Speaker:

Welcome to Open Heart Surgery with Boots, where we explore the

Speaker:

journey of heart health through the eyes of those who live it every

Speaker:

day. I'm your host, Boots Knighton, and in season

Speaker:

five, we're focusing on what it truly means to

Speaker:

thrive. We'll dive into cutting edge medical advances,

Speaker:

share powerful stories from both sides of the stethoscope,

Speaker:

and learn how to be better advocates for our own health.

Speaker:

From candid conversations with cardiac patients to

Speaker:

insights from dedicated healthcare professionals, each

Speaker:

episode brings you closer to understanding the complex world

Speaker:

of heart health. Whether you're navigating your own cardiac

Speaker:

journey or supporting someone who is, you're in the right

Speaker:

place. So let's get to today's story.

Speaker:

Hello, welcome to another episode of Open Heart Surgery with

Speaker:

Boots. I am your host, Boots Knighton coming at you from

Speaker:

Victor, Idaho, where it is snowing today.

Speaker:

I'm recording this in early January and I am

Speaker:

so excited for this season. This is the fifth

Speaker:

season of Open Heart Surgery with Boots and

Speaker:

I am bringing you my A plus game this

Speaker:

season, bringing the most distinguished guests yet. And

Speaker:

today I am so thrilled that Dr.

Speaker:

Marshall Runge, who wants to be called Marshall,

Speaker:

has agreed to come on and share his

Speaker:

expertise and wisdom with us. And let me just talk about

Speaker:

Dr. Marshall Runge for a second. He's a distinguished

Speaker:

physician scientist, considered a leader in

Speaker:

academic medicine, and an advocate for the integration of

Speaker:

AI into healthcare systems. He

Speaker:

currently serves as dean of the medical school at the

Speaker:

University of Michigan. Wow. Aren't we lucky to have him

Speaker:

today? With numerous accolades and awards, Dr.

Speaker:

Range has earned a reputation as one of the foremost experts

Speaker:

in healthcare innovation. His work is bridging

Speaker:

technology and medicine and has been pivotal in reshaping

Speaker:

the modern healthcare landscape. Dr.

Speaker:

Runge, aka Marshall, thank you so much for

Speaker:

saying yes in your busy schedule. It really is an

Speaker:

honor. Well, thank you, Boots, and thank you so much for

Speaker:

that very kind introduction. My entire

Speaker:

career has been focused on cardiovascular disease, although

Speaker:

I have other responsibilities, both in seeing

Speaker:

patients, trying to help patients understand their disease, and in

Speaker:

both doing research in my own research area,

Speaker:

as well as being able to help interpret some of the

Speaker:

research that we see and we see quick headlines in the

Speaker:

press and trying to help people, and we're all people, after all,

Speaker:

understand what they can do for their heart. And I think the

Speaker:

opportunities we look at in the future with AI and

Speaker:

large language models are just so

Speaker:

intriguing. Say more about that because I was

Speaker:

just reading an article recently, I think maybe it was

Speaker:

in the Washington Post about just the

Speaker:

journey of even chat GPT and

Speaker:

GPT5 and how hard it is

Speaker:

to get that I had no idea how expensive it

Speaker:

is and then how cutthroat it is and, and so

Speaker:

it made me think about our upcoming conversation. It just

Speaker:

sounds like it's not as easy and straightforward

Speaker:

as I thought it was. Well, I'll make

Speaker:

a couple of comments. So the first is that in terms of just day to

Speaker:

day use of AI, I now use it all the

Speaker:

time and platform I use is offered for free at

Speaker:

our university at the University of Michigan. It's chat

Speaker:

GPT4 and you have to get comfortable with it a little

Speaker:

bit. But once you understand what kinds of questions to ask

Speaker:

and that you're really having a conversation as weird as that might be with a

Speaker:

computer, you can find out so much that

Speaker:

is meaningful information. I always double check

Speaker:

it. But to give you an example, part of what I do,

Speaker:

and most physicians do is I have to do continuing

Speaker:

medical education and maintenance of certification. And in doing that

Speaker:

I every quarter I have to answer a bunch of questions and I

Speaker:

find that I can get really

Speaker:

outstanding data and interpretations from

Speaker:

ChatGPT in a much more rapid

Speaker:

manner than if I use any traditional medical resource. So I've

Speaker:

come to really find it to be invaluable. And

Speaker:

if for you or you probably know this, but for any, any of your

Speaker:

listeners or viewers, I think what they'll find is you have

Speaker:

to give, you have to kind of train yourself to use it, but then it

Speaker:

is, it is invaluable. So I'm a big fan of, of that part of

Speaker:

AI. I also, what I find so

Speaker:

amazing and intriguing is that AI works.

Speaker:

This sounds a little corny, but AI works in mysterious

Speaker:

ways and it gathers all this information and it integrates

Speaker:

it. And in so many instances in medicine, and I'll talk about

Speaker:

some in heart health, it'll come up with answers that we just would never have

Speaker:

thought of asking, questions that we never thought of asking, that

Speaker:

can be extremely helpful. And there's some great examples out there,

Speaker:

some in cardiovascular disease, some in prevention, some in

Speaker:

therapeutic areas. And so I think we're facing

Speaker:

a moment in which things are going to really change

Speaker:

dramatically in healthcare and in health and all of us thinking

Speaker:

about our own health, it's been called this AI movement's been called

Speaker:

a Promethean moment. I had to look up that. So pro

Speaker:

Prometheus was a Greek God who, you know, caused lightning and

Speaker:

fire and all kinds of things. And after these moments everything was different

Speaker:

going forward. And I almost. That's somewhat of an exaggeration, but I think

Speaker:

things are going to be very different in our coming years

Speaker:

with AI and what it can bring us. So I'm hearing

Speaker:

excitement, lots of excitement. Okay. For

Speaker:

me, I feel a sense of trepidation

Speaker:

because I, admittedly, because I, I believe

Speaker:

in like heart connection. Right. I'm, I'm thinking hard all the time

Speaker:

and having this, this connection with you and in

Speaker:

community. And so as a patient, when I hear

Speaker:

you say that, part of me is like, oh cool. It's kind of like

Speaker:

double checking your thinking when you're working with a patient and helping them

Speaker:

find like the, the proper way to treat whatever needs to be

Speaker:

treated. But then also part of me is like, well, then we take out that

Speaker:

soul connection with our providers and our community.

Speaker:

And so I realize that's more of an existential

Speaker:

question or thought, but part of me has a little bit of

Speaker:

trepidation because I don't want to lose that, that, that connection with

Speaker:

fellow humans. Boots, that is a great

Speaker:

point. And you'll hear different people talk about AI

Speaker:

and how maybe an AI bot could

Speaker:

replace a healthcare provider, replace a doctor or

Speaker:

a nutritionist or a therapist. And I don't think

Speaker:

that's going to happen. And the reason I don't think that's going to happen

Speaker:

is because you miss that human connection. And that is so

Speaker:

important. As people connect with each other, as they connect with their care

Speaker:

providers, as their care providers connect with them, there's

Speaker:

subtleties in the way that all of us interact that cannot

Speaker:

really be replicated by AI.

Speaker:

The best I've heard is that explanation, and I don't know when,

Speaker:

if ever this will be overcome, is that AI can mimic, that

Speaker:

it feels you, that it has emotional responses, but it does not have

Speaker:

emotional responses. That's based on what you're telling it and what it thinks you

Speaker:

want to hear. And so, and in some cases that's turned out to be

Speaker:

somewhat dangerous because a person can get so connected to

Speaker:

an AI bot that becomes their friend. And that's just

Speaker:

not realistic. No. Well, there's just not a soul

Speaker:

there. There is no soul. Yes, it's

Speaker:

soulless. Right, Right. Taking a step back, you

Speaker:

mentioned you could go and ask a question.

Speaker:

Could you give us some examples of when, of what

Speaker:

that would be? What. What is a recent question you've asked of

Speaker:

maybe regarding a patient or. I don't know what you can share, but I'm just

Speaker:

really curious. Well, I'll give you both my personal

Speaker:

experience and also what is out there in the medical Literature. Now I think

Speaker:

I'll start with what's out there in the medical literature. So AI turns

Speaker:

out to have a predictive value for heart

Speaker:

disease from examining retinal scans.

Speaker:

So if you go to the doctor, and particularly if you have diabetes,

Speaker:

you'll have a retinal scan, a photograph of your retina, sort of the back

Speaker:

part of the eye where the business part of seeing occurs.

Speaker:

And what's been found recently, which is

Speaker:

just amazing, is that based on those retinal

Speaker:

scans, AI is picking up cues that can help

Speaker:

it predict if your likelihood of having

Speaker:

heart disease and even your five year mortality.

Speaker:

And so how does it do that? Well, that's part of the

Speaker:

unknown about AI. It's taking together these huge amounts of data

Speaker:

that we don't really, we can't assimilate. I mean, I can't assimilate

Speaker:

everything in the world at the same time. And it's looking

Speaker:

for patterns. Now sometimes those patterns turn out to be spurious and they're not really.

Speaker:

It may be a pattern kind of like, well, I feel like every time I'm

Speaker:

humming a certain tune, I get a green light instead of a red light. So,

Speaker:

you know, it can be as spurious as that. But many of these findings have

Speaker:

turned out to be true and have turned out because it's picking

Speaker:

up a pattern that we wouldn't be looking for.

Speaker:

So I think that's where AI can really have an impact. It picks up patterns

Speaker:

that we're maybe not used to. So to give you a common

Speaker:

everyday question that I get, let's think about people who

Speaker:

have a elevated LDL cholesterol.

Speaker:

So LDL cholesterol is the bad cholesterol. It's associated with buildup

Speaker:

of plaque in the coronary arteries, associated with a

Speaker:

increased risk of heart attack and stroke and cardiac

Speaker:

death. And what we have known for a long time

Speaker:

is that statins drugs like

Speaker:

Atorvastatin or Lipitor or Rovastatin or

Speaker:

Crestor have a protective effect. And if you take

Speaker:

all the big studies that have been done, they show that that

Speaker:

protective effect against heart problem, heart related

Speaker:

problems, including cardiac death, can be up to 22%.

Speaker:

Now that's a big, that's a big impact. And I personally am a big fan

Speaker:

of statins. I take a statin, my LDL cholesterol is somewhat

Speaker:

elevated. My brother, who has basically the same LDL pattern I

Speaker:

do, chooses not to take a statin. We're both still alive and

Speaker:

well. And so it begs the question, well, what

Speaker:

are these studies showing? Us and when you really look at those in

Speaker:

detail, it's that not all the 20,000 patients who were

Speaker:

studied on or not on a statin, they didn't all get a

Speaker:

20% benefit. It's a small number who get a big benefit and then a whole

Speaker:

bunch of people who don't get any benefit. And as you know, I'm sure

Speaker:

you're viewers and listeners know statins do

Speaker:

cause myalgias, muscle pains, or other kinds of side

Speaker:

effects that for some people make it virtually impossible to take a

Speaker:

statin. Well, think about if we could be much more precise in

Speaker:

who would really benefit from those statins and

Speaker:

prevention. I think speaking broadly for American

Speaker:

healthcare and the costs of healthcare, and in the

Speaker:

case of cardiac disease, the number of procedures or bypass

Speaker:

surgery or whatever, when you think about those things

Speaker:

and the cost of those things, the way out of our

Speaker:

conundrum is prevention. So

Speaker:

in the United States, obesity is now well over

Speaker:

50% of the population, and that carries with it a risk

Speaker:

of diabetes, a very high risk of diabetes. And

Speaker:

so if we could prevent this really tsunami of

Speaker:

obesity that's hitting the United States or lessen it, that's

Speaker:

how we save money in healthcare. It's not by. I mean, we do need all

Speaker:

the advanced procedures, and I'm a great fan of advanced procedures, but what we

Speaker:

need to do is lessen the entry into that

Speaker:

inevitable pipeline. So I gave

Speaker:

the cholesterol example. I'll give you another one that is really intriguing to me that

Speaker:

I don't understand very well at all. But AI has turned out

Speaker:

to be really valuable in both

Speaker:

wearable devices. I have a not advertising for Apple, but I have an

Speaker:

Apple Watch and in other types of wearable

Speaker:

devices and picking up patterns that we wouldn't ordinarily

Speaker:

associate with increased risk. So, for example,

Speaker:

the amount of variability you have in your heart rate when you

Speaker:

are not exercising or exercising is quite

Speaker:

a predictor. And AI can analyze that in a way that's difficult to do

Speaker:

in anything less than a wearable, as

Speaker:

another example, and this has been shown mainly in Alzheimer's

Speaker:

disease, but very subtle changes in

Speaker:

phraseology using social media, for example, or

Speaker:

your intonation when you're speaking on a phone can be analyzed by

Speaker:

AI and predict memory decline.

Speaker:

Alzheimer's maybe five years before any other

Speaker:

known tests, including cat scans and MRIs, et cetera.

Speaker:

So what is it picking up out of all that? I don't know. People are

Speaker:

studying what it. What is it that is picking up. But what's clear is it's

Speaker:

picking up these patterns that are very difficult for us as, you know,

Speaker:

thinking, interacting human beings to pick up in each other. You know,

Speaker:

it's not like someone says, oh, I feel awful, I'm so depressed.

Speaker:

It's very subtle changes that can be picked up by AI. And

Speaker:

I want to say one last thing. One of the. And then I'll stop talking.

Speaker:

One of the great unknowns in heart disease that I've studied

Speaker:

in our own research, but also is a big

Speaker:

topic is when are you at risk? If you have a plaque in one of

Speaker:

your coronary arteries, you have a blockage, when are you at risk of

Speaker:

that plaque cracking or causing

Speaker:

that artery to be blocked off? And you don't want to. If you think that

Speaker:

if you had data that you're at high risk in the next few weeks,

Speaker:

you'd absolutely want to get something done. On the other hand, if

Speaker:

you have data that shows you're not at risk and you need to continue your

Speaker:

exercise, you need to continue your dietary measures, your statin or

Speaker:

whatever medications, then you wouldn't have to rush off and have

Speaker:

a cardiac catheterization. Well, AI is proving

Speaker:

in early studies to be able to detect what those subtle differences are

Speaker:

between what's called a vulnerable plaque, one that might rupture, and

Speaker:

a stable plaque. That's been something that's been studied

Speaker:

for decades, including invasive

Speaker:

studies looking at putting a catheter in and examining that plaque

Speaker:

and seeing how much fat or calcium or whatever is in that plaque.

Speaker:

But it appears to be the case that AI may be able to detect

Speaker:

the difference between a dangerous and a not dangerous plaque based on

Speaker:

imaging like a CAT scan or an mri, non invasive

Speaker:

imaging. So I just give this as a few examples of where I

Speaker:

see the future going there. We're not there yet. And with with

Speaker:

the caveat, the important caveat that you mentioned, we need to have

Speaker:

healthcare providers be able to have a conversation with

Speaker:

their concerned patients about this. It can't just all pop up from a

Speaker:

search of ChatGPT, but I think those tools will be very valuable.

Speaker:

Mind blowing and relieving because it's. Heart

Speaker:

catheterizations are not fun. Absolutely not

Speaker:

fun for anyone. I've actually

Speaker:

literally said I'd rather have an open heart surgery than a heart

Speaker:

cath. So that says it all. Yeah, my

Speaker:

therapist was like, why on earth would you say that? And I was like, well,

Speaker:

because you're asleep for your open heart surgery. Yeah,

Speaker:

it's terrible. But anyway, I so

Speaker:

much hope in everything you just shared as a As a heart

Speaker:

patient, and I so appreciate it and I would love to add a little something

Speaker:

to the heart rate variability. I have a

Speaker:

Garmin watch that I'm actually taking a vacation from right now

Speaker:

because I noticed this can be like a two part

Speaker:

discussion. I noticed it was causing health

Speaker:

anxiety. And that's like an delicate line you

Speaker:

walk, right? Like, okay, I'm watching my data,

Speaker:

but I noticed that my data was stealing my joy

Speaker:

and my sense of peace. And since I've stopped wearing

Speaker:

it, I feel so much better. And I was just reading

Speaker:

another article, I'm forgetting where now I read a lot. But how,

Speaker:

you know, healthcare anxiety actually does have adverse

Speaker:

effects on our health. So here's AI

Speaker:

informing me on my wrist of, you know,

Speaker:

lack of sleep, lack of health, heart rate variability. And I'm starting to

Speaker:

panic, which becomes like this, this

Speaker:

snowball effect. But as you're saying, you know, it's

Speaker:

also very beneficial to know when something is

Speaker:

amiss because I was able to go to my

Speaker:

cardiologist over a year ago and be like, something's not right.

Speaker:

And we were able to make some changes because of my watch.

Speaker:

Right. So it's this fine line and I think that's where like

Speaker:

having a cardiac psychiatrist or a really good therapist, like, I have people

Speaker:

who can help manage the emotional and mental stress

Speaker:

of having a heart issue, but also, and at the same

Speaker:

time harness the power of AI to

Speaker:

improve our lives. You know, boots, that's interesting because

Speaker:

I haven't had anybody personally tell me a story like yours, but

Speaker:

I absolutely believe it. It's sort of an extension of

Speaker:

what we have called for years white coat syndrome. So I've been

Speaker:

a doctor for over 40 years.

Speaker:

White coat syndrome. Oh, white coat. Yep.

Speaker:

White coat syndrome is when you go in to get your

Speaker:

blood pressure measured. Doesn't matter if the doctor's actually wearing a white coat or not,

Speaker:

but your blood pressure goes up because of this anticipatory stress,

Speaker:

just like you're talking about with your watch. And I've been a doctor

Speaker:

for over 40 years. I have white coat syndrome. I have to like,

Speaker:

just Zen out, you know, when I go for my annual physical because my

Speaker:

blood pressure, you know, bounces up over what it normally

Speaker:

is. Just thinking, well, golly, what could be going wrong? I'm having my

Speaker:

annual evaluation. So what you're talking

Speaker:

about is taking that to a whole new level where it's bothering you all the

Speaker:

time, not just when you go get your blood pressure checked. Yeah,

Speaker:

and I totally can believe that, you know,

Speaker:

the Interesting thing about heart rate variability to me is

Speaker:

it has different components, how much your heart rate varies when you do different things.

Speaker:

But I'm finding myself using it with my watch is when

Speaker:

I'm doing some episodic exercise. So the other

Speaker:

day I was playing tennis with one of my kids and, and I was running

Speaker:

all, all over the place and I thought, well, let me see what my heart

Speaker:

rate is. So it had gotten up to like, after a long point had gotten

Speaker:

up to 135. And so, you know, that's not terribly high,

Speaker:

but it's not, you know, my normal is about in the 60s. And so

Speaker:

I wanted to see how long it took for it to start

Speaker:

dropping down. And it took a minute or two, didn't ever get back down to

Speaker:

the 60s. And then we kept playing. But it's that

Speaker:

one part of heart rate variability that I think

Speaker:

people can monitor for themselves has to do with your conditioning level.

Speaker:

And so the better conditioning you are, the faster your heart

Speaker:

rate drops. If you do something and it gets your heart rate way up and

Speaker:

it just is kind of staying up there very slowly

Speaker:

dropping, what does that tell you? Well, it tells you you could be better

Speaker:

conditioned. And so that's not quite the same as looking at

Speaker:

your, your wearable and thinking, oh my gosh, what's happening now?

Speaker:

So, so there's some good things that you can get out of that. And again,

Speaker:

these are all things that just work. Weren't present when I started practicing

Speaker:

medicine, when, when I started practicing cardiology. In fact, it was before

Speaker:

the earliest of these drugs, called

Speaker:

thrombolytic drugs that would dissolve a heart clot in one of your coronary arteries,

Speaker:

those were just being test studied. It was in the mid-80s. Now,

Speaker:

when you think about all the tools that we have, you know, one other thing

Speaker:

I forgot to mention having to do with heart surgery is

Speaker:

I think that our ability and heart disease and in other

Speaker:

areas to use robotics has been limited.

Speaker:

And it's partly because of expense, because you buy that robot for I don't know

Speaker:

how much, millions of dollars. And all the proprietary supplies

Speaker:

that are used with the robot are expensive. And to date,

Speaker:

the outcomes haven't been shown to be better than a highly skilled

Speaker:

surgeon. But I could, I could foresee a

Speaker:

way that those could be used as they are in other

Speaker:

instances with a minimally invasive approach. So not having to crack

Speaker:

your sternum, your breastbone, and the recovery

Speaker:

time for that is much, much faster. There's, there is minimally evasive

Speaker:

cardiac surgery now where the Recovery time can be in

Speaker:

days rather than in the month or more that it takes for your

Speaker:

breastbone to heal, your sternum to heal. So I think all these things

Speaker:

are things we can look for in the future when we're not there yet.

Speaker:

Well, you know, it's interesting. I've had a couple of conversations with

Speaker:

surgeons about that, because with one of my

Speaker:

defects, myocardial bridging, I'm part of a Facebook support group for

Speaker:

that. And there's more and more people on, in

Speaker:

that forum that are going to

Speaker:

a couple of different places in the United States for

Speaker:

robotic unroofing. And it's been mixed results. A

Speaker:

lot of them have had issues with their lungs afterwards. A lot of

Speaker:

collapsed lungs, a lot of pericarditis that I

Speaker:

normally haven't been hearing about through, like, the more traditional open heart

Speaker:

surgery route. And my surgeon, before I had my surgery, I had

Speaker:

my surgery by a trained Mayo surgeon who

Speaker:

is down at Intermountain Hospital in Marie, Utah. And

Speaker:

I asked him about the pros and cons because at the time I was still

Speaker:

like, should I travel to Chicago? Should I come to you?

Speaker:

And, you know, he was saying, it's just too dangerous. Like,

Speaker:

it really is good to have eyes on the heart. And I

Speaker:

can't remember exactly. It was four years ago now, but, you know, he,

Speaker:

he said it just is almost safer to still

Speaker:

have actual hands in there. Getting the lay of the land.

Speaker:

This is my own way of explaining it. Getting the lay of the land of

Speaker:

the heart and seeing what needs to happen. But that was four

Speaker:

years ago, maybe. And, and maybe you can speak to that a little more eloquently

Speaker:

than I just did, but it just, it doesn't seem foolproof

Speaker:

to me yet. You were pretty eloquent there, I'd say.

Speaker:

And you hit the nail on the head. And there are these

Speaker:

concerns. So, for example, removing that thin piece of

Speaker:

tissue that's lying on top of your coronary artery, causing a bridge,

Speaker:

it means different things if you're, if you're, if the

Speaker:

surgeon's looking at it and can expose your entire

Speaker:

heart versus if the surgeon's looking through a

Speaker:

little scope at what the robot is doing. And I, and I

Speaker:

can. I. I had never heard before that there's an

Speaker:

increased incidence of pericarditis, but I can

Speaker:

believe it because the pericardium, you can treat very

Speaker:

gently if the surgeon. I'm not a surgeon. The surgeon can treat very gently if

Speaker:

the chest is open, whereas that may be more difficult to do and more

Speaker:

irritating to the pericardium, if it's done by this

Speaker:

robot that's being instrumented. What I have heard

Speaker:

is, although it's not common, there are certainly

Speaker:

cases where there's a problem with the robotic

Speaker:

approach nicking the wrong artery or causing

Speaker:

bleeding or something like that, that it converts to an

Speaker:

open heart procedure, so an open chest procedure. And

Speaker:

so honestly, Boots, I don't see that there's been a

Speaker:

huge step forward in robotic heart surgery at

Speaker:

present. It's not used very many places, as you know.

Speaker:

Yeah, I think that's, as I mentioned before, partly expense,

Speaker:

partly lack of better outcomes, but I think

Speaker:

also they're like everything. There are a lot of things that need to be

Speaker:

worked out. Maybe it'll turn out that it's never a great approach,

Speaker:

but the only way we'll know is when we learn more about it. Right. Here's

Speaker:

an example where maybe AI is not

Speaker:

necessarily the route. And this is where we have the human to human

Speaker:

connection in the operating room. Right,

Speaker:

right. Yeah. And I, you know, with all my excitement about, about

Speaker:

AI, and I am excited about AI, I think all of

Speaker:

this needs to be looked at very carefully because

Speaker:

it's very doubtful, even to me as an enthusiast, that

Speaker:

AI is the cure all. It's just not a cure all. I think of it

Speaker:

more in terms of being able to look at information,

Speaker:

patterns from vast, vast stores of information that would be

Speaker:

impossible to look at otherwise. Yeah, one, one example I saw

Speaker:

recently had to do with rare, what are called

Speaker:

orphan or rare genetic diseases where they

Speaker:

don't occur commonly, but they do occur, and they're thought to be

Speaker:

some of these. I think the definition is fewer than 4,000 a year in the

Speaker:

United States. So a pretty small number of conditions.

Speaker:

And what AI has found is that although there may be

Speaker:

a gene, a specific gene that's thought to be the problem, there

Speaker:

are other contributing genes that may affect the, that

Speaker:

do affect, seemingly affect the severity of that

Speaker:

gene defect, such that in one person it's not a big problem, in another

Speaker:

person it's quite lethal. And so trying to understand

Speaker:

all those parameters, because as advanced as geneticists are these

Speaker:

days, and as large as the databases they look at,

Speaker:

it's just not currently possible to analyze all the genes in the

Speaker:

genome. 30 over 30,000 genes, and they're

Speaker:

over 3 billion base pairs. And so how

Speaker:

do you analyze that? Well, I'm hopeful, not proven, but I'm

Speaker:

hopeful that AI can help us look at these things. For

Speaker:

example, I'll take two other examples. Lots of people have A high cholesterol, it

Speaker:

never bothers them. So my mother had a LDL

Speaker:

cholesterol of 250. I mean, that's sky high. But she had an

Speaker:

HDL cholesterol of her HDL cholesterol was like 100, which is

Speaker:

also sky high. And so she lived to be

Speaker:

94. She never took a statin. She never, I mean, she walked, but she

Speaker:

wasn't like a major exerciser. And so

Speaker:

that what might have been fatal for somebody else wasn't at all for

Speaker:

her. And it's all around these surrounding genes, I think that

Speaker:

we just don't understand. But that gets back to this question about

Speaker:

even something as seemingly simple as cholesterol management. If we

Speaker:

knew more about who would benefit from cholesterol lowering drugs and in whom

Speaker:

there is no benefit, you could say the same thing about drugs that help with

Speaker:

remodeling the heart. So after a person's had a heart attack,

Speaker:

there are, we have sort of the guideline driven five

Speaker:

drugs that are supposed to help in remodeling. Those help in many people,

Speaker:

they don't help in all people. And maybe it's a contribution of one drug more

Speaker:

than another. But when, when a person is asked to take five drugs

Speaker:

up to three times a day, you know, that's very

Speaker:

difficult to do. And, and talk about raising your stress level. Did I

Speaker:

miss my noon dose? It's, we can

Speaker:

do better. And I think AI will be a tool that will help us

Speaker:

do better. And that's the key. It's a tool

Speaker:

and I think that it's important how we frame it.

Speaker:

To me as a patient, it's like, okay, take the human aspect of

Speaker:

my provider, my healthcare, my team. I have a whole team

Speaker:

and consider AI as part

Speaker:

of the team. Yeah, that's exactly it. And,

Speaker:

and I tell, yeah. And you're still CEO. The CEO of your healthcare.

Speaker:

We are CEOs and we hire you. We hire all of y'all

Speaker:

heart healthcare providers and AI. Right. So yeah,

Speaker:

I think that's a great way to look at it. And, and obviously you've embraced

Speaker:

this, but I think for those who listen and view your, your podcast,

Speaker:

I think it's important for people to be the CEO of their own

Speaker:

healthcare. And I think I strongly feel like the more information they have,

Speaker:

the better. I will tell you that when the Internet got

Speaker:

going and people could look up stuff, could get information, even

Speaker:

before Google, people would come in sometimes to see me

Speaker:

highly motivated, sometimes highly educated people would have a

Speaker:

stack of papers this thick and they wanted me to read it, I'm like, oh,

Speaker:

come on. But as is true with the Internet, in so

Speaker:

many circumstances, what you get from Internet

Speaker:

responses is more or less like social media. It's opinions.

Speaker:

And so having something that helps weed out those opinions, whether it's

Speaker:

a medical reference, like up to date, or whether it's AI or whether it's

Speaker:

whatever it is, I think can really help people

Speaker:

simplify how they think of being their own health care

Speaker:

CEO. I love that term. Yeah. And can we unpack

Speaker:

that a little more? Because where I'm now going in my brain is,

Speaker:

should I show up in your office today as a patient,

Speaker:

how would I. And I want to get an A plus from you is like,

Speaker:

rock star patient. You know, what would that look like to you as a

Speaker:

provider? And let me give you an example. One thing I make up that would

Speaker:

look, you know, be A plus rock star would be I

Speaker:

show up with, like, my list of medications I'm on. I can

Speaker:

give you maybe I have a heart rate or,

Speaker:

excuse me, a blood pressure monitor at home, so I can maybe show up with

Speaker:

some data. I can show up with maybe a food log of what I've eaten

Speaker:

in the past week. Like, I. I always come at. I

Speaker:

always approach it as, how can I help? You have the best

Speaker:

picture of me because I only get, like, a certain amount of

Speaker:

minutes with you. Right. But add to that or subtract from

Speaker:

it. Like, what. What is a rock star patient that helps you

Speaker:

perform your best care for the patient? Well, you've got a

Speaker:

lot of components there in what you do, and I think

Speaker:

meaningful information is extremely valuable.

Speaker:

In some cases, your healthcare provider may want to get that in advance so they

Speaker:

can look at it. Other times, you can just bring it forward. I think, from

Speaker:

the provider standpoint, from the physician standpoint, having

Speaker:

that distilled in a way that if I'm seeing you,

Speaker:

I can take a look at what you've brought in, and in two or

Speaker:

three or four minutes, I can understand it is incredibly much more

Speaker:

valuable than hearing about each single episode that you've had

Speaker:

that you think might be important to your health. And so I think that will

Speaker:

be. That is an advantage of having some quantifiable information

Speaker:

that you'll have from your. From your watch, from whatever. And so. But rather

Speaker:

than showing, Bringing every tracing in, showing it, say, well, here's what the summary

Speaker:

is, and they may want to dive into it more. So I think

Speaker:

that I think food logs are great. I think exercise logs are great. I think

Speaker:

exercise logs along with if you have a wearable, what's going on with your

Speaker:

wearable when you're exercising? If you say, well I'm, I'm walking,

Speaker:

you know, three miles a day and it turns out you're walking one mile an

Speaker:

hour and your heart rate never varies, that's not the same thing as a brisk

Speaker:

three mile a day walk. So I think those things are all very

Speaker:

valuable and I think having them, you're being able to

Speaker:

produce them which takes a little bit of work on your, on your side in

Speaker:

a way that's pretty easily understandable and digestible. It's is

Speaker:

invaluable to your healthcare provider. Some of these things. If I could

Speaker:

interrupt and to yourself, because think about it, I mean

Speaker:

it's so interesting the conversations I have with people

Speaker:

who, and you know, I'm pretty well known in my community. A lot of people

Speaker:

know I had heart surgery and I ended up speaking on the TEDx stage about

Speaker:

it. So then you know, that made friends. Congratulations. Thank you. It

Speaker:

was really neat. So I find that I'm like the heart

Speaker:

confessional. So people are like the health

Speaker:

confessional. People just come up to me and just start talking, talking to me

Speaker:

about like their life which I'm happy to hold space for. But it's

Speaker:

so interesting to me. I'll ask questions and how

Speaker:

people hadn't thought to even raise awareness around that

Speaker:

aspect of their bodies or their health or that perspective.

Speaker:

Right. And so I guess that's where like your

Speaker:

role comes in as provider. Being able to ask the right questions

Speaker:

to boil down to what needs to be addressed that day.

Speaker:

But I just find with the wearable, just the

Speaker:

food log, I bring that up because like when the more I look at a

Speaker:

food log, the wearable, yes I'm taking a vacation from it right now.

Speaker:

But it, what it did do on a positive level is

Speaker:

raise my awareness and it helped me make the

Speaker:

changes I needed to make for my health because

Speaker:

therefore, because then I was aware and I was getting the real

Speaker:

time input data input day to

Speaker:

day. So that's another good thing about AI is that it

Speaker:

can raise your awareness. And I know there's like apps on the phone now for

Speaker:

even food logs. I did like the standard like pencil and paper

Speaker:

but there are, there are so many tools and tricks that we have at our

Speaker:

palm on our, on our iPhones that like can help us raise

Speaker:

our awareness to be better patients for healthcare providers like

Speaker:

you. Yeah, those are great comments

Speaker:

Boots. The food log reminds me so I've off and

Speaker:

on had trouble with my weight and particularly as your metabolism starts

Speaker:

slowing down in your 30s and 40s. And so I remember

Speaker:

my internist at the time said, one, just go see

Speaker:

this nutritionist. I'm like, I know about nutrition. And they said, no, just go

Speaker:

see him. And so one of the things they did was we sort of talked

Speaker:

for a while and they said, well, why don't you do a food log? And

Speaker:

I said, why? They said, well, maybe you're, you have some

Speaker:

eating habits that you could think about. And they said, for

Speaker:

example, do you eat at night? And I was like, yeah, but not that much.

Speaker:

So when I kept that food log, it was just, it

Speaker:

was, I don't know what. It was astoundingly terrible. So, you know,

Speaker:

I was, I was, I was getting in an extra, you know, 6 or 800

Speaker:

calories after dinner. So. And that, that was a habit

Speaker:

I'd had for a while. And I, I just thought, well, you know, how bad

Speaker:

can like, some chips and dip be? Well, it can be bad.

Speaker:

And you're like, oh, yeah.

Speaker:

So I think, I think your comment, I'm kind of

Speaker:

circling back to your comment about self

Speaker:

awareness. It, it is, when you do things like that, it is very

Speaker:

helpful. I also want to make one comment about interaction

Speaker:

with healthcare providers and AI. So you may

Speaker:

well be aware of this or you may not be. There's, there

Speaker:

are programs now or they're products that use what's called

Speaker:

ambient AI to record your interaction with your healthcare

Speaker:

provider. We, we use one here. The one we use is called

Speaker:

Nuance. Dax. Dax. But there's several of

Speaker:

these, and they don't just record your conversation. They put it

Speaker:

into a, into a note. So you and I are

Speaker:

talking. And if this were, if we had nuance

Speaker:

on at the end of this, I'd say summarize my conversation with Brooks and

Speaker:

it would have it all summarized, or in the case of a medical visit,

Speaker:

it'll have it all summarized into what your present illness is, what

Speaker:

your past medical history is, what your review systems

Speaker:

are. And what that does is it frees your

Speaker:

doctor, nurse, healthcare provider from having to take notes. Or

Speaker:

many of us have both personally on the provider side, but also on the patient

Speaker:

side, met with our primary care physician or our physician, and

Speaker:

seeing them, they're just typing away, you know, furiously during our

Speaker:

interaction. This frees them to really have a much more meaningful

Speaker:

conversation. And that, that is again another example

Speaker:

of benefit from AI. Now since we use that, I know

Speaker:

that I need to read that because it may be Full of errors or may

Speaker:

have misinterpreted something. But it still is so much faster than my

Speaker:

starting from scratch to dictate or type in a

Speaker:

medical. A note from our medical interaction. Well, and how

Speaker:

many patients do you see in a day? Right. And you have to keep all

Speaker:

those people straight. That's right, yeah. My cardiologist

Speaker:

uses. I don't know what the program is, but yeah, she.

Speaker:

She is sold on it. She said it has saved her so much

Speaker:

time. Yeah, I think it's saved many people. And electronic medical

Speaker:

records, or electronic health records, I think have

Speaker:

many positive to them, but from the provider side,

Speaker:

they have been an enormous time sink. So I think these

Speaker:

new approaches will be helpful. In fact, it's a little bit

Speaker:

of an aside. I have a hobby of writing

Speaker:

medical fiction, so I. I wrote a. I wrote a novel about electronic

Speaker:

medical records and things that could go bad with electronic medical

Speaker:

records. It's a novel. It's not factual. I'm glad you brought that up. What

Speaker:

is the title of it? I was just reading the summary of it.

Speaker:

Oh, the title of that is Coded To Kill. And the.

Speaker:

The premise is that there's a group of ne'er do wells

Speaker:

who are hacking into the unified medical records of a big

Speaker:

hospital and using it to dig up

Speaker:

dirt. But also, have you heard the term Internet of things?

Speaker:

No. So IoT or Internet of things is

Speaker:

a term that's used to describe how everything's

Speaker:

connected to everything. And a lot of what we do, you know, for

Speaker:

example, we don't have a system like this in our home. But if you.

Speaker:

If it's a really hot day and you want to crank down the air conditioner

Speaker:

on your way home, on your drive home, you can do that through your Internet

Speaker:

of things. In this case, in the. In the novel, because so many things

Speaker:

are connected in a hospital setting, these ne'er do wells are

Speaker:

leveraging this Internet of things. So, for example, I didn't have

Speaker:

any idea until I started working on this. When you're in the hospital and you

Speaker:

get a bag of IV fluids, I figured there was a pharmacist or

Speaker:

a pharmacy tech who put together those

Speaker:

bags. Well, in big hospitals these days, it's done by robots, which are

Speaker:

incredibly accurate and they don't make mistakes,

Speaker:

except for if they're programmed wrong. And so you can imagine how

Speaker:

somebody who's trying to kill somebody in the hospital could

Speaker:

reprogram that pharmacy robot to give the wrong medicines or give a

Speaker:

lethal dose of something. So anyway, the novel's about things like that.

Speaker:

And. Oh, wow. Great thing about. Thing about fiction is you can just make up

Speaker:

whatever you want and there's no fact checking. Exactly. Well, I was

Speaker:

gonna. Whoops, I just hit my mic. I was just gonna ask. I hope it

Speaker:

wasn't based on any true stories that you know of.

Speaker:

The novel is not based on any true novel stories. What. What

Speaker:

stimulated me to write it, though, was when I was at the University

Speaker:

of North Carolina, there was an incident there that a

Speaker:

famous athlete, that all kinds of people had looked at their medical record. They weren't

Speaker:

supposed to be looking. I mean, those are supposed to be private. But they'd looked

Speaker:

because we had electronic medical records. So I had the

Speaker:

dubious charge of having to speak to about 50 faculty members who'd

Speaker:

inappropriately accessed this athlete's record. And, you know, I

Speaker:

know I don't know about you, but about me, I worry that that

Speaker:

happens. And so we actually have, at the University of Michigan, as do many

Speaker:

places, we have a AI driven scanner of electronic medical

Speaker:

records that looks at every single electronic medical record every

Speaker:

day and figures out whether if you looked at. If

Speaker:

I looked at your record, was that because I'm your cardiologist or

Speaker:

just because I'd heard you were in the hospital? And if I was

Speaker:

doing that for my own reasons at the University of Michigan, I get fired.

Speaker:

And I think that's the way it should be. But you know, that that also

Speaker:

is something that's benefited from the advent of AI Even before we were

Speaker:

hearing about. AI Wow, you are a treasure. And

Speaker:

I either blabbermouth. I'm not sure which one.

Speaker:

Before we part, I have two

Speaker:

questions that you can answer very succinctly. Number

Speaker:

one, what is the medical

Speaker:

advice or advice you wish you

Speaker:

could give to all heart patients? If there's just something you want to scream from

Speaker:

the mountaintops that you don't get to say enough, that you just

Speaker:

don't feel said enough to we heart patients. What is it? Well,

Speaker:

it's very much akin to what you were talking about. And I always learn from

Speaker:

people. You can and you should be the CEO of your health. And

Speaker:

there are things that you can do to improve your health to

Speaker:

prevent having more heart problems that aren't as terrible as

Speaker:

you think they are. So be the CEO of your health. Love

Speaker:

it. And then number two, and I think we already have an

Speaker:

idea just based on our whole conversation today. But like, when you get

Speaker:

up in the morning and you go to work at University of

Speaker:

Michigan, what are you the most excited about? Well, I'm

Speaker:

excited. We talked a lot about AI. I'm excited because

Speaker:

I think there's a future in health care that's going to

Speaker:

accelerate more than at any time during my 40

Speaker:

years in health care. And I think that's exciting because I think

Speaker:

we'll get the tools and have the ways that we can control

Speaker:

our own health and that our patients can control their own health in a

Speaker:

manner that really was unimaginable 15 or 20 years

Speaker:

ago. So I'm excited about that.

Speaker:

So being proactive instead of reactive.

Speaker:

Right. I'm less excited about the fact that one of the two

Speaker:

elevators from the parking lot I park in is being worked

Speaker:

on, and it's seven flights of stairs. So at the end

Speaker:

of that, I feel. At the end of that, I feel good about it. Otherwise,

Speaker:

I'd never be walking those seven flights of stairs when I come in.

Speaker:

I hope you get your own parking space, by the way. Well,

Speaker:

I sort of have a parking place. Okay. I think you've

Speaker:

earned it. I think it's okay. You can own the fact that you have your

Speaker:

own. Your own parking space. Well, I will. I will. Then, yes,

Speaker:

I have my own parking space. Oh, good.

Speaker:

Well, Dr. Marshall Ranghi, thank you so much

Speaker:

for your time today. I speak for

Speaker:

all heart patients. We all benefit from your work, and I

Speaker:

can hardly wait to see what comes next from you and your

Speaker:

team at the University of Michigan. And for everyone

Speaker:

listening today, be sure to check out the

Speaker:

show notes. I'll have a bio in there of Dr. Range

Speaker:

and a way to find him and buy his

Speaker:

book, support his work and just

Speaker:

keep taking care of you, like he said. Like I said, you are the

Speaker:

CEO of your own health. And remember, in case no one has

Speaker:

told you today, I love you. You

Speaker:

matter, and your heart is your best friend. Thanks,

Speaker:

Dr. Runge. Thanks, Boots. A privilege to be on your show.