1 00:00:07,223 --> 00:00:08,693 Evan Troxel: Welcome to the TRXL podcast. 2 00:00:08,813 --> 00:00:09,743 I'm Evan Troxel. 3 00:00:10,013 --> 00:00:13,223 In this episode, I welcome Nathan Miller back to the podcast. 4 00:00:13,343 --> 00:00:17,993 Nate is the founder of Proving Ground, a digital transformation agency, and 5 00:00:17,993 --> 00:00:22,133 he specializes in collaborating with designers and builders to implement 6 00:00:22,133 --> 00:00:27,143 digital strategies for reducing waste, enhancing creativity and making better 7 00:00:27,143 --> 00:00:28,853 decisions about the built environment. 8 00:00:29,333 --> 00:00:33,053 In addition to developing new software, like the popular LunchBox 9 00:00:33,053 --> 00:00:37,523 plugin for Grasshopper and Dynamo, Nate frequently publishes writings 10 00:00:37,523 --> 00:00:41,423 about digital business practices, critical evaluation of technology 11 00:00:41,423 --> 00:00:45,383 trends and ethical considerations influencing the adoption of new 12 00:00:45,383 --> 00:00:48,083 technology in the construction industry. 13 00:00:48,413 --> 00:00:52,013 There's also a very useful weekly workflow series running over at the 14 00:00:52,013 --> 00:00:56,363 Proving Ground blog, showing off how to implement their machine learning tools 15 00:00:56,603 --> 00:01:01,163 and LunchBox plugins, for example, that caught my eye a couple of months ago. 16 00:01:01,523 --> 00:01:05,212 You should definitely check it out by following the link in the show notes. 17 00:01:05,723 --> 00:01:09,293 Today, we discuss the importance of maintaining a critical view when it 18 00:01:09,293 --> 00:01:13,853 comes to tools and technology, the need to evaluate new technologies and 19 00:01:13,853 --> 00:01:18,113 innovations carefully to determine if they align with your desired goals, 20 00:01:18,593 --> 00:01:23,063 the value of balancing established experience with new advancements and 21 00:01:23,063 --> 00:01:27,083 fostering bi-directional learning between innovators and experienced professionals, 22 00:01:27,563 --> 00:01:31,793 the value of navigating the constantly evolving nature of technology and 23 00:01:31,793 --> 00:01:36,923 architectural design, the importance of learning from previous projects to drive 24 00:01:36,923 --> 00:01:39,593 continuous improvement, and other topics. 25 00:01:39,957 --> 00:01:44,217 So without further ado, I bring you my conversation with Nate Miller. 26 00:01:50,407 --> 00:01:52,127 I would love to just talk about proving ground. 27 00:01:52,227 --> 00:01:55,567 I'd love to talk about kind of how you got, because the last 28 00:01:55,567 --> 00:01:58,287 time we talked we didn't talk about that as far as I remember. 29 00:01:58,447 --> 00:02:01,847 I mean, it was, it's a fuzzy time in history, I think. 30 00:02:01,907 --> 00:02:06,527 But, um, I remember us talking about C O V I D and just like, it 31 00:02:06,527 --> 00:02:07,926 was great to have a conversation. 32 00:02:08,187 --> 00:02:08,407 And 33 00:02:08,407 --> 00:02:10,847 so like, wherever it goes is wherever it goes. 34 00:02:11,147 --> 00:02:15,247 Uh, I don't, I don't actually like to set an agenda up front, but I would like 35 00:02:15,247 --> 00:02:19,167 to show, you know, talk about what you're doing and you're, you know, 36 00:02:19,167 --> 00:02:20,727 you're doing the Lord's work, I'm sure. 37 00:02:20,997 --> 00:02:23,167 Nathan Miller: Well, well, we can, we 38 00:02:23,167 --> 00:02:29,847 can, um, we can let the listeners decide if, um, you know, in 20, 39 00:02:29,947 --> 00:02:31,447 we did the first one in 2020. 40 00:02:32,582 --> 00:02:33,722 Now we're in 2023. 41 00:02:34,182 --> 00:02:39,882 Has Nate become more or less anxious and unhinged in this, 42 00:02:39,942 --> 00:02:41,442 in that, in that time span? 43 00:02:42,062 --> 00:02:44,482 Um, 'cause it doesn't really seem like crisis. 44 00:02:44,702 --> 00:02:48,522 The crisis of, of world events has really ever gone away, 45 00:02:49,237 --> 00:02:49,457 Evan Troxel: No, 46 00:02:49,942 --> 00:02:50,242 Nathan Miller: you know? 47 00:02:50,242 --> 00:02:51,442 it's just sort of been like, 48 00:02:51,727 --> 00:02:52,216 Evan Troxel: Just a 49 00:02:52,216 --> 00:02:52,777 different version. 50 00:02:52,802 --> 00:02:53,042 Nathan Miller: more, 51 00:02:53,487 --> 00:02:53,777 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 52 00:02:53,802 --> 00:02:54,082 Nathan Miller: just Yeah. 53 00:02:54,082 --> 00:02:55,602 Different versions, more of them. 54 00:02:55,662 --> 00:02:56,082 And so 55 00:02:56,632 --> 00:03:01,802 your listeners can be like, whoa, we thought, you know, he was on the 56 00:03:01,802 --> 00:03:07,042 edge in 2020 and now he's really, he's really taken the plunge, um, 57 00:03:08,147 --> 00:03:08,267 Evan Troxel: I, 58 00:03:08,387 --> 00:03:14,047 I read something Nate that was like, uh, you get like more and more anxious 59 00:03:14,507 --> 00:03:20,327 and I know, maybe angry, maybe like questioning until like age 55 is like 60 00:03:20,427 --> 00:03:23,007 the, the, the culmination of all that. 61 00:03:23,507 --> 00:03:27,447 And then, and then it just gets better and it's like, it's some, 62 00:03:27,447 --> 00:03:28,727 something happens, you know? 63 00:03:28,747 --> 00:03:30,367 I'm sure that's just like some number that 64 00:03:30,427 --> 00:03:31,367 is an average, but 65 00:03:32,537 --> 00:03:34,427 Nathan Miller: Well, it's like reaching the top of a rollercoaster. 66 00:03:34,567 --> 00:03:36,307 You're, you're like, you're at the top. 67 00:03:36,307 --> 00:03:39,387 You're like, okay, I'm just going to, I'm, I'm 55 now. 68 00:03:39,447 --> 00:03:40,227 I'm just gonna coast. 69 00:03:41,047 --> 00:03:41,337 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 70 00:03:41,447 --> 00:03:42,347 Nathan Miller: I'm on my way down. 71 00:03:43,466 --> 00:03:44,827 is all someone else's problem, 72 00:03:45,122 --> 00:03:45,862 Evan Troxel: To hell with it. 73 00:03:46,012 --> 00:03:46,302 Yeah. 74 00:03:46,466 --> 00:03:48,227 Nathan Miller: Yeah, that's right. 75 00:03:48,767 --> 00:03:49,466 That's right. 76 00:03:50,857 --> 00:03:52,466 Well, that's, it's, you know, I'm getting there. 77 00:03:52,587 --> 00:03:55,787 I, I think this is all, this is, this is good to have a, have a convo. 78 00:03:55,947 --> 00:03:57,747 I, I turned 40 this year. 79 00:03:58,687 --> 00:04:03,347 Um, and I think that's, that's like, it's like, I didn't think it would 80 00:04:03,347 --> 00:04:06,307 mean too much, but it's kind of like in the back of your mind I'm like, oh, 81 00:04:06,367 --> 00:04:08,937 I'm, I'm not in my thirties anymore. 82 00:04:09,152 --> 00:04:09,572 Evan Troxel: we right. 83 00:04:09,997 --> 00:04:14,057 Nathan Miller: and I think about, I think about technology and the, the 84 00:04:14,057 --> 00:04:19,697 space that we operate in and, you know, you're always told, uh, at least 85 00:04:19,976 --> 00:04:23,137 I always felt like, you know, when I was first getting into the, the. 86 00:04:23,967 --> 00:04:27,467 The architecture and computational design scene. 87 00:04:28,527 --> 00:04:33,287 You know, you'd have the, you know, the, the, the project, you know, the senior 88 00:04:33,287 --> 00:04:38,047 project manager principal talking about, oh, he's, he's into the new stuff. 89 00:04:38,117 --> 00:04:39,927 It's a, it's a young person's game, 90 00:04:40,387 --> 00:04:40,607 you 91 00:04:40,692 --> 00:04:40,982 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 92 00:04:41,172 --> 00:04:41,462 Yeah. 93 00:04:41,667 --> 00:04:44,327 Nathan Miller: And now I'm like the, I'm, now I'm kinda get 94 00:04:44,327 --> 00:04:45,767 to be that, that older guy. 95 00:04:45,967 --> 00:04:46,487 I mean, like, 96 00:04:46,947 --> 00:04:47,237 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 97 00:04:47,467 --> 00:04:47,757 Yeah. 98 00:04:47,757 --> 00:04:49,677 You, you're still an emerging professional. 99 00:04:49,677 --> 00:04:53,557 You're still a, you're still a youngster in, in the architectural profession. 100 00:04:54,297 --> 00:04:58,917 You have to, like, you have to have some serious gray hair to be considered senior. 101 00:04:59,597 --> 00:05:00,477 Anything, you know, 102 00:05:02,607 --> 00:05:05,347 Nathan Miller: um, between you and me, I don't think I'll ever have gray hair 103 00:05:07,997 --> 00:05:08,527 Evan Troxel: just between 104 00:05:08,547 --> 00:05:08,767 us. 105 00:05:09,037 --> 00:05:11,937 Nathan Miller: as, as you can, as you can, as you can tell, as 106 00:05:11,937 --> 00:05:12,897 you can tell from my haircut. 107 00:05:13,177 --> 00:05:13,577 I don't know. 108 00:05:13,757 --> 00:05:14,937 It could be gray right now. 109 00:05:15,337 --> 00:05:16,137 I, I wouldn't know. 110 00:05:16,747 --> 00:05:16,967 Evan Troxel: Oh, 111 00:05:16,977 --> 00:05:17,537 Nathan Miller: I wouldn't know. 112 00:05:17,797 --> 00:05:19,367 Evan Troxel: it's like I grow my beard out. 113 00:05:19,927 --> 00:05:24,447 I don't actually, my wife won't allow it, but uh, when I, when it pokes out, it's 114 00:05:24,447 --> 00:05:26,607 like, whoa, there it's just white man. 115 00:05:26,607 --> 00:05:27,847 Like, what 116 00:05:28,207 --> 00:05:28,367 happened? 117 00:05:28,547 --> 00:05:29,877 Nathan Miller: Yeah, that's right. 118 00:05:31,037 --> 00:05:31,687 Evan Troxel: What happened? 119 00:05:31,687 --> 00:05:32,687 Where'd that come from? 120 00:05:33,547 --> 00:05:34,247 Oh my God. 121 00:05:34,637 --> 00:05:34,927 Yeah. 122 00:05:35,197 --> 00:05:37,887 It's, it's, uh, it's eyeopening at, at that point, 123 00:05:39,647 --> 00:05:39,937 Nathan Miller: Sure. 124 00:05:40,087 --> 00:05:40,607 Evan Troxel: actually feel it. 125 00:05:40,867 --> 00:05:42,567 So anyway, yeah. 126 00:05:42,577 --> 00:05:43,887 Let's talk about proving ground. 127 00:05:43,887 --> 00:05:47,167 Let's talk about what you've been up to for the last three years, two 128 00:05:47,167 --> 00:05:48,567 and a half years since we talked. 129 00:05:48,727 --> 00:05:51,767 I mean, that was a, that was an episode for the, for the books 130 00:05:51,917 --> 00:05:54,927 that was like solid covid time. 131 00:05:55,107 --> 00:05:57,607 We were just like getting our feet back under us. 132 00:05:57,987 --> 00:06:01,087 And I mean, so much has happened since then. 133 00:06:01,507 --> 00:06:09,847 And you are creating order out of chaos, which is the a e c tech sphere and maybe 134 00:06:09,847 --> 00:06:13,607 just the architectural profession in general, but like you, the tools that 135 00:06:13,607 --> 00:06:15,847 you make, the training that you provide. 136 00:06:16,227 --> 00:06:20,607 You know, you go in and, and, and you kind of do these assessments on firms and you, 137 00:06:20,947 --> 00:06:24,807 you're, you, you've always been kind of the champion of digital transformation 138 00:06:25,317 --> 00:06:29,607 when it comes to architecture using technology to, its, to its benefit. 139 00:06:29,867 --> 00:06:31,007 So, I mean, let's. 140 00:06:31,937 --> 00:06:33,137 Let's talk about roofing ground. 141 00:06:33,137 --> 00:06:37,497 Let's talk about Nate Miller, who is the, the founder of, and the team 142 00:06:37,517 --> 00:06:39,177 behind what, what you're working on. 143 00:06:39,987 --> 00:06:40,277 Nathan Miller: Sure. 144 00:06:40,307 --> 00:06:40,597 Yeah. 145 00:06:40,737 --> 00:06:44,637 You know, it's proving ground turned eight years old 146 00:06:45,057 --> 00:06:47,077 as a company, um, this year. 147 00:06:47,617 --> 00:06:54,047 Um, and, and before that, you know, if you, if I really rewind the 148 00:06:54,167 --> 00:06:56,447 clock, proving ground was a blog, 149 00:06:57,187 --> 00:06:57,537 Evan Troxel: Right. 150 00:06:58,117 --> 00:06:58,657 . That's right. 151 00:06:58,707 --> 00:07:02,767 Nathan Miller: to like, even to this day, you know, there's that blog element to it. 152 00:07:03,897 --> 00:07:08,837 And, you know, if, I think if I, if I really think back to what, what 153 00:07:09,467 --> 00:07:15,867 really motivated, I guess that initial genesis was, you know, maybe a. 154 00:07:16,427 --> 00:07:20,797 Idea of a, a question on what can technology really do 155 00:07:21,217 --> 00:07:24,197 to benefit the building design? 156 00:07:24,207 --> 00:07:25,917 Originally, the building design process. 157 00:07:26,237 --> 00:07:27,317 'cause I was a designer at the time, 158 00:07:27,417 --> 00:07:30,597 and you know, as, as we all know, when you're a designer, that's 159 00:07:30,597 --> 00:07:31,717 all you can think about is design. 160 00:07:32,057 --> 00:07:35,037 Um, and, uh, and it becomes kind of your 161 00:07:35,397 --> 00:07:35,797 whole world. 162 00:07:36,377 --> 00:07:40,197 But I think we've kind of broadened the scope, uh, quite a bit in more 163 00:07:40,197 --> 00:07:43,717 recent years as we've been thinking about construction and, and operations. 164 00:07:44,897 --> 00:07:51,637 Uh, but it, it really did start as a, as a way to sort of, and this is I guess 165 00:07:51,657 --> 00:07:57,457 the, the, name of, of the company and, and previously the blog, you know, to 166 00:07:57,457 --> 00:08:05,617 prove that this stuff, this new stuff, technology and computation and, you 167 00:08:05,617 --> 00:08:11,497 know, uh, tech, uh, being the umbrella term can actually transform how we work 168 00:08:11,677 --> 00:08:14,617 to, uh, tort, you know, to a better. 169 00:08:15,567 --> 00:08:16,177 Kind of state, 170 00:08:16,667 --> 00:08:20,767 um, whether it's better design, um, a better construction process or 171 00:08:20,807 --> 00:08:25,567 a better, uh, lifecycle management of, of the, our, the building. 172 00:08:26,147 --> 00:08:32,246 Um, and when, when I first was like getting into this space, you 173 00:08:32,246 --> 00:08:35,486 know, the blog really was more of a journal than anything else. 174 00:08:35,907 --> 00:08:41,447 You know, you kind of have a set of, of, of, interest areas like, 175 00:08:41,866 --> 00:08:47,537 oh, what if you had a grasshopper definition help you plan your building? 176 00:08:47,677 --> 00:08:48,897 And like, what would that look like? 177 00:08:49,117 --> 00:08:49,417 You know? 178 00:08:49,417 --> 00:08:52,937 And, and the, you know, you could actually probably go back to some of 179 00:08:52,937 --> 00:08:56,537 those early posts where it's like, oh yeah, you could probably do something 180 00:08:56,537 --> 00:09:01,847 with, um, novel uses of tessellation and, and figure out relationships 181 00:09:01,847 --> 00:09:04,287 between kind of auto-generated geometry 182 00:09:04,387 --> 00:09:07,327 and, you know, think about planning that way, or you're using something 183 00:09:07,327 --> 00:09:13,392 like, You know, one of the, one of the OG grasshopper plugins, kangaroo, maybe 184 00:09:13,412 --> 00:09:19,032 can we actually use a physics engine to help us solve, you know, how spaces 185 00:09:19,082 --> 00:09:21,432 might come together in, in some way. 186 00:09:21,432 --> 00:09:21,752 Right? 187 00:09:22,412 --> 00:09:28,432 And so it really was like this, this, um, this journal or diary of of 188 00:09:28,432 --> 00:09:32,192 experiments, which eventually became, oh, I'm gonna write my own plugin. 189 00:09:32,492 --> 00:09:36,592 Um, now, and, you know, either the first one I wrote was a plugin called 190 00:09:36,792 --> 00:09:40,992 Slingshot, which was all about sending data out of Grasshopper into a database 191 00:09:41,052 --> 00:09:46,512 and then lunchbox, um, which if I rewind the clock, I think that was 192 00:09:46,512 --> 00:09:50,152 like 20 10, 20 11, uh, when the first 193 00:09:50,152 --> 00:09:51,552 release of Lunchbox was out. 194 00:09:52,872 --> 00:09:56,812 Um, and that one, that one was derived from, like, I just wanted to go. 195 00:09:57,112 --> 00:09:58,692 In some ways it was kind of driven by. 196 00:09:59,912 --> 00:10:03,072 I just want to be able to get through this competition as fast as possible, 197 00:10:03,072 --> 00:10:07,112 because I know I'm gonna be doing paneling systems and I know I'm gonna be doing a 198 00:10:07,112 --> 00:10:09,152 lot of complex geometry and structure. 199 00:10:09,572 --> 00:10:12,392 So can I create a plugin that will help me get through this without 200 00:10:12,392 --> 00:10:13,512 having to reinvent it every time? 201 00:10:13,692 --> 00:10:13,912 And 202 00:10:13,912 --> 00:10:15,672 that's what, you know, that's what Lunchbox became. 203 00:10:16,252 --> 00:10:21,032 Um, and you know, if I then kind of look at our current state, um, what I like 204 00:10:21,032 --> 00:10:26,012 to think, uh, proving ground has become, you know, we're a company now, which is 205 00:10:26,012 --> 00:10:30,452 very different than someone sitting in front of the, the computer writing a blog. 206 00:10:31,152 --> 00:10:39,572 Um, but a lot of that original, that sort of original kind of thinking from those 207 00:10:39,572 --> 00:10:44,577 days where you're experimenting or asking questions, you're looking at what can What 208 00:10:44,637 --> 00:10:48,577 can a building design and construction and operations process look like? 209 00:10:49,277 --> 00:10:54,817 Um, if we were to employ certain techniques or technologies, um, has really 210 00:10:54,817 --> 00:10:57,817 been a driver for a lot of our work today. 211 00:10:58,117 --> 00:11:03,297 And, you know, that's kind of turned into different forms of service. 212 00:11:03,717 --> 00:11:06,337 You know, you mentioned the strategy side, which is super important. 213 00:11:06,397 --> 00:11:12,297 I'd like to actually talk a lot about that, um, because it, it feeds into maybe 214 00:11:12,297 --> 00:11:17,097 some peripheral subject matters related to what we're seeing happening today with 215 00:11:17,867 --> 00:11:19,857 generative AI and all that other stuff. 216 00:11:19,877 --> 00:11:22,657 And a lot of people are asking a lot of questions right now in their 217 00:11:22,857 --> 00:11:24,337 practices, like, what, what is this gonna do? 218 00:11:24,797 --> 00:11:28,637 Um, but you have the strategy side. 219 00:11:28,737 --> 00:11:31,477 You have, you know, building, continuing to build tools. 220 00:11:32,057 --> 00:11:37,917 Um, we've productized some of them and that was really, I guess, I. 221 00:11:39,337 --> 00:11:40,787 That really started in 2020. 222 00:11:41,487 --> 00:11:42,587 in some ways, that was a, 223 00:11:42,657 --> 00:11:45,587 that was a survival instinct in, in some ways when, 'cause we 224 00:11:45,587 --> 00:11:46,387 didn't know what was gonna happen. 225 00:11:46,527 --> 00:11:49,547 And um, all of a sudden our tr our in-person 226 00:11:49,907 --> 00:11:52,787 training and in-person workshops and, and 227 00:11:53,067 --> 00:11:54,827 strategy Just like went away. 228 00:11:55,287 --> 00:12:00,187 And so we needed to think about, okay, how can proving ground start to put itself 229 00:12:00,187 --> 00:12:01,427 out there in new, in different ways? 230 00:12:01,527 --> 00:12:04,387 And that led to a segment of our stuff becoming more product 231 00:12:04,977 --> 00:12:08,747 productized and then different kinds of service, which allowed us 232 00:12:08,767 --> 00:12:12,867 to, to do what we do, um, in a capacity that didn't require us 233 00:12:12,867 --> 00:12:15,297 to be in the room physically. 234 00:12:15,347 --> 00:12:15,697 Right. 235 00:12:16,207 --> 00:12:16,557 Evan Troxel: right. 236 00:12:18,222 --> 00:12:19,032 There's a lot there. 237 00:12:19,102 --> 00:12:23,022 I mean, I, I even think back to what you were, where you started with this online 238 00:12:23,022 --> 00:12:28,542 journal basically, and I, I, my question is like, how did you decide to make that 239 00:12:28,662 --> 00:12:30,662 a public journal versus a private journal? 240 00:12:30,662 --> 00:12:34,582 Because I think there's a, we've see it all the time through you're, you're in 241 00:12:34,582 --> 00:12:39,582 a position where you looking at firms and you're seeing the duplication of 242 00:12:39,582 --> 00:12:43,182 effort in every one of these firms, and I think one of the big reasons of 243 00:12:43,182 --> 00:12:48,352 the duplication of effort is people are not publicly dreaming about this stuff. 244 00:12:48,352 --> 00:12:51,432 They're not publicly talking about this stuff, and so therefore, 245 00:12:51,432 --> 00:12:52,392 they're in their own silo. 246 00:12:52,402 --> 00:12:55,552 Maybe they're looking at what other people are doing, but because the majority 247 00:12:55,722 --> 00:13:00,952 don't publicly put out there what they're working on in the sense that you did 248 00:13:00,952 --> 00:13:04,582 with proving ground on the blog, I think that's just a very different approach. 249 00:13:04,762 --> 00:13:08,832 Why did you decide to go that route instead of keeping it to yourself? 250 00:13:09,597 --> 00:13:11,417 Nathan Miller: You know, that's a really good question. 251 00:13:11,757 --> 00:13:14,817 Um, I, I don't know if I know the exact answer to that. 252 00:13:15,097 --> 00:13:22,897 I, I, I, I first started the blog right as I graduated from school. 253 00:13:23,637 --> 00:13:26,497 Um, and at the time it wasn't even called Proving Ground. 254 00:13:26,517 --> 00:13:29,857 It was just like, I, I heard of people starting, you know, 255 00:13:30,307 --> 00:13:32,297 blogs I had done, like I. 256 00:13:32,747 --> 00:13:36,357 This has taken me way back, but pre, pre-Facebook days, you know, I was 257 00:13:36,357 --> 00:13:38,037 all, I was like, what was it called? 258 00:13:38,037 --> 00:13:38,637 Live Journal. 259 00:13:39,377 --> 00:13:44,477 Um, I was doing that, uh, when I was in college, uh, ear, early days of college. 260 00:13:44,697 --> 00:13:50,737 And, um, know, the Facebook became really popular when I was in college. 261 00:13:52,157 --> 00:13:56,737 And so in some ways I feel like that maybe just instilled a bit of like, 262 00:13:57,127 --> 00:14:03,587 okay, um, in order for, you know, if I think about where the world was going 263 00:14:05,037 --> 00:14:11,777 how street cred, um, and career and things like that, maybe taking us, 264 00:14:11,957 --> 00:14:12,977 you know, where that might be going. 265 00:14:13,087 --> 00:14:13,937 It's gonna be online. 266 00:14:14,997 --> 00:14:20,267 And so in some ways the starting a blog was, it served two purposes. 267 00:14:20,447 --> 00:14:26,027 One, for my own sake, I could track what I was doing and, you know, maybe if 268 00:14:26,027 --> 00:14:28,387 there were some, some idea of trends and. 269 00:14:30,162 --> 00:14:32,082 In, the work that I was doing and what that would be. 270 00:14:33,262 --> 00:14:39,372 Um, but there was also this idea that, um, you know, you could, you could 271 00:14:39,372 --> 00:14:40,972 kind of make a name for yourself by 272 00:14:40,972 --> 00:14:43,252 putting, putting things out there, especially if you're doing things 273 00:14:43,252 --> 00:14:44,772 that were really, really new. 274 00:14:44,992 --> 00:14:51,042 And at the time, tools like Grasshopper, um, were really, really new. 275 00:14:51,582 --> 00:14:56,882 And, um, there was, there was a bit of a, in those early days of Grasshopper, and I 276 00:14:56,882 --> 00:14:58,682 think that it still persists to this day. 277 00:14:59,192 --> 00:15:02,202 It's very community driven type of tool. 278 00:15:02,522 --> 00:15:02,812 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 279 00:15:03,302 --> 00:15:07,842 Nathan Miller: And I remember when it was in the first days of beta, you had 280 00:15:07,882 --> 00:15:12,082 a Google, a public Google group where if you wanted to learn anything about 281 00:15:12,312 --> 00:15:17,682 Grasshopper, that was the only place you could get any information because you 282 00:15:17,682 --> 00:15:19,962 had David Rutten writing the software. 283 00:15:20,952 --> 00:15:23,832 He was, he was like almost building an airplane while he was trying to 284 00:15:23,832 --> 00:15:25,072 figure out where to land it, you know? 285 00:15:25,077 --> 00:15:25,367 Evan Troxel: yeah. 286 00:15:25,377 --> 00:15:25,727 Right. 287 00:15:25,812 --> 00:15:28,912 Nathan Miller: Um, and then you had all these people, like contributing ideas 288 00:15:29,492 --> 00:15:34,512 and throwing in example files, throwing in files that were needed for debugging. 289 00:15:34,972 --> 00:15:38,812 And, you know, you don't want to, I think in that context, you don't 290 00:15:38,812 --> 00:15:41,812 wanna be the person to be like, okay, I'm gonna take all of this and 291 00:15:41,812 --> 00:15:43,652 make like this really private thing. 292 00:15:44,312 --> 00:15:47,932 Um, you wanna like, absorb that information and put something else 293 00:15:48,032 --> 00:15:53,092 out there so you can maybe help shift and shape that community in some ways. 294 00:15:53,167 --> 00:15:53,587 Evan Troxel: Mm-hmm. 295 00:15:54,072 --> 00:15:58,772 Nathan Miller: And I think that that was really a big driver, um, for, for that. 296 00:15:58,852 --> 00:16:01,052 I think the idea of community, the community driven 297 00:16:01,547 --> 00:16:01,967 Evan Troxel: Mm-hmm. 298 00:16:02,592 --> 00:16:06,452 Nathan Miller: of the tools that I were, I was using in combination with, 299 00:16:07,192 --> 00:16:14,282 um, just a general cultural ethos around putting yourself out there 300 00:16:14,662 --> 00:16:16,442 in, in the, you know, right, right. 301 00:16:16,442 --> 00:16:24,022 As social media was becoming Super, super, um, popular, um, you know, 302 00:16:25,482 --> 00:16:28,652 gave, gave me that, that kind of platform with proving ground. 303 00:16:29,072 --> 00:16:29,292 Um, 304 00:16:30,027 --> 00:16:33,807 Evan Troxel: it, it's also where, where it seems like the, you, 305 00:16:33,867 --> 00:16:35,047 you found your tribe, right? 306 00:16:35,207 --> 00:16:38,047 I mean that, that that's the idea of an online community. 307 00:16:38,147 --> 00:16:44,807 But, but you, there's so many other people kind of in your cohort that I would 308 00:16:44,807 --> 00:16:50,007 assume kind of came out of you finding those people in that location online. 309 00:16:51,502 --> 00:16:51,792 Nathan Miller: sure. 310 00:16:51,872 --> 00:16:53,072 I mean, I think, I think so. 311 00:16:53,192 --> 00:16:59,492 I mean, there's, there's the, you know, the, it, if, I think, if I think back to. 312 00:17:01,187 --> 00:17:05,767 You could almost get really specific here with, with the Grasshopper stuff, but 313 00:17:06,186 --> 00:17:12,207 the original like kind of plugin cohort that we're putting out tools, uh, I think 314 00:17:12,267 --> 00:17:15,087 to this day are among the most popular. 315 00:17:15,307 --> 00:17:18,327 You have, we mentioned Kangaroo earlier by Daniel Piker. 316 00:17:18,906 --> 00:17:25,047 Um, you had, uh, Firefly, uh, authored by people like Andy Payne. 317 00:17:25,587 --> 00:17:29,997 You have, um, you know, there, there are some that I, I don't 318 00:17:29,997 --> 00:17:33,557 know if they've quite continued on. 319 00:17:33,697 --> 00:17:37,437 You know, I think about, you know, stuff like late the, I think more 320 00:17:37,677 --> 00:17:41,877 recently like the ladybug tools that kind of, you know, it's afford a 321 00:17:41,877 --> 00:17:45,917 few, a few more years, but you know, it's now one of those kind of staples 322 00:17:46,337 --> 00:17:49,117 of, of the, uh, the workflow. 323 00:17:49,417 --> 00:17:51,837 And then I'd like to, you know, put Lunchbox in there too. 324 00:17:51,897 --> 00:17:52,517 You know, it's just, 325 00:17:52,667 --> 00:17:56,277 it's become those things like when people get Grasshopper and people get Rhino, 326 00:17:56,277 --> 00:17:58,397 they get those plugins I just mentioned. 327 00:17:59,377 --> 00:17:59,817 Parallel with it, 328 00:18:00,357 --> 00:18:06,137 um, because that's what, you know, in some ways gives it, its, um, its juice. 329 00:18:06,597 --> 00:18:09,137 Um, more, more than what's available outta the box. 330 00:18:09,137 --> 00:18:09,417 Right. 331 00:18:10,287 --> 00:18:11,877 Evan Troxel: Especially for architecture, right? 332 00:18:11,997 --> 00:18:14,877 I think that, yeah, there's, there's some key words when it comes to 333 00:18:15,267 --> 00:18:18,477 Grasshopper that are the plugin names that you're mentioning, right? 334 00:18:18,547 --> 00:18:22,277 There's others out there as well, like human ui or, I mean, there's, 335 00:18:22,277 --> 00:18:23,277 there's a bunch of examples, 336 00:18:23,517 --> 00:18:24,347 Nathan Miller: Human ui. 337 00:18:24,367 --> 00:18:24,587 Yep. 338 00:18:24,967 --> 00:18:28,337 Evan Troxel: I mean, it, it's, it's one of those things where in 339 00:18:28,337 --> 00:18:33,017 architecture circles, there's kind of the usual suspects of, of grasshopper 340 00:18:33,017 --> 00:18:34,057 plugins like you talk about. 341 00:18:34,157 --> 00:18:37,377 And I mean, I don't know if they go beyond that. 342 00:18:37,437 --> 00:18:41,377 You would know better than I would, um, being the author of it, but, but, 343 00:18:42,457 --> 00:18:47,097 Architecture specifically kind of relies heavily, especially I would 344 00:18:47,097 --> 00:18:52,177 assume in in school, like in in really like form finding design exploration 345 00:18:52,177 --> 00:18:53,497 where everybody's a designer. 346 00:18:53,787 --> 00:18:56,977 Those are gonna be kind of the, the plugins that get passed 347 00:18:56,977 --> 00:18:58,337 around more than more than others. 348 00:18:59,137 --> 00:18:59,257 Hmm. 349 00:18:59,442 --> 00:19:00,132 Nathan Miller: Yeah, no doubt. 350 00:19:00,252 --> 00:19:04,112 I mean, like it, I, I think one of the things that has been very 351 00:19:04,162 --> 00:19:07,582 surprising, take Lunchbox as an example. 352 00:19:08,392 --> 00:19:14,742 Every now and then I'll get pinged on LinkedIn or, um, some, you 353 00:19:14,742 --> 00:19:17,342 know, directly through email of someone saying what they're doing 354 00:19:17,772 --> 00:19:21,862 with the, the students, because I, I really have no insight into any 355 00:19:22,262 --> 00:19:23,022 anything that anyone does. 356 00:19:23,522 --> 00:19:23,742 Um, 357 00:19:23,807 --> 00:19:24,947 Evan Troxel: you're not creepy like that. 358 00:19:24,947 --> 00:19:27,587 You're, you're like, I wanna see exactly which ones they're clicking 359 00:19:27,607 --> 00:19:28,707 on and how they're using 'em. 360 00:19:28,707 --> 00:19:28,867 Yeah. 361 00:19:28,897 --> 00:19:29,747 It's all phoning home. 362 00:19:29,747 --> 00:19:30,027 Yeah. 363 00:19:30,027 --> 00:19:30,707 That doesn't happen. 364 00:19:30,982 --> 00:19:31,552 Nathan Miller: yeah, yeah. 365 00:19:31,692 --> 00:19:37,312 And, and so, and so for, for context, I am like, I'm pretty against a lot of that. 366 00:19:37,652 --> 00:19:43,832 So, um, even, even with our product stuff, um, if anyone is interested 367 00:19:44,052 --> 00:19:47,777 in Knowing that side of the philosophy, we don't track anything. 368 00:19:48,517 --> 00:19:52,457 Um, and, and so the only way I know if someone's doing something cool 369 00:19:52,457 --> 00:19:55,537 with it is that they, you know, say, Hey Nate, look what I made. 370 00:19:55,917 --> 00:20:01,457 But to the original point, um, I've, I've had people that are 371 00:20:01,527 --> 00:20:05,257 designing automobiles, showing me something they did with Lunchbox, 372 00:20:05,757 --> 00:20:10,537 and I was like, you're using Lunchbox, pa like the paneling stuff to do 373 00:20:10,857 --> 00:20:13,437 a cool pattern on like a Ford. 374 00:20:13,587 --> 00:20:14,517 Like what? 375 00:20:14,857 --> 00:20:18,037 Or you know, some other, uh, and then, and then, uh, I, I 376 00:20:18,037 --> 00:20:20,197 saw one pop up on Instagram. 377 00:20:20,437 --> 00:20:24,357 I got, this was a couple of years back when we first released some 378 00:20:24,357 --> 00:20:26,237 of the ML tools for Lunchbox. 379 00:20:26,817 --> 00:20:33,237 And someone had cobbled together, like a self-driving, like a 380 00:20:33,237 --> 00:20:34,837 virtualized self-driving car. 381 00:20:34,907 --> 00:20:37,637 Basically a car that figured out its way through a racetrack 382 00:20:37,637 --> 00:20:38,837 using some of the ML tools. 383 00:20:38,957 --> 00:20:41,297 I was like, what 384 00:20:42,417 --> 00:20:43,027 Evan Troxel: What a moment. 385 00:20:43,287 --> 00:20:44,067 That's so cool. 386 00:20:44,447 --> 00:20:45,187 That's so cool. 387 00:20:45,187 --> 00:20:46,927 Nathan Miller: And, you know, and it was, I don't even know if it 388 00:20:46,927 --> 00:20:49,287 was like, was it a stu It may have been a student, it may have been 389 00:20:49,397 --> 00:20:49,687 Evan Troxel: Yeah, 390 00:20:50,117 --> 00:20:54,247 Nathan Miller: some researcher, but I was like, you could, I'm like, 391 00:20:54,487 --> 00:20:58,047 I had no idea you could do that with the, the tools that I made. 392 00:20:58,107 --> 00:21:01,127 And that's actually one of the more gratifying aspects of, 393 00:21:01,127 --> 00:21:05,447 a lot of it is like if you put something out there, you made it for 394 00:21:05,487 --> 00:21:06,927 a particular purpose for yourself. 395 00:21:06,987 --> 00:21:13,997 But then when it becomes that you never intended or became or becomes something 396 00:21:13,997 --> 00:21:18,677 that it's another author clearly put their stamp on it, I think it becomes way 397 00:21:18,677 --> 00:21:21,317 more interesting, um, because of that. 398 00:21:22,102 --> 00:21:22,392 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 399 00:21:22,782 --> 00:21:23,072 Yeah. 400 00:21:23,372 --> 00:21:28,192 And, and you guys have gone down that road now with, with conveyor and Semantic and 401 00:21:28,292 --> 00:21:36,332 Tracer and, and so I mean, that was maybe your first foray into productizing digital 402 00:21:36,382 --> 00:21:38,372 technology, a piece of software, right. 403 00:21:38,472 --> 00:21:41,412 And, and that's led you down this path, like you said, that 404 00:21:41,412 --> 00:21:42,692 was kind of kicked off when. 405 00:21:43,532 --> 00:21:46,672 You started when, when Covid happened because of the uncertainty 406 00:21:46,672 --> 00:21:49,312 of all the in-person work that you were doing as well. 407 00:21:49,492 --> 00:21:53,032 So let's talk about, let's talk about some of those tools before we get into 408 00:21:53,032 --> 00:21:56,592 the strategy side, because I know you, you, we bookmarked the strategy stuff. 409 00:21:56,712 --> 00:21:56,832 I 410 00:21:56,832 --> 00:21:57,752 definitely want to get there. 411 00:21:57,772 --> 00:22:00,032 So let's get this, the product stuff taken care of. 412 00:22:00,032 --> 00:22:04,832 But I, the tools that you guys have developed and released as 413 00:22:04,832 --> 00:22:06,672 products are absolutely incredible. 414 00:22:06,732 --> 00:22:11,672 And like I said, you're kind of creating, um, some calm in this world of chaos, 415 00:22:12,142 --> 00:22:16,752 helping people get their stuff from one tool to another or visualizing 416 00:22:16,752 --> 00:22:21,752 their data or making useful tools, let's just call it that, that, that 417 00:22:21,812 --> 00:22:23,632 handle a bunch of different scenarios. 418 00:22:23,652 --> 00:22:25,072 But maybe you can go through some of those. 419 00:22:25,932 --> 00:22:26,222 Nathan Miller: sure. 420 00:22:26,412 --> 00:22:26,702 Yeah. 421 00:22:26,722 --> 00:22:33,772 So, um, the, the tools we're talking about here, um, and we can go 422 00:22:33,772 --> 00:22:35,332 through each one, uh, very briefly. 423 00:22:35,592 --> 00:22:40,292 The conveyor, semantic and tracer are the three, um, tools that we 424 00:22:40,292 --> 00:22:46,327 have available on PG apps, our proving ground apps, and those were 425 00:22:46,327 --> 00:22:50,187 all born out of services initially. 426 00:22:50,527 --> 00:22:54,787 Um, they were tools or the bones of them were tools that were used to 427 00:22:55,677 --> 00:23:00,467 solve a real world problem that we as, um, consultants were encountering. 428 00:23:01,587 --> 00:23:04,407 Um, whether it had been a building or helping someone compose a 429 00:23:04,407 --> 00:23:06,367 dashboard or synthesize some data. 430 00:23:07,547 --> 00:23:12,637 And at a certain point we realized that, hey, some of this stuff might be 431 00:23:12,997 --> 00:23:15,437 valuable as a generalizable toolkit. 432 00:23:16,057 --> 00:23:19,837 Um, and I think conveyor is the first example of this. 433 00:23:20,457 --> 00:23:24,597 Um, the problem of interoperability between different design applications 434 00:23:24,777 --> 00:23:28,157 has been an area of interest of mine for, for, for years. 435 00:23:28,897 --> 00:23:34,357 Um, if I go back to like rewind the clock to the early days of lunchbox and. 436 00:23:35,412 --> 00:23:40,712 You know, 20, you know, two, between 2009 and 2011, I was working on a, a 437 00:23:40,712 --> 00:23:47,192 stadium at M B B J, and I think it was one of the first documented use cases 438 00:23:47,292 --> 00:23:49,112 of Grasshopper at such a large scale. 439 00:23:49,612 --> 00:23:49,832 Um, 440 00:23:50,262 --> 00:23:50,612 Evan Troxel: Right? 441 00:23:51,292 --> 00:23:55,352 Nathan Miller: we, we were trying to parametrically solve this exterior and 442 00:23:55,422 --> 00:23:59,672 kind of interior seating bowl of the stadium with, with grasshopper and kind 443 00:23:59,672 --> 00:24:03,832 of computational methods, uh, just to get us in some ways just because we had to, 444 00:24:03,852 --> 00:24:05,272 we had to get our way through the project. 445 00:24:05,612 --> 00:24:10,512 And, but there was like this other conundrum with that workflow that 446 00:24:10,512 --> 00:24:15,352 we had to figure out was, you know, we're doing this all in RiNo, but 447 00:24:15,492 --> 00:24:17,272 we needed to get it over into Revit 448 00:24:17,282 --> 00:24:17,702 Evan Troxel: Mm-hmm. 449 00:24:18,012 --> 00:24:20,062 Nathan Miller: because that's, that's what our firm was using. 450 00:24:20,062 --> 00:24:23,662 That's what M B B J was using and continues to use and many 451 00:24:23,662 --> 00:24:24,502 other firms are using it. 452 00:24:24,502 --> 00:24:25,862 But we had no like path. 453 00:24:26,667 --> 00:24:27,367 To, to get there. 454 00:24:27,367 --> 00:24:31,967 There was basically some, at that time we were like looking at novel ways of using 455 00:24:32,287 --> 00:24:36,647 SS a t, like automating s a t exports and, and imports in just to get the 456 00:24:36,847 --> 00:24:38,647 documentation set, get some drawings out. 457 00:24:40,757 --> 00:24:46,367 that kind of woke me up to the fact that all of the systems that we 458 00:24:46,467 --> 00:24:51,577 use in this industry are not very well integrated with each other. 459 00:24:51,997 --> 00:24:56,057 And if we think about the time waste that occurs during a design process, 460 00:24:56,487 --> 00:24:59,737 there's a good chunk of that is in figuring out how you can move 461 00:24:59,737 --> 00:25:04,937 information, um, and data between these, these platforms that we need to use. 462 00:25:05,317 --> 00:25:11,992 Um, and I have a very I guess shop mindedness to me. 463 00:25:12,172 --> 00:25:16,592 You know, if I, if I think about a, a shop, I have different tools for 464 00:25:16,592 --> 00:25:20,232 different purposes and I'm gonna grab the tool that's best for the job. 465 00:25:20,812 --> 00:25:22,632 I'm not gonna try to screw something in with a hammer. 466 00:25:22,852 --> 00:25:28,632 I'm not gonna try to like saw something off with, um, you know, pair of tin snips. 467 00:25:28,752 --> 00:25:31,032 You know, you, you want to pick the right thing. 468 00:25:31,692 --> 00:25:35,762 And so I always wondered like, why can't we have that kind 469 00:25:35,762 --> 00:25:37,042 of mentality with our tools? 470 00:25:37,222 --> 00:25:40,042 And the thing that prevents a lot of that is like, okay, well if I use 471 00:25:40,092 --> 00:25:42,722 Rhino over here for this purpose, somehow that needs to jump over 472 00:25:42,722 --> 00:25:43,882 into Revit to do something else. 473 00:25:44,022 --> 00:25:46,842 And maybe it needs to go over to analysis software to do something else. 474 00:25:48,452 --> 00:25:56,362 And so, um, shortly after I left M B B J and joined Case, um, which was 475 00:25:56,382 --> 00:26:00,122 the company I was with, um, consulting Group out of, out of New York City, 476 00:26:00,302 --> 00:26:04,362 um, in case any, uh, are familiar was acquired by WeWork, which is why 477 00:26:04,362 --> 00:26:05,922 Proven Ground is a company now exists. 478 00:26:08,262 --> 00:26:11,152 Long, uh, long, long path there. 479 00:26:11,692 --> 00:26:16,392 But we were interested in, you know, a kind of similar set of, of things. 480 00:26:16,492 --> 00:26:21,382 We started to look at different integrations, um, between these softwares. 481 00:26:21,422 --> 00:26:24,102 I was building up different solutions. 482 00:26:24,242 --> 00:26:26,582 One was called Rhino Mo, which was a Dynamo Rhino 483 00:26:26,582 --> 00:26:26,862 reader 484 00:26:27,012 --> 00:26:27,132 Evan Troxel: right. 485 00:26:27,762 --> 00:26:28,302 Nathan Miller: at the time. 486 00:26:29,162 --> 00:26:35,182 Um, and then as proving ground got started, we got 487 00:26:35,402 --> 00:26:37,022 put onto a couple of projects. 488 00:26:37,242 --> 00:26:40,262 One was the Lucas Museum of Narrative Art, currently under construction. 489 00:26:40,762 --> 00:26:42,702 And it looks phenomenal. 490 00:26:42,882 --> 00:26:45,862 Um, it's taking a long time, but it looks phenomenal. 491 00:26:46,372 --> 00:26:48,062 Hats off to that team for what they've done. 492 00:26:48,402 --> 00:26:52,022 And the American Museum of Natural History by, uh, studio Gang, uh, was 493 00:26:52,022 --> 00:26:53,102 another one that we were involved in. 494 00:26:53,822 --> 00:26:58,242 And these two projects had, um, challenged us. 495 00:26:59,657 --> 00:27:02,637 At the time it was just two of us, some really small team at proving ground 496 00:27:02,637 --> 00:27:05,917 to figure out a way that how we can officially move this hyper complex 497 00:27:06,077 --> 00:27:12,277 geometry, um, seamlessly between these applications and do it in a way that 498 00:27:12,577 --> 00:27:15,917 didn't necessarily require us to be at the, in the driver's seat because 499 00:27:15,917 --> 00:27:17,917 we needed to hand the workflow off to 500 00:27:18,117 --> 00:27:18,397 a team. 501 00:27:18,447 --> 00:27:18,867 Evan Troxel: Mm-hmm. 502 00:27:19,577 --> 00:27:21,117 Nathan Miller: And that's kind of where Conveyor was born. 503 00:27:21,137 --> 00:27:28,237 We, we needed to figure out a way for these geometries to transfer, assuming the 504 00:27:28,297 --> 00:27:32,917 end user knew nothing about Grasshopper, assuming that there wasn't necessarily 505 00:27:32,977 --> 00:27:36,157 an advance, like what we would call an advanced modeling toolkit, but maybe 506 00:27:36,277 --> 00:27:41,117 a, you know, a generalized modeling, uh, skill set around knowing how to 507 00:27:41,117 --> 00:27:45,077 manipulate Rhino models and knowing how to manipulate Revit models using 508 00:27:45,227 --> 00:27:46,797 more, more of the conventional tools. 509 00:27:47,817 --> 00:27:50,917 And that's where Conveyor kind of situated itself and we kind of built, 510 00:27:50,917 --> 00:27:54,397 started building up this toolkit that allowed for that to occur. 511 00:27:55,617 --> 00:28:01,547 And right now it's, um, know, kind of grown to a point where a number 512 00:28:01,687 --> 00:28:06,067 of of practices have adopted it as kind of their enterprise wide 513 00:28:06,387 --> 00:28:07,307 solution, which is really cool. 514 00:28:07,307 --> 00:28:09,827 They're like, Hey, all of our designers use Rhino. 515 00:28:11,007 --> 00:28:12,067 All of them use Revit. 516 00:28:12,127 --> 00:28:16,027 If you're that kind of firm that is using those tools primarily Conveyor 517 00:28:16,027 --> 00:28:23,217 kind of becomes a way for them to stitch those two together and, and offset in 518 00:28:23,217 --> 00:28:30,177 some ways the, um, the necessity for the advanced, you know, grasshopper 519 00:28:30,287 --> 00:28:34,897 toolkit that is oftentimes as much as powerful as it is, can also be, 520 00:28:34,897 --> 00:28:38,697 become a barrier and cause a bit of a digital divide in an organization. 521 00:28:38,812 --> 00:28:39,232 Evan Troxel: Mm-hmm. 522 00:28:39,357 --> 00:28:41,817 Nathan Miller: And so we're, we're trying to figure out how we, how 523 00:28:41,817 --> 00:28:42,977 we bridge that with conveyor. 524 00:28:43,812 --> 00:28:45,152 Evan Troxel: And it's like, what makes this easy? 525 00:28:45,152 --> 00:28:45,392 Right? 526 00:28:45,392 --> 00:28:48,392 Like you, you talked about those other layers of complexity that 527 00:28:48,412 --> 00:28:50,112 not everybody's gonna get into. 528 00:28:50,212 --> 00:28:57,602 And so dialing it back to geometry and, and maybe some data from this major 529 00:28:57,602 --> 00:28:59,722 application to this major application. 530 00:28:59,722 --> 00:29:03,822 Without the grasshopper, without the dynamo part, how do you make, what, 531 00:29:03,822 --> 00:29:06,582 what would this look like if it were easy to get geometry between these two? 532 00:29:06,882 --> 00:29:09,542 And you've created an interface that allows that to happen. 533 00:29:10,172 --> 00:29:10,712 Nathan Miller: That's right. 534 00:29:11,452 --> 00:29:14,312 And, you know, I think the other, the other thing that's, that's fun 535 00:29:14,442 --> 00:29:19,552 about that project and, and product. 536 00:29:20,012 --> 00:29:21,632 Um, I, I think about it as a project. 537 00:29:21,912 --> 00:29:23,272 'cause a project is something that's ongoing. 538 00:29:23,512 --> 00:29:23,752 A product 539 00:29:23,752 --> 00:29:24,992 always feels so final. 540 00:29:25,572 --> 00:29:28,152 Um, in some ways I think about these things as projects. 541 00:29:28,272 --> 00:29:29,512 'cause they're, they're always kind of going, 542 00:29:29,802 --> 00:29:30,482 Evan Troxel: software's never done. 543 00:29:30,512 --> 00:29:30,802 Yeah. 544 00:29:30,972 --> 00:29:36,502 Nathan Miller: yeah, it's never, never done But, um, one of the things that 545 00:29:36,502 --> 00:29:41,502 became really fun, I think in, you know, post 2020, getting into 20 21, 20 22, 546 00:29:42,322 --> 00:29:47,622 is that Rhino Seven came out and the McNeil folks had developed Rhino inside, 547 00:29:49,152 --> 00:29:56,837 um, which introduces the of the, the, the, the ability to directly integrate 548 00:29:56,967 --> 00:30:02,437 Rhino into another application and Rhino inside Revit is like their, you 549 00:30:02,437 --> 00:30:04,117 know, in some ways a flagship example 550 00:30:04,217 --> 00:30:09,837 of like, Hey, you can now launch Grasshopper within Revit and do with 551 00:30:09,987 --> 00:30:14,637 Grasshopper similar things that you might have been doing with Dynamo. 552 00:30:15,057 --> 00:30:18,917 Um, oh, and by the way, it starts to solve some of the interoperability 553 00:30:19,277 --> 00:30:21,957 challenges between these platforms 'cause they're now kind of directly linked. 554 00:30:23,307 --> 00:30:28,197 Well, that became really fun for us because not only did they kind of create 555 00:30:28,577 --> 00:30:33,847 the, the, the connect, the ability to launch Rhino and Grasshopper from 556 00:30:33,847 --> 00:30:38,707 within Revit, that pipeline becomes something that a third party developer 557 00:30:38,707 --> 00:30:43,707 like ourselves could actively use to expand on tools like Conveyor. 558 00:30:44,327 --> 00:30:47,667 So outta the box, you download Rhino inside Revit, you can. 559 00:30:48,742 --> 00:30:51,982 Open up Grasshopper and do grasshopper things within Revit, 560 00:30:52,052 --> 00:30:53,102 have a lot of fun with that. 561 00:30:53,922 --> 00:31:01,252 Um, but can also launch Rhino and then use the conveyor translators that we've 562 00:31:01,252 --> 00:31:05,412 made and have a direct back and forth from Rhino without having to touch Grasshopper. 563 00:31:05,462 --> 00:31:08,932 We're kind of able to use the pipeline that the generous folks at McNeil 564 00:31:08,932 --> 00:31:13,812 have been able to carve out, um, to allow us to use our logic and our, 565 00:31:14,032 --> 00:31:17,412 um, kind of translation methodologies to make the process even easier. 566 00:31:18,392 --> 00:31:23,612 So it's, it's like, again, it comes back to that community side of things, right? 567 00:31:23,612 --> 00:31:25,612 Like McNeil's part of the community. 568 00:31:25,662 --> 00:31:26,612 We're part of the community. 569 00:31:26,612 --> 00:31:30,172 There's a lot of people a part of this network and their thinking 570 00:31:30,172 --> 00:31:31,772 allowed us to expand our thinking. 571 00:31:31,832 --> 00:31:35,892 And, you know, we've been work, you know, um, sharing ideas back 572 00:31:35,892 --> 00:31:37,692 and forth for, for a while now. 573 00:31:37,692 --> 00:31:41,692 And I think it, you know, it, it starts to work both ways and that that's 574 00:31:41,692 --> 00:31:43,452 really, really fun when that happens. 575 00:31:45,042 --> 00:31:47,222 Evan Troxel: The kinds of geometry that you're sending back and forth. 576 00:31:47,382 --> 00:31:48,942 I mean, it's not just boxes, right? 577 00:31:49,012 --> 00:31:50,182 It's not just rectangles. 578 00:31:50,292 --> 00:31:53,902 It's, it's like the two examples that you cited, the Lucas Museum and 579 00:31:53,902 --> 00:31:56,222 the, and the studio gang example. 580 00:31:56,732 --> 00:32:02,102 I've seen photos of those and like to actually get that kind of geometry 581 00:32:02,272 --> 00:32:07,372 built in the real world as a physical object is incredibly difficult. 582 00:32:07,472 --> 00:32:09,572 And tools like these actually make it. 583 00:32:10,612 --> 00:32:11,412 Possible and easier 584 00:32:11,672 --> 00:32:12,972 at the same time, , right? 585 00:32:12,972 --> 00:32:18,052 Like that's a, that's kind of a holy grail of, of realizing design intent. 586 00:32:18,312 --> 00:32:20,132 Uh, it's absolutely incredible. 587 00:32:21,222 --> 00:32:21,512 Nathan Miller: Yeah. 588 00:32:21,622 --> 00:32:22,552 Yeah, yeah. 589 00:32:22,612 --> 00:32:27,472 The, the, uh, I, there's not a single, I, you know, I always like to joke whenever 590 00:32:27,512 --> 00:32:31,752 I, when I give a lecture about those two buildings and our digital workflow as 591 00:32:32,352 --> 00:32:36,652 that's a part of it, um, you know, there's not a single straight line in either of 592 00:32:36,652 --> 00:32:38,812 those, either of those projects, it seems. 593 00:32:39,072 --> 00:32:46,712 And, um, We had to really, we, we published a, a peer reviewed paper 594 00:32:46,982 --> 00:32:50,312 through the, the Acadia conference about some of the stuff that we were 595 00:32:50,312 --> 00:32:52,552 doing with novel mesh translation. 596 00:32:53,532 --> 00:33:00,672 Um, and historically MeSHs have been like the bane of every Revit modeler BIM model. 597 00:33:00,672 --> 00:33:03,312 You know, anyone that's doing bim the bane of their existence. 598 00:33:03,472 --> 00:33:04,192 'cause it's like mesh. 599 00:33:04,342 --> 00:33:07,712 What can we do with, we need solids, we need really clean solids, which is, you 600 00:33:07,712 --> 00:33:10,432 know, na naturally, you know, gravitated. 601 00:33:10,992 --> 00:33:14,152 I think a lot of those platforms to being able to, you know, we 602 00:33:14,152 --> 00:33:15,792 think about 'em as boxy modelers. 603 00:33:15,792 --> 00:33:25,322 You know, you draw, these, um, normal normative buildings, um, tell you're 604 00:33:25,322 --> 00:33:26,482 you're blue in the face, right? 605 00:33:27,022 --> 00:33:37,202 Um, but meshes are really, um, powerful ways of conveying complex shapes. 606 00:33:37,502 --> 00:33:38,922 Um, and they're. 607 00:33:40,987 --> 00:33:43,407 You can get very, like, you know, they're, they're the basis 608 00:33:43,547 --> 00:33:47,807 of, you know, entertainment software, character modeling. 609 00:33:47,957 --> 00:33:50,487 They're the basis of everything when it comes to just displaying 610 00:33:50,487 --> 00:33:51,607 geometry on your screen. 611 00:33:52,507 --> 00:33:57,547 And so a lot of the, the, the workflow development that was done for those 612 00:33:57,547 --> 00:34:02,147 projects was about how we can actually capture the mesh in such a way that 613 00:34:02,287 --> 00:34:07,027 it can be cut, um, that it will look good on a sheet, be part of the 614 00:34:07,267 --> 00:34:18,027 documentation, have a level of fidelity to it that, um, is, is, um, you know, 615 00:34:18,246 --> 00:34:20,347 uh, supportive of the design intent. 616 00:34:20,567 --> 00:34:22,347 You know, we don't want it to be too coarse. 617 00:34:22,347 --> 00:34:23,187 We don't need it to be too 618 00:34:23,507 --> 00:34:23,627 detailed. 619 00:34:23,687 --> 00:34:27,746 So we developed, you know, ways of, you know, refining those meshes as part of 620 00:34:27,746 --> 00:34:29,667 that whole translation workflow process. 621 00:34:30,687 --> 00:34:35,127 And it became such that, you know, one of the, I think one of the, um, 622 00:34:36,246 --> 00:34:38,456 More interesting features of conveyor. 623 00:34:38,456 --> 00:34:40,857 If we get into the specifics of the different things that translates 624 00:34:40,857 --> 00:34:44,297 is how it handles the, the mesh component and makes them usable. 625 00:34:44,597 --> 00:34:49,657 Um, and part of, part of BIM in a way that they, I don't think were previously 626 00:34:50,516 --> 00:34:51,167 Evan Troxel: Yeah, for sure. 627 00:34:51,717 --> 00:34:54,887 Well, let's, let's get through your other two, uh, as well. 628 00:34:55,107 --> 00:34:56,806 So which one do you wanna talk about next? 629 00:34:56,806 --> 00:34:57,367 Conveyor. 630 00:34:57,767 --> 00:34:58,217 Nathan Miller: well there. 631 00:34:58,337 --> 00:35:01,257 I think they, they, those are, those two are like companions in, 632 00:35:01,277 --> 00:35:04,737 in many ways because they, they touch on business intelligence. 633 00:35:05,397 --> 00:35:12,257 Um, and the idea of telling a story with your data and when 634 00:35:12,257 --> 00:35:14,337 we, when I was at Case, I. 635 00:35:14,647 --> 00:35:17,747 Um, we were doing a lot of work with Tableau at the time 'cause 636 00:35:17,747 --> 00:35:21,547 we were, you know, basically creating reports to help our clients 637 00:35:21,547 --> 00:35:23,267 understand their standards better. 638 00:35:23,417 --> 00:35:23,707 Like 639 00:35:23,707 --> 00:35:28,107 what was in their models, um, the quality of their, of their digital assets. 640 00:35:29,087 --> 00:35:31,987 And that kind of experience opened me up to this world of like, oh, 641 00:35:32,097 --> 00:35:35,747 what if you could actually use data as a storytelling device, much 642 00:35:35,747 --> 00:35:40,387 like you would use a rendering to tell an architectural story, um, or a drawing. 643 00:35:40,967 --> 00:35:45,547 You know, can you use the data com data side of all of this to tell, to tell, um, 644 00:35:46,007 --> 00:35:51,107 the story or expand on the story in a way that, um, that more conventional modes of 645 00:35:51,107 --> 00:35:53,067 architectural representation don't allow? 646 00:35:54,167 --> 00:35:58,027 Um, and so as proofing ground was getting started, power 647 00:35:58,027 --> 00:35:59,227 BI was becoming more popular. 648 00:35:59,407 --> 00:36:05,577 We were starting to see it pop up on desktops, um, of our clients and, you 649 00:36:05,577 --> 00:36:09,257 know, project managers were using it from like a, a scheduling purpose. 650 00:36:09,597 --> 00:36:16,767 And, um, You'd see a, you know, accounting departments using it and, you know, uh, 651 00:36:18,097 --> 00:36:21,797 and a number of other kind of, you know, analysts, uh, using that kind of tool. 652 00:36:22,217 --> 00:36:26,817 And at a certain point it became kind of apparent like, well, what if, what 653 00:36:26,817 --> 00:36:32,177 if we could make connections from Power BI into the model assets that 654 00:36:32,177 --> 00:36:39,637 people were using, and not only display the data, but display the kinds of 655 00:36:39,637 --> 00:36:43,837 representation that we need to be able to tell the story of our architecture. 656 00:36:45,617 --> 00:36:50,987 Um, and so that, that's where Semantic and Tracer came into play. 657 00:36:51,047 --> 00:36:57,147 And I think Tracer was in some ways, first because we had been working with building 658 00:36:57,147 --> 00:37:00,827 information models for, you know, quite a while, and were very familiar with the 659 00:37:00,837 --> 00:37:03,947 Revit, um, underlying data structure. 660 00:37:04,487 --> 00:37:09,947 And so Tracer started off as a way of, okay, let's get the data out into a. 661 00:37:11,012 --> 00:37:11,812 Database structure. 662 00:37:12,112 --> 00:37:14,572 So a structure that sits apart from Revit entirely, 663 00:37:14,812 --> 00:37:15,232 Evan Troxel: Mm-hmm. 664 00:37:15,632 --> 00:37:18,772 Nathan Miller: um, such that it can then be hooked in to a place like 665 00:37:18,772 --> 00:37:24,732 Power bi and we can run analysis on quantities and, um, parameter values 666 00:37:25,032 --> 00:37:29,172 and element counts and, you know, just basically unpack what's in that model. 667 00:37:31,162 --> 00:37:35,662 Um, and then that evolved into what if we started to serialize geometry 668 00:37:36,042 --> 00:37:37,102 in a number of different ways. 669 00:37:37,172 --> 00:37:43,432 What if we could convert the areas of a, of re model to a geo json 670 00:37:43,432 --> 00:37:46,432 such that you could start to display it in like a, a mapping viewer? 671 00:37:47,572 --> 00:37:52,442 Um, and then what if you were able to take the three dimensional geometry 672 00:37:52,462 --> 00:37:57,082 of a Revit file and turn it into a, um, a set of meshes that could then 673 00:37:57,082 --> 00:37:58,442 be rendered in a three D viewer? 674 00:37:58,582 --> 00:38:01,362 And can we, could we even get a three D viewer in Power bi? 675 00:38:01,542 --> 00:38:03,522 Was, was another kind of big part of that question. 676 00:38:04,262 --> 00:38:10,797 And so, um, Tracer was born out of like, okay, we're gonna, we have a data analysis 677 00:38:10,797 --> 00:38:12,077 thing, we need to get the data out. 678 00:38:12,617 --> 00:38:16,597 And then the viewers became a way for us to then stitch it 679 00:38:16,597 --> 00:38:17,917 all back together in Power bi. 680 00:38:18,857 --> 00:38:26,687 And with that information, a designer or an architect or a project manager can 681 00:38:26,687 --> 00:38:32,007 compose a story with within Power BI that tells them something about their building. 682 00:38:33,067 --> 00:38:37,927 And I was just on a phone call earlier this week, phone call. 683 00:38:38,147 --> 00:38:39,327 No one does phone calls anymore. 684 00:38:39,467 --> 00:38:41,487 It was a Zoom call, um, 685 00:38:42,252 --> 00:38:42,592 Evan Troxel: of course. 686 00:38:42,732 --> 00:38:42,952 of 687 00:38:42,952 --> 00:38:43,072 course. 688 00:38:43,092 --> 00:38:43,432 It was 689 00:38:43,447 --> 00:38:45,807 Nathan Miller: I just, I feel like I, I feel like I'm just constantly like 690 00:38:45,807 --> 00:38:47,847 dating myself in this, in this convo. 691 00:38:48,297 --> 00:38:50,967 Again, we'll leave it up to the viewers to decide if I've become 692 00:38:50,967 --> 00:38:52,527 more or less unhinged since 2020. 693 00:38:52,592 --> 00:38:53,042 Evan Troxel: It's okay. 694 00:38:53,042 --> 00:38:57,442 We're we're, we're recording this episode right now on, on V h s, so, yeah. 695 00:38:57,462 --> 00:38:57,752 Nathan Miller: Okay. 696 00:38:57,972 --> 00:38:58,192 Oh, 697 00:38:58,712 --> 00:38:59,002 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 698 00:38:59,152 --> 00:38:59,832 Nathan Miller: my comfort area. 699 00:38:59,972 --> 00:39:00,322 Evan Troxel: Right. 700 00:39:00,582 --> 00:39:01,072 Nathan Miller: perfect. 701 00:39:02,092 --> 00:39:02,712 Uh oh. 702 00:39:02,712 --> 00:39:03,472 That's a relief. 703 00:39:04,172 --> 00:39:07,872 Um, actually that would be really funny if you like published like a really grainy 704 00:39:08,272 --> 00:39:11,312 v h s quality of this this recording, 705 00:39:12,842 --> 00:39:13,272 Evan Troxel: We're just 706 00:39:13,292 --> 00:39:14,992 one filter away from that 707 00:39:16,052 --> 00:39:17,312 Nathan Miller: SS side. 708 00:39:18,092 --> 00:39:22,032 And, um, before I get back on topic, I'm gonna take myself off topic. 709 00:39:22,652 --> 00:39:27,592 Um, I got my son into music, um, in this last year. 710 00:39:28,652 --> 00:39:36,732 And the way I got him into music is I bought him a, it's not an original, 711 00:39:37,512 --> 00:39:40,652 but it's something you can, you can get, you can still get them on Amazon. 712 00:39:40,832 --> 00:39:42,652 Um, kind of a knockoff Walkman. 713 00:39:42,972 --> 00:39:43,262 Evan Troxel: Nice. 714 00:39:43,952 --> 00:39:48,692 Nathan Miller: And I found a bunch of cassettes that my parents 715 00:39:48,832 --> 00:39:49,932 had that I used to listen to. 716 00:39:50,372 --> 00:39:50,832 Evan Troxel: Oh, cool. 717 00:39:50,932 --> 00:39:54,972 Nathan Miller: went on eBay and found a bunch of stuff that. 718 00:39:56,367 --> 00:39:57,737 That I used to listen to as well. 719 00:39:57,787 --> 00:40:02,687 And so now my son is into music through a growing cassette collection. 720 00:40:02,707 --> 00:40:04,367 And this is one I haven't given to him yet. 721 00:40:05,027 --> 00:40:06,367 Um, he's nine years old. 722 00:40:07,717 --> 00:40:10,607 He's, uh, you know, he is into rock and stuff like that, but I also have been 723 00:40:10,607 --> 00:40:11,807 giving him the Guardians of the Galaxy. 724 00:40:11,947 --> 00:40:14,447 You can, you can buy new stuff on cassette. 725 00:40:14,987 --> 00:40:17,647 So this is the Guardian Galaxy Volume three, 726 00:40:18,412 --> 00:40:18,702 Evan Troxel: Nice. 727 00:40:19,087 --> 00:40:21,727 Nathan Miller: cassette that I bought off of Amazon, and 728 00:40:22,277 --> 00:40:22,687 it's awesome. 729 00:40:22,722 --> 00:40:22,922 Evan Troxel: cool. 730 00:40:23,302 --> 00:40:25,722 So have you introduced him to a number two pencil yet? 731 00:40:25,722 --> 00:40:27,682 And, and the usefulness of that with, with, 732 00:40:27,887 --> 00:40:29,427 Nathan Miller: Oh yeah, he knows, he knows how to use it. 733 00:40:29,607 --> 00:40:31,747 He knows how Oh, oh, you mean to re to, to, 734 00:40:31,807 --> 00:40:32,507 to Unspool. 735 00:40:32,507 --> 00:40:32,667 Yeah. 736 00:40:32,667 --> 00:40:36,467 I, I did, I did take him through a demo of that because he ended up, uh, 737 00:40:36,887 --> 00:40:40,227 his, his cassette player ended up chewing up, uh, Metallica's, ride 738 00:40:40,227 --> 00:40:42,387 the Lightning a couple weeks back. 739 00:40:42,807 --> 00:40:46,267 So I had to like, I had to like go, this is how you fix it. 740 00:40:47,132 --> 00:40:47,752 Evan Troxel: That's awesome. 741 00:40:47,982 --> 00:40:48,792 Yeah, so cool. 742 00:40:48,912 --> 00:40:53,652 I actually, it's funny that you say that 'cause I just saw, and I wanted it so bad. 743 00:40:53,812 --> 00:40:58,412 I just saw an iPhone case that was a cassette tape, like a old school Max cell 744 00:40:58,472 --> 00:41:02,972 or r c A tape, so, so from the back, your phone actually looks like a cassette tape. 745 00:41:03,892 --> 00:41:04,312 Nathan Miller: That's 746 00:41:04,312 --> 00:41:04,512 sweet. 747 00:41:04,682 --> 00:41:05,082 Evan Troxel: really sweet. 748 00:41:05,392 --> 00:41:05,682 Yeah. 749 00:41:05,852 --> 00:41:06,792 Nathan Miller: So how do we get on this subject? 750 00:41:06,792 --> 00:41:08,992 We got that on the subject because I said phone call 751 00:41:09,042 --> 00:41:09,332 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 752 00:41:09,332 --> 00:41:10,212 You were on a phone call 753 00:41:10,212 --> 00:41:10,812 earlier this 754 00:41:10,912 --> 00:41:12,312 Nathan Miller: was like, yeah, I was on, I was on a phone, I 755 00:41:12,312 --> 00:41:13,552 was on phone, I was on the telly 756 00:41:14,172 --> 00:41:24,752 and uh, Um, so they, uh, the comment back or the question to me was like, oh, well 757 00:41:24,752 --> 00:41:27,792 what use cases have you seen with Tracer? 758 00:41:28,772 --> 00:41:33,572 And I couldn't, I couldn't answer the question in a very straightforward way. 759 00:41:33,732 --> 00:41:35,812 'cause they were looking to like, oh, this is primarily 760 00:41:35,842 --> 00:41:37,212 used for like, space planning, 761 00:41:37,472 --> 00:41:41,172 you know, or like showing the program in three D or, or showing something else. 762 00:41:41,392 --> 00:41:43,492 And I was like, well, we've seen a lot of them. 763 00:41:43,752 --> 00:41:46,532 So there's the planning and programming stuff that architects. 764 00:41:47,102 --> 00:41:50,182 Like to use, like space tracking and, you know, showing blocking 765 00:41:50,202 --> 00:41:51,902 and stacking of, of rooms. 766 00:41:52,722 --> 00:42:00,422 And then we've seen, um, an uptick in contractors downloading the tool 767 00:42:00,422 --> 00:42:03,982 because what they wanna do is they want to take the Revit model, turn it 768 00:42:03,982 --> 00:42:09,222 into a database, and then, and then attach, uh, power BI to like their 769 00:42:09,222 --> 00:42:10,702 costing and scheduling database. 770 00:42:10,722 --> 00:42:14,302 And then create a dashboard that shows like a timeline of construction 771 00:42:14,362 --> 00:42:18,262 or shows element installation and, and tracking over time. 772 00:42:18,842 --> 00:42:24,062 And then we've seen owners using it for, um, you know, we as a component to 773 00:42:24,062 --> 00:42:27,462 their digital twin solution, where it's like, oh yeah, we're gonna have Power 774 00:42:27,482 --> 00:42:30,502 BI and that's gonna be attached to this real-time database that's giving power 775 00:42:30,522 --> 00:42:33,142 bi x information about, um, our facility. 776 00:42:33,802 --> 00:42:38,902 Um, and the three D piece is, you know, there to, to convey the model. 777 00:42:38,962 --> 00:42:40,982 And so people are like really scrapping together. 778 00:42:42,337 --> 00:42:45,497 Interesting use cases out of it, again, in unanticipated ways. 779 00:42:46,277 --> 00:42:51,937 Um, we've had, um, and speaking of unanticipated ways, you know, we've had 780 00:42:51,957 --> 00:42:58,337 people that are in like biomedical, um, and, and chemistry, like wanting to show 781 00:42:58,607 --> 00:43:05,817 digital models of, you know, biology or like d n A structures, like, Hey, 782 00:43:05,817 --> 00:43:11,337 will this help us show like the mesh of this, of this structure over here, 783 00:43:11,337 --> 00:43:14,217 this, this chemical structure and come with the data that we're collecting. 784 00:43:14,357 --> 00:43:16,257 I'm like, sure, why not? 785 00:43:16,337 --> 00:43:17,057 I know nothing about this. 786 00:43:17,077 --> 00:43:19,457 In fact, I became, I came very close to failing chemistry 787 00:43:19,457 --> 00:43:20,457 when I was in high school. 788 00:43:21,277 --> 00:43:21,497 Um, 789 00:43:21,717 --> 00:43:21,937 but 790 00:43:22,087 --> 00:43:22,937 yeah, have at 791 00:43:22,952 --> 00:43:23,632 Evan Troxel: wanna ask that 792 00:43:23,727 --> 00:43:24,017 . Nathan Miller: Yeah. 793 00:43:24,037 --> 00:43:25,417 I'm the last person you want to ask about. 794 00:43:25,417 --> 00:43:25,697 Yeah. 795 00:43:25,697 --> 00:43:26,457 Three D sure. 796 00:43:26,557 --> 00:43:26,977 But you, 797 00:43:27,577 --> 00:43:29,777 I don't want to, I don't, I know nothing about what you do. 798 00:43:30,517 --> 00:43:32,377 Um, but. 799 00:43:33,472 --> 00:43:38,772 So that it, it, the versatility of the business intelligence platforms like 800 00:43:39,182 --> 00:43:44,932 Power bi, um, and others really start, you know, it, it, to me it becomes a really 801 00:43:45,252 --> 00:43:52,062 interesting design tool in a way wherein of designing your, I think, I think back 802 00:43:52,062 --> 00:43:57,062 to when I was in school or even when I was doing a lot of competition work in, 803 00:43:57,082 --> 00:44:02,302 in designing, you design your board, you know, and you have your rendering and 804 00:44:02,322 --> 00:44:04,142 you have maybe some, you have a diagram, 805 00:44:05,082 --> 00:44:10,442 you know, and you know, power BI is like, wow, what if you gave an, gave an 806 00:44:10,442 --> 00:44:12,402 owner or gave your client a dashboard 807 00:44:12,512 --> 00:44:17,282 that lets them explore that in a way and, and do so in a way that you've 808 00:44:17,312 --> 00:44:21,522 curated and you've, you know, you've published as a designer that, that. 809 00:44:22,147 --> 00:44:23,327 Evan Troxel: And be fully interactive. 810 00:44:23,407 --> 00:44:28,607 I think I rem I'm remembering, uh, one of your AU classes that I attended years and 811 00:44:28,607 --> 00:44:34,547 years ago where you were basically showing this at its initial state, I think. 812 00:44:34,767 --> 00:44:39,827 And because you had like the Revit, uh, you know, example project in Power bi. 813 00:44:40,147 --> 00:44:41,227 I don't think it was three D yet. 814 00:44:41,307 --> 00:44:44,477 I think it was just two D at that point, and you were just 815 00:44:44,477 --> 00:44:46,117 typing in a query and it was. 816 00:44:46,817 --> 00:44:51,627 Isolating information and showing you like how many classrooms are in this building. 817 00:44:51,727 --> 00:44:56,227 It was like you could ask it a question in regular language and it would kind 818 00:44:56,227 --> 00:44:59,387 of parse that and filter that data down and just show you what you were asking. 819 00:44:59,407 --> 00:45:05,997 And, and I, I remember just like opening up my eyes to the possibilities here 820 00:45:06,297 --> 00:45:11,917 for allowing someone else who is not a designer, who's not working in Revit, 821 00:45:11,917 --> 00:45:17,637 who's not working on the project, to be able to track progress, answer 822 00:45:17,877 --> 00:45:21,317 questions with a client, make sure that you're on track with the program. 823 00:45:21,587 --> 00:45:24,237 Like all the pieces are there, that the sizes are right. 824 00:45:24,297 --> 00:45:31,007 It was, and it was just, it, it was amazing to see using a, a completely 825 00:45:31,007 --> 00:45:36,167 different tool to kinda look through that, into the model, but, but 826 00:45:36,167 --> 00:45:37,567 something that anybody could access. 827 00:45:37,627 --> 00:45:41,087 And I think that's what really was, was eyeopening to me about it back then. 828 00:45:42,932 --> 00:45:45,772 Nathan Miller: I think, I think there's something like, and this in some ways 829 00:45:45,942 --> 00:45:51,272 feeds into our, we can maybe lightly touch on the strategy stuff here because there 830 00:45:51,272 --> 00:45:57,512 is a underlying philosophy in play when it comes to that, that add, I guess you could 831 00:45:57,512 --> 00:46:00,192 call it an attitude or a, an approach. 832 00:46:01,252 --> 00:46:12,192 Um, if you can give someone, give a non-expert, um, information or data that 833 00:46:12,192 --> 00:46:17,352 once previously required an expert, but you're giving it to them in a way that 834 00:46:17,352 --> 00:46:20,312 they can, then I digest and understand. 835 00:46:20,972 --> 00:46:22,792 You've, you've all of a sudden set up. 836 00:46:23,477 --> 00:46:27,817 Um, what in my view would be like the foundational part 837 00:46:27,817 --> 00:46:29,337 of a digital transformation? 838 00:46:30,847 --> 00:46:33,947 Di Digital tools and technology are not transformational. 839 00:46:34,927 --> 00:46:43,927 If they are relegated to a select view, in my view, they need to be something 840 00:46:43,927 --> 00:46:48,567 that, a, allow, it allows us to have them opened up to a cross section 841 00:46:48,627 --> 00:46:54,407 of, of stakeholders, uh, of people, um, such that they can participate. 842 00:46:55,107 --> 00:47:02,267 And when I think about the, you know, the, you know, uh, power bi, um, and the stuff 843 00:47:02,387 --> 00:47:05,747 that we're, you know, doing with Semantic and Tracer, it's really about that. 844 00:47:06,217 --> 00:47:11,467 It's about people like people to compose a model, uh, uh, whether it's a Rhino model 845 00:47:11,467 --> 00:47:16,467 or a Revit model that requires expertise, that requires someone to go into, to the, 846 00:47:16,847 --> 00:47:19,827 to the three D world, um, and construct. 847 00:47:21,057 --> 00:47:22,247 Their, their model. 848 00:47:23,227 --> 00:47:27,647 Um, but then if you have publishing tools, stuff that allows you to take 849 00:47:27,647 --> 00:47:32,287 that information and put it in a way that with a nominal amount of knowledge 850 00:47:32,287 --> 00:47:37,397 of how you might rotate a three D view or click on a bar graph and see the, see 851 00:47:37,397 --> 00:47:42,877 the impact of that selection on a model, um, you've all of a sudden made a, a, an 852 00:47:42,897 --> 00:47:47,637 opaque process far more transparent and allows for more people to participate 853 00:47:48,387 --> 00:47:50,557 than were participating previously. 854 00:47:50,897 --> 00:47:53,837 And then you've created the, you know, some, some level of foundation 855 00:47:53,937 --> 00:47:55,997 for a transformational conversation. 856 00:47:56,297 --> 00:47:56,517 Um, 857 00:47:57,222 --> 00:47:57,512 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 858 00:47:58,022 --> 00:48:01,662 I, I would, I would say, like, to, to be really specific about 859 00:48:01,662 --> 00:48:03,622 it, is you're letting them drive. 860 00:48:03,962 --> 00:48:08,842 And, and that is, that's a big deal because you, you could do everything that 861 00:48:08,842 --> 00:48:13,722 you just said by watching over someone's shoulder who is the expert driver, but to 862 00:48:13,922 --> 00:48:15,802 actually give them the, the steering wheel 863 00:48:16,502 --> 00:48:21,282 is a completely different game because it's actually started to create a 864 00:48:21,282 --> 00:48:22,522 relationship between the person. 865 00:48:23,387 --> 00:48:27,607 The data, not, not even the tool necessarily, but, but like what, what are 866 00:48:27,607 --> 00:48:30,767 the answers that they're trying to get? 867 00:48:31,427 --> 00:48:34,307 And that creates a level of transparency. 868 00:48:34,407 --> 00:48:38,867 It creates a level of accountability to build trust in the system and 869 00:48:39,037 --> 00:48:42,907 build a relationship with the people who are allowing, or in 870 00:48:43,227 --> 00:48:44,347 enabling that even to happen. 871 00:48:44,647 --> 00:48:50,977 And that there, there's way bigger impacts to that, that that allows for on, on a 872 00:48:50,977 --> 00:48:53,017 pro, for a project than, than without it. 873 00:48:53,237 --> 00:48:55,857 And that's where that transformation can actually gain a foothold. 874 00:48:56,277 --> 00:48:59,687 Because if it's, if it's just tools and there's no trust and there's 875 00:48:59,687 --> 00:49:03,527 no relationship, then it's just tools like, it, it doesn't make, it 876 00:49:03,527 --> 00:49:04,727 doesn't actually make a difference. 877 00:49:05,477 --> 00:49:05,767 Nathan Miller: Yeah. 878 00:49:06,477 --> 00:49:11,247 Well, and I think, um, there's, there's another aspect to it that I think is also 879 00:49:11,247 --> 00:49:15,767 really important is that it somehow, there needs to be a bit of a fun side to it. 880 00:49:16,507 --> 00:49:16,727 Um, 881 00:49:17,067 --> 00:49:17,487 Evan Troxel: Agreed. 882 00:49:18,247 --> 00:49:22,597 Nathan Miller: We've seen many dashboards, you know, reports and things like that, 883 00:49:23,347 --> 00:49:27,677 that just by the, you know, that that contain a lot of really good information, 884 00:49:27,777 --> 00:49:32,797 but just by nature of them being boring as hell, no one wants to look at 'em 885 00:49:33,217 --> 00:49:34,637 or ga gain any insight. 886 00:49:34,637 --> 00:49:35,077 And, and 887 00:49:35,077 --> 00:49:39,107 so when I think about this idea of composing and publishing 888 00:49:39,202 --> 00:49:39,622 Evan Troxel: Mm-hmm. 889 00:49:39,967 --> 00:49:43,667 Nathan Miller: and the, uh, the, the element of creativity that can go into it, 890 00:49:43,697 --> 00:49:45,307 it's in some ways like designing a game. 891 00:49:45,327 --> 00:49:46,547 You want the game to be fun. 892 00:49:47,127 --> 00:49:51,107 You want there to be self-discovery by the person playing it. 893 00:49:51,727 --> 00:49:57,507 And so you as a designer of say, your dashboard that has attachments into 894 00:49:57,807 --> 00:50:04,547 bim, um, or, uh, rhino or any of these other applications, you want it to be 895 00:50:04,697 --> 00:50:07,067 such that there's a level of intuition. 896 00:50:07,067 --> 00:50:11,027 There's a level of like, I want to go deeper and you want to encourage this 897 00:50:11,027 --> 00:50:13,267 kind of interaction with the data. 898 00:50:14,087 --> 00:50:15,307 Um, that. 899 00:50:16,872 --> 00:50:21,182 Helps, helps that end user become educated, but also have 900 00:50:21,182 --> 00:50:22,142 fun with it along the way. 901 00:50:22,142 --> 00:50:24,982 Like, Hey, I've never seen this before, or, Hey, isn't this cool? 902 00:50:26,042 --> 00:50:31,852 Um, you know, if, if we're, if we can create tools that are helping designers 903 00:50:31,962 --> 00:50:34,972 compose in that way, then I think that's, that's where we want to be. 904 00:50:36,212 --> 00:50:36,332 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 905 00:50:36,452 --> 00:50:39,492 I I, I love that idea too, because I, you, you. 906 00:50:40,432 --> 00:50:42,852 You use the analogy of like laying out your boards when 907 00:50:42,852 --> 00:50:43,692 you were in school, right? 908 00:50:43,712 --> 00:50:46,612 And, and you're placing views on sheets. 909 00:50:47,372 --> 00:50:51,092 Probably in, in design or back in my day it was Cork Express. 910 00:50:51,102 --> 00:50:51,452 Right. 911 00:50:51,652 --> 00:50:51,942 Nathan Miller: Yeah. 912 00:50:52,032 --> 00:50:52,382 Right. 913 00:50:52,632 --> 00:50:55,372 Evan Troxel: it was like that you, you draw a frame and then you decide 914 00:50:55,372 --> 00:50:56,292 what you're gonna put in that frame. 915 00:50:56,312 --> 00:50:57,892 It could be text, it could be an image. 916 00:50:58,072 --> 00:51:01,692 Now it's a fully interactive three D model that if you click on this frame 917 00:51:01,692 --> 00:51:05,572 over here, it's gonna isolate that information and it's gonna update in 918 00:51:05,572 --> 00:51:09,652 these other views to reflect kind of the thing that you're drilling down into. 919 00:51:10,232 --> 00:51:13,392 But it creates that, it's another level, right? 920 00:51:13,392 --> 00:51:16,712 Because of the interactivity then, then just the two D boards on the wall work. 921 00:51:17,292 --> 00:51:22,312 And it encourages exploration and it encourages someone to scratch 922 00:51:22,372 --> 00:51:26,832 an itch and find out something that isn't just a parent on the surface. 923 00:51:27,092 --> 00:51:27,872 It is deeper. 924 00:51:28,012 --> 00:51:31,112 And that is what's so interesting, I think about architecture in general. 925 00:51:32,307 --> 00:51:35,237 Real architecture does that as well in a spatial way. 926 00:51:35,367 --> 00:51:38,357 Maybe it does it with light, maybe it does it with color, maybe it does it 927 00:51:38,357 --> 00:51:41,757 with texture, maybe it does it with the size and proportion of the room. 928 00:51:42,417 --> 00:51:47,997 But we're talking about using this to get us there and, and this building, 929 00:51:48,067 --> 00:51:52,317 this relationship along the way, using tools like this that enable 930 00:51:52,317 --> 00:51:58,797 that to happen is a fantastic way to deliver that project and include 931 00:51:58,797 --> 00:52:00,797 people in the process along the way. 932 00:52:01,682 --> 00:52:02,912 Nathan Miller: right, right. 933 00:52:04,177 --> 00:52:04,467 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 934 00:52:04,517 --> 00:52:05,107 Super cool. 935 00:52:06,772 --> 00:52:08,952 Nathan Miller: Um, there's also, you know, there's an element here where 936 00:52:08,952 --> 00:52:10,512 there's, there's also a, I think a. 937 00:52:11,887 --> 00:52:15,727 Component to what we do that also operates, you know, we're, we try to 938 00:52:15,727 --> 00:52:21,047 do new things, um, but we also build on what's there, um, in, in many ways, 939 00:52:21,137 --> 00:52:21,557 Evan Troxel: Mm-hmm. 940 00:52:21,627 --> 00:52:25,167 Nathan Miller: you know, we're not proving ground isn't a company that we're not 941 00:52:25,167 --> 00:52:28,927 designing our own ground up platform, you know, which I think requires a, a, 942 00:52:28,967 --> 00:52:31,007 a very different kind of business model. 943 00:52:31,337 --> 00:52:31,687 Right. 944 00:52:31,707 --> 00:52:35,007 You know, we, we have amazing kind of platforms being built by the ground, 945 00:52:35,007 --> 00:52:38,647 up by the folks at like high par, um, and, and, and, and others out there. 946 00:52:38,647 --> 00:52:38,967 Right. 947 00:52:39,627 --> 00:52:46,207 Um, we, we are, you know, building tools that naturally extend things that people 948 00:52:46,307 --> 00:52:48,167 are already familiar with to a degree. 949 00:52:48,787 --> 00:52:53,167 So, like Conveyor, you know, rhino and Rev are known commodities 950 00:52:53,167 --> 00:52:54,007 in the world of design. 951 00:52:54,017 --> 00:52:56,727 We're trying to introduce another level of integration in there. 952 00:52:57,547 --> 00:53:02,927 Um, power BI is a well established product, um, and the idea of creating, 953 00:53:04,267 --> 00:53:11,837 you know, web viewable, um, You know, three D reports is also somewhat 954 00:53:11,997 --> 00:53:16,477 familiar, but we're, we're trying to layer in this idea of ease of 955 00:53:16,477 --> 00:53:22,117 accessibility and, you know, the idea of like a no code type of environment. 956 00:53:22,977 --> 00:53:25,717 It, it's also been advantageous because it allows us to tap into 957 00:53:26,117 --> 00:53:29,817 existing infrastructure if we're able to sort of say like, Hey, 958 00:53:29,817 --> 00:53:31,657 our tools work with your stuff. 959 00:53:32,357 --> 00:53:34,857 Um, because that's what they're designed to do. 960 00:53:35,527 --> 00:53:40,507 There's, there's, there's a, you know, there, there's an appetite 961 00:53:40,507 --> 00:53:44,547 there to be like, oh, okay, we don't, we don't need to overhaul our entire 962 00:53:45,697 --> 00:53:48,027 kind of IT or software infrastructure 963 00:53:48,207 --> 00:53:51,627 to get to this capability you're talking about, you're naturally extending and 964 00:53:51,627 --> 00:53:58,627 taking us to a, to a place that is, um, built on what we have as our skill sets 965 00:53:59,687 --> 00:54:03,667 and our, our infrastructure and, and taking it to another, another level. 966 00:54:04,892 --> 00:54:07,312 Evan Troxel: It reminds me of like old car magazines where it was 967 00:54:07,312 --> 00:54:09,152 like bolt-on performance, right? 968 00:54:09,172 --> 00:54:11,032 And it was like, anybody can do it. 969 00:54:11,052 --> 00:54:11,392 You know? 970 00:54:11,772 --> 00:54:13,152 Uh, that's the idea, right? 971 00:54:13,172 --> 00:54:16,472 Is like you've already got the, the building blocks in place, you 972 00:54:16,472 --> 00:54:19,872 have the expertise, and now you're just gonna extend the capabilities 973 00:54:20,292 --> 00:54:22,032 or get a little bit more. 974 00:54:23,242 --> 00:54:28,452 Just an an add-on that that helps do the things that, other words in other 975 00:54:28,452 --> 00:54:30,292 ways are extremely difficult to do. 976 00:54:30,552 --> 00:54:33,372 You couldn't piece that together yourself without an extremely 977 00:54:33,902 --> 00:54:34,972 large amount of effort. 978 00:54:34,982 --> 00:54:35,332 Right. 979 00:54:35,512 --> 00:54:35,732 So, 980 00:54:35,922 --> 00:54:36,212 Yeah. 981 00:54:36,442 --> 00:54:36,732 Yeah. 982 00:54:36,752 --> 00:54:39,412 The value in the tool is, is kind of obvious the first time you use it. 983 00:54:39,912 --> 00:54:40,132 So 984 00:54:40,747 --> 00:54:41,097 Nathan Miller: right. 985 00:54:42,782 --> 00:54:44,372 Evan Troxel: let's talk about this strategy thing. 986 00:54:44,652 --> 00:54:48,612 I mean, you're, because this, I think, does kind of provide the gateway into 987 00:54:48,612 --> 00:54:50,172 that part of the conversation, right? 988 00:54:50,172 --> 00:54:54,702 Because this is where you're now addressing the other 989 00:54:54,702 --> 00:54:56,182 people in the room, right? 990 00:54:56,322 --> 00:55:00,822 And you're, because a lot of times I think the, the software, the, 991 00:55:00,822 --> 00:55:04,542 the startups are focused on the actual users of the software. 992 00:55:05,202 --> 00:55:08,902 But there's this whole other world to the business of architecture 993 00:55:09,542 --> 00:55:13,852 where there's decision makers and stakeholders in many different levels 994 00:55:14,312 --> 00:55:16,492 beyond the actual users who are. 995 00:55:17,347 --> 00:55:19,327 Delivering the projects right there. 996 00:55:19,327 --> 00:55:21,747 They're, and there's, there's even different layers there, right? 997 00:55:21,747 --> 00:55:24,747 There's, there's the, the juniors and the mids and the seniors 998 00:55:24,767 --> 00:55:27,187 and, and that everyone kind of touches things in a different way. 999 00:55:27,187 --> 00:55:30,207 But then you've got that on the, you know, the overhead side 1000 00:55:30,207 --> 00:55:31,567 as well of, of the business. 1001 00:55:31,787 --> 00:55:37,587 Uh, and, and so I'm interested to kind of hear what you've been noticing in 1002 00:55:37,587 --> 00:55:40,347 the business of architecture and how you're helping address some of the 1003 00:55:40,347 --> 00:55:43,267 digital transformation side of that with the tools that you're releasing, 1004 00:55:43,267 --> 00:55:48,147 but also with the, the strategy and the, you're, you're doing your own 1005 00:55:48,177 --> 00:55:50,747 kind of analysis of these firms, right? 1006 00:55:50,767 --> 00:55:51,187 To help 1007 00:55:51,257 --> 00:55:55,587 them understand the landscape that they're in, how they're participating 1008 00:55:55,747 --> 00:55:58,747 in it, in ways that, in which they may, may not even be aware of. 1009 00:55:58,937 --> 00:56:01,627 Because you get to, you get to step back and you get to look 1010 00:56:01,627 --> 00:56:02,867 across the entire landscape. 1011 00:56:04,397 --> 00:56:09,837 Nathan Miller: Yeah, so, uh, strategy, the strategic work that we do, um, 1012 00:56:10,617 --> 00:56:15,427 was really among, I, I think some of the earliest consulting, uh, pro, uh, 1013 00:56:15,427 --> 00:56:17,547 projects that we've been a part of. 1014 00:56:17,767 --> 00:56:17,987 It. 1015 00:56:18,137 --> 00:56:23,267 It's sort of been the way that we're able to connect and create, I think, meaningful 1016 00:56:23,547 --> 00:56:28,027 collaborations from, um, and you used the term earlier, the idea of trust. 1017 00:56:28,097 --> 00:56:34,227 Because trust is really the, the currency that a, I think, a 1018 00:56:34,227 --> 00:56:35,907 good strategy relies on in order 1019 00:56:35,907 --> 00:56:36,707 to make it actionable. 1020 00:56:36,707 --> 00:56:39,707 There needs to be trust between, you know, I would say would 1021 00:56:39,707 --> 00:56:41,387 call us maybe coaches, coaches 1022 00:56:41,687 --> 00:56:43,187 and people that we're helping to coach. 1023 00:56:43,207 --> 00:56:47,827 And there also needs to be trust among the stakeholders within a business to, 1024 00:56:48,207 --> 00:56:52,387 um, realize the potential of the things that they're interested in realizing. 1025 00:56:53,247 --> 00:57:02,162 Um, and so, The, the strategy work that we do is, you know, I I I call it the 30, 1026 00:57:02,182 --> 00:57:09,762 you know, it's like the 30,000 foot, um, view of, of an organization and what the 1027 00:57:09,782 --> 00:57:18,232 impact of digital or is, can and should be within that, within that company. 1028 00:57:19,572 --> 00:57:23,632 And I think there's, there's a misconception usually right off the 1029 00:57:23,632 --> 00:57:26,552 bat that we're gonna come in and we're gonna tell them which tools to 1030 00:57:26,552 --> 00:57:28,592 use and then that's gonna solve it. 1031 00:57:29,132 --> 00:57:34,992 Um, or that we're gonna come in with a, uh, a new set of technologies that 1032 00:57:35,312 --> 00:57:39,472 they've never heard of before, and that's gonna be something that they're 1033 00:57:39,472 --> 00:57:40,832 gonna implement as the next stage. 1034 00:57:41,582 --> 00:57:44,032 What, what more often is the case? 1035 00:57:45,972 --> 00:57:48,312 Is that an architectural business? 1036 00:57:50,282 --> 00:57:53,302 Or a construction business or an owner operator business, they ha 1037 00:57:53,302 --> 00:57:59,022 they, they might have a lot of the tools and the technology in place 1038 00:57:59,202 --> 00:58:02,262 to some degree, it's right there. 1039 00:58:02,382 --> 00:58:04,262 I mean, it's like right on their desktop in some way. 1040 00:58:05,202 --> 00:58:12,462 But what they're missing is the attention to process, um, and the 1041 00:58:12,462 --> 00:58:17,822 attention to people and their skills in order to, to, to motivate the 1042 00:58:17,822 --> 00:58:19,982 organization to really see the benefit. 1043 00:58:21,202 --> 00:58:26,912 Um, part of, you know, it's, it's part of a lot of my introductory talks that 1044 00:58:26,952 --> 00:58:28,512 I give on the subject of strategy. 1045 00:58:30,102 --> 00:58:34,282 Um, it deals with two components to a successful strategy. 1046 00:58:34,552 --> 00:58:37,322 There's this idea of the smart component. 1047 00:58:38,637 --> 00:58:42,127 Like, and we all, we, we've heard the term smart business, you 1048 00:58:42,127 --> 00:58:43,727 know, work smarter, not harder, 1049 00:58:44,387 --> 00:58:45,727 um, and those types of things, right? 1050 00:58:45,727 --> 00:58:49,247 That, that, that refers to like, okay, you have the technology, you have the tools. 1051 00:58:49,387 --> 00:58:53,087 You might have different tactics that you're employing those tools with. 1052 00:58:53,787 --> 00:58:59,787 Um, but then there's, and you know, maybe knowledge management's a part of that 1053 00:58:59,897 --> 00:59:01,627 kind of the smart side, Right. 1054 00:59:01,627 --> 00:59:05,267 Content management, it's like the nuts and bolts that go into 1055 00:59:05,267 --> 00:59:07,427 making a, a smarter organization. 1056 00:59:08,127 --> 00:59:10,787 But then you also have the health side. 1057 00:59:11,007 --> 00:59:12,187 So smart and healthy. 1058 00:59:12,457 --> 00:59:19,587 Healthy is the, the part that is far more challenging to address in a 1059 00:59:19,867 --> 00:59:24,387 strategic way and actually requires way more effort and attention from 1060 00:59:24,387 --> 00:59:27,427 people that are non technologists, which is why I really like this, 1061 00:59:27,427 --> 00:59:32,187 because what you have to do within a, in my view, a healthy 1062 00:59:32,187 --> 00:59:34,827 organization is an organization that. 1063 00:59:36,347 --> 00:59:40,167 Has levels of accountability for certain initiatives that are taking place. 1064 00:59:41,217 --> 00:59:47,767 There is maybe even a sense of, of equity, um, within an organization, 1065 00:59:48,687 --> 00:59:52,807 i e equity, and both in terms of how, how you're thinking about how a certain 1066 00:59:52,907 --> 00:59:59,287 cap capability can spread equitably across, uh, a staff, but also people 1067 00:59:59,287 --> 01:00:00,647 that might be contributing to that. 1068 01:00:00,747 --> 01:00:04,207 Are they getting an upside from it, um, in a, in a meaningful way 1069 01:00:04,207 --> 01:00:06,007 in their work and their paycheck? 1070 01:00:06,027 --> 01:00:06,847 You know, something like that. 1071 01:00:07,057 --> 01:00:09,807 There might, there's also, uh, communication, um, 1072 01:00:09,917 --> 01:00:12,607 something far overlooked like, Hey, you have a new thing. 1073 01:00:12,827 --> 01:00:15,527 How is it being like, talked about 1074 01:00:15,707 --> 01:00:16,407 in your company 1075 01:00:16,677 --> 01:00:17,027 Evan Troxel: right. 1076 01:00:17,667 --> 01:00:17,887 Nathan Miller: and. 1077 01:00:20,057 --> 01:00:26,477 And then there's the, the big B, which is behavior as part of the, the healthy 1078 01:00:26,667 --> 01:00:32,437 side is your team s set up in such a way where they are being motivated 1079 01:00:32,777 --> 01:00:36,037 to change the way they do things. 1080 01:00:37,797 --> 01:00:43,497 And that one right there is probably the, you could call it the biggest speed 1081 01:00:43,497 --> 01:00:48,257 bump or barrier, uh, in any organization when it comes to digital transformation. 1082 01:00:48,837 --> 01:00:52,977 Um, and I'm sure you've heard it in many of the places that you've worked. 1083 01:00:53,797 --> 01:00:55,457 Why are you doing something a certain way? 1084 01:00:55,837 --> 01:00:59,057 The answer is usually, well, that's just the way I've always done it. 1085 01:00:59,632 --> 01:00:59,922 Evan Troxel: Yeah, 1086 01:00:59,977 --> 01:01:01,257 Nathan Miller: there's very little 1087 01:01:01,867 --> 01:01:06,137 motivation to push an individual to sort of be like, well, maybe I 1088 01:01:06,137 --> 01:01:09,017 should look at it a different way or change the way I'm, I'm working. 1089 01:01:09,942 --> 01:01:10,232 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 1090 01:01:10,717 --> 01:01:11,097 Nathan Miller: and so 1091 01:01:11,262 --> 01:01:13,702 Evan Troxel: is why you have to engage those leaders as well, because 1092 01:01:13,812 --> 01:01:18,342 that, that mentality comes out of, uh, I mean, I don't have time 1093 01:01:18,342 --> 01:01:19,702 to look at another way to do it. 1094 01:01:20,142 --> 01:01:24,202 I don't know that there's a better way to do it, and the project has been 1095 01:01:24,212 --> 01:01:29,162 built around slicing up time in the way that we've always done things, 1096 01:01:29,382 --> 01:01:29,722 and so 1097 01:01:29,722 --> 01:01:32,762 therefore, you give me that amount of time to do the thing. 1098 01:01:32,882 --> 01:01:34,522 I will take that amount of time to do the thing. 1099 01:01:35,742 --> 01:01:36,282 Nathan Miller: That's right. 1100 01:01:36,512 --> 01:01:37,042 It's a ma. 1101 01:01:37,042 --> 01:01:40,402 It's, it's like, it's like a, it's a beha B. 1102 01:01:40,662 --> 01:01:43,642 The, the B is for behavior of the bee is also for bias. 1103 01:01:43,932 --> 01:01:44,282 Right? 1104 01:01:44,392 --> 01:01:44,682 It's 1105 01:01:44,682 --> 01:01:48,162 like they have through, through their professional upbringing, through, 1106 01:01:48,192 --> 01:01:53,082 through our, the habits that we build, the rules of thumb that we cultivate. 1107 01:01:53,212 --> 01:01:56,882 These are great things in many respects because it allows us to work, you 1108 01:01:56,882 --> 01:02:00,002 know, we, we are gaining experience, we are developing rules of thumb. 1109 01:02:00,022 --> 01:02:03,602 We are figuring out faster ways to shortcut problems 1110 01:02:03,602 --> 01:02:05,482 that we always encounter. 1111 01:02:05,482 --> 01:02:08,722 These are necessities for us to be successful, but if 1112 01:02:08,722 --> 01:02:10,442 we're not careful, those. 1113 01:02:11,422 --> 01:02:16,842 Um, habits and those rules of thumb can also put the blinders on our 1114 01:02:16,842 --> 01:02:18,482 ability to see other possibilities. 1115 01:02:19,342 --> 01:02:22,682 And that's kind of why I like to think about our strategy is like, can we o, 1116 01:02:22,822 --> 01:02:28,842 can we come into the room and help take some of those blinders off and help 1117 01:02:29,322 --> 01:02:34,842 motivate an organization at different levels, whether it's the designer doing 1118 01:02:34,942 --> 01:02:38,562 the project or it's the project manager that's trying to figure out how to staff 1119 01:02:38,682 --> 01:02:42,442 a project appropriately, or it's the executive trying to make a high level, um, 1120 01:02:42,762 --> 01:02:51,672 decision on where to invest in training in, um, know, in a new capability or how 1121 01:02:51,672 --> 01:02:55,792 they might be developing a relationship with a, with a prospective client. 1122 01:02:56,172 --> 01:03:01,152 Can we help them look past maybe some of what they know and get 1123 01:03:01,152 --> 01:03:04,552 into an area where they might be uncomfortable at first, but recognize 1124 01:03:05,142 --> 01:03:08,672 that hey, this, this new capability can take us where we want to go. 1125 01:03:09,572 --> 01:03:10,672 Um, and if we can get. 1126 01:03:11,702 --> 01:03:13,032 That kind of attitude in place. 1127 01:03:13,732 --> 01:03:19,622 Um, the roadmap and a roadmap is usually like the, what I refer to 1128 01:03:19,622 --> 01:03:22,342 as a roadmap is usually the artifact that comes out of every strategy. 1129 01:03:22,342 --> 01:03:25,702 Engagement kind of sets a near, mid and long-term set of goals. 1130 01:03:26,212 --> 01:03:32,902 That roadmap very much easier to execute because you can see where you're going 1131 01:03:33,602 --> 01:03:37,582 and you have this level of buy-in at these different levels that help 1132 01:03:37,582 --> 01:03:42,182 people, um, know where they're going and know how they are participants 1133 01:03:42,202 --> 01:03:43,662 in that, in that ride together. 1134 01:03:45,292 --> 01:03:48,792 Evan Troxel: So many times someone like you, Nate, will come into a business. 1135 01:03:49,717 --> 01:03:52,097 And do the thing that you just talked about. 1136 01:03:52,197 --> 01:03:55,897 You'll create this report, you'll create the roadmap, and then you're 1137 01:03:55,897 --> 01:04:01,927 out, and then they're left to their own devices and, and there maybe are, there 1138 01:04:01,927 --> 01:04:06,487 maybe aren't some directly responsible individuals for each key element on there. 1139 01:04:07,277 --> 01:04:07,497 And 1140 01:04:08,077 --> 01:04:09,897 it tends to, I, I don't know. 1141 01:04:10,017 --> 01:04:14,237 I guess it's just my experience, but it's like if there's no one 1142 01:04:14,237 --> 01:04:15,717 owning it, it doesn't happen. 1143 01:04:15,847 --> 01:04:16,197 Right? 1144 01:04:16,197 --> 01:04:16,397 It 1145 01:04:16,397 --> 01:04:20,117 was like we went through the exercise, we checked the box, we realized the 1146 01:04:20,117 --> 01:04:21,637 things that we never realized before. 1147 01:04:21,797 --> 01:04:25,877 I, I, I was reminded, I think of Donald Rumsfeld's Rumsfeld's quote, right? 1148 01:04:25,937 --> 01:04:29,397 We have the known knowns, the known unknowns, and the unknown unknowns. 1149 01:04:29,397 --> 01:04:31,757 And it's like, you don't, you can't fault someone for not 1150 01:04:31,757 --> 01:04:32,757 knowing what they don't know. 1151 01:04:33,057 --> 01:04:37,157 And because they're so busy on the projects, delivering the things, doing it 1152 01:04:37,157 --> 01:04:40,717 the way that they've always done it, that they're not even coming up for air to kind 1153 01:04:40,717 --> 01:04:44,997 of survey the, the current state to see what, what else out there is possible. 1154 01:04:46,407 --> 01:04:51,547 You as this injection get to come in and kind of show people what, what might be 1155 01:04:51,787 --> 01:04:53,267 possible after you've listened to them. 1156 01:04:53,927 --> 01:05:01,297 Um, I mean, as far as efficacy goes to these kinds of, uh, relationships that 1157 01:05:01,297 --> 01:05:06,907 you enter into with them, how, I'm sure you've seen it go both ways, good and bad. 1158 01:05:07,007 --> 01:05:10,307 But I mean, if you were to kind of assign a ratio to it, what do you think that 1159 01:05:10,307 --> 01:05:15,737 that would be for, for implementation and success of, of those interactions? 1160 01:05:19,232 --> 01:05:24,332 Nathan Miller: I would, I would say, you know, there, there's, there's, you know, 1161 01:05:24,412 --> 01:05:28,772 I don't, I don't know if I have like a sta like a statistical like percentage 1162 01:05:28,792 --> 01:05:33,692 or I could say like, Hey, these, you know, folks we're at, we're at 80 1163 01:05:33,917 --> 01:05:34,337 Evan Troxel: 80 1164 01:05:34,337 --> 01:05:34,617 20 1165 01:05:35,402 --> 01:05:36,492 Nathan Miller: yeah, we're at 80 20. 1166 01:05:36,502 --> 01:05:38,012 We're at 80 20, 80% of 1167 01:05:38,012 --> 01:05:38,252 the time. 1168 01:05:38,752 --> 01:05:40,172 Our strategies work every time. 1169 01:05:40,282 --> 01:05:43,572 Like I don't know if I can do, I don't know if I can say that, um, with 1170 01:05:43,572 --> 01:05:48,652 certainty, but what I can say, um, is that there, there, there definitely 1171 01:05:48,752 --> 01:05:53,812 is the, the breakdown that, that you described there, there are, um, companies 1172 01:05:53,812 --> 01:05:56,332 that we've worked with where we've come in and we've done the strategy. 1173 01:05:56,942 --> 01:06:01,692 We've even set up the kind of account, like an accountability 1174 01:06:01,932 --> 01:06:05,492 structure and who's doing what, and then we'll check in on them. 1175 01:06:07,182 --> 01:06:11,322 You know, six months later, a year later, um, and be like, Hey, how are those? 1176 01:06:11,462 --> 01:06:13,842 Or, or we'll see them at an event, be like, Hey, how, how are 1177 01:06:13,842 --> 01:06:15,642 those, some of those initiatives we worked with you ongoing. 1178 01:06:15,642 --> 01:06:20,642 Like, well, you know, we, we just haven't been able to, to, to find the 1179 01:06:20,642 --> 01:06:27,652 time to, to do the, um, you know, the machine learning study or, or to, or 1180 01:06:27,652 --> 01:06:30,012 to, to enact the new training program 1181 01:06:30,652 --> 01:06:31,272 Evan Troxel: Mm, mm-hmm. 1182 01:06:31,902 --> 01:06:34,482 Nathan Miller: and, you know, but we're gonna, we're gonna get to it, you know? 1183 01:06:34,822 --> 01:06:37,962 Um, and, and you, you kind of like, 1184 01:06:37,992 --> 01:06:38,322 kind of 1185 01:06:38,362 --> 01:06:38,842 Evan Troxel: get the feeling. 1186 01:06:39,482 --> 01:06:39,772 Yeah. 1187 01:06:40,042 --> 01:06:42,442 Nathan Miller: like, yeah, you know, that maybe, you know, that one's not gonna 1188 01:06:43,312 --> 01:06:44,002 pick up steam. 1189 01:06:44,002 --> 01:06:49,352 But then, then we have the ones that are very, like, um, know, we've had, we've 1190 01:06:49,352 --> 01:06:55,072 had repeat strategies where it was like we would do like, like a three year plan. 1191 01:06:56,102 --> 01:07:01,242 And the, the, the team that was responsible for looking at the, the 1192 01:07:01,562 --> 01:07:06,122 tactics and the strategies that we had been talking about was very diligent 1193 01:07:06,122 --> 01:07:10,221 about going through each one, and they were starting to see results. 1194 01:07:10,221 --> 01:07:13,062 And at the end of three years, we're now Like I said, we're 1195 01:07:13,062 --> 01:07:13,742 an eight year old company. 1196 01:07:14,192 --> 01:07:14,482 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 1197 01:07:14,552 --> 01:07:17,702 Nathan Miller: We're now able to have repeat strategies where they're like, 1198 01:07:17,702 --> 01:07:18,862 Hey, we're done with our roadmap. 1199 01:07:19,072 --> 01:07:20,622 We're able to do X, Y, and Z. 1200 01:07:20,712 --> 01:07:21,822 Let's do another one 1201 01:07:22,642 --> 01:07:25,542 and look at the next three years based on where we've landed. 1202 01:07:26,202 --> 01:07:30,622 And they will come to us with a level of confidence that the things that 1203 01:07:30,971 --> 01:07:36,862 they had done were working out, and that the insight we were able to 1204 01:07:36,862 --> 01:07:41,422 provide was also gonna help them, elevate them to the next level. 1205 01:07:41,642 --> 01:07:45,302 And that, that becomes a very strong relationship and 1206 01:07:45,302 --> 01:07:46,382 a high trust relationship. 1207 01:07:47,382 --> 01:07:47,502 I. 1208 01:07:47,662 --> 01:07:50,242 And those are, those are two like examples where it's sort of like 1209 01:07:50,242 --> 01:07:53,322 we do the thing and then we, like you said, might go away for a 1210 01:07:53,322 --> 01:07:54,322 while or we're not like 1211 01:07:54,642 --> 01:07:54,762 actively 1212 01:07:55,117 --> 01:07:58,177 Evan Troxel: you're not, you're not actually delivering it. 1213 01:07:58,527 --> 01:08:01,537 It's up to them to deliver it on on it. 1214 01:08:01,537 --> 01:08:01,817 Yeah. 1215 01:08:02,332 --> 01:08:05,392 Nathan Miller: But we've also been a part of a number of, of strategies 1216 01:08:05,392 --> 01:08:09,072 that are like, yeah, we'll do, we'll work on the tactics together. 1217 01:08:09,652 --> 01:08:14,152 And oh, by the way, like these five over here are things that 1218 01:08:14,152 --> 01:08:16,072 we can directly help you with. 1219 01:08:16,176 --> 01:08:16,596 Evan Troxel: Mm-hmm. 1220 01:08:16,852 --> 01:08:20,792 Nathan Miller: Um, implementing a centralized, uh, data warehouse, 1221 01:08:20,812 --> 01:08:25,152 for example, or setting up, setting your self, setting them up with a 1222 01:08:25,392 --> 01:08:26,752 training around interoperability. 1223 01:08:27,912 --> 01:08:30,772 Things like that become natural points of entry for us 1224 01:08:30,832 --> 01:08:32,051 to be more hands on 1225 01:08:32,242 --> 01:08:34,417 with the .With the approach. 1226 01:08:34,836 --> 01:08:38,617 And I tend to like, obviously I like those more because it's like, oh yeah, it's 1227 01:08:38,617 --> 01:08:40,417 like kind of more, more business, right? 1228 01:08:40,877 --> 01:08:44,176 But it, but it's also, I like them because it, it gives us more of 1229 01:08:44,176 --> 01:08:45,657 a hand in the success or failure 1230 01:08:45,917 --> 01:08:47,817 of what the roadmap could be. 1231 01:08:48,157 --> 01:08:55,827 And I feel like with more involvement, we're able to help continue 1232 01:08:55,886 --> 01:08:57,747 to give advice along the way, 1233 01:08:58,567 --> 01:09:05,547 and that lends itself to a better, um, chance at the transformation succeeding. 1234 01:09:06,667 --> 01:09:12,267 I will say that I, I have a blog article that states as much, and, you 1235 01:09:12,267 --> 01:09:15,787 know, is, is based on some research, digital transformation initiatives 1236 01:09:15,807 --> 01:09:17,426 are really, really hard to pull off. 1237 01:09:17,577 --> 01:09:17,867 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 1238 01:09:18,447 --> 01:09:22,457 Nathan Miller: Um, I think there's a, there's a statistic out there 1239 01:09:22,487 --> 01:09:26,176 that they did a survey of like big companies that were initiating 1240 01:09:26,176 --> 01:09:27,857 digital transformation initiatives. 1241 01:09:28,527 --> 01:09:32,297 They have like an 82% failure rate which 1242 01:09:32,832 --> 01:09:33,562 Evan Troxel: There's a number, 1243 01:09:33,657 --> 01:09:35,256 Nathan Miller: a really high, there's a number. 1244 01:09:35,287 --> 01:09:35,737 It's a really 1245 01:09:35,737 --> 01:09:40,707 high, I mean, because what, what happens is, um, and it 1246 01:09:40,707 --> 01:09:42,147 all comes back to that B word 1247 01:09:42,907 --> 01:09:43,107 behavior. 1248 01:09:43,242 --> 01:09:43,662 Evan Troxel: mm-hmm. 1249 01:09:43,937 --> 01:09:45,987 Nathan Miller: What they're able to do is you're able to sort of say 1250 01:09:45,987 --> 01:09:49,506 like these digital transformation initiatives as well-meaning as 1251 01:09:49,506 --> 01:09:50,747 well thought out as they can be. 1252 01:09:51,207 --> 01:09:56,707 If you're not able to, again, attach their success or failure in a way that 1253 01:09:56,707 --> 01:10:03,147 is relevant to the, to a wide range of stakeholders that will see some 1254 01:10:03,147 --> 01:10:07,587 kind of upside in their work, um, then they're gonna stick with what's known. 1255 01:10:08,087 --> 01:10:12,747 Um, and they're gonna stick with the, the way that they've always done things and. 1256 01:10:13,992 --> 01:10:17,312 You know, and I, I think is especially true in larger organizations 1257 01:10:17,312 --> 01:10:19,232 where there's just a lot of complexity, a 1258 01:10:19,232 --> 01:10:20,152 lot of bureaucracy, 1259 01:10:20,992 --> 01:10:22,232 a lot of different opinions. 1260 01:10:22,732 --> 01:10:28,842 Um, and you know, it's easy, I think with, if, if, um, you're an employee in 1261 01:10:28,842 --> 01:10:33,602 a large company and the kind of upper echelon of leadership comes down like, 1262 01:10:33,602 --> 01:10:35,322 Hey, we're releasing a new strategy. 1263 01:10:35,742 --> 01:10:36,762 It doesn't matter what it is. 1264 01:10:37,022 --> 01:10:43,082 It could be related to, um, you know, the, the food service as much as it 1265 01:10:43,082 --> 01:10:44,562 is the technology that they're using. 1266 01:10:44,832 --> 01:10:45,122 Evan Troxel: Sure. 1267 01:10:45,772 --> 01:10:50,902 Nathan Miller: Um, but if, if it's one of those things where hey is, is 1268 01:10:50,902 --> 01:10:57,382 coming on down and my project manager isn't really talking to me about it 1269 01:10:58,082 --> 01:11:03,142 and my, um, you know, my principal is just sort of like, okay, whatever. 1270 01:11:03,142 --> 01:11:05,462 We're gonna ride this out for, for three years and then 1271 01:11:05,462 --> 01:11:05,982 we'll have a new 1272 01:11:06,262 --> 01:11:06,342 strategy. 1273 01:11:06,762 --> 01:11:10,262 You know, there's sort of this element of like, yeah, we'll wait and see. 1274 01:11:11,087 --> 01:11:15,787 Um, as opposed to, uh, you know, Hey, let's get on this. 1275 01:11:16,247 --> 01:11:17,107 You know, and that's where 1276 01:11:17,107 --> 01:11:17,667 you want to get past. 1277 01:11:17,687 --> 01:11:20,187 You wanna get past the wait and see stage and to, and to show 1278 01:11:20,187 --> 01:11:24,707 results with these strategies that can, can be meaningful to people. 1279 01:11:25,517 --> 01:11:28,337 Evan Troxel: you, you mentioned the word upside and I'm, I'm wondering if 1280 01:11:28,357 --> 01:11:36,207 you have any particular thoughts about, I mean, it is so important for someone 1281 01:11:36,227 --> 01:11:38,967 to see upside early is my guess, right? 1282 01:11:39,207 --> 01:11:42,167 , because I don't do what you do, but that makes a lot of sense. 1283 01:11:42,267 --> 01:11:46,167 And so do you focus on that a lot on the work that you're doing there? 1284 01:11:46,167 --> 01:11:49,307 Because I mean, some, you, you said you've got, you've got a 1285 01:11:49,307 --> 01:11:53,107 short-term, a midterm, and a long-term kind of staging of the plan. 1286 01:11:53,907 --> 01:11:54,847 The short-term stuff. 1287 01:11:54,967 --> 01:11:59,347 I, I would assume kind of has to show value very quickly so 1288 01:11:59,377 --> 01:12:03,667 that it even has a chance of continuing to that mid-level point. 1289 01:12:04,497 --> 01:12:06,947 Just general thoughts on, on that kind of thing. 1290 01:12:07,242 --> 01:12:09,932 Nathan Miller: Yeah, we call them quick wins and I'm sure it, it, 1291 01:12:10,082 --> 01:12:13,212 it's, it's a common terminology, common consulting terminology. 1292 01:12:13,352 --> 01:12:14,452 You might might say the, 1293 01:12:14,452 --> 01:12:15,132 the quick win. 1294 01:12:15,132 --> 01:12:20,012 We need a, we need a way to, um, demonstrate the value of an 1295 01:12:20,012 --> 01:12:24,012 opportunity right away so that people can latch on and wanna see more. 1296 01:12:24,022 --> 01:12:24,372 Right. 1297 01:12:24,892 --> 01:12:25,182 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 1298 01:12:25,622 --> 01:12:32,972 Nathan Miller: Um, this is where I think computational design has an 1299 01:12:32,972 --> 01:12:37,212 advantage in a way because it's not full-blown software development. 1300 01:12:38,112 --> 01:12:42,572 Um, but you can still develop extremely powerful automation technology 1301 01:12:42,642 --> 01:12:46,772 like techniques and technology that will help elevate a process. 1302 01:12:47,712 --> 01:12:51,612 And so what we oftentimes see is like, okay, there are these, okay, 1303 01:12:51,612 --> 01:12:57,192 we need to get some momentum behind, um, our data management behind, 1304 01:12:57,452 --> 01:12:58,632 uh, planning and programming. 1305 01:12:58,632 --> 01:12:59,152 What can we do? 1306 01:12:59,452 --> 01:13:00,992 Oh, well, I. 1307 01:13:02,092 --> 01:13:06,192 Uh, let's think about what you're using today and let's prototype 1308 01:13:06,192 --> 01:13:11,752 something really quick in Grasshopper or Dynamo that allows you to circumvent 1309 01:13:11,822 --> 01:13:15,232 some waste that we know your teams are dealing with right, right now. 1310 01:13:15,732 --> 01:13:20,262 And let's do it in two weeks, you know, and develop something that we can get 1311 01:13:20,262 --> 01:13:22,222 in their hands and, and help them. 1312 01:13:23,402 --> 01:13:27,602 And 'cause all of a sudden you're taking a high level, I, you know, something 1313 01:13:27,602 --> 01:13:30,962 that might be super high level in the 30,000 foot strategy view, and 1314 01:13:30,962 --> 01:13:34,362 you're saying, okay, now we're gonna bring this down to a solution rapidly. 1315 01:13:35,102 --> 01:13:40,822 Um, that's gonna hit person doing some level of production. 1316 01:13:41,742 --> 01:13:46,342 so that all of a sudden can, can generate a lot of excitement and also puts a 1317 01:13:46,342 --> 01:13:50,142 lot of, um, uh, interest, uh, behind. 1318 01:13:51,112 --> 01:13:53,652 The technology initiatives like, oh, I had no idea we could do this. 1319 01:13:53,752 --> 01:13:55,812 Why, why don't we have more computational designers? 1320 01:13:55,812 --> 01:13:56,972 Where can we get more training? 1321 01:13:57,472 --> 01:14:00,252 Um, how can I participate in this, in this training? 1322 01:14:00,832 --> 01:14:05,732 How can, um, can I sit in on the next, uh, strategy meeting so 1323 01:14:05,732 --> 01:14:06,972 we can talk about what we need? 1324 01:14:06,972 --> 01:14:10,092 Because we think this could turn into a new, uh, tool for 1325 01:14:10,412 --> 01:14:11,932 us that has broader reach. 1326 01:14:12,472 --> 01:14:16,332 And, and those quick wins can help, you know, prompt the questions, 1327 01:14:16,672 --> 01:14:18,572 um, and prompt the dialogue. 1328 01:14:19,652 --> 01:14:24,112 And, you know, when we, when we build software, uh, that's, that's, that's 1329 01:14:24,112 --> 01:14:28,472 part of our, i, I think, workflow in general is that if we're building 1330 01:14:28,472 --> 01:14:33,352 something custom, we want to have, um, prototypes, we want to have wire 1331 01:14:33,372 --> 01:14:37,632 frames, we want to have things that take something from the abstract into 1332 01:14:37,632 --> 01:14:38,992 something that is actually meaningful 1333 01:14:39,252 --> 01:14:40,752 and we know can deliver. 1334 01:14:40,752 --> 01:14:41,072 Right. 1335 01:14:42,312 --> 01:14:44,152 Evan Troxel: Just like the architectural design process, right? 1336 01:14:44,382 --> 01:14:44,752 , it's like, 1337 01:14:45,272 --> 01:14:46,882 Nathan Miller: It's, it's amazing the parallels there. 1338 01:14:46,882 --> 01:14:47,122 You know, 1339 01:14:47,122 --> 01:14:50,002 the, the architectural design process you want to have, you know, you 1340 01:14:50,002 --> 01:14:52,882 have your sketches, you have your initial renderings, you go through 1341 01:14:52,882 --> 01:14:54,242 the different phases of design. 1342 01:14:55,022 --> 01:15:00,522 Um, actually something that, uh, we, we've drawn that parallel before and it tends 1343 01:15:00,522 --> 01:15:03,962 to resonate is like digital transformation is just another design problem. 1344 01:15:04,422 --> 01:15:08,842 And you're going through a very similar set of steps and, you know, you might end 1345 01:15:08,842 --> 01:15:13,562 up with, uh, designs that get discarded and you're gonna end up with, uh, and 1346 01:15:13,562 --> 01:15:15,322 that's, think about those as iterations 1347 01:15:15,322 --> 01:15:17,682 that are taking you on the path to, to realizing the 1348 01:15:18,022 --> 01:15:18,242 the 1349 01:15:18,402 --> 01:15:20,252 Evan Troxel: It's, it's, it might be circuitous, right? 1350 01:15:20,252 --> 01:15:20,412 It 1351 01:15:20,412 --> 01:15:23,372 might not be that straight line that, that somebody really, ideally wants, 1352 01:15:23,432 --> 01:15:24,852 but rarely ever happens, right? 1353 01:15:24,912 --> 01:15:26,492 And, and you do have to have kind of that. 1354 01:15:27,302 --> 01:15:30,422 That loopy nature to it too, because you learn in the process and then 1355 01:15:30,422 --> 01:15:33,582 you go back and you, you know, like two steps forward, one step back. 1356 01:15:33,582 --> 01:15:36,502 You're not going all the way back, but you, you learn something along the way 1357 01:15:36,502 --> 01:15:38,022 and you're gonna continue on from there. 1358 01:15:38,642 --> 01:15:40,942 Uh, I think it creates a level of ownership too. 1359 01:15:41,292 --> 01:15:45,742 Like you said, you, you have this high level report that, that the highest 1360 01:15:45,742 --> 01:15:49,862 level people in the company are, are responding to, but then you take it down 1361 01:15:49,862 --> 01:15:54,542 to the grassroots, to the floor and you say, here's a technology that we can 1362 01:15:54,542 --> 01:15:59,862 introduce that's gonna make this person and this process better, and that's 1363 01:15:59,862 --> 01:16:01,782 gonna have an outcome of excitement. 1364 01:16:02,202 --> 01:16:05,302 And it, it starts to get their gears turning. 1365 01:16:05,962 --> 01:16:07,822 And now you have both levels working, right? 1366 01:16:07,922 --> 01:16:12,502 You, you have a high level and a grassroots level working together to 1367 01:16:12,502 --> 01:16:17,902 deliver on those strategies, but actually really in a, in a useful day-to-day way. 1368 01:16:18,282 --> 01:16:21,622 And it, I think it does take both to be really successful, right? 1369 01:16:21,622 --> 01:16:23,902 It's like you, you've gotta see it. 1370 01:16:24,577 --> 01:16:28,417 You've gotta see progress at both ends of the scale, and you've gotta have 1371 01:16:28,417 --> 01:16:29,977 ownership at both ends of the scale 1372 01:16:30,397 --> 01:16:32,617 for it to have a chance to make it. 1373 01:16:33,522 --> 01:16:34,062 Nathan Miller: That's right. 1374 01:16:34,442 --> 01:16:34,942 That's right. 1375 01:16:35,737 --> 01:16:37,597 Evan Troxel: The the other thing that, that I was thinking about 1376 01:16:37,597 --> 01:16:40,477 when you were talking about these reports is flexibility and like 1377 01:16:40,497 --> 01:16:44,517 the, is how much flexibility is built in because you're, if you're doing a 1378 01:16:44,517 --> 01:16:49,017 three year report and I think about what's happened in the last year, 1379 01:16:49,247 --> 01:16:50,617 it's like the report's gotta change. 1380 01:16:50,727 --> 01:16:58,817 Nate , something happened in technology, uh, the explosion of, you know, large 1381 01:16:59,137 --> 01:17:04,897 language models, AI as an example, would have an effect on digital transformation, 1382 01:17:05,177 --> 01:17:07,857 I would assume, pretty obviously. 1383 01:17:07,857 --> 01:17:08,177 Right. 1384 01:17:08,237 --> 01:17:08,457 and 1385 01:17:08,457 --> 01:17:14,017 so I, and so I'm just wondering how, how do you navigate that as a 1386 01:17:14,017 --> 01:17:17,916 consultant to these companies building flexibility into your reports or not? 1387 01:17:18,857 --> 01:17:19,147 Nathan Miller: Yeah. 1388 01:17:19,287 --> 01:17:24,107 So, um, I would say that yes, you know, I think, yeah, I use the term report. 1389 01:17:25,257 --> 01:17:27,037 Um, I also use the term roadmap. 1390 01:17:27,247 --> 01:17:31,597 These are, these are very, um, would say by nature. 1391 01:17:33,112 --> 01:17:34,662 Meant to be living documents. 1392 01:17:35,002 --> 01:17:42,302 Um, the, the, the, the early sort of stage stuff, like the near term tactics 1393 01:17:42,302 --> 01:17:47,022 that are often like outlined are far more concrete than the late, the later stuff. 1394 01:17:47,322 --> 01:17:54,502 And I think what, what, they, what they also need to do, um, what a, what a good 1395 01:17:54,782 --> 01:18:02,022 strategy also needs to do is provide some basis of criticality into them. 1396 01:18:02,842 --> 01:18:08,742 So you have a north star, uh, that you're headed towards and you know 1397 01:18:10,492 --> 01:18:12,541 what not to get distracted by. 1398 01:18:13,082 --> 01:18:16,782 And I think that's one of the more dangerous, we don't think about it as 1399 01:18:16,782 --> 01:18:22,902 often, but it is one of the more, uh, dangerous and area things that can really 1400 01:18:23,282 --> 01:18:26,302 derail a strategy where it's like, I. 1401 01:18:26,791 --> 01:18:30,892 Oh my God, something new just came along and I'm gonna table everything 1402 01:18:30,892 --> 01:18:32,332 else and just look at this new thing. 1403 01:18:32,617 --> 01:18:32,777 Evan Troxel: Squirrel. 1404 01:18:32,967 --> 01:18:33,257 Yeah. 1405 01:18:33,832 --> 01:18:33,952 Nathan Miller: Squirrel. 1406 01:18:34,022 --> 01:18:34,512 Exactly. 1407 01:18:34,932 --> 01:18:37,072 And with technology, boy, is that easy. 1408 01:18:37,472 --> 01:18:39,552 I can look at my LinkedIn feed right now 1409 01:18:40,012 --> 01:18:45,032 and I'll, I I will show you a feed of dozens of people doing the squirrel 1410 01:18:45,032 --> 01:18:46,632 thing at this moment in time. 1411 01:18:48,132 --> 01:18:53,312 and I, and, and so what I, what I, what I think is important then is to sort 1412 01:18:53,312 --> 01:18:56,952 of say like, okay, we know technology is gonna be changing and evolving 1413 01:18:57,092 --> 01:18:58,312 and there's gonna be a new thing. 1414 01:18:59,172 --> 01:19:03,352 But what you need to do as a practice is be able to say like, does this new 1415 01:19:03,352 --> 01:19:10,962 thing, um, we critically look at it, does it support where we wanna go? 1416 01:19:11,791 --> 01:19:14,002 Does it take away from where we want to go? 1417 01:19:14,702 --> 01:19:19,602 Um, or is it just a general kind of r and d and we're just gonna kind 1418 01:19:19,602 --> 01:19:20,922 of wait it out and see what happens? 1419 01:19:22,972 --> 01:19:25,322 Um, and I think. 1420 01:19:25,992 --> 01:19:30,412 In a lot of cases, if we hear of something new, there's, there's an element that we, 1421 01:19:30,752 --> 01:19:34,092 you know, we want to educate ourselves as much as we can about something that is 1422 01:19:34,092 --> 01:19:36,092 maybe capturing the popular imagination. 1423 01:19:36,552 --> 01:19:42,022 But there's also an aspect of like, yeah, we're gonna wait about 1424 01:19:42,022 --> 01:19:44,862 eight, between 18 and 24 months to see how it actually shakes out, 1425 01:19:44,922 --> 01:19:53,562 to see if it will, um, be something that is going to concretely 1426 01:19:53,562 --> 01:19:55,962 move us in a new direction. 1427 01:19:56,622 --> 01:20:01,122 Um, because, you know, the, the there's two sides of an ear. 1428 01:20:01,291 --> 01:20:05,041 Being an early adopter, you're, you're basically gambling, you are, you're 1429 01:20:05,041 --> 01:20:06,482 putting a gamble, you're placing a bet. 1430 01:20:06,742 --> 01:20:11,922 You're like, Hey, this new thing is going to be the thing, or 1431 01:20:12,152 --> 01:20:13,282 it's not gonna be the thing. 1432 01:20:13,742 --> 01:20:17,002 And you know, it's really a 50 50 shot, you know, 1433 01:20:17,222 --> 01:20:21,022 um, many people do, like, I remember when Google Glass came out. 1434 01:20:22,452 --> 01:20:22,932 Do you remember that? 1435 01:20:22,962 --> 01:20:26,692 Like, there I knew just maybe a, a few people that, that were early 1436 01:20:26,692 --> 01:20:30,732 adopters and they were walking around with the Google glass and they had 1437 01:20:30,752 --> 01:20:34,291 the thing, and it just fell flat on 1438 01:20:34,291 --> 01:20:36,812 its face and, you know, it wasn't the new thing, you know? 1439 01:20:36,812 --> 01:20:40,252 And now, now, today you do have some more augmented things, you know, 1440 01:20:40,252 --> 01:20:41,612 since I, you brought it up earlier. 1441 01:20:42,132 --> 01:20:42,852 I do a lot of swimming. 1442 01:20:42,962 --> 01:20:46,652 I've seen, I get ads pushed to me all the time where you can get ar goggles 1443 01:20:47,282 --> 01:20:50,652 that will show you like all of your stats as you're, as you're doing laps. 1444 01:20:51,312 --> 01:20:54,532 Pretty cool that it was like, oh, this is actually a practical use of that. 1445 01:20:54,532 --> 01:20:57,452 One thing I saw that failed, fell on it face a while back. 1446 01:20:57,952 --> 01:21:07,952 Um, so you want, you want to, you wanna have, um, yeah, you wanna be 1447 01:21:07,952 --> 01:21:11,872 careful with the new stuff, I think in, in a way where you, you just wanna 1448 01:21:11,872 --> 01:21:16,791 make sure that you're, you're engaging with it in a way that is going to be 1449 01:21:16,791 --> 01:21:18,791 productive and it's not a distraction. 1450 01:21:19,452 --> 01:21:25,207 Um, You're not gonna be sinking a lot of money into something that ends up 1451 01:21:25,207 --> 01:21:28,387 being a, you know, ends up going nowhere. 1452 01:21:28,767 --> 01:21:31,666 You know, there's, 'cause there's, you know, as we know this world of 1453 01:21:31,666 --> 01:21:35,867 architecture, you know, you have, you know, there's a business model 1454 01:21:36,187 --> 01:21:41,357 attached to it where r and d is already really hard to come by, um, and 1455 01:21:41,427 --> 01:21:43,237 justify certain levels of investment. 1456 01:21:43,457 --> 01:21:43,957 So you're, 1457 01:21:43,957 --> 01:21:48,367 you're kind of like, okay, is this the metaverse is a good example of 1458 01:21:48,367 --> 01:21:51,007 this, this, it's like, it kind of blew up last year, right? 1459 01:21:51,107 --> 01:21:53,927 You know, it was like at first beginning of the year, everyone 1460 01:21:53,927 --> 01:21:55,527 was hot on the, on, on metaverse. 1461 01:21:55,757 --> 01:21:57,967 It's like, boom, this is where it's going. 1462 01:21:58,867 --> 01:22:01,567 And by the end of the year, all those stocks, 1463 01:22:01,847 --> 01:22:03,407 taint and crypto along with it, 1464 01:22:03,507 --> 01:22:09,087 you know, and it's, and it's like there's a level of, of churn that happens in 1465 01:22:09,117 --> 01:22:14,887 tech that you, you, wanna build a, a critical view around so you don't get 1466 01:22:15,747 --> 01:22:20,847 sucked in, um, in a way that is gonna be detrimental to your, to your goal. 1467 01:22:21,637 --> 01:22:23,817 Evan Troxel: you, you talked about that critical look of, 1468 01:22:23,997 --> 01:22:25,497 of the business over time. 1469 01:22:27,372 --> 01:22:32,072 And I'm, I was thinking as you're saying that it's like, because it's come up on 1470 01:22:32,072 --> 01:22:36,642 this podcast, it's come up on my other podcast about how architecture in general, 1471 01:22:37,102 --> 01:22:41,882 the, the profession is bad at, at looking at itself as a design problem, right. 1472 01:22:41,882 --> 01:22:42,362 Looking at 1473 01:22:42,382 --> 01:22:43,882 its business as a design problem. 1474 01:22:44,502 --> 01:22:48,002 And the way that I just started to think about it as you were talking was, it's not 1475 01:22:48,002 --> 01:22:51,522 like a architectural design problem, it's more like a software design problem in 1476 01:22:51,522 --> 01:22:53,082 that the software is kind of never done. 1477 01:22:53,092 --> 01:22:53,442 Right. 1478 01:22:53,442 --> 01:22:54,802 Where a building is like, yep. 1479 01:22:54,822 --> 01:22:58,562 At some point you hand it over to the contractor and they hand it 1480 01:22:58,562 --> 01:23:01,602 over to the owner and, and then you're onto the next project, right? 1481 01:23:01,782 --> 01:23:04,522 And, and there's, of course, there's software like that too that just 1482 01:23:05,132 --> 01:23:06,922 stops getting maintained or whatever. 1483 01:23:07,592 --> 01:23:07,812 But, 1484 01:23:08,112 --> 01:23:13,332 but for the long running apps that we've been using for decades that 1485 01:23:13,332 --> 01:23:18,232 have just been like built up over time and new features added and other ones 1486 01:23:18,232 --> 01:23:21,312 deprecated and like, that's what a business is, is much more like, and so 1487 01:23:21,812 --> 01:23:24,192 to, to really have that critical view. 1488 01:23:25,147 --> 01:23:31,607 In an ongoing way and constantly watching and adjusting and really having, you 1489 01:23:31,607 --> 01:23:36,337 know, your fingers on the pulse of what's going on is, is of course, this is what 1490 01:23:36,337 --> 01:23:38,857 leadership and firms are responsible for. 1491 01:23:39,517 --> 01:23:43,416 Uh, and yet there's a lot of businesses out there that could be 1492 01:23:43,416 --> 01:23:45,377 doing a heck of a lot better because 1493 01:23:45,757 --> 01:23:46,177 Nathan Miller: Mm-hmm. 1494 01:23:46,577 --> 01:23:47,477 Evan Troxel: of so many reasons, 1495 01:23:48,407 --> 01:23:52,227 Nathan Miller: I mean, the oppo, the opposite of all of this is true. 1496 01:23:52,257 --> 01:23:54,387 Like, you know, there's one side you don't wanna get caught up, 1497 01:23:54,447 --> 01:23:56,666 but you don't wanna have the blinders on where you're gonna get, 1498 01:23:57,007 --> 01:24:00,347 you know, sideswiped by something that you didn't know was coming. 1499 01:24:00,887 --> 01:24:07,357 Um, you know, with the large language model and the AI stuff, I mean, we're not, 1500 01:24:07,767 --> 01:24:10,677 we're, uh, that's been a long time coming, 1501 01:24:10,977 --> 01:24:12,037 you know, it's, it's 1502 01:24:12,037 --> 01:24:14,197 been the, it's been kind of pr, it's been present. 1503 01:24:14,737 --> 01:24:15,087 Evan Troxel: right? 1504 01:24:15,252 --> 01:24:18,272 Nathan Miller: The, the discourse, um, if you were, if you had your pulse 1505 01:24:18,291 --> 01:24:20,712 on the conversations to the president of the discourse for a really long 1506 01:24:20,712 --> 01:24:26,712 time, and now we're, you know, seeing prompt engines and, and, and things 1507 01:24:26,712 --> 01:24:29,112 like that, which are, you know, it's making it, you know, it's getting 1508 01:24:29,112 --> 01:24:32,472 into the popular kind of imagination in a way that it hadn't previously. 1509 01:24:32,692 --> 01:24:34,312 And people are like, where'd this come from? 1510 01:24:34,382 --> 01:24:37,272 Like, well, it's, it's kind of been there, you know? 1511 01:24:37,427 --> 01:24:37,777 Evan Troxel: Right. 1512 01:24:38,927 --> 01:24:39,217 Yeah. 1513 01:24:39,447 --> 01:24:39,737 Yeah. 1514 01:24:39,887 --> 01:24:41,337 It's, uh, it's, it's crazy. 1515 01:24:41,577 --> 01:24:46,447 I, I think also about the idea of the innovation curve versus the 1516 01:24:46,607 --> 01:24:50,647 adoption curve, and so you're, you're watching this from a, I think it's 1517 01:24:50,647 --> 01:24:54,087 framed in, in your world, under the, the guise of digital transformation. 1518 01:24:54,087 --> 01:24:54,407 Right? 1519 01:24:54,407 --> 01:24:54,767 Which is 1520 01:24:54,767 --> 01:24:57,407 kind of the actual adoption of. 1521 01:24:58,416 --> 01:25:02,017 Innovation and technology in business to do better, to do more 1522 01:25:02,117 --> 01:25:04,657 to what whatever the, the outcomes that you're looking for are. 1523 01:25:04,967 --> 01:25:06,777 What, what do you see as, as there? 1524 01:25:06,777 --> 01:25:10,537 Because the way that I've described it in talks that I've given is like innovators 1525 01:25:10,637 --> 01:25:14,857 are, and this is a, a belief that, that we've kind of established it within our 1526 01:25:14,857 --> 01:25:18,577 company that we share is innovators are innovating on top of innovation, and 1527 01:25:18,577 --> 01:25:20,697 therefore the curve is up into the right. 1528 01:25:20,817 --> 01:25:24,277 I mean, that's, that's the direction that it goes because they, it 1529 01:25:24,277 --> 01:25:25,277 can't, you can't even help it. 1530 01:25:25,347 --> 01:25:27,916 Like that's, those are the people who think like that 1531 01:25:28,107 --> 01:25:29,517 naturally are going to do that. 1532 01:25:29,857 --> 01:25:35,277 And then there's the people doing the work who maybe do have the blinders on in some 1533 01:25:35,277 --> 01:25:39,157 categories, and maybe they're aware of other things in, in other categories, but, 1534 01:25:39,416 --> 01:25:42,397 but the adoption curve is much lower and 1535 01:25:42,397 --> 01:25:42,797 slower. 1536 01:25:43,457 --> 01:25:48,637 And so that chasm by definition only gets bigger and bigger and 1537 01:25:48,637 --> 01:25:49,597 bigger and bigger and bigger. 1538 01:25:49,807 --> 01:25:50,157 Right. 1539 01:25:50,697 --> 01:25:53,117 I'm wondering what you think about, about that because you're 1540 01:25:53,277 --> 01:25:54,277 actually boots on the ground. 1541 01:25:55,307 --> 01:25:59,947 Even trying to help people get over that gap in their firms. 1542 01:26:00,087 --> 01:26:01,547 And so how do you, how do you see that? 1543 01:26:01,547 --> 01:26:03,187 Do you see it like that or do you see it differently? 1544 01:26:04,222 --> 01:26:04,722 Nathan Miller: No, it's true. 1545 01:26:04,802 --> 01:26:08,442 I mean, you're, you're really kind of speaking to, um, I. 1546 01:26:09,397 --> 01:26:12,916 You know, there's that, uh, there's that quote, the future is here. 1547 01:26:12,916 --> 01:26:14,157 It's just not evenly distributed. 1548 01:26:14,577 --> 01:26:16,916 You know, you know that, that's very true. 1549 01:26:17,457 --> 01:26:21,037 Um, especially in the world of construction. 1550 01:26:21,617 --> 01:26:31,877 Um, there are that are doing amazing, innovative stuff 1551 01:26:32,147 --> 01:26:33,437 like, like you just described. 1552 01:26:33,437 --> 01:26:34,677 It's innovation on top of innovation. 1553 01:26:34,677 --> 01:26:35,916 They're accelerating. 1554 01:26:37,537 --> 01:26:44,537 Um, and then you have firms that are decidedly not doing that. 1555 01:26:44,997 --> 01:26:52,987 Um, and they, you know, I I had a, I had a a, a call just last week, last two weeks, 1556 01:26:54,087 --> 01:26:56,827 and I, I, dropped the term grasshopper. 1557 01:26:57,107 --> 01:26:57,867 I just said, oh yeah. 1558 01:26:57,867 --> 01:27:00,547 You know, we, we built some tools with Grasshopper and 1559 01:27:00,737 --> 01:27:01,827 they were like, grasshopper? 1560 01:27:01,827 --> 01:27:02,227 What's that? 1561 01:27:04,597 --> 01:27:05,297 You know, and, 1562 01:27:05,952 --> 01:27:06,791 Evan Troxel: Legitimate question. 1563 01:27:07,647 --> 01:27:08,797 Nathan Miller: Legit legitimate question. 1564 01:27:08,857 --> 01:27:11,157 Uh, I have been trying to figure that out for like the last 1565 01:27:11,597 --> 01:27:12,117 13 years. 1566 01:27:12,422 --> 01:27:12,772 Evan Troxel: Right. 1567 01:27:13,177 --> 01:27:16,077 Nathan Miller: Um, I'm really thinking about it. 1568 01:27:16,617 --> 01:27:19,467 Um, but you know, we take for granted 1569 01:27:19,767 --> 01:27:27,027 how, uh, established some of these products are, and some people just 1570 01:27:27,257 --> 01:27:29,267 have not have not engaged at all. 1571 01:27:29,367 --> 01:27:33,666 And for all intents and purposes, the firm that I was talking with at 1572 01:27:33,666 --> 01:27:36,067 that point in time was profitable and 1573 01:27:36,127 --> 01:27:38,787 had a good customer base and was moving along just fine. 1574 01:27:38,932 --> 01:27:39,282 Evan Troxel: Right? 1575 01:27:39,967 --> 01:27:43,107 Nathan Miller: And I think that's, that's like, that's an important thing 1576 01:27:43,107 --> 01:27:47,067 that it's always to have important to have those kinds of gut checks is like, 1577 01:27:49,477 --> 01:27:57,977 just because something is innovative, um, doesn't necessarily negate or 1578 01:27:58,447 --> 01:28:01,416 supersede or override the benefit of. 1579 01:28:02,532 --> 01:28:05,512 Of doing things in a way that's already established as well. 1580 01:28:05,812 --> 01:28:08,472 So like, I'm not, you know, I, I think you're right. 1581 01:28:08,592 --> 01:28:14,262 I think you're, you're right that you have, you have innovators that are always 1582 01:28:14,262 --> 01:28:19,502 gonna be, you know, moving the curve, moving that curve, um, up into the right. 1583 01:28:21,122 --> 01:28:26,012 But, you know, I, I think it, you know, this comes back to the air, the 1584 01:28:26,012 --> 01:28:29,452 kind of point I was, you know, making earlier about being critical about 1585 01:28:29,541 --> 01:28:31,252 where you're at and where you're going. 1586 01:28:32,112 --> 01:28:39,302 Um, and, and maybe it's just who I am, um, as well, because when I was at M B B 1587 01:28:39,382 --> 01:28:44,182 J, you know, I was, I was the grasshopper guy, you know, and I love building 1588 01:28:44,232 --> 01:28:48,202 stuff in, in, you know, grasshopper. 1589 01:28:49,072 --> 01:28:53,962 But I tell you, when it came crunch time, there, there was nothing stopping 1590 01:28:54,022 --> 01:28:55,362 me from being like, you know what? 1591 01:28:56,041 --> 01:28:57,862 I'm gonna get in these CAD plans and 1592 01:28:58,152 --> 01:28:58,902 we're gonna be 1593 01:28:59,242 --> 01:28:59,822 Evan Troxel: Export to 1594 01:28:59,892 --> 01:29:00,382 AutoCAD 1595 01:29:00,652 --> 01:29:02,142 Nathan Miller: Yeah, we're gonna be ripping through these, 1596 01:29:02,172 --> 01:29:03,462 ripping through the document 1597 01:29:03,602 --> 01:29:07,982 set, you know, like you have to do it and you have to do it to get, get by 1598 01:29:07,982 --> 01:29:11,862 and you need to kind of rely on, on, you know, those, those experiences too. 1599 01:29:13,122 --> 01:29:17,582 Um, so in many ways it comes down to maybe there's an element of balance there. 1600 01:29:17,812 --> 01:29:19,541 Like there's so much expertise. 1601 01:29:19,541 --> 01:29:22,902 Like we talk, you talked about the gray hairs in this industry, right? 1602 01:29:23,122 --> 01:29:27,702 Um, earlier and you know how um, and I may be getting to be one of those 1603 01:29:27,722 --> 01:29:35,712 two, um, at this point, but, you know, there's so much experience there and 1604 01:29:36,912 --> 01:29:42,842 just because there's new stuff coming in, and just because there are, you know, 1605 01:29:43,502 --> 01:29:47,722 highly innovative technologies, while you don't want to have people putting 1606 01:29:47,722 --> 01:29:53,402 their blinders on, you also don't wanna negate very well established experience. 1607 01:29:54,332 --> 01:29:59,992 Um, how a building comes together, how architecture gets made. 1608 01:30:00,532 --> 01:30:08,552 Um, you know, I think you almost, you almost wanna, we called it, um, you know, 1609 01:30:08,552 --> 01:30:12,112 it was kind of, there's like a term that we, that was popular there for a while. 1610 01:30:12,112 --> 01:30:14,672 It's called upward mentoring or reverse mentoring. 1611 01:30:14,982 --> 01:30:19,512 Something we often advocated for in, in, in a lot of strategies also was 1612 01:30:19,512 --> 01:30:24,192 something that M B B J was kind of big on, is that you would pair up, um, your, 1613 01:30:25,192 --> 01:30:30,142 you know, someone that is doing new things and engaging with new content. 1614 01:30:30,472 --> 01:30:34,742 Maybe it's grasshopper, maybe it's rendering, maybe it's, um, you 1615 01:30:34,742 --> 01:30:36,302 know, a different form of design. 1616 01:30:36,392 --> 01:30:39,822 You'd pair those individuals up with people that are very well 1617 01:30:39,822 --> 01:30:43,422 established in the field and you would try to set up mechanism where 1618 01:30:43,422 --> 01:30:44,422 they can learn from each other. 1619 01:30:45,002 --> 01:30:48,602 Um, And, and feed, feed, feed forward. 1620 01:30:48,622 --> 01:30:53,402 So it's not a, a, pure dichotomy of people that aren't doing it 1621 01:30:53,402 --> 01:30:54,442 and people that are doing it. 1622 01:30:54,512 --> 01:30:58,242 It's more of like, what can you share in order to make a product, you know, 1623 01:30:58,582 --> 01:31:02,122 to to generate kind of a productive transformation that operates in both ways. 1624 01:31:02,547 --> 01:31:03,207 Evan Troxel: the Venn diagram. 1625 01:31:03,397 --> 01:31:05,047 Yeah, the greens and the grays, right? 1626 01:31:05,197 --> 01:31:05,487 Yeah. 1627 01:31:05,517 --> 01:31:07,367 That, that spot, that sweet spot in the middle. 1628 01:31:07,427 --> 01:31:10,807 It, I, there was a book written by one of the partners, I believe 1629 01:31:10,807 --> 01:31:13,367 it was N B B J, and it was called Designing the Design Firm. 1630 01:31:13,467 --> 01:31:14,127 And they did 1631 01:31:14,127 --> 01:31:17,567 talk about, talked about that in there, that that's a fantastic book 1632 01:31:17,777 --> 01:31:19,727 about leadership in design firms. 1633 01:31:19,837 --> 01:31:20,127 Yeah. 1634 01:31:20,912 --> 01:31:21,202 Nathan Miller: Yeah. 1635 01:31:21,797 --> 01:31:24,897 Evan Troxel: Um, this, this idea, and maybe, maybe we should start to 1636 01:31:24,897 --> 01:31:31,617 wrap up here, but I, I've, the whole idea of, of that bi-directional, I 1637 01:31:31,617 --> 01:31:33,777 mean, talk about interoperability. 1638 01:31:34,207 --> 01:31:35,017 Nate, uh, 1639 01:31:35,112 --> 01:31:36,532 Nathan Miller: that's what we're, that's what we're, that's what 1640 01:31:36,532 --> 01:31:39,172 it, it all comes down, it all comes back to interoperability. 1641 01:31:40,232 --> 01:31:43,452 Uh, bi-directional exchange of data. 1642 01:31:45,057 --> 01:31:47,517 Evan Troxel: It is, it is about creating these connections 1643 01:31:47,587 --> 01:31:49,797 between experience and wisdom. 1644 01:31:50,007 --> 01:31:50,357 Right? 1645 01:31:50,757 --> 01:31:55,567 I mean, it is interesting also to think about those people who are the 1646 01:31:55,927 --> 01:32:01,007 operators using these maybe high tech solutions early in their career, but 1647 01:32:01,067 --> 01:32:06,377 not knowing the things that they need to know to actually deliver a project and 1648 01:32:06,697 --> 01:32:07,977 creating the connections between those. 1649 01:32:07,977 --> 01:32:12,337 Because like you, you talk about, you know, navigating the building code. 1650 01:32:12,367 --> 01:32:14,457 Talk about navigating a stakeholder meeting. 1651 01:32:14,527 --> 01:32:18,377 Talk about getting a client to sign off on something and go to the next level or 1652 01:32:18,637 --> 01:32:23,017 an ad service or, and, and I think it's funny because you always see 1653 01:32:23,017 --> 01:32:27,297 these, uh, analogies being driven toward like the automobile, the 1654 01:32:27,297 --> 01:32:32,137 automotive industry in design or, or any kind of product based design, and 1655 01:32:32,377 --> 01:32:35,697 applying those ideas to architecture and look how much better architecture 1656 01:32:35,697 --> 01:32:37,697 would be if we only did this thing. 1657 01:32:37,757 --> 01:32:40,977 And it's like it is actually a completely different animal. 1658 01:32:41,157 --> 01:32:42,617 It is completely different. 1659 01:32:43,862 --> 01:32:49,282 How many times does a, does a automotive firm engage a customer to 1660 01:32:49,302 --> 01:32:53,992 ask 'em their preference when they're designing a car like hardly ever 1661 01:32:54,252 --> 01:32:55,992 is, my guess is the answer to that. 1662 01:32:56,252 --> 01:32:59,152 I'm sure it happens, but, but like the architectural design process 1663 01:32:59,291 --> 01:33:01,192 is completely different than that. 1664 01:33:01,442 --> 01:33:02,472 Completely different. 1665 01:33:02,812 --> 01:33:08,172 And it, it's interesting to me to kind of see or listen to you talk about 1666 01:33:08,472 --> 01:33:14,342 the experience that, that you've had throughout your career to navigate like 1667 01:33:14,372 --> 01:33:18,222 this really complicated thing called an architectural design P practice. 1668 01:33:18,272 --> 01:33:18,622 Right? 1669 01:33:18,742 --> 01:33:20,142 I mean, and it is a practice. 1670 01:33:20,142 --> 01:33:26,102 It's not, it's not a, it is a project , it is this ongoing, it's not a product. 1671 01:33:26,362 --> 01:33:31,702 It is a project and it, and it is constantly being reevaluated and the 1672 01:33:31,702 --> 01:33:35,942 goalposts are always moving and the people who are in those companies are 1673 01:33:35,942 --> 01:33:38,022 always moving around and it's a, it is a. 1674 01:33:40,272 --> 01:33:44,852 It is just this really interesting kind of, uh, what's the word? 1675 01:33:45,002 --> 01:33:48,532 Organic thing that's just constantly changing all the time. 1676 01:33:49,427 --> 01:33:49,717 Nathan Miller: Yeah. 1677 01:33:49,937 --> 01:33:53,437 And then, you know that, that, and that's at just a singular 1678 01:33:53,877 --> 01:33:54,277 business level. 1679 01:33:54,737 --> 01:34:00,297 And it's, it's even more true as you get out and think about like the larger team 1680 01:34:00,497 --> 01:34:01,697 structure that goes behind a project. 1681 01:34:02,517 --> 01:34:08,577 Um, you know, it's, it's, it's always interesting to me to, for me to 1682 01:34:08,577 --> 01:34:14,197 think about, hey, when a project team finishes a project, The odds of that 1683 01:34:14,197 --> 01:34:18,117 team coming together again in that exact same way to do a project again, 1684 01:34:18,117 --> 01:34:20,717 that's almost identical, is also rare. 1685 01:34:21,457 --> 01:34:25,797 You know, and you have to figure out, okay, how are we adapting to a 1686 01:34:25,797 --> 01:34:27,477 new context with new collaborators? 1687 01:34:27,937 --> 01:34:31,237 It may even be the same client, but you're paired with like a different contractor, 1688 01:34:31,397 --> 01:34:35,597 a different engineering team, and you need to, you need to think, 1689 01:34:35,697 --> 01:34:40,317 you need to figure out tactics that will help you grapple with that. 1690 01:34:40,657 --> 01:34:47,957 And, um, how, how can you take, one of the big questions we, we often ask our 1691 01:34:48,187 --> 01:34:52,916 clients in a strategic, you know, from a strategic perspective is like, how 1692 01:34:52,916 --> 01:34:58,037 do you take what you just finished on one project and mobilize what you've 1693 01:34:58,037 --> 01:34:59,957 learned to support the next one? 1694 01:35:00,977 --> 01:35:06,407 And if you're a firm that has figured that out, I think you are in a position 1695 01:35:07,197 --> 01:35:09,166 that is far better than most. 1696 01:35:09,707 --> 01:35:12,447 Um, I would say you're in the 99th percentile. 1697 01:35:12,467 --> 01:35:17,327 And you, and you, even though, even if that firm itself is not a digital firm, 1698 01:35:18,107 --> 01:35:22,246 you're probably putting yourself by just figuring that one part out, figuring out 1699 01:35:22,246 --> 01:35:25,687 how you're gonna learn from one project to the next and expand and improve. 1700 01:35:26,067 --> 01:35:32,047 You've probably set yourself up to be more of an innovator, um, than any firm 1701 01:35:32,077 --> 01:35:34,647 that has the latest cutting edge tools. 1702 01:35:35,227 --> 01:35:40,407 Um, in my view, you've, you've created a, a, healthy organization that is 1703 01:35:40,477 --> 01:35:45,927 continually trying to learn, um, and that you are naturally going to innovate 1704 01:35:45,947 --> 01:35:48,287 and evolve with technology over time. 1705 01:35:48,987 --> 01:35:55,227 Um, because you've, you've, you've mobilized a very, uh, healthy behavior. 1706 01:35:57,192 --> 01:35:59,472 Evan Troxel: I think that's a perfect place to wrap this one up. 1707 01:35:59,672 --> 01:35:59,791 I, 1708 01:36:00,022 --> 01:36:00,312 I've, 1709 01:36:00,602 --> 01:36:01,272 we've done a lot. 1710 01:36:01,282 --> 01:36:02,272 We've covered a lot here. 1711 01:36:02,452 --> 01:36:07,897 Um, I will include links to everything that you've . Brought up in this 1712 01:36:07,897 --> 01:36:10,577 conversation in the show notes for this episode, which I encourage 1713 01:36:10,577 --> 01:36:13,537 people to read, but if you could just tell everybody where they can 1714 01:36:13,537 --> 01:36:14,937 find you, that would be fantastic. 1715 01:36:15,717 --> 01:36:16,007 Nathan Miller: Sure. 1716 01:36:16,267 --> 01:36:22,327 Um, so I am I am on LinkedIn. 1717 01:36:22,327 --> 01:36:25,127 That's probably the primary place you'll be able to connect with 1718 01:36:25,127 --> 01:36:26,847 me at a, on a professional level. 1719 01:36:27,547 --> 01:36:31,127 Um, so if you search Nathan Miller on LinkedIn, um, I think my title 1720 01:36:31,197 --> 01:36:34,887 says something obtuse like I'm a digital transformation specialist. 1721 01:36:35,027 --> 01:36:43,527 So look for that, um, And then, um, you can also find proving ground on Instagram. 1722 01:36:44,387 --> 01:36:47,527 And then in the, in the show notes, you should, uh, I'll make sure Evan 1723 01:36:47,527 --> 01:36:51,967 here has links to my website or the Proving Ground website, as well as 1724 01:36:52,067 --> 01:36:55,127 the Proving Ground App site where you can try out some of the software. 1725 01:36:55,207 --> 01:36:55,967 I, I've mentioned, 1726 01:36:56,327 --> 01:36:56,937 Evan Troxel: Fantastic. 1727 01:36:57,637 --> 01:36:58,057 Nathan. 1728 01:36:58,117 --> 01:36:58,737 Always a 1729 01:36:58,812 --> 01:36:59,032 Nathan Miller: on. 1730 01:36:59,272 --> 01:37:00,712 I, I was gonna say, I'm also, 1731 01:37:00,972 --> 01:37:01,312 I'm No, 1732 01:37:01,312 --> 01:37:02,232 longer on Twitter or 1733 01:37:02,537 --> 01:37:02,657 Evan Troxel: right. 1734 01:37:03,012 --> 01:37:05,592 Nathan Miller: That's another thing that's changed in the last, since 2020. 1735 01:37:05,752 --> 01:37:09,432 A lot of social media has fallen by the wayside for me and I highly recommend it. 1736 01:37:11,812 --> 01:37:13,032 Evan Troxel: You are on Mastodon. 1737 01:37:13,272 --> 01:37:13,832 I, I've 1738 01:37:13,832 --> 01:37:14,272 connected 1739 01:37:14,412 --> 01:37:15,532 Nathan Miller: a Mastodon great 1740 01:37:15,602 --> 01:37:17,762 Evan Troxel: are we, are any of us really on Mastodon? 1741 01:37:17,902 --> 01:37:18,482 Not that much. 1742 01:37:18,802 --> 01:37:18,962 Probably 1743 01:37:19,682 --> 01:37:20,822 Nathan Miller: and that's the way I like it. 1744 01:37:20,902 --> 01:37:25,142 I like being able to sort of let it sit and I feel like I can just let it sit 1745 01:37:25,282 --> 01:37:27,382 for weeks at a time and then I'll come back to it. 1746 01:37:27,692 --> 01:37:28,302 Mast alone's. 1747 01:37:28,302 --> 01:37:28,462 Great. 1748 01:37:28,842 --> 01:37:29,462 No algorithm. 1749 01:37:29,522 --> 01:37:31,302 Trying to keep me addicted. 1750 01:37:31,442 --> 01:37:31,932 Evan Troxel: awesome. 1751 01:37:32,402 --> 01:37:35,572 Well, Nathan, this is a, a true pleasure always to talk to you, 1752 01:37:35,592 --> 01:37:38,252 and I look forward to hopefully seeing you in the near future. 1753 01:37:38,262 --> 01:37:38,692 We'll see 1754 01:37:38,692 --> 01:37:38,852 what 1755 01:37:38,932 --> 01:37:39,412 Nathan Miller: hope so too. 1756 01:37:39,842 --> 01:37:40,132 Evan Troxel: yeah. 1757 01:37:40,232 --> 01:37:40,652 Nathan Miller: Thanks. 1758 01:37:40,652 --> 01:37:42,652 for having having me on for part two. 1759 01:37:43,182 --> 01:37:43,482 Evan Troxel: All right. 1760 01:37:43,752 --> 01:37:44,242 Anytime.