new variation of a 639 00:42:45,783 --> 00:42:46,527 strategy. AndI sometimes go like… It's kind of like the same 640 00:42:02,077 --> 00:42:10,841 that you've had before, just a little bit of a new twist to it. 641 00:42:10,841 --> 00:42:18,353 But other than that, it's pretty much the same thing. So how 642 00:42:18,353 --> 00:42:25,865 do you balance this kind of like being forced to innovate and 643 00:42:25,865 --> 00:42:34,003 coming up with new indices, maybe in an approach or in an effort 644 00:42:34,003 --> 00:42:40,263 to stay relevant versus just over optimizing things and churning 645 00:42:40,263 --> 00:42:46,523 out new product for the sake of producing new products? 646 00:42:47,571 --> 00:43:06,411 Yeah, that's an amazing question actually. Why it's an amazing 647 00:43:06,411 --> 00:43:29,019 question is because it's part of human nature to observe, and then 648 00:43:29,019 --> 00:43:49,743 think, and then try to do better, specifically in that space. 649 00:43:49,743 --> 00:44:10,467 So, if I observe my trend following strategy in April, then 650 00:44:10,467 --> 00:44:36,843 probably there is a temptation to say, oh, if only we're a bit slower 651 00:44:36,843 --> 00:44:59,451 or if only we're a bit, I don't know, overweight this asset 652 00:44:59,451 --> 00:45:22,059 class or the other asset class, or if only we're not doing 653 00:45:22,059 --> 00:45:42,783 dynamic sizing or we're doing like not a static size, whatever. 654 00:45:42,783 --> 00:46:03,507 So, this temptation exists and, I think in itself, it's quite 655 00:46:03,507 --> 00:46:16,695 inherent to have those biases of overfitting. Somaybe another 656 00:42:57,690 --> 00:43:41,539 way of asking the same question is to say, how do you control 657 00:43:41,539 --> 00:44:25,388 data mining in a way? Because frankly, if there's a new idea, this 658 00:44:25,388 --> 00:45:02,491 idea is probably driven by the fact that something must probably 659 00:45:02,491 --> 00:45:36,221 have worked better and, therefore, let me just launch this 660 00:45:36,221 --> 00:46:09,951 tweak because that tweak will just make the recent performance 661 00:46:09,951 --> 00:46:16,697 look better. Sohow do you control for it? I mean, my personal 662 00:43:21,396 --> 00:43:55,221 view is that this is genuinely product culture. There's no better 663 00:43:55,221 --> 00:44:35,196 way to be conscious of data mining unless you just call it out. 664 00:44:35,196 --> 00:45:24,396 So, it is part of our, at least as far as I see it and given 665 00:45:24,396 --> 00:46:01,296 the responsibility I have in the product teams, that I would flag, 666 00:46:01,296 --> 00:46:16,671 look, now we're data mining. Fine,let's look at it, let's get 667 00:43:02,502 --> 00:43:28,098 a better sense of what the results suggest. But we should be 668 00:43:28,098 --> 00:43:53,694 very conscious of these data mining biases. And as soon as you 669 00:43:53,694 --> 00:44:15,024 acknowledge them, then it makes, I think, your brain iterate 670 00:44:15,024 --> 00:44:40,620 in a very different fashion because then you see all those new 671 00:44:40,620 --> 00:44:59,817 kind of very skilled individuals, that get hired from 672 00:44:59,817 --> 00:45:23,280 university, being exposed to those biases. But as soon as you 673 00:45:23,280 --> 00:45:46,743 call them out, then they start ingraining a culture whereby any 674 00:45:46,743 --> 00:46:14,472 new tweak they do is not about making the Sharpe ratio look better 675 00:46:14,472 --> 00:46:16,605 anymore. So,I don't think there's a right answer to your question 676 00:43:22,419 --> 00:44:00,435 in the sense, okay, that's the blueprint. I think it's a combination 677 00:44:00,435 --> 00:44:28,947 of acknowledgment, a combination of calling it out, a 678 00:44:28,947 --> 00:45:00,627 combination of being very thoughtful and studying some of the 679 00:45:00,627 --> 00:45:38,643 work that has happened in the academic space to control for determining 680 00:45:38,643 --> 00:46:16,659 biases. I think there is no way you can avoid data mining. IfI 681 00:42:52,609 --> 00:43:22,837 were to show you 10 back tests, you would basically drop the 682 00:43:22,837 --> 00:43:50,546 bottom one just purely because you wouldn't think about it. So, 683 00:43:50,546 --> 00:44:20,774 when it comes to changing a strategy or changing a design, what 684 00:44:20,774 --> 00:44:56,040 we try to strive for is (I tend to say that quite often) that 685 00:44:56,040 --> 00:45:11,154 explaining the underperformance is more important 686 00:45:11,154 --> 00:45:43,901 than, you know, being lucky on the upside. We would love to outperform, 687 00:45:43,901 --> 00:46:06,572 but if we cannot explain underperformance, that's the worst 688 00:46:06,572 --> 00:46:16,648 thing that can happen. So,at the end of the day, we are only successful 689 00:43:14,312 --> 00:43:38,622 because our clients are successful. And, you know, we live 690 00:43:38,622 --> 00:44:07,794 and die by those performances. I know everyone would say the same 691 00:44:07,794 --> 00:44:34,535 thing, asset managers and banks alike. But there is no other 692 00:44:34,535 --> 00:45:06,138 way for us to prove to our clients, over the years, that sustained 693 00:45:06,138 --> 00:45:18,293 (not necessarily outperformance), explainable underperformance, 694 00:45:18,293 --> 00:45:47,465 in light of what we initially suggested that we will build, would 695 00:45:47,465 --> 00:46:16,637 bring to us in terms of a kind of confidence and reward. So,I'm 696 00:43:02,507 --> 00:44:24,655 not sure whether I answered your question. I don't think there's 697 00:44:24,655 --> 00:45:39,335 an easy answer to the question. That's the process that 698 00:45:39,335 --> 00:46:16,675 we kind of go through. 699 00:46:17,181 --> 00:46:21,809 Yeah, I think you did answer it in the sense that you're following 700 00:46:21,809 --> 00:46:25,725 a rigorous process as far as research and science is concerned, 701 00:46:25,725 --> 00:46:29,285 and you're not just producing products for the product's provision's 702 00:46:29,285 --> 00:46:33,201 sake. Like, you know, there's no schedule. Every week you have 703 00:46:33,201 --> 00:46:37,473 to come up with new index, which would be ridiculous. So, you 704 00:46:37,473 --> 00:46:41,389 want to come up with something that's meaningful and different compared 705 00:46:41,389 --> 00:46:43,169 to what you had before. 706 00:46:43,881 --> 00:46:47,385 And also, no reaction to emotion. I mean, we could have reacted 707 00:46:47,385 --> 00:46:50,889 in SVB, we could have reacted last year in the dollar/yen unwind, 708 00:46:50,889 --> 00:46:54,393 we could have reacted in April when it comes to trend following 709 00:46:54,393 --> 00:46:57,313 which just basically sat behind, saw what the markets were 710 00:46:57,313 --> 00:47:01,109 here to basically tell us in terms of maybe a new regime, maybe 711 00:47:01,109 --> 00:47:04,321 not, I don't know. But reacting on emotion and just making 712 00:47:04,321 --> 00:47:07,241 the last drawdown outperform is purely the recipe for underperformance. 713 00:47:09,362 --> 00:47:20,659 One thing, and maybe as a final question, we've mentioned the 714 00:47:20,659 --> 00:47:30,929 US$1,300 billion, and we're not exactly sure whether that number 715 00:47:30,929 --> 00:47:41,199 is right or wrong. We've asterisked this and conditioned it 716 00:47:41,199 --> 00:47:54,550 on a couple of parameters. But by and large, where do you think, 717 00:47:54,550 --> 00:48:05,847 if anywhere, could the QIS business have become too large? I 718 00:48:05,847 --> 00:48:19,198 mean, do you see effects of crowding in some of the markets or 719 00:48:19,198 --> 00:48:24,333 in some of the strategies? Letme give you just an example and 720 00:47:15,738 --> 00:47:24,505 I'm absolutely not sure whether I'm right or wrong. But for 721 00:47:24,505 --> 00:47:32,475 instance, when you look at commodity indices and liquidity provision 722 00:47:32,475 --> 00:47:43,633 around index roles, business day 5, 6, 7, 8 or 9, which, you know, 723 00:47:43,633 --> 00:47:53,197 that the GSCI type of roll period. It’s a very successful strategy, 724 00:47:53,197 --> 00:48:01,964 probably 10 to 15 years ago, providing liquidity during that role, 725 00:48:01,964 --> 00:48:09,934 and then reversing the position, you know, five days later. 726 00:48:09,934 --> 00:48:18,701 I think that strategy has largely decayed, then roll days have 727 00:48:18,701 --> 00:48:24,280 changed. So maybe that's just one example. I'dlike to hear your 728 00:47:16,302 --> 00:47:32,958 view on this of, yeah, enough money has crowded into that space 729 00:47:32,958 --> 00:47:48,226 so that the effect has essentially gone away and the market 730 00:47:48,226 --> 00:48:06,270 is now balanced. Would you say that's a fair statement? And if so, 731 00:48:06,270 --> 00:48:22,926 are there any other pockets of the business where you see similar 732 00:48:22,926 --> 00:48:24,314 effects? 733 00:48:25,152 --> 00:52:28,241 Yeah, so both are very good questions, and that’s a question 734 00:52:28,241 --> 00:56:53,429 that comes very often, I should say. So, how should I answer? 735 00:48:25,152 --> 00:49:39,699 Letme just first answer, maybe, picking up your example. You're 736 00:49:39,699 --> 00:50:40,692 referring to commodity congestion, I guess, and the fact 737 00:50:40,692 --> 00:51:48,462 that there is passive exposure to the benchmark roles, specifically 738 00:51:48,462 --> 00:52:56,232 for institutions that do not want to hold physical commodities 739 00:52:56,232 --> 00:53:57,225 and want to be just financially exposed to commodity 740 00:53:57,225 --> 00:55:18,549 prices and therefore they need to follow an index of all things 741 00:55:18,549 --> 00:56:33,096 because it's easy in this regard. But that index is following 742 00:56:33,096 --> 00:56:53,427 a predetermined schedule. So,there are days that you need 743 00:49:34,914 --> 00:51:34,506 to sell the futures you're holding and buy the new one. So, 744 00:51:34,506 --> 00:53:54,030 over the course of a few days, that is supply, net supply of the 745 00:53:54,030 --> 00:56:03,588 contract you want to move away from and net demand for the contract 746 00:56:03,588 --> 00:56:53,418 you want to go into. Now,if the market is elastic, you would 747 00:49:34,072 --> 00:51:17,452 not expect any price impact from this activity. But lo and behold, 748 00:51:17,452 --> 00:52:43,602 for years, because there was this passive requirement for commodity 749 00:52:43,602 --> 00:54:26,982 exposure, it had kind of an impact, a negative impact from selling 750 00:54:26,982 --> 00:56:18,977 at the same time that everyone is selling and buying at the same 751 00:56:18,977 --> 00:56:53,437 time that everyone's buying. So,there was this kind of strategy 752 00:49:17,470 --> 00:50:39,684 called congestion that said, look, I really know when that benchmark 753 00:50:39,684 --> 00:52:24,320 growth will operate, so let me just do it a few days before. So, 754 00:52:24,320 --> 00:54:08,956 I'm going to buy whatever else is going to buy a few days before 755 00:54:08,956 --> 00:55:46,118 they do so and I'm going to sell whatever else we're going to 756 00:55:46,118 --> 00:56:53,384 be selling a few days before they do so. So,then I do like a 757 00:49:27,390 --> 00:51:11,120 long/short portfolio and I capture what is called the congestion 758 00:51:11,120 --> 00:52:44,477 premium, which is nothing more than liquidity premium, liquidity 759 00:52:44,477 --> 00:54:38,580 provision here. Now, rightly so, as you said, around 2015, ‘16, 760 00:54:38,580 --> 00:56:43,056 ‘17, ‘18, this started kind of underperforming in a way and flattening 761 00:56:43,056 --> 00:56:53,429 out. It'sinteresting because we wrote a report back then. I spent 762 00:50:32,224 --> 00:52:50,848 some time with the team, that's in 2018, 2019, and we wrote 763 00:52:50,848 --> 00:54:57,920 a report on specifically this particular point. And there is a 764 00:54:57,920 --> 00:56:53,440 very subtle point here of what crowding implications would be. So,if 765 00:48:47,250 --> 00:50:48,789 this were to be massively crowded, as in QIS investors that 766 00:50:48,789 --> 00:53:01,377 do congestion, at the margin you would expect to see very negative 767 00:53:01,377 --> 00:54:40,818 performance. Because now you're the one congesting the market 768 00:54:40,818 --> 00:56:31,308 and whoever is doing the benchmark rolls is actually benefiting 769 00:56:31,308 --> 00:56:53,406 from it. Butoddly enough, we saw the strategy flattening out and 770 00:50:08,882 --> 00:52:02,985 the flattening out of the strategy, it's more that the initial 771 00:52:02,985 --> 00:53:57,088 demand for this liquidity is no longer there. In other words, 772 00:53:57,088 --> 00:55:40,818 whether you pre-roll or post-roll or roll together with a 773 00:55:40,818 --> 00:56:53,429 benchmark roll, you have no impact whatsoever. Themarket started 774 00:48:44,700 --> 00:49:43,344 becoming elastic again. It started absorbing this net demand 775 00:49:43,344 --> 00:51:08,052 and net supply. And I guess, if you like, the outcome of this 776 00:51:08,052 --> 00:52:06,696 analysis suggested that investors became smarter in the way 777 00:52:06,696 --> 00:53:31,404 that they rolled the exposures and they now, or at the time, were 778 00:53:31,404 --> 00:54:30,048 doing more enhanced data exposure in commodities rather than 779 00:54:30,048 --> 00:55:35,208 too many investors crowding out the congestion trade. And this 780 00:55:35,208 --> 00:56:40,368 is very subtle, but very important. The strategy became flat, 781 00:56:40,368 --> 00:56:53,400 not underperforming. Loand behold, in 2022, congestion trade 782 00:49:24,449 --> 00:50:49,159 came back again because obviously there was this kind of 783 00:50:49,159 --> 00:52:05,398 need for commodity exposure during the kind of Russia/Ukraine 784 00:52:05,398 --> 00:53:38,579 conflict. So, congestion did come back, but also we can think 785 00:53:38,579 --> 00:55:11,760 of congestion in a different fashion now. Do we see congestion 786 00:55:11,760 --> 00:56:44,941 trades operating in enhanced bid as exposures? That could be a 787 00:56:44,941 --> 00:56:53,412 question. Sothat's, I guess, statement number one. But where I 788 00:49:16,492 --> 00:50:12,966 want to focus on, as a consequence of this discussion, is 789 00:50:12,966 --> 00:51:14,574 that this demand for commodity rolls is not driven by some sort 790 00:51:14,574 --> 00:52:05,914 of risk sharing mechanism. It's a pure asset allocation decision. 791 00:52:05,914 --> 00:53:02,388 So, the premium, in itself, shouldn't exist in the first place. 792 00:53:02,388 --> 00:54:14,264 And this is the space that, you know, if there is too much of 793 00:54:14,264 --> 00:55:21,006 crowding, it can go away. Or obviously if there is no demand for 794 00:55:21,006 --> 00:56:22,614 those benchmark rolls, as it happened to be the case, there is 795 00:56:22,614 --> 00:56:53,418 no premium to be harvested anyway. It'svery different when 796 00:48:55,496 --> 00:50:18,942 we start looking into maybe volatility selling. So, if we sell 797 00:50:18,942 --> 00:51:27,216 volatility, there is an underlying risk factor that there 798 00:51:27,216 --> 00:53:05,834 is a segment of the market that is not willing to take, and 799 00:53:05,834 --> 00:54:36,866 we're happy to basically take the other side by selling those options 800 00:54:36,866 --> 00:56:15,484 and be paid the premium that whoever is willing to hedge is willing 801 00:56:15,484 --> 00:56:53,414 to pay and pay more. So,can we now observe crowding implications? 802 00:49:15,979 --> 00:50:43,111 Maybe the premium falls. I tend to use this basic example. If 803 00:50:43,111 --> 00:51:55,721 we all become car insurance sellers or car insurance providers, 804 00:51:55,721 --> 00:53:37,375 the premium to insure your car is going to drop purely by the economics 805 00:53:37,375 --> 00:54:42,724 of competition. But that doesn't, in itself, suggest that 806 00:54:42,724 --> 00:56:09,856 the premium is going to go to zero, maybe negative, unless somehow 807 00:56:09,856 --> 00:56:53,422 we will all become better drivers. So,there's a fundamental 808 00:49:07,508 --> 00:51:14,576 link here between what is the price to pay for specific insurance, 809 00:51:14,576 --> 00:53:00,466 and what is the underlying risk sharing mechanism, and where 810 00:53:00,466 --> 00:55:07,534 the market will clear in terms of pricing that risk. That's the 811 00:55:07,534 --> 00:56:53,424 price of the premium, the risk premium, if you like. Butyou know, 812 00:48:59,037 --> 00:51:03,282 suggesting that this can become negative, I think it's a very 813 00:51:03,282 --> 00:53:30,117 bold statement. And the reason why I'm saying so is that there is 814 00:53:30,117 --> 00:55:45,657 a barrier to entry. Who is going to be selling this insurance 815 00:55:45,657 --> 00:56:53,427 if it drops below a threshold? So,the more kind of crowding you 816 00:49:27,571 --> 00:51:05,658 end up observing, the more subdued the returns would be. It’s 817 00:51:05,658 --> 00:52:52,662 still positive in the longer term, but then the barrier of entry 818 00:52:52,662 --> 00:54:12,915 will just increase. So, there's an equilibrium here that 819 00:54:12,915 --> 00:55:59,919 is achieved purely by the fact that it's an underlying risk sharing 820 00:55:59,919 --> 00:56:53,421 mechanism, and that's different to congestion. Andthen 821 00:48:46,330 --> 00:50:32,220 obviously, the last segment of alpha seeking strategies would be 822 00:50:32,220 --> 00:52:07,521 more behavioral. Trend following, I think, it's a prime 823 00:52:07,521 --> 00:54:04,000 example here. We can debate what crowding will bring to trend 824 00:54:04,000 --> 00:55:49,890 following. There's an argument to be had whereby trend following 825 00:55:49,890 --> 00:56:53,424 is actually benefiting from early crowding. Theproblem here 826 00:49:26,145 --> 00:53:09,786 is more risk management. The problem here is how those negative 827 00:53:09,786 --> 00:56:53,427 skew events can be moderated. So, the implications are very different. 828 00:48:25,152 --> 00:50:34,710 Sowhere am I going with all this stuff? I think crowding implications 829 00:50:34,710 --> 00:52:04,404 have been overstated because they haven't necessarily been looked 830 00:52:04,404 --> 00:53:44,064 through the economics and the mechanics of the strategies. But 831 00:53:44,064 --> 00:55:33,690 that in itself should not basically put us behind the curtain 832 00:55:33,690 --> 00:56:53,418 and say, look, there's no problem at all. So,I mean, if I 833 00:48:58,592 --> 00:50:18,848 were to give another example, I think intraday momentum is a space 834 00:50:18,848 --> 00:51:32,416 where, probably, some crowding via the QIS wrapper has been there 835 00:51:32,416 --> 00:52:52,672 in the, I guess, years of 2021, 2022, when this product became 836 00:52:52,672 --> 00:54:06,240 very popular. I don't think that the intraday momentum, in itself, 837 00:54:06,240 --> 00:55:06,432 has lost its reactivity or defensiveness profile, but maybe 838 00:55:06,432 --> 00:56:06,624 the cost of care of maintaining this defensive strategy 839 00:56:06,624 --> 00:56:53,440 has kind of increased over the years. NowI think the biggest (be 840 00:48:46,182 --> 00:49:17,727 careful with my wording), the biggest consideration that banks 841 00:49:17,727 --> 00:49:59,787 and QIS desks should have is on the externalities that come with 842 00:49:59,787 --> 00:50:31,332 similar products being designed by banks and similar investors 843 00:50:31,332 --> 00:51:02,877 holding similar products for specific objectives, which are also 844 00:51:02,877 --> 00:51:44,937 very similar. So, if you hold a 60/40 portfolio and an overlay, 845 00:51:44,937 --> 00:52:34,007 and I hold a 60/40 and an overlay, both of us will react on 846 00:52:34,007 --> 00:53:12,562 a macro signal that would make us deliver the overall portfolio, 847 00:53:12,562 --> 00:53:54,622 and as a consequence of that both of us will probably de-lever 848 00:53:54,622 --> 00:54:29,672 our alternatives. So, those components now can expose the realized 849 00:54:29,672 --> 00:55:11,732 correlations that we haven't seen in a backtest. And I think those 850 00:55:11,732 --> 00:55:36,267 externalities and contagion impact of orchestrating activity 851 00:55:36,267 --> 00:56:18,327 to macro shocks is more the concerning factor than how do we 852 00:56:18,327 --> 00:56:53,377 design a strategy to make it be less crowding impacted. Soyes, 853 00:48:37,858 --> 00:50:00,447 there's a lot of focus on that. There's a lot of focus together 854 00:50:00,447 --> 00:51:23,036 with our trading desk as to how they see and experience the markets. 855 00:51:23,036 --> 00:52:45,625 But if there is one pillar of focus, when we design those products, 856 00:52:45,625 --> 00:54:08,214 is to build them for scale, to your point, but for very conscious 857 00:54:08,214 --> 00:55:11,744 kind of scaling rather than let's just consume the liquidity 858 00:55:11,744 --> 00:56:40,686 of the market however much it can deliver to us and move on with 859 00:56:40,686 --> 00:56:53,392 our lives. Again,we are only assessed by our performance. So, 860 00:51:14,577 --> 00:54:04,002 all these are very important considerations. Very long winded 861 00:54:04,002 --> 00:56:53,427 answer, but I know it's not an easy question. 862 00:56:53,442 --> 00:57:07,692 Not an easy topic. At the end of the day this is what counts, right? 863 00:57:07,692 --> 00:57:19,092 It's the performance. If your indices do not perform, if they do 864 00:57:19,092 --> 00:57:30,492 not provide the premium that we suggest or expect there to be, 865 00:57:30,492 --> 00:57:41,892 then the volume will dry up, people will leave and you'll see 866 00:57:41,892 --> 00:57:48,542 reversion of your flows. Such as life. Lookon that note, I think 867 00:57:15,492 --> 00:57:48,567 that's a good wrap. Let's close this week's conversation. Wehope 868 00:56:54,912 --> 00:57:04,467 that everybody has enjoyed it as much as we did making the episode 869 00:57:04,467 --> 00:57:14,022 for you. I hear from Niels that next week Alan will be joined 870 00:57:14,022 --> 00:57:22,842 by Yoav. So that should be a fun conversation. It's also your 871 00:57:22,842 --> 00:57:31,662 chance to have them tackle some of your questions, if you like. 872 00:57:31,662 --> 00:57:39,012 You can send them, as usual, by email to info@toptradersunplugged.com. 873 00:57:39,012 --> 00:57:48,567 Niels will pick them up and do his best to bring them up. So,from 874 00:56:58,692 --> 00:57:30,192 Nick and me, thanks so much for listening and we look forward 875 00:57:30,192 --> 00:57:48,567 to being back with you next week. 876 00:57:49,292 --> 00:57:59,732 Thanks for listening to the Systematic Investor podcast series. 877 00:57:59,732 --> 00:58:15,972 If you enjoy this series, go on over to iTunes and leave an honest 878 00:58:15,972 --> 00:58:31,052 rating and review. And be sure to listen to all the other episodes 879 00:58:31,052 --> 00:58:35,692 from Top Traders Unplugged. Ifyou have questions about systematic 880 00:57:58,574 --> 00:58:17,138 investing, send us an email with the word ‘question’ in the subject 881 00:58:17,138 --> 00:58:23,326 line to info@toptradersunplugged.com and 882 00:58:23,326 --> 00:58:35,702 we'll try to get it on the show. Andremember, all the discussion 883 00:57:51,987 --> 00:57:57,916 that we have about investment performance is about the past and 884 00:57:57,916 --> 00:58:02,767 past performance does not guarantee or even infer anything 885 00:58:02,767 --> 00:58:07,618 about future performance. Also, understand that there's a significant 886 00:58:07,618 --> 00:58:13,008 risk of financial loss with all investment strategies and you 887 00:58:13,008 --> 00:58:18,937 need to request and understand the specific risks from the investment 888 00:58:18,937 --> 00:58:23,788 manager about their products before you make investment decisions. 889 00:58:23,788 --> 00:58:30,256 Thanks for spending some of your valuable time with us and we'll 890 00:58:30,256 --> 00:58:35,646 see you on the next episode of the Systematic Investor.