Welcome to part two of our conversation with Kimberly Lafferty where we look into why there is so much abuse and misuse of power in spiritual organizations and our pressing need for training and ethics in these turbulent times.
Speaker AWelcome to Deep Transformation Self, Society, Spirit, life enhancing paradigm rattling conversations with cutting edge thinkers, contemplatives and activ.
Speaker AWith Dr.
Speaker ARoger Walsh and John Dupuy join us in the evolutionary fast lane as we take a deep dive into transformational practice.
Speaker APeak experience, profound understanding, powerful contribution.
Speaker BYou're pointing to also to another implication of ethics here, another perspective which is seem to be talked about much, certainly not in our western culture.
Speaker BAnd that is we can all do it as an experiment and observe it for ourselves.
Speaker BAnd that is if we check in in a moment when we are motivated to act unethically.
Speaker BWhat we find is that the mind is consumed and run by emotions such as anger and fear and jealousy and motives such as greed or mode of attack.
Speaker BAnd what we can see in our own direct experiences, if we act those out, we reinforce them and strengthen them.
Speaker BIn traditional terms deepen our own karma.
Speaker BBut the good news is that if we look into the mind at the moments where we're motivated to act ethically and the way I define ethics as is focuses on intention, that something an intention is ethical to the extended aims to enhance the well being of, of everyone affected by the action, including ourselves.
Speaker BIf it doesn't include ourselves, it's sacrifice.
Speaker BIf it only looks at ourselves, it's narcissism.
Speaker BSo it's the both and.
Speaker BBut if we look into our minds at those moments when we are moved to act ethically to enhance the well being of all, we find that the mind is imbued with emotions such as love and joy and motives of kindness and generosity and compassion and they are reinforced.
Speaker BSo yes, you're pointing to a very important thing that the future changes.
Speaker BBut in the very moment of the action there's reinforcement of either positive or painful mental qualities.
Speaker CThank you so much, Roger.
Speaker CAbsolutely.
Speaker CYeah, absolutely.
Speaker CIt ends up being I benefit when we do these ethical.
Speaker CWe should probably find another word for this.
Speaker CThese actions that benefit ourselves and others.
Speaker CYou know, the happiness that comes and the joy that comes is just extraordinary.
Speaker CSo.
Speaker CAnd the ease and the ability to meditate.
Speaker BYes.
Speaker CIs so tied in with acting in.
Speaker CAnyone who's tried to meditate, anyone who's gone into retreat can certainly tell you that we want to clear up the things that are bothering us.
Speaker CYou know, my teacher used to say just go after your number one mental affliction.
Speaker CJust acknowledge.
Speaker CDo the shadow work, for those of you familiar with that term, you know, do the work you need to do to recognize what's actually arising in our own psychology before we go into retreat.
Speaker CBecause you'll certainly see it in retreat.
Speaker BOh, yes.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BAmplified.
Speaker BJack Cornfield used to say, it's very hard to have a nice, quiet, calm sitting if you've been running around being angry and attacking people during the day.
Speaker CYes, yes, it is.
Speaker BSo you've given us a beautiful overview of a multi level and multi developmental stage perspective on ethics.
Speaker BAnd I love the way you took it up to kind of the absolute of the recognition of.
Speaker BNo, Kimberly.
Speaker BGiving.
Speaker BNo.
Speaker BNo individual person receiving.
Speaker BRather, Zadyashanti would say there's only one relationship, the divine entertaining itself.
Speaker BAnd we come.
Speaker BThis brings us to a problematic area.
Speaker BWe've talked about kind of an ideal and.
Speaker BAnd what is real and.
Speaker BBut yeah, we see people and I know this has been an area of deep concern for you and you work with the.
Speaker BYou're on the board of the organization for Integral, for, let's see, spiritual integrity.
Speaker BYes.
Speaker BThere are a lot of teachers who have acted in not so ethical ways.
Speaker BManipulated, sexually manipulated for power.
Speaker BHow are we to understand this?
Speaker CHow are we to understand this?
Speaker COh, well, we're human.
Speaker CI mean, how should we go into this?
Speaker CWe're all human.
Speaker CSo just to acknowledge, you know, compassion and care for all of the parts inside and out and all of our efforts as beings in the world, just trying to be happy.
Speaker CSo starting there, the wonderful being on the board for the asi, the association for Spiritual Integrity, as particularly as a spiritual teacher, somebody who identifies as a somewhat, you know, quiet, but certainly somebody who's in a spiritual community as a spiritual teacher and has been around for a few decades and seen the difficulties and challenges of, you know, being in spiritual community.
Speaker CAnd what happens.
Speaker CYou can't really find any spiritual community out there perhaps who has not had some sort of issue or schism or scandal or all of these things just because we're human, we're divine and we're human too.
Speaker CAnd there's certainly ranges to that.
Speaker CThere's one distinction I like to say is there's misuse of power and abuse of power.
Speaker CAnd when you're in the position of being a teacher or a leader of anything, you know, not just spiritual, but really anything, there are these structures and challenges that we have in terms of the relational aspects of getting along with each other and projecting and trauma and all of this.
Speaker CSo most I would venture to even say that Any spiritual teacher, at some point, just like any leader is going to misuse power.
Speaker CI've done it myself.
Speaker CI've realized, oh, I've made a mistake.
Speaker CI shouldn't have done that.
Speaker CWe're learning as we go, right?
Speaker CI shouldn't ask anyone who's a student to do anything that I don't pay them for or whatever is the issue.
Speaker CMisuse of power is something we just need to acknowledge that might happen and be very eyes open and aware of the tendency to do that.
Speaker CAny spiritual teacher, and I will put a line under this and put my foot down on this, any spiritual teacher should report to somebody, should have a board, should have a mentor, should have somebody that text them.
Speaker CIt should have a community that has a feedback process.
Speaker CAnd even with all of these, there's still going to be challenges because we're human and we're trying to figure it out and we're trying to practice.
Speaker CLike in my community, the Vajrayana School were practicing these things that require a lot of us, like being divine light and seeing each other as divine light.
Speaker CThese are not small things.
Speaker CRight?
Speaker ASo, Kimberly, this is a very, very important subject for me.
Speaker ASo do you think it is possible for an individual to have a deep realization at the same time and not talking about you catching yourself, like not paying somebody than where you should have or something going, oh, I'm sorry, God, you know, but this chronic malignant lack of ethics and acting out and hurting people at the same time, having this deep realization, can those coexist?
Speaker CYes and no.
Speaker CI mean, apparently so we have a lot of case studies, right?
Speaker COr this is the case.
Speaker CAnd I would venture to say, based on my experience, you could have a non dual realization, like a true emptiness realization and still be quite early developmentally and have a lot of shadow and a lot have a lot of trauma.
Speaker CAnd so yes, it can go exist because I assert that the later stages of wisdom should definitely lead you to bodhichitta and ethics.
Speaker CAnd if it's not, then there's a problem, you know, just to come back to the beginning.
Speaker CIf it's not, then there's something is amiss, right, in the state of Denmark.
Speaker CSo I assert that.
Speaker CBut apparently so, yes, you know, and you can have.
Speaker CWe see this in the developmental research, you know, early realizations and then claims and truth claims, all of this happens.
Speaker CAnd yeah, there's still a lot of problem.
Speaker CAnd so there is, you know, there's misuse of power, which every teacher needs to be aware of and cognizant of.
Speaker CAnd have a feedback loop for.
Speaker CAnd then there's the abuse of power, which are the stories that you see.
Speaker CAnd this is when it's chronic.
Speaker CThis is when there is no work, you know, shadow work for the teacher.
Speaker CThe teacher isn't getting feedback.
Speaker CIt's something that happens.
Speaker CThey sleep with their students again and again and again.
Speaker AOr maybe it's character biological.
Speaker AYou know, maybe they're just a sociopath with a very deep realization.
Speaker CYes, it certainly could be okay, sadly.
Speaker CYeah, you know, sadly.
Speaker CAnd we see that in a lot of leaders, I think.
Speaker BAnd so what you're pointing to many things here, Kimberly, one of them being that insights don't do it all by any means.
Speaker BAnd one of the things you are one of the integrators of contemporary psychological and developmental understanding with traditional wisdom.
Speaker BAnd one of the things we now is now clear is that there are certain things that contemplation doesn't reveal.
Speaker BIt doesn't reveal unconscious psychodynamics or psychological defenses.
Speaker BAnd it doesn't help us recognize developmental stages.
Speaker BSo there are just parts of the psyche and its potentials and capacities which we have only recognized in the last century with Western psychology and which contemplative practices have been ignorant about.
Speaker BThey are masterful for states and cultivation of particular qualities and capacities and insights, but they also have their limits.
Speaker CAbsolutely.
Speaker CWhich is why it's so important and we're so fortunate to live in 2024 to bring them all together.
Speaker CAnd Roger, you've been such a, you know, an exemplar of that with your work.
Speaker CAnd everybody go out, buy Essential Spirituality and Roger's other works right now, you know, that really do integrate the wisdom of modernity and psychology in the third person perspective with our first person experiences, you know, and we need to bring them all together.
Speaker CWe tend to overcorrect in this culture.
Speaker CAnd there have been a lot of, just to say, of course, issues with abuses of power with our spiritual teachers.
Speaker CAnd this is what we're looking at and looking to support through our work at the asi, which is a nonprofit.
Speaker CAnd what's missing, interestingly, for many of our spiritual teachers, however, people who self identify as spiritual teachers, they might be yoga teachers.
Speaker CA lot of people who are now acupuncturists or working in the healing modalities identify themselves that way.
Speaker CThey know they're doing something more than just healing the body.
Speaker CSo what is missing for many of them is everything we've been talking about is ethical training, not in terms of do this list of things don't do this list of things, but exactly, John, what you keep bringing us back to, which is the why.
Speaker CThe why.
Speaker CAnd that does seem to be missing for a lot of teachers out there, interestingly, even though they're ordained or they've gone through their own training in some form or another.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker BAnd there's also.
Speaker BWe've been talking primarily about individuals and the ways in which individuals, as you said so beautifully, both divine and human, and we screw up.
Speaker BIn my naive youth of not so many years ago, naivety, anyway, youth was a little further, further away.
Speaker BI used to think that, you know, really awake people wouldn't screw up.
Speaker BNow I think everyone screws up and wise people clean up.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker BSo we're talking about individuals.
Speaker BAnd you mentioned the culture is overcorrected in a way and in some ways become very condemnatory without offering more of a supportive, rehabilitative, at least possibilities.
Speaker BAnd that's my addition to what you were saying.
Speaker BBut there's also a larger picture, and the one which encapsulates it for me was the book by Brian Victoria called Zenith War, which laid out in painful detail the way of multiple Zen teachers leading up to and during World War II, had actively supported Japan's militaristic, nationalistic, xenophobic horrors.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker BAnd again, the question.
Speaker BI have my own take on this and love to dialogue with you, but I'd love to hear, you know, your take because you have so many perspectives.
Speaker BYou have traditional training, your developmental, your psychological.
Speaker BWhat are some of the ways you understand this?
Speaker COh, why these apparently spiritual practitioners would act in violent ways.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker AOr support the invasion of countries and just the cruel, you know, treatment of conquered peoples.
Speaker AAnd samurai.
Speaker ABloody war.
Speaker AWarrior ethics, for example.
Speaker CYou got it.
Speaker CWarrior ethics.
Speaker CYep.
Speaker COne of my favorite subjects.
Speaker CWell, you know, we referred to the wisdom.
Speaker CBuddhists are just obsessed with this idea of emptiness.
Speaker CRight.
Speaker CThis idea of ultimate reality, this idea of wisdom.
Speaker CAnd so we assume that in this example, you know, monks, whatever tradition, have cultivated something that is akin to wisdom and compassion and whatever that is in the earlier development, up to conformist stage of development, we would say up to ethnocentric stage of development.
Speaker CEmptiness and wisdom is only correlated with concrete things.
Speaker CAnd so I can imagine for some reason I'm seeing a Zen monk with a samurai sword, I don't know, out there doing feudal warring from their own ethical ground.
Speaker CEmptiness and wisdom is merely the fact that things out there change.
Speaker CThings out there I can't control.
Speaker CAnd the beings that I'm looking at are still ethnocentric.
Speaker CI don't yet see.
Speaker CSee if I am putting myself in that human moment of evolution and putting myself in their shoes.
Speaker CI don't yet see those who think differently than me and especially those who look differently than me.
Speaker CEven with what they're wearing and where they come from, they're not yet people in a way.
Speaker CYou know, they don't have that same care of concern.
Speaker CAnd this is why developmental theory helps explain so much.
Speaker CThese are good people.
Speaker CThere's nothing wrong with them, but there's this lack of understanding yet that the world is much bigger.
Speaker CYou know, it's like you can only see the objects right in front of you.
Speaker CSo anything outside of that, it just doesn't even exist yet.
Speaker CSo these beings are working with what they have is what I assume, you know, putting aside any pathologies that might be occurring or collective traumas or everything else that goes on.
Speaker CThey're doing their best.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BSo you're drawing a very important distinction between contemplative training and the stage at which people are at.
Speaker BAnd let me suggest a couple of other things I'd love to hear you respond to.
Speaker BOne is Zen is sometimes referred to, and this isn't fair, but I'll use the phrase somewhat degenerate tradition in the sense that in some ways in Japan, it's been passed on from father to son, and the lineage holders have not necessarily been chosen on the basis of their practice or realization.
Speaker BSo perhaps some of these people weren't so realized is one thing.
Speaker BSecond is you point very powerfully to the possibility that these people work are actually very clearly acting out of a fairly not so mature ethnocentric developmental stage.
Speaker BThe third thing which is most problematic is some of them seem to ration use insights into and teachings about profound things such as emptiness as rationalizations for action.
Speaker CYes.
Speaker BI can quote it, you know, if ordered to tramp.
Speaker BIf ordered to march, tramp, tramp, you know, no one dies.
Speaker BNo one kills.
Speaker BI mean.
Speaker CYes.
Speaker BYeah, well, that's one side of it.
Speaker BAnd the other not.
Speaker BThere's others.
Speaker CYes.
Speaker CAnd this is the danger and why a lot of the more profound mystical approaches were kept quiet because of their potential misuse.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker CThere's nobody to kill.
Speaker CThere's nobody to be killed.
Speaker CCome over here.
Speaker CLet me chop your head off.
Speaker CTell me that that's nobody.
Speaker CYou know, it's nobody the way you thought.
Speaker CYeah, that's the big danger and problem and misunderstanding of emptiness.
Speaker CAnd it's very common to misuse it, to misuse.
Speaker COh, the emptiness of ethics.
Speaker CRight.
Speaker CSo I can do whatever I want and there is no consequence.
Speaker BYeah, very important.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker CLike the emptiness of truth in our post truth world, which isn't really true because things are true, just not the way we thought they were true.
Speaker CSo, you know, one thing I'll say, maybe it'll help your listeners too.
Speaker CThis emptiness idea too is the truth of something is how it functions.
Speaker CRight.
Speaker CSo if this sword functions to chop your head off, then the sword doesn't function the way you thought, but it still functions.
Speaker CRight.
Speaker COr that might be too esoteric for, for leaving us.
Speaker CBut there's emptiness doesn't mean nothing's true.
Speaker CIt means things function just not the way you thought before.
Speaker CAnd yeah, it's something that needs to be corrected, I think in the tradition.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker BAnd again, one of the things you're pointing to here is the, the way that the tradition now can be complemented and enriched by contemporary understanding and your emphasis being with adult development.
Speaker BThere's also the recognition of psychodynamics and defenses and essentially we need to update certain understandings and practices.
Speaker BDo you see any particular ethical issues that need attention and specifically need to be addressed from our time?
Speaker BYou've actually mentioned one which is postmodern thought and the trap of kind of non truth perspective.
Speaker BSo maybe you'd like to say more about that.
Speaker BMaybe there are other topics as well that you have in mind and I haven't thought of, but love to hear any ways you'd like to run with the idea of, okay, what are some contemporary issues that weren't part of world's problems a thousand years ago?
Speaker CYes, well, it's sometimes painful to see what's happening in our world just turning on the news or just hearing the way that we speak to each other in TV shows or in media.
Speaker CIt's challenging to see.
Speaker CAnd of course the answer.
Speaker CI'm first going to say as a developmentalist that applying a developmental understanding in developmental education is essential to any situation that we have.
Speaker CThat there's not going to be a one answer for everybody, that we have to be very specific with the interventions that we take both inside and out and be developmentally appropriate with where they are.
Speaker CSo an example of that is just speaking.
Speaker CIf I'm going to work with a misunderstanding with somebody about they're getting triggered to an earlier trauma response, something that happened with childhood, then the I'm going to apply healing and intervention that's going to be appropriate to early childhood.
Speaker CI'm not going to go to the highest levels of oh, just see yourself as Divine light, for example, or later stages.
Speaker CSo I do want to say that what we're missing seems to be the, I'll just say spiritual education.
Speaker CI think if I had to choose one aspect, postmodern society in large part has, again, for good reasons and sometimes not so helpful reasons, has sort of relegated a lot of our, say, traditional spiritual traditions to the garbage heap, so to speak.
Speaker CAnd that is unfortunate.
Speaker CAnd when we don't have, for example, as a mother, you know, this is very relevant for me when we don't have that traditional what we think of now from the older stages and look back and go, oh, that was so rote.
Speaker CThat was so black and white.
Speaker CBut when we don't teach our three year olds and our four year olds and our five year olds that there is a God who's watching or there is even a Santa, I mean, all we were left with was Santa, right?
Speaker CWe don't even really have Santa anymore.
Speaker CYou know, Santa's not even watching, you know, when we don't have.
Speaker CAnd it doesn't have to be Sunday school, it doesn't have to be, I have a 13 year old, you know, he's not being raised a Buddhist traditionally.
Speaker CRight.
Speaker CThere's ways that we can teach these things in everyday language without getting into trappings and ritualism.
Speaker CRight?
Speaker CBut we did teach him.
Speaker CAnd when we do teach have our kids, we need to teach them that what they do matters and that there is something watching them.
Speaker CIt's actually a stage, it's a developmental challenge that's really important where you start to see that you're not, you're not alone in the universe, right?
Speaker CAnd there is an impact to your actions and mom has eyes on the back of her head and that there is a consequence to doing harm.
Speaker CRight.
Speaker CAnd so we need boundaries that we don't have for a lot of our young people.
Speaker CAnd when I'm saying 3, 4, 5, I'm talking about kids at that age and I'm talking about those parts inside of us too, at the same time.
Speaker CBecause when we don't have these traditional boundary structures, to be frank, we end up raising narcissists.
Speaker CAnd you know, in simple general, just all general terms, but in general terms, I think that's one of the interventions that we need to do specifically.
Speaker CIt doesn't mean send all your kids to Sunday school, but it does mean take a look at how boundaries and ethics and teaching our kids some basic structures that we find in our humanities, that we find throughout our human tradition are really important to move us out of the egocentric stage of development and to really care for other people.
Speaker AAnd it seems there has to be also a transmission of the compassion that these rules are based in from a higher level, that children can understand it and applies for people at higher levels too.
Speaker AThey have to feel that the being that's saying, you shouldn't do this, you should do this, you shouldn't do this is coming from a place that, wow, if that's wisdom, I want some, you know, I want, this is a role model.
Speaker AI want to be like this person.
Speaker AAnd it raises a question, and I've never asked anybody this before, but somebody who's deeply.
Speaker AAnd it's good for you too, Roger.
Speaker ABut it's deeply studied in the tradition of Buddhism, Indo, Tibetan Buddhism.
Speaker AHow legitimate do you think these transmissions of authority are?
Speaker AIn other words, because you go through the ceremony and you get the robe or you get the title or something.
Speaker AIs that 100%, you know, or is that just probably pretty good, maybe 60% or if you're lucky, it works.
Speaker AOr is there actually, you know, something that really.
Speaker AAnd I imagine psychologically, if a person would take on that responsibility, accept it for the importance that it is they might behave that might help them to grow into a higher level of behavior and being.
Speaker ABut how legitimate is all that stuff?
Speaker CWell, I'll take a.
Speaker CYou know, I think it depends.
Speaker CI mean, not.
Speaker CIt's kind of.
Speaker CIt depends, of course, right?
Speaker COn how the individual, what's arising for them.
Speaker CI can tell you just personally, a personal antidote about that is my experience is we live in a multi populated cosmos with a K.
Speaker CAnd for me there is, yes, I've done the work, yes, I've done the retreats.
Speaker CI also, Kimberly, as a Persona, even in my corporate life, I've always been a teacher, right?
Speaker CI've always been that sort of my archetype.
Speaker CI'm an educator, I'm a teacher.
Speaker CSo there's a reason in the relative reality, on a personality side, I was tapped to step into that role.
Speaker CYes, I had some clear light experience.
Speaker CYes, I did my retreats.
Speaker CAnd I'm also a teacher, right?
Speaker CSo.
Speaker CAnd I think my teachers recognize that in me.
Speaker CBut for me it was finding my passion, getting the education, getting the realization, doing the retreats.
Speaker CI'm a teacher by calling.
Speaker CBut beyond that, there's something about standing on the shoulders, as we say, of a lineage that is still with me.
Speaker CI feel as if I've stepped into a family of humanity that goes back hundreds and thousands of years and that I can feel Even now at my back, I can feel into the future.
Speaker CAnd so just for me, it's anybody.
Speaker CThis is accessible to anybody.
Speaker COnce you step into a school or a lineage or a family, it's this invisible, shall we say, mystical indeed, belonging in a very deep way that goes to sort of early childhood and humanity where I'm not alone.
Speaker CAnd that's what it represents to me.
Speaker CIt's like this mystical family.
Speaker CNot that I am empowered to be, you know, though that might be true too.
Speaker CIt's more of a company.
Speaker CIt just makes this human life much more zesty and interesting and timeless, you know.
Speaker AYeah.
Speaker BThank you for that personal note, Kimberly.
Speaker BI also want to go back and just make sure a couple of things you said are emphasized.
Speaker BAnd one is you were.
Speaker BYou were making a point about the importance of ethical training or ethical inculcation or transmission.
Speaker BI think you were making the point of ethics as much a transmission as anything else, John, based in compassion as really important to bringing people into our culturating them.
Speaker BAnd I love the way the two of you were kind of complementary because you were saying, Kimberly, it's really important that education be developmentally appropriate for people, which isn't really something that's recognized much outside schools.
Speaker BYeah, that feels very important.
Speaker BAnd so you were emphasizing the importance of developmentally appropriate, you know, God's watching.
Speaker BAnd John, you.
Speaker BYou brought in the perspective.
Speaker BAnd that ideally comes from a place of deep, profound compassion, which is a beautiful integration there.
Speaker BAnd that point you make about the developmental appropriateness of one's interaction.
Speaker BYou were talking about education, but one's interaction with anyone in the world feels so important.
Speaker BSo I want to make sure, before we finish, we dive a little more deeply into your developmental understandings.
Speaker BYou've immersed yourself so deeply in the study of development, including adult development, including late post conventional stages, which our culture knows almost nothing about.
Speaker CYes.
Speaker BOne of the implications of what you were both saying was that.
Speaker BAnd you particularly, Kimberly, talked about the way religion has been and its values have been kind of marginalized in much of conventional culture.
Speaker BAnd unfortunately, the marginalization has been based on the cultural recognition of only the conventional stages of religion.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BAnd religion, as far as I can see, is the only human institution we have that spans the entire spectrum of development.
Speaker BSo it has these extraordinary potentials, these trans conventional perspectives which are lost, tragically.
Speaker BSo.
Speaker BSo you're one of the people who's bringing this understanding into contemporary practice and understanding of religion.
Speaker BAnd so maybe you could say, just riff on your appreciation of what this developmental perspective has to Add to our understanding of human nature potentials and contemplative practices.
Speaker CSure.
Speaker CThank you.
Speaker CWell, I was first attracted to developmental theory for adults in particular because as I was reading about these later stages, not higher but later stages of development that we're getting researched on.
Speaker CRight.
Speaker CThis is research in the past 20, 30, 40 years, which, Roger, you, I know, have had just such an important part of that movement and that the field and what you've observed the past 40 years is something that I would like to interview you about.
Speaker CBut what I noticed in the developmental research, especially coming from the deep Indo Tibetan studies and in my own experience was they seemed to be using sometimes different language to talk about the same phenomena.
Speaker CIt seems like that.
Speaker CAnyway, there was a.
Speaker CWithout collapsing them into each other, there was some obvious correlations going on between the later stages of adult human development and these spiritual states and realizations and capacities that Indo Tibetan Buddhism was pointing out and that I'd had tastes of myself.
Speaker CAnd so that was the original attraction to development in particular because we had the research on it.
Speaker CRight.
Speaker CIt comes out of a body of research which is pretty significant.
Speaker CSo the gifts of developmental observation and research has shown us that meaning making radically shifts throughout our lifespan.
Speaker CAnd not only does meaning making radically shift throughout most people's lifespan, you know, we, it evolves and changes.
Speaker CBut because of that, our reality itself shifts throughout our meaning making and our lifespan.
Speaker CAnd not only that, but we hold everything that's come before inside of us.
Speaker CSo the metaphor that you often see referred to as the metaphor of the Russian dolls, right?
Speaker COr of concentric circles.
Speaker CSo development isn't a ladder, it's a balloon.
Speaker CIt's much more.
Speaker CWe take everything that comes before with us.
Speaker CAnd every time we talk about development, I always circle this and underline it again is we are all of it.
Speaker CEven as we recognize that there are a variety of stages that an individual, a culture, a society, a system, evolutionary waves in concentric circles like a balloon that we tend to grow through.
Speaker CUltimately we're also all of it.
Speaker CSo it's not a better than or worse than.
Speaker CIt's nothing like that.
Speaker CIt's these waves, like waves on an ocean that we go through.
Speaker CAnd so understanding what stage or wave, or let's say tone I'm coming from in any given moment, I'm coming from as Kimberly, a person with history and a psychology and all of these different stages inside of me, from the 3 year old Kimberly to the 10 year old Kimberly to the 20 year old Kimberly to now the 50 something year old Kimberly.
Speaker CRight.
Speaker CI need to be aware of what?
Speaker CAm I having an argument with my husband right now and reverting to teenager self.
Speaker CIt could be that I am actually acting like my teenager stage of development right now.
Speaker CI'm aware of that, right?
Speaker CEven as I'm resting in a clear light, I'm aware of that.
Speaker CWho am I talking to?
Speaker CWhat stage is presenting from them right now?
Speaker CWhether it be individually or whether it be somebody from a different belief system or political party or history or group or society.
Speaker CSo where am I coming from?
Speaker CWhere is this other person coming from?
Speaker CYou know, where?
Speaker CWhat's their meaning making in this moment which affects their reality and the reality that they are actually seeing and experiencing and that I adjust accordingly.
Speaker CYou know, this is part of the ethics that I'm operating on and that we want to get to developmentally is that I can't go around convincing everybody, shaming everybody, yelling at everybody to believe the way I do.
Speaker CHow well does that work?
Speaker ANot very well.
Speaker CI mean, come on.
Speaker CBut what if I sit down with my family member at Thanksgiving, right?
Speaker COr at the holiday table and attuned first to where I'm truly coming from, Keep myself regulated is key.
Speaker CRight.
Speaker CDivine light, ideally.
Speaker CRight to be in that place and attune to where this being is coming from in any given moment, it could change and speak to them.
Speaker CWe're all together in this.
Speaker CWe're all, you know, waves in the ocean and to connect and to empathize and to get in their shoes and to see where they're coming from and to find the common ground.
Speaker CAnd developmental education and tools can very much help us do that because the language we use is different depending on what developmental meaning making the objects we see are different.
Speaker CAnd as I said, how we make meaning is different.
Speaker CI want everybody to understand it really is a different reality.
Speaker CSo arguing over which is more real is not going to get us anywhere.
Speaker BParticularly since the differences are usually assumed to be differences of attitude or.
Speaker BOr belief rather than grounded in different developmental stages.
Speaker BAnd it feels like so much of our.
Speaker BOur cultural divisiveness at this stage is a reflection of arguments across different stages rather than just different attitudes or perspectives.
Speaker AAnd each stage trying to force everybody else to go along with their particular values, sometimes even violently.
Speaker AYou know, this is it.
Speaker AThis is what I believe.
Speaker AEverybody has to believe this way, or you're not fully human or you don't deserve respect, or maybe you're a catwoman or something like that.
Speaker ARight?
Speaker CAbsolutely.
Speaker CAnd it's not working very well.
Speaker CAnd in fact, if we can really embrace our instinct for true plurality and apply it to developmental rights and understanding and see the beautiful tapestry of those who think differently than us and see differently than us and really leverage the strengths of each of those.
Speaker CThen we can find our way forward, Leverage the strengths of religion, leverage the strengths of traditionalism, leverage the strengths of social justice and those issues and awareness, and then we can correct the overcorrection, perhaps.
Speaker BBeautiful.
Speaker BI hadn't heard anyone phrase it the way you did.
Speaker BLeverage the strengths.
Speaker CThat's beautiful.
Speaker BOf each perspective and stage.
Speaker BIt's a very beautiful way of holding it.
Speaker BAnd perhaps we need to add in.
Speaker BThere's been so much emphasis on diversity, but there's been no recognition as yet of the actual, even existence of developmental diversity or the importance of recognizing it in order to be able to recognize the source of these arguments.
Speaker BSo many arguments and so many divisions in culture and to make it possible to even begin to repair them.
Speaker AYeah, it seems almost essential, doesn't it?
Speaker AAnd like you said, Buddhism keeps evolving.
Speaker AAdding the developmental understanding to this ancient tradition just opens everything up.
Speaker AIt's amazing.
Speaker AKen used to say, if you think you're enlightened, go home for the holidays.
Speaker BThat's right.
Speaker BRight.
Speaker ABut the way you described it is exactly if you're enlightened, how you would act.
Speaker AGoing home for the holidays.
Speaker AIt's very, very good the way you said it.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BThere was a psychiatrist by the name of Arthur Dyckman who had.
Speaker BWho had his.
Speaker BA test of enlightenment, which came to be known as the Dyckman Test of Enlightenment.
Speaker BAnd first I thought it was a joke, and then the more I thought his test was, you want to know if someone's awake, ask the spouse.
Speaker BYeah, that's a good test.
Speaker CAbsolutely.
Speaker BYes.
Speaker CYeah.
Speaker AMrs.
Speaker ABuddha wasn't very convinced.
Speaker AShe was like, enlightenment Schmeman, why don't you stay home with me and the kids?
Speaker CYou know?
Speaker CYes, that comes back from the story.
Speaker BSo.
Speaker BYeah.
Speaker BKimberly, what do you see as.
Speaker BWhat actually changes as people mature?
Speaker BI mean, I'm thinking of the various capacities seem to come online in sequential ways, and you emphasized one of them earlier.
Speaker BThat is the capacity for a larger perspective, encompassing more and more people in one's scope of care and concern.
Speaker BAnd not only spatial, but also temporal.
Speaker BThat is, the capacity to take more generations into account.
Speaker BFor example, the beautiful Native American tradition of think of the effects of what you're doing on the seventh generation.
Speaker BSo.
Speaker BBut what are some of the other capacities that tend to come online as people mature?
Speaker AStay tuned for part three of our transformational conversation with Kimberly Lafferty.
Speaker AThank you very much for being a part of this conversation.
Speaker AWe hope that you were moved, as we are moved, being part of it ourselves.
Speaker AWe'd also like to say that this is being funded by Roger and myself.
Speaker AIt comes out of our pockets.
Speaker ASo if you would like to help us to mainly to get this podcast out to more people, because the bigger audience have which is steadily growing, but the more people we can reach and the more marketing we can do, the more positive effect we can have on the world.
Speaker ASo we've done a couple of ways, but we'd like you to buy us a cup of coffee, very simple.
Speaker AAnd I do that with podcasts that I support.
Speaker AAnd I find it's very satisfying.
Speaker ASo thank you for your help, thank you for your presence and thank you for all you are and all you do.
Speaker CWe love you.