Good morning, everybody.
Rob:Today we're joined by Marilia Shimon, a registered nutritional
Rob:therapist specializing in gut health, specifically IBS and SIBO.
Rob:Marilia has an interesting story, which we'll touch on shortly and hold
Rob:certifications from both the Institute of Functional Medicine and Monash University.
Rob:Marilia, thanks for being here.
Rob:Can you tell us a little more about yourself and how you
Rob:ended up in alternative GI care?
Marillia:Thank you for having me.
Marillia:Uh, so it was through my own health journey.
Marillia:I was a proud owner of an iron stomach.
Marillia:I could eat and drink whatever I wanted.
Marillia:And indigestion was not part of my vocabulary, uh, until I had
Marillia:an episode of food poisoning and everything changed literally overnight.
Marillia:And I've spent good seven years jumping from doctor to doctor.
Marillia:running all sorts of tests that all came back normal, which
Marillia:is unfortunately very common.
Marillia:And I just couldn't, couldn't really get to the root cause of my problem.
Marillia:I was told that my symptoms were due to IBS, but they kept getting
Marillia:progressively worse year after year.
Marillia:And I was just like, how is it possible that they keep
Marillia:getting worse if it's just IBS?
Marillia:And by saying just IBS, I'm not underestimating the, uh, the
Marillia:consequences of having IBS, you know, obviously it's, it's a burden.
Marillia:It's not a, an easy condition to navigate, but my symptoms really were
Marillia:drastically getting worse year after year.
Marillia:So I thought there is something else to it.
Marillia:And I realized that the food poisoning from the beginning, I understood
Marillia:the food poisoning was the initial trigger for my digestive symptoms,
Marillia:given I had none before that.
Marillia:And it was then through my own research trying to connect the pieces that I
Marillia:came across SIBO and how for poisoning a bacterial infection can lead to that,
Marillia:uh, and then everything made sense.
Rob:Of course.
Rob:And how did your, uh, symptoms present initially from a, from an idea standpoint?
Rob:Was a lot of sort of pain, distention, bloating, those sorts of things or?
Marillia:Yeah, so lots of distention, bloating.
Marillia:I went from being able to eat absolutely everything to not being
Marillia:able to eat pretty much anything.
Marillia:Whatever I ate was, was causing me problems.
Marillia:So like multiple food intolerances, I had acid reflux, indigestion,
Marillia:distention, all of those really terrible symptoms that unfortunately
Marillia:a lot of people are experiencing.
Rob:Yeah, I think that's just all too common again in society where we
Rob:are sort of just faced with not only large levels of, uh, of toxins in
Rob:the environment, but also just foods that trigger these, these gut issues.
Rob:I know today we're going to be touching heavily on SIBO.
Rob:That's our discussion point.
Rob:But before we carry on, can we just quickly sort of break down the
Rob:difference between IBS and SIBO?
Rob:I think a lot of people sort of see them as one thing, but obviously,
Rob:and to some extent they are, but there's quite a discrepancy.
Rob:There's, could you just sort of break down the difference between them?
Marillia:So they are both.
Marillia:Uh, similar conditions and they can coexist.
Marillia:Symptoms are very similar in the sense of like they have
Marillia:bloating, abdominal distention, they can have either constipation,
Marillia:diarrhea, or a combination of both.
Marillia:But the main symptom to keep in mind that defers them is abdominal pain.
Marillia:So in IBS, we must have abdominal pain in order to fit
Marillia:the criteria of IBS diagnosis.
Marillia:And in SIBO, we don't really have that.
Marillia:So I would say that's the main thing to keep an eye on.
Marillia:And, you know, with that abdominal pain comes visceral hypersensitivity, which
Marillia:is a hallmark symptom of IBS, which means you have an overly sensitive gut.
Marillia:So you feel, you know, what my clients usually say is like, you
Marillia:feel like that there's another person living inside your body.
Marillia:If that makes sense, that your gut has a life of its own, which
Marillia:it does, obviously, but you shouldn't be feeling that 24 seven.
Marillia:And in IBS with visceral hypersensitivity, you do have that.
Marillia:gut brain brain gut brain connection much more highlighted.
Rob:Okay.
Rob:And then, uh, by extension, what is SIBO?
Rob:How would you define SIBO?
Rob:And if you are sitting on somebody next to a plane and they asked you what you did.
Rob:But how would you define what SIBO is?
Marillia:So SIBO stands for small intestinal bacterial overgrowth, and it
Marillia:means exactly what the name suggests.
Marillia:There is an overgrowth of bacteria in the small intestine.
Marillia:And we shouldn't have that many bacteria in that part of the intestines because
Marillia:that's where we break down food and there is absorption of nutrients and all.
Marillia:So essentially, it's not an infection, it's just an overgrowth of bacteria
Marillia:in the wrong place in the gut.
Marillia:We should have large amounts of bacteria in the large intestine,
Marillia:but not in the small intestine.
Rob:Yeah, I think that's what people will often sometimes sort of refer to
Rob:when they are talking to about dysbiosis.
Rob:So would you almost say that SIBO is a form of dysbiosis then?
Marillia:Yeah, some, some, uh, experts do say that it's a form of dysbiosis,
Marillia:is a disorder of the whole GI ecosystem.
Marillia:So I think there are different ways of, you know, explaining it.
Marillia:But yeah, dysbiosis is definitely one of them.
Marillia:And
Rob:I know we'll begin on the treatment in a shortly and bear
Rob:with me, but, uh, to just give the listener a bit more of a background,
Rob:there are various types of SIBO.
Rob:Can you sort of elucidate the different types and how they
Rob:maybe present differently?
Marillia:Yeah, of course.
Marillia:So as of now, we know that there are three types, hydrogen dominant SIBO,
Marillia:methane dominant and hydrogen sulfide.
Marillia:So the hydrogen dominant one has.
Marillia:Uh, presents the symptoms like bloating and diarrhea, or sometimes it could
Marillia:be a bit of constipation as well.
Marillia:The methane, it's predominantly bloating and constipation.
Marillia:And the hydrogen sulfide is bloating and more severe diarrhea than the hydrogen.
Marillia:So they all have bloating in common, but then it's more like,
Marillia:is it on the constipation side?
Marillia:Is it on the mixed side or is it on the diarrhea side?
Marillia:Fair enough.
Rob:And then I suppose the, the golden question is, and it's obviously a
Rob:fairly long answer and it depends on the individual, but is there sort of
Rob:a common cause of these conditions, these sorts of SIBO types of conditions
Rob:in general, or are they all as unique as the individual in question?
Marillia:Yeah, so I think the most important thing to understand
Marillia:is that SIBO is not a root cause.
Marillia:It's a result of impaired gut motility.
Marillia:So as the gut slows down in the movement of the gut slows
Marillia:down, it can allow bacteria to overgrow in the small intestine.
Marillia:Why that happens?
Marillia:We know that the physiological underlying causes are dysfunction of
Marillia:the migrating motor complex, which are the cleaning waves, you know,
Marillia:or the housekeeping of the gut.
Marillia:And why that happens?
Marillia:There are different reasons.
Marillia:We know that the most common cause of MMC dysfunction is food poisoning.
Marillia:So got a stomach bug.
Marillia:Typical story.
Marillia:Like mine was able to eat everything.
Marillia:Got a stomach bug overnight.
Marillia:Things kind of changed and then after a few months got things
Marillia:got progressively worse and then that's because you developed SIBO.
Marillia:But there are other, other underlying causes as well.
Marillia:It can be structural issues, scarring from surgery, diabetes,
Marillia:or even it could be side effect of medications that slow down the gut.
Rob:Okay, and that being peristalsis that the MCC is affecting, is that correct?
Marillia:Yeah, it's it's the movement.
Marillia:It's actually affecting the MMC and like upper digestive, not just peristalsis.
Rob:Okay, so it's sort of going from a sort of a neurological
Rob:level all the way down to the gut.
Marillia:Yeah, that's
Rob:interesting that I did not know and I suppose this would be a perfect
Rob:segue to talk about how generally you start working with patients and
Rob:how you start treating individuals.
Rob:There are a lot of ways of doing this, but what is your sort of main modality
Rob:when you start talking about when you have somebody who obviously comes to you with.
Rob:These digestive complaints, and obviously they also present, uh, in other words,
Rob:brain fog, aching joints, a lot of very broad, non specific complaints.
Rob:How do you go about sort of breaking that down and then working with an
Rob:individual from, from the beginning?
Marillia:So the most important thing always is to rule out
Marillia:medical conditions, right?
Marillia:That's the first thing.
Marillia:So you want to see your GP or a specialist and rule out
Marillia:things like Crohn's, ulcerative colitis, celiac disease and all.
Marillia:So you've done all that.
Marillia:That's usually the top three things that they will investigate.
Marillia:That's all clear.
Marillia:Most likely they will tell you then it's IBS because you know, with IBS, we don't
Marillia:have a test, but we have that criteria that we follow tick some of the boxes.
Marillia:Okay.
Marillia:IBS off you go.
Marillia:But then we know that there is more to it, right?
Marillia:Now, we know that 30 to 80 percent of IBS can be SIBO.
Marillia:So then next step in what I usually do is, okay, have you tested for SIBO?
Marillia:So that's how we start.
Marillia:Most of the time it comes back positive, but obviously you need
Marillia:to rule out other things as well.
Marillia:So lactose intolerance is so common, but not tested and it could be that
Marillia:that's As simple as that, you know, you just have a lactose intolerance.
Marillia:Are you using, uh,
Rob:sorry to interrupt, but are you using breath testing predominantly
Rob:to test for, for CV or various, uh, different breath tests?
Marillia:Yes, predominantly breath test.
Marillia:If you look at the research, that's what's being used as well.
Marillia:So, you know, at the moment, I think that's the best tool we have.
Marillia:So as I was saying, like, you need to think about other things like food
Marillia:intolerances, histamine intolerance, lactose intolerance, fructose intolerance.
Marillia:You just obviously need to correlate the symptoms.
Marillia:But then if we have a positive, uh, SIBO breath test and they correlate with the
Marillia:symptoms that the client is experiencing, we then need to tackle that either
Marillia:liaising with, with their, uh, GP, you know, in, in order to get antibiotics,
Marillia:or then we go down antimicrobial route, uh, herbal antibiotics essentially.
Rob:Do you find, uh, slight tangent, do you find food
Rob:sensitivity testing to be accurate?
Rob:There, there are lots of different panels out there.
Rob:Uh, companies like Cyrex tend to test not only IGE, but IGA as well, I believe.
Rob:Whereas others just, and I think I've got this right, just test IGE.
Rob:So you sort of get these false positives with a lot of food testing services.
Rob:Uh, do you think they're effective or is ultimately just an elimination diet?
Rob:sort of the way to go in trying to determine what food triggers
Rob:you may or may not have.
Marillia:Well, so we know the gold standard is the elimination diet, right?
Marillia:So that's, that's what I do.
Marillia:And it is.
Marillia:It is boring, it requires commitment, patience, time, but there's no
Marillia:other way, so that's the way I go.
Rob:Fair enough.
Rob:And then speaking of elimination diets, do you have a preferred one?
Rob:Do you sort of just stick your plans purely on meat and tell them to get on
Rob:with it, or do you just, do you remove certain potentially triggering food
Rob:groups like FODMAPs or carbohydrates?
Rob:Uh, what's the, sort of the lowest common denominator for you there?
Marillia:Yeah.
Marillia:So I'm trained on the use of the low FODMAP diet with Monash University.
Marillia:And that's usually really what I do because there's so much scientific
Marillia:evidence to back up the low FODMAP diet.
Marillia:We know that up to 75 percent of individuals feel better
Marillia:on a low FODMAP diet, but it.
Marillia:It is a diet that requires guidance.
Marillia:You know, it's not as simple as, okay, here's a food of a list of foods you
Marillia:can eat and food that you cannot eat.
Marillia:It's really not like that.
Marillia:It's much more about portion control than yes or no.
Marillia:Uh, so that's usually the route I take is, is the low FODMAP diet.
Rob:Can you just explain what the low FODMAP diet is?
Rob:I can never get the acronym right, but, uh, it is, it's basically, and
Rob:I'll obviously get you explain it.
Rob:Removing certain, excuse me, fermentable foods from the diet.
Rob:Is that correct?
Marillia:Yeah, so you're removing essentially, not removing, you're lowering
Marillia:the intake of fermentable carbohydrates.
Marillia:FODMAP stands for fermentable oligosaccharides, desaccharides,
Marillia:monosaccharides, and polios.
Marillia:And exactly, these are fermentable carbohydrates in everyone's gut.
Marillia:But as we were talking earlier, the gut of IBS is overly sensitive.
Marillia:So that fermentation causes a lot of discomfort, you know, in the connection
Marillia:of the gut with the gut and the brain.
Marillia:Uh, so you're just lowering that intake to see if symptoms get better as well.
Marillia:And as I said, 75 percent of, of individuals do have
Marillia:a positive result with that.
Rob:That's interesting.
Rob:So it's not necessarily completely removing that food, but it's, it's about
Rob:sort of just lowering the quantity.
Rob:Is that correct?
Marillia:Exactly.
Marillia:Yeah.
Marillia:So as I said earlier, it's not about eat this, don't eat that.
Marillia:It's about how much you're eating of those specific fault maps in the meal.
Marillia:Uh, and if you're, you know, making sure you're not fault map stacking.
Marillia:So for example, if you're a person that snacks a lot and you're just
Marillia:grazing throughout the day and you're just adding those fault maps,
Marillia:you know, on top of each other.
Marillia:And then obviously towards the end of the day, you're super bloated, super
Marillia:distended because you didn't have.
Marillia:that break that your digestive system needs in order to, to break down food,
Marillia:the food that you ate previously.
Marillia:So it is really much about.
Marillia:Okay.
Rob:And then with an elimination diet, such as the FODMAP diet,
Rob:you often have to then obviously, well, not often, you have to then
Rob:reintroduce foods at a certain point.
Rob:Obviously people can't just live on these diets.
Rob:Um, well, I mean they can, but then we end up with more issues later.
Rob:Not
Marillia:ideal.
Marillia:Definitely
Rob:not.
Rob:How are you then reintroducing foods in a patient or in an individual
Rob:with these, with these issues?
Marillia:Yeah.
Marillia:So it's, it's very systematic.
Marillia:You, um, You choose one fault map at a time.
Marillia:So we have six fault maps.
Marillia:You choose one at a time and then you reintroduce them
Marillia:over a period of three days.
Marillia:You assess symptoms day one, you're fine, you move on to portion of day two.
Marillia:And then if you feel fine, you move on to portion of day three.
Marillia:If at day two, you already feel that your symptoms are, are already starting to come
Marillia:back, you then don't move on to day three and you'll find your threshold and your
Marillia:trigger of that, of, of those fault maps.
Marillia:So it's, it's time consuming, as I said earlier, you know, any
Marillia:elimination diet is, you need to reintroduce step by step and then
Marillia:find what works for you, what doesn't.
Marillia:But if you do all of them, you know, Within eight weeks, you can get it done.
Marillia:And I always say to my clients, if you do it, eight weeks are going to pass.
Marillia:If you don't do it, eight weeks are going to pass.
Marillia:So you might as well get over it.
Rob:Yeah, of course.
Rob:And when you're sort of reintroducing foods, do you find any sort of,
Rob:uh, concurrent issues with maybe things like oxalates, uh, obviously
Rob:things like a raspberries, a high in oxalates, I believe.
Rob:Sweet potatoes as well.
Rob:Do you ever find that when you're reintroducing Specific foods that you
Rob:will sort of hit a a plateau where maybe there is another a food insensitivity
Rob:That's oil not food insensitivity.
Rob:Excuse me a plant Antinutrient in this for us in this case is causing an issue
Marillia:I don't see that often or the one the one thing I see people react
Marillia:the most is Fructone which is one of the fault maps And that is found in things
Marillia:like garlic, onion, leeks, and that is by far, and the research also backs this
Marillia:up, the one that most people react to.
Marillia:So they may be able to reintroduce all the other FODMAPs fine, but perhaps
Marillia:the fructan is the one that they need to kind of manage in smaller portions.
Rob:Okay, fair enough.
Rob:And what do you think about this cheating using FODMAPs,
Rob:uh, FODMAP digesting enzymes?
Rob:Uh, do you think those have a place or are they just not
Rob:really dealing with the issue?
Marillia:I think they have a place.
Marillia:I mean, they, they are heavily backed by scientific evidence as well.
Marillia:The ones that are in the market, they have their own research.
Marillia:And I definitely think there is a place, you know, especially like if you're
Marillia:traveling, if you're eating out and you know, you, why not have that support?
Rob:Okay.
Rob:So I suppose you can have your cake and eat it.
Rob:Maybe it's not ideal all the time.
Marillia:Yeah.
Marillia:I mean, exactly.
Marillia:But you don't, you don't want to be used, be using those enzymes all
Marillia:the time because essentially you are breaking down that fiber that you want
Marillia:to be digested by gut bacteria, right?
Marillia:In the large intestine.
Marillia:So if you're using that fiber every, uh, that enzyme every day, you're
Marillia:not really getting the benefit of that, of that dietary fiber, but
Marillia:yes, you can have the cake and eat it too in certain occasions for sure.
Rob:And speaking of enzymes, uh, what do you think about the
Rob:use of things like betaine HCL?
Rob:Not necessarily only to support the digestive process, but
Rob:also to sort of offset the development of further dysbiosis.
Rob:Yeah.
Rob:In conditions such as candida, quite often there is an argument to be made
Rob:about increasing stomach acid by way of betaine HCL supplementation to sort
Rob:of just support that digestive process and to help keep that bacteria at bay.
Rob:Do you have any thoughts there?
Rob:Is it something you ever use at all, perhaps?
Marillia:Yeah.
Marillia:I do use with, uh, especially my CBO clients a lot.
Marillia:We know that we see, but there is, uh, an issue also with stomach acid
Marillia:production and stomach acid is like the first line of defense, right?
Marillia:It's everything that we're putting in our mouths is the connection of the
Marillia:external world with our internal world.
Marillia:So we need to have that.
Marillia:protective barrier and the stomach acid is there to kill any, you know, opportunistic
Marillia:bacteria, pathogens, so on and so forth.
Marillia:So we know that we see, but we also need to support that.
Marillia:So I do use that as part of my protocols.
Rob:Okay.
Rob:And one more question on digestion and I promise you we'll move on, but
Marillia:just regarding
Rob:histamine, obviously when There are, there's an imbalance in histamine levels.
Rob:You're going to have higher or lower levels of stomach acid.
Rob:I suppose one might say that by addressing the root cause of, uh,
Rob:the SIBO you, that you would then rectify the underlying histamine issue.
Rob:But do you ever sort of go after maybe a histamine or an MCAS issue
Rob:directly, uh, trying to sort of lower or increase histamine levels
Rob:to, to thereby support digestion?
Marillia:Yeah.
Marillia:And I see, I see his feminine tolerance a lot with, as a consequence of SIBO.
Marillia:So it's, as you said, it's about understanding the underlying cause,
Marillia:what it is that it's causing that.
Marillia:And then I think you kind of need to, you need to assess what is more urgent,
Marillia:let's say, you know, so if you have a client, if I have a client with.
Marillia:SIBO and histamine intolerance, and the histamine intolerance seems to be the
Marillia:thing that is driving, you know, the rashes, this, all the skin symptoms and
Marillia:potentially also diarrhea, then I go first on a low, put them on a low histamine
Marillia:diet to bring the symptoms, you know, calm it down, let's say, and then tackle
Marillia:SIBO, but it is a step by step process.
Rob:Perfect.
Rob:Understood.
Rob:Right.
Rob:One more question about diet.
Rob:And this is a selfish question because this was where my body of research
Rob:and my academic background was in.
Rob:But ketogenic diets, what do you think about them in terms of their ability
Rob:to sort of maybe help to modulate the symptoms of some of these issues?
Rob:Obviously you, you, with the ketogenic diet, you're not necessarily
Rob:getting rid of the FODMAPs.
Rob:But just by reducing the carbohydrate burden on the body, is that ever
Rob:an effective strategy or is it sort of really only sort of dealing
Rob:with one third of the problem?
Marillia:I don't really implement the ketogenic diet simply because the research
Marillia:shows that it's actually one of the most detrimental diets for the gut microbiome.
Marillia:So it's not, it's not something I work with.
Marillia:I do understand it has its place, you know, for different conditions,
Marillia:but it's not something that I, I, I practice in my clinic.
Rob:Okay, perfect.
Rob:Understood.
Rob:I'll stop preaching about that one then.
Rob:All right, so moving on to sorts of Treatment modalities beyond just diet.
Rob:What else are you using?
Rob:Things like probiotics, antimicrobials, et cetera.
Marillia:Yeah.
Marillia:Uh, so yes, antimicrobials, definitely using that.
Marillia:So I always discuss with my clients that they have two options, right?
Marillia:So if we're tackling seabird, they can go down the antibiotic route, refluxamine.
Marillia:but they can also go down the herbal supplementation.
Marillia:So I present both, we discuss and, you know, let them decide
Marillia:what it is that they want to do.
Marillia:Uh, if they want to, to go down the, the herbal route, then yes, uh, using
Marillia:a combination of of herbs, allicin, berberine, oregano oil, anine.
Marillia:Always have a biofilm disruptor there as well.
Marillia:Uh, and then, you know, combining those herbs for about four to six
Marillia:weeks and, and see how symptoms get better, retest, see where we are at,
Marillia:do we need more, what do we do next.
Rob:And just to clarify rifampicin, rifampicin is an antibiotic that
Rob:doesn't pass into the bloodstream.
Rob:It just works in the gastrointestinal tract.
Rob:Is that correct?
Marillia:Yes.
Marillia:So 99 percent of the absorption is in the, in the GI tract.
Marillia:So absolutely.
Rob:Okay.
Rob:Um, then regarding the antimicrobials again, how are
Rob:you recycling them specifically?
Rob:Do you find that people become tolerant to these compounds pretty quickly?
Rob:Uh, do you have some that you prefer?
Rob:Um, how do you, uh, treat somebody with, well, a patient
Rob:with, with these, uh, compounds?
Marillia:Yeah.
Marillia:So I find that most of them are well tolerated, apart from allicin.
Marillia:Allicin is definitely the one that most people react to.
Marillia:Uh, and then it's really about, okay, let's say there's an ideal.
Marillia:that you should be taking, but you know, if that doesn't work for you
Marillia:and it's actually giving you more symptoms than results, then you
Marillia:need to find whatever works for you.
Marillia:So if it is, you know, one capsule a day, or if it's the whole, the
Marillia:full dosage, but every other day.
Marillia:So we, we really need to work with each individual and
Marillia:find out what works for them.
Marillia:But I find that all the others are very well tolerated apart from the allicin.
Rob:And the issue with allicin being the prebiotic fiber
Rob:that then triggers the, uh,
Marillia:Yeah.
Marillia:Potentially.
Marillia:Yes.
Marillia:Oh, okay.
Marillia:And it is, it is quite difficult to digest as well.
Marillia:It can be a bit, it can be a bit heavy and also it depends, you know,
Marillia:so like if you take it before a meal or after a meal that all these
Marillia:things can also make a difference.
Rob:Is that sort of, and allicin obviously just for
Rob:people is garlic extract.
Rob:Is that correct?
Rob:It's the active ingredient in garlic.
Marillia:Yeah, and usually the fault map is removed, you know,
Marillia:through this process, but still some people cannot tolerate it.
Marillia:It could be for other reasons, different compounds.
Rob:Okay.
Rob:And use of probiotics, specifically things like Saccharomyces boulardii?
Marillia:Yeah, I do use it a lot.
Marillia:I think there's a lot of, you know, as we know, there's a lot of research
Marillia:for Trevor's diarrhea and, and the use of Saccharomyces boulardii.
Marillia:So that is one I use.
Marillia:I use quite often, especially when I am dealing with clients that have
Marillia:like post infectious IBS slash SIBO.
Rob:And other classes of probiotics, do you find that they are effective
Rob:or do you really just sort of rely on Saccharomyces specifically?
Marillia:Yeah, no, I do use some lactobacillus, Bifidobacteria.
Marillia:There is also some research, you know, the research with SIBO
Marillia:and probiotics is very limited.
Marillia:So there's a lot that we know about IBS, but not specifically SIBO.
Marillia:But it is also a matter of trial and error, you know, that there is the
Marillia:research and you know what to use.
Marillia:But again, does that work for that person?
Marillia:Great.
Marillia:It doesn't work.
Marillia:Okay, let's do something else.
Marillia:So I also use sport, sport based probiotics sometimes and I find
Marillia:that they are very well tolerated.
Rob:Okay, perfect.
Rob:And when looking at probiotics, like specifically the A lot has been made
Rob:in recent, well, definitely in recent years about working with specific species
Rob:beyond just the strain and, and just for the listeners, probiotics are broken
Rob:down at a high level into the genus, so sort of the, the overarching family,
Rob:then specific species, and then specific strains, I hope we got that right, and
Rob:for the most part, the literature that I've looked at seems to indicate that
Rob:the species is where it's Is what you need to focus on as a clinician, but
Rob:then you get a lot of companies that start marketing specific strains of
Rob:specific species, uh, as being the go to.
Rob:Do you find this to have any merit in your experience or is it again just
Rob:work at the species level enough?
Marillia:I think the strains, the strains level is, is becoming very predominant
Marillia:and we'll see more and more of like, you know That specific strain that has been
Marillia:researched for that specific thing or that one for that other thing So definitely
Marillia:it's uh, it's something I keep in mind.
Rob:Okay, so it is taking hold.
Rob:That's interesting Moving on, I'd love to get some feedback.
Rob:Well, I'd love to pick your brain about some specific questions.
Rob:Let's call them rapid fire questions.
Marillia:Yeah.
Rob:Olympic system retraining.
Rob:It's been made quite popular again in recent months or in recent, in recent
Rob:years, programs like the Gupta method.
Rob:I believe there are a few in the States and one in Australia called DN DNRS.
Rob:What do you think about limbic system retraining
Rob:specifically for, for gut issues?
Marillia:I think it's really important.
Marillia:We know just like the low FODMAP diet has a lot of scientific evidence.
Marillia:There's also scientific evidence for things like yoga, meditation,
Marillia:gut directed hypnotherapy.
Marillia:These are all things that can help with symptoms, with GI symptoms.
Marillia:So, you know, I mentioned before 75 percent of the individuals respond
Marillia:to a low FODMAP diet, but then there is the other part that doesn't.
Marillia:And then we start to consider, okay, so how about yoga, meditation, hypnotherapy,
Marillia:all of those things can also help.
Marillia:So they definitely have a place.
Marillia:And, you know, it's like every health condition, that's what I believe at
Marillia:least is a combination of factors, right?
Marillia:That will make a difference.
Marillia:It's not like one thing will solve the problem is, is the whole toolkit.
Rob:Okay.
Rob:Next one, vagal nerve stimulation.
Rob:A lot of these devices on the market, like the Sense8 and the Apollo, I suppose
Rob:they're working on a similar level to the limbic system retraining, but have
Rob:you ever utilized those in your practice?
Rob:What do you think of those?
Rob:Okay.
Marillia:So I do recommend to clients and I think the main reason
Marillia:is because nowadays most of us really struggle with doing nothing, you
Marillia:know, telling someone to sit down for 10 minutes and literally do nothing,
Marillia:not watch TV, not scroll the phone.
Marillia:It's, it's a challenge.
Marillia:So I find that these devices kind of make them feel that they're
Marillia:doing something while they're doing nothing, if that makes sense.
Marillia:So that, that's mostly when I, I recommend, you know, if I feel that
Marillia:the client does have some difficulty in just like relaxing and taking
Marillia:10 minutes to switch off, I'm like, okay, how about you get this device?
Marillia:Because at least you, you feel that, you know, you're doing something while
Marillia:you're relaxing at the same time.
Marillia:But other than that, I just tell them to gargle twice a day, like strong.
Marillia:Vibrations.
Rob:Could you just discuss what the vagus nerve is and why potentially
Rob:it could be an issue in people with vagus nerve dysregulation could be
Rob:an issue in people with IBS and SIBO?
Marillia:Yeah.
Marillia:So we know that the vagus nerve is what connects the gut and the brain, right?
Marillia:And it's this two way communication pathway.
Marillia:And it is.
Marillia:This connection is so intense where the brain sends messages to the gut,
Marillia:the gut sends messages to the brain.
Marillia:Actually the gut sends more messages to the brain than the brain to the gut.
Marillia:And there can be a dysfunction, like chronic stress can, can create a
Marillia:dysfunction in this communication and then lead to digestive symptoms.
Marillia:But also this biosis in the gut can interrupt this communication and create
Marillia:health problems, mental health problems.
Marillia:So things like depression and anxiety, we know that, you know, there is
Marillia:a big correlation between a gut dysbiosis and depressive symptoms.
Marillia:So that's where this nerve it's engages in this to in this way
Marillia:in the communication between them
Rob:Yeah And the way I understand it when you sort of activate the the
Rob:vagus nerve you are activating the the parasympathetic Sympathetic branch of the
Rob:nervous system and by doing so you start to lower levels of stress hormones like
Rob:cortisol adrenaline all of these Chemicals in the body that drive stress that then
Rob:drive the production of molecules such as cytokines that just increase inflammation.
Rob:And then you get this sort of, you fall into this vicious
Rob:cycle where the body's inflamed.
Rob:It's, which then triggers the vagus nerve, which then triggers
Rob:release of these chemicals.
Rob:And it's very hard to get out of.
Rob:And again, uh, from my view of the literature, there does seem to be some.
Rob:It is to show that by stimulating the vagus nerve, you can help get it out of
Rob:this loop and then allow the body to heal.
Rob:Yeah, at a high level, that seems to be how these devices work.
Rob:And yeah, again, there does seem to be a fair amount of clinical efficacy for them.
Marillia:Yeah.
Marillia:And as you said, it's about activating the parasympathetic nervous system, right?
Marillia:And we know that that's the rest and digest and you need to be in
Marillia:the rest and digest mode in order to be able to digest, break down
Marillia:food properly and avoid bloating, distention and digestive symptoms.
Marillia:So it definitely, I'm sure the devices have a place, you know,
Marillia:and however, whatever works for the person, you know, and if the device
Marillia:is the thing that works, why not?
Rob:Of course.
Rob:Next one.
Rob:This one is probably, yeah, it's going to raise some eyebrows.
Rob:Uh, the carnivore diets.
Rob:Uh, do you like it?
Rob:Do you not like it?
Marillia:I mean, for me, it's a hard no.
Marillia:And I, I get that, you know, I, I started eating a carnivore diet
Marillia:and all my GI symptoms disappeared.
Marillia:Yeah.
Marillia:Obviously you removed the triggers, right?
Marillia:It's as simple as that, but you didn't really, yeah, you,
Marillia:you didn't really address the underlying cause of the problem.
Marillia:So if you bring the foods back, you're actually potentially going
Marillia:to feel even worse because you depleted your gut from fiber.
Marillia:The diversity of gut bacteria is definitely lower, and then you're
Marillia:going to be able to tolerate even less foods than, than before.
Marillia:So it is a hard no for me.
Rob:Fair enough.
Rob:Another contentious topic.
Rob:Prebiotics.
Rob:There seems to be this divisive line in the functional GI
Rob:community about prebiotics.
Rob:Some practitioners swear by them, others run a mile from them.
Rob:We sort of touched on this earlier that, uh, at least initially there
Rob:may not be the best intervention, but what are your thoughts on prebiotics?
Marillia:Yeah, so obviously like prebiotics are amazing because
Marillia:they are essentially feeding our beneficial gut bacteria, right?
Marillia:And I think the main problem why There is confusion is because we are, we are
Marillia:talking about two different things.
Marillia:We're talking about people that are just looking to improve their gut
Marillia:health, but they don't have GI issues.
Marillia:And then people that have GI issues, and the advice is just
Marillia:not the same for these two groups.
Marillia:Uh, if you know, like prebiotics are found in things like garlic, onions, leeks.
Marillia:And if I tell a SIBO client or an IBS client, yeah, you know, go
Marillia:ahead and eat garlic onion leeks.
Marillia:they're going to feel terrible.
Marillia:So who are we trying to help here?
Marillia:You know, so if it's generalized good health advice, prebiotics, yes.
Marillia:Amazing.
Marillia:Go for it.
Marillia:But if you have SIBO, like this is not going to be a good idea unless
Marillia:you have dealt with the sequel.
Marillia:So.
Marillia:You know, the most common ones are like inulin, FOS.
Marillia:I definitely stay away from those, depending on the profile of the client.
Marillia:Talking about IBS, SIBO clients, then they don't usually tolerate those well.
Marillia:But I do like PHGG, partially hydrolyzed guar gum.
Marillia:I find it very well tolerated.
Marillia:Uh, we know it's, uh, like low FODMAP, you know, there are even
Marillia:some in the market that are certified low FODMAP by Monash University.
Marillia:So I do use that a lot and actually there is one clinical trial that showed
Marillia:that the combination of rifaximin with PHEG to be more effective than
Marillia:rifaximin alone in eradicating SIBO.
Marillia:So it definitely has, has its place.
Rob:So ultimately context matters when it comes to as with everything.
Rob:Exactly.
Rob:Perfect.
Rob:We've covered a lot and I want to be respectful of your time.
Rob:As we sort of draw to an end, what, if we could summarize this in its entirety,
Rob:what five tips would you give to somebody wanting to improve their gut health?
Rob:And I know that's like saying how long is a piece of string, but if
Rob:you were to just, uh, and it's like one of the, on one of those desiring
Rob:questions, what would you take with you?
Rob:But just broadly speaking.
Marillia:Yeah.
Marillia:So I'm going to say.
Marillia:what I would do to improve gut health in, in the scenario of my clients.
Marillia:Okay.
Marillia:So in the, in that context, the generalized advice, we know eat a,
Marillia:uh, plant rich diet, you know, colors, dietary fiber, probiotics, prebiotics, but
Marillia:that doesn't really suit my, my people.
Marillia:So I'm going to focus on that.
Marillia:I would say number one, which is It may sound silly, but it's minimize the risk
Marillia:of catching a stomach bug because that can, it can be life changing, you know,
Marillia:and we don't really understand that because no one is really talking about it.
Marillia:So that will be the one, the the first thing.
Marillia:The second thing would be minimize the intake of unnecessary antibiotics.
Marillia:Obviously they are important, they have a time and place, but as I
Marillia:said, unnecessary because we know that they are essentially a bomb.
Marillia:If you're dealing with symptoms, understand what's causing them.
Marillia:I always think that symptoms are signs that something isn't right.
Marillia:So don't ignore them and look for the, the, the, why, you know, ask why you
Marillia:are experiencing symptoms, address the underlying cause of the problem.
Marillia:And work with a specialist to overcome dietary restrictions, you know, because
Marillia:at the end, that's what you really want.
Marillia:You want to be able to eat a variety of foods,
Rob:definitely something.
Rob:I mean, yeah, those words are ones to live by for sure.
Rob:Okay.
Rob:Final question.
Rob:Uh, taking everything into account that you've, that you've learned over the
Rob:years, uh, how do you live your life?
Rob:Uh, and there'll definitely be some overlap with the previous answer.
Rob:I'm sure But how are you optimizing your day to day lifestyle, uh, sort
Rob:of based on these sort of functional medicine philosophies that we discussed
Rob:to sort of, yeah, live your best life?
Marillia:So I truly think it's about nailing the basics, you know, and to be
Marillia:very, very cliche health is well for me.
Marillia:I lost my health and I know it's, you know, it doesn't matter what you have.
Marillia:If you don't have your health, it's absolutely pointless.
Marillia:So for me, it's really about nailing the foundations.
Marillia:And as I said before, as well, it is multifactorial.
Marillia:It's not, I will do this one thing that is going to be the solution,
Marillia:but it's a combination of things.
Marillia:Thanks.
Marillia:It does require discipline because, you know, it's much easier to not think
Marillia:about all the things that you need to do to achieve long term health.
Marillia:Uh, but I prioritize sleep.
Marillia:I make sure my meals are balanced, that I get enough color on my
Marillia:plate, protein, dietary fiber.
Marillia:I exercise daily.
Marillia:I do strength training, cardio exercises, and then I also try to rest and have fun.
Rob:Marilia, that is amazing advice, and I think Yes, there's
Rob:definitely something that I need to sort of take on board as well.
Rob:Where can people find you if they want to work with you?
Marillia:Yeah, so they can find me, uh, online on my website,
Marillia:which is gutfulnessnutrition.
Marillia:com or Instagram and my handle is gutfulnessnutrition.
Rob:Perfect.
Rob:We'll be sure to link to all of those in the show notes as well.
Rob:Marilia, thank you so much for your time.
Rob:We really appreciate it and we'll have to do this again soon.
Marillia:Absolutely.
Marillia:Thank you, Rob.