1 00:00:02,649 --> 00:00:13,089 Welcome to Top Traders Unplugged. In markets success doesn’t 2 00:00:13,089 --> 00:00:24,689 come from predicting what happens next, it comes from being 3 00:00:24,689 --> 00:00:31,649 prepared for what you can’t predict. In each episode we go deep 4 00:00:04,620 --> 00:00:10,450 with some of the world’s most thoughtful minds in investing, economics, 5 00:00:10,450 --> 00:00:16,280 and beyond to understand how they think, how they prepare, and 6 00:00:16,280 --> 00:00:21,580 how they decide, and the experiences that shaped how they 7 00:00:21,580 --> 00:00:26,880 see the world. No noise, no short-cuts, just real conversations 8 00:00:26,880 --> 00:00:31,650 to help you think better and invest with confidence. 9 00:00:36,220 --> 00:00:46,340 Welcome and welcome back to this week's edition of the Systematic 10 00:00:46,340 --> 00:00:55,540 Investor series with Nick Baltas, from Goldman Sachs, and I, 11 00:00:55,540 --> 00:01:04,740 Moritz Seibert, from Takahe Capital, where each week we take 12 00:01:04,740 --> 00:01:15,780 the pulse of the global markets through the lens of a rules-based 13 00:01:15,780 --> 00:01:16,700 investor. Today I'm sitting in for my friend Niels Kaastrup-Larsen 14 00:00:46,930 --> 00:00:58,830 who would normally be recording this show with Nick, but 15 00:00:58,830 --> 00:01:13,110 Niels is traveling this week and therefore unable to get in front 16 00:01:13,110 --> 00:01:16,680 of the mic. So, Nick, Niels likes to start this show, as usual, 17 00:00:45,210 --> 00:00:55,998 with his ‘what's been on your radar lately’ question. And I'd like 18 00:00:55,998 --> 00:01:08,584 to pick this up and ask you, well, what's been on your radar lately? 19 00:01:08,584 --> 00:01:16,675 What's been keeping you busy? What's top of mind? 20 00:01:17,910 --> 00:01:20,744 Yeah, Niels does that and it's good to see you Moritz. It's been 21 00:01:20,744 --> 00:01:22,706 like what, six months since we were here together. 22 00:01:22,710 --> 00:01:24,306 Yeah, six months or something like that. 23 00:01:25,110 --> 00:01:39,883 So yeah, it's always a pleasure to kind of connect again 24 00:01:39,883 --> 00:01:55,999 with you. What's been on my mind frankly is very, very busy, 25 00:01:55,999 --> 00:02:08,086 very busy with no clear activity. Obviously, the markets 26 00:02:08,086 --> 00:02:26,888 have been keeping us up on our feet for some time now, you know, 27 00:02:26,888 --> 00:02:44,347 complacency and at the same time eager to get to the next phase 28 00:02:44,347 --> 00:02:59,120 of this micro situation. It certainly takes a good amount of 29 00:02:59,120 --> 00:03:01,806 our time. I'm spending a good amount of my, I guess, quasi free 30 00:01:41,478 --> 00:02:00,822 time on exploring how all this AI frenzy is going to impact, both 31 00:02:00,822 --> 00:02:23,142 the way that we do things on the day to day, but also how research 32 00:02:23,142 --> 00:02:42,486 is going to change from this point onwards. So, it's more of an 33 00:02:42,486 --> 00:02:57,366 exploration phase at the moment kind of ideas and creativity 34 00:02:57,366 --> 00:03:01,830 comes into play. Obviously at the same time, you know, we try to 35 00:01:43,360 --> 00:02:08,910 make sure that is kind of an underlying process as to how we do 36 00:02:08,910 --> 00:02:30,810 things and how we would want to be doing things going forward. 37 00:02:30,810 --> 00:02:52,710 But I would say this is something that I'm spending a good 38 00:02:52,710 --> 00:03:01,835 amount of my time on. I know coding has always been part of my 39 00:01:34,569 --> 00:01:50,334 day, in the recent years a bit less so. But now there was a chance 40 00:01:50,334 --> 00:02:06,099 of kind of going back to it. And it's kind of nice to see how 41 00:02:06,099 --> 00:02:18,711 you can start building even tools for your own kind of personal 42 00:02:18,711 --> 00:02:29,221 life through the new technology. So, I think a combination 43 00:02:29,221 --> 00:02:40,782 of very busy client activity, some travel, there is nothing that 44 00:02:40,782 --> 00:02:56,547 is on top of my mind that I would just flag as one. It's just 45 00:02:56,547 --> 00:03:01,802 a very, very busy period. Thankfully in a few hours I'll be 46 00:01:42,932 --> 00:02:13,484 heading out for a week of a holiday. So, that's basically what 47 00:02:13,484 --> 00:02:54,220 I have on my mind, that I need this one week to spend with the family 48 00:02:54,220 --> 00:03:01,858 and the kids. 49 00:03:02,420 --> 00:03:40,419 Yeah, well deserved, as you told me. I wish you a great holiday. 50 00:03:02,420 --> 00:03:14,744 Like you, the markets are keeping us busy. I mean, not necessarily 51 00:03:14,744 --> 00:03:28,095 from putting trades on but just the ups and downs and all the 52 00:03:28,095 --> 00:03:37,338 volatility, especially in the petroleum markets, continues to be 53 00:03:37,338 --> 00:03:40,419 a big theme. Luckily trend following strategies are doing quite 54 00:03:06,445 --> 00:03:14,495 well this year in light of the situation, and as far as I'm concerned, 55 00:03:14,495 --> 00:03:21,970 I had a great day in Zurich yesterday, was in Klein’s. I met 56 00:03:21,970 --> 00:03:28,870 a common acquaintance of ours, as I've mentioned we shall not mention 57 00:03:28,870 --> 00:03:36,920 his name but it's been just a great day there. It's a great city, 58 00:03:36,920 --> 00:03:40,370 everybody seems to be doing well. 59 00:03:40,830 --> 00:03:43,950 True, true, very good friend, very good friend. 60 00:03:43,950 --> 00:05:15,168 So yeah, he definitely says hi. Now there's quite some interesting 61 00:03:56,275 --> 00:04:23,390 topics I'd like to discuss with you today, Nick, but before 62 00:04:23,390 --> 00:04:50,505 we go there, there's usually a trend following update that Niels 63 00:04:50,505 --> 00:05:15,155 does, and I just want to follow the same schedule. So, here's 64 00:03:45,686 --> 00:03:54,366 the performance update as of yesterday night, which is Wednesday 65 00:03:54,366 --> 00:04:00,442 evening, May 20th. Month-to-date and year-to-date performance 66 00:04:00,442 --> 00:04:11,726 numbers: for the BTOP 50 index it's up 1.46% for the month, and 67 00:04:11,726 --> 00:04:21,274 more than 11% for the year. (As I've mentioned, trend following 68 00:04:21,274 --> 00:04:32,558 is doing quite all right this year.) The SocGen CTA Index has similar 69 00:04:32,558 --> 00:04:42,974 numbers, 1.55% positive for the month, and up about 12% for the 70 00:04:42,974 --> 00:04:52,522 year. SocGen Trend, a little better, 2.11% for the month, and 71 00:04:52,522 --> 00:05:03,806 up a little bit more than 12% for the year. The Short-Term Traders 72 00:05:03,806 --> 00:05:15,090 Index is up about 1% this month, and up 6% for the year. Equities, 73 00:03:45,704 --> 00:04:08,506 MSCI World up 2.4% for the month, and 8% for the year. Bonds, 74 00:04:08,506 --> 00:04:31,308 they're down about 50 pips for the month, and down about 25 pips 75 00:04:31,308 --> 00:04:50,602 for the year. And the unbeatable S&P 500 Total Return index 76 00:04:50,602 --> 00:05:15,158 is up 3.19% for the month, and 9% for the year. Isn't that amazing. 77 00:03:43,950 --> 00:04:15,995 I mean, you just don't bet against the S&P 500 anymore. I mean, 78 00:04:15,995 --> 00:04:45,575 every time I look at the performance and I report to somebody, 79 00:04:45,575 --> 00:05:10,225 you know, what's the performance of the S&P 500, it's 80 00:05:10,225 --> 00:05:15,155 always up. 81 00:05:16,850 --> 00:05:21,335 It's hard to beat. It has become harder to beat, but I guess 82 00:05:21,335 --> 00:05:25,130 eventually becomes a bit of concentration. But not on S&P itself, 83 00:05:25,130 --> 00:05:28,235 but in the three, four, five, six constituents within. 84 00:05:28,560 --> 00:05:30,513 AI stocks and the Magnificent Seven, maybe, yeah, precisely. 85 00:05:31,880 --> 00:05:36,200 And then, you know, there's the big event coming up with SpaceX 86 00:05:36,200 --> 00:05:39,440 which will probably increase that concentration quite a bit. 87 00:05:40,400 --> 00:05:43,559 I mean, yeah, we're all kind of following the news over the last 88 00:05:43,559 --> 00:05:46,232 couple of days, with evaluations, and so on, and so forth. 89 00:05:46,232 --> 00:05:49,148 So, I think that's going to be quite an IPO to remember. 90 00:05:49,340 --> 00:05:53,179 Yeah. So, as you mentioned, Nick, we chatted about six months 91 00:05:53,179 --> 00:05:57,367 or so ago. And when we recorded the topic was about the 92 00:05:57,367 --> 00:06:01,555 QIS space at large. Like, how many assets are there, what types 93 00:06:01,555 --> 00:06:06,092 of clients do you have, how do you wrap the exposures into, like, 94 00:06:06,092 --> 00:06:10,280 is it swaps, or nodes, or options, and these type of things? 95 00:06:10,280 --> 00:06:15,166 And maybe this is a good point to reconnect, and catch up, and ask 96 00:06:15,166 --> 00:06:19,005 you what's been happening lately in QIS land? What have clients 97 00:06:19,005 --> 00:06:22,844 been interested in? Is there any theme that attracts clients and 98 00:06:22,844 --> 00:06:25,287 grabs their attention? Anything that's standing out? 99 00:06:26,420 --> 00:06:54,200 So, generally, in terms of themes, you wouldn't hear something 100 00:06:54,200 --> 00:07:19,202 that is dramatically different. I think the whole QIS 101 00:07:19,202 --> 00:07:46,982 space has become a vehicle of expressing specific macro views, 102 00:07:46,982 --> 00:08:14,762 frankly speaking. It has departed, at least for some time 103 00:08:14,762 --> 00:08:42,542 now, the premise of designing an uncorrelated stream of return 104 00:08:42,542 --> 00:09:21,434 that you're going to put on top of your SAA, and it's going to 105 00:09:21,434 --> 00:09:38,102 do the job no matter what. I think it has started being utilized 106 00:06:42,205 --> 00:07:09,265 to express macro views, some of which can have a systematic expression. 107 00:07:09,265 --> 00:07:27,305 Said differently, somebody could possibly argue that year-to-date, 108 00:07:27,305 --> 00:07:58,875 being long equities and maybe long oil on the back end of the macro 109 00:07:58,875 --> 00:08:23,680 dynamics, or maybe shorting some bonds, is a macro call that 110 00:08:23,680 --> 00:08:50,740 they would want to deploy, which is not too dissimilar of arguing 111 00:08:50,740 --> 00:09:15,545 that, hey, a trend following expression of that is nothing more 112 00:09:15,545 --> 00:09:38,095 than what a QIS solution could deliver in this regard. So, to go 113 00:06:36,506 --> 00:07:16,850 back to your question, the theme, I think, for the year, or 114 00:07:16,850 --> 00:08:03,918 at least in the early days, was more about how the whole AI CapEx 115 00:08:03,918 --> 00:08:37,538 is going to impact positively, profitably for the equity market 116 00:08:37,538 --> 00:09:14,520 and more broadly for the economy. And soon after that, obviously 117 00:09:14,520 --> 00:09:38,054 with the geopolitics, things turned quite substantially. We're 118 00:06:27,872 --> 00:06:46,748 kind of pricing in rate cuts and now we're kind of debating how 119 00:06:46,748 --> 00:07:07,076 many of rate hikes we're going to see. So, I think that pivot, around 120 00:07:07,076 --> 00:07:24,500 March, led to memories of 2022, I should say. There have been 121 00:07:24,500 --> 00:07:40,472 discussions along the lines of is inflation picking up again? Clearly, 122 00:07:40,472 --> 00:07:57,896 in the news and in the public releases, that's exactly what we're 123 00:07:57,896 --> 00:08:15,320 seeing. So, the question then becomes, is that going to be sticky? 124 00:08:15,320 --> 00:08:32,744 Is it going to start impacting how equity and bond correlation plays 125 00:08:32,744 --> 00:08:51,620 out? Is that a story that relates back to the days of dispersion 126 00:08:51,620 --> 00:09:03,236 dynamics of maybe interest rate volatility, trend following 127 00:09:03,236 --> 00:09:19,208 (to your point) the good performance this year is maybe the 128 00:09:19,208 --> 00:09:35,180 consequence as well as the invitation of another good year in 129 00:09:35,180 --> 00:09:38,084 this regard. So, I should say if there is anything that I would 130 00:07:05,459 --> 00:07:40,949 basically put forward as a thematic it’s around inflation. And 131 00:07:40,949 --> 00:08:12,890 obviously, pockets of inflation relate to maybe some equity 132 00:08:12,890 --> 00:08:51,929 hedging at times. And obviously, if you look at the market, 133 00:08:51,929 --> 00:09:38,066 like, okay, do I actually need a hedge at this point in time? It's 134 00:06:28,846 --> 00:07:00,384 actually the V shape in March was very different to the ones before. 135 00:07:00,384 --> 00:07:27,070 It was the one that kind of dropped…It didn't drop dramatically, 136 00:07:27,070 --> 00:07:58,608 but it did drop over the course of like a couple of weeks. 137 00:07:58,608 --> 00:08:27,720 And then the recovery was very, very quick. I think we have 138 00:08:27,720 --> 00:08:56,832 rarely seen this type of a dynamic. Typically you see a fast 139 00:08:56,832 --> 00:09:33,222 way down and a bit more of a kind of slow recovery was the other 140 00:09:33,222 --> 00:09:38,074 way around. So, that's the main theme, frankly speaking. Inflation, 141 00:06:55,348 --> 00:07:53,204 if you were to put like a tag on it, with all the small kind of 142 00:07:53,204 --> 00:08:32,980 sub components of it, one could be equity hedging, the other 143 00:08:32,980 --> 00:09:09,140 one could be maybe some opportunistic pockets. (I think we're 144 00:09:09,140 --> 00:09:38,068 going to discuss later on for commodity curve.) You know, there's 145 00:06:39,197 --> 00:07:34,564 a good question as to whether commodity curve is in a mean reversion 146 00:07:34,564 --> 00:08:29,931 kind of dynamic at the moment. So, these are more like smaller pockets 147 00:08:29,931 --> 00:09:25,298 of expressing a macro view, to my point in the beginning. So, that's 148 00:09:25,298 --> 00:09:38,075 what we're seeing. But, you know, I would say, you know, quite 149 00:09:18,941 --> 00:09:38,110 busy. 150 00:09:38,110 --> 00:09:51,448 What I forgot to ask, last time we were speaking (it's one of 151 00:09:51,448 --> 00:10:02,734 the questions left over), from a broader perspective, I'd be interested 152 00:10:02,734 --> 00:10:12,994 whether you see across your business any cyclicality in client 153 00:10:12,994 --> 00:10:14,020 interest? Are there bursts of interests when, you know, risk is 154 00:09:43,720 --> 00:09:51,574 on, or risk is off and they want to hedge, or does it correlate 155 00:09:51,574 --> 00:09:59,989 with a bull market in the S&P 500, or is it more like a constant 156 00:09:59,989 --> 00:10:05,599 flow of interest, and also then transactions where it's kind 157 00:10:05,599 --> 00:10:11,770 of like, yeah, we're doing deals every month no matter what 158 00:10:11,770 --> 00:10:14,014 the markets are doing? 159 00:10:14,930 --> 00:10:47,942 So, there is cyclicality in the interest, but I would say there 160 00:10:47,942 --> 00:11:12,701 is, generally, stable flow of conversations and activity, which 161 00:11:12,701 --> 00:11:45,713 is obviously a good thing for the overall industry. But the thematics, 162 00:11:45,713 --> 00:12:18,725 or maybe (I'm going to maybe again repeat myself) the macro views 163 00:12:18,725 --> 00:12:46,235 that investors have could be expressed with a systematic solution. 164 00:12:46,235 --> 00:12:59,990 So, QIS becomes the vehicle. So, to your point, if there is a 165 00:10:25,930 --> 00:10:41,055 risk of mindset, you'll see more of a defensive tilting either 166 00:10:41,055 --> 00:10:56,180 of portfolios, or reduction of risk on the exposures, or deploying 167 00:10:56,180 --> 00:11:14,055 some defensive components to it. If the mindset is more of a recovery 168 00:11:14,055 --> 00:11:29,180 or maybe normalization, you would see a bit more volatility selling, 169 00:11:29,180 --> 00:11:45,680 maybe some carry trades. And less so, you’re kind of seeing, as 170 00:11:45,680 --> 00:12:04,930 I said earlier on, the vehicle that will do the job no matter what, 171 00:12:04,930 --> 00:12:20,055 like the alpha engine, you still have those needs every now 172 00:12:20,055 --> 00:12:36,555 and then. But the cyclicality, I would say, comes and goes more 173 00:12:36,555 --> 00:12:51,680 with the macro dynamics and then the QIS solutions just become 174 00:12:51,680 --> 00:12:59,930 the vehicles to express those views. Maybe the one thing that I 175 00:10:30,908 --> 00:11:00,201 personally keep on using as an anecdote is that, specifically, when 176 00:11:00,201 --> 00:11:26,831 it comes to defensiveness, you end up seeing, broadly speaking, 177 00:11:26,831 --> 00:11:58,787 an act of regret and a reactive function rather than a proactive. 178 00:11:58,787 --> 00:12:28,080 So, for instance, we can speak about trend following because in 179 00:12:28,080 --> 00:12:57,373 2018 in Volmageddon it did not perform, obviously, because of the 180 00:12:57,373 --> 00:13:00,036 reversion. 2020 Wasn't a stellar year, at least during COVID. 181 00:10:28,196 --> 00:10:47,358 And the reaction there was, how about we know, and we end up 182 00:10:47,358 --> 00:11:02,098 buying some volatility as a defensive component. And then, obviously, 183 00:11:02,098 --> 00:11:19,786 2022 came about that you had the spot down/vol down, long vol 184 00:11:19,786 --> 00:11:33,052 did not deliver, trend following did. But obviously the 185 00:11:33,052 --> 00:11:49,266 macro environment was the one for trend following to deliver. So, 186 00:11:49,266 --> 00:12:09,902 then post 2022 you kind of had the reverse. Okay, long vol was not 187 00:12:09,902 --> 00:12:27,590 the defensive trade. At least for this market let's go back into 188 00:12:27,590 --> 00:12:42,330 trend following. But then some disappointment came because of some 189 00:12:42,330 --> 00:13:00,018 of the V shapes we've seen in the last couple of years. So, I think 190 00:10:21,278 --> 00:10:44,554 this act of regret is not necessarily healthy from a product 191 00:10:44,554 --> 00:11:03,598 design standpoint when it comes to managing those portfolios. 192 00:11:03,598 --> 00:11:31,106 So, if there's one thing that, you know, we typically try to bring 193 00:11:31,106 --> 00:11:54,382 forward is that specifically for some of those pockets of more 194 00:11:54,382 --> 00:12:15,542 strategic views it's not, let's follow what did well yesterday, 195 00:12:15,542 --> 00:12:43,050 but rather it's kind of take a step back, see what we're solving 196 00:12:43,050 --> 00:12:59,978 for and strategically kind of allocate to it. So, that's maybe 197 00:10:30,407 --> 00:11:27,156 the only one that, in addition to the cyclicality, somebody should 198 00:11:27,156 --> 00:12:23,905 argue maybe let's let the cyclicality alone take a step back, 199 00:12:23,905 --> 00:13:00,018 assess and allocate on a strategic basis. 200 00:13:00,360 --> 00:13:01,800 Could be easier said than done. 201 00:13:02,600 --> 00:13:05,264 Absolutely, absolutely. And, you know, nobody has an infinite 202 00:13:05,264 --> 00:13:08,224 horizon of investment, and everyone is assessed on the basis 203 00:13:08,224 --> 00:13:11,184 of performance. So, obviously carry risk is a key consideration 204 00:13:11,184 --> 00:13:14,440 here that is not easily quantifiable. So, I'm with you on 205 00:13:14,440 --> 00:13:15,328 this one 100%. 206 00:13:15,360 --> 00:13:34,031 As you mentioned, we're going to be speaking about commodity curve 207 00:13:34,031 --> 00:13:53,231 carry and how it has done in the recent environment. But before 208 00:13:53,231 --> 00:14:12,431 we go there, and then also into some other details, I'd like 209 00:14:12,431 --> 00:14:31,631 to bring up a very interesting article that I found, written by 210 00:14:31,631 --> 00:14:50,831 Greg Zuckerman from the Wall Street Journal. I think it was published 211 00:14:50,831 --> 00:15:14,831 about a month or so ago, on 20 April, and its title is, Wall Street 212 00:15:14,831 --> 00:15:26,031 Brings Sophisticated Quant Strategies to the Masses. So, let 213 00:13:19,517 --> 00:13:38,033 me, maybe within a minute or so, frame the discussion and let 214 00:13:38,033 --> 00:13:56,549 me cite some interesting parts from that article. Here we go. Quantitative 215 00:13:56,549 --> 00:14:11,979 investment strategies for clients are one of JP Morgan's fastest 216 00:14:11,979 --> 00:14:28,952 growing businesses. The bank has seen QIS revenue rise 30% so 217 00:14:28,952 --> 00:14:47,468 far this year from the same period in 2025, according to people 218 00:14:47,468 --> 00:15:05,984 close to the matter. That is an acceleration from the 25% growth 219 00:15:05,984 --> 00:15:24,500 seen in recent years, making it one of JP Morgan's fastest growing 220 00:15:24,500 --> 00:15:26,043 businesses. Goldman Sachs Asset Management (so that is related 221 00:13:34,623 --> 00:13:59,637 to you) for instance, now manages about US$175 billion in quantitative 222 00:13:59,637 --> 00:14:22,377 investment strategy funds, which equates to about 5% of GSAM's 223 00:14:22,377 --> 00:14:38,295 overall assets under management. According to Premier 224 00:14:38,295 --> 00:15:07,857 Lab, the overall size of the QIS space is now about US$1 trillion 225 00:15:07,857 --> 00:15:26,049 and about US$3 trillion when you include leverage. And either 226 00:13:19,935 --> 00:13:40,959 way, the profits are piling up for the banks, which charge investors 227 00:13:40,959 --> 00:14:00,231 depending on the complexity of their trades, QIS revenue is nearly 228 00:14:00,231 --> 00:14:17,751 risk free (something, by the way, I wouldn't necessarily agree 229 00:14:17,751 --> 00:14:38,775 with, but let me continue). QIS revenue is nearly risk free and 230 00:14:38,775 --> 00:14:56,295 generally reliable. Since the trades are preset, banks don't have 231 00:14:56,295 --> 00:15:17,319 to set aside as much capital for these trades relative to other 232 00:15:17,319 --> 00:15:26,079 kinds of businesses they're doing. So let me stop there. Just 233 00:13:31,989 --> 00:13:57,919 some background. This was an interesting article about the QIS 234 00:13:57,919 --> 00:14:26,442 space, I thought, because it continues with pros and cons, but 235 00:14:26,442 --> 00:14:57,558 it kind of like looked at the space from a different perspective, 236 00:14:57,558 --> 00:15:26,081 I thought. Is there anything you'd like to add to this? 237 00:15:28,321 --> 00:15:40,471 I mean, QIS, as an industry, has been receiving progressively 238 00:15:40,471 --> 00:15:53,836 more visibility. Right? It's not the first time that there is 239 00:15:53,836 --> 00:16:07,201 an article in, if you like, broader interest media and that, 240 00:16:07,201 --> 00:16:20,566 in itself, is a data point that is worth obviously observing 241 00:16:20,566 --> 00:16:31,501 and acknowledging. You know, some of those articles obviously 242 00:16:31,501 --> 00:16:48,511 come with catchy titles in one way or the other. And now I wouldn't 243 00:16:48,511 --> 00:17:04,306 be able to comment too much on that, otherwise we'd have to make 244 00:17:04,306 --> 00:17:09,166 sure that everything exactly… I don't want to make any specific 245 00:15:35,671 --> 00:15:47,221 presentation here beyond the fact that it is a solution that, 246 00:15:47,221 --> 00:15:59,821 in itself, has become of broader use because of the use of 247 00:15:59,821 --> 00:16:09,271 technology, and data, and trading capabilities. At the end 248 00:16:09,271 --> 00:16:22,921 of the day, banks do sit in the middle of buyers and sellers. 249 00:16:22,921 --> 00:16:31,321 They have the ability, historically, to deliver portfolios 250 00:16:31,321 --> 00:16:41,821 of stocks, or commodity futures, or tradable assets, in a 251 00:16:41,821 --> 00:16:54,421 variety of formats. And I think the benefit of having a bank 252 00:16:54,421 --> 00:17:05,971 operating a QIS business is that there is also a structuring 253 00:17:05,971 --> 00:17:09,121 pedigree underlying it. So, something we discussed, I believe, 254 00:15:37,633 --> 00:15:56,257 last time is that those profiles can be delivered in a call 255 00:15:56,257 --> 00:16:14,881 option, in a capital protected structure, in an OTC swap. So, the 256 00:16:14,881 --> 00:16:35,057 access to it has become easier over the years. Some of those articles 257 00:16:35,057 --> 00:16:55,233 obviously come up and say the place is crowded. I mean, my response 258 00:16:55,233 --> 00:17:09,201 to it is that it's always the easy way. 259 00:17:10,321 --> 00:17:11,201 Let me stop you there. 260 00:17:11,201 --> 00:17:13,910 Trend following has the same problem historically, right? It's 261 00:17:13,910 --> 00:17:16,920 always crowded, right? It's always like, let's point the finger. 262 00:17:16,921 --> 00:17:33,169 Because there's pros and cons. And I thought the article was actually 263 00:17:33,169 --> 00:17:49,417 quite balanced and well done because it does cover the pros and 264 00:17:49,417 --> 00:18:05,665 cons. And so, the pros, or the advantages mentioned are, for instance 265 00:18:05,665 --> 00:18:17,851 (I'm citing again from the article) for institutional investors 266 00:18:17,851 --> 00:18:25,975 and allocators, QIS are very convenient. It's outsourced infrastructure 267 00:17:19,720 --> 00:17:27,184 is essentially quant as a service. Bespoke implementations 268 00:17:27,184 --> 00:17:34,648 are possible. They're operationally easy to access through 269 00:17:34,648 --> 00:17:44,911 swaps and other wrappers like you've mentioned. You know, you have 270 00:17:44,911 --> 00:17:57,040 this easy go-to point to get the exposure that you want or maybe 271 00:17:57,040 --> 00:18:07,303 the hedge that you want and you have it, essentially, outsourced 272 00:18:07,303 --> 00:18:19,432 to some other trading desk and you don't have to do it yourself. 273 00:18:19,432 --> 00:18:25,963 And so, this is the good thing. The cons or the disadvantages, 274 00:17:23,086 --> 00:17:34,183 the potential disadvantages that were mentioned are that the 275 00:17:34,183 --> 00:17:45,280 flows may result in crowding and synchronized positioning. In 276 00:17:45,280 --> 00:17:57,610 practice, many bank QIS offerings look very similar, if not 277 00:17:57,610 --> 00:18:07,474 identical, and they often provide overlapping exposures. Too 278 00:18:07,474 --> 00:18:21,037 many investors doing the same trades can reduce the potential for 279 00:18:21,037 --> 00:18:25,969 profits. It's probably true. 280 00:18:26,501 --> 00:18:56,421 I mean, I would say that's a textbook definition of crowding. 281 00:18:56,421 --> 00:19:26,341 So, I don't think it's delivering anything new that we did 282 00:19:26,341 --> 00:19:50,821 not know. I would say, from designing systematic strategies, 283 00:19:50,821 --> 00:20:28,901 whether we sit on the buy side or the sell side, ultimately it is 284 00:20:28,901 --> 00:21:01,541 very important to be prudent on risk management and on how we 285 00:21:01,541 --> 00:21:09,701 consume market liquidity. So, from that perspective, of course 286 00:18:38,297 --> 00:19:03,855 we can have the argument that there is more demand. But I guess, 287 00:19:03,855 --> 00:19:25,481 to the extent that somebody approaches the design of a strategy 288 00:19:25,481 --> 00:19:49,073 or an investment in a prudent manner, they should account for incremental 289 00:19:49,073 --> 00:20:10,699 flows into a specific premium or overlap of positions between different 290 00:20:10,699 --> 00:20:38,223 strategies. And then we tend to think, or I tend to think of looking 291 00:20:38,223 --> 00:21:03,781 at the flow as a whole rather than strategy by strategy in isolation. 292 00:21:03,781 --> 00:21:09,679 So that's important. Obviously, the externalities are 293 00:18:39,825 --> 00:19:19,797 there and can be there, but it's not dissimilar to any other 294 00:19:19,797 --> 00:19:53,107 investment type. It can be a discretionary call that delivers 295 00:19:53,107 --> 00:20:29,748 too much concentration. It can be inflow into private equity markets, 296 00:20:29,748 --> 00:21:06,389 for instance. Anything that has excess demand can lead to subdued 297 00:21:06,389 --> 00:21:09,720 returns. So, the question then becomes, is the market deep enough 298 00:18:46,901 --> 00:19:11,381 to consume the demand? And that is something that we, on the 299 00:19:11,381 --> 00:19:33,821 design side, have to be very, very focused on, obviously working 300 00:19:33,821 --> 00:19:52,181 with trading very closely. That's something we would always 301 00:19:52,181 --> 00:20:16,661 monitor and make sure that if a particular feature in the market 302 00:20:16,661 --> 00:20:43,181 seems to be crowded out, then we should make sure that we look 303 00:20:43,181 --> 00:21:09,701 at our design better or maybe we have a conversation with our clients. 304 00:18:26,501 --> 00:18:53,699 And, frankly speaking, these are all sophisticated investors looking 305 00:18:53,699 --> 00:19:23,919 into sophisticated designs. And this whole exercise is more than 306 00:19:23,919 --> 00:19:51,117 just, oh, here's like a supermarket of possibilities. Let 307 00:19:51,117 --> 00:20:33,425 me just get one or two because they've had a good backtest. I think 308 00:20:33,425 --> 00:21:00,623 the industry has matured substantially to design and assess 309 00:21:00,623 --> 00:21:09,689 those investment vehicles. And, you know, the last thing that 310 00:18:40,606 --> 00:19:06,801 I would also flag is that this flow that arguably has been growing, 311 00:19:06,801 --> 00:19:35,011 part of it is genuinely new, but part of it is also a replacement 312 00:19:35,011 --> 00:20:03,221 one. So, if I were to say that there is a trend following strategy, 313 00:20:03,221 --> 00:20:23,371 sometimes it could be a replacement of a different strategy, 314 00:20:23,371 --> 00:20:47,551 or a CTA exposure, or vice versa. And this is never quantifiable 315 00:20:47,551 --> 00:21:09,716 because it's impossible to track it down. So, that is another… 316 00:21:09,731 --> 00:21:11,009 …the right, pockets… 317 00:21:11,011 --> 00:21:14,451 Precisely. And that was also how this business, broadly speaking, 318 00:21:14,451 --> 00:21:18,235 as an industry, came about; what could be systematized and what 319 00:21:18,235 --> 00:21:23,051 is the value of systematizing a process vis a vis, a more of a 320 00:21:23,051 --> 00:21:25,803 discretionary kind of allocation. I'm not sure whether 321 00:21:25,803 --> 00:21:29,931 I'm answering any question, but I don't think there is a specific 322 00:21:29,931 --> 00:21:34,403 question to be answered more than kind of giving my kind of remarks 323 00:21:34,403 --> 00:21:35,435 on this one. 324 00:21:35,461 --> 00:21:40,103 I mean, it's a generality, like you say, the textbook definition. 325 00:21:40,103 --> 00:21:45,167 Too much money thrown at any one thing will destroy or impact, 326 00:21:45,167 --> 00:21:46,855 decay, its return potential. 327 00:21:46,861 --> 00:21:47,181 Right. 328 00:21:47,181 --> 00:21:51,575 We can see this in all sorts of strategies. QIS should not be 329 00:21:51,575 --> 00:21:55,969 any different. I have no reason to back it up. But when you 330 00:21:55,969 --> 00:22:00,025 look at some of the, say, more niche QIS strategies, say, liquidity 331 00:22:00,025 --> 00:22:04,081 provision to the BCOM or GSEI role window, maybe there is some 332 00:22:04,081 --> 00:22:08,475 decay that you can spot. Maybe there is too much money chasing these 333 00:22:08,475 --> 00:22:12,869 opportunities. I do not know. You know that better than I do. But 334 00:22:12,869 --> 00:22:16,249 clearly there are impacts. It doesn't go without side effects. 335 00:22:17,521 --> 00:22:42,517 That's why I think it's very important to look through the details 336 00:22:42,517 --> 00:23:05,430 and understand the driving force of any strategy. So, you mentioned 337 00:23:05,430 --> 00:23:24,177 congestion. It's actually very good example. So, congestion shouldn't 338 00:23:24,177 --> 00:23:36,675 be there in the first place. In other words, there should be no 339 00:22:22,295 --> 00:22:29,797 reason why somebody is rewarded of pre or post rolling those 340 00:22:29,797 --> 00:22:37,299 commodity futures, aside from the fact that there is perhaps some 341 00:22:37,299 --> 00:22:43,437 passive demand for those benchmark rolls because they happen 342 00:22:43,437 --> 00:22:50,257 to belong to commodity benchmarks. So, if the market operates 343 00:22:50,257 --> 00:22:58,441 in a way that is creating an opportunity that can be harvested, 344 00:22:58,441 --> 00:23:05,943 it's actually the reverse that there is an arbitrage that should 345 00:23:05,943 --> 00:23:13,445 be there. It is purely a consequence of supply and demand 346 00:23:13,445 --> 00:23:21,629 imbalance. And obviously the more of that you do, the less of 347 00:23:21,629 --> 00:23:27,767 the performance you should expect to have precisely because 348 00:23:27,767 --> 00:23:33,905 you're capitalizing on an arbitrage that shouldn't be there 349 00:23:33,905 --> 00:23:36,633 in the first place. This is very different to arguing that selling 350 00:22:26,697 --> 00:22:37,020 volatility, for instance, could wipe out the premium. Perhaps 351 00:22:37,020 --> 00:22:49,637 the magnitude can drop but nobody could argue that being on 352 00:22:49,637 --> 00:23:03,401 the side of the insurer is now, if you like, a non-rewarded 353 00:23:03,401 --> 00:23:13,724 trade unless somehow human beings become risk loving rather 354 00:23:13,724 --> 00:23:26,341 than risk averse. But last time I checked, those utility functions 355 00:23:26,341 --> 00:23:36,664 remain to being upward and concave rather than convex. 356 00:23:36,791 --> 00:23:38,391 You don't sell insurance for free. 357 00:23:38,551 --> 00:23:49,601 Exactly right. So, I think from that perspective the crowding 358 00:23:49,601 --> 00:24:02,861 argument is perhaps an input into the time variation of risk premia. 359 00:24:02,861 --> 00:24:16,121 But could that be a reason for the wiping out? It depends. And the 360 00:23:40,341 --> 00:23:50,186 dependence has to go to the underlying reason why a Specific 361 00:23:50,186 --> 00:23:59,136 investment philosophy has been successful. And if there's an underlying 362 00:23:59,136 --> 00:24:08,086 source of risk that is captured and delivered, the reward 363 00:24:08,086 --> 00:24:16,141 for it should be non-negative more often than not. So, that's, 364 00:23:41,235 --> 00:24:00,023 that's how we kind of look at it and that's how we typically approach 365 00:24:00,023 --> 00:24:16,127 it, or I approach it in my research kind of focus areas. 366 00:24:16,631 --> 00:24:40,237 Very well, the quote that I thought was most interesting (and 367 00:24:40,237 --> 00:25:10,281 then we can move on), but this one I thought was really good. So, 368 00:25:10,281 --> 00:25:18,865 let me read that. Aggressive hedge funds have been trying to profit 369 00:24:23,951 --> 00:24:33,101 from the growth of QIS programs by anticipating their traits, 370 00:24:33,101 --> 00:24:43,166 says Arnab Sen, who used to develop QIS products at Barclays 371 00:24:43,166 --> 00:24:52,316 before joining Paloma Partners as a portfolio manager. These funds 372 00:24:52,316 --> 00:25:03,296 try to act before the QIS programs can, resulting in a cat 373 00:25:03,296 --> 00:25:13,361 and mouse game that can cause unusual movements in various investments. 374 00:25:13,361 --> 00:25:18,851 It exacerbates moves in the market. This was the first time I 375 00:24:21,815 --> 00:24:32,183 heard that hedge funds may be front running the QIS trigger trades. 376 00:24:32,183 --> 00:24:43,415 And I'm not sure how they can even… Most of your index methodologies, 377 00:24:43,415 --> 00:24:52,919 you don't have the full detail. You can't just download them 378 00:24:52,919 --> 00:25:04,151 on the Internet and find out what exactly is going on. I think 379 00:25:04,151 --> 00:25:11,927 you have some redacted versions, but the full technicalities 380 00:25:11,927 --> 00:25:18,839 aren't usually in the public domain, are they? 381 00:25:20,491 --> 00:25:41,581 I mean obviously part of that is part of the IAP and it's not too 382 00:25:41,581 --> 00:25:58,453 dissimilar to how a hedge fund would operate in this regard. Right? 383 00:25:58,453 --> 00:26:12,513 So, obviously there are details that matter and the importance 384 00:26:12,513 --> 00:26:22,355 of those details ultimately protect the investor. We owe to deliver 385 00:25:24,911 --> 00:25:38,171 what we feel is to be delivered. And in this regard, part 386 00:25:38,171 --> 00:25:51,431 of the IAP has to remain with those that, you know, eventually 387 00:25:51,431 --> 00:26:05,796 allocate to it. Now, could we argue that, you know, we can front 388 00:26:05,796 --> 00:26:16,846 run any strategy? I mean, again, that's a textbook design. 389 00:26:16,846 --> 00:26:22,371 Right? It's a textbook assumption. So, I don't know specifically 390 00:25:24,086 --> 00:25:33,433 what comment I could make on this one beyond the fact that, you 391 00:25:33,433 --> 00:25:42,780 know, it's put on a piece of like electronic paper. It could be 392 00:25:42,780 --> 00:25:53,565 the case and could not be the case at the same time. Like I think 393 00:25:53,565 --> 00:26:05,788 it can easily be put down as a claim in the same way as we can say, 394 00:26:05,788 --> 00:26:14,416 you know, CTA's have been crowded for the last 15 years and 395 00:26:14,416 --> 00:26:22,325 therefore that's part of the reason for sometimes a good performance. 396 00:26:23,491 --> 00:26:48,907 Maybe we should reach out to Paloma Partners. And Arnab Sen, specifically, 397 00:26:48,907 --> 00:27:20,677 and ask him to show the P&L of his front run QIS trades, see how 398 00:27:20,677 --> 00:27:46,093 it's doing, but my guess is he's going to decline the invitation. 399 00:26:23,491 --> 00:26:30,551 Anyway, let's leave that article from the Wall Street Journal 400 00:26:30,551 --> 00:26:38,317 aside and move on and speak about commodity curve carry, which 401 00:26:38,317 --> 00:26:48,201 we agreed to do in our pre call. The reason we wanted to speak 402 00:26:48,201 --> 00:26:56,673 about this is because it's one of the QIS strategies that, shall 403 00:26:56,673 --> 00:27:05,145 we say, has suffered some damage this year in light of the 404 00:27:05,145 --> 00:27:10,793 curve dynamics and the substantial increase in volatility 405 00:27:10,793 --> 00:27:16,441 in commodity markets across the board. Especially, obviously, 406 00:27:16,441 --> 00:27:24,207 in the energy markets where we've seen, if not record backwardation, 407 00:27:24,207 --> 00:27:31,973 but then close to record backwardation in WTI and rent curve 408 00:27:31,973 --> 00:27:41,151 shifts in a very rapid period of time, very short period of time, 409 00:27:41,151 --> 00:27:46,093 which has, I presume, caused some drawdowns. So, why don't we 410 00:26:30,523 --> 00:26:46,345 just… or, Nick, you specifically, why don't you just, 411 00:26:46,345 --> 00:27:03,925 you know, report, from a broader perspective, how these strategies 412 00:27:03,925 --> 00:27:26,779 have done, how bad the damage is, what the outlook is, why these 413 00:27:26,779 --> 00:27:46,117 strategies work. I mean, take it where you want to go. 414 00:27:47,651 --> 00:28:50,327 So, commodity curve is probably the most long-standing systematic 415 00:28:50,327 --> 00:30:06,931 strategy that has been designed in a QIS format. You know, 416 00:30:06,931 --> 00:30:48,715 it probably goes back 15 years. I guess, for those that are 417 00:27:59,993 --> 00:28:26,734 not very much aware, just a very brief intro. This is about rolling 418 00:28:26,734 --> 00:28:51,418 commodity futures exposures on the back end of the curve and shorting 419 00:28:51,418 --> 00:29:14,045 the front. Typically, the front is very steep in a contango 420 00:29:14,045 --> 00:29:38,729 shape and therefore the roll yield is very expensive. So, by shorting 421 00:29:38,729 --> 00:30:03,413 the front you end up kind of getting a differential yield versus 422 00:30:03,413 --> 00:30:26,040 rolling the back. So, this differential return of the back versus 423 00:30:26,040 --> 00:30:46,610 the front across commodity markets is what we call commodity 424 00:30:46,610 --> 00:30:48,667 curve. It's a carry trade and ultimately tries to achieve the yield 425 00:28:28,296 --> 00:29:12,636 differential from those roles, on the back and the front. And that 426 00:29:12,636 --> 00:29:49,586 is done across a variety of commodities. The benchmark universe 427 00:29:49,586 --> 00:30:37,621 of BCOM as well as kind of more frontier markets are now utilized 428 00:30:37,621 --> 00:30:48,706 for those trades. What is the primary risk here? The primary risk 429 00:28:07,766 --> 00:28:34,586 here is that by you shorting the closest to be delivered contract, 430 00:28:34,586 --> 00:28:59,171 you are exposed to what we call shift into a backwardation, 431 00:28:59,171 --> 00:29:23,756 which in layman's terms means that a commodity market with close 432 00:29:23,756 --> 00:29:48,341 to spot delivery is going to rally substantially. In other words, 433 00:29:48,341 --> 00:30:17,396 for a commodity to rally in the very short term, it's more likely 434 00:30:17,396 --> 00:30:48,686 that there is too much of a demand or too little of a supply. 435 00:27:47,651 --> 00:28:20,299 And most of the times commodity prices would shoot up because 436 00:28:20,299 --> 00:28:52,947 there's a supply shock. And that's exactly what happened in March. 437 00:28:52,947 --> 00:29:25,595 Obviously, with the situation in the Middle East, and the Strait 438 00:29:25,595 --> 00:30:07,147 of Hormuz, and all that lot, the price of oil (as you just said, 439 00:30:07,147 --> 00:30:33,859 Moritz) skyrocketed. So those curve positions that were shorting 440 00:30:33,859 --> 00:30:48,699 the front were significantly impacted. I should add to that that 441 00:27:58,511 --> 00:28:14,801 year-to-date performance has also had another catalyst that didn't 442 00:28:14,801 --> 00:28:36,521 actually recover from it, and that was the kind of natural gas 443 00:28:36,521 --> 00:28:56,431 moves in January. So, that was (for those that remember), there 444 00:28:56,431 --> 00:29:18,151 was like a weekend or so that the weather forecast became much 445 00:29:18,151 --> 00:29:43,491 more kind of negative in the US and at the time the demand for 446 00:29:43,491 --> 00:29:59,781 natural gas actually increased in anticipation of cold weather. 447 00:29:59,781 --> 00:30:23,311 So, that had the first kind of negative kicker into a curve strategy 448 00:30:23,311 --> 00:30:35,981 that obviously became significantly greater coming into 449 00:30:35,981 --> 00:30:48,651 kind of March, to your earlier point. So, drawdown was quite significant. 450 00:28:08,706 --> 00:28:59,238 So, if you look into kind of simple implementations of a curve 451 00:28:59,238 --> 00:29:45,559 strategy, I know we're talking about something like 10% for instance. 452 00:29:45,559 --> 00:30:36,091 And this is certainly the largest we have seen since, you know, 453 00:30:36,091 --> 00:30:48,724 we have data. 454 00:30:50,011 --> 00:30:53,911 Is this the largest ever, the worst drawdown for these type of 455 00:30:53,911 --> 00:30:54,886 strategies right now? 456 00:30:55,691 --> 00:31:00,031 It is indeed, let's say, for the last 40 years. And if you were 457 00:31:00,031 --> 00:31:04,061 to kind of focus on the most recent period is possibly two times 458 00:31:04,061 --> 00:31:08,091 the largest we have seen so far. I think the previous one was 459 00:31:08,091 --> 00:31:08,711 in 2018. 460 00:31:09,291 --> 00:31:10,011 Quite significant. 461 00:31:10,491 --> 00:33:06,113 So, it is quite significant. And 2018 was more of a natural gas 462 00:33:06,113 --> 00:33:15,007 shock. What I should say is that, because the drawdown came from 463 00:31:28,278 --> 00:31:47,682 a very well understood move, that in itself is the number one 464 00:31:47,682 --> 00:32:08,703 risk factor when it comes to a curve carry trade possibly will connect 465 00:32:08,703 --> 00:32:29,724 it to the earlier point that there is no arbitrage here that is 466 00:32:29,724 --> 00:32:49,128 to be captured at no risk. There is an underlying source of 467 00:32:49,128 --> 00:33:06,915 risk for which investors are rewarded. Yes, the drawdown has been 468 00:33:06,915 --> 00:33:15,000 quite significant, by all means. I would say historically most 469 00:31:14,641 --> 00:31:24,601 of the drawdowns have come either by weather shocks, to my earlier 470 00:31:24,601 --> 00:31:34,561 point, or from some sort of supply disruptions or like some outages 471 00:31:34,561 --> 00:31:42,031 or some geopolitical conflicts. And it looks quite similar 472 00:31:42,031 --> 00:31:52,821 to 2022. We had a similar situation in Q1, 2022, but at the 473 00:31:52,821 --> 00:32:01,951 time the impact of the move was less aggressive because, you 474 00:32:01,951 --> 00:32:11,911 know, if you remember it came obviously from Russian oil. It was 475 00:32:11,911 --> 00:32:18,551 initially sanctions and then obviously self-imposed by Russia 476 00:32:18,551 --> 00:32:28,511 themselves kind of cutting, if you like, the supply chain. But also, 477 00:32:28,511 --> 00:32:39,301 the production that was kind of controlled at the time was a fraction 478 00:32:39,301 --> 00:32:48,431 of the one that we're currently kind of facing. So, the 479 00:32:48,431 --> 00:32:57,561 Impact was smoother through time and less aggressive on the downside. 480 00:32:57,561 --> 00:33:05,861 But that's maybe the closest in terms of fundamental dynamics 481 00:33:05,861 --> 00:33:14,991 of a drawdown to the one we're kind of experiencing today. And I 482 00:31:15,373 --> 00:31:42,224 think maybe a bit more technically now, not only the Russia 483 00:31:42,224 --> 00:32:06,634 situation was easier because of those dynamics, but because it 484 00:32:06,634 --> 00:32:35,926 was slower, you ended up kind of benefiting from a slight recovery. 485 00:32:35,926 --> 00:33:00,336 Whereas now, because you're rolling out of the current contract, 486 00:33:00,336 --> 00:33:14,982 you're almost crystallizing the negative P&L. It's a bit more 487 00:31:22,347 --> 00:31:57,915 of a technicality. But the way that the impact into the strategy 488 00:31:57,915 --> 00:32:33,483 happened, back then versus now, had less of an effect as it 489 00:32:33,483 --> 00:33:14,979 had today. So, I can pause here if you have any points to make. 490 00:33:15,891 --> 00:33:21,449 Well, is this a good time to buy? Well, that is not the question 491 00:33:21,449 --> 00:33:26,610 you're going to answer but let me rephrase it. Or maybe you will 492 00:33:26,610 --> 00:33:31,374 answer it because there tends to be some mean reversion to this. 493 00:33:31,374 --> 00:33:36,138 Or I would have rephrased it and said, are clients calling you 494 00:33:36,138 --> 00:33:41,299 now to redeem and get out of the strategy because they can't stand 495 00:33:41,299 --> 00:33:46,063 the pain, they have that 10% drawdown, as you mentioned in that 496 00:33:46,063 --> 00:33:49,239 naive implementation or whatever implementation it is, there 497 00:33:49,239 --> 00:33:53,606 is going to be some drawdown that is certainly inconvenient and 498 00:33:53,606 --> 00:33:57,973 it's very large relative or the largest relative to the history 499 00:33:57,973 --> 00:33:59,164 of the strategy? Or are they more like, well, this is a great 500 00:33:29,851 --> 00:33:46,603 time to buy because it's now probably, or it might be relatively 501 00:33:46,603 --> 00:33:59,167 cheap now, relative to the return expectation going forward. 502 00:34:00,371 --> 00:34:39,695 So, there are two things I would say. So, curve carry, historically, 503 00:34:39,695 --> 00:35:12,465 was the driving force of systematic strategies in the commodity 504 00:35:12,465 --> 00:35:55,066 space. But in the year of 2026, there are other ways of extracting 505 00:35:55,066 --> 00:36:27,836 some positive returns from the commodity markets which have allowed 506 00:36:27,836 --> 00:37:03,883 the investor base looking into the space of diversifying the exposure 507 00:37:03,883 --> 00:37:20,268 across other types of premia. And, you know, why I'm saying that 508 00:34:17,857 --> 00:34:42,837 is because the benefit of having diversifying sources of return 509 00:34:42,837 --> 00:35:12,813 in a portfolio context allows you to weather quite well the period 510 00:35:12,813 --> 00:35:42,789 through March. And, I would say, perhaps because of that or perhaps 511 00:35:42,789 --> 00:36:07,769 because it's very well understood that this is the risk 512 00:36:07,769 --> 00:36:35,247 and therefore we're exposed to it and we're experiencing it, the 513 00:36:35,247 --> 00:37:02,725 reaction from the market has been much less aggressive than what 514 00:37:02,725 --> 00:37:20,211 was the case a few years back. So, I would say, in this regard, 515 00:34:22,939 --> 00:35:01,627 there is more of patience in the sense that a recovery phase, 516 00:35:01,627 --> 00:35:33,867 which would bring prices down, will make the strategy benefiting 517 00:35:33,867 --> 00:36:12,555 from it and will benefit the strategy from it both because of 518 00:36:12,555 --> 00:36:54,467 the yield differential on the front of the back and the spot movement 519 00:36:54,467 --> 00:37:20,259 that is going to happen on the front. Now, is that the right time 520 00:34:17,027 --> 00:34:50,339 to enter? My claim would be that, obviously, in the very short-term 521 00:34:50,339 --> 00:35:18,099 risk is still there. The situation is unresolved. And, as 522 00:35:18,099 --> 00:35:54,187 you said in the beginning, it is the theme that we're looking day-after-day 523 00:35:54,187 --> 00:36:30,275 where the oil price is going to go. And sometimes it shoots up, 524 00:36:30,275 --> 00:37:03,587 sometimes it shoots down. But the news is driving the price more 525 00:37:03,587 --> 00:37:20,243 so than the supply demand dynamics. So, I think there's much 526 00:34:16,236 --> 00:34:54,312 more of an implicit impact into the oil price itself. But I 527 00:34:54,312 --> 00:35:29,215 should say there is certainly a future to the strategy. There's 528 00:35:29,215 --> 00:35:57,772 nothing fundamentally harmed by a risk realization. Of course, 529 00:35:57,772 --> 00:36:35,848 at the same time, you can have investors that hit specific risk 530 00:36:35,848 --> 00:37:13,924 limits and that can cause, in itself, a downsize. I mean that's 531 00:37:13,924 --> 00:37:20,270 by design. But as you said, to summarize, I should say that client 532 00:34:19,995 --> 00:34:37,835 reaction has been relatively similar to what I have personally 533 00:34:37,835 --> 00:35:01,027 seen in the trend following space in the last few years. We know 534 00:35:01,027 --> 00:35:18,867 what we're exposed to. The ultimate risk is realizing we're 535 00:35:18,867 --> 00:35:42,059 fine to take it because we're here to harvest the premium in the 536 00:35:42,059 --> 00:36:01,683 medium term. And it is, to marry your point, the strategies 537 00:36:01,683 --> 00:36:21,307 that, over the longer term, have had very strong and positive 538 00:36:21,307 --> 00:36:35,579 returns for commodities without necessarily decaying in the 539 00:36:35,579 --> 00:36:58,771 magnitude. And I think that also goes back to what are the principles 540 00:36:58,771 --> 00:37:20,179 that deliver the premium in the first place? Why is it there? 541 00:34:00,371 --> 00:34:22,140 The last point, I should say, is that implementation matters. There 542 00:34:22,140 --> 00:34:43,909 are implementations that beta heads the front and the back. There 543 00:34:43,909 --> 00:35:11,615 are others that are a bit more dynamic in the selection of the curve 544 00:35:11,615 --> 00:35:35,363 and the points of the curve that they would roll. Some implementations 545 00:35:35,363 --> 00:36:01,090 would bring you very close to the spot price, so you'd close the 546 00:36:01,090 --> 00:36:24,838 spread, so you're not exposed to the market anymore. Some of them 547 00:36:24,838 --> 00:36:52,544 would beta heads in front of the back, so they would be less impacted 548 00:36:52,544 --> 00:37:18,271 by the move because the front is more volatile, so you reduce your 549 00:37:18,271 --> 00:37:20,250 exposure. Maybe this is too technical now, but you get the point 550 00:35:45,080 --> 00:37:20,270 that there are variations that have actually been positive year-to-date. 551 00:37:21,081 --> 00:37:21,721 Oh really? 552 00:37:21,961 --> 00:37:28,961 Yes. Think about it. Let's do the most basic one of them all. If 553 00:37:28,961 --> 00:37:34,961 you are dynamic in the selection of the back, in a backwardation 554 00:37:34,961 --> 00:37:40,961 state, you'll come to the front. If you come to the front, 555 00:37:40,961 --> 00:37:46,461 you close the spread, so you're not exposed to the market 556 00:37:46,461 --> 00:37:52,461 anymore. And in that closing of the spread, if you're beta adjusting 557 00:37:52,461 --> 00:37:56,961 the front, you're even less exposed to the front. So, in this 558 00:37:24,247 --> 00:37:31,105 transition of closing the spread, you're also reducing the 559 00:37:31,105 --> 00:37:38,725 front exposure and then the whole thing is substantially more 560 00:37:38,725 --> 00:37:47,107 diluted than obviously being like, I'm long the F6, I'm short 561 00:37:47,107 --> 00:37:57,013 the F0, and I'm just stuck on it on a dollar neutral basis. 562 00:37:58,381 --> 00:38:00,221 Yeah. Or contract neutral basis. 563 00:38:00,781 --> 00:38:01,821 Correct, correct. 564 00:38:03,021 --> 00:38:12,767 Yeah, interesting. Look, I mean I don't have any detailed knowledge 565 00:38:12,767 --> 00:38:22,513 on this. I'm definitely not forecasting, but you know, the backwardation 566 00:38:22,513 --> 00:38:33,145 that we're seeing and Brent and WTI, I mean, it's insane. Yeah, 567 00:38:33,145 --> 00:38:44,663 but that does not mean that it couldn't get even more insane. I 568 00:38:44,663 --> 00:38:48,207 mean, this is markets. What is it, about US$20 now difference between 569 00:38:12,285 --> 00:38:25,023 front and whatever, like you know, 12 months out or something 570 00:38:25,023 --> 00:38:37,761 like that. So, roughly (I don't have the exact numbers), but, 571 00:38:37,761 --> 00:38:48,183 I mean, could it become US$40? Why not? Right? I mean, if there 572 00:38:08,185 --> 00:38:22,386 is a complete crisis, and people are like just scrambling for 573 00:38:22,386 --> 00:38:35,296 barrels, and there's this massive supply shock, and we don't 574 00:38:35,296 --> 00:38:48,206 have enough going around, the front can be bid up. 575 00:38:49,491 --> 00:38:54,099 I think the interesting thing is that in the current macro dynamic 576 00:38:54,099 --> 00:38:58,323 with obviously this shortage of supply that, you know, we observe, 577 00:38:58,323 --> 00:39:03,315 and it's in the hard data as well, there are some snippets of 578 00:39:03,315 --> 00:39:07,923 news that talk about how the production engine is now kind of 579 00:39:07,923 --> 00:39:11,763 almost like learning to operate with lower supply. So, it's 580 00:39:11,763 --> 00:39:15,987 a good question whether the market can absorb the shortage rather 581 00:39:15,987 --> 00:39:20,595 than the fundamental exposure that the economy has on it is just 582 00:39:20,595 --> 00:39:22,899 not static. It’s hard to quantify. 583 00:39:23,901 --> 00:39:28,927 Yeah, I did speak with an oil trader in the Middle East. He told 584 00:39:28,927 --> 00:39:33,594 me that there are big efforts being made of moving barrels by train, 585 00:39:33,594 --> 00:39:36,466 getting into different offloading points and unloading points, 586 00:39:36,466 --> 00:39:41,492 and even trucks are running to get to Oman and you know, kind of 587 00:39:41,492 --> 00:39:45,800 like bypass the Strait of Hormuz and you know the, what is 588 00:39:45,800 --> 00:39:49,031 it, the east/west pipeline in Saudi is at capacity. 589 00:39:49,081 --> 00:39:50,873 It's fascinating though, right? It's fascinating because, 590 00:39:50,873 --> 00:39:53,689 you know, we'll talk about financial markets and then as soon 591 00:39:53,689 --> 00:39:55,993 as you start speaking about commodities, you're talking about 592 00:39:55,993 --> 00:39:57,017 like the actual physical… 593 00:39:57,521 --> 00:39:58,561 Yeah, the real thing. 594 00:39:58,881 --> 00:40:01,041 The real thing, right. So, it's quite fascinating, actually, 595 00:40:01,041 --> 00:40:02,001 getting into this space. 596 00:40:02,241 --> 00:40:46,980 Love these markets. Anyway, let's leave it there with a commodity 597 00:40:16,553 --> 00:40:36,232 curve carry. Maybe in six months time we're going to reconnect 598 00:40:36,232 --> 00:40:46,966 and it'll be recovered. Who knows? But back to our most favorite 599 00:40:05,361 --> 00:40:10,561 topic, trend following, I guess, is something that goes with 600 00:40:10,561 --> 00:40:16,281 the systematic investor series. At least this is how it started. 601 00:40:16,281 --> 00:40:20,961 So, trend following performance in 2026, I think we've 602 00:40:20,961 --> 00:40:26,681 said, is actually quite good. From your perspective, one of the 603 00:40:26,681 --> 00:40:31,881 questions that always came up is, like, alternative markets, smaller 604 00:40:31,881 --> 00:40:36,041 markets versus standard markets, more markets versus less 605 00:40:36,041 --> 00:40:42,801 markets, I think you have it all in your QIS suite of products. 606 00:40:42,801 --> 00:40:46,961 What's been performing best, what's been performing worst? 607 00:40:48,261 --> 00:41:29,081 Let me start… Where should I start? If I start from the markets 608 00:41:29,081 --> 00:42:06,761 that perform the best, I mean, alternative markets in my mind (and 609 00:42:06,761 --> 00:42:41,301 we can disagree on the definition because there is no clear 610 00:42:41,301 --> 00:43:09,561 differentiation between what makes a market alternative or conventional 611 00:43:09,561 --> 00:43:47,241 beyond maybe just liquidity). The more kind of, let's call it conventional 612 00:43:47,241 --> 00:44:06,081 markets, I think they have outperformed. We can look into maybe 613 00:41:03,716 --> 00:41:28,444 non BCOM or non-benchmark commodities. You know, year-to-date 614 00:41:28,444 --> 00:42:08,627 it hasn't been a specific good period for that part for the trend 615 00:42:08,627 --> 00:42:42,628 following space. You know, the interesting thing is that if you 616 00:42:42,628 --> 00:43:13,538 start looking into different premia like a reversion or skewness 617 00:43:13,538 --> 00:43:44,448 dynamics it’s the exact opposite. So, the benefit of diversification 618 00:43:44,448 --> 00:44:06,085 of premia also prevails across all markets. So, specifically, in 619 00:40:55,500 --> 00:41:22,043 the commodity space, we were talking about kind of benchmark markets 620 00:41:22,043 --> 00:41:46,173 have done very well capturing obviously the precious metals in 621 00:41:46,173 --> 00:42:15,129 the early days of the year and then January. Precisely. And then 622 00:42:15,129 --> 00:42:41,672 kind of moving into the energy markets and benefiting very, very 623 00:42:41,672 --> 00:43:10,628 strongly in the recent period. So, pretty much like in a straight 624 00:43:10,628 --> 00:43:41,997 line up, in a way, on the commodity front, and the other asset 625 00:43:41,997 --> 00:44:03,714 classes obviously being long equities, shorter the dollar, short 626 00:44:03,714 --> 00:44:06,127 bonds. I rarely remember a period whereby all four major asset 627 00:41:12,681 --> 00:41:39,543 classes have been contributing positively. And this is one of the 628 00:41:39,543 --> 00:42:06,405 few. Interestingly, in rates, I know I remember kind of discussing 629 00:42:06,405 --> 00:42:40,593 year end with a crew here about what would be my bet for the 630 00:42:40,593 --> 00:43:09,897 year. And so far it didn't start as I was anticipating but, 631 00:43:09,897 --> 00:43:41,643 you know, since the beginning of March I think the trend has picked 632 00:43:41,643 --> 00:44:06,063 up which is actually like an interesting observation to have. 633 00:40:48,261 --> 00:41:39,873 You know, we haven't had it for like two, three years actually 634 00:41:39,873 --> 00:42:18,582 now, since 2022. So, performance has been very strong. 635 00:42:18,582 --> 00:43:01,592 I think benchmark markets have been delivering the principal components, 636 00:43:01,592 --> 00:43:48,903 in all fairness. So, the equity, the dollar, the energy complex, 637 00:43:48,903 --> 00:44:06,107 and the rates one. So, the whole spectrum has been delivering. 638 00:41:09,569 --> 00:41:33,921 Economic trends have done well, frankly speaking, pointing 639 00:41:33,921 --> 00:42:07,405 into rising or falling growth, but certainly being helped by some 640 00:42:07,405 --> 00:42:28,713 precious exposure. And then, obviously, diversifying components 641 00:42:28,713 --> 00:43:02,197 to trend following reversion, like carry, things that I have been 642 00:43:02,197 --> 00:43:29,593 very vocal about for another year, continuously adding performance. 643 00:43:29,593 --> 00:44:06,121 It's been actually quite a very strong year for the whole spectrum. 644 00:40:48,261 --> 00:41:17,823 I would say, if I were to make a classification to your question 645 00:41:17,823 --> 00:41:40,563 as to how broad or how centralized somebody should become, 646 00:41:40,563 --> 00:42:05,577 when it comes to trend following program, in my mind, stylistically 647 00:42:05,577 --> 00:42:28,317 solving for defensiveness. Somebody should go with a core market 648 00:42:28,317 --> 00:42:51,057 universe because all you're trying to achieve is the principal 649 00:42:51,057 --> 00:43:11,523 component moves maybe with a slightly lower long-term adjusted 650 00:43:11,523 --> 00:43:34,263 returns. Looking for long-term adjusted returns, I would go broader. 651 00:43:34,263 --> 00:44:01,551 That perhaps will have a cost in terms of how much defensiveness 652 00:44:01,551 --> 00:44:06,099 you get. And I think this was also in a paper, from Man, that was 653 00:42:50,747 --> 00:44:06,123 actually quite nice, a couple of months ago. 654 00:44:06,931 --> 00:44:09,479 Correct. They looked at different portfolio compositions 655 00:44:09,479 --> 00:44:12,755 with more like alternative markets, more markets, less markets. 656 00:44:12,755 --> 00:44:17,487 And that's exactly what they showed, is like if you have a smaller 657 00:44:17,487 --> 00:44:20,763 concentrated portfolio of macro markets, you have that positive 658 00:44:20,763 --> 00:44:21,491 skew defense. 659 00:44:21,491 --> 00:44:22,051 Exactly. 660 00:44:22,291 --> 00:44:25,091 Especially during equity drawdowns. But your long-term expected 661 00:44:25,091 --> 00:44:27,891 Sharpe ratio performance potential is maximized more when 662 00:44:27,891 --> 00:44:31,391 you add all these alternative markets because they're, you know… 663 00:44:31,391 --> 00:44:34,541 I use syncratic bets on something different. They materialize 664 00:44:34,541 --> 00:44:36,291 at some point in time. 665 00:44:36,451 --> 00:44:40,719 Precisely. But I don't think this year it's necessarily the recipe 666 00:44:40,719 --> 00:44:44,211 for disaster nor for outperformance. Yes, fine, if we 667 00:44:44,211 --> 00:44:46,927 just look into the non-benchmark commodities, maybe 668 00:44:46,927 --> 00:44:51,195 the trend following space has not been very lucrative, but the 669 00:44:51,195 --> 00:44:56,239 reversion one has. But that's a bit more of a kind of handpicked 670 00:44:56,239 --> 00:45:00,119 selection round rather than like a bigger group of assets. 671 00:45:00,701 --> 00:45:14,465 It matches my observation. I mean, when we look at the SocGen 672 00:45:14,465 --> 00:45:24,788 CTA index, I mentioned the performance numbers earlier, it's 673 00:45:24,788 --> 00:45:38,552 up about 12% or whatever it is. Right? So, that's the largest 674 00:45:38,552 --> 00:45:52,316 - 20 CTAs. There's a big exposure to the big macro market 675 00:45:52,316 --> 00:46:03,786 markets, so, they're doing well with these type of markets. 676 00:45:00,701 --> 00:45:06,181 There are some CTAs out there trading concentrated portfolios that 677 00:45:06,181 --> 00:45:13,305 are up 50%, some are up 100%. They have these massive years. And 678 00:45:13,305 --> 00:45:20,977 then when we go down the list and we look at the managers that 679 00:45:20,977 --> 00:45:27,005 are more in the alternative markets space, or have a broader 680 00:45:27,005 --> 00:45:31,937 portfolio that includes smaller markets, we at Takahe, we're 681 00:45:31,937 --> 00:45:39,061 one of them. We're not really catching up with these or we're not 682 00:45:39,061 --> 00:45:45,089 there because the other markets have been a drag this year. 683 00:45:45,089 --> 00:45:51,117 We have allocated risk to them and they haven't been performing 684 00:45:51,117 --> 00:45:59,337 as well. Whereas if we had all the risk in silver and gold and the 685 00:45:59,337 --> 00:46:03,721 energy markets, we would have done much better. But that by no 686 00:45:12,173 --> 00:45:43,721 means says anything about what will happen next month or between 687 00:45:43,721 --> 00:46:03,797 now and the end of the year. 688 00:46:03,801 --> 00:46:05,201 Right after the fact, we always know. 689 00:46:05,601 --> 00:46:06,241 Exactly. 690 00:46:06,241 --> 00:46:07,521 That's true. That's true, that's true. 691 00:46:08,471 --> 00:46:31,439 Hey, there is a question, and that relates (as we're closing down), 692 00:46:31,439 --> 00:46:54,407 there's a question that came in for you, Nick, relating, I presume, 693 00:46:54,407 --> 00:47:19,289 to trend following. So, let me bring it up. It's a listener question 694 00:47:19,289 --> 00:47:23,119 from Vladimir. So here we go. Researchers and practitioners in 695 00:46:16,999 --> 00:46:31,923 the rules-based investment community publish prolifically on 696 00:46:31,923 --> 00:46:57,507 the topics of the role of CTAs in portfolios, various signals and 697 00:46:57,507 --> 00:47:10,299 factors, portfolio construction, etc. There's little 698 00:47:10,299 --> 00:47:23,091 work and less conversation about execution. So, the question 699 00:46:12,023 --> 00:46:23,863 is, is there alpha in execution? Is there discretion in 700 00:46:23,863 --> 00:46:35,703 execution and when is that discretion exercised? What are the 701 00:46:35,703 --> 00:46:45,175 go-to and preferred execution strategies that minimize slippage? 702 00:46:45,175 --> 00:46:59,383 Is there a case for execution optimization per asset or asset class? 703 00:46:59,383 --> 00:47:14,775 And what percentage of time is spent on execution R and D; research 704 00:47:14,775 --> 00:47:23,063 and development? Keep up the good work. Thank you Vladimir for 705 00:46:58,235 --> 00:47:23,117 the question. So, long question, summarizing, is there alpha 706 00:46:18,145 --> 00:46:33,347 in execution? How do you execute? How do you minimize slippage? 707 00:46:33,347 --> 00:46:49,931 And is it kind of like a market by market distinction that 708 00:46:49,931 --> 00:47:06,515 you could possibly make saying we're going to be executing the S&P 709 00:47:06,515 --> 00:47:23,099 500 in a different way than we're going to be executing cocoa? 710 00:47:23,841 --> 00:47:42,629 So, I think the question can be answered very differently when 711 00:47:42,629 --> 00:48:04,833 it's posed to kind of a QIS business versus, you know, some kind 712 00:48:04,833 --> 00:48:25,329 of CTA that are managing with the fiduciary element, a trend following 713 00:48:25,329 --> 00:48:44,117 portfolio. So, maybe my answer would be kind of perhaps different 714 00:48:44,117 --> 00:49:01,197 to yours, Moritz. Right? Because, you know, we're kind of 715 00:49:01,197 --> 00:49:19,985 sitting on like the opposite seats of that question. So, broadly 716 00:49:19,985 --> 00:49:37,065 speaking, QIS would typically deliver, on a guaranteed basis, some 717 00:49:37,065 --> 00:49:54,145 closing price or some TWOP, let's put it this way. In this regard, 718 00:47:32,511 --> 00:48:04,301 the risk of achieving whatever reference price has been quoted in 719 00:48:04,301 --> 00:48:33,201 the index documentation lies with the trading desk. But ultimately 720 00:48:33,201 --> 00:49:02,101 whoever is exposed to this systematic strategy will get whatever 721 00:49:02,101 --> 00:49:31,001 they can calculate effectively by, to your earlier point, doing 722 00:49:31,001 --> 00:49:54,121 the sum product of quantities and price changes. So, in this regard, 723 00:47:32,429 --> 00:48:00,340 our attempt is to make sure that getting into the market is a 724 00:48:00,340 --> 00:48:21,810 passive exercise precisely because we would want to avoid having 725 00:48:21,810 --> 00:48:47,574 any impact whatsoever. And the way that both from a design standpoint, 726 00:48:47,574 --> 00:49:06,897 but also from a risk management standpoint approach, the 727 00:49:06,897 --> 00:49:32,661 problem is we want to deliver the strategy. There is no execution 728 00:49:32,661 --> 00:49:54,131 alpha that in itself will become part of the return. And therefore, 729 00:47:29,305 --> 00:47:59,357 in this journey of delivering as passively as possible the reference 730 00:47:59,357 --> 00:48:32,141 prices in the documentation of the index, the attempt is be passive, 731 00:48:32,141 --> 00:48:59,461 be thoughtful, market by market, risk class with the trading 732 00:48:59,461 --> 00:49:32,245 desk; they have the ability and the clarity to decide upon how 733 00:49:32,245 --> 00:49:54,101 and when they would execute into the market. I think this is 734 00:47:29,405 --> 00:47:43,315 very different to running the strategy yourself, because in that 735 00:47:43,315 --> 00:48:00,007 case you can benefit from it and therefore your clients can benefit 736 00:48:00,007 --> 00:48:13,917 from it above and beyond a guaranteed closing price. Which, 737 00:48:13,917 --> 00:48:29,218 obviously, at times can work to your benefit, sometimes at your 738 00:48:29,218 --> 00:48:44,519 expense. So, I think there is certainly value in doing execution 739 00:48:44,519 --> 00:49:03,993 research. And by no means am I saying here that we should not focus 740 00:49:03,993 --> 00:49:23,467 on that. It is purely, if you like, the boundaries that a QIS business 741 00:49:23,467 --> 00:49:38,768 operates under, that makes that more of an internal focus rather 742 00:49:38,768 --> 00:49:51,287 than, if you like, an externally deliverable profile in 743 00:49:51,287 --> 00:49:54,069 this regard. But to get your thoughts, because I think you are 744 00:48:52,251 --> 00:49:54,138 much more on that right than myself. 745 00:49:54,471 --> 00:50:33,071 Fair enough, and you're absolutely correct to say that it 746 00:50:33,071 --> 00:51:15,531 is a different perspective that we need to take because, through 747 00:51:15,531 --> 00:51:54,131 your index documentation, you promise and you guarantee, say, a 748 00:51:54,131 --> 00:52:36,591 settlement price to the client and your marking the strategy at 749 00:52:36,591 --> 00:53:15,191 exactly that price, and that is where it is transacted. Now, if 750 00:50:00,463 --> 00:50:39,411 you trade at a different level to that price, that is slippage and 751 00:50:39,411 --> 00:51:09,371 that positive or negative slippage (it can be either direction) 752 00:51:09,371 --> 00:51:48,319 is on the books of Goldman Sachs, you know, with all the netting 753 00:51:48,319 --> 00:52:21,275 impacts that you have. But it's essentially for you to manage 754 00:52:21,275 --> 00:52:57,227 that and it's your risk to manage that. And it's not something 755 00:52:57,227 --> 00:53:15,203 that you're mirroring onto the client. In our case, that's different 756 00:50:11,481 --> 00:50:48,903 because every time we realize slippage, it is, again, either positive 757 00:50:48,903 --> 00:51:29,727 or negative, but it's directly routed on to the client because it 758 00:51:29,727 --> 00:52:17,355 shows up in the P&L. And so, to summarize, I think there is, I'm 759 00:52:17,355 --> 00:53:04,983 not sure if alpha is the right word, but there is value in execution 760 00:53:04,983 --> 00:53:15,189 and executing efficiently. And all of these markets… this is one 761 00:50:18,799 --> 00:50:49,209 of the questions Vladimir has, is there different execution strategies 762 00:50:49,209 --> 00:51:28,742 per market? And my answer to that is yes, there is, because all 763 00:51:28,742 --> 00:52:05,234 of these markets operate in a different way in the order book. 764 00:52:05,234 --> 00:52:26,521 They have different settlement procedures, different settlement 765 00:52:26,521 --> 00:52:56,931 windows, different periods of time. Some have like 30 seconds, 766 00:52:56,931 --> 00:53:15,177 some have 30 minutes to settle. Trading Brazilian live cattle 767 00:50:15,603 --> 00:51:03,150 has a very different settlement window than trading live 768 00:51:03,150 --> 00:52:11,829 cattle in the US on the CME. The liquidity profile and the liquidity 769 00:52:11,829 --> 00:52:59,376 concentration is very different. So, there is value that 770 00:52:59,376 --> 00:53:15,225 you can extract. And maybe an episode that Vladimir, if you're 771 00:50:11,199 --> 00:50:32,109 interested in, that's worth listening to is my conversation with 772 00:50:32,109 --> 00:50:55,110 Tom Babbedge, from Gresham, and he did speak about... So, they 773 00:50:55,110 --> 00:51:13,929 trade alternative markets, they trade markets such as propane, 774 00:51:13,929 --> 00:51:36,930 and butane gas, and smaller markets. And he has reported that 775 00:51:36,930 --> 00:51:57,840 these are markets where you would, in expectation, assume that 776 00:51:57,840 --> 00:52:25,023 the slippage is going to be much higher relative to if you traded 777 00:52:25,023 --> 00:52:48,024 the S&P 500 E-mini futures contract, which is very liquid. And 778 00:52:48,024 --> 00:53:11,025 he reported that their slippage in the past year has actually 779 00:53:11,025 --> 00:53:15,207 been nil. And the way they do it, they do a lot of R and D in execution, 780 00:50:21,463 --> 00:50:41,707 is they have a more patient approach to getting into the trade. 781 00:50:41,707 --> 00:50:56,890 They're not forcing themselves to immediately transact and consume 782 00:50:56,890 --> 00:51:17,134 liquidity from the order book. They sit there, they can wait. It's 783 00:51:17,134 --> 00:51:34,004 more like… He said it's still systematized and rules-based, but 784 00:51:34,004 --> 00:51:55,935 it's more like a human element to the execution process to get you 785 00:51:55,935 --> 00:52:19,553 into a trade. And he said that there is value there. Like if we 786 00:52:19,553 --> 00:52:36,423 didn't do it in that thoughtful way, they would probably 787 00:52:36,423 --> 00:53:00,041 pay 2% or 3% in slippage per year. And now they do not because 788 00:53:00,041 --> 00:53:15,224 they have a specific focus on doing it efficiently. I can only 789 00:50:12,720 --> 00:51:25,716 echo that, not to the same extent as Tom Babbedge, but clearly 790 00:51:25,716 --> 00:52:32,629 there are missteps that you can easily avoid when executing poorly 791 00:52:32,629 --> 00:53:15,210 and there is value by executing efficiently. 792 00:53:16,031 --> 00:53:19,071 I can live with that. I can live with that. 793 00:53:21,102 --> 00:53:32,064 Nick, to wind it down, a final question I'd like to ask you, and 794 00:53:32,064 --> 00:53:42,243 that is my question, it didn't come from a listener. Do you have 795 00:53:42,243 --> 00:53:51,639 a QIS index that does trend following on single name cash equities 796 00:53:51,639 --> 00:53:52,422 only? I think it's an interesting space, but as you know, 797 00:53:27,242 --> 00:53:33,382 I may have overlooked something, but I've never seen an 798 00:53:33,382 --> 00:53:40,750 index that does that. And I was wondering, with all the indices 799 00:53:40,750 --> 00:53:49,960 that banks come up with, why is it not there? (If it is not there, 800 00:53:49,960 --> 00:53:52,416 I might be wrong.) 801 00:53:52,992 --> 00:54:34,068 Yeah, I don't think you'll find it on the street, but maybe 802 00:54:34,068 --> 00:55:15,144 I don't know the industry at that level of depth, obviously. Broadly 803 00:55:15,144 --> 00:55:49,374 speaking, the single stock space has always been thought of 804 00:55:49,374 --> 00:56:30,450 as a cross-sectional space. There is a pocket I should buy, there's 805 00:56:30,450 --> 00:57:11,526 a pocket I should sell, and that's a relative trade rather than 806 00:57:11,526 --> 00:57:28,641 like a time series one. And obviously momentum is the better 807 00:54:07,530 --> 00:54:31,760 expression of trend following the single stock space. But momentum 808 00:54:31,760 --> 00:55:00,836 is now buying the winners, sorting the losers. And I think part 809 00:55:00,836 --> 00:55:29,912 of the reason why this is the implementation that, you know, you 810 00:55:29,912 --> 00:55:54,142 typically see more of is because a more time-series implementation 811 00:55:54,142 --> 00:56:23,218 would be probably like timing the market in a way, like buying 812 00:56:23,218 --> 00:56:54,717 the stocks when the market is kind of rallying and then kind of 813 00:56:54,717 --> 00:57:26,216 selling them when the market is selling off with a bit of cross-sectionality 814 00:57:26,216 --> 00:57:28,639 here. I don't necessarily think that this is a bad idea and 815 00:54:19,051 --> 00:54:45,110 I'm sure it's going to have positive return partly because of 816 00:54:45,110 --> 00:55:15,907 the market timing ability that it would have. There was, if I have 817 00:55:15,907 --> 00:55:44,335 good recollection of this one, I think there is a very interesting 818 00:55:44,335 --> 00:56:12,763 paper by maybe it's Jegadeesh and Goyal (I hope I'm not wrong), 819 00:56:12,763 --> 00:56:41,191 a couple of years back, maybe three, four, five years ago, looking 820 00:56:41,191 --> 00:57:02,512 into the difference between a time series implementation, which 821 00:57:02,512 --> 00:57:23,833 is trend following, and a cross sectional implementation, which 822 00:57:23,833 --> 00:57:28,571 is momentum. And the focus there was to look into single stock 823 00:54:35,272 --> 00:55:17,552 implementation because you have the breadth to do momentum cross 824 00:55:17,552 --> 00:56:04,060 sectionally, but also you can do a trend following strategy, to 825 00:56:04,060 --> 00:57:03,252 your point. And what they show is that one is very similar to the 826 00:57:03,252 --> 00:57:28,620 other, plus some market timing mechanism. If you have 100 stocks, 827 00:54:04,107 --> 00:54:39,675 and you go long 60, and you go short 40, it's almost as if you go 828 00:54:39,675 --> 00:55:04,128 long and short 40 as a cross-section momentum and then the 829 00:55:04,128 --> 00:55:35,250 remaining 20 will give a bit of a beta to the market. So, what 830 00:55:35,250 --> 00:55:59,703 they're trying to show is that the two implementations are kind 831 00:55:59,703 --> 00:56:21,933 of sister implementations of the same premium with an additional 832 00:56:21,933 --> 00:56:46,386 market timing element. So, the question then becomes, where is my 833 00:56:46,386 --> 00:57:08,616 return coming from? How is that attribution of skill delivered 834 00:57:08,616 --> 00:57:28,623 from a market timing mechanism versus a cross-sectional premium? 835 00:53:52,992 --> 00:54:20,180 So, I guess to paraphrase, all I'm trying to say here is that what 836 00:54:20,180 --> 00:54:43,484 you're saying is not, I guess it's not a question that doesn't 837 00:54:43,484 --> 00:55:12,614 have any value in it in the sense that I can see the value it 838 00:55:12,614 --> 00:55:37,860 can bring. Maybe the one thing that has become more popular is something 839 00:55:37,860 --> 00:56:01,164 that came up a few years back called factor momentum, which is 840 00:56:01,164 --> 00:56:18,642 looking into cross sectional premia and allocating between value, 841 00:56:18,642 --> 00:56:43,888 and quality, and growth, and so on, and so forth, on the basis 842 00:56:43,888 --> 00:57:05,250 of their relative momentum. But that in itself will start picking 843 00:57:05,250 --> 00:57:28,554 up that sometimes it is trend on the factors that have performed. 844 00:53:52,992 --> 00:54:33,682 So, indirectly, maybe that's an expression, in the single stock 845 00:54:33,682 --> 00:55:18,441 space, of a trend following strategy which is doing trend following 846 00:55:18,441 --> 00:56:07,269 at the factor level, which is long/short, in itself, as a design. 847 00:56:07,269 --> 00:56:47,959 So, the vehicle itself is long/short, but the allocation is 848 00:56:47,959 --> 00:57:28,649 done on the base of time series momentum onto them. And that, 849 00:54:03,022 --> 00:55:08,217 I think, primarily comes from some of the kind of slow moving flow 850 00:55:08,217 --> 00:56:08,397 in the equity factor space, now that it's available in an ATF 851 00:56:08,397 --> 00:57:08,577 format and other types kind of retail wrappers. So, that's how we 852 00:57:08,577 --> 00:57:28,637 look into this one. I have a feeling that there is an ETF in this 853 00:55:24,226 --> 00:57:03,754 kind of trend ETF space that does single names. I cannot recall 854 00:57:03,754 --> 00:57:28,636 who that is. 855 00:57:29,692 --> 00:57:35,027 Yeah, well, that definitely doesn't seem to be a crowded space 856 00:57:35,027 --> 00:57:41,817 because we both don't know off the top of our heads whether it exists 857 00:57:41,817 --> 00:57:48,607 or not, or whether there is an ETF. So, maybe it's food for thought, 858 00:57:48,607 --> 00:57:53,942 maybe something for your research team to look into at some 859 00:57:53,942 --> 00:57:59,762 point and come up with an index. I definitely find it interesting. 860 00:57:29,692 --> 00:57:42,744 Anyway, it's been an hour, so on that note, Nick, it's been great 861 00:57:42,744 --> 00:57:54,792 to chat with you again about the QIS space. Oh, you're raising 862 00:57:54,792 --> 00:57:59,812 your finger. You found something? 863 00:58:00,372 --> 00:58:04,440 Yeah, you know, from memory, I think that was the Chesapeake trend, 864 00:58:04,440 --> 00:58:08,508 and I think that's the one that does the four asset classes 865 00:58:08,508 --> 00:58:10,881 and then single names. There you are. 866 00:58:10,892 --> 00:58:15,260 Oh, yeah, so Jerry and the Chesapeake team, they have that on 867 00:58:15,260 --> 00:58:17,080 top of the other things. 868 00:58:17,082 --> 00:58:20,082 That's what I had in mind but unless I check it, I don't want to 869 00:58:20,082 --> 00:58:21,482 put the name down. That's the one. 870 00:58:22,122 --> 00:58:26,778 For sure, I can confirm that is the case. They're trading single 871 00:58:26,778 --> 00:58:32,210 names, but obviously on top of oil, on top of rates, on top copper, 872 00:58:32,210 --> 00:58:37,254 and so on, and so forth. But as a kind of stand-alone version, 873 00:58:37,254 --> 00:58:41,522 just single name trend. Yeah, maybe food for thought. Maybe at 874 00:58:41,522 --> 00:58:46,178 some point we'll have that index as well. It would be interesting 875 00:58:46,178 --> 00:58:50,834 to follow, I guess, and compare to the S&P 500, like everything 876 00:58:50,834 --> 00:58:53,162 is compared to the S&P 500. 877 00:58:53,232 --> 00:58:57,472 Such an incorrect benchmark for a long/short strategy, but anyway. 878 00:58:58,032 --> 00:59:01,832 Yeah, well, it's an incorrect benchmark for trend following strategies 879 00:59:01,832 --> 00:59:05,632 too, but nevertheless, we're comparing it to the S&P 500. 880 00:59:05,632 --> 00:59:06,112 I know. 881 00:59:06,512 --> 00:59:18,812 Anyway, let's wrap it up here, Nick. I hope, listeners, that you 882 00:59:18,812 --> 00:59:32,137 have enjoyed it as much as Nick and I enjoyed chatting to each 883 00:59:32,137 --> 00:59:39,312 other and making the conversation for you. Next week, 884 00:59:07,878 --> 00:59:16,757 I think Niels will be back and hosting the show again. And meanwhile, 885 00:59:16,757 --> 00:59:25,636 if you have any questions or if you'd like to submit a question 886 00:59:25,636 --> 00:59:31,783 for the next episode, please email us at info@toptradersunplugged.com 887 00:59:31,783 --> 00:59:39,296 and we will do our best to bring your question up. From Nick 888 00:59:10,370 --> 00:59:33,518 and me, thanks so much for listening and until next time on 889 00:59:33,518 --> 00:59:39,305 Top Traders Unplugged. 890 00:59:40,211 --> 00:59:50,001 Thanks for listening to Top Traders Unplugged. If you feel you 891 00:59:50,001 --> 00:59:58,901 learned something of value from today's episode, the best way 892 00:59:58,901 --> 01:00:10,471 to stay updated is to go on over to your favorite podcast platform 893 01:00:10,471 --> 01:00:22,931 and follow the show so that you'll be sure to get all the new 894 01:00:22,931 --> 01:00:31,831 episodes as they're released. We have some amazing guests lined 895 01:00:31,831 --> 01:00:43,401 up for you and to ensure our show continues to grow, please leave 896 01:00:43,401 --> 01:00:54,081 us an honest rating and review. It only takes a minute and 897 01:00:54,081 --> 01:01:06,541 it's the best way to show us you love the podcast. We'll see you 898 01:01:06,541 --> 01:01:11,881 next time on Top Traders Unplugged. This podcast expresses 899 00:59:42,471 --> 00:59:56,160 the views of its hosts and the guests appearing on the podcast as 900 00:59:56,160 --> 01:00:09,849 of the date of its recording, and such views are subject to change 901 01:00:09,849 --> 01:00:21,432 without notice. Top Traders Unplugged do not have any duty or 902 01:00:21,432 --> 01:00:29,856 obligation to update the information contained herein. Furthermore, 903 01:00:29,856 --> 01:00:40,386 Top Traders Unplugged make no representation to its accuracy and 904 01:00:40,386 --> 01:00:51,969 it shall not be assumed that past investment performance is an 905 01:00:51,969 --> 01:01:02,499 indication of future results. Moreover, wherever there is a potential 906 01:01:02,499 --> 01:01:11,976 for profit, there is also the possibility of loss. This content 907 00:59:49,608 --> 01:00:35,940 is made available for educational purposes only and should 908 01:00:35,940 --> 01:01:11,976 not be used for any other purpose. The information contained 909 00:59:47,034 --> 01:00:15,348 in this podcast does not constitute, and should not be construed 910 01:00:15,348 --> 01:00:43,662 as investment advice, or an offer to sell, or a solicitation 911 01:00:43,662 --> 01:01:06,828 to buy any securities or related financial instruments in 912 01:01:06,828 --> 01:01:11,976 any jurisdiction. Certain information contained herein concerning 913 00:59:46,027 --> 00:59:58,114 economic trends and performance is based on or derived 914 00:59:58,114 --> 01:00:07,515 from information provided by independent third-party sources. 915 01:00:07,515 --> 01:00:20,945 Top Traders Unplugged may believe that the sources from which 916 01:00:20,945 --> 01:00:33,032 such information are obtained are reliable. However, Top Traders 917 01:00:33,032 --> 01:00:45,119 Unplugged cannot guarantee the accuracy of such information and 918 01:00:45,119 --> 01:00:58,549 has not independently verified the accuracy or completeness of such 919 01:00:58,549 --> 01:01:11,979 information or the assumptions on which such information is based. 920 00:59:39,312 --> 01:00:02,472 This podcast, including the information contained herein, may 921 01:00:02,472 --> 01:00:31,422 not be reproduced, copied, republished or posted in whole or 922 01:00:31,422 --> 01:01:06,162 in part in any form, without the prior written consent of Top 923 01:01:06,162 --> 01:01:11,952 Traders Unplugged.