Hello, dear listener.
Trevor:Episode 437 of the Iron Fist and the Velvet Glove podcast, where we talk about
Trevor:news and politics and sex and religion.
Trevor:I'm Trevor.
Trevor:On the screen there, the slumlord of regional Queensland, Scott, how are you?
Trevor:Good thanks, Trevor.
Trevor:Yourself?
Trevor:I'm well.
Trevor:And Joe, the tech guy, how are you?
Joe:Good, Neil.
Trevor:Joe, you've got a task first up, is to explain what happened with that,
Trevor:uh, whole incident on the internet, but we'll get to that in a moment.
Trevor:If you're in the chat room, say hello, um, I've got the chat up
Trevor:on my screen so I can see that.
Trevor:Yes, well, of course we're going to talk about Biden pulling out of the race, and
Trevor:I've got various clips by various just crazy Americans, so, you know, Scott,
Trevor:there's not a lot happening in local.
Trevor:Australian politics is there.
Trevor:So I know we could be accused of just running a pretty USA centric podcast
Trevor:episode on this occasion, but there's just not much really happening.
Scott:Not a hell of a lot's happening, no.
Trevor:No, so it's not every day that a sitting president pulls out
Trevor:of the race, right at the death.
Trevor:So, um.
Trevor:You did see that meme I sent you?
Trevor:Which one was that, Joe?
Joe:Nation with increasingly limited access to birth control,
Joe:thanks man for pulling you out.
Trevor:Yeah, I did say yes.
Trevor:Thank you for that, Joe.
Trevor:Um, so, before we get into the, that sort of stuff, um, Joe,
Trevor:CloudStrike, what happened?
Trevor:CloudStrike.
Trevor:Yeah, what happened?
Joe:Uh, alright, so it's an advanced antivirus program.
Joe:It's a corporate antivirus program.
Joe:Amongst other things.
Joe:And, um, it phones home for updates and it also reports everything that's going
Joe:on on your computer so that, uh, corporate IT can have an idea of dodgy behavior,
Joe:um, going around the corporation.
Joe:Uh, because it's an antivirus program and it's looking for
Joe:abnormal behavior, it hooks very deeply into the operating system.
Trevor:It's got a lot of permissions.
Joe:It's got a lot of permissions.
Joe:It, it's deep, deep inside, and, and it's loaded immediately upon Boot up.
Scott:Mm-Hmm,
Scott:. Joe: So what happened was, uh, an update was pushed out by CrowdStrike.
Scott:To the Falcon Sensor, and it looks like it was a corrupt file, which when it loaded
Scott:up, um, caused the program to crash, but that took down the whole operating system,
Scott:uh, and because it's an initial, uh, loaded program, even though they rolled
Scott:back, once they figured out what was going on, they rolled back, uh, the software
Scott:update, or sorry, the file update, Um, the affected computers couldn't actually
Scott:be booted up long enough to contact the internet to download the new file.
Scott:And even worse, if you had an encrypted hard drive, you couldn't boot into
Scott:recovery mode to delete the dodgy file to get it back up and running.
Scott:So you have to then find your secret key.
Scott:For each individual computer, go around each individual computer in turn, boot
Scott:them into save mode with the recovery key and then roll back the software update.
Trevor:So some organizations with literally thousands of computers had to
Trevor:physically manually reboot and somebody stand there and catch it at a stage and
Trevor:get it, get that initial thing out of there so it could then boot up properly.
Joe:So the real big question is, yeah, um.
Joe:Most corporations have learned through painful experience that you don't roll out
Joe:software updates as soon as they come out.
Joe:You test them on a limited subset of computers.
Joe:Uh, and now obviously, antivirus, you want the latest updates as
Joe:soon as possible because bad people out there are doing bad things.
Joe:And, uh, People just, a crowd striker running on 60 percent of the Fortune
Joe:500, Fortune 1000 enterprises, so they've captured a large section
Joe:of the market, uh, and this was their way of doing business.
Scott:Mm.
Joe:And um, yeah, the question is why was this out of date update
Joe:pushed out on a Thursday night and why hadn't it been properly tested?
Joe:Mm.
Joe:Because the fact that it brought down so many computers so quickly means
Joe:that it hadn't been adequately tested.
Trevor:Interesting.
Trevor:Showing how vulnerable our society is Oh, absolutely.
Trevor:Is something as simple as that.
Trevor:Whereas things crashing down,
Joe:it only affected windows.
Joe:Um, there was a kind of.
Joe:Schadenfreude from people who run Linux and Macs, but really no
Joe:big crowing about it, um, because realistically, Could it happen to them?
Joe:Any operating system can be affected, and again, the same with the
Joe:virus, antivirus, um, providers.
Joe:Um, it's easy enough to say, oh, it had never happened to us, but, you know,
Joe:until you're absolutely sure that your processes are up to spec, it's And in the
Joe:security field, a lot of people have been going, yeah, people test for compliance
Joe:rather than testing for or planning for, um, what happens when it all goes wrong.
Trevor:I was listening to this podcast with this guy, he was an IT guy.
Trevor:It was a podcast about something completely different, a bit like this one,
Trevor:where the guy happens to be an IT guy.
Trevor:And he was saying that they try and encourage all of their staff
Trevor:to switch off their computers when they leave at the end of the day.
Trevor:And one of the ideas is that if something like this happens at midnight, then,
Trevor:um, you could, you don't have to fix it.
Trevor:Well, you sort of cut it off at the pass and in the, in the morning, quickly
Trevor:make sure people don't reboot their computers until the danger has passed.
Trevor:Is that good practice, Joe?
Trevor:Turn your computer off?
Joe:I mean, saving electricity for a start, um, I mean, hopefully
Joe:your IT is better than just relying on updates overnight.
Joe:It looks like Trevor's lost his audio again.
Joe:It does.
Scott:Yeah, I was wondering what happened with them.
Joe:Yeah, um.
Joe:There was a number of comments that were saying things like, well, of
Joe:course, you know, the best form of antivirus is for you not to be online.
Joe:So, uh, obviously they fulfilled that purpose.
Joe:You can't get a virus if you're not online to get it.
Scott:Very true.
Scott:Yeah.
Joe:Um, I, I think a lot of people, I mean, obviously, um, CrowdStrike
Joe:are going to get absolutely hammered by their customers.
Joe:Just for the cost of rebuilding all these computers or fixing all these computers.
Joe:Yeah, think of the overtime bill, uh, and the loss of business
Joe:for a lot of, um, customers.
Joe:Uh, we were lucky because we were going into Friday afternoon.
Joe:Um, I think the US who were just coming into Friday morning would
Joe:have had a full day of outage.
Joe:And therefore a much bigger impact for them.
Joe:No, we can't hear
Scott:you.
Joe:Hang on, you're on mute.
Trevor:Speaking of crazy tech things, I just don't know why this thing does
Trevor:it when in this restream podcast.
Trevor:Um, anyway, hopefully it's only the one time.
Trevor:There's another mystery, internet mystery.
Trevor:Right.
Trevor:Okay.
Trevor:Was that everything on the cloud strike, uh, that would be relevant?
Trevor:Um,
Joe:that was one other thing.
Joe:I'm just trying to, you'd mentioned something, but I can't
Joe:remember off the top of my head.
Trevor:Okay.
Trevor:Might come back to Ah, Scott.
Trevor:The whole, um, Joe Biden pulling out of the race, and I
Scott:think he had to do it.
Trevor:Yes.
Trevor:And we were sort of arguing before we came to Yeah, not arguing, but, um,
Trevor:I was saying, like, it just doesn't matter if Kamala Harris gets in.
Trevor:Um, she'll just continue what Joe Biden would have done.
Trevor:And Trump is going to continue a lot of the same things.
Trevor:Does it really make any difference?
Scott:It does because, you know, Trump is going to turn his back on
Scott:world trade and everything else.
Scott:Now, I know you've got some issues with that, but, um,
Scott:the worldwide Biden's already
Trevor:doing that.
Trevor:Kamala Harris will do that when it comes to China and chips.
Scott:With China and chips and everything else, they're doing that.
Scott:They've got their reasons for that.
Scott:I don't actually subscribe to their reasons, but they do
Scott:have their reasons for that.
Scott:So,
Trevor:there's no difference there, yeah?
Scott:No, okay, that's one thing that there's no difference there.
Scott:Yeah, there would be a hell of a difference for bodily
Scott:autonomy in the United States.
Scott:If you actually had a situation that Trump could get another term in, and if
Scott:he could actually do what Project 2025 actually calls for, then you'd end up
Scott:with a, you'd end up with a blanket ban on abortion across the whole country,
Scott:which would then result in people going south of the border or north of
Scott:the border to have a termination done.
Scott:Isn't that a stylish thing?
Scott:It's a state issue now, however, the Yanks have actually talked about, there
Scott:have been some lunatic, on the lunatic right, that have actually talked about
Scott:having a national ban on abortions.
Scott:They're actually, they're actually talking about having a law in the federal, in
Scott:the federal arena that would actually supersede anything the states would have.
Joe:If the Supreme Court could rule that a fetus was a living human being.
Joe:They would.
Joe:No, but, so if a case made it as far as the Supreme Court, and the Supreme Court
Joe:ruled that a fetus was a human being, then federal laws, state laws against murder.
Joe:Automatically kick in.
Scott:Exactly.
Trevor:Okay.
Trevor:I'll grant you, there may be some minor differences on.
Trevor:I don't
Scott:think they're minor differences.
Scott:I think they're major
Trevor:differences.
Trevor:Effectively they're minor because even if.
Scott:I wouldn't call that minor.
Scott:That is a, that is, that is something that you cannot
Scott:possibly call a minor difference.
Scott:It is a major difference.
Scott:These are bedroom issues.
Scott:This is cultural stuff.
Scott:It's a, it's a bedroom issue.
Scott:However, it is actually being done now.
Scott:Roe v.
Scott:Wade is now on the Ash Heap of history.
Scott:Yes.
Scott:And that, that is ridiculous because you've got six or seven states in the US
Scott:that have actually had their trigger laws have now kicked in and they've actually
Scott:gone to this ridiculous stage saying you can't abort if it's after five weeks.
Scott:And then, if you got that, Most women don't even know they're knocked up until
Scott:8 or 12 weeks or something like that.
Scott:So it's too late for them to get a legal abortion, so they're going to cross
Scott:the border over into the California.
Scott:You've had, you've had some of those right wing nutjob AGs in those southern states
Scott:actually speaking out loud, saying the quiet bit out loud, and they're saying
Scott:that they're going to prosecute women that leave the state to have a termination.
Scott:Here's what I'm
Trevor:saying.
Trevor:Here's what I'm saying.
Trevor:There's going to be no difference is say, Kamala Harris gets in.
Trevor:Roe v.
Trevor:Wade's there.
Trevor:There's going to be states, redneck states, that are maintaining
Trevor:their abortion um, bans.
Trevor:And, and she won't be able to do anything about it,
Scott:really.
Scott:Well, I agree that it's going to be pretty hard for her to do something
Scott:about it unless she's got, unless she's got congressional support.
Scott:So, for starters,
Trevor:she's going to have to get a majority of the Congress.
Scott:Yeah.
Trevor:And, then, pass a federal law.
Trevor:Which will then be challenged in courts that are dominated by
Trevor:Republican appointees who are not going to like the federal law and are
Trevor:going to be upholding states rights.
Trevor:AOC is
Joe:trying to impeach two of the Supreme Court justices.
Trevor:What's that, Joe?
Trevor:Sorry.
Trevor:AOC is trying
Joe:to impeach two of the Supreme Court justices.
Trevor:Yeah.
Joe:So if they go Or, or Big Ifs.
Joe:No, no, but yeah, yours were
Trevor:Big Ifs as well.
Trevor:So Alison in the chat room went, Trevor, exclamation mark, exclamation mark.
Trevor:And I don't blame her.
Trevor:I'm not saying, I'm not saying that bedroom issues aren't a big deal.
Trevor:I'm saying the difference that will effectively happen.
Trevor:isn't going to happen.
Scott:But the abortion rock show
Trevor:is going to continue exactly the same way it has and Kamala Harris
Trevor:won't be able to do anything about it.
Trevor:That's my point is that there's no effective difference is going
Trevor:to result from her election.
Trevor:Even though, yes, they want to fix that issue, but it just won't happen.
Joe:Well, but, but even if they, she can't make it any better, at least she
Joe:can stop it getting worse, which is the suspicion that will happen under Trump.
Trevor:Well, if every state becomes just more and more redneck,
Trevor:then what can she do about it?
Scott:Well, I think she could actually try, she could actually try and
Scott:have a federal law that would get.
Scott:And
Trevor:try and run
Scott:it through this Supreme Court.
Scott:Yeah, okay, you've got that, but you know, um, that Supreme Court is only a decree.
Scott:So I guarantee there'll be a difference.
Scott:If
Joe:the justices die, she gets to appoint more Supreme Court justices.
Scott:Well, she gets to nominate them.
Scott:Well, you know what, they won't let her.
Trevor:The Republicans won't, they will stall.
Trevor:Supreme Court appointment
Joe:for four years.
Joe:But hang on.
Joe:Don't forget the Supreme Court has ruled that she can, within her remit as
Joe:president, do anything that a president can do with no criminal charges.
Joe:She could assassinate some of them.
Joe:She could assassinate whoever she wants.
Joe:Like,
Trevor:okay.
Trevor:So there's going to be an argument over abortion, but it's going to be a, a,
Trevor:um, They're just an argument that's not going to make any effective change.
Trevor:That's, that's what I'm saying.
Trevor:What else is going to be different?
Trevor:We've also got
Scott:the other thing too about Supreme Court justice that waxes
Scott:lyrically and all that sort of stuff.
Scott:And he says, well, maybe we should, maybe we should revisit the gay marriage thing.
Trevor:Yes.
Scott:You know, and that is something that I honestly believe
Scott:they could actually take off if they got their opportunity to.
Trevor:And if it rolls off to the Supreme Court and the Supreme
Trevor:Court makes that decision again.
Trevor:Yeah.
Trevor:She might never do anything about it.
Scott:Well, she could actually, she could actually have some sort
Scott:of marriage law act in the, in the federal, federal government.
Trevor:Which will then roll through the courts, end up at the Supreme
Trevor:Court and be told, for some, whatever crazy reason, you can't do it.
Scott:Anyway, I just think that, um, there are people like
Scott:yourself that are making light of Trump possibly coming back.
Trevor:No, I'm not making light of it.
Scott:Well, I think you are, because you, you're actually quite
Scott:excited about AUKUS being knocked on the head, which I agree with.
Scott:But that's a big issue.
Scott:AUKUS is a big issue and it should be knocked on the head.
Scott:However, there are other things going along there that would, that would
Scott:make the American people suffer more under a Trump presidency than they
Scott:would under a Harris presidency.
Trevor:Like what?
Trevor:Like, I'm not excited by a Trump presidency.
Trevor:Good lord,
Scott:I think you are.
Trevor:Only from the point of view that I think it will most likely lead to Aukus
Trevor:being officially cancelled before it's eventually cancelled in 10 years time.
Trevor:That doesn't make me excited about or wanting Trump, but
Trevor:we're just kidding ourselves.
Trevor:This is so performative.
Trevor:Where the way that the U.
Trevor:S.
Trevor:conducts itself in foreign relations and military affairs and also just its own
Trevor:people, um, it's still going to continue.
Joe:They're
Trevor:singing from the same song sheet, these people.
Joe:Trump handed Afghanistan back to the Taliban, he was quite happy about that.
Trevor:Well hang on, wasn't it Biden who pulled out of Afghanistan?
Trevor:No.
Trevor:Didn't they criticise Biden for
Joe:doing it too quickly?
Scott:They did.
Scott:But, you know, Trump was the one that started it.
Scott:But Trump had signed
Joe:the agreement with the Taliban and Trump had said, we're pulling
Joe:these troops out by this date.
Joe:So Biden had to do that.
Joe:Right.
Trevor:So, what are you saying?
Joe:So what I'm saying is You know, uh, there is a difference
Joe:between them and, um, Well, they
Trevor:both, I mean, if Biden wanted to, he could have said, I've changed
Trevor:my mind, we're starting in Afghanistan.
Trevor:They both wanted to at that point.
Joe:I think by that time, um, if they changed their mind, the
Joe:infrastructure wasn't in place.
Joe:They'd pulled back enough of the infrastructure to make it
Joe:very difficult for them to stay.
Scott:There'll be one difference.
Scott:I think the Taliban was already moving across the country by
Scott:the time that In foreign policy,
Trevor:there will be a difference.
Trevor:Trump will pull out of assisting The Paris Accord.
Trevor:Will pull out of assisting Ukraine.
Trevor:Yes.
Trevor:So Ukraine will be forced to enter into a negotiated peace with Russia.
Joe:Another state like Belarus.
Joe:So,
Trevor:um, so that would be one difference in foreign policy,
Joe:but
Trevor:you know, the, what's going on in Gaza, the support of
Trevor:Israel and what's going on there.
Trevor:The expansion of NATO into ENC China if it can.
Joe:No, no, no.
Joe:He's not za that at all.
Joe:He doesn't want na, he doesn't know nato.
Scott:Actually, you might be
Joe:right
Scott:there.
Scott:Well, he's
Trevor:actually, yes, he might.
Trevor:He might actually tear that back.
Trevor:You're quite right.
Trevor:He
Scott:said to NATO members and unless they, unless they pay 2% of their GDPs
Scott:in the defense that he's, then I think he said, well, I would encourage the Russians
Scott:to do whatever the hell they wanted to.
Trevor:You know what we've just decided amongst us.
Trevor:He's going to probably cause a peace in the Ukraine and pull NATO back from China.
Trevor:Maybe I am starting to get excited.
Scott:It's not peace in the Ukraine at all.
Scott:It would be a bloody disaster.
Scott:More
Trevor:of a disaster than what's happening now?
Scott:If they were forced to negotiate with that bastard Putin, all he would
Scott:do is slice up the country bit by bit.
Scott:And he'd come, he'd go back in, he'd go across beyond his border, lick his
Scott:wounds, rebuild his troops, go back in for another bite, until the whole bloody
Scott:country was absorbed as part of Russia.
Trevor:More of a disaster than what's happening now.
Scott:Um, yeah.
Scott:In terms of lives being lost, no, there would be less lives being lost, however.
Scott:It's not, you can't just roll your eyes and say that's not a bad idea.
Scott:It's one of those things, it's something that you cannot just say.
Scott:Yeah,
Joe:if only the Allies during the 1940s had just rolled over when
Joe:Hitler wanted the whole of Europe.
Joe:You know, uh, and less lives would have been lost.
Joe:Do
Trevor:you reckon the surviving Ukrainians agree with me or you?
Joe:I would say that a lot of the surviving Ukrainians want Russia out.
Joe:They don't like life under Russian rule.
Joe:Do
Trevor:you reckon a fair number of them would agree with me?
Trevor:Possibly.
Scott:A small
Trevor:number would.
Scott:Yeah.
Trevor:What if it is,
Scott:what if it is a
Trevor:majority of the Ukrainians agree with me?
Trevor:If it's a
Scott:majority of Ukrainians agree with you, then that would be fine,
Scott:it would show, it would mark you out.
Scott:They're not
Trevor:allowed to vote.
Trevor:He's cancelled the election.
Trevor:It says he can't run one.
Scott:Because he's being invaded by a foreign country.
Scott:Yeah.
Scott:I know the Russians like It's because his democracy
Trevor:is under threat.
Trevor:I
Scott:mean, this is the thing, it might well be the
Trevor:case, if he had an election, everyone would boot him out
Trevor:because they've had enough of it.
Trevor:They want their remaining men.
Trevor:Uh, to live.
Scott:Potentially, and if that is the result of the Ukrainian
Scott:election, you have to stand by it.
Trevor:We won't know, you won't hold one.
Scott:Well, we'll have to wait and see.
Joe:I know people who definitely would rather be at war than be under Putin.
Trevor:I'm sure there would be people with the opposite view.
Trevor:We just have no idea of Of the percentages or whatever.
Trevor:Yeah,
Joe:I look in the UK.
Joe:Anyway, who cares
Trevor:what people think.
Trevor:Democracies are, get things wrong anyways.
Trevor:Exactly.
Scott:I cannot believe you're turning your back on democracy.
Scott:And you know,
Joe:um, President for life, Trump.
Joe:He's been eyeing up Mugabe's, uh, reign of power.
Joe:Has
Trevor:he been, has he been applauding Mugabe, has he?
Joe:No, he hasn't, but I'm sure he would.
Joe:If you'd ever heard of Mugabe, I'm sure he'd be, you know, he's a strong man.
Joe:Yeah,
Trevor:yeah.
Trevor:Do
Joe:you honestly think if Trump gets into power, he will
Joe:leave at the end of four years?
Trevor:Uh, uh, I have n no, no.
Trevor:I dunno what he would do.
Trevor:I have, I have no idea.
Trevor:I think wanna, probably not.
Trevor:I, I think he would, I think he would probably, um, try and install his son
Trevor:or daughter or something like that.
Trevor:So I think he'd try and.
Trevor:I
Joe:mean, the way he was cozying up to Kim, I think he would very much like the
Joe:USA to be his own private North Korea.
Scott:Yeah.
Scott:And that really wouldn't surprise me because, you know, North Korea has locked
Scott:itself off from the rest of the planet.
Trevor:Quite possible.
Trevor:Quite possible.
Scott:I just think he's an idiot.
Scott:That's all.
Scott:And I, I cannot believe that anyone would be actually applauding
Scott:him coming back to office.
Trevor:Yeah.
Trevor:Well, it looks like a majority of Americans are.
Scott:Well, that's very true, and I just don't understand
Joe:it.
Joe:No, I don't think it's going to be a majority of Americans.
Joe:It never has been
Trevor:a majority of Americans.
Trevor:And a majority of the, uh, what's it called?
Joe:The, uh, Electoral Council?
Joe:No.
Trevor:Yeah.
Trevor:The Electoral College.
Trevor:The Electoral College, yes.
Trevor:Looks like enough of them will.
Trevor:Which is close enough.
Trevor:It's huge numbers anyway.
Trevor:But, um, yeah, John Simmons is in the chat room.
Trevor:He's 30 minutes behind catching up.
Trevor:Right.
Scott:He's not going to catch up that conversation, is he?
Trevor:Wow.
Trevor:That was a good old fashioned argument there.
Trevor:Yeah.
Trevor:Let's have some more.
Trevor:Because
Scott:you're wrong.
Scott:What part am I wrong again?
Scott:You're wrong about the United States.
Scott:You're wrong about the United
Trevor:States.
Trevor:Was
Scott:I wrong?
Scott:You honestly believe that it doesn't really matter which side wins.
Joe:Were you here for the full 10 minute argument?
Trevor:Yeah, yeah, yeah, that's true.
Trevor:I think, for the most part, it doesn't matter.
Trevor:I think that the, the rock show will continue pretty much as it
Trevor:has, except for the Ukraine, and probably defunding of NATO, keeping
Trevor:them out of threatening China.
Trevor:But, um,
Scott:otherwise I don't think, I don't think The sorts
Trevor:of things that affect most people Other than some culture war issues,
Trevor:which are very big issues, I think Kamala
Joe:Harris will be the best.
Joe:Right-wing government go, um, president they've had since, um, Obama.
Joe:She, she will be the what, the best right-wing president
Joe:they'll have had since Obama.
Joe:Right.
Trevor:So you're agreeing with me in the sense that, that the economy
Trevor:and the running of the economy.
Trevor:Well,
Joe:the choice is right or far right.
Joe:There is no left wing in American politics.
Trevor:An extractive capitalism that favours the 1 percent run by Donald Trump,
Trevor:or the same thing run by Kamala Harris?
Joe:Well, a slightly less bad.
Joe:There is a difference.
Joe:It's not great.
Trevor:Yeah.
Trevor:You know, arguably, I was listening to something about, um, It was the
Trevor:donors pulling out of funding for the Democrats that was one of the driving
Trevor:forces for them getting onto Biden and saying, you've got to pull out.
Trevor:So.
Joe:Trump in, in the one paragraph going on about how great Elon Musk was and
Joe:how we ought to make life easy for Elon Musk and the next breath saying he gives
Joe:me 45 million a month, was it, for some stupid amount of money into his super PAC?
Joe:Right.
Joe:Literally in the same paragraph, he was saying, He's a great guy,
Joe:and by the way, he's a big donor.
Joe:And he's a big donor of mine.
Scott:Yeah, which is just crazy, because it was only 10 minutes earlier
Scott:that he was blasting electric vehicles.
Scott:Yeah,
Joe:yeah.
Joe:And you know, he was there to drain the swamp, remember?
Trevor:Yeah.
Trevor:Yeah.
Trevor:Well.
Trevor:Anyway, I like what, uh, Caitlin Johnston had to say, basically, that the rock
Trevor:show's gonna be run the same way.
Trevor:She put it this way, Every few years the U.
Trevor:S.
Trevor:Empire has this weird little festival where it pretends the government
Trevor:is changing hands and will now begin operating in a way that is
Trevor:meaningful, meaningfully different from the way it was operating before.
Trevor:And she says, The elections themselves are a performative ritual put on to
Trevor:help people feel good about themselves.
Trevor:Like a religious sacrament performed by a priest.
Trevor:You guys disagree, but that's good.
Trevor:Yeah.
Trevor:Ah, anyway, we can't be sure.
Trevor:I think
Scott:that Caitlin Johnson probably lives in California or somewhere like that.
Scott:She lives in Melbourne.
Scott:She lives in Melbourne.
Scott:Does she?
Scott:Okay.
Scott:Well, she, she doesn't have to worry about the sort of nonsense that is
Scott:being considered by the Supreme Court.
Scott:She doesn't have to worry about paying a fortune for her drugs or anything else.
Scott:You know, it's crazy that, um, the Yanks do not have, um,
Scott:insulin at an affordable price.
Scott:And what did
Trevor:Biden do about
Scott:that?
Scott:Well, he did actually lower the price of insulin.
Trevor:Right.
Trevor:Okay, so they do have insulin at a good price.
Scott:It's a better price.
Scott:It's not as cheap as it is in Australia, but it is a better price than what it was.
Scott:Right.
Scott:See, it's utterly crazy that, uh, anyway, we can talk about the American
Scott:healthcare system if you wanted to, but, um, it's one of those things.
Scott:I just don't understand why the Yanks have got this, look at
Scott:me, I pay for my own healthcare.
Scott:Well, big deal, you know, you're a fucking idiot.
Trevor:Yeah, well, attaching it to, as part of your work package, remuneration
Trevor:package is a disastrous idea, so, yeah.
Trevor:Anyway.
Trevor:Will Kamala Harris get the nod?
Trevor:Uh, there'll be a Democratic National Convention.
Trevor:Yeah, what's your theory on that one, Scott?
Scott:Uh, well, I mean, I think that, I think that she probably will
Scott:get the nod because Biden is, Biden's delegates and everything are there.
Scott:They're probably going to be more inclined to actually vote the way he wants them to.
Scott:So he wants them to vote for Kamala Harris.
Joe:Uh, my feeling is she's a black woman.
Joe:Is she gonna get the support of America?
Joe:I mean, you're gonna get the misogynistic racists outta the woodworks anyway.
Joe:Yeah, exactly.
Joe:They'll be everywhere.
Joe:Are you gonna get enough people who would support her or are they
Joe:gonna be enough of the fence?
Trevor:Voted.
Trevor:They voted for Obama.
Trevor:So the They did, but he was a man.
Trevor:Yes.
Trevor:So, yeah.
Scott:But he might have been a man and everything else, but he was
Scott:also a black man and he was a hell.
Scott:Well, he was.
Scott:No, he was.
Scott:He was
Joe:half a black man.
Scott:Well, he was half a black man.
Scott:She was, well, she was, um, half Indian, half, um, half Indian,
Scott:half, um, Caribbean, almost slave.
Trevor:Yeah.
Trevor:Grant Clark says she's deeply unpopular.
Scott:Oh, that's Landon Hardbottom.
Scott:I know she's deeply unpopular because she was the AG of, um, she was
Scott:the AG in California, wasn't she?
Scott:She
Joe:was a prosecutor in California.
Joe:she's very conservative.
Joe:Hmm.
Trevor:Same.
Trevor:Yeah.
Trevor:Okay.
Trevor:Um, what else have I got here?
Trevor:Um, so yeah, we'll find out, Democratic National Convention on the 19th of August.
Trevor:Uh, I read an article in the Courier Fail, which said one of the reasons why
Trevor:it took so long to get Biden to quit.
Trevor:Of course it seems it was his wife, and apparently she hates
Trevor:Kamala Harris, because as part of a debate they were having in 2019.
Trevor:Kamala Harris suggested Biden was a racist for opposing busing
Trevor:used to desegregate schools.
Trevor:So because Harris suggested Biden was a racist, um, Biden's wife, um,
Trevor:has hated Kamala Harris ever since.
Trevor:And one of the reasons why she resisted so long.
Trevor:and encouraged her husband to keep going was because it was probably
Trevor:likely that Harris would get the nod.
Trevor:She really didn't want that.
Trevor:So that is according to an article in the Courier Failed.
Trevor:So take that with a grain of salt.
Trevor:You know, this would have been, um, see, according to insiders,
Trevor:which could, it could mean anybody.
Trevor:Yeah.
Trevor:Right.
Trevor:Well, Trump announced a, um, a vice presidential running mate.
Trevor:And, uh, just a reminder that the reason he had to pick a new VP is because his
Trevor:own supporters tried to kill his last one.
Scott:Well, he
Trevor:was also
Joe:a theocrat.
Trevor:Yes.
Trevor:So, um, this time we've got, uh, this guy, J.
Trevor:D.
Trevor:Vance.
Trevor:Um, let's have a bit of a listen to him break things up with a bit of a clip here.
Vance:I think in this movement of national conservatism, what we need more
Vance:than inspiration, is we need wisdom.
Vance:And there is a wisdom in what Richard Nixon said approximately 40, 50 years ago.
Vance:He said, and I quote, the professors are the enemy.
Joe:Cultural revolution.
Trevor:What's that Joe?
Joe:Cultural revolution.
Joe:Yeah.
Trevor:Yeah.
Joe:Yeah, like the Chinese did, just take them out and kill them.
Trevor:Yeah, won't even bother re educating them.
Joe:Yeah.
Trevor:Yeah.
Trevor:Um, I did a quick Google search, uh, what did Nixon actually say?
Trevor:Apparently this comes from tapes that were recovered.
Trevor:Um, he said, um, never forget, he tells National Security Advisors
Trevor:Henry Kissinger and Alexander Haig in a conversation, December 14th, 1972.
Trevor:This is Nixon.
Trevor:Never forget, the press is the enemy.
Trevor:The press is the enemy.
Trevor:The establishment is the enemy.
Trevor:The professors are the enemy.
Trevor:The professors are the enemy.
Trevor:Write that on a blackboard a hundred times.
Trevor:That's what Nixon said.
Trevor:I don't know why Vance missed out on, um, the press and the establishment.
Trevor:You know, he remembered the professors, but um.
Trevor:Well, I just think he was trying to make the
Scott:point about the education system because, you know, he wants to
Scott:abolish the Department of Education.
Trevor:Yes.
Trevor:Uh, does he?
Joe:Yeah.
Joe:You know when your work is too educated, otherwise they get ideas.
Joe:Yeah,
Trevor:kind of that.
Trevor:Uh, the Republican convention was full of people kissing the ring.
Scott:Mmm.
Trevor:Most notably, Nikki Haley.
Trevor:Here's a little bit of her.
Haley:Donald Trump has my strong endorsement, period.
Clip:That was
Haley:Donald Trump has my strong endorsement, period.
Clip:That was Nikki Haley on the convention floor last night.
Clip:And here's a reminder of what she used to sound like just four short months ago.
Clip:Of course, many of the same politicians who now publicly
Clip:embrace Trump privately dread him.
Clip:They know what a disaster he's been and will continue to be for our party.
Clip:They're just too afraid to say it out loud.
Clip:Well, I'm not afraid to say the hard truths out loud.
Clip:I feel no need to kiss the ring.
Trevor:Well, she didn't then.
Trevor:Four months later, she felt the need to kiss the
Joe:ring.
Joe:Where's her sticking plaster?
Trevor:Yes, for those unaware, people at the Republican Convention were wearing a
Trevor:big wad of sticking, of sort of a bandage on their left ear, right ear, as support.
Trevor:for Donald Trump, who was wearing a very oversized bandage on his ear, so, uh
Trevor:The supporters were just wearing that.
Trevor:Did you not see that, Scott?
Scott:Yeah, I did see it.
Scott:That was ridiculous that he had such a huge bandage and everything over on his,
Scott:um, on his ear because the whole thing was, it was just a, it was just a little
Scott:nick, yes, with an AR 15, which yes, would have been fatal had it been quarter
Scott:of an inch over, but you know, it's.
Scott:Just ridiculous that he actually wore something like that.
Scott:And then you had this other situation that people were cutting up sanitary
Scott:napkins and that sort of stuff to tape them to their ears so that
Scott:they could look like Donald Trump.
Scott:It was a joke.
Joe:I did see the comment that, uh, it's not since Stormy Daniels
Joe:has a woman, uh, have women been so disappointed by two inches.
Joe:Yeah.
Trevor:Um, so yeah, shameless, uh, Nikki Haley, just completely shameless.
Trevor:Carrie Lake was the governor in Arizona who was disputing that the, um, election
Trevor:was valid and interesting interview where the interviewer really nails it.
Trevor:This is a great example of an interviewer knowing their stuff, keeping
Trevor:their cool and being able to just.
Trevor:Um, Not Let Go, with an interviewee who's just talking shit.
Trevor:So, this is a little bit of a longish one, but pay attention to the, the way
Trevor:that this particular journalist had such a, a really good grasp of the facts,
Trevor:and I thought conducted this as about as well as you possibly could, so, um.
Trevor:So, yeah, in the chat room, Mike Tyson, this is from Greg, Mike Tyson
Trevor:bit off a guy's ear off, and he didn't wear as big a bandage as Trump did.
Trevor:Alright, here's, uh, Carrie Lake, um, yeah, we'll play some of this.
Clip:I actually think you need your head examined.
Clip:Can you answer that?
Clip:I think you need your head examined.
Clip:Donald Trump has talked, Ms.
Clip:Trump's talked about the need for a new, uh, Tone in politics, a
Clip:civility in politics, a kind of unity.
Clip:What does that mean to you?
Clip:I actually think the tone has always been good.
Clip:I believe that what we're trying to push is a strong economy, secure borders.
Clip:These are policies everybody wants.
Clip:You don't think the tone in American politics got out of hand?
Clip:I think the tone It's really disturbing when the media is calling
Clip:a man like Donald Trump, Hitler.
Clip:They're comparing him to Hitler.
Clip:Like J.
Clip:D.
Clip:Vance.
Clip:Like the media is doing.
Clip:But J.
Clip:D.
Clip:Vance was probably, like many Americans, they listen to the media.
Clip:And for eight years, the media has been tearing President Trump apart.
Clip:A good man who everybody loved before he ran.
Clip:Imagine having a smear campaign going on about you for eight years.
Clip:Pretty soon, everyone wouldn't like you.
Clip:And so I applaud the fact that people like J.
Clip:D.
Clip:Vance and others, we've seen Amber Rose.
Clip:She did a speech.
Clip:People are coming over going, Whoa, the media was lying and I believed it.
Clip:And it's so irresponsible.
Clip:And you falsely claimed that Trump won in 2020.
Clip:You called for the imprisonment of those who accepted Trump's defeat, including
Clip:your own opponent in Arizona, Katie Hobbs.
Clip:Why did you do that?
Clip:Called for the imprisonment of what?
Clip:Of opponents like Katie Hobbs who accepted Trump's defeat.
Clip:Why did you falsely claim that Trump won in 2020?
Clip:Well, I'm not going to sit here and go through all of
Clip:the evidence of what happened.
Clip:Do you believe Joe Biden won 81 million votes?
Clip:Do you think he's more popular?
Clip:A guy who can't string two sentences together.
Clip:You believe he's more Obama?
Clip:I'm asking you, do you believe that he is the most popular president in history?
Clip:You have to have evidence.
Clip:Half you gotta have brain cells.
Clip:Okay, so you don't believe that Joe Biden won the election in 2020 The
Clip:election was run fraudulently and you refuse to concede in 2022 as well your
Clip:own contest Well, obviously obviously you're sitting across the pond and you
Clip:don't understand what's happened and I'm not gonna argue about it for defamation
Clip:Because this is how corrupt the system
Trevor:Goes on
Joe:Because Biden got more votes than Obama deed Therefore it's fraud.
Joe:It couldn't be that people were worried about Trump getting back in and therefore
Joe:turned out and droves to vote for Biden whether they liked him or not.
Scott:I think there was a hell of that because you did have a higher turnout.
Scott:Yeah, absolutely.
Scott:People had actually seen what the Trump presidency was like and
Scott:they didn't want to repeat it.
Trevor:Anyway, good work by the interviewer there and the rest of
Trevor:that interview she nails her but it's probably a little bit too long for this.
Trevor:Um, A little bit of, um, just crazy American stuff.
Trevor:Article from the New York Times, so it must be true.
Trevor:Um, in Las Vegas and surrounding communities, more than 97, sorry, 970, 000
Trevor:feet of electrical wiring, uh, that's the equivalent of 184 miles, have gone missing
Trevor:from streetlights over the past two years.
Trevor:The lights are going out across American citizens, they're going out across
Trevor:American cities, As a result of a brazen and opportunistic type of crime, thieves
Trevor:have been stripping copper wire out of thousands of streetlights and selling
Trevor:it to scrap metal recyclers for cash.
Trevor:Oh, there's a good sign of the decline of the entirety of the world.
Trevor:I
Joe:have actually heard that, I think in the UK.
Joe:Right.
Joe:That, um, it was, it was public parks, they'd been pulling up the cable to
Joe:steal, going to light poles in the parks.
Joe:Right.
Joe:Yeah.
Joe:But that's under 14 years of Conservative government, rather
Joe:than under two years of Joe Biden.
Joe:Ah, dear.
Joe:I think people are doing it tough all over the world.
Trevor:Yes, that is doing it tough.
Trevor:I haven't heard of that in Australia yet, of people pulling up public wiring in, in
Scott:They don't, they only steal if it hasn't actually been, if it hasn't
Scott:been, if it hasn't been used, it's it.
Scott:So they do have a problem with, um, uh, the cables and that sort of stuff
Scott:going missing from, uh, the yards and whatnot over there, and Energex.
Scott:So stuff will go missing from there.
Scott:And if you also, any of the.
Scott:One of the more security conscious builders and everything up here is
Scott:actually really worried about their job sites until they can get them secure
Scott:because the copper, the copper pipes and everything are going missing.
Scott:So people do actually knock that sort of stuff off.
Trevor:You know when they have the sort of, um, street dump thing
Trevor:where you put your rubbish out on the footpath to get collected?
Trevor:If you put out an appliance with an electric cord and people
Trevor:come along and snip the cord and leave the appliance behind?
Trevor:Yes, that happens.
Joe:Um, I remember talking to a telecoms guy who'd been in Africa
Joe:and was saying, you know, they had such a problem with people digging
Joe:up the phone lines for the copper.
Joe:When fibre came in, they went, great, we won't have this problem anymore.
Joe:And a couple of weeks later, the fibre optics had been dug
Joe:up and turned into a table lamp.
Trevor:Landon Hardbottom says, thanks for the side hustle idea, Fist.
Scott:I can't imagine Landon actually getting out and doing it himself.
Trevor:He'd probably pay minions to do it.
Trevor:Yeah.
Trevor:Liz Truss, former British PM, and now very pro Republican.
Trevor:He's been hanging around that convention and making speeches.
Joe:Nigel Farage has gone over there as well.
Trevor:Yes.
Trevor:He
Joe:was going to go and become Trump's aide or something, wasn't he?
Trevor:Yes.
Trevor:But that's Nigel Farage.
Trevor:We've got Liz Cruster.
Trevor:He's a former British Prime Minister.
Joe:Well, she's just as nutty.
Joe:Yeah,
Scott:I know.
Scott:But isn't Nigel Remember, she tanked
Joe:the British economy in 40 days.
Joe:Yeah.
Joe:Yeah.
Joe:Yeah.
Scott:Yeah.
Scott:Isn't Nigel Farage an MP in the British government?
Scott:He is now an MP.
Scott:Yeah, he's not in the British government, but anyway, he is
Scott:an MP in British Parliament.
Trevor:Yeah, anyway, this is what the UK is missing out on with
Trevor:Liz Truss not in power anymore.
Clip:I have to confess I've never been to Pennsylvania, but I do
Clip:have in my possession a liberty.
Clip:I have to confess I've never been to Pennsylvania, but I do
Clip:have in my possession a liberty.
Clip:A Liberty Bell Showerhead, which is, which is an exact replica of the
Clip:showerhead that President Reagan has in his ranch in California, which I
Clip:recently visited, and I will be proudly installing this showerhead as a symbol.
Clip:of liberty and democracy, and of course, Pennsylvania.
Clip:Because you all know, you all know why you're so important, which is this is a
Clip:crucial state in order for President Trump to be reinstalled in the White House.
Scott:Yep, she was in there.
Trevor:There you go, Landon, there's another idea.
Trevor:Start manufacturing Liberty Bell shower heads.
Trevor:Mate, you are going to clean up.
Trevor:If you can make those widely available.
Trevor:Oh, that's the former Prime Minister.
Trevor:It's just, it's so sad that this, there we go.
Trevor:That's, that's where we've reached.
Trevor:Ah, what else have I got here?
Trevor:Um, Yeah, I mean we could make fun of Americans and crazy people all
Trevor:day, which we will continue to do.
Trevor:Um, this one coming up is, what have I got here?
Trevor:It's um,
Trevor:Donald Jr's girlfriend, Kimberly Guilfoyle.
Trevor:She gets to make speeches at this convention.
Trevor:Good God.
Trevor:Um, hers was a cracker.
Trevor:Um, I'll play, I'll play some of hers.
Trevor:Um, here we go.
Clip:It is no wonder that the heroes who stormed the beaches of Normandy
Clip:and faced down communism sadly say they don't recognize our country anymore.
Clip:This is not
Trevor:There you go, um Stormed Normandy to face down communism.
Scott:Yeah, no.
Scott:Well, they did face down communists once they, once they got to the,
Scott:uh, river in the center of Germany and they linked hands with them.
Trevor:Yeah, well, that wasn't facing them down, was it?
Scott:No, it was facing them, that's all.
Scott:But, you know, Yes,
Trevor:yes.
Trevor:I think it just
Scott:had so much Botox in there, it's no longer working, it's fucked up her brain.
Joe:If you want, for a mere 72.
Joe:31 from Amazon, you can buy a Liberty Bell shower head.
Trevor:And they're available already.
Joe:Yeah.
Trevor:There you go.
Trevor:Of course they would be.
Joe:Well, that's where she got hers from, I think.
Trevor:Right.
Trevor:72.
Joe:Yeah.
Scott:US.
Trevor:Plus postage.
Scott:There we go.
Scott:Maybe Landon was ahead of the game after all.
Scott:Yeah.
Trevor:Yeah.
Trevor:What else have I got here?
Trevor:Um, an old clip of Joe Biden when he still had his marbles.
Trevor:Um, play this one.
Clip:Our conversation with Zaganoff was repeated with Leavitt.
Clip:They talked about they don't want this NATO expansion.
Clip:They know it's not in their security interest and on and on
Clip:and said, well, and if you do that, we may have to look to China.
Clip:And I couldn't help using the colloquial expression from my
Clip:state by saying to Zaganoff, lots of luck in your senior year.
Clip:Um, you know, uh, good luck.
Clip:And if that doesn't work, try Rand.
Clip:Um, and uh, I'm serious.
Clip:I said that to them and these were, uh, And, and, and they know, I
Clip:knew, they knew, everybody knows.
Clip:That that is not an option and everybody knows every one of those leaders
Clip:acknowledges and needs and they resent it But they need, they need to look West and
Clip:the question is where this is deserved.
Trevor:Well, actually they don't, turns out.
Trevor:So Russia has turned to Iran and China and Going quite well for
Trevor:them in terms of their economy.
Trevor:So let's just go just to show how the world has changed that it was just
Trevor:laughable um for Russia to consider teaming up with Iran and China as
Trevor:if that would help them in any way.
Trevor:And now, of course, they're completely able to bypass the U.
Trevor:S.
Trevor:system.
Trevor:And times have changed.
Trevor:He was more, um, had more vigor back in the day.
Trevor:He was younger.
Trevor:Yeah.
Trevor:Had more hair.
Trevor:Yeah.
Trevor:Um, what else have I got here?
Trevor:Shall we talk about, um, the Labor Party and religion?
Scott:Yeah, I think so.
Trevor:So, private schools, Scott.
Scott:Yeah, I know.
Trevor:In the five years to 2022, private schools in New
Trevor:South Wales spent an estimated 1.
Trevor:5 billion on capital projects.
Trevor:1.
Trevor:5 billion, private schools, New South Wales, five years.
Trevor:Building funds, which parents are encouraged to donate to, are given tax
Trevor:deductible status by the Commonwealth.
Trevor:New South Wales.
Trevor:The Australian Productivity Commission called for these building
Trevor:funds to be stripped of their tax deductible status in a report,
Trevor:and the response from the Albanese government was swift and unequivocal.
Trevor:Andrew Lee said the proposed changes are not being considered.
Trevor:So, there we go.
Trevor:A productivity commission says, here's an idea.
Trevor:Remove a religious privilege.
Trevor:Labor.
Trevor:The first thing it does in response to the report is say,
Trevor:uh, not that particular idea.
Trevor:That's not happening.
Joe:It's not necessarily religion.
Joe:It could be completely a religious private schools.
Joe:The point is that private schools are getting funded by the taxpayer
Joe:in terms of tax breaks, and none of that money is flowing down into the
Joe:public schools that are underfunded.
Trevor:Yeah.
Trevor:But either way.
Trevor:Yes, true.
Trevor:It doesn't have to be religious.
Trevor:No, that's true.
Trevor:So yes, disappointing federal Labor from that point of view.
Trevor:We were talking earlier about the difference between, you know,
Trevor:what does it matter whether the Republicans or the Democrats get in?
Trevor:Did it make much difference having Albanese and not having Scott
Trevor:Morrison, other than stage 3 tax cuts?
Trevor:Was there any other issue where we could have said things are different because
Trevor:of Albanese rather than Scott Morrison?
Scott:Not really.
Scott:You know, that's just a, um, that's symptomatic of our compulsory voting
Scott:system and everything over here.
Scott:It forces both parties to compete for the centre.
Scott:So you've got the centre right and the centre left.
Scott:It is a preferable system because you do not have to try and motivate
Scott:your base by throwing out red meat to the left wing or red meat to the
Scott:right wing to get them out to vote for you, which is a preferable system.
Scott:So I honestly believe that because there's not that much difference between the
Scott:right wing of the Labor Party and the left wing of the Liberal Party, then you've
Scott:got a position that's going to be fairly much the same regardless of who wins.
Scott:Now, clearly that was preferable what Albanese did with the Stage 3 tax cuts.
Scott:But that is probably the only real difference between the two parties.
Scott:And, you know, looking at the religion treatment and that sort of stuff, they're
Scott:pretty much on a line ball call with that.
Scott:Mm.
Scott:You know, that, that was ridiculous.
Scott:Like, you know, they, they could have actually, they could have actually said,
Scott:well, the um, uh, they could have actually said, well, you know, the, um, who was it?
Scott:Productivity Commission said you scrap it, didn't they?
Scott:Yeah.
Scott:Yeah, they could have actually used that as cover.
Scott:They could have said, well, the Productivity Commission sold us to remove
Scott:this, so that's why we're doing it.
Scott:But they didn't do that.
Scott:No.
Scott:God knows why.
Scott:Yeah.
Trevor:Well, Scott, it's just going to make it easier when you eventually are
Trevor:in that voting booth and you put down a vote for the, for um, the Greens.
Trevor:I'm not looking
Scott:forward to that.
Trevor:I'm
Scott:not looking forward to it at all.
Trevor:Just keep that sort of issue in mind as you put that little stroke
Trevor:of the pencil for the number one.
Trevor:Yeah, don't
Joe:forget, when you preference the greens, that tells Labor that you're
Joe:not happy with their centrist position and you want them further left.
Scott:Yeah,
Trevor:that'll feel good, Scott.
Scott:I'll have to wait and see.
Trevor:Locally?
Trevor:No, still federally.
Trevor:Um, Speaker of the House of Representatives, Milton Dick, is set
Trevor:to appear alongside controversial religious figures at an event
Trevor:promoting the influence of conservative Christianity throughout Australia.
Trevor:It's the RAW 24 Leaders Summit in Brisbane.
Trevor:And early September.
Trevor:Are they raw dogging too?
Trevor:What's that?
Joe:I said are they raw dogging too?
Trevor:Well.
Trevor:Raw 24.
Trevor:Um, Critics of the event, The Rationalist Society, called the
Trevor:summit an event promoting the Seven Mountains Mandate ideology.
Trevor:Now, there's going to be a bunch of hard cored Christians, and, um.
Trevor:Speaker of the House, Milton Dick, is gonna be there.
Trevor:They're just as captured by religion as the rest of them.
Trevor:Ah, finally, here's an interesting one.
Trevor:This might cause more arguments.
Trevor:The CFMEU, they're not so bad, are they?
Trevor:Okay, go on, give it to us.
Trevor:This was an article in Crikey.
Joe:Mm, I read it.
Trevor:Yeah, Guy Rundle.
Trevor:And what he's essentially saying is that, that the CFMEU is one of the few unions or
Trevor:perhaps the only union that has actually made sure that workers got their share
Trevor:of, of the money that's flying around.
Trevor:And that.
Joe:Unlike the shoppies.
Trevor:Unlike the shoppies and many other unions.
Trevor:And in this whole sort of debate about the worth or value of the CFMEU, there's
Trevor:very little discussion where people go, uh, you know, we've got guys who
Trevor:are actually earning good money and living good lifestyles as a result
Trevor:of, of the union, um, on their behalf.
Trevor:So that was sort of Guy Rundle's argument.
Trevor:And he, in his, in the article also, sort of hinting that a lot of the
Trevor:allegations against them are a beat up and what would you expect from
Trevor:someone like, um, the Fairfax Papers.
Trevor:Um, what else can we say that he says here?
Trevor:Um, let's see if I can find some interesting bits.
Trevor:Um, yeah, he's kind of saying that, that in Victoria there was a huge
Trevor:number of big infrastructure projects.
Trevor:Which big companies were more than willing to, uh, get involved in, even though the
Trevor:CFMEU would be controlling the worksites.
Trevor:Because they were getting big money from the government, and if it wasn't
Trevor:big enough to cover the expense, they could go back to the government.
Trevor:And the government would give them more money to cover the expense.
Trevor:So he's saying that there's all sorts of funny money flying around by the Victorian
Trevor:Labour Party on big ticket infrastructure and the CFMEU made sure that their
Trevor:members got a fair share of that fat pie that was there and that other unions.
Trevor:So, um, uh, what else did he say here?
Trevor:He's not saying that the leadership are innocent of misdoings, um, but he's also
Trevor:pointing out that At different times, um, the developers hired bikies to keep the
Trevor:CFMEU out of the, um, out of the picture.
Trevor:And, uh, uh, anyway, it was an argument providing a sort of a flip
Trevor:side to the narrative that's being put out there about the evil CFMEU.
Trevor:They're basically pointing out, yes, but, at the end of the day, one of
Trevor:the few unions that's actually got, undoubtedly, benefits for its members.
Trevor:What do you think of that idea, Scott?
Trevor:Well,
Scott:I wondered whether or not there was another side to it,
Scott:and I still haven't read Crikey.
Scott:But it's, um, it's one of those things.
Scott:Now, Sitka's obviously a vile human being, you know, he has been involved
Scott:in some fairly ghastly things towards women and that sort of stuff, so, you
Scott:know, I think that we could all pretty much understand that he's a prick, but
Scott:I honestly believe that, um, there's probably a fair bit of envy going on down
Scott:there, like the, um, other unions might be a bit envious of the CFMEU because they're
Scott:getting good deals for their workers.
Scott:You know, um, I hadn't read the, I haven't read the article, um, to go
Scott:through it and that sort of stuff.
Scott:So I will actually read it now.
Scott:It doesn't surprise me that someone has actually taken the other
Scott:side to it and had a look at it.
Scott:Because, you know, the other thing is it's always just coming out of the
Scott:right wing media saying that they're a bunch of bastards and everything
Scott:else, which you could actually think of, well, they can't all be bastards.
Scott:You know, now, sick is obviously a vile human being.
Scott:But, you know, that doesn't mean that he didn't have the best interest
Scott:of his union members at heart.
Scott:And I would actually, I'd actually prefer to be part of a more militant
Scott:union than the one I'm part of.
Scott:But anyway, it is what it is.
Trevor:Rundle says, does one really believe that wage theft in bars and
Trevor:restaurants would have been so open, so gluttonous, so cruel and indifferent,
Trevor:had hospitality and retail had a major union as militant as the CFMEU?
Scott:No,
Trevor:exactly.
Trevor:Good point.
Scott:It's one of those things, I just think that if we could go back to the way
Scott:it was in the 70s, when, you know, yes, it was a pain in the ass, because every
Scott:summer the trolley dolls wouldn't fly.
Scott:Every winter the power got turned off and the beer wasn't made by,
Scott:made by Christmas because the unions are actually closing it all down.
Scott:However, we also had a lot fairer distribution of money and that sort of
Scott:stuff between workers and the employers back then than what we have now.
Scott:And I honestly believe if you did have militancy out there, just enough to
Scott:scare the pants off the employers, So then they had to turn around and
Scott:actually start giving their, giving their workforce a reasonable living.
Scott:Then that would be enough to turn things around.
Scott:So if we had a few more CFMEUs out there Just to scare the pants
Scott:off the work, off the employers, that it would actually improve.
Scott:Anyway,
Trevor:Joe, were you about to say something?
Joe:You know, I was on an infrastructure build down in Victoria 10, I don't know,
Joe:15 years ago, and literally as I got on site, I was hit up when I was doing the
Joe:health and safety, uh, by the union rep going, so, uh, what's your hourly rate?
Joe:And you know, what, what penalties are you getting?
Joe:To make sure I was getting a fair deal if I was coming on his work site.
Joe:Uh, and you know, I'm all for that.
Joe:I I've seen how not all employers, but some employers can screw, uh,
Joe:workers over any way they can.
Joe:And I think we need strong unions to protect.
Joe:Yeah, the disparity between the haves and the have nots at the moment,
Joe:I think, is very much down to a, um, a less unionized workforce.
Scott:If we had a more unionized workforce, I don't think that
Scott:they would get away with it as much as they are lately.
Scott:But, it's one of those things, I don't know how you're going to reverse that,
Scott:because you've got a lot of people in the private sector, even, even friends
Scott:of mine that are miners, and that sort of stuff, they're saying they don't
Scott:want to, they don't want to sign up to the union, because they reckon
Scott:the union's only in it for the money.
Scott:Have you
Joe:seen the red unions?
Scott:Sorry?
Joe:Are you aware of the Red Unions?
Scott:No, who are they?
Joe:Uh, they are a bunch of new unions that have been set up allegedly by members
Joe:of the LNP or former members of the LNP.
Scott:Okay, gotcha.
Joe:Um, so they were very pro supporting the health workers that were anti vax.
Joe:So they're, yeah, pro liberty and pro this and pro that.
Scott:Yeah, it's a load of nonsense, yeah.
Trevor:Mm.
Trevor:So just at the end of this article, Guy Rundle says, Through all this,
Trevor:one comes neither to bury John Setka, nor to praise him, nor to romanticise
Trevor:any violence that may have arisen.
Trevor:The leadership is a collective, and who did what, good and bad,
Trevor:is as much a mystery to outsiders as is any merry band of brothers.
Trevor:But now is the time to show basic solidarity for a union whose main crime
Trevor:appears to be to have gained, quite possibly, the best deal for manual
Trevor:workers in the history of the world.
Trevor:This goes on, unless one retains the bourgeois illusion that one
Trevor:deserves to be paid more because of having done a degree in.
Trevor:Semiotics or Film Noir still being paid off.
Trevor:The success of the CFMEU should be taken by workers everywhere more as
Trevor:an affirmative lesson, not a warning.
Trevor:Forget the nonsense about lollipop sign holders etc etc.
Trevor:Construction remains hard, long and sometimes dangerous work.
Trevor:Good luck to anyone who got a share of the profits out of it by the CFMEU.
Trevor:Solidarity can be built from it but It is made, not given, by
Trevor:the hard labour of organising.
Trevor:So, anyway, I thought it was an interesting sort of flip on the
Trevor:narrative of just a bunch of bullies and you've got to remember, they've
Trevor:achieved more for their members than any other union in Australia and through
Trevor:collective solidarity, so good point, Guy Rundle, quite enjoy reading his stuff.
Trevor:And there we have it, gentlemen.
Trevor:That's a tick over the hour.
Trevor:That was fun.
Trevor:I really enjoyed the argument at the beginning.
Trevor:That was almost, uh, 12th man ish.
Trevor:It was.
Scott:I would have thought we probably had a bit of a different point
Scott:than what the 12th man would have.
Scott:Exactly.
Trevor:We haven't been meeting the spectator.
Trevor:Yeah, but the style of, you know, good old fashioned disagreement.
Trevor:I liked it.
Trevor:Exactly.
Trevor:Right, gentlemen, you're around next week.
Trevor:Yeah, I'm around.
Trevor:I'm around.
Trevor:Joe's around.
Trevor:Okay.
Trevor:We'll talk to you then.
Trevor:Bye for now.