1 00:00:00,282 --> 00:00:01,412 ProClima studio again. 2 00:00:03,227 --> 00:00:07,241 ProClima, major sponsor of the podcast, if you're tuning in for the first time. 3 00:00:07,241 --> 00:00:07,560 I don't know why that's so 4 00:00:07,561 --> 00:00:07,792 funny. 5 00:00:07,840 --> 00:00:08,315 I don't know why that's 6 00:00:08,317 --> 00:00:08,408 so funny. 7 00:00:08,408 --> 00:00:11,248 I know, 'cause we kind of… It's funny, 'cause we actually forget each 8 00:00:11,248 --> 00:00:13,873 time to do it, and then we're, and we forget to introduce our guest as well. 9 00:00:13,873 --> 00:00:16,325 Yeah, but we also, we also, like, never know who's gonna, 10 00:00:16,326 --> 00:00:17,617 like, start the podcast either. 11 00:00:17,617 --> 00:00:17,637 I know. 12 00:00:17,637 --> 00:00:19,642 And so it's like, uh, you, we're, like, looking at each other. 13 00:00:19,642 --> 00:00:21,611 'Cause you've actually watched this on YouTube, I'm, like, looking 14 00:00:21,613 --> 00:00:23,316 at Matt, and he's like, "Uh…" 15 00:00:23,337 --> 00:00:25,147 So ProClima, big sponsor of ours. 16 00:00:25,334 --> 00:00:25,984 Built to last. 17 00:00:25,986 --> 00:00:29,808 We've been using ProClima for, since 2018. 18 00:00:29,819 --> 00:00:32,292 So actually, on census, we should… This is gonna cover… So we're 19 00:00:32,292 --> 00:00:33,096 gonna talk about monitoring- Not 20 00:00:33,096 --> 00:00:33,799 census. 21 00:00:33,825 --> 00:00:34,255 It's not… It's the census. 22 00:00:34,255 --> 00:00:34,417 'Cause 23 00:00:34,417 --> 00:00:35,748 did anyone fucking do the census- Yeah. 24 00:00:35,753 --> 00:00:36,510 … two nights ago? 25 00:00:36,753 --> 00:00:37,260 What? 26 00:00:37,752 --> 00:00:40,342 So I'm gonna… I could get myself in so 27 00:00:40,342 --> 00:00:43,015 much- That, like, that's why I need to go on fucking medication, 'cause I… It took 28 00:00:43,015 --> 00:00:44,238 me, like, four hours to do that and- So 29 00:00:44,450 --> 00:00:46,483 I, I could get myself into so much trouble here. 30 00:00:46,487 --> 00:00:47,228 So- And I'm just gonna say it 31 00:00:47,228 --> 00:00:49,815 … one of the most, single most, uh, important bits of 32 00:00:49,816 --> 00:00:50,817 government data collection. 33 00:00:50,890 --> 00:00:51,444 Is it actually? 34 00:00:51,576 --> 00:00:53,205 Uh, of super useful in 35 00:00:53,210 --> 00:00:53,543 so many ways. 36 00:00:53,543 --> 00:00:55,155 Uh, do you know, as I'm reading- It's actually … as I'm reading 37 00:00:55,155 --> 00:00:56,156 through it, I'm like- Really? 38 00:00:56,174 --> 00:00:58,234 … "Okay, I understand why we're doing this." Like, I get it. 39 00:00:58,239 --> 00:00:58,746 Absolutely critical. 40 00:00:58,756 --> 00:00:59,500 I totally get it. 41 00:00:59,551 --> 00:00:59,968 Absolutely. 42 00:00:59,968 --> 00:01:01,109 The… But I had to fill out Noah's. 43 00:01:01,212 --> 00:01:05,048 She's 13 months old, and the question I get is what level is 44 00:01:05,048 --> 00:01:06,268 the highest level of education. 45 00:01:06,268 --> 00:01:06,431 I 46 00:01:06,551 --> 00:01:06,734 got 47 00:01:06,759 --> 00:01:07,345 that one too. 48 00:01:07,345 --> 00:01:10,761 I was like, "I'm just gonna tick tertiary." Like, I- I hope you didn't. 49 00:01:10,942 --> 00:01:11,036 What? 50 00:01:11,036 --> 00:01:11,396 I did. 51 00:01:11,465 --> 00:01:13,580 But, like, like, it's a stupid thing, but- You have 52 00:01:13,582 --> 00:01:14,916 just skewed all the data, 53 00:01:14,922 --> 00:01:15,226 Matthew. 54 00:01:15,230 --> 00:01:17,652 No, because, like, obviously it, when you do certain people, it 55 00:01:17,659 --> 00:01:18,749 filters the different questions. 56 00:01:18,765 --> 00:01:19,311 Yeah, it does. 57 00:01:19,317 --> 00:01:22,542 Surely as a kid that is 13 months old, they go- Yeah … "Let's 58 00:01:22,545 --> 00:01:23,375 clear that question." 59 00:01:23,396 --> 00:01:26,103 You, you can't, you can't prejudice what the answer's gonna be, though. 60 00:01:26,161 --> 00:01:27,801 You've got to let the respondent answer. 61 00:01:27,832 --> 00:01:30,958 And then the reason why it takes the better part of a year for the census 62 00:01:30,958 --> 00:01:34,527 results to come out is they do a whole lot of cleaning of the data to remove- 63 00:01:34,747 --> 00:01:38,827 obviously eg- egregious entries, like what you've just done there, Mr. Callan. 64 00:01:39,124 --> 00:01:41,993 Well, there's one which is like, "What language does she talk?" I wrote other. 65 00:01:41,993 --> 00:01:42,646 I wrote baby talk. 66 00:01:42,666 --> 00:01:43,628 I wrote baby too. 67 00:01:43,845 --> 00:01:44,603 I wrote baby too. 68 00:01:45,136 --> 00:01:45,525 I wrote baby- 69 00:01:45,646 --> 00:01:49,463 A- and you two- … you two are why it takes the better part of a year- 70 00:01:49,463 --> 00:01:51,782 … for the census data to come out. 71 00:01:52,428 --> 00:01:53,695 I can't believe he wrote that one. 72 00:01:53,783 --> 00:01:55,460 I mean, she screenshotted it too. 73 00:01:55,591 --> 00:01:57,018 So we have a kid about the same age. 74 00:01:57,018 --> 00:01:59,956 And I wrote, and I wrote, f- "What language?" Other, baby. 75 00:01:59,956 --> 00:02:00,249 Baby talk. 76 00:02:00,978 --> 00:02:01,669 That's what I wrote. 77 00:02:02,232 --> 00:02:02,534 Look at him. 78 00:02:02,866 --> 00:02:07,414 And so you are delaying the construction of hospitals in new build areas- 79 00:02:07,414 --> 00:02:08,861 Oh, I'm not taking responsibility 80 00:02:08,944 --> 00:02:10,189 the construction of roads- I blame the government for that 81 00:02:10,271 --> 00:02:10,310 … all sorts of things. 82 00:02:10,310 --> 00:02:10,656 Yeah. 83 00:02:10,724 --> 00:02:14,186 Well, don't ask stupid questions that you might get stupid answers to. 84 00:02:14,240 --> 00:02:16,409 They- They're very- Yeah … reasonable questions if you were- Yeah. 85 00:02:16,409 --> 00:02:16,877 Do you know what? 86 00:02:16,907 --> 00:02:20,986 I, I must admit, I, as I'm reading through it, I'm just like, "Oh yeah, I 87 00:02:20,986 --> 00:02:22,027 kinda understand why this is important." 88 00:02:22,027 --> 00:02:22,164 We do it 89 00:02:22,164 --> 00:02:22,885 every two years? 90 00:02:23,370 --> 00:02:24,091 Every five years. 91 00:02:24,415 --> 00:02:26,197 Oh, I felt like I did it not long ago. 92 00:02:26,864 --> 00:02:29,835 Um, so we're talking monitoring and censoring. 93 00:02:30,156 --> 00:02:32,764 Um, I did, I was having a chat with Cam. 94 00:02:32,764 --> 00:02:34,904 I don't know if you've seen this ProClima in Denmark the other day. 95 00:02:35,066 --> 00:02:35,978 I don't want to get in trouble here. 96 00:02:35,978 --> 00:02:36,343 Germany. 97 00:02:36,346 --> 00:02:36,824 Germany. 98 00:02:36,887 --> 00:02:40,316 They've actually released an, or they're looking at an ADHERO, and it's 99 00:02:40,320 --> 00:02:42,132 got sensors built into the ADHERO. 100 00:02:43,838 --> 00:02:48,186 Do we talk to Villy about this for- No … sensors with water and stuff like 101 00:02:48,186 --> 00:02:48,459 that too? 102 00:02:48,459 --> 00:02:50,698 Yeah, so apparently they can like, yeah, so if you- Yeah … so idea, like 103 00:02:50,699 --> 00:02:54,556 I was like, I… My brain goes to like you could do a rooftop deck, you put 104 00:02:54,559 --> 00:02:57,117 the Adhere on, it's got the sensors all wired into it, so if there's something 105 00:02:57,117 --> 00:02:58,649 going wrong, it will l- alert you. 106 00:02:58,684 --> 00:03:00,580 Yeah, I think, I think Villy was saying, um, they're doing it- It's 107 00:03:00,580 --> 00:03:03,306 not here in Australia- It, it- … and it's being tried and tested overseas. 108 00:03:03,306 --> 00:03:04,284 It- So just caveat 109 00:03:04,286 --> 00:03:07,463 on that … and, and it's for, um, uh, like big commercial buildings, 110 00:03:07,464 --> 00:03:08,495 like if there's a leak in the wall. 111 00:03:08,506 --> 00:03:09,457 Mass timber and stuff. 112 00:03:09,457 --> 00:03:10,598 Mass timber, yeah, yeah, that's right. 113 00:03:10,598 --> 00:03:13,090 Like, what a, like, what a great idea if we could make it work. 114 00:03:13,090 --> 00:03:16,316 I think there's some issues around the electrical voltage through a membrane, and 115 00:03:16,316 --> 00:03:17,831 the standards and codes, and what happens. 116 00:03:17,834 --> 00:03:18,103 Yeah. 117 00:03:18,399 --> 00:03:21,872 Which is fair enough, but I think that is such a brilliant idea. 118 00:03:21,997 --> 00:03:25,138 There's no reason why you can't install little water me- uh, moisture 119 00:03:25,147 --> 00:03:27,444 sensors in a roof assembly now. 120 00:03:27,677 --> 00:03:29,434 Like, there's plenty of those things available- Well, 121 00:03:29,435 --> 00:03:30,779 just- … under 20 bucks a pop. 122 00:03:30,837 --> 00:03:32,329 You could do the bathroom as well though. 123 00:03:32,365 --> 00:03:32,965 Well, that's what I have. 124 00:03:32,965 --> 00:03:32,975 Put 125 00:03:33,054 --> 00:03:33,716 them in your bathroom. 126 00:03:33,781 --> 00:03:35,152 Yeah, so I've got… What have I got? 127 00:03:35,418 --> 00:03:36,125 Well, it's probably similar. 128 00:03:36,127 --> 00:03:39,674 The other day we ripped up the roof at my house, and we put the little, um, 129 00:03:40,345 --> 00:03:44,573 temperature humidity sensor in there to see, uh, what's actually happening 130 00:03:44,573 --> 00:03:47,211 for our moisture, because you can convert, you've taught me, Cameron, 131 00:03:47,212 --> 00:03:52,834 and my little Claudis now does, does a conversion, and it converts from 132 00:03:52,913 --> 00:03:56,753 absolute, uh, from relative to absolute, so we can see how much grams of water. 133 00:03:56,817 --> 00:03:57,321 Is that correct? 134 00:03:57,391 --> 00:03:58,215 In, in the air, 135 00:03:58,245 --> 00:03:58,394 yeah. 136 00:03:58,394 --> 00:03:59,573 Yeah, in the air, in the air. 137 00:03:59,573 --> 00:04:01,628 So you can actually see what, how much moisture is actually in that- 138 00:04:02,572 --> 00:04:03,197 depending on that calculation. 139 00:04:03,207 --> 00:04:03,689 Yeah, right. 140 00:04:04,104 --> 00:04:05,865 So, um, monitoring- 141 00:04:05,894 --> 00:04:06,807 And then, and then why would we do that? 142 00:04:06,821 --> 00:04:07,623 What, why would we bother? 143 00:04:07,693 --> 00:04:09,777 How much water's sitting in those cavities and- 144 00:04:10,031 --> 00:04:10,188 Mm 145 00:04:10,188 --> 00:04:12,078 is it gonna rot out or? 146 00:04:12,215 --> 00:04:15,756 And, and I think Hamish's point is the key whenever you start 147 00:04:15,766 --> 00:04:16,969 thinking about monitoring. 148 00:04:16,971 --> 00:04:19,314 So whenever I have discussions about this, people seem to wanna 149 00:04:19,329 --> 00:04:21,384 jump straight to the, the answer. 150 00:04:21,533 --> 00:04:23,139 "What, what should I use?" 151 00:04:23,444 --> 00:04:24,390 Just not tread pine. 152 00:04:24,411 --> 00:04:25,209 What… No, no. 153 00:04:25,385 --> 00:04:28,601 What, what sort of, what sort of monitor- What sort of 154 00:04:28,612 --> 00:04:30,990 monitoring device should I use? 155 00:04:31,306 --> 00:04:35,639 And the, and the qu- and to me that's a perplexing question because it's 156 00:04:35,641 --> 00:04:37,105 like, well, what do you want to know? 157 00:04:37,340 --> 00:04:37,719 Yeah. 158 00:04:38,118 --> 00:04:38,280 Like- 159 00:04:38,281 --> 00:04:39,201 What's your hypothesis? 160 00:04:39,599 --> 00:04:40,965 Well, I guess here, here, here's a question. 161 00:04:41,109 --> 00:04:44,751 W- what should we be monitoring, and, and what is, what is a 162 00:04:44,751 --> 00:04:45,659 valuable thing to monitor? 163 00:04:45,680 --> 00:04:47,473 'Cause we can monitor anything and everything. 164 00:04:47,492 --> 00:04:49,204 So I like at my house, so we've got- 165 00:04:49,424 --> 00:04:50,176 I was asking Cam. 166 00:04:50,196 --> 00:04:52,357 Yeah, I know, but I've got temperature and, and humidity 167 00:04:52,357 --> 00:04:53,055 'cause I just wanna know- 168 00:04:53,312 --> 00:04:53,547 Yeah 169 00:04:53,675 --> 00:04:54,205 … how we're sitting. 170 00:04:54,207 --> 00:04:54,811 It's internal. 171 00:04:55,046 --> 00:04:55,258 Yeah. 172 00:04:55,428 --> 00:04:57,377 So that, so that's, that's, that makes sense. 173 00:04:57,413 --> 00:04:58,920 But what are some of the other things that we should be monitoring? 174 00:04:58,923 --> 00:04:59,207 Okay. 175 00:04:59,219 --> 00:05:01,976 So, so we could start with the, the thermal performance 176 00:05:01,980 --> 00:05:03,182 or comfort of the building. 177 00:05:03,182 --> 00:05:03,206 Yeah. 178 00:05:03,206 --> 00:05:06,022 And obviously ambient temperature is one of those. 179 00:05:06,044 --> 00:05:07,392 That's air temperature. 180 00:05:07,865 --> 00:05:12,223 Uh, uh, relative humidity is important, obviously for the moisture within 181 00:05:12,225 --> 00:05:15,469 the, the buildup, building up within different parts of the building. 182 00:05:15,763 --> 00:05:19,484 Um, if you wanna measure thermal comfort more accurately, you 183 00:05:19,484 --> 00:05:22,347 wanna be look, looking at things like the black bulb temperature. 184 00:05:22,431 --> 00:05:26,197 So this is the radiant surface temperatures of within the building, 185 00:05:26,522 --> 00:05:30,398 because the way we perceive temperature is not just about the air temperature 186 00:05:30,399 --> 00:05:35,182 in the space, it's also the radiation of the sur- Ah, okay … the surfaces. 187 00:05:35,198 --> 00:05:40,573 So about 60% of the heat transfer from us to our environment is from our 188 00:05:40,579 --> 00:05:43,242 skin radiating towards cold surfaces. 189 00:05:43,794 --> 00:05:47,621 And so if you can imagine a building that's 22 degrees air temperature 190 00:05:47,621 --> 00:05:52,453 inside in winter, and you've got single glazing, then that glass is probably 15 191 00:05:52,453 --> 00:05:54,200 degrees maybe, the surface temperature. 192 00:05:54,582 --> 00:05:57,111 And so your skin is radiating to that surface. 193 00:05:57,335 --> 00:05:58,965 And how you- So how are you test- how are you testing radiation? 194 00:05:59,156 --> 00:05:59,355 You… 195 00:05:59,484 --> 00:06:01,049 This is a black bulb thermometer. 196 00:06:01,123 --> 00:06:04,482 So it's, the simple way to do this is you get a temperature sensor. 197 00:06:04,486 --> 00:06:05,945 These cost, like, two bucks. 198 00:06:06,403 --> 00:06:08,658 You put them in a, get this, in a- He's getting 199 00:06:08,658 --> 00:06:10,575 excited 'cause we've got him on a topic he loves here. 200 00:06:10,582 --> 00:06:11,058 I 201 00:06:11,058 --> 00:06:11,445 love it. 202 00:06:11,445 --> 00:06:13,225 I love it … you, you put them in a ping pong ball. 203 00:06:14,562 --> 00:06:18,248 And you pr- and you spray that ping pong ball matte black. 204 00:06:19,249 --> 00:06:21,411 So you cut, cut the ping pong ball in half and 205 00:06:21,411 --> 00:06:23,269 then- Or, you know, just cut a little hole, drill a little hole- 206 00:06:23,269 --> 00:06:23,909 Put it in there … in the bottom. 207 00:06:24,102 --> 00:06:24,325 Okay. 208 00:06:24,325 --> 00:06:27,012 You slot this thing on a wire, the sensor, the thermocouple- Like there's 209 00:06:27,013 --> 00:06:28,592 a- … into this ping pong ball. 210 00:06:28,618 --> 00:06:30,047 The black will absorb the heat the most? 211 00:06:30,090 --> 00:06:30,384 Yeah. 212 00:06:30,385 --> 00:06:33,243 And it's, and it's a, and it's absorbing the radiation from 213 00:06:33,245 --> 00:06:34,412 the environment around it. 214 00:06:34,749 --> 00:06:37,698 And so the air temperature within that ping pong ball is 215 00:06:37,698 --> 00:06:39,279 essentially the radiant temperature. 216 00:06:39,747 --> 00:06:42,924 So we're not talking radiation from maybe electrical wires here? 217 00:06:42,973 --> 00:06:43,331 No, no. 218 00:06:43,340 --> 00:06:44,586 We're, we're, we're talking- 219 00:06:44,674 --> 00:06:45,531 Not EMF stuff … thermal 220 00:06:45,537 --> 00:06:45,928 radiation. 221 00:06:45,938 --> 00:06:47,558 That's another thing we could test that Cam's big on. 222 00:06:49,383 --> 00:06:51,806 Fucking hell, Matt So you broke the bank 223 00:06:52,042 --> 00:06:52,392 I know. 224 00:06:52,610 --> 00:06:53,287 It's gonna get you. 225 00:06:53,585 --> 00:06:54,539 So m- moving on. 226 00:06:54,738 --> 00:06:59,152 So what… Okay, so, so I l- I love… I, I, my kids would love this, by the 227 00:06:59,152 --> 00:07:00,390 way, like actually going and doing it. 228 00:07:00,391 --> 00:07:02,057 But why would we bother testing that? 229 00:07:02,162 --> 00:07:02,793 Well, what's the benefit? 230 00:07:02,813 --> 00:07:04,762 What, what, what, what data is that giving us? 231 00:07:04,870 --> 00:07:09,649 So i- if you're trying to make an argument to a client, say for yourselves 232 00:07:09,649 --> 00:07:13,849 as builders, that we can't put single glazing in your house because it's 233 00:07:13,849 --> 00:07:17,306 gonna condensate and because your thermal comfort's not gonna be very 234 00:07:17,307 --> 00:07:21,792 good, you could use that to demonstrate that the overall surface temperatures 235 00:07:21,792 --> 00:07:24,938 within this room, if you've got a room that you can use, and there's plenty 236 00:07:24,938 --> 00:07:28,543 of buildings around that would be like that, uh, is, is significantly 237 00:07:28,544 --> 00:07:30,051 different to the air temperature. 238 00:07:30,242 --> 00:07:34,968 So that, that, um, uh, radiant surface temperature is much, much 239 00:07:34,968 --> 00:07:37,347 lower, and therefore it's not gonna be comfortable for you. 240 00:07:37,347 --> 00:07:37,373 A- 241 00:07:37,442 --> 00:07:39,877 and this hooks back to your little data hub that you'd make 242 00:07:39,889 --> 00:07:41,913 with the Raspberry Pi thing, and 243 00:07:42,273 --> 00:07:43,512 just simply- That, that's the way I do it- Yeah … but you can buy 244 00:07:43,513 --> 00:07:44,779 these things as commercial things. 245 00:07:44,781 --> 00:07:44,892 Okay. 246 00:07:44,892 --> 00:07:48,724 There's a, there's a mob in, um, I think it's Canada or the US that sells a box. 247 00:07:49,040 --> 00:07:52,250 I did look at buying one of those, like 600 US bucks or something like that. 248 00:07:52,669 --> 00:07:56,339 It's, it's a, it measures to ASHRAE 55, which is the com- 249 00:07:56,394 --> 00:07:57,528 thermal comfort standard. 250 00:07:57,583 --> 00:07:57,761 Yeah. 251 00:07:57,809 --> 00:08:01,173 And so it measures air temperature, relative… uh, no, not relative humidity, 252 00:08:01,207 --> 00:08:02,993 'cause that's not a, a variable at play. 253 00:08:03,260 --> 00:08:06,281 This, this whole radiant surface temperatures and stuff, 254 00:08:06,628 --> 00:08:07,773 and it gives you that data. 255 00:08:07,773 --> 00:08:11,002 It's a very cool little gadget that we've… Well, heaps of fun. 256 00:08:11,471 --> 00:08:11,778 Uh- 257 00:08:12,221 --> 00:08:13,699 But we don't need it for the way we would build. 258 00:08:13,721 --> 00:08:14,305 We kinda know. 259 00:08:14,564 --> 00:08:19,814 No, unless you wanna verify that what you've done is, is, is bee's knees. 260 00:08:20,222 --> 00:08:20,447 Yeah. 261 00:08:20,449 --> 00:08:25,093 Um, but, but I suppose this is the other big thing with monitoring, is like it's 262 00:08:25,100 --> 00:08:29,873 one thing to get data, which is these days is relatively cheap and easy to do, 263 00:08:30,508 --> 00:08:32,868 but the data of itself is not the object. 264 00:08:32,952 --> 00:08:34,254 I've got a bunch of numbers here. 265 00:08:34,283 --> 00:08:35,213 So what? 266 00:08:35,456 --> 00:08:35,794 Yeah. 267 00:08:35,881 --> 00:08:37,645 How do I interpret this data? 268 00:08:37,655 --> 00:08:43,751 How do I analyze this data in order to obtain information or insights into the 269 00:08:43,751 --> 00:08:46,023 problem I, uh, was asking at the outset? 270 00:08:46,443 --> 00:08:48,778 So back to Matt's word, you know, hypothesis. 271 00:08:48,786 --> 00:08:50,615 That's what scientists like to use. 272 00:08:50,979 --> 00:08:59,473 My hypothesis is that, uh, you know, the, um, the, the cavity within this wall is, 273 00:08:59,494 --> 00:09:03,569 is going to have very, uh, extreme… 274 00:09:03,616 --> 00:09:05,458 you know, is gonna suffer from lots of condensation- 275 00:09:05,531 --> 00:09:06,481 Yeah … or something like that. 276 00:09:06,687 --> 00:09:10,518 And, and you might then go and define what you mean by lots 277 00:09:10,519 --> 00:09:11,955 of condensation numerically. 278 00:09:12,025 --> 00:09:12,198 Yep. 279 00:09:12,441 --> 00:09:16,750 And then you go and design an experiment in order to test that hypothesis. 280 00:09:17,785 --> 00:09:22,000 Or you might be at a more sort of, uh, subjective level. 281 00:09:22,691 --> 00:09:26,269 Uh, as a client, the client has built, you know, commissioned you to build 282 00:09:26,269 --> 00:09:30,239 their house, and they're h- hopefully very happy with it subjectively. 283 00:09:30,510 --> 00:09:33,143 But hey, I'm numerically oriented. 284 00:09:33,369 --> 00:09:37,714 I want to understand more how, how to benchmark the performance of this house. 285 00:09:37,725 --> 00:09:39,577 Well, humidity was a, that's what went wrong with my own house, so 286 00:09:39,577 --> 00:09:41,909 I thought, well, living quite in a hu- like it was quite humid. 287 00:09:42,391 --> 00:09:44,158 So yeah, perfect example, right? 288 00:09:44,172 --> 00:09:47,807 So, you know, the conversation we had last summer was you'd 289 00:09:47,807 --> 00:09:49,170 just moved into your house. 290 00:09:49,182 --> 00:09:52,603 You said it felt like it was really humid, and we happen to 291 00:09:52,615 --> 00:09:54,061 have sensors in your building. 292 00:09:54,070 --> 00:09:54,274 Yeah. 293 00:09:54,391 --> 00:09:57,985 The temperature and relative humidity sensors, and I could demonstrate to 294 00:09:57,986 --> 00:10:03,202 you through that data that in fact the humidity in your house was well within the 295 00:10:03,202 --> 00:10:05,199 boundaries that I would expect it to be. 296 00:10:05,973 --> 00:10:10,454 Which I think was right b- in the sense that the way we 297 00:10:10,454 --> 00:10:12,262 perceive humidity is really 298 00:10:13,920 --> 00:10:15,872 Like it's how, like I found, I found it stickier So what, so we don't… So what, 299 00:10:15,890 --> 00:10:17,063 what, yeah, so what was it in 300 00:10:17,067 --> 00:10:19,281 your- I just found it a little bit stickier than what I thought so. 301 00:10:19,308 --> 00:10:22,075 But as we'd probably, we'd just moved in, there was a lot of water 302 00:10:22,077 --> 00:10:23,243 that went into the lime wash paint. 303 00:10:23,527 --> 00:10:25,536 The slab was probably still somewhat curing. 304 00:10:25,800 --> 00:10:27,185 There's a lot of plaster water. 305 00:10:27,224 --> 00:10:29,476 Like- Yeah … there's still water within the building most likely that was still- 306 00:10:29,492 --> 00:10:31,144 But, but you didn't- Yeah … have excessive humidity. 307 00:10:31,156 --> 00:10:31,464 No, no, no. 308 00:10:31,642 --> 00:10:31,666 We didn't. 309 00:10:31,666 --> 00:10:31,876 So, so I 310 00:10:31,888 --> 00:10:32,457 think that's- 311 00:10:32,473 --> 00:10:33,394 Yeah, that, that's, yeah, 'cause you, you just 312 00:10:33,395 --> 00:10:35,410 said- But also compared to outside it was pretty low 313 00:10:35,521 --> 00:10:37,560 I, I, I think what you're experiencing was temperature. 314 00:10:37,736 --> 00:10:37,987 Yeah, yeah. 315 00:10:37,987 --> 00:10:42,072 So o- often in the summer, i- certainly in southern Australia, when we 316 00:10:42,175 --> 00:10:46,708 claim it's really humid today, it's often just because it's quite warm- 317 00:10:46,842 --> 00:10:47,192 Yeah, yeah 318 00:10:47,208 --> 00:10:47,698 … inside. 319 00:10:47,724 --> 00:10:50,175 Was it, was it, was it… Do you also think that maybe in your situation it was 320 00:10:50,175 --> 00:10:52,174 just you recalibrating what you- It was 321 00:10:52,176 --> 00:10:53,183 expectation probably too 322 00:10:53,183 --> 00:10:53,616 was normal? 323 00:10:53,632 --> 00:10:53,948 Yeah. 324 00:10:54,058 --> 00:10:54,939 So like, uh- Yes. 325 00:10:55,002 --> 00:10:57,618 Like- So in summer- Yeah … I think of what I've learned, you gotta work 326 00:10:57,620 --> 00:11:01,942 pretty hard with a energy efficient home to keep it low because if you 327 00:11:01,942 --> 00:11:03,674 just let it go, it will just cost- 328 00:11:03,674 --> 00:11:05,896 Be interesting, be interesting to have this conversation in, you 329 00:11:05,896 --> 00:11:08,232 know, April next year to see- Yeah 330 00:11:08,233 --> 00:11:08,857 what you experience 331 00:11:08,871 --> 00:11:10,320 because- Well, I know, I'm kind of learning how to use the house. 332 00:11:10,328 --> 00:11:10,396 Yeah. 333 00:11:10,396 --> 00:11:11,968 Like I didn't run my ceiling fans. 334 00:11:11,968 --> 00:11:14,702 I also don't have the best cross ventilation, but I know now how I 335 00:11:14,703 --> 00:11:15,984 could maybe- Yeah … improve on that. 336 00:11:16,207 --> 00:11:16,444 Yeah. 337 00:11:16,444 --> 00:11:16,454 Yeah. 338 00:11:16,519 --> 00:11:16,995 Um- 339 00:11:17,061 --> 00:11:19,800 And we did have a conversation- Yeah … about how, so in the thermal 340 00:11:19,800 --> 00:11:22,314 modeling, we make assumptions about how often you open your windows. 341 00:11:22,314 --> 00:11:22,487 Yeah. 342 00:11:22,525 --> 00:11:22,877 Yeah. 343 00:11:22,877 --> 00:11:25,809 And being in, in, in a western Melbourne, you weren't opening your windows. 344 00:11:25,809 --> 00:11:25,949 No. 345 00:11:25,949 --> 00:11:26,040 Do you know? 346 00:11:26,042 --> 00:11:28,852 I was just thinking as we're having this conversation, like, there's so, such 347 00:11:28,871 --> 00:11:34,525 great, like, YouTube, like, shorts that we could do out of these conversations. 348 00:11:34,528 --> 00:11:37,709 Like, I think there's like actually doing some of these experiments and 349 00:11:37,947 --> 00:11:41,338 showing people how easy they are and then putting it into context because maybe 350 00:11:41,339 --> 00:11:44,733 I'm just a nerd and I, I, I find this stuff interesting, but, like, this would 351 00:11:44,745 --> 00:11:46,403 be cool stuff to actually do at home. 352 00:11:46,659 --> 00:11:49,948 Mm. Like, if you're thinking about renovating and you're asking, "Why 353 00:11:49,949 --> 00:11:52,286 wouldn't I just turn the AC on?" Like, "Why wouldn't I just put the 354 00:11:52,288 --> 00:11:55,105 heater on?" And if you can actually do some of these really simple 355 00:11:55,105 --> 00:11:57,872 tests at home, you can actually demonstrate the reason why you would do 356 00:11:57,872 --> 00:11:57,983 it. 357 00:11:58,034 --> 00:12:02,323 Or, or conversely, why is it when I do turn the heating on, I'm still cold? 358 00:12:02,363 --> 00:12:02,863 Yes. 359 00:12:02,916 --> 00:12:03,386 There you go. 360 00:12:03,680 --> 00:12:06,361 Well- Yeah … the reason it's cold is because of radiating surface temperatures, 361 00:12:06,390 --> 00:12:08,182 and here's the data to demonstrate that. 362 00:12:08,182 --> 00:12:08,387 Yeah, yeah. 363 00:12:08,496 --> 00:12:10,819 I think the one that we looked at doing in mine, I just ran out of time because 364 00:12:10,820 --> 00:12:13,168 Nicole, uh, was due any day at that point. 365 00:12:13,170 --> 00:12:14,257 It was the last thing on my mind. 366 00:12:14,314 --> 00:12:17,890 We- the question we had was, and I always get this with clients with slabs, is 367 00:12:17,891 --> 00:12:19,195 like, "Oh, is it gonna be that warm? 368 00:12:19,195 --> 00:12:23,882 It's gonna be cold on the slab." Whilst I can tell you definitely not at my house. 369 00:12:24,183 --> 00:12:27,452 A temperature probe that we could've had that was hooked up would tell us at 370 00:12:27,453 --> 00:12:28,751 all times what the slab was sitting at. 371 00:12:29,102 --> 00:12:31,819 Mm. Having said that, I kind of now know with my underfloor heating in 372 00:12:31,819 --> 00:12:37,233 my, my bathroom upstairs, if I turn it on, it, it kinda gives me a gauge, 373 00:12:37,233 --> 00:12:41,632 a temperature sensor with, like, what it's at, and usually it's at 19.5 or 20. 374 00:12:42,050 --> 00:12:44,346 I don't know how accurate that is, but that- The 375 00:12:44,346 --> 00:12:45,176 slab is 19.5. 376 00:12:45,185 --> 00:12:45,425 Yeah. 377 00:12:45,425 --> 00:12:45,655 Roughly. 378 00:12:45,655 --> 00:12:45,939 Yeah. 379 00:12:45,977 --> 00:12:46,603 Roughly. 380 00:12:46,608 --> 00:12:46,618 Yeah. 381 00:12:46,798 --> 00:12:47,060 So- 382 00:12:47,113 --> 00:12:48,560 The slab itself is probably higher. 383 00:12:48,560 --> 00:12:51,446 Isn't that a thermo- stat in the room itself? 384 00:12:51,446 --> 00:12:52,853 So that's measuring air temperature. 385 00:12:53,534 --> 00:12:55,560 I, no, well, I don't know. 386 00:12:55,949 --> 00:12:58,663 Because it's, it's all hooked up through a wire to the, the coils underneath I've 387 00:12:58,663 --> 00:13:00,516 got a test that you could do to test the, um- 388 00:13:00,565 --> 00:13:01,279 I'll put a spindle- You get a 389 00:13:01,279 --> 00:13:02,485 ping pong ball, you cut it in 390 00:13:02,489 --> 00:13:03,170 half. 391 00:13:03,572 --> 00:13:06,903 Um- I, I think most of those devices, there'll be a little thermocouple within 392 00:13:06,905 --> 00:13:08,217 the controller- Big … on your wall. 393 00:13:08,232 --> 00:13:08,358 Yeah. 394 00:13:08,358 --> 00:13:09,774 And so it's measuring air temperature. 395 00:13:09,780 --> 00:13:09,851 Yeah. 396 00:13:09,991 --> 00:13:10,480 Yeah, okay. 397 00:13:10,534 --> 00:13:11,508 Uh, um- 398 00:13:11,517 --> 00:13:13,457 But a good one at the moment we're talking about a lot, and I've been 399 00:13:13,459 --> 00:13:16,507 joking for a while, is the n- you don't need treated pine batons. 400 00:13:16,897 --> 00:13:19,882 We now have sensors going in a lot of our projects, 'cause we've got this 401 00:13:19,882 --> 00:13:24,238 hypothesis, and we want to prove within Melbourne all the projects we're working 402 00:13:24,238 --> 00:13:26,597 on that, yes, you don't need treated pine. 403 00:13:26,605 --> 00:13:26,615 Mm-hmm. 404 00:13:26,730 --> 00:13:28,043 And that's my hypothesis. 405 00:13:28,482 --> 00:13:31,264 A- a- and I think, you know, a little, a word of caution that we need to 406 00:13:31,264 --> 00:13:32,792 be careful what we mean by proof. 407 00:13:33,115 --> 00:13:37,786 Like, you know, we've proved beyond reasonable doubt that smoking causes 408 00:13:37,786 --> 00:13:39,053 lung cancer and is bad for you. 409 00:13:39,053 --> 00:13:39,214 Yeah. 410 00:13:39,221 --> 00:13:39,377 Yeah. 411 00:13:39,434 --> 00:13:39,662 You know? 412 00:13:39,670 --> 00:13:40,062 That- Yeah, what 413 00:13:40,062 --> 00:13:41,195 you're doing is probably anecdotal 414 00:13:41,241 --> 00:13:43,640 … uh, a- a- and there is a- 415 00:13:43,807 --> 00:13:44,508 Nice beyond reasonable 416 00:13:44,510 --> 00:13:44,723 doubt. 417 00:13:44,724 --> 00:13:48,744 You know, s- s- science is about tr- trying to establish truth, 418 00:13:48,779 --> 00:13:50,215 but it is never definitive. 419 00:13:50,385 --> 00:13:50,503 Yeah. 420 00:13:50,503 --> 00:13:51,822 And it can always be questioned. 421 00:13:51,822 --> 00:13:55,836 So I might do some research and discover that, in fact, smoking is 422 00:13:55,837 --> 00:13:57,238 good for you because of something. 423 00:13:57,238 --> 00:14:00,371 Now, clearly the scientific community is gonna have, you 424 00:14:00,371 --> 00:14:02,105 know, raise eyebrows at that. 425 00:14:02,109 --> 00:14:04,668 And so your evidence to refute that- 426 00:14:04,915 --> 00:14:05,109 Yeah 427 00:14:05,113 --> 00:14:09,870 … years of experience and knowledge has got to be bloody compelling in order 428 00:14:09,871 --> 00:14:11,785 to change everyone's view of the world. 429 00:14:11,820 --> 00:14:16,237 But that is how science works, is continually doing new research- 430 00:14:16,274 --> 00:14:19,791 Yeah … testing existing hypotheses, trying to find holes in things. 431 00:14:19,872 --> 00:14:23,906 Yeah, and I think for us with the, we just want to show that- I, I'm 432 00:14:23,914 --> 00:14:26,559 pretty certain we don't need it, and we can have a rough guide that it's, 433 00:14:26,804 --> 00:14:30,224 whilst it's not a PhD or a thesis or anything like that, it's gonna be enough 434 00:14:30,227 --> 00:14:33,904 information that we feel comfortable that what we're doing is completely 435 00:14:33,904 --> 00:14:35,449 fine I think at the end of the day, that's what it comes down to. 436 00:14:35,459 --> 00:14:38,645 Like- Yeah … and, and, okay, this is my opinion, my opinion only. 437 00:14:38,714 --> 00:14:43,003 Like, on a wall, on a vertical surface on a wall, I would be like, "Yeah, you know 438 00:14:43,003 --> 00:14:48,613 what? I'd probably put non-treated pine battens, uh, hard up against the, um, 439 00:14:48,614 --> 00:14:52,301 cladding, and then non-treated battens for the cladding battens." If I go to the 440 00:14:52,303 --> 00:14:56,752 roof, I'll probably put treated battens on them, like hard up against the, um… 441 00:14:57,190 --> 00:14:57,949 But that's just me. 442 00:14:57,968 --> 00:14:59,686 Well, that, that's where I've got- And that's where my gut, my gut 443 00:14:59,741 --> 00:15:02,376 feels And, and, and, and maybe more so on a flat roof than a sloping roof. 444 00:15:02,376 --> 00:15:02,496 Exa- 445 00:15:02,496 --> 00:15:02,928 exactly. 446 00:15:02,928 --> 00:15:03,107 Yeah. 447 00:15:03,107 --> 00:15:04,603 'Cause that's where I've got one of my sensors- Yeah … on a flat 448 00:15:04,603 --> 00:15:06,503 roof that gets- Yeah … zero sun. 449 00:15:06,676 --> 00:15:06,878 Yeah. 450 00:15:06,895 --> 00:15:08,286 At all, like zero, it's south. 451 00:15:08,309 --> 00:15:12,175 It's like it can't get sun, and it's on a cavity batten, and it's 452 00:15:12,175 --> 00:15:13,421 a white roof that's two degrees. 453 00:15:13,904 --> 00:15:14,646 Mm. With- 454 00:15:15,189 --> 00:15:18,074 A- a- and just back to the monitoring part of that. 455 00:15:18,080 --> 00:15:20,627 So what you've got in there at the moment is- Yeah … a temperature and 456 00:15:20,627 --> 00:15:23,888 relative- Yeah, yeah … humidity sensor that's measuring the conditions in 457 00:15:23,891 --> 00:15:25,444 the air- Yeah … within that cavity. 458 00:15:25,777 --> 00:15:29,594 And then the other way we do that for that particular problem is we use 459 00:15:29,594 --> 00:15:31,790 those little pin-type moisture meters. 460 00:15:31,790 --> 00:15:31,804 The 461 00:15:31,821 --> 00:15:32,699 pro- protometers, whatever 462 00:15:32,737 --> 00:15:33,044 you call them. 463 00:15:33,044 --> 00:15:33,054 Yeah. 464 00:15:33,054 --> 00:15:37,573 That, that screw into the, the stud and measure the water moisture 465 00:15:37,584 --> 00:15:39,359 content within the timber itself. 466 00:15:39,359 --> 00:15:39,747 Is that what you've 467 00:15:39,747 --> 00:15:40,915 got at- Pro- pro- protometers … have you done that at your 468 00:15:40,916 --> 00:15:41,584 place? 469 00:15:41,765 --> 00:15:44,075 S- so- Yeah … I've got, got a few of those around, and- Yeah … Sean 470 00:15:44,075 --> 00:15:45,180 down in Tassie's got plenty of them. 471 00:15:45,180 --> 00:15:45,652 I've got, I've 472 00:15:45,652 --> 00:15:47,199 got one in one of my projects as well. 473 00:15:47,294 --> 00:15:47,453 Yeah. 474 00:15:47,478 --> 00:15:49,493 If, if we're just buying them, we're gonna put one on each job. 475 00:15:49,852 --> 00:15:50,074 Yeah. 476 00:15:50,185 --> 00:15:52,272 So, so coming back to where we started. 477 00:15:52,500 --> 00:15:54,632 What's your question that you wanna find out about? 478 00:15:54,977 --> 00:15:57,386 How are we gonna evaluate that question? 479 00:15:57,483 --> 00:15:59,847 You know, what are the parameters by which we're gonna measure it? 480 00:15:59,872 --> 00:16:01,583 Temperature, water moisture content. 481 00:16:01,909 --> 00:16:03,990 And then what are our measures of success? 482 00:16:04,019 --> 00:16:08,587 What do we define as acceptable or failure for this particular, uh, 483 00:16:08,637 --> 00:16:10,242 question that we're asking ourselves? 484 00:16:10,343 --> 00:16:12,968 So what are we doing for the, the treated pine? 485 00:16:13,117 --> 00:16:15,670 Like, what would you consider an, an okay amount of absolute 486 00:16:16,335 --> 00:16:17,911 moisture within that cavity? 487 00:16:18,410 --> 00:16:22,007 Well, that's, so that's where, you know, when I started off this whole- 488 00:16:22,007 --> 00:16:24,520 Yeah … hornet's nest of of de- debate- 489 00:16:24,617 --> 00:16:24,824 Yeah 490 00:16:24,824 --> 00:16:30,197 … is I was demonstrating that the relative humidity, or, uh- Yeah … within 491 00:16:30,198 --> 00:16:33,983 that cavity, you know, spends a long period of time, from sort of evening, 492 00:16:33,983 --> 00:16:37,276 6:00 p.m. in the evening, till 8:00 or 9:00 a.m. in the morning- Yeah 493 00:16:37,276 --> 00:16:40,355 at or above 80% relative humidity in a Victorian climate. 494 00:16:41,327 --> 00:16:46,612 And I suggested that to me feels, my hypothesis is, that feels like 495 00:16:46,617 --> 00:16:50,627 that's quite a long time to be in that sort of condition in- 496 00:16:50,656 --> 00:16:50,816 Yeah 497 00:16:50,893 --> 00:16:52,557 … admittedly colder conditions. 498 00:16:52,973 --> 00:16:59,070 Is there sufficient drying during the subsequent day period- To more 499 00:16:59,073 --> 00:17:01,011 than compensate for that wetting that's occurred overnight And 500 00:17:01,012 --> 00:17:05,069 that's probably the time right now we're talking in middle of Aug- or 501 00:17:05,144 --> 00:17:07,642 middle of August is this is where it's like the worst drying capacity A- 502 00:17:07,699 --> 00:17:10,004 a- and you're seeing that for your house already. 503 00:17:10,004 --> 00:17:12,476 Well- You know, the roof is getting high relative humidity 504 00:17:12,627 --> 00:17:16,165 But it's, for sometimes it's actually colder in that cavity than it is outside 505 00:17:16,355 --> 00:17:19,665 A- and that was to my point, that it's extreme in both directions. 506 00:17:19,666 --> 00:17:23,361 Yeah When the sun is out and striking that- Yeah … that cladding, the 507 00:17:23,363 --> 00:17:25,286 cavity is warmer than outside. 508 00:17:25,286 --> 00:17:28,178 Yeah Overnight, especially on a clear night- 509 00:17:28,252 --> 00:17:28,531 Yeah 510 00:17:28,531 --> 00:17:30,654 it will be colder than outside. 511 00:17:30,670 --> 00:17:31,240 Yeah, I noticed that. 512 00:17:31,240 --> 00:17:33,942 I was, I was like, "Oh, it's ac-" and it was, like, two degrees colder 513 00:17:33,994 --> 00:17:34,655 in that little cavity Is it night 514 00:17:34,655 --> 00:17:35,008 sky 515 00:17:35,196 --> 00:17:35,420 radiation? 516 00:17:35,420 --> 00:17:36,321 Radiation, yeah Correct. 517 00:17:36,539 --> 00:17:40,377 But what that doesn't establish is that the batten's gonna rot 518 00:17:41,333 --> 00:17:41,669 Yes. 519 00:17:42,590 --> 00:17:46,673 And that's the, that's the, you know, if there's a weakness in my argument, I 520 00:17:46,675 --> 00:17:48,828 argue it's that second part of the link. 521 00:17:49,034 --> 00:17:53,127 The, the first part of my argument that these are extreme environments, I think 522 00:17:53,129 --> 00:17:56,166 I can, you know, confidently state. 523 00:17:56,455 --> 00:17:59,906 I cannot say that that means your button's gonna rot out. 524 00:17:59,982 --> 00:18:03,045 Well, the best way to do it is in 30 years, take off everyone's 525 00:18:03,047 --> 00:18:06,018 bull and roof and go do a massive eye test and see what's happened. 526 00:18:06,018 --> 00:18:07,773 Which is a bit late, of course. 527 00:18:07,808 --> 00:18:08,112 Yeah. 528 00:18:08,393 --> 00:18:08,599 Uh, 529 00:18:08,632 --> 00:18:08,936 yeah. 530 00:18:09,189 --> 00:18:11,826 Um, but just coming back to the whole monitoring question. 531 00:18:11,851 --> 00:18:16,201 So I think we've got, there's probably three classes of monitoring 532 00:18:16,201 --> 00:18:17,488 we might wanna do on a building. 533 00:18:17,744 --> 00:18:20,922 So we've got thermal comfort, temp- temperature, relative humidity. 534 00:18:20,922 --> 00:18:22,423 Let's put that in a, a box. 535 00:18:22,450 --> 00:18:22,700 Yep. 536 00:18:23,434 --> 00:18:27,918 The second one is probably related to indoor environment quality or indoor 537 00:18:27,950 --> 00:18:32,622 air quality, things like, uh, everyone talks about CO2, carbon dioxide, 538 00:18:32,666 --> 00:18:35,365 particulate matter, and so on, which we can come back to in a second. 539 00:18:35,853 --> 00:18:38,692 And the third one is energy use. 540 00:18:39,584 --> 00:18:39,914 So- 541 00:18:40,018 --> 00:18:40,334 Oh, yeah 542 00:18:40,414 --> 00:18:44,573 … part, part of this that always comes up, especially in passive house world, is 543 00:18:44,574 --> 00:18:48,891 we've got these particular parameters, you know, our prediction of how much heating 544 00:18:48,891 --> 00:18:52,525 energy you're gonna require and how much cooling energy you're going to require. 545 00:18:53,163 --> 00:18:54,944 And you might ask a reasonable question. 546 00:18:55,299 --> 00:18:59,602 Having paid, you know, Carlin Construction or Sanctum Homes X dollars for my house, 547 00:18:59,999 --> 00:19:03,248 how do I know that I'm consuming as much energy as they say I would do? 548 00:19:03,302 --> 00:19:04,051 How do you do that? 549 00:19:04,053 --> 00:19:06,872 You have to go back to the switchboard on each circuit, put a sensor- 550 00:19:06,953 --> 00:19:08,717 With great difficulty- Just, yeah … is the short answer. 551 00:19:08,717 --> 00:19:08,773 Yeah. 552 00:19:08,791 --> 00:19:11,189 So you put a CT clamp, a current transformer- Yeah 553 00:19:11,189 --> 00:19:13,270 clamp on the, on the heat pump- 554 00:19:13,747 --> 00:19:13,931 Yeah 555 00:19:13,950 --> 00:19:14,528 … circuit. 556 00:19:14,583 --> 00:19:18,478 So you've wired up a, an in- a heat pump, you know, an AC inside. 557 00:19:18,816 --> 00:19:20,147 You put the CT clamp on it. 558 00:19:20,160 --> 00:19:24,658 You can measure the current draw going into that heat pump, how much 559 00:19:24,697 --> 00:19:28,852 energy, how many watts or how many watt hours are going into the heat pump. 560 00:19:29,475 --> 00:19:34,765 The problem is, that's not how much heating is going into the house or how 561 00:19:34,768 --> 00:19:36,166 much cooling is going into the house. 562 00:19:36,186 --> 00:19:36,213 It 563 00:19:36,222 --> 00:19:38,699 gets lost or it might be absorbed by the thermal mass in the house. 564 00:19:38,701 --> 00:19:38,797 Is 565 00:19:38,797 --> 00:19:39,156 that what you mean? 566 00:19:39,179 --> 00:19:39,457 No, no. 567 00:19:39,457 --> 00:19:41,772 It's because of the coefficient of performance- Okay. 568 00:19:41,772 --> 00:19:43,962 Yeah … the function of how the heat pump works. 569 00:19:44,391 --> 00:19:46,050 'Cause it- Yep … take it another way. 570 00:19:46,050 --> 00:19:46,213 It's not a 571 00:19:46,217 --> 00:19:46,984 one-to-one ratio. 572 00:19:46,985 --> 00:19:47,178 Is that 573 00:19:47,179 --> 00:19:47,471 what you mean? 574 00:19:47,471 --> 00:19:47,481 No. 575 00:19:47,744 --> 00:19:48,897 Let, let me take it another way. 576 00:19:48,899 --> 00:19:54,729 So Matt's got, um, a resistive heat, uh, heating in the floor in your bathroom. 577 00:19:54,789 --> 00:19:55,009 Yeah. 578 00:19:55,009 --> 00:19:55,019 Yeah. 579 00:19:55,027 --> 00:19:55,981 Super efficient heating. 580 00:19:56,873 --> 00:19:57,339 No, it's not. 581 00:19:58,038 --> 00:20:02,931 So if I, if I had that CT clamp on a circuit, like I just wired 582 00:20:02,941 --> 00:20:05,211 up one dedicated- Yeah … circuit for that, that- Yeah … uh, 583 00:20:05,232 --> 00:20:06,300 resistive heating element. 584 00:20:06,677 --> 00:20:11,113 If I know I've got one kilowatt of draw, or two-- let's go with a more 585 00:20:11,113 --> 00:20:13,229 realistic number, 200 watts- Yeah 586 00:20:13,229 --> 00:20:17,684 going through that circuit into your resistive towel rail, I know that I've 587 00:20:17,684 --> 00:20:21,412 got almost exactly 200 watts- Yep … of heating going into your bathroom. 588 00:20:21,558 --> 00:20:21,740 Yep. 589 00:20:21,859 --> 00:20:22,693 One to one, perfect. 590 00:20:22,736 --> 00:20:24,723 I've measured how much heating I put in my building. 591 00:20:25,503 --> 00:20:29,807 But for the vast majority of us, the most of our heating in the winter 592 00:20:29,840 --> 00:20:33,873 is being fed through, met through a heat pump, a reverse cycle AC. 593 00:20:34,401 --> 00:20:39,401 And so when you put that 200 watts into your Daikin, Mitsubishi, whatever 594 00:20:39,958 --> 00:20:43,662 heat pump, you're not actually generating 200 watts of heating. 595 00:20:43,731 --> 00:20:44,757 Might be generating 1,000. 596 00:20:44,959 --> 00:20:48,977 You're generating 1,000 because what you're doing is pumping heat energy. 597 00:20:49,412 --> 00:20:49,526 Yeah. 598 00:20:49,526 --> 00:20:52,892 You're running a compressor that's extracting heat energy from 599 00:20:52,892 --> 00:20:56,462 the air around you outside and injecting that inside the building. 600 00:20:56,607 --> 00:20:59,964 It's not moving air, to be clear, but it's moving the heat energy. 601 00:21:00,022 --> 00:21:00,338 Mm. Mm. 602 00:21:00,644 --> 00:21:04,305 And it's transforming it by a factor of three to five. 603 00:21:04,379 --> 00:21:04,762 Yeah, okay. 604 00:21:04,772 --> 00:21:07,802 So you'd have to have a… You'd have to know their coefficient performance, 605 00:21:07,805 --> 00:21:09,861 then do a calculation and convert that. 606 00:21:10,172 --> 00:21:10,495 Which- 607 00:21:10,540 --> 00:21:13,068 At a- Yeah … at a given temperature, and there's a whole bunch of factors 608 00:21:13,068 --> 00:21:16,509 that come into that because that COP is not a constant, and so 609 00:21:16,511 --> 00:21:18,147 it would always be an estimate. 610 00:21:18,668 --> 00:21:22,127 But depending on what you're trying to do, that might be fine. 611 00:21:22,338 --> 00:21:26,261 Like, if you're trying to validate your model, knowing that you're 612 00:21:26,262 --> 00:21:30,246 within plus or minus, say, 10% is almost certainly good enough. 613 00:21:30,318 --> 00:21:30,459 Yeah. 614 00:21:30,459 --> 00:21:32,520 You're not gonna try and sue your builder because you're 615 00:21:32,520 --> 00:21:34,491 using 10% more heating energy. 616 00:21:35,213 --> 00:21:36,087 If you use- Well, who's- 617 00:21:36,087 --> 00:21:39,033 five times more- Yeah … then you'd be like, "Hang on a minute. Did you put the 618 00:21:39,034 --> 00:21:40,445 insulation in that you said you did?" 619 00:21:40,445 --> 00:21:42,769 Or how's this, who's to say they haven't just left a window open the whole time? 620 00:21:42,882 --> 00:21:44,611 And, and there's, and, and, and- 621 00:21:44,612 --> 00:21:45,415 It's user error 622 00:21:45,446 --> 00:21:47,520 … how do you know if in the middle of winter they haven't set 623 00:21:47,520 --> 00:21:49,279 their thermostat to 26 degrees? 624 00:21:49,477 --> 00:21:49,803 Yeah. 625 00:21:50,172 --> 00:21:51,058 So, so, yes. 626 00:21:51,071 --> 00:21:53,881 So, so the, I think Jeremy Spencer says you can have a ten-star 627 00:21:53,881 --> 00:21:55,171 house with a one-star occupant. 628 00:21:55,419 --> 00:21:55,502 Yeah. 629 00:21:55,502 --> 00:21:58,204 Like, you know, it's, it's- That's actually good … it's brilliant, yeah. 630 00:21:58,206 --> 00:21:58,988 It's, it's spot on, 631 00:21:58,988 --> 00:21:59,301 isn't it? 632 00:21:59,301 --> 00:22:01,976 So, so let's go back to the second one when we think about air quality 633 00:22:01,976 --> 00:22:05,019 and stuff, because I think let's, let's look at old homes first 634 00:22:05,019 --> 00:22:06,267 that aren't even high-performing. 635 00:22:07,361 --> 00:22:10,547 Carbon monoxide monitoring should be in, uh, anything you're burning 636 00:22:10,548 --> 00:22:11,959 anything inside- Yeah … or gas 637 00:22:11,967 --> 00:22:12,431 appliances. 638 00:22:12,436 --> 00:22:15,465 So, so car- carbon monoxide only if you're burning something inside your house. 639 00:22:15,465 --> 00:22:15,475 Yeah. 640 00:22:15,790 --> 00:22:17,793 Or, or ga- or you got a gas cooktop. 641 00:22:18,433 --> 00:22:18,645 Yeah. 642 00:22:18,713 --> 00:22:19,032 Or not 643 00:22:19,032 --> 00:22:19,262 gas top. 644 00:22:19,262 --> 00:22:19,820 Well, that's, that's burning something in your house. 645 00:22:19,820 --> 00:22:20,374 Yeah, yeah, yeah, okay. 646 00:22:20,374 --> 00:22:21,145 Yeah, yeah, fair point. 647 00:22:21,246 --> 00:22:21,513 Yeah. 648 00:22:21,972 --> 00:22:22,196 Yeah. 649 00:22:22,196 --> 00:22:25,824 So, so, you know, don't burn stuff in your house, carbon monoxide problem goes away. 650 00:22:26,044 --> 00:22:26,259 Yeah. 651 00:22:26,342 --> 00:22:29,659 So do, too, does nitrogen dioxide, nitrogen- Yeah, yeah … oxides. 652 00:22:29,661 --> 00:22:29,937 Yeah. 653 00:22:30,178 --> 00:22:30,727 NOx. 654 00:22:30,846 --> 00:22:31,054 Yeah. 655 00:22:31,308 --> 00:22:35,775 Um, so you can do an awful lot for indoor air quality just by not burning stuff. 656 00:22:35,821 --> 00:22:36,043 Yeah. 657 00:22:36,153 --> 00:22:37,897 And that includes Hamish's fireplace. 658 00:22:39,121 --> 00:22:39,496 Um- 659 00:22:39,522 --> 00:22:42,237 And, A, can you get those cheap sensors as well, like we got for mine, for those 660 00:22:42,237 --> 00:22:43,293 sort of things, or that's a bit different? 661 00:22:43,301 --> 00:22:43,324 Yeah. 662 00:22:43,329 --> 00:22:47,326 You can go to Bunnings, they've got a CO2- CO- CO, carbon 663 00:22:47,327 --> 00:22:49,470 monoxide- Yeah … um, alarm. 664 00:22:49,708 --> 00:22:49,929 Yeah. 665 00:22:49,991 --> 00:22:51,581 Because this is such a critical problem. 666 00:22:51,586 --> 00:22:54,109 Especially, you know, everyone will have heard those stories about those 667 00:22:54,127 --> 00:22:55,793 un-flued gas heaters- Yeah, yeah 668 00:22:55,793 --> 00:22:59,141 that killed the little old lady because the thing gunked up. 669 00:22:59,215 --> 00:23:01,875 And carbon monoxide is clear, odorous. 670 00:23:02,411 --> 00:23:05,143 You just feel a bit drowsy, gonna have a bit of a nap, and you're dead. 671 00:23:05,610 --> 00:23:05,864 Yeah. 672 00:23:06,101 --> 00:23:06,437 Okay. 673 00:23:06,468 --> 00:23:08,579 So, so it's something… Okay, so you can get them from Bunnings. 674 00:23:08,618 --> 00:23:12,377 And okay, and they're, where are you in most of those f- is that 675 00:23:12,388 --> 00:23:15,580 mainly a gas appliance, or is that, a wood fire's just as highly likely? 676 00:23:15,678 --> 00:23:18,296 Well, a- any of, any incomplete combustion- 677 00:23:18,346 --> 00:23:19,660 Yeah … will generate some CO. 678 00:23:20,032 --> 00:23:20,205 Yeah. 679 00:23:20,205 --> 00:23:20,498 Okay. 680 00:23:20,714 --> 00:23:21,120 Um- Okay. 681 00:23:21,141 --> 00:23:21,657 Interesting. 682 00:23:22,115 --> 00:23:23,799 That's a very… Okay. 683 00:23:24,226 --> 00:23:27,518 And then because you did say that they, and it's from my basic 684 00:23:27,522 --> 00:23:29,982 chemi- chemistry knowledge, once you add that extra molecule, it's 685 00:23:29,982 --> 00:23:31,069 a whole different calculation. 686 00:23:31,110 --> 00:23:31,321 Yeah. 687 00:23:31,321 --> 00:23:31,331 Yeah. 688 00:23:31,331 --> 00:23:34,570 So this is, this, this was a, you know, a classic anecdote a few months ago. 689 00:23:34,575 --> 00:23:34,787 Yeah. 690 00:23:34,840 --> 00:23:38,297 A, a passive house project where the client had a fireplace and despite 691 00:23:38,297 --> 00:23:41,684 many years of me trying to convince them not to, they did it anyway. 692 00:23:41,745 --> 00:23:46,222 Okay, yes, you can certify passive houses with fireplaces. 693 00:23:46,222 --> 00:23:49,242 So if you're listening out there and adamant that's what you want to do, 694 00:23:49,803 --> 00:23:53,302 okay, I'm gonna try and convince you adamantly that you shouldn't do that. 695 00:23:53,573 --> 00:23:55,796 But ultimately you can do it. 696 00:23:56,258 --> 00:23:57,621 Uh, um, that- 697 00:23:58,508 --> 00:24:00,124 So more people do it just to annoy Cam. 698 00:24:00,128 --> 00:24:01,036 Yeah, possibly. 699 00:24:01,437 --> 00:24:03,523 And so in this, a- and, and one- They're fucking expensive 700 00:24:03,523 --> 00:24:03,765 as 701 00:24:03,781 --> 00:24:04,450 fireplaces 702 00:24:04,451 --> 00:24:07,613 too … one, one of the requirements if you do that for a passive house is 703 00:24:07,613 --> 00:24:09,945 that you have a carbon monoxide alarm. 704 00:24:10,004 --> 00:24:13,390 It's not a, it's not a monitor, it's not recording the carbon 705 00:24:13,402 --> 00:24:14,512 monoxide concentration. 706 00:24:14,525 --> 00:24:17,657 It just triggers and it sets off like a fire alarm, a smoke alarm. 707 00:24:18,028 --> 00:24:21,901 It just triggers when it hits the, a threshold to say- Open a 708 00:24:21,903 --> 00:24:23,701 window … "Shit's hit the fan. Get out of your building now." 709 00:24:23,914 --> 00:24:24,367 Okay. 710 00:24:24,524 --> 00:24:24,735 You know? 711 00:24:24,735 --> 00:24:28,603 And, and, and, and does it go… At that level, are you moving fast? 712 00:24:28,961 --> 00:24:29,762 Like, do you want to get out of the- 713 00:24:30,006 --> 00:24:30,295 Yeah 714 00:24:30,295 --> 00:24:31,776 'cause I, I, I don't know what the threshold is, so 715 00:24:31,776 --> 00:24:32,422 I'll be- You're not gonna go, 716 00:24:32,422 --> 00:24:33,344 " I'll, I'll be a few hours." 717 00:24:33,372 --> 00:24:33,495 No. 718 00:24:33,495 --> 00:24:34,609 You're not gonna finish your TV show. 719 00:24:34,665 --> 00:24:39,129 I mean, uh, cle- clearly they'd be setting it at a sensitivity way below the level 720 00:24:39,203 --> 00:24:40,087 at which- Oh, well, I was just gonna 721 00:24:40,214 --> 00:24:42,894 say- But if it w- w- just open all your windows and doors, worst case. 722 00:24:42,940 --> 00:24:45,856 Yeah, and turn off whatever the- Yeah, yeah, yeah … it is that you're doing. 723 00:24:45,888 --> 00:24:46,281 So cut, 724 00:24:46,332 --> 00:24:46,472 so 725 00:24:46,508 --> 00:24:46,815 carbon 726 00:24:46,815 --> 00:24:47,192 monoxide. 727 00:24:47,205 --> 00:24:50,162 You know, if for argument's sake it is a fireplace, you know, call someone 728 00:24:50,162 --> 00:24:52,255 to come and have a look at it- Yeah … 'cause maybe the flue's blocked up. 729 00:24:52,269 --> 00:24:52,468 Yeah, yeah. 730 00:24:52,468 --> 00:24:53,887 You know, obvious things like that. 731 00:24:54,110 --> 00:24:55,731 Um- Like, they're not, they're $20 on Amazon. 732 00:24:55,733 --> 00:24:57,653 I'm just looking right now, like, of the alarm. 733 00:24:57,660 --> 00:24:58,841 Like, they're not even that expensive. 734 00:24:58,887 --> 00:25:01,474 No, no, uh, to just like a smoke alarm, right? 735 00:25:01,807 --> 00:25:04,077 Um, so I think, you know, i- if you have combustion in your 736 00:25:04,081 --> 00:25:05,213 house, you should have that. 737 00:25:05,550 --> 00:25:09,839 The, the next one is you, you add an extra mo- oxygen molecule to carbon monoxide- 738 00:25:09,841 --> 00:25:12,673 It's CO2 … you get carbon dioxide, which is a completely different thing. 739 00:25:12,699 --> 00:25:16,294 And so coming back to my little anecdotal story, in that particular 740 00:25:16,294 --> 00:25:19,031 job, the client was adamant they had a carbon monoxide sensor. 741 00:25:19,655 --> 00:25:23,286 They sent me a photo of it to send to the certifier for review, and I looked 742 00:25:23,286 --> 00:25:27,357 at the photo, and it was an Aranet4, which is a carbon dioxide sensor. 743 00:25:27,875 --> 00:25:28,944 Which would've looked very high. 744 00:25:29,082 --> 00:25:29,370 That's true. 745 00:25:29,370 --> 00:25:29,828 You'd be dead. 746 00:25:29,872 --> 00:25:32,829 A- a- and they also had the, the IKEA one that I keep talking 747 00:25:32,837 --> 00:25:34,156 about and Hamish about too. 748 00:25:34,448 --> 00:25:36,981 Um, but they were measuring carbon dioxide. 749 00:25:37,021 --> 00:25:39,122 Completely different- … compound altogether. 750 00:25:39,130 --> 00:25:39,289 Molecule altogether. 751 00:25:39,302 --> 00:25:40,153 So what's different between the 752 00:25:40,154 --> 00:25:40,405 two? 753 00:25:40,618 --> 00:25:42,311 One's got an extra, two extra oxygen. 754 00:25:42,474 --> 00:25:43,054 So- Okay, okay. 755 00:25:43,054 --> 00:25:46,035 But what, what's, what's the reality of monoxide and 756 00:25:46,035 --> 00:25:46,821 dioxide? 757 00:25:46,821 --> 00:25:50,671 Yeah, so, so carbon dioxide is, again, a combustion byproduct, 758 00:25:50,671 --> 00:25:52,410 but is also something we exhale. 759 00:25:52,627 --> 00:25:52,739 Okay. 760 00:25:52,749 --> 00:25:56,370 So in a building- Yeah … the majority of the carbon dioxide in our 761 00:25:56,370 --> 00:25:59,721 environment either comes from outside, because there is, as we know, a 762 00:25:59,727 --> 00:26:01,825 concentration of carbon dioxide outside. 763 00:26:01,827 --> 00:26:01,842 Yep. 764 00:26:02,053 --> 00:26:06,329 About 425 parts per million at the moment, increasing at about two 765 00:26:06,329 --> 00:26:10,773 parts per million, contributing significantly to our, our climate crisis. 766 00:26:10,773 --> 00:26:10,970 Yep. 767 00:26:11,049 --> 00:26:11,427 Okay. 768 00:26:11,474 --> 00:26:14,904 Um, so some of it's coming from outside, but when I'm inside a 769 00:26:14,904 --> 00:26:18,955 building, the CO2 concentrations, like in this room that three of us are in 770 00:26:18,955 --> 00:26:23,679 a relatively small meeting room now, the CO2 in, in here is probably north 771 00:26:23,681 --> 00:26:28,779 of 1,000 parts per million You know, maybe 1,500, something like that Mm. 772 00:26:28,779 --> 00:26:30,927 So it's, it's a bit, it feels a bit stuffy in here. 773 00:26:31,175 --> 00:26:35,430 That's not, I would argue, the CO2 directly that we're 774 00:26:35,546 --> 00:26:37,083 experiencing or sensing 775 00:26:37,088 --> 00:26:37,886 The nitrous oxide? 776 00:26:38,241 --> 00:26:41,649 No, it's, it's, uh, odors- Okay … all sorts of other things that you 777 00:26:41,656 --> 00:26:42,722 sense that's- Ambience is a bit 778 00:26:42,722 --> 00:26:43,309 stinky 779 00:26:43,392 --> 00:26:47,858 … y- You don't, you don't really sense CO2. 780 00:26:47,936 --> 00:26:51,459 You can't, you know, um, sniff your nose and go, "Oh, it's about 781 00:26:51,459 --> 00:26:52,892 900 parts per million in here." 782 00:26:53,069 --> 00:26:54,449 What's a, what's a safe- Interesting … what's 783 00:26:54,450 --> 00:26:55,444 a, what's a safe level? 784 00:26:56,363 --> 00:26:56,709 Well- 785 00:26:56,723 --> 00:26:57,775 We don't know yet, do we? 786 00:26:58,269 --> 00:27:03,858 Well, I, I think that's a complicated que- question So, so n- normally you 787 00:27:03,859 --> 00:27:08,084 talk about 10,000 parts per million being really problematic, dangerous. 788 00:27:08,120 --> 00:27:12,522 I think 5,000 is sort of above that, is starting to get into 789 00:27:12,522 --> 00:27:13,947 your orange zone, if you like. 790 00:27:13,964 --> 00:27:14,245 Yeah. 791 00:27:14,314 --> 00:27:16,681 But those levels are never experienced in buildings. 792 00:27:16,681 --> 00:27:16,842 At what 793 00:27:16,843 --> 00:27:17,947 point does the canary die? 794 00:27:18,293 --> 00:27:21,360 At the canary, you know, 10,000, nor- well north of 10,000. 795 00:27:21,402 --> 00:27:21,748 Okay. 796 00:27:22,106 --> 00:27:22,333 You know, 797 00:27:23,292 --> 00:27:24,747 yeah, well, could be 100,000. 798 00:27:24,747 --> 00:27:25,717 I can't even remember that. 799 00:27:25,717 --> 00:27:25,855 Two, 800 00:27:25,855 --> 00:27:28,219 and if I ever s- Yeah, but- … if I ever, like, start, uh, like a 801 00:27:28,219 --> 00:27:32,035 sensor, um, company, it's gonna be called Canary, Yellow Canary. 802 00:27:32,237 --> 00:27:34,204 There's actually a sensor out there that actually- 803 00:27:34,380 --> 00:27:34,507 Oh, 804 00:27:34,509 --> 00:27:34,806 really? 805 00:27:34,812 --> 00:27:37,342 … flips upside down when your CO2 goes above whatever the 806 00:27:37,342 --> 00:27:37,769 threshold- And, and is, and is it a 807 00:27:37,769 --> 00:27:38,295 canary that 808 00:27:38,296 --> 00:27:38,669 just like- 809 00:27:38,671 --> 00:27:38,942 No. 810 00:27:39,173 --> 00:27:40,079 I think it's like a canary … Oh, that's brilliant. 811 00:27:40,079 --> 00:27:41,740 I'm gonna buy one of them just for the sake of it. 812 00:27:41,781 --> 00:27:44,673 Uh, for people who are not numeric, I guess it's kinda handy 'cause you 813 00:27:44,675 --> 00:27:45,668 don't have to worry about the number. 814 00:27:45,668 --> 00:27:47,803 It's canary's happy, canary's dead- … right? 815 00:27:47,890 --> 00:27:48,439 Well, I got a problem. 816 00:27:49,098 --> 00:27:54,363 Um, but what I would argue is those very high levels never happen, so the fact 817 00:27:54,363 --> 00:27:57,971 that I can't remember what those numbers are hopefully points to you to realize 818 00:27:57,978 --> 00:27:59,235 that- Yeah … they're immaterial. 819 00:27:59,452 --> 00:27:59,656 Yeah. 820 00:27:59,762 --> 00:28:02,425 What matters is, you know, those realistic levels that we 821 00:28:02,425 --> 00:28:03,597 might experience in buildings. 822 00:28:03,618 --> 00:28:05,860 An unoccupied building, about 420. 823 00:28:06,308 --> 00:28:09,233 Typical building, maybe 600 to 1,000. 824 00:28:09,929 --> 00:28:10,321 You know, so it's- What's a 825 00:28:10,321 --> 00:28:11,117 passive house sit at? 826 00:28:11,510 --> 00:28:12,815 Well, it, it depends. 827 00:28:13,456 --> 00:28:13,738 Fuck me. 828 00:28:13,755 --> 00:28:14,956 How many people are in the building? 829 00:28:15,185 --> 00:28:15,809 You just line him up then. 830 00:28:15,846 --> 00:28:16,090 But, 831 00:28:16,362 --> 00:28:17,660 uh- No, I thought it was about… I thought it, I said about 832 00:28:17,660 --> 00:28:18,703 five, yeah, 500 to 700 … yeah, 833 00:28:18,704 --> 00:28:20,686 in a bedroom, which is the critical- Yeah 834 00:28:20,686 --> 00:28:23,059 a master bedroom, where you often have two occupants and a relatively- And a 835 00:28:23,059 --> 00:28:27,447 dog … small volume for eight hours, then it will o- often go to 1,000 or 1,200. 836 00:28:27,467 --> 00:28:28,492 Even in a passive house? 837 00:28:28,515 --> 00:28:30,674 Mm. And what would a standard house as a comparison be? 838 00:28:31,089 --> 00:28:32,147 North of 2,000. 839 00:28:32,285 --> 00:28:32,632 Okay. 840 00:28:32,658 --> 00:28:35,168 And what about, what about a master bedroom with a dog, 841 00:28:35,236 --> 00:28:36,520 two adults, and three kids? 842 00:28:36,558 --> 00:28:37,260 It depends. 843 00:28:37,329 --> 00:28:37,803 What are you doing? 844 00:28:37,985 --> 00:28:40,742 Well, if you got, if, if you got ventilation, you know, it, it, it- 845 00:28:40,742 --> 00:28:42,748 No, it's cold in win- it's cold in Melbourne, so the- 846 00:28:42,748 --> 00:28:43,650 all the windows are closed 847 00:28:43,713 --> 00:28:44,879 Natural ventilation, isn't it? 848 00:28:44,954 --> 00:28:49,517 But, but, but whatever it is, I argue that it's not all that important. 849 00:28:49,607 --> 00:28:50,163 Yeah, okay. 850 00:28:50,321 --> 00:28:54,297 It, it's, that, those levels of CO2 are most certainly not gonna kill you. 851 00:28:54,405 --> 00:28:54,603 Yeah. 852 00:28:54,603 --> 00:28:55,793 That's not controversial. 853 00:28:55,867 --> 00:28:56,072 Yeah. 854 00:28:56,205 --> 00:28:59,686 There is some dis- debate or discussion about whether it affects 855 00:28:59,686 --> 00:29:03,216 your temporary cognition, you know, your ability to solve problems. 856 00:29:03,254 --> 00:29:03,428 Yeah. 857 00:29:03,680 --> 00:29:07,186 And as per a previous conversation we had, I argued, well, if that were 858 00:29:07,186 --> 00:29:11,265 true, why is it that submariners- operate in a submarine for north 859 00:29:11,266 --> 00:29:15,072 of 2,000 parts per million and are doing pretty damn complicated things. 860 00:29:15,072 --> 00:29:15,375 Yeah. 861 00:29:16,017 --> 00:29:20,675 Um, and the other part is that it might affect your sleep quality and make you 862 00:29:20,675 --> 00:29:22,525 a bit grumpy in the morning and so on. 863 00:29:22,525 --> 00:29:25,447 So, you know, temporary effects possibly- Kids will do 864 00:29:25,448 --> 00:29:26,140 that too, eh? 865 00:29:27,399 --> 00:29:30,564 I- it's a, it's, it… Th- th- these sort of, you know- And yours 866 00:29:30,564 --> 00:29:31,627 haven't even started yet, mate. 867 00:29:31,657 --> 00:29:32,280 You're, you're- No. 868 00:29:32,280 --> 00:29:32,656 No, she's started 869 00:29:32,695 --> 00:29:33,565 one, one year old. 870 00:29:33,652 --> 00:29:34,006 No. 871 00:29:34,235 --> 00:29:36,392 O- o- or cause you, like, headaches, things like this. 872 00:29:36,393 --> 00:29:36,820 I mean, the- You 873 00:29:36,820 --> 00:29:38,330 talking about kids causing headaches or the- 874 00:29:38,814 --> 00:29:40,658 A- and this is, this is the key thing, right? 875 00:29:40,667 --> 00:29:44,331 If you're trying to design an experiment to measure the impact of 876 00:29:44,331 --> 00:29:49,569 CO2 or, or say your hypothesis is that C- high CO2 concentrations above 877 00:29:49,569 --> 00:29:53,761 1,000 parts per million increase the r- likelihood of having a headache. 878 00:29:54,188 --> 00:29:55,664 Well, how do you design an experiment for that? 879 00:29:55,664 --> 00:29:55,994 What if you've got 880 00:29:56,001 --> 00:29:57,620 kids or what if- Because- … what if you've been up… Yeah. 881 00:29:57,658 --> 00:29:58,765 What do you find is good sleep? 882 00:29:58,889 --> 00:30:02,100 People are gonna get headaches anyway, regardless of- Hmm … the CO2. 883 00:30:02,100 --> 00:30:02,283 Do you take 884 00:30:02,300 --> 00:30:02,654 Panadol? 885 00:30:02,654 --> 00:30:03,742 Do you not take Panadol? 886 00:30:03,857 --> 00:30:07,397 And so this has always comes down to the quality of the design of experiment 887 00:30:07,411 --> 00:30:11,598 to try and separate the impact of CO2 on all the other things that cause 888 00:30:11,607 --> 00:30:14,777 headaches or whatever it is that these symptoms you're interested in. 889 00:30:15,120 --> 00:30:19,139 So I argue, yes, you can monitor CO2, and there are sensors out there that can do 890 00:30:19,140 --> 00:30:25,262 that now very cheaply, and they can do it reasonably well with the key caveat that 891 00:30:25,322 --> 00:30:28,655 all of them are recalibrating once a week. 892 00:30:29,198 --> 00:30:32,928 They have a process called automatic baseline calibration. 893 00:30:33,444 --> 00:30:38,721 So they take the past seven days of data in their little circuitry, 894 00:30:38,967 --> 00:30:41,532 and they say, "Right, what was the lowest value I measured?" 895 00:30:42,036 --> 00:30:45,291 And then they re-baseline that to atmospheric. 896 00:30:46,419 --> 00:30:51,789 So if we accept that outside is 420 parts, and I've measured that over 897 00:30:51,789 --> 00:30:57,129 the past week I got down to 500 parts, then I'm gonna re-baseline. 898 00:30:57,130 --> 00:31:03,085 I'm gonna shift all my data now down 80 parts because I, I have 899 00:31:03,088 --> 00:31:08,478 assessed that my sensor has drifted 80 parts away from baseline, and 900 00:31:08,479 --> 00:31:09,846 so then I'm gonna re-baseline. 901 00:31:10,308 --> 00:31:16,119 Now that works if your sensor is exposed to outdoor conditions once a week But 902 00:31:16,120 --> 00:31:21,143 in a building that might be occupied 24/7, CO2 might never drop below 600 903 00:31:21,144 --> 00:31:22,650 parts per million over that week. 904 00:31:22,778 --> 00:31:25,194 So you kind of need two sensors, one in, one out, that talk to each other. 905 00:31:26,021 --> 00:31:26,997 Conceivably. 906 00:31:27,058 --> 00:31:30,788 Um, but again, you know, to my mind, it doesn't much matter- 907 00:31:30,788 --> 00:31:32,777 So it's basically gonna get difference in 3%. 908 00:31:32,920 --> 00:31:37,133 A- and these sensors have got a f- you know, a, a, a variability in error 909 00:31:37,181 --> 00:31:41,638 accuracy to them anyway, and if you're measuring your CO2 at 1,000 when 910 00:31:41,638 --> 00:31:44,570 it's really 1100 or 900, who cares? 911 00:31:44,901 --> 00:31:45,152 Yeah. 912 00:31:45,267 --> 00:31:50,529 Especially given that we don't even know that there's a real impact. 913 00:31:50,624 --> 00:31:54,367 But something like P 2.5 is probably more important. 914 00:31:54,457 --> 00:31:57,708 And this comes to where I was alluding to the other day when 915 00:31:57,708 --> 00:31:59,349 I said measure what matters. 916 00:31:59,783 --> 00:32:06,449 Mm. So if we accept that the debate around CO2 as a pollutant in itself 917 00:32:06,472 --> 00:32:12,192 is disputed, then is there some other measure of air quality which does matter? 918 00:32:12,527 --> 00:32:19,033 And that, in my view, is fairly clear, and that is fine particular matter, PM 2.5. 919 00:32:19,437 --> 00:32:25,624 So the 2.5 means microns, so you know, m- uh, 10 to the minus six meters, so 920 00:32:25,670 --> 00:32:30,698 tiny little particles of dust, polle- well, pollens are much bigger than this, 921 00:32:30,698 --> 00:32:36,069 but thing, things in the air that we breathe in that get past all the hairs 922 00:32:36,069 --> 00:32:40,500 and stuff in with our throats and get deep into our lungs, go across the blood 923 00:32:40,570 --> 00:32:45,060 barrier, get absorbed into our blood, get into our brains, has been associated 924 00:32:45,062 --> 00:32:47,960 with dementia, all sorts of cancers, 925 00:32:48,438 --> 00:32:50,475 um- Like definitive like smoking, like we know this? 926 00:32:51,015 --> 00:32:51,213 Yeah. 927 00:32:51,272 --> 00:32:52,234 Uh, well, yes. 928 00:32:52,302 --> 00:32:56,265 So, well, so the evidence is increasingly clear- Okay … but 929 00:32:56,265 --> 00:32:57,491 we may try and be a little bit- 930 00:32:57,518 --> 00:32:59,917 So it's not like PFAS where we still don't know what it does. 931 00:33:00,735 --> 00:33:01,106 Yeah. 932 00:33:01,188 --> 00:33:05,476 Uh, what, what I think, you know, and clearly I'm no air quality expert, but- 933 00:33:05,703 --> 00:33:10,500 Pretty good … what, what, what the, what the, um, air quality community 934 00:33:10,502 --> 00:33:14,819 seem to have established over the past 15 or 20 years is that PM 2.5 935 00:33:15,191 --> 00:33:19,970 is increasingly coming up as by far and away the most significant indoor 936 00:33:19,972 --> 00:33:22,316 pollutant that affects our health. 937 00:33:22,329 --> 00:33:27,002 So the, what we're talking about now is those items that are burnt 938 00:33:28,030 --> 00:33:28,909 O- oftentimes. 939 00:33:28,953 --> 00:33:32,017 There, there, there was also, you know, when you get a windstorm through, 940 00:33:32,020 --> 00:33:33,678 it's blowing all sorts of stuff up. 941 00:33:33,678 --> 00:33:38,021 I mean, the dust you see is clearly much coarser, much broader 942 00:33:38,022 --> 00:33:39,912 than, than this very fine matter. 943 00:33:39,934 --> 00:33:40,019 Yep. 944 00:33:40,019 --> 00:33:41,994 But there'll be fine matter you can't see that apart from that. 945 00:33:41,994 --> 00:33:42,196 Yeah, it's like 946 00:33:42,196 --> 00:33:44,194 when you fry the dumplings off, that's what spikes mine. 947 00:33:44,293 --> 00:33:46,308 It kills Cam's data. 948 00:33:46,832 --> 00:33:47,119 Yeah. 949 00:33:47,208 --> 00:33:48,097 A- a- and, and 950 00:33:48,097 --> 00:33:48,928 there's- 'Cause it's just frying stuff. 951 00:33:48,931 --> 00:33:48,945 Yeah. 952 00:33:48,945 --> 00:33:50,839 If you boiled stuff all day, you'd be totally fine. 953 00:33:50,919 --> 00:33:51,219 Okay. 954 00:33:51,219 --> 00:33:55,792 So, so where is the PM2.5 in our buildings coming in, in from our houses? 955 00:33:55,806 --> 00:33:56,722 Let's concentrate on that. 956 00:33:57,070 --> 00:34:00,363 Half of it generally is coming from outside. 957 00:34:00,875 --> 00:34:03,983 And so that might be, you know, Matt always tells me how he 958 00:34:03,984 --> 00:34:05,600 lives in the western suburbs of- Pressure from into our, our twin, 959 00:34:05,600 --> 00:34:05,890 sorry 960 00:34:06,030 --> 00:34:07,673 … you know, industrial- Yep … things. 961 00:34:07,673 --> 00:34:09,496 You've got trucks, cars. 962 00:34:09,761 --> 00:34:12,382 You know, a car, uh, when you've got combustion, you've got 963 00:34:12,393 --> 00:34:13,880 stuff coming out of the exhaust. 964 00:34:14,159 --> 00:34:17,085 Even, like, the brake pads, when the brake pads go on, that generates 965 00:34:17,094 --> 00:34:18,415 lots of fine particulate matter. 966 00:34:18,420 --> 00:34:18,433 Yeah. 967 00:34:18,663 --> 00:34:20,837 The tires, when they're running on the road, they kick 968 00:34:20,837 --> 00:34:21,646 up all this fine particles. 969 00:34:21,646 --> 00:34:21,882 Other people 970 00:34:21,884 --> 00:34:24,359 burning the fire, which makes up, was it 33% of all? 971 00:34:24,696 --> 00:34:25,473 60, I would say. 972 00:34:25,473 --> 00:34:25,735 60, 973 00:34:25,743 --> 00:34:26,415 sorry, yes. 974 00:34:26,868 --> 00:34:27,136 Yeah. 975 00:34:27,136 --> 00:34:31,447 So, so t- what Matt was alluding there too is in the western suburbs of Melbourne, 976 00:34:31,755 --> 00:34:35,752 where they've done attribution studies to identify where all this PM2.5 is 977 00:34:35,752 --> 00:34:39,455 coming from, the typical response is, "Oh, it's all the factories in 978 00:34:39,455 --> 00:34:40,888 the west," or, "It's all the trucks." 979 00:34:41,172 --> 00:34:45,451 Well, no, 60% of it is p- domestic wood fires. 980 00:34:45,509 --> 00:34:46,040 Really? 981 00:34:46,085 --> 00:34:48,900 Imagine telling people, imagine being that dickhead that says, "Stop your 982 00:34:48,904 --> 00:34:50,609 wood fires." Imagine being that person. 983 00:34:50,609 --> 00:34:51,049 Ah. 984 00:34:51,049 --> 00:34:51,701 It'd be shocking. 985 00:34:51,701 --> 00:34:53,609 You'd break the internet if you suggested that. 986 00:34:54,225 --> 00:34:58,560 Um- … a- and then think of how many people actually have wood fires in, 987 00:34:58,560 --> 00:34:59,080 in the western suburbs of Melbourne. 988 00:34:59,080 --> 00:35:00,187 Can we just get some kind of clickbait here? 989 00:35:00,187 --> 00:35:00,971 Yeah, sorry to, sorry. 990 00:35:00,971 --> 00:35:05,077 Like, you know, how many people actually have wood fires in the western suburbs 991 00:35:05,077 --> 00:35:07,688 of Melbourne- Probably about- … and how many are running them on any one night? 992 00:35:07,702 --> 00:35:09,940 So probably, like, uh, I'm not… I'm gonna pull a number. 993 00:35:09,977 --> 00:35:14,252 Ma- maybe let's call it at a max 5% would have a wood fire, and of 994 00:35:14,254 --> 00:35:15,960 that 5%, how many are running it? 995 00:35:16,321 --> 00:35:16,636 And then- 996 00:35:16,673 --> 00:35:22,814 And, and yet they're contributing 60% of the PM2.5 in the winter season in western 997 00:35:22,814 --> 00:35:22,966 suburbs of Melbourne. 998 00:35:22,966 --> 00:35:25,022 'Cause lighting a fire takes effort, and when you come home from work, you 999 00:35:25,026 --> 00:35:28,293 go, "Oh, I can't be fucked. Just turn on the electric heater or don't have wood." 1000 00:35:28,703 --> 00:35:29,144 That's right. 1001 00:35:29,359 --> 00:35:32,580 So, so that's my… So half of it's coming from outside. 1002 00:35:32,604 --> 00:35:33,248 Is it dropping? 1003 00:35:33,295 --> 00:35:35,243 Because I'm assuming back in the day there would be a lot more 1004 00:35:35,243 --> 00:35:36,274 wood fires that have been lit. 1005 00:35:36,977 --> 00:35:40,199 Well, I, it's probably increasing over recent decades because it's 1006 00:35:40,200 --> 00:35:41,792 an increasingly popular thing. 1007 00:35:42,878 --> 00:35:44,832 Certainly in a lot of projects I'm involved in. 1008 00:35:44,836 --> 00:35:45,036 Yeah. 1009 00:35:45,242 --> 00:35:47,743 It, it feels like the fancier the house, the more likely 1010 00:35:47,744 --> 00:35:48,855 there is to be a fireplace. 1011 00:35:48,864 --> 00:35:51,396 Yeah, I've got to get a particulate sensor back outside, 'cause 1012 00:35:51,398 --> 00:35:53,708 mine caught fire, ironically. 1013 00:35:54,719 --> 00:35:54,901 What? 1014 00:35:55,000 --> 00:35:55,355 How did that- 'Cause I 1015 00:35:55,727 --> 00:35:57,233 put it, I, it's not meant to be the rain, I put it in the rain. 1016 00:35:57,251 --> 00:35:57,650 Oh, okay. 1017 00:35:57,982 --> 00:35:58,431 Yeah, okay. 1018 00:35:58,486 --> 00:36:01,861 So, so half of it's coming from outside, so how do we manage that? 1019 00:36:01,885 --> 00:36:04,507 Obviously an airtight building envelope is a great way to start. 1020 00:36:04,626 --> 00:36:04,791 Yeah. 1021 00:36:04,791 --> 00:36:05,639 Hey look, Passive House. 1022 00:36:05,957 --> 00:36:09,970 Uh, another part of course is HRV, so you filter any air that you 1023 00:36:09,972 --> 00:36:11,230 are bringing into the building. 1024 00:36:11,233 --> 00:36:11,243 Yeah. 1025 00:36:11,658 --> 00:36:15,751 But do bear in mind that most of the standard grade filters you have in 1026 00:36:15,757 --> 00:36:21,975 things like HRV are not capturing a, a pa- part of that PM2.5. 1027 00:36:22,025 --> 00:36:25,558 They're certainly catching some of it, but they don't have, you know, HEPA grade or 1028 00:36:25,563 --> 00:36:28,065 hospital grade filtration to capture- Mm 1029 00:36:28,065 --> 00:36:29,265 all of the really fine stuff. 1030 00:36:29,951 --> 00:36:35,428 The other half of the particulates are generating within the building, and so 1031 00:36:35,768 --> 00:36:41,842 the two obvious sources there are if you have a wood fire, and this is, you 1032 00:36:41,842 --> 00:36:45,441 know, where I get to my disgruntlement with people with wood fires. 1033 00:36:45,554 --> 00:36:45,994 Hamish. 1034 00:36:45,994 --> 00:36:49,274 A- and Hamish will tell me he's got a great wood fireplace with a closed 1035 00:36:49,277 --> 00:36:52,892 door that he keeps nice and sealed and stuff, and I'm like, "Yeah, but how 1036 00:36:52,893 --> 00:36:54,391 do you get the wood into that fire?" 1037 00:36:54,436 --> 00:36:55,095 It's Blue Cheese. 1038 00:36:55,095 --> 00:36:56,770 "Oh, well, I open the door." Blue Cheese wood. 1039 00:36:56,770 --> 00:36:57,267 That, y- yeah. 1040 00:36:57,774 --> 00:37:00,516 Of course you're opening the door, and when you open the door, the room 1041 00:37:00,519 --> 00:37:04,147 floods with the particulates, which then continue to float around that 1042 00:37:04,147 --> 00:37:06,101 room thereafter, which you inhale. 1043 00:37:07,838 --> 00:37:08,688 So that's so- 1044 00:37:08,715 --> 00:37:13,151 But also on that, you're also… It's a selfish thing because 1045 00:37:13,152 --> 00:37:15,161 you're actually polluting the air outside to your neighbor. 1046 00:37:15,284 --> 00:37:16,610 Uh, ex- well, if, 1047 00:37:16,656 --> 00:37:18,701 uh, yeah- And who- that's assuming he's burning good stuff too. 1048 00:37:18,959 --> 00:37:21,970 Uh, uh, that's, that he's not burning treated pine, for example. 1049 00:37:22,263 --> 00:37:22,478 Yeah. 1050 00:37:22,537 --> 00:37:22,779 Yeah. 1051 00:37:22,922 --> 00:37:22,932 Anything 1052 00:37:22,932 --> 00:37:23,146 else? 1053 00:37:23,146 --> 00:37:25,074 But, but we, we shouldn't be having treated pine. 1054 00:37:26,366 --> 00:37:27,003 But, but- Have you got any 1055 00:37:27,012 --> 00:37:27,474 data on that? 1056 00:37:28,498 --> 00:37:30,990 In a, in an urban area, that's part of the thing, isn't it? 1057 00:37:31,006 --> 00:37:32,841 Or, or even regional towns. 1058 00:37:32,861 --> 00:37:32,923 It's 1059 00:37:32,923 --> 00:37:33,595 burn whatever you can get your 1060 00:37:33,598 --> 00:37:33,937 hands on. 1061 00:37:33,944 --> 00:37:37,389 This, this is what gets me in, like, you know, regional Victoria where, you know, 1062 00:37:37,623 --> 00:37:39,776 we, we, we all live in, in Victoria. 1063 00:37:40,205 --> 00:37:43,871 All of these regional towns, great air quality, and then come winter, 1064 00:37:43,871 --> 00:37:45,794 they're all firing up their wood fires. 1065 00:37:45,816 --> 00:37:49,436 Often these towns are in little valleys, and all the smoke just sits there. 1066 00:37:50,183 --> 00:37:53,436 I mean, I don't know, like I, I, I live, I wander outside on 1067 00:37:53,436 --> 00:37:55,932 a cold Sunday morning- I love 1068 00:37:55,932 --> 00:37:56,455 the smell of it 1069 00:37:56,703 --> 00:37:58,639 … and, like, I don't want to hate the smell. 1070 00:37:58,640 --> 00:37:59,973 I'm not saying you should go and light a fire. 1071 00:37:59,991 --> 00:38:03,295 But then where I am, like I kind of, I'm right near the river, so you 1072 00:38:03,297 --> 00:38:06,578 can kind of see the smoke sort of sitting over the river, and I'm like, 1073 00:38:06,596 --> 00:38:07,757 "Oh, this co- looks quite nice." 1074 00:38:07,782 --> 00:38:08,144 Beautiful. 1075 00:38:08,386 --> 00:38:08,654 It's like- It's 1076 00:38:08,654 --> 00:38:09,299 quite aesthetic 1077 00:38:09,332 --> 00:38:13,956 … it looks, a- a- and there's must be some innate genetic thing in us humans, right? 1078 00:38:13,956 --> 00:38:16,953 We all love the look of the flames and the- Yeah … randomness of them, 1079 00:38:16,954 --> 00:38:18,640 and I get that whole cozy thing. 1080 00:38:18,990 --> 00:38:20,858 That's all beside the way. 1081 00:38:21,453 --> 00:38:21,916 You know, the, the- 1082 00:38:22,011 --> 00:38:22,751 Put it on the TV. 1083 00:38:22,763 --> 00:38:24,307 Just get the fireplace on YouTube and- 1084 00:38:24,496 --> 00:38:27,935 The evidence is what it is, that this stuff is not good to be burning. 1085 00:38:27,935 --> 00:38:28,219 No, 1086 00:38:28,271 --> 00:38:28,522 I know. 1087 00:38:28,539 --> 00:38:31,608 And, and I'm not, I'm not sitting here trying to argue against it either. 1088 00:38:31,629 --> 00:38:33,054 Like, I'm very well aware of it. 1089 00:38:33,074 --> 00:38:35,840 Yeah, you burned your fireplace on the weekend with your hot tub. 1090 00:38:36,020 --> 00:38:36,946 A- a- a- and to- 1091 00:38:36,983 --> 00:38:37,736 I'm not gonna stop. 1092 00:38:38,367 --> 00:38:38,853 I'm not gonna stop. 1093 00:38:38,913 --> 00:38:39,675 I'm very jealous. 1094 00:38:39,719 --> 00:38:40,656 I'm not, I'm not gonna stop. 1095 00:38:40,853 --> 00:38:41,953 I was in that wood fired hot 1096 00:38:41,980 --> 00:38:42,120 tub. 1097 00:38:42,120 --> 00:38:43,601 I'm so je-… I'm, I'm actually jealous. 1098 00:38:43,634 --> 00:38:44,847 In fact, do you know what? 1099 00:38:44,909 --> 00:38:46,476 It was too hot. 1100 00:38:46,525 --> 00:38:50,286 We actually had to put more cold water in it, it was that hot on the weekend. 1101 00:38:50,541 --> 00:38:54,773 But to be fair- … we all make risk assessments in our lives, you know. 1102 00:38:54,913 --> 00:38:58,365 Some of us drink, and alcohol's not good for us either, right? 1103 00:38:58,554 --> 00:39:01,365 We all know that, but we choose to take that risk. 1104 00:39:01,381 --> 00:39:04,947 And- Yeah … you know, driving a car, you might get dead when you jump in the car. 1105 00:39:05,390 --> 00:39:06,849 It's just a reality of life. 1106 00:39:06,862 --> 00:39:08,273 So we accept that there are risks. 1107 00:39:08,618 --> 00:39:13,755 But to Matt's point before, when you do start up that wood fire in a built-up 1108 00:39:13,756 --> 00:39:16,844 area, you're not just affecting yourself, you're affecting your neighbors. 1109 00:39:16,844 --> 00:39:16,860 Yeah. 1110 00:39:16,876 --> 00:39:19,453 So there is a moral question about this. 1111 00:39:19,797 --> 00:39:23,716 Um, but to the point of monitoring- These, these- What 1112 00:39:23,716 --> 00:39:25,709 was the other part that you were gonna say that makes up in the house? 1113 00:39:25,747 --> 00:39:26,317 We haven't got to the other 1114 00:39:26,317 --> 00:39:26,928 50% Oh, s- sorry. 1115 00:39:26,928 --> 00:39:27,183 Yes. 1116 00:39:27,183 --> 00:39:27,401 Right. 1117 00:39:27,401 --> 00:39:28,375 So combustion. 1118 00:39:28,375 --> 00:39:29,633 So first part is combustion. 1119 00:39:29,633 --> 00:39:31,024 Wood fires are concentrated on. 1120 00:39:31,024 --> 00:39:33,270 If you've got gas cooktop- Yeah … obviously that's contributing. 1121 00:39:33,270 --> 00:39:34,057 We know that's bad. 1122 00:39:34,057 --> 00:39:35,526 So don't burn stuff in buildings. 1123 00:39:35,531 --> 00:39:35,721 Yeah. 1124 00:39:35,935 --> 00:39:39,305 The other part is related to burning, which is, uh, cooktops. 1125 00:39:39,435 --> 00:39:42,656 Whenever you are cooking something, like frying something on a frying 1126 00:39:42,656 --> 00:39:46,848 pan, you are generating a whole range of gases- Oh, yeah … and 1127 00:39:46,857 --> 00:39:48,037 p- and partic- particulate things. 1128 00:39:48,464 --> 00:39:50,316 To Matt's point, you know, frying dumplings. 1129 00:39:50,316 --> 00:39:52,084 Dumplings, stir fries, Asian food. 1130 00:39:52,198 --> 00:39:54,243 You spike the fuck out of it. 1131 00:39:54,475 --> 00:39:54,852 Yeah. 1132 00:39:54,919 --> 00:39:55,314 I would know. 1133 00:39:55,314 --> 00:39:55,984 I don't monitor it. 1134 00:39:56,055 --> 00:39:58,997 Oh, it's… Especially if I joke that, look- See, 1135 00:39:58,997 --> 00:40:00,491 no, sometimes ignorance is bliss. 1136 00:40:00,493 --> 00:40:02,645 Like, living in a non-passive house- I, I put- … when you've got the 1137 00:40:02,647 --> 00:40:04,180 fireplace there and nothing's- 1138 00:40:04,185 --> 00:40:04,671 Look, I will- 1139 00:40:04,689 --> 00:40:07,734 … beeping at you or anything like that, just is like everything's fine and dandy 1140 00:40:07,772 --> 00:40:08,519 I put my hand up. 1141 00:40:08,519 --> 00:40:10,986 I did make a mistake, and I will agree with you, Cam. 1142 00:40:11,004 --> 00:40:13,368 I should have ducted my range hood outside and not recirculated 1143 00:40:13,370 --> 00:40:15,488 it after seeing the data. 1144 00:40:16,366 --> 00:40:19,841 I, I'm looking forward to the letter that s- says, "Cameron, you were right." 1145 00:40:19,946 --> 00:40:24,214 You, you are right, but still, I still will argue that I would not 1146 00:40:24,256 --> 00:40:27,104 do a above cooktop range hood. 1147 00:40:27,122 --> 00:40:30,470 I would still downdraft, even though the physics suggests that it's not right. 1148 00:40:30,716 --> 00:40:31,525 I know, but I- Well, 1149 00:40:31,525 --> 00:40:34,520 I'd, I'd much rather a downdraft that's externally venting- 1150 00:40:34,578 --> 00:40:36,163 Yeah … you know, for the amount that's required … a- and I wish I did that. 1151 00:40:36,198 --> 00:40:41,754 And I don't think I can retrofit one in the future. 1152 00:40:42,328 --> 00:40:43,671 I, I probably do hard now. 1153 00:40:43,702 --> 00:40:45,138 I probably could if I wanted to. 1154 00:40:45,394 --> 00:40:46,881 Anything's possible with time and money. 1155 00:40:47,176 --> 00:40:47,625 Yeah. 1156 00:40:47,745 --> 00:40:47,919 I, 1157 00:40:47,921 --> 00:40:51,241 I- But, but, but I, I think, you know, I've got a recirc in my house- 1158 00:40:51,269 --> 00:40:51,598 Yeah 1159 00:40:51,696 --> 00:40:53,709 … because at the time I thought that was the- 1160 00:40:53,808 --> 00:40:54,167 It was fi- 1161 00:40:54,212 --> 00:40:56,084 it- … easiest and best choice. 1162 00:40:56,740 --> 00:41:00,220 We, you know, this is what we all constantly should be questioning 1163 00:41:00,220 --> 00:41:00,877 our assumptions and- What 1164 00:41:00,879 --> 00:41:04,604 is your particular insight of your 2.5 get up to if you cook, out of interest? 1165 00:41:04,607 --> 00:41:05,846 So have you spotted the highest you've spiked it? 1166 00:41:05,846 --> 00:41:08,377 Well, it, it varies wildly depending on what- Yeah … you're cooking, doesn't it? 1167 00:41:08,383 --> 00:41:08,562 But- 1168 00:41:08,564 --> 00:41:09,674 Have you hit the 999? 1169 00:41:09,698 --> 00:41:10,285 I've done that. 1170 00:41:10,394 --> 00:41:11,067 No, I've not. 1171 00:41:11,113 --> 00:41:12,634 Only if you blow a match right over the- 1172 00:41:12,663 --> 00:41:18,106 I literally was like, was this, uh- I think I was smoking something, which is 1173 00:41:18,902 --> 00:41:19,693 Well, crack? 1174 00:41:19,841 --> 00:41:23,814 No, no, I was smoking off like a, like a stir fry purposely, 1175 00:41:24,267 --> 00:41:25,853 and it, yeah, he went- It 1176 00:41:25,879 --> 00:41:26,517 went nuts, yeah … it 1177 00:41:26,517 --> 00:41:26,892 went. 1178 00:41:27,014 --> 00:41:31,527 A- and, and so, so, so the back to the point about monitoring, these 1179 00:41:31,527 --> 00:41:34,737 th- these things used to be really difficult and expensive to monitor. 1180 00:41:34,742 --> 00:41:36,727 You need, you know, lab grade stuff- Yeah … that would cost 1181 00:41:36,738 --> 00:41:37,826 tens of thousands of dollars. 1182 00:41:38,040 --> 00:41:39,244 That is no longer true. 1183 00:41:39,244 --> 00:41:39,352 Yeah, just 1184 00:41:39,352 --> 00:41:40,139 get them from China. 1185 00:41:40,300 --> 00:41:41,169 Al- AliExpress. 1186 00:41:41,190 --> 00:41:44,496 You can go to AliExpress and get this stuff for, like, well under 100 bucks. 1187 00:41:44,496 --> 00:41:46,954 You can go to, you know, I keep banging on about that one. 1188 00:41:46,955 --> 00:41:47,362 I can get it. 1189 00:41:47,362 --> 00:41:47,886 You can get it at IKEA. 1190 00:41:48,286 --> 00:41:52,937 Now, th- these, these sensors, and we'd need maybe to just talk about 1191 00:41:52,937 --> 00:41:56,163 the details of how these sensors work for a second, because it is 1192 00:41:56,164 --> 00:41:57,845 relevant to interpreting the data. 1193 00:41:58,356 --> 00:42:00,829 But these things are now well under 100 bucks. 1194 00:42:01,189 --> 00:42:06,395 Um, they are giving you a guide which your nose, eyes, et cetera, 1195 00:42:06,404 --> 00:42:08,183 have no way of really knowing about. 1196 00:42:08,184 --> 00:42:12,972 So to Hamish's point about ignorance is bliss- Mm … you carry on until 1197 00:42:12,974 --> 00:42:15,866 you get one of these things, and then you observe what it does. 1198 00:42:16,108 --> 00:42:19,280 And to your point, Matt, you observe it go nuts when you're 1199 00:42:19,295 --> 00:42:20,789 actually doing the cooking event. 1200 00:42:21,029 --> 00:42:26,240 But moreover, for the next four or five hours The room is still 1201 00:42:26,240 --> 00:42:27,848 indicating very high particulate levels 1202 00:42:27,848 --> 00:42:29,899 You've got to be at… Like, so I just open my big sliders 1203 00:42:29,901 --> 00:42:30,937 and open the windows and foom. 1204 00:42:30,942 --> 00:42:31,104 Fresh. 1205 00:42:31,104 --> 00:42:32,808 But I take an energy, I take an energy penalty. 1206 00:42:32,959 --> 00:42:36,515 But also the flip side, like if you have makeup air now with a thermal 1207 00:42:36,529 --> 00:42:38,852 box, you're gonna have a makeup, you're gonna have a penalty too. 1208 00:42:38,957 --> 00:42:41,682 A- and, and certainly in, you know, passive house where we're very keen 1209 00:42:41,682 --> 00:42:44,652 on trying to get- Yeah … that energy right, this is a significant impact. 1210 00:42:44,658 --> 00:42:46,862 So I don't shy away from the fact- Is it though? 1211 00:42:46,862 --> 00:42:47,660 … that it increases complexity. 1212 00:42:47,705 --> 00:42:48,562 I don't really care. 1213 00:42:48,622 --> 00:42:52,372 It's kinda nice, like, this sounds so precious, 'cause it's so warm inside. 1214 00:42:52,658 --> 00:42:55,346 Sometimes it is kinda nice to open the big slider when it's a bit cooler. 1215 00:42:55,390 --> 00:42:56,538 Ooh, it's nice. 1216 00:42:56,553 --> 00:42:57,176 So taking the cold 1217 00:42:57,182 --> 00:42:57,192 line. 1218 00:42:57,192 --> 00:42:59,518 It's like a bit of a fresh- it's like, it's like a cool breeze that's come past. 1219 00:42:59,548 --> 00:43:03,533 A- and certainly I think we'd all agree on balance, if it's gonna cost you an 1220 00:43:03,535 --> 00:43:05,910 extra 15 bucks a year to heat your house- 1221 00:43:06,033 --> 00:43:06,819 Not even that 1222 00:43:07,254 --> 00:43:12,199 to, to on the other hand, flush out these, you know- Yeah … harmful pollutants, 1223 00:43:12,202 --> 00:43:13,312 then clearly you're gonna choose 1224 00:43:13,312 --> 00:43:13,441 the former. 1225 00:43:13,441 --> 00:43:15,795 You'll drop it within three minutes quickly. 1226 00:43:15,821 --> 00:43:17,042 We were chatting a couple things and, um, 1227 00:43:17,330 --> 00:43:19,743 um, to- So just how do you sense it, monitor EMF? 1228 00:43:19,757 --> 00:43:20,546 We never got to that. 1229 00:43:20,779 --> 00:43:22,142 We… I'm just gonna ignore that. 1230 00:43:22,185 --> 00:43:25,578 Um, so it, like, it probably is a conversation we should have again 1231 00:43:25,578 --> 00:43:27,506 about externally ducted range hoods. 1232 00:43:27,509 --> 00:43:30,923 'Cause it is a, I think on 100% of my projects now, it's a topic- 1233 00:43:30,928 --> 00:43:32,580 Code … it's a topic of discussion. 1234 00:43:32,585 --> 00:43:33,319 Well, it's NCC though. 1235 00:43:33,941 --> 00:43:35,365 Well, you can get a performance solution. 1236 00:43:35,924 --> 00:43:38,006 I think y- I thought you need to still- 1237 00:43:38,330 --> 00:43:39,595 Yeah, I'm not sure if you can now. 1238 00:43:39,596 --> 00:43:40,527 No, I don't think you can. 1239 00:43:40,527 --> 00:43:44,529 I, I, I think you can on the basis that it's a moisture issue in the code, so you 1240 00:43:44,529 --> 00:43:46,920 could get a performance solution that- Yeah … your research is gonna work 1241 00:43:46,921 --> 00:43:48,203 with- Yeah … in correlation with HRV. 1242 00:43:48,223 --> 00:43:51,458 But I, regardless, I'm arguing it's not a good idea. 1243 00:43:51,613 --> 00:43:52,928 Externally vent your range hood. 1244 00:43:53,100 --> 00:43:53,598 Yeah, okay. 1245 00:43:53,598 --> 00:43:53,944 There you go. 1246 00:43:54,370 --> 00:43:58,368 Um, so other things we should monitor, um, bedrooms, bathrooms? 1247 00:43:58,874 --> 00:44:01,258 No, I don't need to monitor… If you have a… Well- 1248 00:44:02,028 --> 00:44:02,250 Yeah. 1249 00:44:02,266 --> 00:44:05,096 So, so, uh, you know, what are you monitoring- Yeah … in these spaces? 1250 00:44:05,109 --> 00:44:08,853 In, in your wet areas, your bathrooms, you're probably the relative humidity in 1251 00:44:08,854 --> 00:44:10,577 combination with temperature is critical. 1252 00:44:10,763 --> 00:44:11,118 Yep. 1253 00:44:11,308 --> 00:44:13,788 Emphasis on in combination with temperature, 'cause relative 1254 00:44:13,795 --> 00:44:16,156 humidity only means something if you know- It's always gonna be humid 1255 00:44:16,158 --> 00:44:17,214 in there when you've had a shower 1256 00:44:17,314 --> 00:44:17,927 … the temperature as well. 1257 00:44:17,927 --> 00:44:17,937 Yeah. 1258 00:44:17,937 --> 00:44:21,015 Uh, a- and you wanna see that diminishing- Yeah … over the subsequent, you know, 1259 00:44:21,019 --> 00:44:25,545 hour or so to, to minimize the risk of condensation and, and mold growth- Mm 1260 00:44:25,545 --> 00:44:26,522 forming in those spaces. 1261 00:44:26,903 --> 00:44:31,283 Um, but just if I can jump back to the sensors just for a second, these things 1262 00:44:31,286 --> 00:44:36,588 now are extraordinarily cheap And you can get any number of proprietary systems. 1263 00:44:36,595 --> 00:44:38,980 But I would just emphasize, 'cause everyone goes, "Ooh, what's 1264 00:44:38,980 --> 00:44:41,425 the most accurate one?" Well, that's not really the point. 1265 00:44:41,941 --> 00:44:44,633 You know, you're not looking for lab-grade accuracy anyway. 1266 00:44:44,633 --> 00:44:45,950 You're just looking for an indication. 1267 00:44:45,960 --> 00:44:48,351 Is, you know- Mm … has my PM gone through the roof 'cause I've 1268 00:44:48,351 --> 00:44:50,087 been frying dumplings or hasn't it? 1269 00:44:50,603 --> 00:44:54,086 Uh, so, you know, the precision is not, not so critical. 1270 00:44:54,543 --> 00:44:58,528 Um, what matters is probably the wrapper around it, particularly if you're not 1271 00:44:58,595 --> 00:45:01,816 a technically sort of interested, you just want something plug and play. 1272 00:45:01,982 --> 00:45:04,662 So has it got an app that I can pull up- Mm … and see what these 1273 00:45:04,664 --> 00:45:08,218 numbers are, and that tells me green, red, you know, so I can interpret 1274 00:45:08,240 --> 00:45:09,670 what is good and what is bad? 1275 00:45:10,110 --> 00:45:13,584 Uh, in the back end, is it logging and recording that data so I 1276 00:45:13,584 --> 00:45:16,913 can see historically am I better or worse than I was last week? 1277 00:45:16,970 --> 00:45:19,061 'Cause you're probably trying to manage your building better. 1278 00:45:19,061 --> 00:45:23,724 Mm. You know, I'm gonna open my sliding door after I do the cooking this week. 1279 00:45:24,239 --> 00:45:25,233 How have I performed? 1280 00:45:25,241 --> 00:45:25,817 You know, am I- 1281 00:45:25,818 --> 00:45:26,166 Yeah 1282 00:45:26,364 --> 00:45:29,424 … is it doing what I, I'm hoping it's going to do? 1283 00:45:30,790 --> 00:45:32,120 No, like I find it helpful. 1284 00:45:32,242 --> 00:45:36,149 Like it, it's kind of nice when, again, being precious, like I wake up, I can 1285 00:45:36,150 --> 00:45:39,531 check the outside temperature, and I'm like, "What do I need to wear today?" 1286 00:45:39,855 --> 00:45:43,095 Mm. 'Cause you do lose the perception of- Mm … what's comfortable. 1287 00:45:43,306 --> 00:45:47,407 A-a-and what I use this sort of data for, uh, from the thermal point of view, 1288 00:45:47,407 --> 00:45:50,324 but also from the air quality point of view, is trying to benchmark buildings. 1289 00:45:50,349 --> 00:45:54,476 Like, all of this data is only useful if it's contextual and if it actually 1290 00:45:54,476 --> 00:45:57,456 provides insight into a problem or- Mm 1291 00:45:57,456 --> 00:45:58,231 a solution. 1292 00:45:58,563 --> 00:46:03,259 Um, and if I can establish, say, the temperature, the diurnal 1293 00:46:03,260 --> 00:46:06,835 temperature range, so the high of the temperature during the day, it drops 1294 00:46:06,835 --> 00:46:08,587 overnight to a low in the morning. 1295 00:46:08,588 --> 00:46:11,842 And we know in our classic Aussie rubbish building, it might drop 1296 00:46:11,856 --> 00:46:13,339 10 degrees or more overnight. 1297 00:46:13,340 --> 00:46:15,640 You know, it's 10 degrees inside when you wake up in the morning. 1298 00:46:15,820 --> 00:46:17,276 Probably Hamish's house- Yep … now. 1299 00:46:17,322 --> 00:46:17,843 Definitely. 1300 00:46:17,882 --> 00:46:21,720 Um, whereas in Matt's house, without any heating overnight, it's probably 1301 00:46:21,721 --> 00:46:23,133 only dropping one or two degrees. 1302 00:46:23,168 --> 00:46:23,427 Yeah. 1303 00:46:23,681 --> 00:46:25,847 And so that's a benchmark of performance. 1304 00:46:26,231 --> 00:46:29,566 And so I can look at various buildings, you know, which, which I've been involved 1305 00:46:29,566 --> 00:46:33,158 or others have been, and you can say, "Well, how am I performing relative 1306 00:46:33,158 --> 00:46:35,492 to the greater cohort of buildings?" 1307 00:46:36,225 --> 00:46:39,176 A-a-and, and maybe that provides you some insight to say, "Well, 1308 00:46:39,177 --> 00:46:42,943 that building's performing really well because it's done X, Y, and Z." 1309 00:46:43,547 --> 00:46:44,416 What do you want to test? 1310 00:46:44,417 --> 00:46:49,062 If you could, if you could go forward, say, five years, and if we had a… 1311 00:46:49,284 --> 00:46:51,536 Like, what were three things you'd want to test to know the answer 1312 00:46:51,536 --> 00:46:54,418 to or have good data on right now? 1313 00:46:54,990 --> 00:46:57,143 I don't know about three things I can think of off the top of my head. 1314 00:46:57,152 --> 00:47:00,141 I think we need to know more about cavities and buildups. 1315 00:47:00,193 --> 00:47:00,212 Yep. 1316 00:47:00,212 --> 00:47:03,121 Like, uh, think about our flat roof details. 1317 00:47:03,162 --> 00:47:06,772 Mm. Um, you know, we all recognize now with flat roofs we're gonna 1318 00:47:06,785 --> 00:47:09,952 have a substrate on the top- Yeah … ply OSB or something, and 1319 00:47:09,952 --> 00:47:11,496 then maybe a peel and stick membrane. 1320 00:47:12,130 --> 00:47:15,836 If we're not having a, a vapor- Insulate … control or air, uh, vapor control membrane 1321 00:47:15,836 --> 00:47:21,255 on the inside, how problematic is that likely to be in our particular climates? 1322 00:47:21,579 --> 00:47:25,449 Like, we can do this hygrothermal wa- modeling using things like Wolfie to try 1323 00:47:25,449 --> 00:47:29,859 and get an idea on those sort of things, but how… D-does that reflect reality? 1324 00:47:30,376 --> 00:47:34,195 Um, and we're constantly playing with different wall and roof buildups, 1325 00:47:34,197 --> 00:47:35,422 you know, exterior insulation. 1326 00:47:36,190 --> 00:47:39,802 I, I'd love to see more monitoring of those buildups, you know, within 1327 00:47:39,802 --> 00:47:42,976 the assembly itself, not just within the house and outside the house, 1328 00:47:42,976 --> 00:47:44,652 but at different layers within. 1329 00:47:44,822 --> 00:47:45,267 So the one 1330 00:47:45,269 --> 00:47:47,437 Justin- I think, I think, I reckon that's the most important one, 'cause that, 1331 00:47:47,452 --> 00:47:48,713 that's the ones that you can't see. 1332 00:47:48,737 --> 00:47:52,615 Well, that's one like Justin's doing right now- … where it's the insulation at the 1333 00:47:52,626 --> 00:47:55,726 top quarter, bottom quarter of a truss roof- Yeah … and completely wrapping. 1334 00:47:55,980 --> 00:47:57,104 That to me is really interesting. 1335 00:47:57,413 --> 00:47:59,114 A- and I think we'd all agree on that. 1336 00:47:59,115 --> 00:47:59,125 Yeah. 1337 00:47:59,127 --> 00:47:59,588 So- It 1338 00:47:59,677 --> 00:48:00,419 can change a code. 1339 00:48:00,932 --> 00:48:01,762 Y- yeah. 1340 00:48:01,799 --> 00:48:06,418 A- and we need data- Yeah … and then to analyze that data, to provide insights- Mm 1341 00:48:06,435 --> 00:48:09,656 to go, "Hey, this actually looks like it's all right. We feel confident 1342 00:48:09,673 --> 00:48:12,813 now that this could be incorporated, say, into the building code." 1343 00:48:12,884 --> 00:48:13,150 Yeah. 1344 00:48:13,384 --> 00:48:14,245 If done this way. 1345 00:48:14,275 --> 00:48:16,381 Hey, um, Cam, thanks for coming on today. 1346 00:48:16,405 --> 00:48:20,054 Like I, I mean, I, I'm sitting here right now thinking I've got so 1347 00:48:20,054 --> 00:48:22,973 many more questions that I reckon this conversation could keep going. 1348 00:48:22,974 --> 00:48:23,242 Like, I'm 1349 00:48:23,243 --> 00:48:26,924 buying a CO2, not, no, not a CO2, sorry, a carbon monoxide monitor 1350 00:48:26,927 --> 00:48:28,131 for my parents' house now for their- 1351 00:48:28,178 --> 00:48:28,393 Yeah 1352 00:48:28,395 --> 00:48:28,899 … their wood fire. 1353 00:48:28,990 --> 00:48:30,462 I'm just gonna put it in their house- … go, go for it. 1354 00:48:30,471 --> 00:48:30,755 Yeah. 1355 00:48:30,799 --> 00:48:33,252 And at, like to what we were talking about before, I almost don't wanna 1356 00:48:33,252 --> 00:48:34,511 know, but I probably do wanna know. 1357 00:48:34,747 --> 00:48:38,708 Mm. And yeah, I've got a, I've got a young daughter and two young kids, you know. 1358 00:48:39,175 --> 00:48:41,751 And Junie, like, literally stands behind me while I'm like trying 1359 00:48:41,751 --> 00:48:43,690 to light the fire, and I'm like, "Hey, babe, you've gotta move out of 1360 00:48:43,694 --> 00:48:44,682 the way." And I'm just like- Yeah. 1361 00:48:46,051 --> 00:48:46,613 Thank you, Cameron. 1362 00:48:46,623 --> 00:48:46,794 Thank 1363 00:48:46,794 --> 00:48:47,468 you for your time again. 1364 00:48:47,468 --> 00:48:47,478 Yeah. 1365 00:48:47,504 --> 00:48:47,524 Thanks, Cam. 1366 00:48:47,524 --> 00:48:48,120 And do you know what? 1367 00:48:48,159 --> 00:48:52,495 I, I've said this once, I'll say it again, like the way that you have y- your ability 1368 00:48:52,497 --> 00:48:55,910 to actually break down complex pro- like- 1369 00:48:55,959 --> 00:48:56,808 Yeah, conversations 1370 00:48:56,808 --> 00:48:59,665 conversations, so some, an idiot like me can understand. 1371 00:48:59,668 --> 00:49:03,206 And, and even to, you know, the reports that you deliver as well, like I can read 1372 00:49:03,210 --> 00:49:05,411 through it, and it's such an easy read. 1373 00:49:05,631 --> 00:49:09,384 I joke and I say it takes me 20 minutes to fumble through something. 1374 00:49:09,386 --> 00:49:11,337 You explain it in three words, and they go, "Yeah. Got it." 1375 00:49:11,452 --> 00:49:12,122 Yeah, yeah. 1376 00:49:12,122 --> 00:49:12,875 So- No, so thanks. 1377 00:49:12,884 --> 00:49:13,538 Thanks for coming on. 1378 00:49:13,720 --> 00:49:14,091 Thank you. 1379 00:49:14,099 --> 00:49:14,521 Appreciate it. 1380 00:49:14,527 --> 00:49:14,547 No worries. 1381 00:49:14,547 --> 00:49:14,858 Thank you.