1 00:00:03,600 --> 00:00:03,760 (Music) 2 00:00:11,760 --> 00:00:21,996 Welcome to U Got Options, an exciting series right here on Top 3 00:00:21,996 --> 00:00:31,379 Traders Unplugged, hosted by none other than Cem Karsan, one of 4 00:00:31,379 --> 00:00:39,909 the sharpest minds when it comes to understanding what's really 5 00:00:39,909 --> 00:00:48,439 driving market moves beneath the surface. In this series, Cem 6 00:00:48,439 --> 00:00:56,969 brings his deep expertise and unique perspective, honed from years 7 00:00:56,969 --> 00:01:05,499 of experience on the trading floor, to candid conversations with 8 00:01:05,499 --> 00:01:14,882 some of the brightest minds in the industry. Together, they unpack 9 00:01:14,882 --> 00:01:22,559 the shifting tides and underlying forces that move markets 10 00:01:22,559 --> 00:01:26,900 and the opportunities they create. Aquickreminder before we 11 00:00:19,585 --> 00:00:36,800 dive in, U Got Options is for informational and educational purposes 12 00:00:36,800 --> 00:00:55,580 only. None of the discussions you're about to hear should be considered 13 00:00:55,580 --> 00:01:12,795 investment advice. As always, please do your own research and consult 14 00:01:12,795 --> 00:01:26,880 with a professional advisor before making any investment decisions. 15 00:00:11,760 --> 00:00:28,282 Now,what makes this series truly special is that it's recorded 16 00:00:28,282 --> 00:00:47,808 right from the heart of the action on the trading floor of the 17 00:00:47,808 --> 00:01:04,330 Cboe. That means you might catch a little background buzz. Phones 18 00:01:04,330 --> 00:01:20,852 ringing, traders shouting as Cem and his guests unpack real world 19 00:01:20,852 --> 00:01:26,860 insights in real time. Wewouldn't have it any other way 20 00:00:24,906 --> 00:00:49,320 because this is as authentic as it gets. And with that, it's time 21 00:00:49,320 --> 00:01:11,856 to hear from those who live and breathe this complex corner of 22 00:01:11,856 --> 00:01:26,880 the markets. Here is your host, Cem Karsan. 23 00:01:28,260 --> 00:01:32,231 Welcome back to another episode of U Got Options from the 24 00:01:32,231 --> 00:01:36,563 Cboe floor, brought to you by Kai Media and Top Traders Unplugged. 25 00:01:36,563 --> 00:01:40,895 Today we talk to Lyn Alden. She is known, obviously, for This 26 00:01:40,895 --> 00:01:44,505 Train Does Not Stop, and that fiscal dominance (absolutely agree 27 00:01:44,505 --> 00:01:48,837 with) but we test it a little bit with talking about authoritarianism, 28 00:01:48,837 --> 00:01:53,891 how it will play a role versus democracy; AI, will that make a difference; 29 00:01:53,891 --> 00:01:57,862 and of course, crypto, where does crypto stand in this? Where 30 00:01:57,862 --> 00:02:01,120 are we going in the broad scope of things? Ithinkyou're really 31 00:01:42,864 --> 00:02:01,119 going to enjoy this one. 32 00:02:01,120 --> 00:02:01,440 (Music) 33 00:02:23,210 --> 00:02:26,666 Hey guys, and welcome to another U Got Options. I'm here with 34 00:02:26,666 --> 00:02:30,410 Lyn Alden - not only a fan favorite, one of my favorites. Her 35 00:02:30,410 --> 00:02:33,578 work has been kind of something that's led me through the 36 00:02:33,578 --> 00:02:37,034 last four years, really been reading a lot of her stuff, agree 37 00:02:37,034 --> 00:02:40,202 with a lot of it (from a different angle sometimes, sometimes 38 00:02:40,202 --> 00:02:43,658 different path). But one thing you can't argue with is the depth 39 00:02:43,658 --> 00:02:47,114 at which she kind of looks through these things, and the numbers, 40 00:02:47,114 --> 00:02:49,994 and analysis. It's always a pleasure. So, thanks for joining 41 00:02:49,994 --> 00:02:52,586 me today, Lyn. Excited to have a conversation today. 42 00:02:53,120 --> 00:02:54,880 Happy to be here. Looking forward to it. 43 00:02:55,840 --> 00:02:59,636 So, let's dive right in. I mean, what an amazing kind of time. 44 00:02:59,636 --> 00:03:03,432 The things I feel like we've been talking about, in terms of fiscal 45 00:03:03,432 --> 00:03:06,936 dominance and how you can't stop this train, and the broad macro. 46 00:03:06,936 --> 00:03:10,440 It just seems to accelerate every week and every month. For those 47 00:03:10,440 --> 00:03:13,944 that aren't as familiar with your work, and even for those that 48 00:03:13,944 --> 00:03:18,032 are, you might give a little bit of a kind of background on how 49 00:03:18,032 --> 00:03:21,244 you see us at this stage, maybe what's continuing to happen 50 00:03:21,244 --> 00:03:25,040 on path as you'd expect, and also what are some things that might 51 00:03:25,040 --> 00:03:27,084 be changing in the broad macro path? 52 00:03:27,710 --> 00:03:45,126 Sure, it sounds good. Yeah, a lot of my work over the past several 53 00:03:45,126 --> 00:04:00,054 years, I'm really going back to 2019, has focused heavily on the 54 00:04:00,054 --> 00:04:13,738 fiscal aspect, especially in the US, but also globally. And so, 55 00:04:13,738 --> 00:04:29,910 a big part of my investment approach was kind of based on the 56 00:04:29,910 --> 00:04:44,838 observation that I think a large part of the market was kind 57 00:04:44,838 --> 00:04:58,522 of underestimating the power of fiscal and the amount of fiscal 58 00:04:58,522 --> 00:05:13,450 we were likely going to get. And both kind of covering current 59 00:05:13,450 --> 00:05:27,134 topics in fiscal, but also learning a lot from history because 60 00:05:27,134 --> 00:05:43,306 we're going through, I'm not the first one to use this term, but 61 00:05:43,306 --> 00:05:56,990 fiscal dominance, where we've shifted a lot of the leverage from 62 00:05:56,990 --> 00:06:06,942 the private sector up to the public sector. Thishas implications 63 00:03:33,608 --> 00:03:47,370 for nominal GDP, wealth concentration, inflation levels, 64 00:03:47,370 --> 00:04:08,996 market performance. It's got a number of kind of economic, social, 65 00:04:08,996 --> 00:04:26,690 and trading, investing ramifications. And we have to really 66 00:04:26,690 --> 00:04:54,214 go back a long time, at least in the developed world, to see similar 67 00:04:54,214 --> 00:05:15,840 market conditions. So, a lot of the investing approaches of the 68 00:05:15,840 --> 00:05:39,432 past 40 years or so, we're not really geared toward fiscal dominance. 69 00:05:39,432 --> 00:06:06,956 And so, a lot of my work is kind of focused on that importance. 70 00:03:27,710 --> 00:03:45,734 Myinitial background is in engineering, so I kind of have a 71 00:03:45,734 --> 00:04:00,754 systems engineering approach to capital flows. as well as focusing 72 00:04:00,754 --> 00:04:15,774 on the reality of some physical aspects, whether it's energy, 73 00:04:15,774 --> 00:04:35,300 whether it's supply chains as well, that kind of round out my view. 74 00:04:35,300 --> 00:04:54,826 And so, kind of my general view is that, because we're in fiscal 75 00:04:54,826 --> 00:05:12,850 dominance and a number of other things that kind of went into 76 00:05:12,850 --> 00:05:24,866 this situation, we have structurally high fiscal deficits 77 00:05:24,866 --> 00:05:42,890 in the US. That tends to keep nominal things elevated more than 78 00:05:42,890 --> 00:05:59,412 at least many bears would think, but just generally more than 79 00:05:59,412 --> 00:06:06,922 the market participants would think. So,you generally kind of 80 00:03:39,595 --> 00:04:03,365 a run at a hot GDP environment. Nominal asset price 81 00:04:03,365 --> 00:04:31,889 is doing well. They might not do well versus another hard asset 82 00:04:31,889 --> 00:05:00,413 like gold per se, but they're doing well in currency terms, at 83 00:05:00,413 --> 00:05:26,560 least over a multi-year period. And then you kind of get 84 00:05:26,560 --> 00:05:55,084 into that sort of persistent situation. And so, I'm happy to kind 85 00:05:55,084 --> 00:06:06,969 of go where you want. Anotherbig thing I focus on is kind 86 00:03:43,246 --> 00:04:04,608 of that we're shifting toward a more multipolar world over time. 87 00:04:04,608 --> 00:04:27,912 I mean, some of the current headlines might be kind of along 88 00:04:27,912 --> 00:04:49,274 that path. But even just before the current kind of headlines, 89 00:04:49,274 --> 00:05:12,578 it's been kind of a structural approach that I focus on alongside 90 00:05:12,578 --> 00:05:35,882 the fiscal side. It's that kind of shift toward a more multipolar 91 00:05:35,882 --> 00:05:55,302 world. It's a gradual change in reserve currency practices. What 92 00:05:55,302 --> 00:06:06,954 does that mean, good and bad? 93 00:06:07,690 --> 00:06:11,590 And I know my views, and I've read a bit of yours, but I'd love 94 00:06:11,590 --> 00:06:14,450 to talk about why you think it's fairly inevitable, why this 95 00:06:14,450 --> 00:06:17,310 train doesn't stop? Why is the fiscal dominance happening, and why 96 00:06:17,310 --> 00:06:19,390 is it likely to persist, in your view? 97 00:06:21,501 --> 00:06:55,106 Sure. So basically, when we look at how debt cycles work in history, 98 00:06:55,106 --> 00:07:23,541 we're all familiar with the credit cycle, the five to 10-year 99 00:07:23,541 --> 00:07:49,391 typical kind of business cycle, credit cycle. When you string 100 00:07:49,391 --> 00:08:15,241 a lot of those together, especially in modern history, every 101 00:08:15,241 --> 00:08:41,091 time we have a contraction, you'll lower interest rates generally 102 00:08:41,091 --> 00:09:09,526 to a new lower low. You'll often have fiscal stabilizers kick 103 00:09:09,526 --> 00:09:37,961 in either automatically or due to intentional stimulus to kind of 104 00:09:37,961 --> 00:10:06,396 restart that next credit cycle. And when you string a bunch 105 00:10:06,396 --> 00:10:37,416 of those together over 40, 50 years, you get higher and higher 106 00:10:37,416 --> 00:11:08,436 debt levels relative to GDP, and you get lower and lower interest 107 00:11:07,365 --> 00:11:11,021 rates. Andhistorically, when you kind of run that all the way 108 00:06:44,249 --> 00:07:09,065 to the end point, you've run into zero interest rates. You get 109 00:07:09,065 --> 00:07:31,813 very high private debt levels. The highest two private debt bubbles 110 00:07:31,813 --> 00:07:58,697 in the US were basically 1929, early 1930s, and then again in 2007, 111 00:07:58,697 --> 00:08:21,445 2008. Those were kind of the two all-time private sector debt 112 00:08:21,445 --> 00:08:46,261 bubbles in the US. And the problem there is that there's really 113 00:08:46,261 --> 00:09:15,213 kind of nowhere to go. If you look at most metrics in terms of, 114 00:09:15,213 --> 00:09:40,029 say, how much debt exists in the country relative to the monetary 115 00:09:40,029 --> 00:10:04,845 base, how much debt there is relative to GDP, there are multiple 116 00:10:04,845 --> 00:10:27,593 ways to measure it. It's just extremely leveraged. Or, for example, 117 00:10:27,593 --> 00:10:52,409 how much cash banks have on hand relative to all their other 118 00:10:52,409 --> 00:11:11,021 assets and just how much risk they're taking on. Andgenerally 119 00:06:28,925 --> 00:07:13,469 speaking, when you get to that point, instead of kind of letting 120 00:07:13,469 --> 00:07:58,013 it all collapse, a country that controls its own unit of account 121 00:07:58,013 --> 00:08:38,845 and its own money will generally print. And so, you start 122 00:08:38,845 --> 00:09:23,389 to see a shift from the private sector. You kind of deleverage 123 00:09:23,389 --> 00:09:53,085 that through very large fiscal injections, backstops, monetization 124 00:09:53,085 --> 00:10:41,341 of debt when needed. And you kind of, over a period of years, 125 00:10:41,341 --> 00:11:11,037 rotate some of that onto the public sector. Andso, we shift from 126 00:06:37,071 --> 00:07:14,439 out of kind of that private sector debt bubble, we moderate that, 127 00:07:14,439 --> 00:07:51,807 we shift that more to the public sector. And that has implications 128 00:07:51,807 --> 00:08:32,289 because when you get very high public debts, if you run into inflation 129 00:08:32,289 --> 00:09:06,543 for whatever reason, whether it's because you printed a ton of 130 00:09:06,543 --> 00:09:40,797 extra money for a lockdown stimulus, or because you have war 131 00:09:40,797 --> 00:10:21,279 or energy shortages, whatever the case may be, if you try to raise 132 00:10:21,279 --> 00:10:55,533 interest rates in response to that, you get a generally different 133 00:10:55,533 --> 00:11:11,103 outcome than, say, the 1970s. We'regenerally kind of trained to 134 00:06:38,367 --> 00:07:06,477 think that the antidote to inflation is higher rates, which 135 00:07:06,477 --> 00:07:40,209 is sometimes true, and it has some hardening effects on the currency. 136 00:07:40,209 --> 00:08:13,941 But the challenge is, and what makes this very different than the 137 00:08:13,941 --> 00:08:53,295 ‘70s, and more in some ways like the ‘40s, kind of the last time 138 00:08:53,295 --> 00:09:32,649 we were in kind of a public sector debt bubble, is in the ‘70s, 139 00:09:32,649 --> 00:10:03,570 most of the inflation, the money creation we were seeing, was 140 00:10:03,570 --> 00:10:34,491 from private sector bank lending. And of course, we had deficits 141 00:10:34,491 --> 00:10:59,790 on top of that, but quantitatively, the private sector 142 00:10:59,790 --> 00:11:11,034 was the biggest component. So,when you raise interest rates 143 00:06:39,051 --> 00:07:14,151 to slow down bank lending, that has a bigger downward push on 144 00:07:14,151 --> 00:07:43,401 money creation than blowing out the fiscal interest expense - 145 00:07:43,401 --> 00:08:09,726 the government interest expense. Whereas when you have over 146 00:08:09,726 --> 00:08:50,676 100% or 120% debt to GDP, and you have a lot of money creation 147 00:08:50,676 --> 00:09:17,001 coming from fiscal deficits, monetized fiscal deficits, and less 148 00:09:17,001 --> 00:09:52,101 so from very quick bank lending, if you raise rates in the 149 00:09:52,101 --> 00:10:30,126 face of inflation, you do slow down bank lending to a certain degree, 150 00:10:30,126 --> 00:11:05,226 but then you blow out federal interest expense by an even greater 151 00:11:05,226 --> 00:11:11,076 absolute number. Andso, you kind of get into this loop that's 152 00:06:46,041 --> 00:07:17,943 pretty hard to slow down fully. And then on top of that, we 153 00:07:17,943 --> 00:07:42,483 have demographics issues. That's not new to everyone. But when 154 00:07:42,483 --> 00:08:11,931 you kind of lock that in, that's who votes, that's kind of 155 00:08:11,931 --> 00:08:46,287 where a lot of things are. A lot of people are trained to kind 156 00:08:46,287 --> 00:09:03,465 of think that aging demographics are disinflationary, 157 00:09:03,465 --> 00:09:32,913 which can be true if the older demographic is impoverished, if they're 158 00:09:32,913 --> 00:09:59,907 not consuming a lot. But if they're also backstopped by, you 159 00:09:59,907 --> 00:10:24,447 know, very high medical cost per capita, Social Security, all 160 00:10:24,447 --> 00:10:48,987 these other things, that can actually be kind of inflationary, 161 00:10:48,987 --> 00:11:11,073 at least for the things that that demographic consumes. Andso, 162 00:06:25,667 --> 00:06:44,414 a combination of basically just decades of debt accumulation 163 00:06:44,414 --> 00:07:05,244 and where that debt ended up, demographics and entitlements to 164 00:07:05,244 --> 00:07:32,323 support them. And then add on to that (it's kind of more unique 165 00:07:32,323 --> 00:07:57,319 to the US than, say, Europe and elsewhere), is that we're heavily 166 00:07:57,319 --> 00:08:18,149 financialized, meaning that can mean a number of things. But 167 00:08:18,149 --> 00:08:43,145 in this context, it means that our tax receipts are more correlated 168 00:08:43,145 --> 00:09:03,975 with asset prices than many other developed countries. So, if 169 00:09:03,975 --> 00:09:28,971 you're not kind of pumping the stock market with a 12-month lag 170 00:09:28,971 --> 00:09:53,967 or so, you're going to start to get materially weaker tax receipts. 171 00:09:53,967 --> 00:10:21,046 You actually kind of add fuel to the deficit fire. So, we have 172 00:10:21,046 --> 00:10:48,125 a bunch of kind of flywheels that are all very, very, very hard 173 00:10:48,125 --> 00:11:11,038 to slow down. I never quite say impossible, but nearly so. 174 00:11:11,351 --> 00:11:21,812 We definitely agree on fiscal dominance, you can't stop this train. 175 00:11:21,812 --> 00:11:31,322 I think this conversation about why it's inevitable, I think 176 00:11:31,322 --> 00:11:44,636 we slightly disagree on this. I'd love to kind of dive in a little 177 00:11:44,636 --> 00:11:56,048 bit and think about it. And there's no right answer, right? We're 178 00:11:56,048 --> 00:12:08,411 trying to tease this out. But I do think the why is important, 179 00:12:08,411 --> 00:12:18,872 given how things are changing and how those whys might change. 180 00:11:11,351 --> 00:11:16,733 Andby the way, I also agree this is different than the ‘70s, 181 00:11:16,733 --> 00:11:21,701 even though I've highlighted the ‘60s and ‘70s as the most closely 182 00:11:21,701 --> 00:11:26,669 parallel recent time frame, and I'll get to why. But I really, 183 00:11:26,669 --> 00:11:32,465 I have a question that is kind of a leading question for you, which 184 00:11:32,465 --> 00:11:38,261 is, what do you say to people who, again, five years ago, you heard 185 00:11:38,261 --> 00:11:42,401 all about modern monetary theory, right? You heard about debts 186 00:11:42,401 --> 00:11:47,369 don't matter if you're at the exorbitant privilege of the US dollar 187 00:11:47,369 --> 00:11:53,165 (which is a big asterisk, by the way), which we'll get to a little 188 00:11:53,165 --> 00:11:58,133 bit later. But there is a theory out there, and I actually 189 00:11:58,133 --> 00:12:03,515 tend to think that's true, as long as you have the exorbitant privilege 190 00:12:03,515 --> 00:12:08,069 of the US dollar, that the debt itself doesn't necessarily matter. 191 00:12:08,069 --> 00:12:14,279 What is your view on that? And tell me why you feel that you don't 192 00:12:14,279 --> 00:12:18,833 agree with that, because it sounds like you don't agree with. 193 00:11:11,351 --> 00:12:18,941 that. 194 00:12:19,501 --> 00:12:23,329 Well, I think that it does matter. I wouldn't disagree that 195 00:12:23,329 --> 00:12:26,809 it matters. It's just that it's not a complete immunization 196 00:12:26,809 --> 00:12:31,681 of the issue. So, if you take two extremes, if you take a developing 197 00:12:31,681 --> 00:12:35,161 country that does not have almost any external structural demand 198 00:12:35,161 --> 00:12:38,989 for its currency, if they run very large deficits, especially monetized 199 00:12:38,989 --> 00:12:42,469 deficits or partially, they're very likely to rapidly devalue their 200 00:12:42,469 --> 00:12:46,297 currency. Whereas the US, I mean, you have trillions, or realistically 201 00:12:46,297 --> 00:12:48,733 10s of trillions of dollar-denominated liabilities outside 202 00:12:48,733 --> 00:12:54,301 of the US, most not even owe it to the US. Mostly owe it to other 203 00:12:54,301 --> 00:12:57,781 countries, but it's still just inflexible demand for dollars. And 204 00:12:57,781 --> 00:13:01,957 all of that kind of represents a really big absorption for dollars, 205 00:13:01,957 --> 00:13:06,829 let alone just the demand for US assets, you know, kind of a demand 206 00:13:06,829 --> 00:13:08,569 to come and live here. 207 00:13:08,781 --> 00:13:11,925 This is the exorbitant privilege of the US dollar to a great 208 00:13:11,925 --> 00:13:12,449 extent, right? 209 00:13:13,021 --> 00:13:23,876 Yeah. And so basically, that's also why I'm not… The two sides of 210 00:13:23,876 --> 00:13:33,896 the ‘nothing stops the train’ view is that, one, there's very little 211 00:13:33,896 --> 00:13:43,081 method to slow down the deficits, but also that it's not 212 00:13:43,081 --> 00:13:53,936 going to completely go off the rails and just spiral out of control 213 00:13:53,936 --> 00:14:01,451 anytime soon, because it's actually also quite resilient to 214 00:14:01,451 --> 00:14:09,801 upside shocks. Because there is all this entrenched demand for 215 00:14:09,801 --> 00:14:10,636 dollars. Maybewhere we disagree is that the effects still 216 00:13:18,718 --> 00:13:25,048 happen. There still are effects of running those fiscal deficits. 217 00:13:25,048 --> 00:13:32,644 I mean, I think they have effects on asset prices. I think 218 00:13:32,644 --> 00:13:40,240 they have effects on, you know, the economy - winners and losers 219 00:13:40,240 --> 00:13:47,836 in the economy. They have effects on a matter of things, but 220 00:13:47,836 --> 00:13:55,432 they don't have the same effects as they would if, say, you 221 00:13:55,432 --> 00:14:02,395 know, the UK ran a similar playbook. And then especially if, 222 00:14:02,395 --> 00:14:09,358 you know, Egypt ran a similar playbook, there's a spectrum there 223 00:14:09,358 --> 00:14:10,624 for sure. 224 00:14:10,701 --> 00:14:34,173 Yeah, I think obviously there's a dramatic difference, right? 225 00:14:34,173 --> 00:15:02,861 In a normal system, we obviously agree that prices of currency 226 00:15:02,861 --> 00:15:31,549 will adjust to take into account deficits and the issues at 227 00:15:31,549 --> 00:16:02,845 hand. But obviously, as we've seen, this is not news, right? If 228 00:16:02,845 --> 00:16:36,749 the Fed could at any point print all the money at once, fix 229 00:16:36,749 --> 00:17:08,045 the cyclical problems as we go, and then, at some point, just 230 00:17:08,045 --> 00:17:44,557 hit a button on a keyboard and make it monetize that debt, Is it 231 00:17:44,557 --> 00:17:49,773 really debt? AndI'm actually, generally, of the view, as long as 232 00:14:32,831 --> 00:14:57,174 (again, big asterisk) the US has the exorbitant privilege of the 233 00:14:57,174 --> 00:15:19,304 dollar, we really can, debt doesn't matter. Okay? Now, that's 234 00:15:19,304 --> 00:15:52,499 a big asterisk, and we'll have to kind of get to that in a second. 235 00:15:52,499 --> 00:16:21,268 But what it does mean is that the net result, I actually would 236 00:16:21,268 --> 00:16:43,398 argue, even more inflationary. I would argue that, ironically, the 237 00:16:43,398 --> 00:17:07,741 more that you can print to avoid cyclical downturns, it supports 238 00:17:07,741 --> 00:17:32,084 to a baseline non-deflationary path, as we've seen. You always have 239 00:17:32,084 --> 00:17:49,788 that tool that you can deploy at scale. Thebig component I really 240 00:14:26,576 --> 00:15:04,676 think matters is populism. It's who the money is going to. In 241 00:15:04,676 --> 00:15:45,951 our system right now, and the reason that the ‘60s and ‘70s played 242 00:15:45,951 --> 00:16:30,401 out the way they did, in my opinion, is not just because of debts. 243 00:16:30,401 --> 00:17:08,501 I actually think debts are secondary in our system as it stands, 244 00:17:08,501 --> 00:17:43,426 with exorbitant privilege of the US dollar, it's about who's getting 245 00:17:43,426 --> 00:17:49,776 the money. Wekeep doing… And you've talked about this in your 246 00:14:32,181 --> 00:14:53,661 papers. It's a very blunt instrument. Monetary policy and the 247 00:14:53,661 --> 00:15:15,141 Federal Reserve has a very limited ability to stop inflation 248 00:15:15,141 --> 00:15:34,473 when it gets going, because usually what's causing inflation 249 00:15:34,473 --> 00:15:55,953 is actually government sending money, or global conflict, and tariffs, 250 00:15:55,953 --> 00:16:15,285 and protectionism, things that are driven by governmental decisions 251 00:16:15,285 --> 00:16:38,913 that aren't free market, that are really driving kind of money 252 00:16:38,913 --> 00:17:04,689 to people who spend, right? And in my view, the incentives there 253 00:17:04,689 --> 00:17:24,021 are really about, like, political incentives. We were just 254 00:17:24,021 --> 00:17:43,353 talking to Neil Howe, actually, last month, which was, 255 00:17:43,353 --> 00:17:49,797 I think, apropos… So,the reality, in my view, is that the 256 00:14:36,990 --> 00:15:06,200 bigger driver is this populist impulse, these bigger cycles. And 257 00:15:06,200 --> 00:15:44,173 we just had Neil Howe on here talking about the 4th turning and 258 00:15:44,173 --> 00:16:10,462 kind of generational political realities. But inflation, I actually 259 00:16:10,462 --> 00:16:36,751 agree with some monetary theory, modern monetary theory principles 260 00:16:36,751 --> 00:17:14,724 in the sense that I don't think as long as (big asterisk) you 261 00:17:14,724 --> 00:17:43,934 have exorbitant privilege of the US dollar, that debts really 262 00:17:43,934 --> 00:17:49,776 matter, right? Debtsmatter when you're forced by the world to 263 00:14:46,548 --> 00:15:46,293 pay the price. But if we can print as much money as we want and 264 00:15:46,293 --> 00:16:26,123 drive outcomes, especially if we're driving it to capital. That 265 00:16:26,123 --> 00:16:54,004 creates a structurally deflationary force of technological 266 00:16:54,004 --> 00:17:25,868 development, globalization, right? All those things that we've 267 00:17:25,868 --> 00:17:49,766 experienced for the last 40 years. Butmy view is that really 268 00:14:30,321 --> 00:14:59,751 that this populism, the political pressures that demand now 269 00:14:59,751 --> 00:15:38,991 money, fiscal goes to people, which has a velocity of 1, really 270 00:15:38,991 --> 00:16:05,151 can drive those structural inflationary pressures. And that 271 00:16:05,151 --> 00:16:37,851 makes, to your point, this train unstoppable. Because if people 272 00:16:37,851 --> 00:17:17,091 want it, politically, you better give it to them. How are you 273 00:17:17,091 --> 00:17:49,810 going to stop? Otherwise, you get knocked out of office. Idon'tknow. 274 00:14:36,993 --> 00:16:22,161 What are your thoughts about that? And do you agree with that? 275 00:16:22,161 --> 00:17:49,801 Or by all means, pick some bones with that view. 276 00:17:50,531 --> 00:18:28,088 I agree with that view. I just don't view it as mutually exclusive. 277 00:18:28,088 --> 00:19:08,534 I think these things tend to feed on each other. One of the things 278 00:19:08,534 --> 00:19:43,202 I pointed out in a newsletter before is that the long-term debt 279 00:19:43,202 --> 00:20:12,092 cycles correlate with the 4th turnings. And there's build-up ahead 280 00:20:12,092 --> 00:20:46,760 of time in the kind of the second and third turning leading 281 00:20:46,760 --> 00:21:24,317 into that. And I view that as kind of like the quantitative backdrop 282 00:21:24,317 --> 00:21:35,873 to what's happening socially. So,for example, I've read The 4th 283 00:18:06,148 --> 00:18:28,458 Turning because I find it instructive to know what's happening 284 00:18:28,458 --> 00:18:52,999 socially in addition to what's happening from that more kind of 285 00:18:52,999 --> 00:19:10,847 financial engineering perspective. And I think a specific 286 00:19:10,847 --> 00:19:39,850 catalyst for how this kind of came together was as you get those 287 00:19:39,850 --> 00:20:06,622 lower and lower interest rates, as you get that kind of rising 288 00:20:06,622 --> 00:20:35,625 private debt bubble, when they ran into kind of the end of that, 289 00:20:35,625 --> 00:20:57,935 leading into the global financial crisis, they had cut interest 290 00:20:57,935 --> 00:21:24,707 rates all the way to zero. They had banks about as leveraged 291 00:21:24,707 --> 00:21:35,862 as you can get them. So,I mean, just generally speaking, if 292 00:18:12,140 --> 00:18:49,184 you look at total debt in the system, there was something like 293 00:18:49,184 --> 00:19:29,315 US$60 of debt for every US$1 of base money. And bank cash, banks 294 00:19:29,315 --> 00:20:09,446 had 3% of their assets as cash. And then the rest was mostly 295 00:20:09,446 --> 00:20:43,403 loans. So, they were taking on basically a greater proportion of 296 00:20:43,403 --> 00:21:17,360 risk. And you had kind of maximum fractional reserve in the 297 00:21:17,360 --> 00:21:35,882 system measured in various different ways. Andso, when that 298 00:18:09,711 --> 00:18:57,661 started to crumble, that's when interest rates are no longer 299 00:18:57,661 --> 00:19:50,406 cutting it, minor stimulus was no longer cutting it. That's when 300 00:19:50,406 --> 00:20:38,356 they shift more toward bank recapitalization. You know, the last 301 00:20:38,356 --> 00:21:35,896 time they had done something of that scale was the early 1930s. 302 00:17:50,531 --> 00:18:23,083 Andso, when they did that here in, you know, 2008 and 2009, 303 00:18:23,083 --> 00:18:53,131 There was a big populist wave that came quickly after that. You 304 00:18:53,131 --> 00:19:28,187 had the TPR on the right, you had Occupy Wall Street more on the 305 00:19:28,187 --> 00:20:05,747 left. And a lot of that was a reaction to, once you bail out one 306 00:20:05,747 --> 00:20:28,283 group significantly, there's like this, obviously, a big spreading 307 00:20:28,283 --> 00:20:55,827 of unfairness. It's like, well, why did that group get bailed 308 00:20:55,827 --> 00:21:25,875 out? Let's bail out other groups as well. And more people say, 309 00:21:25,875 --> 00:21:35,891 okay, the system's rigged. Itall kind of blew up, and then 310 00:18:14,251 --> 00:18:46,866 we had selective bailouts. And then I think populism started to 311 00:18:46,866 --> 00:19:16,516 build very quickly, especially from that point, because we kind 312 00:19:16,516 --> 00:19:55,061 of ran into financial bedrock. We ran into that peak of the private 313 00:19:55,061 --> 00:20:30,641 sector debt bubble, shifted it more to the public sector. And at 314 00:20:30,641 --> 00:21:00,291 that point, it's kind of everyone's problem, because now we're 315 00:21:00,291 --> 00:21:35,871 shifting it more toward the public ledger that we all care about. 316 00:17:50,531 --> 00:18:37,786 Andso, I do think that, ever since then, we've had rapidly rising 317 00:18:37,786 --> 00:19:06,866 populism. both fiscally, socially, across the board. It's 318 00:19:06,866 --> 00:19:54,121 not an accident that when we had COVID, we had a very different 319 00:19:54,121 --> 00:20:30,471 type of stimulus. Instead of just recapitalizing the banks, it 320 00:20:30,471 --> 00:21:10,456 was way more widespread because I think of where we are. 321 00:21:10,456 --> 00:21:35,901 I do take that populism into account. Anotherway of looking at 322 00:18:09,001 --> 00:19:00,717 it is, in the 2010s, like the Paul Ryan era of the Republican Party, 323 00:19:00,717 --> 00:19:33,963 it was more about trimming entitlement spending. There were 324 00:19:33,963 --> 00:20:07,209 attempts for a “grand bargain” between the Obama administration 325 00:20:07,209 --> 00:20:55,231 and the Republican opposition to say, OK, how can we kind of right-size 326 00:20:55,231 --> 00:21:35,865 entitlement to some degree? How can we do some cost controls? 327 00:17:50,531 --> 00:18:35,606 Butwhen we were in kind of the current - the Trump era of the 328 00:18:35,606 --> 00:19:08,661 Republican Party, for example, in the latest election, I think point 329 00:19:08,661 --> 00:19:44,721 14 in the Republican platform was no cuts to Social Security or 330 00:19:44,721 --> 00:20:20,781 Medicare, right? And so that used to be a Democrat position just 331 00:20:20,781 --> 00:20:53,836 because it's a type of populism. We've kind of exited the 332 00:20:53,836 --> 00:21:32,901 era of fiscal austerity in the US because we have that more structural 333 00:21:32,901 --> 00:21:35,906 populism. AndI think, also, that the structural trade balances 334 00:18:42,542 --> 00:19:51,890 and things like that also contributed to it. So, I think the 335 00:19:51,890 --> 00:20:43,901 long-term debt cycle, the structural trade deficit, and then 336 00:20:43,901 --> 00:21:35,912 the populism component are absolutely an element of that. 337 00:21:35,921 --> 00:22:17,739 But I actually would argue that it's all of it, and let me tell 338 00:22:17,739 --> 00:22:53,583 you why. I think all those things, the trade deficit as well, 339 00:22:53,583 --> 00:23:23,453 is driven by… If you're sending money to corporations, what 340 00:23:23,453 --> 00:23:47,349 happens? You get faster and faster technological development, 341 00:23:47,349 --> 00:24:05,271 right? It's A profit-maximizing machine. Clearly, 342 00:24:05,271 --> 00:24:23,193 that's going to lead to globalization. Corporationsdon't 343 00:21:40,701 --> 00:22:09,381 care about the people of the US versus other countries, they don't. 344 00:22:09,381 --> 00:22:33,281 They're not incentivized to, right? And so, the massive globalization 345 00:22:33,281 --> 00:23:06,741 wave, the building of China over the last 40 years is not a coincidence 346 00:23:06,741 --> 00:23:35,421 that happened over the same time period. At the same time, you 347 00:23:35,421 --> 00:23:59,321 have global peace because if you're trading with other countries, 348 00:23:59,321 --> 00:24:23,221 you're helping them grow. This is the Pax Americana, right? That'swhat 349 00:21:40,567 --> 00:22:08,443 drives peace. It's the lack of populism, sending capital to the 350 00:22:08,443 --> 00:22:27,027 top is what drives peace, globalization, and technological 351 00:22:27,027 --> 00:22:50,257 development. It's the free market system on steroids. And you 352 00:22:50,257 --> 00:23:18,133 could pump a bunch of oxygen into that system. And honestly, you 353 00:23:18,133 --> 00:23:43,686 could do it forever. What happened here in the Mesozoic era? 354 00:23:43,686 --> 00:24:13,885 We got really big dinosaurs. You could pump as much cash as you 355 00:24:13,885 --> 00:24:23,177 want into that system. Andhonestly, if we were cogs, if 356 00:21:49,858 --> 00:22:13,750 you and I weren't human beings, we would do that. That system 357 00:22:13,750 --> 00:22:37,642 creates, in the words of Socrates, do you give the best violin 358 00:22:37,642 --> 00:23:01,534 players the best violins, or do you give the worst violin players 359 00:23:01,534 --> 00:23:27,417 the best violins? His answer was you give them to the best violin 360 00:23:27,417 --> 00:23:45,336 players because you get infinitely beautiful music. The natural 361 00:23:45,336 --> 00:24:03,255 system is a system that creates more advancement, evolution, 362 00:24:03,255 --> 00:24:23,165 survival of the fittest, if we pump more into it. Theproblem with 363 00:21:43,193 --> 00:22:17,129 that is nature is raw in tooth and claw. And it doesn't care about 364 00:22:17,129 --> 00:22:53,489 you or I. And populism, at the end of the day, is when that system 365 00:22:53,489 --> 00:23:27,425 gets so out of shape, as human beings, life isn't fair, but we have 366 00:23:27,425 --> 00:23:58,937 a sense of fairness. We all agree there should be some type of 367 00:23:58,937 --> 00:24:23,177 fairness. And that, which is the left and right dynamic… Thisis 368 00:21:40,505 --> 00:22:03,425 why, since Roman and Greek times, they've talked about left 369 00:22:03,425 --> 00:22:28,637 and right. This is why the political spectrum is populism, equality, 370 00:22:28,637 --> 00:22:44,681 versus this free market, winner-take-all evolutionary system. 371 00:22:44,681 --> 00:23:14,477 So, I think that's everything. It drives the lack of peace. It drives 372 00:23:14,477 --> 00:23:37,397 expansion and trade. It's also when commodities aren't scarce if 373 00:23:37,397 --> 00:24:07,193 we all trade and work with each other in a free world, right? 374 00:24:07,193 --> 00:24:23,237 There's enough for everybody to go around. Butwhen we break up 375 00:21:48,596 --> 00:22:16,481 that system and go talk about our people, protectionism has to 376 00:22:16,481 --> 00:22:41,831 happen. So, we get global conflict, we get commodity scarcity, 377 00:22:41,831 --> 00:23:14,786 right? Anyway, this is my view and that this is the connective tissue 378 00:23:14,786 --> 00:23:40,136 to why this train doesn't stop. And it's really political. 379 00:23:40,136 --> 00:24:13,091 And so, I really think it drives the whole thing. I would love 380 00:24:13,091 --> 00:24:23,231 to hear your thoughts. 381 00:24:23,241 --> 00:24:56,241 Well, I agree. And I think, I mean, the way I would put it is, 382 00:24:56,241 --> 00:25:11,641 there are certain technological milestones that really 383 00:25:11,641 --> 00:25:31,441 matter. So, for example, as global telecom systems gradually 384 00:25:31,441 --> 00:25:53,441 kept improving throughout the 20th century, when we finally got 385 00:25:53,441 --> 00:26:22,041 to kind of the early stages of the internet and just, in general, 386 00:26:22,041 --> 00:26:37,441 fairly high bandwidth communications, that obviously made 387 00:26:37,441 --> 00:26:59,441 globalization a lot easier. It's much easier to coordinate around 388 00:26:59,441 --> 00:27:23,641 the world when you have very efficient ways to communicate with 389 00:27:23,641 --> 00:27:30,241 your off-site operations. Andthen when you add to it. I mean, 390 00:24:42,150 --> 00:25:05,261 you had the opening of China from obviously very, very anti-market 391 00:25:05,261 --> 00:25:30,473 approaches in the early ‘80s. They were kind of opening that up 392 00:25:30,473 --> 00:25:57,786 to the rest of the world, late ‘70s, early ‘80s. Of course, the 393 00:25:57,786 --> 00:26:25,099 fall of the Soviet Union. You had all of this Eastern labor, Eastern 394 00:26:25,099 --> 00:26:46,109 kind of resources connecting with Western capital. And so, this 395 00:26:46,109 --> 00:27:00,816 was this kind of disinflationary globalization boom 396 00:27:00,816 --> 00:27:26,028 because you had all these kind of things that were segmented to 397 00:27:26,028 --> 00:27:30,230 come together. Andlike anything else, there's winners and 398 00:24:42,491 --> 00:25:09,991 losers from that. I mean, prices go down significantly, you 399 00:25:09,991 --> 00:25:40,241 have all these efficiencies build up, but then you also have 400 00:25:40,241 --> 00:26:10,491 protected labor which now has a lot more global competition and 401 00:26:10,491 --> 00:26:43,491 that is perceived as quite unfair. And it kind of widens the 402 00:26:43,491 --> 00:27:16,491 gap between those with capital and those relying on labor. And I 403 00:27:16,491 --> 00:27:30,241 think that builds over time. Andthen behind that, I do think, 404 00:24:44,017 --> 00:25:13,697 there are also these structural things that kind of build 405 00:25:13,697 --> 00:25:46,345 up these higher, higher debt levels, these lower and lower interest 406 00:25:46,345 --> 00:26:13,057 rates. The trade balance itself is fascinating because in 407 00:26:13,057 --> 00:26:45,705 order to run the global reserve currency, it means the whole 408 00:26:45,705 --> 00:27:18,353 world has to have access to that currency, that there's currency 409 00:27:18,353 --> 00:27:30,225 around that's being used. Andthe way the US gets the currency 410 00:24:35,913 --> 00:24:53,337 out to the world is we run these structural trade deficits. 411 00:24:53,337 --> 00:25:10,761 And the demand for the currency kind of fuels those deficits 412 00:25:10,761 --> 00:25:23,433 because basically most currencies, they trade on things 413 00:25:23,433 --> 00:25:32,937 like interest rate differentials, current accounts, 414 00:25:32,937 --> 00:25:50,361 things like that. The dollar has this extra component where there's 415 00:25:50,361 --> 00:26:10,953 like this inflexible extra demand for it on top of all the normal 416 00:26:10,953 --> 00:26:28,377 things. We still have dollar cycles. and things like that. But 417 00:26:28,377 --> 00:26:47,385 on top of all the normal things that matter for currency pairs, 418 00:26:47,385 --> 00:27:03,225 there's just the fact that just, there's this constant kind 419 00:27:03,225 --> 00:27:25,401 of bid for it as a sovereign reserve asset, as the place to store 420 00:27:25,401 --> 00:27:30,153 longer term capital. Andso, compared to all these other dynamics, 421 00:24:35,705 --> 00:24:54,401 the dollar ends up kind of being overvalued. So, it boosts our 422 00:24:54,401 --> 00:25:06,865 input power. It hurts our export competitiveness, especially 423 00:25:06,865 --> 00:25:25,561 on lower margin stuff. So, you know, we become experts in exporting 424 00:25:25,561 --> 00:25:39,583 dollars, securities, high margin tech and healthcare, but it 425 00:25:39,583 --> 00:25:58,279 kind of eats away at our, say, manufacturing exports. And so, these 426 00:25:58,279 --> 00:26:13,859 dynamics kind of reinforce themselves for a while. So, we've 427 00:26:13,859 --> 00:26:32,555 seen a gravitation of wealth away from the Rust Belt and toward, 428 00:26:32,555 --> 00:26:49,693 you know, New York, and Silicon Valley, and all that, because 429 00:26:49,693 --> 00:27:06,831 these imbalances build up over time. As that happens, there also 430 00:27:06,831 --> 00:27:22,411 is that political element that grows. as people are disenfranchised 431 00:27:22,411 --> 00:27:30,201 and it fuels on itself. 432 00:27:30,561 --> 00:27:41,586 Yeah, and this momentum effect, right, to everything, like 433 00:27:41,586 --> 00:27:55,061 you mentioned. You just mentioned three or four, but it goes 434 00:27:55,061 --> 00:28:06,086 across the board. It's the financialization, as you mentioned 435 00:28:06,086 --> 00:28:19,561 before, too. It's the leverage in the system. Everything is assumed 436 00:28:19,561 --> 00:28:37,936 that it will keep going as it goes. I guess my point is, it could 437 00:28:37,936 --> 00:28:50,186 if people weren't in the system and didn't demand fairness. 438 00:27:30,561 --> 00:27:45,625 AndI think we started to see that, to your point, in 2009, 2010, 439 00:27:45,625 --> 00:27:57,461 Occupy Wall Street, Tea Party. The difference is, those people that 440 00:27:57,461 --> 00:28:11,449 were behind that movement were in their 20s. And why were they in 441 00:28:11,449 --> 00:28:25,437 the 20s? Because these are the people that were born in 1982 or 442 00:28:25,437 --> 00:28:38,349 so, because that was the peak in interest rates. That was before 443 00:28:38,349 --> 00:28:48,033 this monetary policy supply side, Reagan, Federal Reserve monetary 444 00:28:48,033 --> 00:28:50,185 policy system. Andso, that generation, who has only now seen 445 00:27:39,993 --> 00:27:53,617 one thing, they didn't see the ‘60s and ‘70s into early ‘80s. All 446 00:27:53,617 --> 00:28:03,049 they've experienced is this one-sided free market economic model, 447 00:28:03,049 --> 00:28:15,625 which isn't fair. And they're at 45% of the wealth creation and 448 00:28:15,625 --> 00:28:27,153 household formation of baby boomers, living at home. You know, 449 00:28:27,153 --> 00:28:40,777 30% of them are living at home in mom and dad's basement. right? 450 00:28:40,777 --> 00:28:50,209 And that creates a lot of anger and populism. 451 00:28:51,681 --> 00:29:02,571 Eventually, those people learn through what's coming, the cycle 452 00:29:02,571 --> 00:29:14,671 that's coming, that the opposite is also a problem. That 453 00:29:14,671 --> 00:29:27,981 even a more fair system then creates much worse economic outcomes, 454 00:29:27,981 --> 00:29:36,451 much slower growth, much slower technological development, 455 00:29:36,451 --> 00:29:48,551 global conflict, all the problems we're seeing, is kind of 456 00:29:48,551 --> 00:29:50,971 my view. So,now the big asterisk, now that we've kind of 457 00:28:56,501 --> 00:29:02,285 talked through this (I think this is a great kind of back-and-forth 458 00:29:02,285 --> 00:29:07,587 conversation). I did say there's a big asterisk. I think it's 459 00:29:07,587 --> 00:29:13,853 more important than ever. I think maybe a year ago, or at least 460 00:29:13,853 --> 00:29:20,119 two years ago, before Trump came in the picture, I think we would 461 00:29:20,119 --> 00:29:25,421 have all said exorbitant privilege of the US dollar is not 462 00:29:25,421 --> 00:29:30,723 going anywhere anytime soon. I think it's hard standing here today, 463 00:29:30,723 --> 00:29:36,507 with what's going on in Iran, for example, to not releasing in 464 00:29:36,507 --> 00:29:42,291 the Strait of Hormuz, and we know about the petrodollar and the 465 00:29:42,291 --> 00:29:47,111 critical importance of that, of not least questioning that timeline 466 00:29:47,111 --> 00:29:50,967 might be shorter. Again, hard to say, right? 467 00:29:53,231 --> 00:29:57,119 But now let's do a little thought experiment. I'd love to hear 468 00:29:57,119 --> 00:30:00,035 your thoughts about what does removing the exorbitant privilege 469 00:30:00,035 --> 00:30:03,923 of the US dollar do to this fiscal dominance, to the picture? 470 00:30:03,923 --> 00:30:08,135 What does this do to macro outcomes? I think we know some of 471 00:30:08,135 --> 00:30:12,671 the scary big answers to that, but I'd love to kind of walk through 472 00:30:12,671 --> 00:30:14,291 maybe how that changes everything. 473 00:30:15,511 --> 00:30:37,027 Sure. I think, I mean, on the negative side, basically, if there's 474 00:30:37,027 --> 00:30:56,750 less external demand for the dollar, and you're running big deficits, 475 00:30:56,750 --> 00:31:21,852 and issuing a lot of debt to fund those deficits, it means a higher 476 00:31:21,852 --> 00:31:41,575 ratio of that debt has to be bought domestically. Which generally 477 00:31:41,575 --> 00:32:03,091 gives you the crowding out effect. It means more so you just 478 00:32:03,091 --> 00:32:24,607 have to buy debt instead of buying equity or making loans and 479 00:32:24,607 --> 00:32:47,916 things like that. Or you have the central bank buy it, in which 480 00:32:47,916 --> 00:33:07,639 case that can contribute to inflation. And so, it takes away 481 00:33:07,639 --> 00:33:27,362 that extra structural, or at least it reduces that extra structural 482 00:33:27,362 --> 00:33:54,257 bid for the dollar and kind of makes it so that the US starts to 483 00:33:54,257 --> 00:34:08,601 resemble many other developed countries in that regard. Theupside 484 00:30:21,127 --> 00:30:54,823 of it is that having the global reserve status is an exorbitant 485 00:30:54,823 --> 00:31:25,711 privilege, but it does come with costs. As I mentioned before, 486 00:31:25,711 --> 00:32:02,215 it means you have to supply the world with dollars, and the world 487 00:32:02,215 --> 00:32:35,911 has this extra bid for dollars. And so, if you're in the 488 00:32:35,911 --> 00:33:03,991 business of selling dollars, like the government is - government 489 00:33:03,991 --> 00:33:32,071 security, dollar securities; or you're in the business of selling 490 00:33:32,071 --> 00:34:02,959 private securities - New York, and Silicon Valley, and all that, 491 00:34:02,959 --> 00:34:08,575 that's great. Basically,we're in the massive kind of dollar export 492 00:30:55,093 --> 00:31:43,471 business. But if you're in the business of making things, especially 493 00:31:43,471 --> 00:32:27,451 lower margin things, doing that in the reserve currency country 494 00:32:27,451 --> 00:33:02,635 is extraordinarily challenging because you're kind of competing 495 00:33:02,635 --> 00:33:33,421 with this artificially valuable currency against countries 496 00:33:33,421 --> 00:34:08,605 that are running more mercantilist type of playbooks. Andthe 497 00:30:21,645 --> 00:31:01,516 math is against you because you can still… If you're like a top 498 00:31:01,516 --> 00:31:38,320 tier performer, you can still make it work, you can still make 499 00:31:38,320 --> 00:32:05,923 the math work. But structurally, one way or another, 500 00:32:05,923 --> 00:32:45,794 we are sending dollars to the rest of the world and it's primarily 501 00:32:45,794 --> 00:33:22,598 through trade deficits, which means that on a trade basis, we have 502 00:33:22,598 --> 00:33:53,268 more losers than winners. Again, if you're outside of that 503 00:33:53,268 --> 00:34:08,603 kind of dollar export business. Andso, another way of 504 00:30:24,906 --> 00:30:47,454 kind of looking at it is the dollar status, as currently structured, 505 00:30:47,454 --> 00:31:08,123 is really good for like America, the empire. I mean, when 506 00:31:08,123 --> 00:31:30,671 you can sanction any country, when we have the advantage that we 507 00:31:30,671 --> 00:31:55,098 can kind of surveil things. So, we can have this kind of global 508 00:31:55,098 --> 00:32:15,767 network of kind of financial surveillance that, you know, if Japan 509 00:32:15,767 --> 00:32:42,073 wants to do that, or the UK wants to do that, or especially if, 510 00:32:42,073 --> 00:33:04,621 you know, a country like Brazil wants to do that, they don't 511 00:33:04,621 --> 00:33:23,411 really have that capability. Whereas the US says, well, you're 512 00:33:23,411 --> 00:33:49,717 all using dollars, so as long as you want to play good with our 513 00:33:49,717 --> 00:34:08,507 system, you have to do these reporting requirements, for example. 514 00:30:15,511 --> 00:30:59,611 So,it gives us a lot of power and insight into the whole global 515 00:30:59,611 --> 00:31:34,261 financial system. But then the cost for America the country, or 516 00:31:34,261 --> 00:32:08,911 America the republic, like our domestic economy, does have a cost 517 00:32:08,911 --> 00:32:53,011 to support that. It's kind of one way of thinking of it is that 518 00:32:53,011 --> 00:33:27,661 in order to maintain that system, we're kind of shipping off 519 00:33:27,661 --> 00:33:59,161 a little piece of our industrial base every year, which 520 00:33:59,161 --> 00:34:08,611 is not infinite. Andso, again, there's winners and losers 521 00:30:31,989 --> 00:31:02,591 of that system. And I think what happens when it kind of reaches 522 00:31:02,591 --> 00:31:28,485 its kind of stretching point, I think one thing that's happened 523 00:31:28,485 --> 00:31:59,087 in this part of the populism dynamic is we just kind of started 524 00:31:59,087 --> 00:32:17,919 openingly questioning, is running these structural trade deficits 525 00:32:17,919 --> 00:32:55,583 every year good for all of us, or is it good for a few? I think 526 00:32:55,583 --> 00:33:21,477 that it's not an accident that's become more elevated in political 527 00:33:21,477 --> 00:33:45,017 rhetoric. That's been a big component of both Trump administrations, 528 00:33:45,017 --> 00:34:08,557 to kind of highlight that more than other administrations have. 529 00:30:15,511 --> 00:31:48,751 Andso, I think that there's upsides and downsides to having the 530 00:31:48,751 --> 00:33:06,451 global reserve currency status, but the messier part is when 531 00:33:06,451 --> 00:34:08,611 it's kind of taken away from you unwillingly. 532 00:34:08,701 --> 00:34:29,785 I would push back a little bit, just for the sake of being political 533 00:34:29,785 --> 00:34:47,857 here too. I would say, losing the exorbitant privilege of the US 534 00:34:47,857 --> 00:35:05,929 dollar would be a massive problem for the US. And I actually 535 00:35:05,929 --> 00:35:22,495 think the benefits, the mild costs there are (to your point), 536 00:35:22,495 --> 00:35:40,567 which is like trade deficits, etc., could in theory, if we print 537 00:35:40,567 --> 00:35:57,133 enough money, we could send it to rebuild that manufacturing base 538 00:35:57,133 --> 00:36:16,711 or to do any number of things, right? It's like that's the core 539 00:36:16,711 --> 00:36:34,783 input. It's the more dominant force, which is that we have pure 540 00:36:34,783 --> 00:36:48,337 power to create unlimited resources. It's the golden goose, 541 00:36:48,337 --> 00:36:49,843 right? ButI hear you that there are definitely general things 542 00:34:44,531 --> 00:35:23,944 that happen, as a function of being the reserve currency, that 543 00:35:23,944 --> 00:36:03,357 can undermine and have a momentum effect, like we talked about, 544 00:36:03,357 --> 00:36:39,187 that can undermine long-term kind of structural issues in the 545 00:36:39,187 --> 00:36:49,936 reserve currency status. Butto our earlier point, you mentioned 546 00:34:20,706 --> 00:34:46,431 that this might be (I want to go back to this point you made earlier), 547 00:34:46,431 --> 00:35:10,441 that this might be much more like the ‘40s. than the ‘60s or ‘70s. 548 00:35:10,441 --> 00:35:31,021 I actually have a thought bubble here that I'd like to kind 549 00:35:31,021 --> 00:35:49,886 of explore with you. So, a really interesting fact (I think 550 00:35:49,886 --> 00:36:08,751 you probably know this), in real terms, a 60/40 portfolio (so 551 00:36:08,751 --> 00:36:27,616 broadly assets, think about it that way) performed the same from 552 00:36:27,616 --> 00:36:49,911 1929 to 1949 as they did from 1962 to 1982 in real terms. Mostpeople 553 00:34:12,243 --> 00:34:35,266 will be like, that's crazy. I’ve got to go see a chart. It's 554 00:34:35,266 --> 00:34:54,747 true. One was a massively deflationary period. One was a massive 555 00:34:54,747 --> 00:35:15,999 inflationary period. And my view on why is because we did not 556 00:35:15,999 --> 00:35:39,022 yet live in a fiat world. The Federal Reserve was still very nascent, 557 00:35:39,022 --> 00:35:56,732 not dominant, right? Monetary policy dominance did not exist yet. 558 00:35:56,732 --> 00:36:16,213 And the introduction and the ability and the flexibility and maneuverability 559 00:36:16,213 --> 00:36:35,694 of the exorbitant privilege of the US dollar, which really comes 560 00:36:35,694 --> 00:36:49,862 from that fiat world, was introduced in 1971. Andso, I would 561 00:34:17,781 --> 00:34:45,021 argue… and you could argue it started a little bit before that, 562 00:34:45,021 --> 00:35:07,721 because even though things were officially kind of broken at 563 00:35:07,721 --> 00:35:34,961 that point in ‘71. It would have already started prior, but I 564 00:35:34,961 --> 00:35:57,661 think that's a huge difference. And just like if you 565 00:35:57,661 --> 00:36:22,631 take from the beginning of time, if kings could shave coins, 566 00:36:22,631 --> 00:36:45,331 they will. This idea of nominal illusion is important, politically 567 00:36:45,331 --> 00:36:49,871 important, right? Andjust like people feel like, oh, the ‘70s 568 00:34:34,153 --> 00:35:02,433 and ‘80s weren't nearly as painful as the Great Depression, 569 00:35:02,433 --> 00:35:39,197 or sorry, the ‘60s and ‘70s, right? The reality is, in some terms 570 00:35:39,197 --> 00:36:13,133 they were… Actually, in a lot of terms, asset-wise, they were the 571 00:36:13,133 --> 00:36:47,069 same. So, I don't know, I'd love to hear your thoughts about 572 00:36:47,069 --> 00:36:49,897 that. 573 00:36:52,181 --> 00:36:59,791 And because of that, I actually agree, if the exorbitant 574 00:36:59,791 --> 00:37:09,684 privilege of the US dollar is broken, I think this looks much more 575 00:37:09,684 --> 00:37:17,294 like the ‘30s and ‘40s, personally. I think the pressures 576 00:37:17,294 --> 00:37:26,426 were dissimilar in both (put it that way), and that things become 577 00:37:26,426 --> 00:37:31,753 much more deflationary structurally, things break without 578 00:37:31,753 --> 00:37:40,124 the stabilizing power of fiat and the exorbitant privilege of the 579 00:37:40,124 --> 00:37:49,256 US dollar in the dominant power in the world, which is obviously 580 00:37:49,256 --> 00:37:50,778 the US. So,I think these two different scenarios are actually 581 00:36:59,219 --> 00:37:07,821 much more… I mean, there are other differences. I'm playing with 582 00:37:07,821 --> 00:37:17,205 the toy model here, but I think they're much more defined by 583 00:37:17,205 --> 00:37:24,243 fiat exorbitant privilege versus not necessarily, in that case, 584 00:37:24,243 --> 00:37:33,627 than anything. And I think that feeds into some of the analysis 585 00:37:33,627 --> 00:37:43,793 that you're seeing on the back end - how things played out. I'd 586 00:37:43,793 --> 00:37:50,831 love to hear your thoughts on that top level. 587 00:37:50,841 --> 00:38:10,978 I do think a lot of things are different in the post-1970s environment. 588 00:38:10,978 --> 00:38:29,566 People will often say, they say before the dollar was the global 589 00:38:29,566 --> 00:38:46,605 reserve currency that the UK pound was the global reserve currency, 590 00:38:46,605 --> 00:39:03,644 and they'll go back from there. But I generally disagree with 591 00:39:03,644 --> 00:39:19,134 that view because before the dollar, really precious metals were 592 00:39:19,134 --> 00:39:36,173 the reserve currency, and all these other things were just like 593 00:39:36,173 --> 00:39:45,467 a layer on top of it. So,the UK system never looked like the US 594 00:38:06,960 --> 00:38:28,452 system does today. And going back from there to others, and to 595 00:38:28,452 --> 00:38:51,735 Spain, and to all that, none of that really looked the same as 596 00:38:51,735 --> 00:39:11,436 it looks today, where the government bond is itself the reserve 597 00:39:11,436 --> 00:39:32,928 asset rather than gold and proxies. So, that does put this in 598 00:39:32,928 --> 00:39:45,465 kind of a different environment than before. AndI think 599 00:37:55,035 --> 00:38:10,413 one thing I would highlight, that kind of goes along, because 600 00:38:10,413 --> 00:38:25,791 we might disagree a little bit about that trade deficit situation. 601 00:38:25,791 --> 00:38:41,169 One of the challenges is that these things are cumulative. And 602 00:38:41,169 --> 00:38:55,149 so, for example, as we run these structural trade deficits, 603 00:38:55,149 --> 00:39:13,323 when people kind of look at that on the surface, they say, well, 604 00:39:13,323 --> 00:39:27,303 it's a good thing because we're giving them devaluing dollars 605 00:39:27,303 --> 00:39:42,681 and we're getting goods and services. It seems like we're winning 606 00:39:42,681 --> 00:39:45,477 from that. Thechallenge is that there's a second step to that, 607 00:38:05,731 --> 00:38:20,621 which is those foreign entities that get the dollars, or 608 00:38:20,621 --> 00:38:37,000 those that they trade those dollars to, then reinvest those into 609 00:38:37,000 --> 00:38:56,357 US assets. So, they buy our equity, they buy our debt. In some 610 00:38:56,357 --> 00:39:12,736 cases, they buy our real estate, they buy our private equity, 611 00:39:12,736 --> 00:39:32,093 whatever the case may be. And so, they actually buy, for the most 612 00:39:32,093 --> 00:39:45,494 part, our appreciating assets from selling us depreciating assets. 613 00:37:50,841 --> 00:38:19,509 Andso, the cumulative effect over time is that the foreign sector 614 00:38:19,509 --> 00:38:45,788 owns a greater and greater percentage of total US assets. Which 615 00:38:45,788 --> 00:39:07,289 also means their voting influence is material, their ability 616 00:39:07,289 --> 00:39:33,568 to influence things grows. And if that just goes on indefinitely, 617 00:39:33,568 --> 00:39:45,513 that obviously has a very... 618 00:39:45,601 --> 00:39:47,041 Well, that breaks the exorbitant privilege… Sorry to interrupt 619 00:39:47,041 --> 00:39:47,201 you. 620 00:39:47,201 --> 00:40:05,258 Yeah, at some point, yeah. So, I think that's a challenge that the 621 00:40:05,258 --> 00:40:20,537 exorbitant privilege, it exists for a time and a place. And 622 00:40:20,537 --> 00:40:37,205 there are certainly actions that can be done to prolong it or 623 00:40:37,205 --> 00:40:53,873 shorten it, but that it's kind of on this gradually ticking clock. 624 00:39:47,201 --> 00:39:57,640 It'skind of like how, aging, right? Or like telomeres at the end 625 00:39:57,640 --> 00:40:08,079 of our DNA. I'm not an expert on that, but basically there's like 626 00:40:08,079 --> 00:40:16,912 a ticking clock that happens either way. And there's certain things 627 00:40:16,912 --> 00:40:26,548 we can do to like prematurely age or there's certain things we 628 00:40:26,548 --> 00:40:37,790 can do to like to layer aging. And I think that the current system 629 00:40:37,790 --> 00:40:49,032 we have in place is kind of like that where you can… yeah, that's 630 00:40:49,032 --> 00:40:53,850 how I view it at least. So,I do think that while we can learn 631 00:39:53,519 --> 00:40:01,241 from history, we are in many ways in a different environment. 632 00:40:01,241 --> 00:40:09,665 And one of the closest comparisons, I think, is the US looks 633 00:40:09,665 --> 00:40:19,493 more like the UK in the ‘40s than the US in the ‘40s, because 634 00:40:19,493 --> 00:40:28,619 in the ‘40s in the US we were a rising manufacturing power, whereas 635 00:40:28,619 --> 00:40:37,043 in the UK they had already kind of hollowed themselves out industrially, 636 00:40:37,043 --> 00:40:44,765 in a similar way that we've kind of gradually hollowed ourselves 637 00:40:44,765 --> 00:40:53,891 out here. And it's just one of the challenges that kind of comes... 638 00:40:53,971 --> 00:40:57,709 I love that aging metaphor. And let me just kind of put in my 639 00:40:57,709 --> 00:41:00,913 own words why. You know, entropy is the way of the world, 640 00:41:00,913 --> 00:41:04,117 right? And things will decay or break at some point without reinforcement 641 00:41:04,117 --> 00:41:07,054 or stabilization. Things that go faster and longer without a burning 642 00:41:07,054 --> 00:41:09,457 of the underbrush naturally create bigger and bigger structural 643 00:41:09,457 --> 00:41:12,127 unthought about problems, right? And we listed four or five 644 00:41:12,127 --> 00:41:15,064 of them, that eventually undo power going to foreign sources because 645 00:41:15,064 --> 00:41:16,933 the assets were running to them, right? 646 00:41:17,241 --> 00:41:54,525 Like we went through the trade deficits and the hollowing out of 647 00:41:54,525 --> 00:42:28,702 the infrastructure. We could go through all of them again. But 648 00:42:28,702 --> 00:43:05,986 I think, to your point, the more that you accelerate, and avoid 649 00:43:05,986 --> 00:43:43,270 the business cycle, and kind of push to more and more growth, 650 00:43:43,270 --> 00:44:11,233 you ultimately kind of live faster and live shorter. AndI think 651 00:41:22,359 --> 00:41:42,831 there's some element of that. I think we have the Federal Reserve 652 00:41:42,831 --> 00:42:03,303 and fiat, the introduction of that, was created to smooth the business 653 00:42:03,303 --> 00:42:23,775 cycle. Our founding fathers of the US would be turning in their 654 00:42:23,775 --> 00:42:40,835 grave if they knew that existed. Because the whole point 655 00:42:40,835 --> 00:43:01,307 was you need crisis to bring people together to pass and reinvigorate 656 00:43:01,307 --> 00:43:18,367 the system, pass amendments and all kinds of other structural 657 00:43:18,367 --> 00:43:37,133 reinforcements so the system does an entropy. The system is… take 658 00:43:37,133 --> 00:43:55,899 a look. It's in entropy, right? And the reason is because 659 00:43:55,899 --> 00:44:11,253 of the Fed and monetary policy creating a smooth… Howmuch reinvigoration 660 00:41:22,359 --> 00:41:44,537 to the structures of democracy did we do in capitalism in ‘08, ’09 661 00:41:44,537 --> 00:42:06,715 - zero, almost zero, and they lasted so short because the Fed swooped 662 00:42:06,715 --> 00:42:30,599 in and made it not a real problem. And so, I do think… anyway… 663 00:42:30,599 --> 00:42:56,189 Not to go on and on about it, but I do think that's an incredible 664 00:42:56,189 --> 00:43:14,955 metaphor and very relevant here, given where we stand. And I 665 00:43:14,955 --> 00:43:37,133 actually argue crisis is the best thing we can hope for at this 666 00:43:37,133 --> 00:43:55,899 point, because a short crisis might invigorate the system and make 667 00:43:55,899 --> 00:44:11,253 it go another 40, 80 years as it is. I'dlike to kind of jump to 668 00:41:28,840 --> 00:41:43,753 the next idea now, which is authoritarianism versus democracy, 669 00:41:43,753 --> 00:42:06,951 right? I think a lot of the smooth, if you look at 4th turnings 670 00:42:06,951 --> 00:42:23,521 and the smooth, like incredible, precise kind of in the 671 00:42:23,521 --> 00:42:45,062 US, cyclicality to it. A lot of that, I think, is tied because 672 00:42:45,062 --> 00:43:03,289 the political will, and this left versus right, and the fixing 673 00:43:03,289 --> 00:43:21,516 of the problems is translated to policy more smoothly because of 674 00:43:21,516 --> 00:43:38,086 the democratic kind of structure. And that was the whole 675 00:43:38,086 --> 00:43:59,627 idea to democracy. It's one of the benefits. There are lots of problems 676 00:43:59,627 --> 00:44:11,226 with it, but that's a huge benefit. Ifwe're moving to, potentially, 677 00:41:30,626 --> 00:41:54,719 a period of more authoritarianism and maybe just more 678 00:41:54,719 --> 00:42:18,812 broadly going to a more structural authoritarian regime here 679 00:42:18,812 --> 00:42:45,582 in the US, how does that change the potential cyclicality 680 00:42:45,582 --> 00:43:15,029 and the fact that, you know, maybe ‘nothing stops this trade’ 681 00:43:15,029 --> 00:43:44,476 is not the issue there. Maybe exorbitant privilege goes on longer 682 00:43:44,476 --> 00:44:11,261 or gets degraded. Let me know your thoughts about that. Ithinkit's 683 00:41:28,842 --> 00:42:07,512 an important part of the argument that people haven't thought 684 00:42:07,512 --> 00:42:50,049 much about because they assume that it couldn't happen, much like 685 00:42:50,049 --> 00:43:36,453 the exorbitant privilege of the US dollar. And I want to explore 686 00:43:36,453 --> 00:44:11,256 that, given the accelerations and issues we're seeing there. 687 00:44:13,251 --> 00:44:30,867 Sure, and I think, of course, the challenge is that even authoritarianism 688 00:44:30,867 --> 00:44:49,951 and democracy can have kind of a spectrum. And so, along with these 689 00:44:49,951 --> 00:45:04,631 cycles we talked about, they're obviously all the going back 690 00:45:04,631 --> 00:45:19,311 to like Greek philosophers, there's these cycles where you have 691 00:45:19,311 --> 00:45:36,927 democracy and then it kind of slowly poisons itself and then you 692 00:45:36,927 --> 00:45:58,947 have a rise of like a tyrant, and then you kind of go through these 693 00:45:58,947 --> 00:46:00,415 cycles. Buteven in the more mild sense, when you have this kind 694 00:44:23,967 --> 00:44:33,790 of like fraying situation and you get that rising populism, you're 695 00:44:33,790 --> 00:44:44,506 more likely to get, say, a landslide and you kind of consolidate 696 00:44:44,506 --> 00:44:54,329 power. And so, for example, FDR, you know, had unusual amounts 697 00:44:54,329 --> 00:45:05,045 of power. He had like 70% of Congress. You know, he basically 698 00:45:05,045 --> 00:45:13,975 had a supermajority. He could potentially stack the court. The 699 00:45:13,975 --> 00:45:24,691 press was under kind of fire. I mean, they banned gold ownership 700 00:45:24,691 --> 00:45:35,407 for 40 years, which is incredible in the land of the free. 701 00:45:35,407 --> 00:45:45,230 They could kind of just unilaterally do a lot of things. 702 00:45:45,230 --> 00:45:56,839 And once that kind of period was over, kind of that that power 703 00:45:56,839 --> 00:46:00,411 sort of decentralized again. Andin recent decades, we have had 704 00:44:18,529 --> 00:44:26,069 a strengthening executive branch, once again. And I do think 705 00:44:26,069 --> 00:44:35,871 that we've kind of entered a little bit more of a mild authoritarian 706 00:44:35,871 --> 00:44:44,919 aspect here, which is just more is happening via, say, the executive 707 00:44:44,919 --> 00:44:54,721 order. It actually is kind of like since the time of FDR, just 708 00:44:54,721 --> 00:45:02,261 the sheer rapidness of executive orders and kind of the 709 00:45:02,261 --> 00:45:11,309 challenge of the legal system and other things that kind of keep 710 00:45:11,309 --> 00:45:21,865 up with that. The fact that we can have just so many military operations 711 00:45:21,865 --> 00:45:28,651 without Congress declaring war, for example, which have massive 712 00:45:28,651 --> 00:45:39,207 effects. I think we are in that kind of more… It's not an accident 713 00:45:39,207 --> 00:45:48,255 that, as you kind of get that rising populism, those rising balances, 714 00:45:48,255 --> 00:45:57,303 you're more likely to get people to say, I don't care what 715 00:45:57,303 --> 00:46:00,319 if it's democracy not… 716 00:46:00,511 --> 00:46:01,151 Burn it down, right? 717 00:46:01,231 --> 00:46:19,821 Yeah, exactly. And of course, it depends on what way you go, that 718 00:46:19,821 --> 00:46:32,691 can obviously backfire tremendously in many cases. And I 719 00:46:32,691 --> 00:46:46,991 think another challenge, of course, is that the global structure, 720 00:46:46,991 --> 00:47:02,721 it's a very related but a slightly different thing than the 721 00:47:02,721 --> 00:47:12,731 authoritarian democracy spectrum, is the rule-of-law spectrum. 722 00:47:12,731 --> 00:47:27,031 Basically, in any given jurisdiction, how strong is the rule-of-law 723 00:47:27,031 --> 00:47:44,191 with say independent courts or just kind of like that the rules 724 00:47:44,191 --> 00:48:01,351 don't change suddenly. And as is often the case, a generally more 725 00:48:01,351 --> 00:48:08,501 democratic environment will have rule-of-law. Inan authoritarian 726 00:46:05,521 --> 00:46:18,391 environment, the rule-of-law is what the ruler wants. Whereas 727 00:46:18,391 --> 00:46:31,261 in that kind of more decentralized power, the rule-of-law 728 00:46:31,261 --> 00:46:48,421 is kind of the highest thing in the land. There are occasional 729 00:46:48,421 --> 00:47:01,291 kind of partial exceptions where you'll have something like 730 00:47:01,291 --> 00:47:11,301 Singapore, which has some authoritarian characteristics (again, 731 00:47:11,301 --> 00:47:28,461 because this is a spectrum), but they also are a very attractive 732 00:47:28,461 --> 00:47:44,191 place for capital because they generally do have pretty good rule-of-law. 733 00:47:44,191 --> 00:47:59,921 It's generally kind of among the closest you get to something 734 00:47:59,921 --> 00:48:08,501 like a benevolent type of authoritarianism. Andso, they're 735 00:46:04,732 --> 00:46:17,569 not like perfect correlates. But I think that what matters here 736 00:46:17,569 --> 00:46:32,740 is that one way or another, we do have a weakening of rule-of-law. 737 00:46:32,740 --> 00:46:50,245 In the US, I would say a big part of it, but also elsewhere (not 738 00:46:50,245 --> 00:47:00,748 everywhere equally). And that affects, one, where capital wants 739 00:47:00,748 --> 00:47:14,752 to be. It affects how quickly capital can form and how efficiently 740 00:47:14,752 --> 00:47:26,422 that capital gets allocated. And in those more authoritarian environments 741 00:47:26,422 --> 00:47:38,092 or in those more fiscally dominant environments, when the state 742 00:47:38,092 --> 00:47:50,929 is kind of running very big interest expense, when it's very 743 00:47:50,929 --> 00:48:02,599 indebted, it doesn't usually just let that happen passively. It 744 00:48:02,599 --> 00:48:08,434 starts kind of fighting back. Andlike in the FDR era, we entered 745 00:46:19,087 --> 00:46:43,639 industrial policy. And now that's a term that's coming up a 746 00:46:43,639 --> 00:47:05,959 lot again recently. It's like running industrial policy, kind of 747 00:47:05,959 --> 00:47:32,743 just being more open about some of these things, and kind of 748 00:47:32,743 --> 00:47:55,063 taking on more industrial and mercantilist policies. I think it's 749 00:47:55,063 --> 00:48:08,455 not an accident that these things… 750 00:48:08,581 --> 00:48:27,241 Yeah, I completely agree. I think another thing (to kind of shift 751 00:48:27,241 --> 00:48:44,346 gears here) that correlates, and I don't think it's a coincidence 752 00:48:44,346 --> 00:49:04,561 that people don't talk about very much, is the growth of AI. My 753 00:49:04,561 --> 00:49:21,666 view is that, you know, we've gone through this 40-year period, 754 00:49:21,666 --> 00:49:34,106 right, of monetary policy-driven, what I call, supply-side 755 00:49:34,106 --> 00:49:49,656 economics, right? Sending money to planet Palo Alto (I call 756 00:49:49,656 --> 00:50:05,206 it), which is a supply-side set of policies; borrowed money, 757 00:50:05,206 --> 00:50:23,866 QE, that goes to capital. And because of that, we've created massive 758 00:50:23,866 --> 00:50:36,306 technological development, right? That's part of what's driven 759 00:50:36,306 --> 00:50:39,416 the inequality. Thishappens during every one of these supply-side 760 00:48:24,461 --> 00:48:50,266 periods. I think it's been on steroids the last 40 years. And so, 761 00:48:50,266 --> 00:49:10,116 since the introduction of the wheel, everybody will think, this 762 00:49:10,116 --> 00:49:33,936 time is different. But new technology and the speed of its development, 763 00:49:33,936 --> 00:49:57,756 once you get to this point where policy starts turning to more 764 00:49:57,756 --> 00:50:19,591 fiscal policy and populism, is exactly at the moment that technology 765 00:50:19,591 --> 00:50:39,441 is almost at its kind of unimaginable, like exponential ascent. 766 00:48:08,581 --> 00:48:36,433 Butits actual ascent is a threat (as all technology is) to 767 00:48:36,433 --> 00:49:06,606 labor. and to populism, and to people. And again, that's not a coincidence 768 00:49:06,606 --> 00:49:32,137 either. So, I actually see AI as this incredible accelerant right 769 00:49:32,137 --> 00:49:59,989 at the end of this cycle, to the populism that's already there. 770 00:49:59,989 --> 00:50:23,199 And again, one of those momentum things, we talked about, 771 00:50:23,199 --> 00:50:39,446 that is likely to actually undo itself. Andpeople, everybody 772 00:48:13,666 --> 00:48:30,616 will think first order thinking that AI is incredibly deflationary. 773 00:48:30,616 --> 00:48:47,566 It's going to create this deflationary force that's going to 774 00:48:47,566 --> 00:49:06,211 wash over everything we do. And yes, technology since the beginning 775 00:49:06,211 --> 00:49:26,551 of time is deflationary, and the growth of it is immensely deflationary. 776 00:49:26,551 --> 00:49:48,586 I'm not arguing that, right? But I think what too few people think 777 00:49:48,586 --> 00:50:05,536 about is how inflationary the response is to that deflationary 778 00:50:05,536 --> 00:50:24,181 impulse exactly at this moment where populism is front and center. 779 00:50:24,181 --> 00:50:39,436 And I don't think that's a coincidence at all. Again,think 780 00:48:14,273 --> 00:48:54,117 about what led to the start of this inflation in 2020. I would argue 781 00:48:54,117 --> 00:49:25,423 COVID was probably, other than the supply issues, right, that were 782 00:49:25,423 --> 00:49:42,499 more short-lived, was structurally deflationary. Well, 783 00:49:42,499 --> 00:50:22,343 it led to massive inflation, it led to and was a catalyst to that 784 00:50:22,343 --> 00:50:39,419 populism which unleashed massive inflationary pressure. So,I'd 785 00:48:19,757 --> 00:49:26,813 love to hear your thoughts on it again. Sorry to dominate that, 786 00:49:26,813 --> 00:50:39,457 but I want to get that thought out there and see your thoughts. 787 00:50:39,471 --> 00:51:09,813 I agree with that. And one way I would kind of characterize that, 788 00:51:09,813 --> 00:51:37,821 the tech deflation and the response, one way to kind of look 789 00:51:37,821 --> 00:52:08,163 at that is that over the course of time, you've got a money 790 00:52:08,163 --> 00:52:31,503 supply, right? And different types of monies grow at different 791 00:52:31,503 --> 00:53:01,845 rates. I mean, back in the 1800s, there was like gold and silver 792 00:53:01,845 --> 00:53:34,521 and kind of the free banking system on top of it. In the modern 793 00:53:34,521 --> 00:54:00,195 era, we have central banking and the Federal Reserve system on 794 00:54:00,195 --> 00:54:07,197 top of that. Andso, we have pretty good data going back to something 795 00:51:05,728 --> 00:51:36,759 like the late 1800s for the US, the UK, and many other countries 796 00:51:36,759 --> 00:52:07,790 of what money supply was doing and what prices were doing. And over 797 00:52:07,790 --> 00:52:29,273 that, call it, 150-year history, there were some periods 798 00:52:29,273 --> 00:52:57,917 of time where the gap between money supply growth and price growth 799 00:52:57,917 --> 00:53:21,787 was bigger or smaller than others. And that's pretty correlated 800 00:53:21,787 --> 00:53:50,431 to just how much productivity is going on, which partially, a lot 801 00:53:50,431 --> 00:54:07,140 of it's technology and sometimes it's region. So,for example, 802 00:50:45,240 --> 00:51:12,162 in the late 1800s, you had a bigger than normal gap in the US 803 00:51:12,162 --> 00:51:31,392 between money supply growth and price growth because we were 804 00:51:31,392 --> 00:51:46,776 literally expanding across a partially empty continent. There's 805 00:51:46,776 --> 00:52:07,929 very little shortage of raw materials. They had the gold rush. 806 00:52:07,929 --> 00:52:25,236 They literally were finding new money. Population was coming 807 00:52:25,236 --> 00:52:52,158 from the rest of the world here. And so, you had all this kind 808 00:52:52,158 --> 00:53:13,311 of growth in the nominal money supply, but very little shortage 809 00:53:13,311 --> 00:53:38,310 of goods and services. Tons of labor was coming, tons of land was 810 00:53:38,310 --> 00:53:55,617 available, tons of literal resources like commodities. So, you 811 00:53:55,617 --> 00:54:07,155 get that bigger than normal gap. Whereas,if you look at the 812 00:50:52,059 --> 00:51:21,431 UK at the same time, the UK is already a developed country and you 813 00:51:21,431 --> 00:51:38,215 have a much tighter correlation between money supply 814 00:51:38,215 --> 00:52:01,293 and prices because there's no just massive source of just abundance. 815 00:52:01,293 --> 00:52:24,371 In a similar way, Japan, after World War II, hyper-productive, bigger 816 00:52:24,371 --> 00:52:49,547 than normal gap. Or Australia during the rise of China and their 817 00:52:49,547 --> 00:53:06,331 huge commodity demand, their nearby neighbor, Australia, that 818 00:53:06,331 --> 00:53:29,409 was happy to supply them all their commodities, they had this 819 00:53:29,409 --> 00:53:48,291 bigger gap between money supply growth and inflation because 820 00:53:48,291 --> 00:54:07,173 they basically, they have the China effect on them. Andin the 821 00:50:47,781 --> 00:51:26,561 US, the other kind of big period of time was the ‘80s and ‘90s 822 00:51:26,561 --> 00:51:59,801 and early 2000s, where we had a bigger than normal gap between 823 00:51:59,801 --> 00:52:35,811 money supply growth and price growth. And a lot of that was automation. 824 00:52:35,811 --> 00:52:52,431 So, we're automating manufacturing. We're globalizing. 825 00:52:52,431 --> 00:53:20,131 So, you know, we're hiring very inexpensive workers in China, 826 00:53:20,131 --> 00:53:47,831 and Bangladesh, and, back then Taiwan (now Taiwan's wealthy), you're 827 00:53:47,831 --> 00:54:07,221 hiring a lot of these foreign workers. So,you're keeping costs 828 00:50:47,535 --> 00:51:07,695 down. You're keeping wages down, speaking of labor. And you're 829 00:51:07,695 --> 00:51:29,871 able to grow money supply a lot without that translating into 830 00:51:29,871 --> 00:51:52,047 a lot of price growth. Whereas, to finish up, the inverse 831 00:51:52,047 --> 00:52:12,207 of that, when you have either slow productivity growth, you've 832 00:52:12,207 --> 00:52:30,351 run into tech ceilings, for example, temporary tech ceilings 833 00:52:30,351 --> 00:52:52,527 where you're just not getting much better very quickly, or you 834 00:52:52,527 --> 00:53:16,719 have war, or shortages of raw material where you just don't have 835 00:53:16,719 --> 00:53:40,911 that abundance sink. So, when you grow money supply, you get price 836 00:53:40,911 --> 00:54:01,071 growth that happens about as quickly because you're not getting 837 00:54:01,071 --> 00:54:07,119 those productivity offsets. Andso what AI represents, the better 838 00:51:01,171 --> 00:51:38,371 it is, the more it is a productivity boost and it suppresses 839 00:51:38,371 --> 00:52:18,671 kind of that white collar wage and it creates so much more abundance 840 00:52:18,671 --> 00:52:55,871 in kind of white-collar type of services in a similar way that 841 00:52:55,871 --> 00:53:26,871 the automation wave and the off-shoring wave did for blue-collar 842 00:53:26,871 --> 00:54:07,171 type of work in the ‘80s and ‘90s. And it's a similar effect… 843 00:54:07,221 --> 00:54:09,453 I think it's really interesting because it's one-to-one 844 00:54:09,453 --> 00:54:12,522 correlated too with the velocity of money. I mean, it's almost 845 00:54:12,522 --> 00:54:15,312 like, when you're talking about the productivity, it’s a magnifier 846 00:54:15,312 --> 00:54:18,660 to the velocity of money. Because if we send money to capital, 847 00:54:18,660 --> 00:54:21,450 that money doesn't trickle down really into the system, right? 848 00:54:21,450 --> 00:54:24,519 It does at first, very briefly. But then the velocity of 849 00:54:24,519 --> 00:54:27,030 that is almost zero, actually, some argue negative, deflationary, 850 00:54:27,030 --> 00:54:30,099 ultimately, over a longer time period. Whereas you send money to 851 00:54:30,099 --> 00:54:32,889 the bottom, it's one-to-one velocity of money, right? But where 852 00:54:32,889 --> 00:54:35,679 the money is going, also drives that productivity and that 853 00:54:35,679 --> 00:54:37,911 kind of magnifying force on top of it. 854 00:54:38,451 --> 00:54:51,431 The 2 are, one-to-one, just a magnifier, they are one-to-one correlated, 855 00:54:51,431 --> 00:55:06,771 and the driver is who's getting the money at the end of the 856 00:55:06,771 --> 00:55:19,751 day? And so, I completely agree with you. Again, there are 857 00:55:19,751 --> 00:55:30,371 other factors. I mean, I'm oversimplifying, obviously, but we're 858 00:55:30,371 --> 00:55:44,531 talking about how the broad structures tend to work and the pressures 859 00:55:44,531 --> 00:55:58,691 in the system. So, I think that's the thing that most people 860 00:55:58,691 --> 00:56:02,231 don't think about. Mostpeople think about AI and technology. It's 861 00:54:45,019 --> 00:54:53,229 deflationary. It's first order. Like, this is going to change 862 00:54:53,229 --> 00:55:04,723 the world. But the reason that this is likely not to be that first 863 00:55:04,723 --> 00:55:14,575 order that everybody thinks is because actually it's a kind of a 864 00:55:14,575 --> 00:55:23,606 closed system with the pressures that then lead to the undoing 865 00:55:23,606 --> 00:55:33,458 of those exact pressures at the end of the cyclicality that we're 866 00:55:33,458 --> 00:55:41,668 talking about. I think that's so critical. It's interesting to 867 00:55:41,668 --> 00:55:52,341 hear. We really agree on a lot of things, but like, really kind 868 00:55:52,341 --> 00:56:01,372 of come to it slightly different. I think that's it's really 869 00:56:01,372 --> 00:56:02,193 powerful. So,one of the last things I want to talk about here 870 00:54:50,859 --> 00:55:06,369 is one of the things you talk a lot about, right? A lot of your 871 00:55:06,369 --> 00:55:19,811 work is focused on crypto and its role kind of in this system. 872 00:55:19,811 --> 00:55:35,321 I'd love to kind of have you speak a little bit to a broader maybe 873 00:55:35,321 --> 00:55:47,729 audience about your views on crypto. And then maybe go back and 874 00:55:47,729 --> 00:55:59,103 forth a little bit because I have maybe some slightly differentiating 875 00:55:59,103 --> 00:56:02,205 views on that. 876 00:56:04,321 --> 00:56:30,145 Sure. So, I kind of have two very different opinions on crypto, 877 00:56:30,145 --> 00:56:55,969 depending on what part of it we're talking about. So, there are 878 00:56:55,969 --> 00:57:21,793 two areas of crypto. One, for me, is that I'm actually bearish 879 00:57:21,793 --> 00:57:45,465 on most things in crypto. So, I've been, for example, structurally 880 00:57:45,465 --> 00:58:04,833 bearish on altcoins. I mean, occasionally they're tradable, but 881 00:58:04,833 --> 00:58:26,353 structurally kind of bearish on their overall use case, their 882 00:58:26,353 --> 00:58:47,873 overall kind of structural growth. I've written a number of 883 00:58:47,873 --> 00:59:13,697 pieces on that. Whereas the two areas that I have been long-term 884 00:59:13,697 --> 00:59:33,065 constructive on are Bitcoin and stablecoins, for somewhat two 885 00:59:33,065 --> 00:59:37,369 different reasons. So,Bitcoin, basically I view it 886 00:56:19,189 --> 00:56:46,447 as, you know, the invention of a decentralized ledger. Which of 887 00:56:46,447 --> 00:57:11,227 course, when it comes into existence, the first question is, 888 00:57:11,227 --> 00:57:43,441 can it work over a sustained period of time? You know, have the 889 00:57:43,441 --> 00:58:13,177 kind of variables… Is this a system that's finally going to, you 890 00:58:13,177 --> 00:58:35,479 know, kind of function? Because there were some predecessors 891 00:58:35,479 --> 00:59:05,215 that, of course, didn't really last. And now that we're 17 years 892 00:59:05,215 --> 00:59:37,429 in, we kind of have at least some data on how it's working. Andthere 893 00:56:07,995 --> 00:56:28,202 is a network effect aspect there, kind of like ethernet, kind 894 00:56:28,202 --> 00:56:48,409 of like USB, kind of like simple mail transfer protocol, kind 895 00:56:48,409 --> 00:57:12,290 of like TCP/IP, where once you win a protocol war, you get this 896 00:57:12,290 --> 00:57:32,497 self-reinforcing effect. It's like you can come out with an ethernet 897 00:57:32,497 --> 00:57:52,704 that's like a little bit more efficient. but you're competing with 898 00:57:52,704 --> 00:58:12,911 the fact that there are 10 billion devices that already have 899 00:58:12,911 --> 00:58:31,281 Ethernet ports, for example, or simple transfer protocol, or even 900 00:58:31,281 --> 00:58:53,325 just a human language. It's hard to say, okay, we're all using 901 00:58:53,325 --> 00:59:11,695 English now, but here's this more efficient language, we're all 902 00:59:11,695 --> 00:59:31,902 going to shift to that. It's like, well, you're chipping into 903 00:59:31,902 --> 00:59:37,413 a network effect. Andso, Bitcoin kind of has that self-reinforcing 904 00:56:30,153 --> 00:57:05,672 network effect of security and liquidity, as well as being just 905 00:57:05,672 --> 00:57:50,878 a kind of a simple design to the base layer that kind of maximizes 906 00:57:50,878 --> 00:58:23,168 for decentralization. So, I view, generally, Bitcoin as a structural 907 00:58:23,168 --> 00:58:55,458 winner, not without risks and challenges and of course massive 908 00:58:55,458 --> 00:59:30,977 volatility, but it has been something I've been kind of multi-year 909 00:59:30,977 --> 00:59:37,435 bullish on. Andthen the other one is just stable coins, which is 910 00:56:25,628 --> 00:56:48,872 when you're running a ledger like this, you can have tokens that 911 00:56:48,872 --> 00:57:12,116 are proxies for things. And so, you can tokenize assets and tokenizing 912 00:57:12,116 --> 00:57:37,297 the dollar has of course been the popular one. Another way of putting 913 00:57:37,297 --> 00:57:58,604 it is that, for many decades, people have liked offshore dollar 914 00:57:58,604 --> 00:58:19,911 bank accounts. So, there are 180 currencies in the world. Most 915 00:58:19,911 --> 00:58:45,092 of them are not very good. Most of them lose value very quickly. 916 00:58:45,092 --> 00:59:06,399 Many people would like to store value in more stable areas. 917 00:59:06,399 --> 00:59:21,895 That's generally been accessible to the wealthy because 918 00:59:21,895 --> 00:59:37,391 of all the overhead costs and all this. Andstablecoins are kind 919 00:56:12,437 --> 00:56:34,756 of like, you use technology, you compress the overhead, you make 920 00:56:34,756 --> 00:56:55,046 an offshore bank account available to anyone with a smartphone. 921 00:56:55,046 --> 00:57:17,365 So, anyone can just hold dollar proxies. You have to trust 922 00:57:17,365 --> 00:57:43,742 those dollar proxies. You have to trust that the US is not going 923 00:57:43,742 --> 00:58:04,032 to sanction those dollar proxies. But let's say you're in 924 00:58:04,032 --> 00:58:28,380 Nigeria, and money supply is growing by 15% a year, and you'd 925 00:58:28,380 --> 00:58:44,612 rather hold dollar equivalents. You say, well, it's 926 00:58:44,612 --> 00:59:02,873 centralized, but it's not controlled by Nigeria. It's controlled 927 00:59:02,873 --> 00:59:27,221 by the US and these other entities. So, it breaks the borders 928 00:59:27,221 --> 00:59:37,366 of finance, to some degree. Andso, ever since the market cap 929 00:56:22,290 --> 00:56:50,527 of stablecoins was about US$30 billion, I've been bullish on it. 930 00:56:50,527 --> 00:57:21,331 I mean, now it's in the ballpark of US$300 billion. So, we've 931 00:57:21,331 --> 00:57:54,702 had like a 10X. And I still think it's got significant room to 932 00:57:54,702 --> 00:58:22,939 run. So those are the two areas that I've been constructive 933 00:58:22,939 --> 00:58:58,877 on, both as an investor and an analyst. And I work in venture, I'm 934 00:58:58,877 --> 00:59:34,815 on some boards for companies, so I also see in kind of the development 935 00:59:34,815 --> 00:59:37,382 ecosystem. 936 00:59:38,992 --> 01:00:08,099 I love the nuance. And I'm going to add some other layers of 937 01:00:08,099 --> 01:00:37,206 nuance here and I'd love to kind of discuss. So, I would agree 938 01:00:37,206 --> 01:00:57,357 100% that DeFi it's an incredible technology, allows for 939 01:00:57,357 --> 01:01:19,747 a much more efficient system writ large. Blockchain in general, 940 01:01:19,747 --> 01:01:42,137 I think, is a transformative technology, not just in finance, 941 01:01:42,137 --> 01:02:04,527 but across all. You know, it'll permeate all technology eventually. 942 01:02:04,527 --> 01:02:35,873 Like that ability to be truly secure (if that is true, by the way), 943 01:02:35,873 --> 01:03:02,741 we always have the other arguments that it may not, long term, 944 01:03:02,741 --> 01:03:27,370 be fully secure. But assuming that, and that they'll solve those 945 01:03:27,370 --> 01:03:29,609 problems. Andby the way, I am also bullish of Bitcoin and the core 946 01:00:03,770 --> 01:00:20,924 cryptocurrencies in some short to medium-term, meaning a couple 947 01:00:20,924 --> 01:00:41,890 years, maybe five years. And that is more, though, a function 948 01:00:41,890 --> 01:01:02,856 of this demand by this generation, as I mentioned, who has 949 01:01:02,856 --> 01:01:16,198 one experience, which is technological advancement, inequality, 950 01:01:16,198 --> 01:01:40,976 right, and a belief that a system should be more fair. I think 951 01:01:40,976 --> 01:02:03,848 that's what's led to its rise, and they're rising to political dominance 952 01:02:03,848 --> 01:02:26,720 over the next decade, you know, about when they peak. And I 953 01:02:26,720 --> 01:02:53,404 think so over the next 5 plus 10 years, I think that the demand, 954 01:02:53,404 --> 01:03:14,370 and growth, and political will to accept these things is strong 955 01:03:14,370 --> 01:03:29,618 enough to, in a sense, support it politically. Mybiggest concern, 956 00:59:52,561 --> 01:00:42,314 long-term, and I do think it structurally has major problems as 957 01:00:42,314 --> 01:01:32,067 a currency or sort of wealth, because it threatens power. Right? 958 01:01:32,067 --> 01:02:21,820 We just talked about the exorbitant privilege of the US dollar, 959 01:02:21,820 --> 01:03:20,619 and how critical that is to the US and its standing power, in 960 01:03:20,619 --> 01:03:29,665 my view. You,I think, have a little bit nuanced view. You don't 961 01:00:28,745 --> 01:01:27,544 think it's all good, all bad. I definitely think if the US loses 962 01:01:27,544 --> 01:02:21,820 exorbitant privilege of the US dollar, it loses its power, its greatest 963 01:02:21,820 --> 01:03:20,619 source of power in the world, is my strong opinion there. And Bitcoin 964 01:03:20,619 --> 01:03:29,665 threatens that. Andso, yes, we currently have a president who, 965 01:00:02,851 --> 01:00:34,663 for a number of reasons, which we won't get into, supports crypto, 966 01:00:34,663 --> 01:01:11,777 and it is politically popular to do so as well. But I do believe 967 01:01:11,777 --> 01:01:48,891 there is a core, and this is why China has had problems with it. 968 01:01:48,891 --> 01:02:18,052 And by the way, if China becomes more dominant, crypto will 969 01:02:18,052 --> 01:02:52,515 also take a back seat to the system, to be clear. They’ve already 970 01:02:52,515 --> 01:03:19,025 kind of signaled that. They want that exorbitant privilege. Everybody 971 01:03:19,025 --> 01:03:29,629 wants that exorbitant privilege. Kingsand queens want 972 00:59:45,020 --> 01:00:01,597 the ability to shave coins. They want the ability to control 973 01:00:01,597 --> 01:00:18,174 these financial outcomes; to tax the people around them. So, I 974 01:00:17,103 --> 01:00:34,751 think long-term, meaning 10 plus years, I think the power and 975 01:00:34,751 --> 01:00:51,328 the growth of crypto actually, Bitcoin, undoes itself as a currency. 976 01:00:51,328 --> 01:01:10,919 So, I think its use case as a currency ultimately will undo itself. 977 01:01:10,919 --> 01:01:25,989 I think in the short to medium-term, meaning five years, 978 01:01:25,989 --> 01:01:44,073 which is a pretty long term (that's all that matters now), I 979 01:01:44,073 --> 01:01:59,143 think supply and demand wise and given the regulatory current 980 01:01:59,143 --> 01:02:14,213 pathways, I think it's a structurally positive path for it. 981 01:02:14,213 --> 01:02:33,804 But I do think long-term it has a major problems as a long-term 982 01:02:33,804 --> 01:02:50,381 currency. Unless you believe a utopia can happen. Unless you believe 983 01:02:50,381 --> 01:03:06,958 that power, the law of the jungle ultimately won't hold true 984 01:03:06,958 --> 01:03:25,042 and that those with power won't want to use their power ultimately 985 01:03:25,042 --> 01:03:29,563 in the world. It,in a sense, castrates power in the places where 986 01:00:17,011 --> 01:01:08,899 it exists. And that's kind of the whole point. That was the whole 987 01:01:08,899 --> 01:01:51,898 idea. That's why it had political power to begin with. And 988 01:01:51,898 --> 01:02:38,806 I think that is, in my opinion, a wonderful ideal, but doesn't 989 01:02:38,806 --> 01:03:29,623 really live well in the real world. I'd love to hear your thoughts. 990 01:03:30,952 --> 01:03:55,696 I think it'll partially depend on how much they can convince the 991 01:03:55,696 --> 01:04:20,440 people of that narrative. I mean, as an example, the US banned 992 01:04:20,440 --> 01:04:45,184 gold, but then 40 years later, unbanned it. Right? And it's not 993 01:04:45,184 --> 01:05:05,804 because they stopped caring about power. It's just because over 994 01:05:05,804 --> 01:05:32,610 time it became more untenable to make it illegal to own a benign 995 01:05:32,610 --> 01:05:51,168 yellow metal. The narrative just wasn't really there compared 996 01:05:51,168 --> 01:05:59,416 to, say, the 1930s. Andso, to the extent that a government says… 997 01:03:44,443 --> 01:04:02,431 At the end of the day, Bitcoin is basically a decentralized Excel 998 01:04:02,431 --> 01:04:18,920 spreadsheet backed up by energy instead of just like a centralized 999 01:04:18,920 --> 01:04:36,908 thing. So, when a government kind of finds itself saying a decentralized 1000 01:04:36,908 --> 01:04:51,898 spreadsheet challenges us, it's really hard to sell that narrative 1001 01:04:51,898 --> 01:05:11,385 to the people. And one of the most bullish things is when China 1002 01:05:11,385 --> 01:05:27,874 will ban Bitcoin mining a dozen times, and there's still a 1003 01:05:27,874 --> 01:05:42,864 non-trivial amount of Bitcoin mining in China, for example. When 1004 01:05:42,864 --> 01:05:54,856 China has trouble fully banning something, it's actually 1005 01:05:54,856 --> 01:05:59,353 kind of resilient. Andthen there's the global element. So, when 1006 01:03:48,944 --> 01:04:18,181 China did their really big 2021 ban on mining, I would say it 1007 01:04:18,181 --> 01:04:40,671 actually was good for the network because you had something 1008 01:04:40,671 --> 01:05:09,908 like 60% 70% of known hash rate in China. And by banning it, 1009 01:05:09,908 --> 01:05:36,896 they didn't get all of it, but they disincentivized and pushed a 1010 01:05:36,896 --> 01:05:59,386 lot of it out. It actually decentralized the network further. 1011 01:03:30,952 --> 01:03:48,321 AndBitcoin, because it's kind of got this decentralized, kind of 1012 01:03:48,321 --> 01:03:57,795 self-rebuilding, self-correcting aspect to it, it 1013 01:03:57,795 --> 01:04:15,164 can kind of route around to wherever the biggest friction points 1014 01:04:15,164 --> 01:04:35,691 are. So, you'd have to have a very coordinated attack on it and 1015 01:04:35,691 --> 01:04:56,218 sustain it and get buy-in from the people so that it doesn't just 1016 01:04:56,218 --> 01:05:13,587 become this massive gray market thing. In a similar way that 1017 01:05:13,587 --> 01:05:34,114 many countries try to make it illegal to own dollars or add frictions 1018 01:05:34,114 --> 01:05:51,483 to their citizens from owning dollars, but dollars still get in 1019 01:05:51,483 --> 01:05:59,378 there and still get used. Andso, I think that kind of like 1020 01:03:46,576 --> 01:04:10,012 gold, kind of like dollars in emerging markets. It's going to go 1021 01:04:10,012 --> 01:04:33,448 through a test. I totally agree that many… I mean, in Europe 1022 01:04:33,448 --> 01:04:56,884 one of the phrases is we have to ban self-hosted assets, self-hosted 1023 01:04:56,884 --> 01:05:16,414 digital assets. It's basically saying that it's too dangerous for 1024 01:05:16,414 --> 01:05:35,944 you to memorize 12 words representing your seed phrase. That’s 1025 01:05:35,944 --> 01:05:59,380 too much power for our people to have. We don't want that. Andof 1026 01:03:43,864 --> 01:05:01,336 course, though, the narratives they will try to use is say, okay, 1027 01:05:01,336 --> 01:05:59,440 it's used by terrorists, so we have to make… 1028 01:05:59,442 --> 01:06:01,134 There's always a narrative to sell it. That's what I was going 1029 01:06:01,134 --> 01:06:01,557 to say. Yeah. 1030 01:06:02,532 --> 01:06:14,841 Yeah. If you can convince enough people. Right? So, if you 1031 01:06:14,841 --> 01:06:28,269 have an environment where a lot of people, they really want that 1032 01:06:28,269 --> 01:06:39,459 security over that freedom. They really do trust their leaders 1033 01:06:39,459 --> 01:06:52,887 to a significant degree. Then yeah, they can make it much harder 1034 01:06:52,887 --> 01:07:04,077 for Bitcoin enthusiasts or any sort of digital asset enthusiasts 1035 01:07:04,077 --> 01:07:19,743 to be in their jurisdiction. And if you do that, if the top five 1036 01:07:19,743 --> 01:07:32,052 countries manage that pretty persistently, it takes a lot of liquidity 1037 01:07:32,052 --> 01:07:38,766 and size out of the network. Butat that point, say five to 10 1038 01:06:09,228 --> 01:06:19,272 years from now, they'd be going up against a pretty big network, 1039 01:06:19,272 --> 01:06:30,153 most likely. I think the smart ones… And I think the most likely 1040 01:06:30,153 --> 01:06:38,523 outcome here is that they target more… Because the biggest 1041 01:06:38,523 --> 01:06:49,404 attack they have on it is they don't like privacy on digital assets 1042 01:06:49,404 --> 01:07:00,285 because that makes it harder for them to trace it and tax it. 1043 01:07:00,285 --> 01:07:08,655 They'll rarely say that. They'll focus on the terrorism aspect, 1044 01:07:08,655 --> 01:07:19,536 or they'll focus on that kind of thing when they talk about privacy. 1045 01:07:19,536 --> 01:07:31,254 But what they also really mean is they want to make sure they know 1046 01:07:31,254 --> 01:07:38,787 if someone owns it so they can tax it. Because,from their perspective, 1047 01:06:06,760 --> 01:06:15,216 if someone's a Bitcoin billionaire equivalent, when they 1048 01:06:15,216 --> 01:06:28,957 sell it or when they transfer it, as long as the government's kind 1049 01:06:28,957 --> 01:06:41,641 of getting its cut, I think that's where it's easier for them 1050 01:06:41,641 --> 01:06:56,439 to have the battleground than to try to make it so that you get 1051 01:06:56,439 --> 01:07:08,066 China-like draconian bans on it in an environment where we have 1052 01:07:08,066 --> 01:07:19,693 the Constitution, or we have countries with some degree of rule 1053 01:07:19,693 --> 01:07:31,320 of law. It's just really challenging to get kind of broad 1054 01:07:31,320 --> 01:07:38,719 buy-in. I think they're going to try. 1055 01:07:39,442 --> 01:07:42,298 Yeah, I think the reality is, look, prediction, for me, has always 1056 01:07:42,298 --> 01:07:44,916 been a function of incentives. Right? Show me the incentives, I'll 1057 01:07:44,916 --> 01:07:47,772 show you the outcome. And I'm just saying that the incentives of 1058 01:07:47,772 --> 01:07:50,866 those in power are both from a tax perspective, and a tracking perspective, 1059 01:07:50,866 --> 01:07:53,722 and a control perspective, as well as from the perspective of controlling 1060 01:07:53,722 --> 01:07:55,626 money supply. Again, exorbitant privilege allows you to 1061 01:07:55,626 --> 01:07:58,006 get better outcomes versus adversaries if you can control your 1062 01:07:58,006 --> 01:07:58,244 currency. 1063 01:08:00,212 --> 01:08:14,182 Countries lose that control. That's actually the whole point of 1064 01:08:14,182 --> 01:08:28,152 Bitcoin. That's why it's so popular, right? Those two reasons, 1065 01:08:28,152 --> 01:08:42,122 the anonymity and the flexibility and ability to move and 1066 01:08:42,122 --> 01:09:00,283 not be completely… As well as not being subject to the the fiat 1067 01:09:00,283 --> 01:09:04,474 kind of constraint. So,I think ultimately that, unfortunately, 1068 01:08:07,094 --> 01:08:23,152 it's a cynical view and it's a pragmatic view, but it's also a realistic 1069 01:08:23,152 --> 01:08:38,063 view in my mind. But we agree that there's still some time for 1070 01:08:38,063 --> 01:08:50,680 that. Hopefully we'll be talking in 5, 10 years, and we'll 1071 01:08:50,680 --> 01:09:04,444 get to kind of, Lyn, discuss where we are at that point. Buta 1072 01:08:04,228 --> 01:08:26,316 wonderful conversation. Thank you so much for coming on. I think 1073 01:08:26,316 --> 01:08:46,396 we covered some really interesting points, and I look forward 1074 01:08:46,396 --> 01:09:04,468 to chatting more and having more conversations over time. 1075 01:09:04,892 --> 01:09:05,172 (Music) 1076 01:09:08,732 --> 01:09:19,644 Thanks for listening to Top Traders Unplugged. If you feel you 1077 01:09:19,644 --> 01:09:29,564 learned something of value from today's episode, the best way 1078 01:09:29,564 --> 01:09:42,460 to stay updated is to go on over to your favorite podcast platform 1079 01:09:42,460 --> 01:09:56,348 and follow the show so that you'll be sure to get all the new 1080 01:09:56,348 --> 01:10:06,268 episodes as they're released. We have some amazing guests lined 1081 01:10:06,268 --> 01:10:19,164 up for you and to ensure our show continues to grow, please leave 1082 01:10:19,164 --> 01:10:31,068 us an honest rating and review. It only takes a minute and 1083 01:10:31,068 --> 01:10:44,956 it's the best way to show us you love the podcast. We'll see you 1084 01:10:44,956 --> 01:10:50,908 next time on Top Traders Unplugged. Butbefore we go, we just 1085 01:09:14,570 --> 01:09:26,246 need to remind you that this podcast expresses the view of Kynexis, 1086 01:09:26,246 --> 01:09:38,895 LLC, and the guests appearing on the podcast as of the date of 1087 01:09:38,895 --> 01:09:49,598 its recording, and such views are subject to change without notice. 1088 01:09:49,598 --> 01:10:01,274 Kynexis LLC and Top Traders Unplugged do not have any duty or 1089 01:10:01,274 --> 01:10:09,058 obligation to update the information contained herein. Furthermore, 1090 01:10:09,058 --> 01:10:17,815 Kynexis, LLC and Top Traders Unplugged make no representation 1091 01:10:17,815 --> 01:10:29,491 to its accuracy and it shall not be assumed that past investment 1092 01:10:29,491 --> 01:10:38,248 performance is an indication of future results. Moreover, wherever 1093 01:10:38,248 --> 01:10:48,951 there is a potential for profit, there is also the possibility 1094 01:10:48,951 --> 01:10:50,897 of loss. Thiscontent is made available for educational purposes 1095 01:09:54,172 --> 01:10:50,972 only and should not be used for any other purpose. Theinformation 1096 01:09:10,422 --> 01:09:19,717 contained in this podcast does not constitute and should not be 1097 01:09:19,717 --> 01:09:28,167 construed as investment advice or an offering of advisory services, 1098 01:09:28,167 --> 01:09:38,307 or an offer to sell or a solicitation to buy any securities 1099 01:09:38,307 --> 01:09:44,222 or related financial instruments in any jurisdiction. 1100 01:09:44,222 --> 01:09:50,137 Certain information contained herein concerning economic trends, 1101 01:09:50,137 --> 01:09:59,432 performance and other data is based on or derived from information 1102 01:09:59,432 --> 01:10:05,347 provided by independent third-party sources. Kynexis LLC 1103 01:10:05,347 --> 01:10:14,642 and Top Traders Unplugged may believe that the sources from which 1104 01:10:14,642 --> 01:10:23,092 such information are obtained are reliable. However, each of Kynexis 1105 01:10:23,092 --> 01:10:31,542 LLC and Top Traders Unplugged cannot guarantee the accuracy of 1106 01:10:31,542 --> 01:10:39,147 such information and has not independently verified the accuracy 1107 01:10:39,147 --> 01:10:46,752 or completeness of such information or the assumptions on 1108 01:10:46,752 --> 01:10:50,977 which such information is based. Thispodcast, including the 1109 01:09:20,416 --> 01:09:46,705 information contained herein, may not be reproduced, copied, republished 1110 01:09:46,705 --> 01:10:27,599 or posted in whole or in part in any form without the prior written 1111 01:10:27,599 --> 01:10:50,967 consent of Kynexis LLC and Top Traders Unplugged.