1 00:00:43,500 --> 00:00:46,260 All right, folks, this is Steve with Macro and Cheese. And 2 00:00:46,260 --> 00:00:49,140 you know what? It's been a minute since we've had MMT on the 3 00:00:49,140 --> 00:00:52,180 show. And the reason why that is is because we're talking about 4 00:00:52,180 --> 00:00:56,060 all the connected webbing, all the things that impact, you know, 5 00:00:56,220 --> 00:01:01,360 when I started first talking to MMT ers, I was such a childlike 6 00:01:01,360 --> 00:01:06,040 person. I really was. I had rose colored glasses on. And I think 7 00:01:06,040 --> 00:01:09,640 the very first time I met my guest, Bill Mitchell, you know, I 8 00:01:09,640 --> 00:01:12,640 was like, hey, you know what's going to change the world? We're 9 00:01:12,640 --> 00:01:15,520 going to, we're going to do all this stuff. And he kind of gently 10 00:01:15,520 --> 00:01:20,440 laughed at me and said, oh. He goes, stephen, this is going to be 11 00:01:20,440 --> 00:01:23,440 a bit of a project. This is going to go beyond our lifetimes, 12 00:01:23,440 --> 00:01:28,540 man. And basically, you know, all that has happened since then 13 00:01:28,940 --> 00:01:32,740 is that the rose colored glasses dropped. I still see many, 14 00:01:32,740 --> 00:01:36,060 many, many, many, many rose colored glasses folks out there. 15 00:01:36,300 --> 00:01:39,700 And maybe that's kind of like a phase of this MMT journey where 16 00:01:39,700 --> 00:01:43,020 you start off seeing the possibilities, but then, you know, 17 00:01:43,020 --> 00:01:46,300 as you get into this a little bit further, you start realizing 18 00:01:46,300 --> 00:01:51,620 that MMT is a lens. And if it's a lens, it's a lens into what 19 00:01:51,620 --> 00:01:56,530 is happening. And if you really want to use MMT as a lens 20 00:01:56,770 --> 00:02:00,730 to understand the world in which you live, Bill Mitchell is 21 00:02:00,730 --> 00:02:05,410 a great person to get to know. Bill Mitchell is one of the most 22 00:02:05,970 --> 00:02:11,689 real guys that I have ever met. And Bill has talked to me many, 23 00:02:11,689 --> 00:02:15,570 many times, patted me on the head gently, lovingly, got me through 24 00:02:15,650 --> 00:02:19,410 my, you know, enthusiasm, youthful enthusiasm. Well, I'm not 25 00:02:19,410 --> 00:02:22,420 young anymore and, and I realized there's a heck of a lot 26 00:02:22,420 --> 00:02:26,140 more road behind me than there is in front of me. And I'm not playing 27 00:02:26,620 --> 00:02:29,420 games anymore. You know, the things that we're talking about now 28 00:02:29,420 --> 00:02:34,660 are for realsies. We are talking about the actual application 29 00:02:34,660 --> 00:02:39,780 of the lens of mmt. And when you understand the stuff that Bill 30 00:02:39,780 --> 00:02:43,460 has written, and we'll go back to reclaiming the state, which I 31 00:02:43,460 --> 00:02:47,100 think is probably one of the most important books you will ever 32 00:02:47,100 --> 00:02:51,240 read. And if you haven't read it, read it, you must Read it because 33 00:02:51,240 --> 00:02:53,920 it's like telling you everything that's going on today. 34 00:02:54,480 --> 00:02:57,640 You know, And I think the big thing that we're going to talk about, 35 00:02:57,640 --> 00:03:02,520 aside from just where the economy is today and really kind 36 00:03:02,520 --> 00:03:06,800 of why it is the way it is today, is we're going to also strip 37 00:03:06,800 --> 00:03:12,440 bare that idea that the economy is broken and they just don't 38 00:03:12,440 --> 00:03:17,630 know what they're doing. They just don't understand. See, that 39 00:03:17,630 --> 00:03:23,390 lie has filled the American mind. Most of the people that I talk 40 00:03:23,390 --> 00:03:26,910 to in the MMT spaces still believe that we're going to vote 41 00:03:26,910 --> 00:03:30,190 a few more progressives in and we're going to change the world. 42 00:03:30,750 --> 00:03:34,950 But they don't understand. They do not understand the neoliberal 43 00:03:34,950 --> 00:03:39,710 project itself fundamentally stripped away the public comments, 44 00:03:40,270 --> 00:03:45,840 stripped away our agency, stripped away any semblance of democracy, 45 00:03:46,560 --> 00:03:54,920 cloistered power and wealth to the top.00, 0.1% and has continued 46 00:03:54,920 --> 00:03:59,680 to do so to this day. And folks, it's not just the great Americans, 47 00:04:00,080 --> 00:04:03,920 these super exceptional Americans. It's happening in Australia 48 00:04:04,320 --> 00:04:10,630 as well. It's happening around the world. This project that MMT 49 00:04:10,630 --> 00:04:16,110 reveals, if you have eyes to see and ears to hear, okay, you will 50 00:04:16,110 --> 00:04:20,870 begin to understand the world in which you live. MMT is the most 51 00:04:20,870 --> 00:04:24,790 accurate way of understanding the economy. It's the most accurate 52 00:04:24,790 --> 00:04:30,070 way of understanding the way monetary systems operate. And Bill 53 00:04:30,070 --> 00:04:33,950 Mitchell, who wrote this wonderful piece, which let me be 54 00:04:33,950 --> 00:04:39,010 fair, I say wonderful, but it's terrifying, but it's wonderful, 55 00:04:39,410 --> 00:04:43,290 called the US Economy on an unstable knife edge at present. Now, 56 00:04:43,290 --> 00:04:47,690 this is back on May 4th. We're in the June timeframe here, so get 57 00:04:47,690 --> 00:04:52,170 your bearings straight. But I asked Bill to come on and Bill was 58 00:04:52,170 --> 00:04:56,810 kind enough to join me because unlike a lot of folks, Bill does 59 00:04:56,810 --> 00:05:01,690 not have that Pollyanna version. And I can stay sane with 60 00:05:01,690 --> 00:05:05,010 somebody that's not speaking in Pollyanna terms, gaslighting me 61 00:05:05,170 --> 00:05:07,210 to believe it's all going to be better and we're just going to 62 00:05:07,210 --> 00:05:09,650 vote a few more progressives and everything's going to be better. 63 00:05:09,730 --> 00:05:13,730 No more lies like that. So without further ado, let me bring 64 00:05:13,730 --> 00:05:17,210 on my guest, Bill Mitchell. Thank you so much for joining me 65 00:05:17,210 --> 00:05:17,890 today, sir. 66 00:05:18,130 --> 00:05:21,650 Yeah, Steve, thanks very much for having me. And hello to all your 67 00:05:21,650 --> 00:05:26,410 listeners from Australia. Early morning Australia in beginning 68 00:05:26,410 --> 00:05:27,730 of winter. It's getting cold. 69 00:05:28,680 --> 00:05:31,360 Wow. It's so weird how different. I guess that's why they 70 00:05:31,360 --> 00:05:33,760 call it Down Under. I mean, it's like it's a totally different 71 00:05:33,760 --> 00:05:36,120 world. We're just getting ready to get warm over here and it's 72 00:05:36,120 --> 00:05:40,480 just becoming evening. But with that in mind, Bill, before we 73 00:05:40,480 --> 00:05:44,360 got started on this, we talked a little bit about the fact that 74 00:05:44,360 --> 00:05:48,520 progressives think that the system is broken. They fundamentally 75 00:05:48,520 --> 00:05:51,200 don't understand why there's always money for a war, but there's 76 00:05:51,200 --> 00:05:55,720 never money for health care. And if we could just get our representatives 77 00:05:55,720 --> 00:06:00,690 to vote the right way and if we could just take over the halls 78 00:06:00,690 --> 00:06:04,450 of whatever, everything would be okay. Hunky dory. I don't think 79 00:06:04,450 --> 00:06:08,770 they realize how late the hour is. And really the fix, what the 80 00:06:08,770 --> 00:06:13,210 fix is. Can you tell us a little bit about what the neoliberal 81 00:06:13,210 --> 00:06:16,650 era did and what the intentions of government is today? 82 00:06:16,970 --> 00:06:20,170 Not the one that everybody wants it to be. I want it to serve 83 00:06:20,170 --> 00:06:23,410 me. I want it to be good for my children. I want the wars to be, 84 00:06:23,410 --> 00:06:28,790 you know, for just causes. I mean, the real actual storyline here 85 00:06:28,950 --> 00:06:33,950 about what the neoliberal project is, was and what its intentions 86 00:06:33,950 --> 00:06:37,470 are and why people have got it wrong when they think the benevolent 87 00:06:37,470 --> 00:06:39,430 government is going to swoop in and save them. 88 00:06:40,070 --> 00:06:44,070 Yeah, well, I think you have to see the government as an institution 89 00:06:45,190 --> 00:06:51,310 and what MMT provides us with, as you use the words lens, and I 90 00:06:51,310 --> 00:06:58,180 introduced that term some many years ago to differentiate between 91 00:06:59,060 --> 00:07:04,740 a lens and an ideology or a set of values. And what MMT does 92 00:07:04,740 --> 00:07:12,020 is provide you with just a clearer lens into understanding how 93 00:07:12,020 --> 00:07:16,020 monetary systems, in other words, economies that use currencies, 94 00:07:16,900 --> 00:07:21,750 which are all the economies, how those currencies actually work 95 00:07:22,710 --> 00:07:29,750 and what the intrinsic capacities of the currency issuer 96 00:07:30,070 --> 00:07:37,110 are within a monetary system, and then what the implications are 97 00:07:37,830 --> 00:07:45,370 of using those capacities in different ways to implement public 98 00:07:45,370 --> 00:07:53,810 policy. Now that's where MMT ends. It's a very clear framework 99 00:07:53,810 --> 00:08:00,130 for understanding those things, but that's the end of it. 100 00:08:00,930 --> 00:08:06,930 And to make sense of the world then. So in other words, you ask 101 00:08:06,930 --> 00:08:14,720 the question, well, why is the American government able to shunt 102 00:08:15,280 --> 00:08:21,560 tons of metal from their planes into and bombing and killing 103 00:08:21,560 --> 00:08:25,760 and maiming and all of that in Iran at the moment? Well, at the 104 00:08:25,760 --> 00:08:28,200 moment they've stopped for a little while, but you know what I 105 00:08:28,200 --> 00:08:33,000 mean. And how can the Israeli government slaughter people in Gaza 106 00:08:33,000 --> 00:08:39,199 by bombing the hell out of them? How can they do that, given 107 00:08:39,199 --> 00:08:45,559 that on the other side they say they can't afford to provide 108 00:08:45,639 --> 00:08:53,119 poverty relief in America and. Or provide decent housing for homeless 109 00:08:53,119 --> 00:08:59,319 people? And so people say, well, how come once I know mmt, how 110 00:08:59,319 --> 00:09:04,150 come we know that the American government could, within the available 111 00:09:05,110 --> 00:09:10,870 productive resources, bomb the hell out of Iran and provide good 112 00:09:10,870 --> 00:09:16,230 healthcare and Education and housing up to the capacity of the 113 00:09:16,230 --> 00:09:22,950 available actual resources, you know, labor and materials. And 114 00:09:23,350 --> 00:09:27,830 so a lot of progressives get caught up in that dilemma of well, 115 00:09:27,830 --> 00:09:33,030 how come? But they don't ask the actual question because just 116 00:09:33,030 --> 00:09:37,590 knowing that the American government has no financial constraint 117 00:09:38,310 --> 00:09:42,710 is a pretty trivial piece of knowledge when it all comes down 118 00:09:42,710 --> 00:09:50,470 to it. And it's amazing how the mainstream narrative trips us 119 00:09:50,470 --> 00:09:57,440 up even on the most trivial fact and convinces us that the American 120 00:09:57,600 --> 00:10:01,920 government is like us as households with a financial constraint. 121 00:10:02,880 --> 00:10:09,040 That's how amazing the fiction that the mainstream economics profession 122 00:10:09,840 --> 00:10:16,400 succeeds in perpetuating. But the point is that knowing that's 123 00:10:16,400 --> 00:10:21,890 a fiction is really not much at all. So, you know, MMT is not 124 00:10:21,890 --> 00:10:27,690 that much at all. The question you've got to ask to understand how 125 00:10:27,690 --> 00:10:33,770 come we can bomb the hell out of Iran or America can, but not provide 126 00:10:34,810 --> 00:10:38,970 decent housing for its population. You've got to go and 127 00:10:38,970 --> 00:10:42,730 understand the dynamics of the actual system that manipulates the 128 00:10:42,730 --> 00:10:49,330 institutions of government, for example. And this is why my work 129 00:10:49,330 --> 00:10:54,610 has always emphasized that it's the understanding of the ideologies 130 00:10:54,610 --> 00:11:01,690 and the values and within this specific context, understanding that 131 00:11:02,090 --> 00:11:06,650 the system that we live in, which we broadly call capitalism, 132 00:11:07,450 --> 00:11:15,620 is a system that is defined by class conflict. And that class conflict 133 00:11:15,620 --> 00:11:21,220 is between broadly, the working class who doesn't have any 134 00:11:21,940 --> 00:11:27,980 means of production and has to sell their labor to a owner of the 135 00:11:27,980 --> 00:11:32,420 means of production, the capitalist class, in order to survive. 136 00:11:33,300 --> 00:11:36,900 And the capitalist class wants to get as much out of the worker 137 00:11:37,700 --> 00:11:43,260 as possible by way of labor time and therefore output, and pay 138 00:11:43,260 --> 00:11:48,340 them as least amount that they can get away with. And the working 139 00:11:48,340 --> 00:11:52,900 class want to do as little as possible for the capitalists and 140 00:11:52,979 --> 00:11:59,300 get paid as much as possible. And that those two conflicting ambitions 141 00:12:00,260 --> 00:12:06,810 really define the system we live in. And then the dynamics that 142 00:12:06,810 --> 00:12:15,330 emerge from that are what defines the policy choices that our 143 00:12:15,330 --> 00:12:22,250 institutions make. So for example, when the Second World War 144 00:12:22,250 --> 00:12:27,370 ended, and effectively the prosecution of the Second World War 145 00:12:28,170 --> 00:12:32,430 ended the Great Depression, that had sort of damaged economic 146 00:12:32,750 --> 00:12:40,190 prosperity during the 1930s. The situation was that the balance 147 00:12:40,190 --> 00:12:47,070 of power was much more tilted towards the working class and capital 148 00:12:47,230 --> 00:12:53,390 had to really bite its tongue because trade unions were becoming 149 00:12:53,390 --> 00:12:59,390 stronger and governments were charged with a sort of social democratic 150 00:12:59,470 --> 00:13:05,840 mission to reduce inequality both at wealth and income, provide 151 00:13:06,000 --> 00:13:11,840 jobs for everybody that wanted them. And that political mission 152 00:13:12,800 --> 00:13:17,560 gave us that so called golden age where we did observe, you know, 153 00:13:17,560 --> 00:13:23,120 the growth of public goods, the growth of public education, public 154 00:13:23,440 --> 00:13:28,700 health care, public transportation, publicly owned utilities 155 00:13:28,700 --> 00:13:33,700 across the world, reduced inequality, true full Employment 156 00:13:33,700 --> 00:13:39,300 unemployment was very low. Real wage growth for the ordinary 157 00:13:39,300 --> 00:13:44,060 person was strong. Productivity growth permitted that. 158 00:13:44,780 --> 00:13:48,540 And we had what seemed to be, you know, it was called the golden 159 00:13:48,540 --> 00:13:55,270 age, but it was still within capitalism and it was just permitted 160 00:13:56,070 --> 00:14:03,630 because the power of the people was expressed through the 161 00:14:03,630 --> 00:14:09,950 political process, was sufficient to offset the desires 162 00:14:09,950 --> 00:14:17,230 of capital to take everything for themselves. Now, if you trace 163 00:14:17,230 --> 00:14:21,650 the history of our economies and our societies over that period, 164 00:14:22,290 --> 00:14:28,850 what you'll understand is that capital was restive, it was not happy, 165 00:14:31,490 --> 00:14:38,290 but because of the political dynamics, it didn't have the capacity 166 00:14:38,290 --> 00:14:45,610 to completely undo the social democratic reforms. Now go into the 167 00:14:45,610 --> 00:14:50,770 1960s and you can see that capital was getting more organized. 168 00:14:51,570 --> 00:14:58,370 And by the early 70s, so in the late 60s, for example, in Australia, 169 00:14:58,530 --> 00:15:02,210 which was, you know, there are differences across the countries, 170 00:15:02,370 --> 00:15:06,850 but the dynamics are representative. In the late 60s, 171 00:15:06,850 --> 00:15:11,850 all the talk in the conservative media, which was mainly 172 00:15:11,850 --> 00:15:16,990 a print media in those days, was trade union power. We've got 173 00:15:16,990 --> 00:15:20,350 to do something about trade union power. As I was growing up 174 00:15:20,350 --> 00:15:24,910 at school, it was all the talk that we've got to reduce trade union 175 00:15:24,910 --> 00:15:28,150 power. Well, who was saying that? Well, the conservative press, 176 00:15:28,150 --> 00:15:33,430 funded by, which was the voice of capital, was saying that. And 177 00:15:33,430 --> 00:15:38,350 by the early 70s, the industrial capital, end of financial 178 00:15:38,430 --> 00:15:43,330 capital hadn't really emerged as the dominant expression of capitalism. 179 00:15:44,050 --> 00:15:48,690 Industrial capital decided that they need to become much more 180 00:15:48,690 --> 00:15:53,850 strategic. And in America, of course, we had the power manifesto 181 00:15:53,850 --> 00:16:01,730 in 1971 and that outlined a explicit strategy by which capital 182 00:16:01,890 --> 00:16:08,730 could regain power over the political process. And that strategy 183 00:16:08,730 --> 00:16:15,410 included things like creating think tanks. So these big think tanks, 184 00:16:16,290 --> 00:16:20,690 the American Enterprise Institute and the Cato Institute 185 00:16:20,690 --> 00:16:24,290 and these type of organizations, these were developments. 186 00:16:24,850 --> 00:16:29,410 Some had been around for years, but a whole lot of new ones 187 00:16:29,410 --> 00:16:33,890 emerged in the early 1970s, not only in America but elsewhere. 188 00:16:34,910 --> 00:16:41,350 And these became well funded institutions that were held out as 189 00:16:41,350 --> 00:16:45,910 research institutes, but were basically just propaganda and marketing 190 00:16:45,910 --> 00:16:49,710 institutes. And they were really well funded and they were 191 00:16:50,430 --> 00:16:55,230 very good at doing what they do. In other words, introducing information 192 00:16:56,270 --> 00:17:02,420 misinformation, masquerading as research, independent research 193 00:17:03,220 --> 00:17:07,140 that was. And then with this massive marketing and press machine 194 00:17:07,140 --> 00:17:13,780 added to it to manipulate the debate. The Powell Manifesto also 195 00:17:14,900 --> 00:17:19,180 developed pathways into the formal education system, both secondary 196 00:17:19,180 --> 00:17:25,380 and tertiary. And what you saw was a dramatic increase in, for example, 197 00:17:25,460 --> 00:17:31,309 funded chairs within the university system and curriculum 198 00:17:31,949 --> 00:17:37,709 that were aimed at influencing curriculum within our both secondary 199 00:17:37,709 --> 00:17:42,109 schools, but also within universities. And the other thing 200 00:17:42,268 --> 00:17:49,149 Powell recommended was that capital take over the media. And 201 00:17:49,229 --> 00:17:55,400 so what you saw in America and its derivatives was Fox News emerges 202 00:17:56,040 --> 00:18:00,760 and Sky News emerges around the world. You know, these Murdoch, 203 00:18:01,240 --> 00:18:07,000 you know, Australia's worst export, Rupert Murdoch, his media 204 00:18:07,080 --> 00:18:12,720 machine was, became a, you know, a misinformation propaganda 205 00:18:12,720 --> 00:18:20,320 machine that was explicitly working to advance the terms of the 206 00:18:20,320 --> 00:18:25,560 aspirations of capital. And so, you know, by the then we had 207 00:18:25,560 --> 00:18:31,080 the OPEC oil crisis in October 1973, when oil prices sort of went 208 00:18:31,080 --> 00:18:35,800 through, you know, double virtually overnight. And that really 209 00:18:35,879 --> 00:18:43,160 gave this emerging fight back by capital. It gave capital the COVID 210 00:18:44,040 --> 00:18:49,170 to allege that the inflation that emerged after that was really 211 00:18:49,250 --> 00:18:55,530 the result of excessive trade union power, of poorly designed and 212 00:18:55,530 --> 00:19:00,250 implemented social democratic welfare policies and all the rest 213 00:19:00,250 --> 00:19:06,690 of it, blah, blah. And even the progressive voices in those days 214 00:19:07,810 --> 00:19:13,360 fell prey to the narrative. And so you started to get, you know, 215 00:19:13,360 --> 00:19:16,880 progressives writing things like the Fiscal Crisis of the state 216 00:19:16,880 --> 00:19:23,520 James O', Connor 1973 the book where progressives were holding out 217 00:19:23,920 --> 00:19:27,520 what we now take as the mainstream progressive view that 218 00:19:27,680 --> 00:19:31,240 oh well, the government's going to run out of money. We want 219 00:19:31,240 --> 00:19:37,080 public hospitals and welfare policies, therefore we have to tax 220 00:19:37,080 --> 00:19:42,660 the rich and do something about the fiscal crisis to ensure 221 00:19:42,660 --> 00:19:47,700 that our progressive policies can be maintained. Now that was just 222 00:19:47,940 --> 00:19:53,540 gross naivety. A because modern monetary theory indicates 223 00:19:53,540 --> 00:19:58,860 that there was no fiscal crisis. There was just a takeover 224 00:19:58,860 --> 00:20:05,140 of government by capital. An explicit takeover. It wasn't a random 225 00:20:05,140 --> 00:20:09,530 event. It was an explicit strategic takeover of the institution 226 00:20:09,530 --> 00:20:15,090 of government. And what it did in the social democratic period those 227 00:20:15,650 --> 00:20:20,450 few decades, the government was really a mediator in the class 228 00:20:20,530 --> 00:20:24,570 conflict and it was sort of trying to balance itself between 229 00:20:24,570 --> 00:20:29,450 the competing interests. And so it would do a bit for labor, but 230 00:20:29,450 --> 00:20:32,850 it would make sure that it didn't disenfranchise capital because 231 00:20:32,850 --> 00:20:37,770 it couldn't afford to put the big media machines and that of they 232 00:20:37,770 --> 00:20:45,050 couldn't upset them too much. But by the 1970s and into the 1980s, 233 00:20:45,050 --> 00:20:51,210 as the neoliberal articulation became widespread throughout the 234 00:20:51,210 --> 00:20:57,290 academy and throughout the public policy institutions and throughout 235 00:20:57,290 --> 00:21:02,930 the, you know, the fourth estate and the media generally. Government 236 00:21:03,090 --> 00:21:07,330 shifted from being a mediator in the class conflict to being an 237 00:21:07,330 --> 00:21:13,930 agent of capital. And capital reconfigured the state. The state 238 00:21:13,930 --> 00:21:19,330 didn't go away. The state wasn't powerless. The emergence of 239 00:21:19,330 --> 00:21:23,250 global financial capital didn't render the national states 240 00:21:23,730 --> 00:21:29,380 powerless. All of the shifts that have occurred that we broadly 241 00:21:29,380 --> 00:21:34,340 call now liberalism occurred through the institution of the state, 242 00:21:34,660 --> 00:21:39,140 through its legislative and regulative capacities. And so really 243 00:21:39,140 --> 00:21:43,500 what capital understood was that if it wanted to achieve its 244 00:21:43,500 --> 00:21:48,740 neoliberal objectives, then it had to do it by co opting the state 245 00:21:48,820 --> 00:21:53,140 in its own image. And that's what happened. And the progressives 246 00:21:53,140 --> 00:21:58,720 sat there and started to worry about identity and politics and they 247 00:21:58,720 --> 00:22:03,840 gave up on the macroeconomic contest and basically just lay down 248 00:22:03,840 --> 00:22:10,560 and surrendered and felt warm and fuzzy by occasionally bleeping 249 00:22:10,560 --> 00:22:16,440 let's tax the rich. And that made them feel okay because it sounded 250 00:22:16,440 --> 00:22:21,850 as though it was a plan. But by then the state had been totally 251 00:22:21,850 --> 00:22:26,010 co opted to pursue the interests of capital. And so you 252 00:22:26,010 --> 00:22:30,250 had all the dimensions of that, the lobbying, the revolving 253 00:22:30,250 --> 00:22:35,210 door where ministers of government would be determining public 254 00:22:35,210 --> 00:22:39,770 policy one minute and then the next day they'd be being paid massive 255 00:22:39,770 --> 00:22:45,170 amounts as consultants or CEOs or something of some other, some 256 00:22:45,170 --> 00:22:49,730 company that was directly benefiting from the policies initiated 257 00:22:49,730 --> 00:22:54,290 the day before. The so called revolving door. And you know, capital 258 00:22:54,290 --> 00:22:59,170 stitched it up. And so when we bemoan the fact that the economy 259 00:22:59,250 --> 00:23:06,170 isn't working that oh woe is us, the economy's failing us, you're 260 00:23:06,170 --> 00:23:12,690 asking the wrong question. Because for the cohort that co opted 261 00:23:12,690 --> 00:23:17,630 government, the changes to our institution called government have 262 00:23:17,630 --> 00:23:23,670 been spectacularly successful, have achieved exactly what the goals 263 00:23:23,670 --> 00:23:29,550 of the takeover were. To redistribute national income to capital 264 00:23:29,950 --> 00:23:35,070 away from the working class. And all of the sort of smoke screens 265 00:23:35,070 --> 00:23:39,790 that get put up to blur the fact that there is a working class, 266 00:23:39,790 --> 00:23:44,110 you know, and to blur the fact that, that all these things are just 267 00:23:44,110 --> 00:23:51,910 happenstance, are just strategic structures to blind us 268 00:23:51,910 --> 00:23:57,550 from the reality that our institution, government, has been 269 00:23:57,550 --> 00:24:05,950 taken over. And the only way to shift it to a progressive orientation 270 00:24:06,830 --> 00:24:13,990 is to take it back, to reclaim it. And the only way, in my view, 271 00:24:13,990 --> 00:24:20,990 that that's going to occur is to overthrow the current power system. 272 00:24:21,790 --> 00:24:26,430 And that means, in my view, that the only future for humanity 273 00:24:26,830 --> 00:24:33,870 is to move beyond capitalism. Now how that's achieved is a good 274 00:24:33,870 --> 00:24:40,040 debate. But you know, I'm now I've been around for a while, my 275 00:24:40,040 --> 00:24:44,840 career is long. And that's where I've come to that all of the 276 00:24:44,840 --> 00:24:47,960 issues that we want our institutional government to address, 277 00:24:48,040 --> 00:24:52,520 like climate change, like peace, like reducing inequality, 278 00:24:53,320 --> 00:24:58,240 like making sure people have got jobs and homes, none of those 279 00:24:58,240 --> 00:25:02,360 things will be achievable in any satisfactory progressive way 280 00:25:03,310 --> 00:25:07,870 without a major shift in power relations within the system. 281 00:25:08,910 --> 00:25:13,070 You are listening to Macro N Cheese, a podcast by Real Progressives. 282 00:25:13,390 --> 00:25:18,510 We are a 501c3 nonprofit organization. All donations are tax 283 00:25:18,590 --> 00:25:22,670 deductible. Please consider becoming a monthly donor on Patreon 284 00:25:22,990 --> 00:25:28,150 Substack or our website, realprogressives.org now back to 285 00:25:28,150 --> 00:25:28,910 the podcast. 286 00:25:32,650 --> 00:25:36,530 You know, that brings me to probably the most painful point before 287 00:25:36,530 --> 00:25:40,290 we get into some of the stuff from your article, and that is I've 288 00:25:40,290 --> 00:25:43,570 talked about this many times and I'll continue to talk about it 289 00:25:43,570 --> 00:25:46,530 until I start to hear others bring it up constantly. And I don't 290 00:25:46,530 --> 00:25:49,290 hear any of them do it because they're, I believe they're cowards. 291 00:25:49,530 --> 00:25:53,610 I'll just say that point blank. But there was a study in 2014 292 00:25:53,850 --> 00:25:58,410 by Princeton called Gillinson Page, where they identified that 293 00:25:58,410 --> 00:26:05,050 the interests, the desires of the voting public had a statistical 294 00:26:05,130 --> 00:26:10,330 near zero impact on public policy. People walk right by that 295 00:26:10,330 --> 00:26:13,209 like I didn't say it, or better yet, they treat it like I 296 00:26:13,209 --> 00:26:16,410 said it. And I didn't have backup for it. But that right there 297 00:26:16,410 --> 00:26:23,050 is a study done by a reputable university, very, very detailed study 298 00:26:23,790 --> 00:26:28,230 that showed, quite frankly, that we live in an oligarchy. Now, 299 00:26:28,230 --> 00:26:31,070 I have friends that will go out there and say, steve, but we're 300 00:26:31,070 --> 00:26:33,270 just going to go ahead and keep doing the same shit we've been 301 00:26:33,270 --> 00:26:36,550 doing over and over again, expecting different results. They 302 00:26:36,550 --> 00:26:39,470 pat me on the head and they walk away. You don't have to like 303 00:26:39,470 --> 00:26:43,030 me. I'd like you to, but you don't have to like me. Go fact check 304 00:26:43,030 --> 00:26:45,950 what we're talking about, what I'm saying and what you're saying. 305 00:26:45,950 --> 00:26:52,140 Because for me, the thing that interested me most and MMT was that 306 00:26:52,140 --> 00:26:58,180 it blended so many. You had to understand everybody else's stuff 307 00:26:58,180 --> 00:27:02,980 so you could explain what they got wrong. So the lens, you could, 308 00:27:03,220 --> 00:27:07,260 through interdisciplinary understanding, you could see the 309 00:27:07,260 --> 00:27:10,900 lens in action. You could understand the motivations once you 310 00:27:10,900 --> 00:27:15,840 understand what is possible. And for a long time, I kept banging 311 00:27:15,840 --> 00:27:18,840 my head against a wall thinking that Bernie Sanders was 312 00:27:18,840 --> 00:27:23,000 going to come and save the world and AOC was going to come save 313 00:27:23,000 --> 00:27:26,720 the world. And there's a lot of MMT'ers out there that will repeat 314 00:27:26,720 --> 00:27:31,480 that to this day in the year of our Lord 2026, which is preposterous. 315 00:27:32,520 --> 00:27:36,840 But here we are in the year of 2026. We're watching the United States 316 00:27:36,920 --> 00:27:41,690 snag up Maduro, a democratically elected, you know, 317 00:27:42,010 --> 00:27:46,810 head of state, okay? And we were watching them bomb Iran. We've 318 00:27:46,810 --> 00:27:51,930 watched them bomb Iraq. We've watched them start proxy wars with 319 00:27:51,930 --> 00:27:56,010 Ukraine. We've watched them do all sorts of things. None of these 320 00:27:56,010 --> 00:28:01,210 things insane stuff with this Trump administration, and absolutely 321 00:28:01,210 --> 00:28:06,170 none of it is stuff that any one of us really voted for. The people 322 00:28:06,250 --> 00:28:10,070 themselves are sitting there scratching their heads, saying, what 323 00:28:10,070 --> 00:28:13,030 Is this. I was at a gas station the other day filling up 324 00:28:13,030 --> 00:28:18,430 my tank, my car, it was $5 a gallon, which is huge for us. I mean, 325 00:28:18,670 --> 00:28:23,349 299 is terrible, but $5 was ridiculous. And nobody's getting 326 00:28:23,349 --> 00:28:27,870 pay raises. And I was sitting there pumping gas and this guy comes 327 00:28:27,870 --> 00:28:33,760 up with a big maga hat on and he says, you know something? He goes, 328 00:28:33,840 --> 00:28:37,960 I told my boss the other day that I have to get a part time job 329 00:28:37,960 --> 00:28:42,640 just to cut the grass because of the gas. And I started laughing. 330 00:28:42,640 --> 00:28:46,360 I said, you know something, that's pretty slick, you know? And 331 00:28:46,360 --> 00:28:50,160 we started talking about it. I broke the MMT story down to him and 332 00:28:50,160 --> 00:28:52,640 I told him point blank. He goes, well, I don't want to get political. 333 00:28:53,200 --> 00:28:56,760 I said, well, we don't have to get political. I said, is there anything 334 00:28:56,760 --> 00:28:59,520 that's happening right now that your family's benefiting from? 335 00:29:00,060 --> 00:29:04,620 He goes, hell no. And I said, me either. And I said, you know what? 336 00:29:04,620 --> 00:29:08,380 Nothing was happening good for me either under Biden either. Nothing's 337 00:29:08,380 --> 00:29:12,020 been happening good period. Our lives are going into hell because 338 00:29:12,020 --> 00:29:17,820 we are dependent sadly on these disgusting capitalist pigs 339 00:29:18,380 --> 00:29:22,660 that run the government, this oligarchy that runs the world, really, 340 00:29:22,660 --> 00:29:27,480 because at the end of the day, the empire is out there busy flexing 341 00:29:27,480 --> 00:29:31,680 its muscles as people are crowing about the end of empire. 342 00:29:32,240 --> 00:29:37,560 I think it's way too soon. And I think that reality is that people 343 00:29:37,560 --> 00:29:40,880 are still not getting the point that this is not something 344 00:29:40,880 --> 00:29:45,400 we're voting our way out of. At best you get a crumb here or a 345 00:29:45,400 --> 00:29:48,720 crumb there, but there is no voting our way out of this. Capital 346 00:29:48,800 --> 00:29:52,720 is large and in charge, and we see this in every aspect of government, 347 00:29:53,260 --> 00:29:57,260 from the university systems, you name it. Bill, I am curious, 348 00:29:57,660 --> 00:30:01,740 you know, what do you think it is about Americans that make them 349 00:30:01,740 --> 00:30:05,300 believe that they can just vote their way out of this? They 350 00:30:05,300 --> 00:30:09,020 have no concept of empire. They have no concept of power. They 351 00:30:09,020 --> 00:30:12,140 truly have tried to pretend that there's no such thing as class. 352 00:30:12,460 --> 00:30:15,180 They've tried to pretend there's no such thing, even loosely, 353 00:30:15,180 --> 00:30:18,580 as capitalism. And they are literally sitting there believing 354 00:30:18,580 --> 00:30:23,700 that some random dude is going to save them from this horrible disaster 355 00:30:23,700 --> 00:30:28,220 that we're living in. I don't fundamentally understand what is 356 00:30:28,220 --> 00:30:32,540 it, the propaganda? Is it just fear of accepting what they have 357 00:30:32,540 --> 00:30:36,180 to do, what they're looking at? I mean, we need a revolution. 358 00:30:36,260 --> 00:30:39,780 There's just whether that be a. However we get there, we need 359 00:30:39,780 --> 00:30:43,620 some form of real honest to God change. And it isn't going to 360 00:30:43,620 --> 00:30:48,100 happen at the Ballot box. And it's killing me quote. 361 00:30:48,660 --> 00:30:52,820 You know, the other aspect of it is that. And it really emerged 362 00:30:52,820 --> 00:30:59,940 in the 1950s and prior, you know, in the 19th century, the elites 363 00:31:00,820 --> 00:31:07,660 were able to retain spectacular wealth while the rest 364 00:31:07,660 --> 00:31:14,430 of us, the peasants, were living in squalid material poverty. 365 00:31:15,310 --> 00:31:21,630 And, you know, in the early era of capitalism, you had the labor 366 00:31:21,630 --> 00:31:27,310 of those in squalid poverty enriching and reinforcing the wealth 367 00:31:28,190 --> 00:31:35,790 of the elites. And what allowed that to happen was religion, 368 00:31:37,230 --> 00:31:45,770 this belief in sort of fate. And in the 1950s, of course, as we 369 00:31:45,770 --> 00:31:53,090 became less sort of bound by Christian, mostly Christian religion, 370 00:31:53,970 --> 00:31:58,930 a new drug had to be introduced to keep us under control. 371 00:32:00,130 --> 00:32:03,810 You know, Karl Marx said religion's the opiate of the masses. 372 00:32:04,690 --> 00:32:10,400 That was his famous sort of reflection on how social stability 373 00:32:10,560 --> 00:32:17,400 was maintained amid squalid poverty. Well, in the 1950s, squalid 374 00:32:17,400 --> 00:32:24,600 poverty was no longer really possible to maintain. Governments 375 00:32:24,600 --> 00:32:30,880 had to redistribute a certain amount of material prosperity to 376 00:32:31,840 --> 00:32:36,760 a proportion of the working class. And this is the emergence 377 00:32:36,760 --> 00:32:42,200 of the middle class. And the way, while religion was the opiate 378 00:32:42,200 --> 00:32:47,080 of the masses in the 19th century, in the 20th century, particularly 379 00:32:47,080 --> 00:32:51,760 the second half of the 20th century, mass consumption became 380 00:32:51,760 --> 00:32:59,560 the opiate. And capital worked out that it could still gain spectacular 381 00:32:59,560 --> 00:33:04,270 profits. It was forced to share a bit of the national income 382 00:33:04,270 --> 00:33:09,230 in a better way than previously, but it could still keep 383 00:33:09,230 --> 00:33:15,550 us under lock and key, keep social stability. And so that we 384 00:33:15,550 --> 00:33:20,270 didn't work out that we were going to work for a capitalist and 385 00:33:20,270 --> 00:33:25,310 create surplus value for them and get underpaid, really. Or the 386 00:33:25,310 --> 00:33:28,310 other way of thinking about it is if the system was different, we 387 00:33:28,310 --> 00:33:33,180 could work less and still have the same material outcomes. Or to 388 00:33:33,180 --> 00:33:37,860 keep us from understanding that, mass consumption became the 389 00:33:37,860 --> 00:33:43,180 vehicle. And so, you know, you had the. Supported by the emergence 390 00:33:43,180 --> 00:33:49,100 of mass advertising that kept us under control and locked us up 391 00:33:49,100 --> 00:33:54,860 into credit arrangements. And as long as we had bigger houses full 392 00:33:54,860 --> 00:33:59,900 up with stuff, gadgets, electronic gadgets, washing machines, 393 00:33:59,980 --> 00:34:05,660 TVs, big garages with cars and all the rest of it, now that's become, 394 00:34:06,620 --> 00:34:12,940 you know, a chain around our necks. And, you know, I prefer not 395 00:34:12,940 --> 00:34:21,140 to think of people as stupid or, you know, naive. I prefer to 396 00:34:21,140 --> 00:34:29,280 see them as captured in a bind that is so pervasive that they have 397 00:34:29,920 --> 00:34:32,840 difficulty understanding how they're going to get out of it. And 398 00:34:32,840 --> 00:34:38,240 so what I mean by that is that most of us are completely locked 399 00:34:38,240 --> 00:34:43,640 into credit arrangements, mortgages, that are so onerous these 400 00:34:43,640 --> 00:34:49,450 days, especially when interest rates increase and the cost of living 401 00:34:49,450 --> 00:34:55,690 increases. That really our whole survival is linked to being 402 00:34:55,690 --> 00:35:02,890 able to keep our jobs and pay our bills, because the alternative 403 00:35:02,890 --> 00:35:09,290 is pretty grim because the financial sector has us by the neck 404 00:35:10,090 --> 00:35:14,940 and we lose our homes if we can't keep paying our credits off. 405 00:35:15,900 --> 00:35:20,700 And, you know, the average citizen's in a real bind, so of course 406 00:35:20,700 --> 00:35:26,220 they're going to worry about maintaining survival rather than 407 00:35:26,940 --> 00:35:34,060 thinking of deeper concerns about how the hell has capital taken 408 00:35:34,060 --> 00:35:39,820 over the US Government. I can understand that households really 409 00:35:40,760 --> 00:35:45,280 will avoid that big question because they're facing such difficulties 410 00:35:45,280 --> 00:35:50,600 just surviving. And that's all part of the strategic plan by capital 411 00:35:50,920 --> 00:35:52,120 to keep us under control,. 412 00:35:54,040 --> 00:35:58,760 That control mechanism that's part of the institutions that control 413 00:35:58,760 --> 00:36:02,680 us all. I mean, like, you know, I've been a relative recent, 414 00:36:03,000 --> 00:36:07,600 you know, study of Gramsci, and I'm nowhere near. It's very thick 415 00:36:07,600 --> 00:36:11,200 and tough to understand because he wrote in jail, and the 416 00:36:11,200 --> 00:36:16,720 stuff he wrote was. Had to be in many ways coded because he didn't 417 00:36:16,720 --> 00:36:21,800 want it to get captured by the people in the jails that, you know. 418 00:36:21,960 --> 00:36:25,080 So it was very difficult. But the things that came from that and 419 00:36:25,240 --> 00:36:29,240 some of the interpretations, understanding how institutions are 420 00:36:29,240 --> 00:36:33,320 representations of the ruling elite and ruling class in general, 421 00:36:34,410 --> 00:36:39,210 these are lessons that maybe never quite made it to Main Street. 422 00:36:39,210 --> 00:36:42,970 People never quite grabbed hold of and understood. And here 423 00:36:42,970 --> 00:36:50,970 we are now in possibly the worst timeline with AI and the lunatics 424 00:36:50,970 --> 00:36:57,010 that have this weird, you know, I can't even call it religion, 425 00:36:57,010 --> 00:37:02,670 this weird mythological fetish of end times with Peter Thiel and 426 00:37:02,670 --> 00:37:08,030 all these other crazy guys that are building the weapons of 427 00:37:08,030 --> 00:37:11,830 war through AI to keep us in prison, basically, to spy on us, 428 00:37:11,830 --> 00:37:18,630 to absolutely decimate us as human beings, I guess. How, you know, 429 00:37:18,630 --> 00:37:22,470 how did this stuff come to be? Because, you know, people, it just 430 00:37:22,470 --> 00:37:25,070 sort of seems like it just happened. It feels like it happened, 431 00:37:25,070 --> 00:37:28,070 like, almost overnight. I mean, you could look at the COVID 432 00:37:28,150 --> 00:37:34,020 pandemic, and we were all docile, behind closed doors, wearing 433 00:37:34,020 --> 00:37:37,660 masks and so forth, while they were busy plotting and planning. 434 00:37:37,900 --> 00:37:41,420 And we got to see a moment where they spent a lot of money, 435 00:37:41,980 --> 00:37:44,740 and we got to see, hey, they can spend this money. And then we 436 00:37:44,740 --> 00:37:48,100 forgot immediately that they could do it. But lo and behold, here 437 00:37:48,100 --> 00:37:54,220 we are literally killing everything in sight. The poor people, 438 00:37:54,540 --> 00:37:59,270 the Palestinians that have been slaughtered. It's just unbelievable. 439 00:37:59,270 --> 00:38:04,350 But this is part of the plan. You know, maybe the AIPAC supporters 440 00:38:04,350 --> 00:38:07,790 voted it, but nobody else wanted this. This isn't what people 441 00:38:07,870 --> 00:38:14,470 wanted. Obviously, people are living in denial, because to stare 442 00:38:14,470 --> 00:38:20,270 down the barrel of reality is pretty dark. It's pretty scary. And 443 00:38:20,750 --> 00:38:24,940 there's parts of me thinking back to Cipher from the movie the 444 00:38:24,940 --> 00:38:29,540 Matrix, where he goes, I know this isn't steak, but I love it anyway. 445 00:38:29,780 --> 00:38:33,860 I mean, I know it's not real, but I'm going to do it anyway. Because 446 00:38:34,020 --> 00:38:38,980 the idea of living on a planet that's been desolated by nuclear 447 00:38:38,980 --> 00:38:41,660 destruction, et cetera, is just not appealing to me. Plug me 448 00:38:41,660 --> 00:38:46,540 back into the battery, give me dreams, I'm good to go. That is a 449 00:38:46,540 --> 00:38:51,880 real kind of outcome. People are afraid to see what is. And then 450 00:38:51,880 --> 00:38:54,480 once you do see it, it's like, so what do I do now? 451 00:38:54,800 --> 00:38:59,560 Yeah, but, Steve, for the average citizen in the suburbs around 452 00:38:59,560 --> 00:39:04,600 the world, life's a struggle. You know, you've got personal struggles 453 00:39:04,600 --> 00:39:08,480 within your families and you've got economic struggles just 454 00:39:08,480 --> 00:39:14,640 paying the bills. And most people don't really have the time 455 00:39:14,800 --> 00:39:20,530 or the energy to think beyond those things. They're all pervasive. 456 00:39:20,530 --> 00:39:26,050 The system has made it much harder for us to. On one hand, it's 457 00:39:26,050 --> 00:39:30,890 offered all of these goodies, these possessions, you know, these 458 00:39:31,210 --> 00:39:37,650 glitzy gadgets and technologies and cars and all the 459 00:39:37,650 --> 00:39:43,510 rest of it that just shine brightly in our eyes. And on the 460 00:39:43,510 --> 00:39:49,110 other hand, it's made it harder for us to get them. And it's 461 00:39:49,110 --> 00:39:55,830 created vehicles where we can get them, like credit, that's completely 462 00:39:55,830 --> 00:40:02,550 enslaved us to the mission to keep working and to make sure we're 463 00:40:02,550 --> 00:40:09,310 solvent and to not really think much beyond that. And, you 464 00:40:09,310 --> 00:40:15,670 know, we're so tired at nights that we sit in front of some TV program 465 00:40:15,830 --> 00:40:20,150 or something, a streaming program these days, you know, pop 466 00:40:20,150 --> 00:40:25,190 entertainment, and we go to bed waiting to get up next morning 467 00:40:25,270 --> 00:40:30,630 for more of the same. So you can't really be too critical of the 468 00:40:30,630 --> 00:40:35,510 average citizen who is totally disenfranchised by their political 469 00:40:35,590 --> 00:40:40,420 systems because their political systems held out as being, 470 00:40:40,420 --> 00:40:45,660 oh, there's this arena of contest where we'll vote and our 471 00:40:45,660 --> 00:40:51,340 expression, our preferences will be revealed, and that will then 472 00:40:52,060 --> 00:40:56,540 manifest in shifts in policy. That's not the way the political 473 00:40:56,620 --> 00:41:02,100 system works at all. And I think that Princeton study demonstrates 474 00:41:02,100 --> 00:41:07,980 that categorically, that's not what it's about. The neoliberal institution 475 00:41:07,980 --> 00:41:14,260 of government is not about hearing our voices and articulating 476 00:41:14,820 --> 00:41:19,260 designing policy to reflect that. It's nothing to do with that. 477 00:41:19,260 --> 00:41:24,820 It's to command the big state, which then allows the legislative 478 00:41:24,820 --> 00:41:30,070 and regulative capacity of that state to do things that please 479 00:41:30,390 --> 00:41:36,790 the funding of that state, which is the elites, you know, they 480 00:41:36,790 --> 00:41:42,030 fund the political movements you know, these big funding organizations 481 00:41:42,030 --> 00:41:44,590 in America, they're called APEX or something. 482 00:41:44,590 --> 00:41:51,190 Are they aipac? Yes, it's the Israeli Political Action Committee, 483 00:41:51,270 --> 00:41:51,830 yeah. 484 00:41:51,830 --> 00:41:53,990 Oh, yeah. But there's a whole lot of them, isn't it? These. 485 00:41:54,150 --> 00:41:54,710 Oh, yes. 486 00:41:55,020 --> 00:41:58,860 Well, you know, and these PACs are representative of the lobbying 487 00:41:58,860 --> 00:42:04,180 interests and most of us don't have a say in any of that. We go 488 00:42:04,180 --> 00:42:10,140 to work each day, if we're lucky these days, and we earn a salary 489 00:42:10,140 --> 00:42:14,820 that's hopefully just sufficient to keep us food on the 490 00:42:14,820 --> 00:42:19,660 table and pay our bills and that's our energy, you know, and 491 00:42:19,660 --> 00:42:23,950 it's been a total takeover. And that's what people, progressives, 492 00:42:24,350 --> 00:42:27,790 I think, abstract from. They think that the political system is 493 00:42:27,790 --> 00:42:33,590 something that, oh, if we just lobby a bit more powerfully and get 494 00:42:33,590 --> 00:42:37,150 a bit of a movement going, we'll be able to shift things. Well, 495 00:42:37,469 --> 00:42:41,870 only around the edges. Nothing intrinsic is going to change. I mean, 496 00:42:42,830 --> 00:42:46,390 you know, we march in the street and I do. I'm angry about 497 00:42:46,390 --> 00:42:52,060 Palestine and Gaza and I march on Saturdays and whatever and shout 498 00:42:52,060 --> 00:42:58,980 and scream and chant slogans. But I know that that assault on humanity 499 00:42:58,980 --> 00:43:04,660 in that part of the world is an explicit expression of a strategy 500 00:43:04,660 --> 00:43:08,820 to make sure that the military, the industrial state, gets 501 00:43:08,820 --> 00:43:12,580 more and more government funding to build more and more weapons 502 00:43:12,900 --> 00:43:17,520 that deliver real income returns to the shareholders of those 503 00:43:17,520 --> 00:43:22,800 companies. That's what it's about. And that's the most sort of 504 00:43:23,520 --> 00:43:28,000 malicious and nasty manifestation of capitalism. But 505 00:43:28,160 --> 00:43:32,560 that's what capitalism is. Take over the state, get government 506 00:43:32,960 --> 00:43:38,400 funding and procurement contracts to underwrite prosperity 507 00:43:38,480 --> 00:43:41,760 for the shareholders of those firms. That's what the system is. 508 00:43:42,920 --> 00:43:46,840 And if we get too much in the road of it, the ordinary citizen 509 00:43:47,080 --> 00:43:53,680 will then be rebuked. But as long as we shut up and take what's 510 00:43:53,680 --> 00:44:01,000 given to us, then the system continues. And I think what the dynamic 511 00:44:01,000 --> 00:44:04,880 of that system, though, is unstable. And I think that's what 512 00:44:04,880 --> 00:44:09,680 I was talking about in that article I wrote in May, that there 513 00:44:09,680 --> 00:44:15,440 was a reason, for example, why trade unions formed in the late 1890s, 514 00:44:16,080 --> 00:44:21,720 and there were reasons why the movement to comprehensive welfare 515 00:44:21,720 --> 00:44:28,240 states in the early 20th century materialized after the Second 516 00:44:28,240 --> 00:44:34,720 World War. And that's because you can only push the citizens of 517 00:44:34,720 --> 00:44:41,580 societies so far. You can only impoverish them so far. And, you 518 00:44:41,580 --> 00:44:45,580 know, in the late 19th century, for example, the ideas of 519 00:44:45,580 --> 00:44:50,340 Karl Marx were becoming more popular among the working class because 520 00:44:51,140 --> 00:44:57,940 those ideas resonated with the view that here we are in squalid 521 00:44:57,940 --> 00:45:03,030 poverty, working our guts out, and the boss was living up on the 522 00:45:03,030 --> 00:45:09,710 hill, in a grand mansion, driving a fancy car and pompous in 523 00:45:09,710 --> 00:45:15,790 every respect. And those institutions, trade unions, welfare 524 00:45:15,790 --> 00:45:19,230 states formed and the capitalists sort of allowed them 525 00:45:19,230 --> 00:45:25,790 to form because it was worked out that otherwise the increasing 526 00:45:25,870 --> 00:45:32,580 social instability, embracing ideas like Marxism, would violently 527 00:45:32,580 --> 00:45:35,980 overthrow the system. And in some countries, of course, Soviet 528 00:45:36,220 --> 00:45:40,660 system emerged in Russia, those countries did overthrow the 529 00:45:40,660 --> 00:45:43,180 capitalist system temporarily. 530 00:45:44,300 --> 00:45:45,180 Temporarily. 531 00:45:45,740 --> 00:45:52,860 And I think the current dynamic with climate change overlaying 532 00:45:53,400 --> 00:46:01,080 the social struggle is we're heading towards unsustainable social 533 00:46:01,080 --> 00:46:06,000 instability. And eventually, as neoliberalism hollows out the 534 00:46:06,000 --> 00:46:12,040 middle class and makes the class conflict much more transparent 535 00:46:12,040 --> 00:46:20,130 again, we will see that social instability demand and rise up again. 536 00:46:20,610 --> 00:46:25,090 Now, whether it rises up in the form of social democratic movements 537 00:46:25,730 --> 00:46:31,970 that can offset the lobbying power of capital, I'm not sure. That 538 00:46:31,970 --> 00:46:37,490 only worked for a few decades in the 1950s and on, or whether it's 539 00:46:37,490 --> 00:46:42,050 something much more fundamental, I'm not sure. It's outside 540 00:46:42,210 --> 00:46:48,360 my area of expertise. But I think there's a reason why those 541 00:46:48,440 --> 00:46:53,480 social democratic institutions emerged. And the dynamic is there 542 00:46:53,480 --> 00:46:59,320 again, but it's much more fundamental now because of the existential 543 00:46:59,400 --> 00:47:03,800 threat of climate change. I think that's a total game changer. 544 00:47:04,440 --> 00:47:09,120 What do you think the impact of AI is on this power dynamic? Now 545 00:47:09,120 --> 00:47:13,210 that they're able to surveil us more, that they're able to basically 546 00:47:13,210 --> 00:47:17,730 use remote weaponry, they're able to do a host of things. I mean, 547 00:47:17,730 --> 00:47:20,450 this has kind of fundamentally changed from just having a bunch 548 00:47:20,450 --> 00:47:24,890 of cops with billy clubs knocking union guys over the head. 549 00:47:25,290 --> 00:47:26,890 It's a little different now, isn't it? 550 00:47:26,970 --> 00:47:32,090 Yeah, it is. And, you know, the way I think about it is that 551 00:47:32,730 --> 00:47:39,030 we were suppressed into sort of mediocrity and subservience. This 552 00:47:39,030 --> 00:47:45,750 is the citizens by mass consumption. In the 1950s, we were 553 00:47:45,750 --> 00:47:49,870 told to shut up and some prosperity would be delivered to 554 00:47:49,870 --> 00:47:56,270 us. And that was overlaid with the sort of macroeconomic fictions 555 00:47:56,990 --> 00:48:02,230 that if we ask for too much from our government, despite the 556 00:48:02,230 --> 00:48:05,790 fact that the military industrial state was getting mega 557 00:48:05,790 --> 00:48:09,660 from the government, but if we ask too much in the form of public 558 00:48:09,740 --> 00:48:14,380 education or public health or whatever, then the government would 559 00:48:14,380 --> 00:48:18,260 run out of money and they'd have to tax us more. And taxes were 560 00:48:18,260 --> 00:48:22,420 bad. And we said, yeah, taxes are bad, therefore we don't want 561 00:48:22,420 --> 00:48:26,540 to ask too much. So the sort of neoliberal mainstream economic 562 00:48:26,780 --> 00:48:33,820 fiction was a vehicle to keep us from having too lofty ambitions 563 00:48:33,980 --> 00:48:39,260 for our government. Now, what we've seen with AI is that the fiction 564 00:48:39,260 --> 00:48:44,980 goes one step further. That our basic understandings of the world 565 00:48:44,980 --> 00:48:50,780 in front of us are now being manipulated by fake images and social 566 00:48:50,859 --> 00:48:56,540 media pumping out so called knowledge that's just total fabrication. 567 00:48:57,660 --> 00:49:00,420 And you know, I'm a professional researcher. I've had 568 00:49:00,420 --> 00:49:06,110 a long career of digging into information and sorting out the wheat 569 00:49:06,110 --> 00:49:12,230 from the chaff. And even I struggle now. I basically don't look 570 00:49:12,230 --> 00:49:17,829 at social media anymore because it's very difficult to sort 571 00:49:17,829 --> 00:49:24,110 out fake from reality. And I think that that additional control 572 00:49:24,350 --> 00:49:29,820 layer is incredibly powerful and who knows where it's going to 573 00:49:29,820 --> 00:49:34,500 end. I mean, we're living now in a fiction and how we break out 574 00:49:34,500 --> 00:49:38,380 of that or move through it, I don't really know. I'm struggling 575 00:49:38,380 --> 00:49:45,980 that with myself as a person to see, you know, I'm a skeptic, 576 00:49:45,980 --> 00:49:51,580 so I doubt everything now. And you've got a president of the most 577 00:49:51,580 --> 00:49:59,950 powerful military who lies to his people every single day and just 578 00:49:59,950 --> 00:50:05,350 make stuff up. And the mainstream media is barely able to, 579 00:50:06,310 --> 00:50:09,430 you know, we've got fact checks and all of that, but you know, 580 00:50:09,590 --> 00:50:13,630 the game's getting lost. Trump just gets out there every day and 581 00:50:13,630 --> 00:50:18,750 just lies his face off and it's being very difficult. So the 582 00:50:18,750 --> 00:50:24,700 average citizen just turns off. And that's a victory for the 583 00:50:24,700 --> 00:50:30,540 elites because they've got us to turn off our government and to 584 00:50:30,540 --> 00:50:34,220 just turn the other cheek and move on and worry about how we're 585 00:50:34,220 --> 00:50:38,380 going to pay the next electricity bill. My goodness, massive 586 00:50:38,380 --> 00:50:38,700 success. 587 00:50:40,540 --> 00:50:44,740 Yeah, yeah, absolutely. Listen, Bill, as we're getting here, 588 00:50:44,740 --> 00:50:48,640 closer to the end of this discussion, I want to give you an 589 00:50:48,640 --> 00:50:53,120 opportunity to leave everybody with kind of like a final word. I 590 00:50:53,120 --> 00:50:58,400 mean, ultimately, I'm not going to lie, it's bleak. The way 591 00:50:58,400 --> 00:51:04,800 out is scary and people are outrageously trapped. They're enslaved 592 00:51:04,800 --> 00:51:09,800 by debt, I'm enslaved by debt. We're all enslaved by the system 593 00:51:09,800 --> 00:51:16,720 now and there's no democratic means of getting out of it. Take 594 00:51:16,720 --> 00:51:19,400 us out. I mean, like, obviously there's no real success 595 00:51:19,400 --> 00:51:21,360 here. I mean, we're all living, we're going to make it through 596 00:51:21,360 --> 00:51:25,840 however we make it through. But your final thoughts? 597 00:51:26,720 --> 00:51:30,480 Well, look, you know, I'm, I'm a sort of optimistic type character 598 00:51:30,960 --> 00:51:37,600 by nature and in this sort of bleak environment, I, I look to family 599 00:51:37,760 --> 00:51:43,880 connections and friends and, you know, those sort of micro ways 600 00:51:43,880 --> 00:51:50,240 of behaving to get joy in the world. When the sun shines, you smile 601 00:51:51,440 --> 00:51:55,640 and, you know, that's really the only way you can cope because 602 00:51:55,640 --> 00:52:01,040 in a macro sense it's, we're heading to Armageddon. In my view, 603 00:52:02,080 --> 00:52:08,220 the climate dynamics are terrifying. What's happening in our 604 00:52:08,220 --> 00:52:14,900 oceans is terrifying. We've been told in the last two days that 605 00:52:14,900 --> 00:52:21,380 there is a dramatic new El Nino occurring in the Pacific which 606 00:52:21,380 --> 00:52:29,180 will devastate farming particularly well on both sides and 607 00:52:29,180 --> 00:52:37,070 cause even worse weather variability, massive storms, et cetera, 608 00:52:37,070 --> 00:52:44,070 which will cause massive damage to agriculture and then the 609 00:52:44,070 --> 00:52:50,110 subsequent cost of living pressures intensify. You know, all 610 00:52:50,110 --> 00:52:54,470 of these things are terrifying. And you know, a report 611 00:52:54,470 --> 00:52:59,820 came out in Australia this week which was telling us that parading 612 00:52:59,820 --> 00:53:05,340 the increasing number of billionaires in Australia and that 613 00:53:06,140 --> 00:53:12,020 on average, this small group of Australian people are increasing 614 00:53:12,020 --> 00:53:18,140 their wealth by 50,000 Australian dollars per minute. Now, 615 00:53:18,140 --> 00:53:24,220 a lot of Australians only earn $50,000 Australian per year. And 616 00:53:24,300 --> 00:53:29,670 you know, if you think about it, put together all of these things, 617 00:53:30,710 --> 00:53:34,710 you know, we're spending billions on military equipment now 618 00:53:34,710 --> 00:53:37,990 because the Americans have bullied the world into becoming more 619 00:53:37,990 --> 00:53:43,830 militaristic again. Yet at the same time, homelessness in Australia 620 00:53:43,990 --> 00:53:46,830 is rising. Now, Australia is one of the wealthiest countries in 621 00:53:46,830 --> 00:53:50,990 the world on average. But you know, we're heading back to squalor 622 00:53:50,990 --> 00:53:56,460 for a significant portion of our population. And so to me, we're 623 00:53:56,460 --> 00:54:00,540 facing, we're heading towards Armageddon on multiple fronts. I 624 00:54:00,540 --> 00:54:07,580 call it the poly crisis. And how that's resolved is not going 625 00:54:07,580 --> 00:54:10,100 to be good in any way. 626 00:54:10,580 --> 00:54:11,460 Terrifying. 627 00:54:11,460 --> 00:54:14,980 You know, the climate effects in Europe, the desertification of 628 00:54:14,980 --> 00:54:20,810 the food bowls in Southern Europe. So how is mainstream continental 629 00:54:20,810 --> 00:54:24,690 Europe going to feed itself in the future? Well, it'll look elsewhere 630 00:54:24,690 --> 00:54:28,930 for food. And how will it get access to that food? Well, it's only 631 00:54:28,930 --> 00:54:34,770 going to come through military conflict. And so, you know, humanity 632 00:54:34,770 --> 00:54:40,450 is fairly myopic. Capitalism is definitely myopic. You know, these 633 00:54:40,530 --> 00:54:46,860 capital people of capital who are designed shifts in our system 634 00:54:47,180 --> 00:54:52,660 called neoliberalism to build more for themselves, well, that can't 635 00:54:52,660 --> 00:54:58,220 be sustained. You can't drive the working class to squalid poverty 636 00:54:58,220 --> 00:55:02,500 again for very long. That's going to have to give. You can't 637 00:55:02,500 --> 00:55:06,940 push the natural environment to its now breaking point forever. 638 00:55:07,500 --> 00:55:11,020 That's going to give. So what's going to be the resolution? 639 00:55:11,020 --> 00:55:15,830 Well, I don't know. It'll probably be a few years after I die, 640 00:55:16,470 --> 00:55:22,190 but it's not looking good for anybody. So for an optimist, you've 641 00:55:22,190 --> 00:55:26,670 got to just look for small micro pleasures, smile when the sun 642 00:55:26,670 --> 00:55:33,790 shines and do what you can to reverse the narrative. But that's 643 00:55:33,790 --> 00:55:38,470 an increasingly hopeless task, I think. I'm sorry, that's the best 644 00:55:38,470 --> 00:55:39,830 I can do for you, Steve? 645 00:55:39,830 --> 00:55:43,310 No, Bill, you nailed it, man. I mean, look, I would much rather 646 00:55:43,310 --> 00:55:46,850 reality than and somebody glazing me with a bunch of phony 647 00:55:46,850 --> 00:55:49,490 lies. So I appreciate it immensely. 648 00:55:49,650 --> 00:55:53,410 And you know, on the hopeful thing, do what you can for the people 649 00:55:53,410 --> 00:55:59,970 around you, fight against injustice, do what you can. And that's 650 00:55:59,970 --> 00:56:03,570 the best you can do these days. And you know, in my view, inform 651 00:56:03,650 --> 00:56:08,690 yourself as best you can and be prepared to get on the front line 652 00:56:08,770 --> 00:56:12,980 when the social instability gets so great that we really do have 653 00:56:12,980 --> 00:56:17,660 to change the system. Don't demur from that responsibility. That's 654 00:56:17,660 --> 00:56:21,500 sort of my mission in the latter half of my life. 655 00:56:22,780 --> 00:56:26,580 I'm with you there, sir. I'm with you. I appreciate this so much. 656 00:56:26,580 --> 00:56:30,060 Thank you for keeping it real with me, Bill. I'm going to go ahead 657 00:56:30,060 --> 00:56:35,140 and close us out. I want to thank you first of all for coming 658 00:56:35,140 --> 00:56:39,310 on with me. As always. It's been, I mean, this is we. We're coming 659 00:56:39,310 --> 00:56:44,750 up on our 400th episode of weekly podcasts going back almost 660 00:56:44,750 --> 00:56:48,790 eight years. And you know, you were episode number one, Bill, and 661 00:56:48,790 --> 00:56:53,190 I thank you so much for being part of that. So with that, folks, 662 00:56:53,190 --> 00:56:56,590 my name is Steve Grumbine. I am the host of Macaron Cheese and 663 00:56:56,590 --> 00:57:00,470 the founder of the nonprofit Real Progressives. We are a 501C3, 664 00:57:00,470 --> 00:57:04,350 not for profit education organization and we are trying to 665 00:57:04,350 --> 00:57:07,110 get the word out, we're trying to teach people and these podcasts 666 00:57:07,110 --> 00:57:11,780 are a way of doing that. With that in mind, we rely on your contributions. 667 00:57:11,860 --> 00:57:16,580 So if you would consider donating to us, you can go to patreon.com 668 00:57:17,620 --> 00:57:22,380 realprogressives you can go to Substack and go to Real Progressives 669 00:57:22,380 --> 00:57:27,460 and become a donor. You can also go to our website, realprogressives.org 670 00:57:27,700 --> 00:57:31,500 and become a monthly donor or a one time donor. And with that, 671 00:57:31,500 --> 00:57:35,020 on behalf of my guest, Bill Mitchell, myself Steve Grumbine, 672 00:57:35,020 --> 00:57:39,700 and the podcast Macro and Cheese, we are out of here. 673 00:57:48,420 --> 00:57:52,140 Production transcripts, graphics, sound engineering, extras 674 00:57:52,140 --> 00:57:55,060 and show notes for Macro n Cheese are done by our volunteer 675 00:57:55,060 --> 00:57:58,580 team at Real Progressives, serving in solidarity with the working 676 00:57:58,580 --> 00:57:59,746 class since 2015.To become a donor, please go to patreon.com realprogressives.substack.com 677 00:57:59,746 --> 00:57:59,854 or realprogressives.org.