1 00:00:00,408 --> 00:00:03,528 Evan Troxel: This episode of the TRXL podcast is made possible 2 00:00:03,528 --> 00:00:05,108 with support from ArchIT. 3 00:00:05,495 --> 00:00:08,315 Are you tired of standard IT services that missed the mark. 4 00:00:08,525 --> 00:00:13,955 Choose ArchIT for specialized proactive, IT management, BIM support and robust 5 00:00:13,955 --> 00:00:16,295 data security tailored for architects. 6 00:00:16,595 --> 00:00:20,805 Whether you're a team of 10 or a growing firm of 50+, ArchIT understands 7 00:00:20,825 --> 00:00:24,515 the architecture industry and will empower your unique, creative vision 8 00:00:24,695 --> 00:00:26,705 to enable you to do your best work. 9 00:00:27,015 --> 00:00:31,515 Embrace a technology team that enhances, not hinders, your design process. 10 00:00:31,815 --> 00:00:37,635 Visit GetArchIT.com for your free IT assessment and start transforming your 11 00:00:37,635 --> 00:00:39,855 firm and your tech experience today. 12 00:00:40,185 --> 00:00:44,535 That's GetArchIT.com. 13 00:00:46,230 --> 00:00:48,030 Welcome to the TRXL podcast. 14 00:00:48,150 --> 00:00:49,110 I'm Evan Troxel. 15 00:00:49,500 --> 00:00:54,330 Phil Read is back on today's show to share his insights from his unique career 16 00:00:54,330 --> 00:00:59,040 at the intersection of architecture and technology, which has spanned his history 17 00:00:59,040 --> 00:01:03,780 with Autodesk, his role in reshaping, digital practice, through Revit and 18 00:01:03,780 --> 00:01:09,360 Enscape and his leadership in fostering collaborative innovation through events 19 00:01:09,390 --> 00:01:12,220 like the AEC Acoustics un-conferences. 20 00:01:12,494 --> 00:01:16,664 Today's conversation, which was once again recorded live and in-person with 21 00:01:16,664 --> 00:01:20,624 Phil in the United Lounge at the Denver airport, just like we did last year, 22 00:01:20,984 --> 00:01:25,783 dives into leveraging AI for meaningful work, the importance of curiosity and 23 00:01:25,783 --> 00:01:30,764 play in professional development, building personas for better communication and 24 00:01:30,764 --> 00:01:35,720 storytelling, rethinking architectural documentation workflows, the evolving 25 00:01:35,720 --> 00:01:41,910 role of BIM managers, integrating empathy into design processes, the transformative 26 00:01:41,910 --> 00:01:46,860 power of constraints, and how AI is reshaping client engagement, education, 27 00:01:46,979 --> 00:01:49,080 and personal creativity in architecture. 28 00:01:49,430 --> 00:01:53,390 Recording this in person with Phil reminded me of our first discussions 29 00:01:53,390 --> 00:01:57,650 back in episodes 145 and 146, which I've linked to in the show notes 30 00:01:57,650 --> 00:02:02,000 if you want to catch up and hear Phil's fascinating story in AEC tech. 31 00:02:02,480 --> 00:02:05,240 And before we get into today's conversation, I would very much 32 00:02:05,240 --> 00:02:08,660 appreciate your support of this podcast if it's one of your favorites 33 00:02:08,990 --> 00:02:13,280 by subscribing wherever you watch or listen, and please leave a review 34 00:02:13,310 --> 00:02:15,470 either on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. 35 00:02:15,890 --> 00:02:19,579 You can also support the mission by becoming a paid member at 36 00:02:19,579 --> 00:02:23,840 trxl.co, just click the join button in the lower right hand corner. 37 00:02:24,260 --> 00:02:27,560 And if you'd like to receive emails, when episodes are published with all of 38 00:02:27,560 --> 00:02:32,030 the links and other information, as they come out, sign up for that by becoming 39 00:02:32,030 --> 00:02:35,870 either a free or paid member at trxl.co. 40 00:02:36,350 --> 00:02:40,280 This was a great conversation with Phil and I've got a bunch of follow-up links 41 00:02:40,310 --> 00:02:44,120 in the show notes to hold you over until the next episode of the podcast comes 42 00:02:44,120 --> 00:02:49,970 out, which will start up again in January of 2025, so be sure to check those out. 43 00:02:50,510 --> 00:02:53,570 They are in your podcast app if you're a paid member or if you're a free 44 00:02:53,570 --> 00:02:56,920 member, you can find them at trxl.co. 45 00:02:57,500 --> 00:03:01,610 So now without further ado, I bring you my wide ranging conversation 46 00:03:01,820 --> 00:03:07,160 with the one and only Phil Read to close out the TRXL podcast for 2024. 47 00:03:14,834 --> 00:03:19,594 Phil Read: there's a podcast, there's a Tesla guy in Singapore. 48 00:03:20,254 --> 00:03:24,934 And I have a habit of, if I watch a documentary or see something 49 00:03:24,934 --> 00:03:29,164 interesting on YouTube, I'll just try to connect with that person on LinkedIn. 50 00:03:29,164 --> 00:03:32,174 And, uh, I connected and then. 51 00:03:32,559 --> 00:03:34,009 He said, Yeah, I'm interested. 52 00:03:34,059 --> 00:03:36,459 I'll be coming to Singapore and happy to buy a lunch. 53 00:03:36,459 --> 00:03:37,639 Would like to learn about what you do. 54 00:03:37,929 --> 00:03:41,539 Well, he ended up putting a podcast together and I ended up, 55 00:03:41,589 --> 00:03:42,799 it's out on YouTube somewhere. 56 00:03:44,039 --> 00:03:44,418 Evan Troxel: Nice. 57 00:03:44,499 --> 00:03:45,849 So you've been on a podcast before. 58 00:03:46,539 --> 00:03:48,668 Phil Read: yes, before yours, I'm sorry. 59 00:03:49,519 --> 00:03:53,439 And, uh, yeah, but he talked about the cars and then, uh, we talked 60 00:03:53,439 --> 00:03:58,874 about investing in Tesla and, Well, I thought it was a good investment. 61 00:03:58,904 --> 00:04:04,474 And, um, and then we went out and met the president of the Tesla club in Singapore. 62 00:04:05,024 --> 00:04:05,994 It's not a very big place. 63 00:04:05,994 --> 00:04:08,114 You could drive around the Island in about an hour. 64 00:04:08,644 --> 00:04:13,926 Um, but he had severely modified his car with electric openers and his screen 65 00:04:13,926 --> 00:04:19,060 would swivel and all this kind of stuff that they had prepared light shows and it 66 00:04:19,084 --> 00:04:19,404 Evan Troxel: Nice. 67 00:04:21,034 --> 00:04:21,204 My 68 00:04:21,204 --> 00:04:25,714 son bought Tesla stock and it's up 200 a share from when he bought it. 69 00:04:25,724 --> 00:04:27,034 He's pretty, pretty thrilled. 70 00:04:27,524 --> 00:04:29,534 He's like, he bought 10 shares or something. 71 00:04:29,544 --> 00:04:30,074 He's very 72 00:04:30,379 --> 00:04:30,899 Phil Read: Perfect. 73 00:04:31,329 --> 00:04:36,279 And, um, yeah, when I bought, So the Model Y, and I've never had a new car. 74 00:04:36,429 --> 00:04:39,549 We bought a new minivan, I think around 2004. 75 00:04:40,029 --> 00:04:40,849 But never had a new car. 76 00:04:40,849 --> 00:04:45,739 Bought a, bought a new Model Y Performance, and it's, you know, when 77 00:04:45,739 --> 00:04:47,619 you buy a used car, you just pay for it. 78 00:04:47,629 --> 00:04:48,769 So I've never had a car payment. 79 00:04:49,259 --> 00:04:54,539 And, um, so I thought, nope, the car's gonna devalue, but the stock might go up. 80 00:04:54,539 --> 00:04:56,949 So I took the money that I would have paid for the car in cash and 81 00:04:56,949 --> 00:04:59,459 just put into Tesla stock, and that was in around the middle of 82 00:04:59,459 --> 00:05:01,379 April, which just was fortuitous. 83 00:05:02,084 --> 00:05:05,724 And I think it's because of the ecosystem that they have. 84 00:05:05,724 --> 00:05:11,074 It's not just the, um, it's not a car, it's an iPad with wheels. 85 00:05:11,134 --> 00:05:11,394 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 86 00:05:12,134 --> 00:05:16,274 Phil Read: And so that ecosystem of we were, as we were chatting before, instead 87 00:05:16,274 --> 00:05:20,214 of hiring just a bunch of developers to try to figure out full self driving, 88 00:05:20,934 --> 00:05:24,324 he's effectively crowdsourced full self driving with how people behave when they 89 00:05:24,663 --> 00:05:25,436 Evan Troxel: able to 90 00:05:26,104 --> 00:05:29,504 Phil Read: And, uh, that's pretty interesting ecosystem. 91 00:05:29,514 --> 00:05:32,459 So the car that you don't drive, Probably talked about this last time. 92 00:05:33,049 --> 00:05:36,379 The TV you don't watch, the phone you don't answer, Those are 93 00:05:36,379 --> 00:05:39,749 usually orders of magnitude very successful technologies. 94 00:05:39,749 --> 00:05:40,769 We started, I think. 95 00:05:41,139 --> 00:05:41,369 Yeah. 96 00:05:41,489 --> 00:05:41,839 Okay. 97 00:05:41,939 --> 00:05:42,189 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 98 00:05:42,475 --> 00:05:43,345 Little did we know. 99 00:05:43,422 --> 00:05:44,835 Phil Read: We're back where we were last time. 100 00:05:44,992 --> 00:05:45,392 Evan Troxel: That's right. 101 00:05:45,392 --> 00:05:45,602 Yeah. 102 00:05:45,602 --> 00:05:45,802 What? 103 00:05:45,812 --> 00:05:46,142 Yeah. 104 00:05:46,202 --> 00:05:46,752 Where are we? 105 00:05:46,882 --> 00:05:46,922 Phil Read: we? 106 00:05:46,922 --> 00:05:49,222 Gate 44, Concourse B, Denver. 107 00:05:49,442 --> 00:05:50,262 Evan Troxel: Denver airport. 108 00:05:50,362 --> 00:05:50,862 That's right. 109 00:05:50,892 --> 00:05:52,822 Phil Read: Yeah, but this way we get breakfast and lunch and we get 110 00:05:52,822 --> 00:05:54,512 to chat about all kinds of things. 111 00:05:55,382 --> 00:05:57,022 Yeah, in person. 112 00:05:57,182 --> 00:05:57,462 That's, 113 00:05:57,487 --> 00:05:58,097 Evan Troxel: Well, thank you for 114 00:05:58,142 --> 00:05:59,862 Phil Read: an important part of it. 115 00:05:59,912 --> 00:06:01,958 Otherwise it feels transactional or something. 116 00:06:02,512 --> 00:06:04,992 Evan Troxel: So you talked about that in terms of leverage, right? 117 00:06:05,022 --> 00:06:07,682 And I just think that's kind of interesting when you put that in the 118 00:06:07,682 --> 00:06:10,202 context of our industry, too, right? 119 00:06:10,202 --> 00:06:14,612 Like looking for places where there's opportunities to use that leverage that 120 00:06:14,612 --> 00:06:18,062 were maybe unforeseen or, Do you think that was all planned out in advance, 121 00:06:18,062 --> 00:06:21,892 this whole idea of crowdsourcing training, and then being able to use 122 00:06:21,892 --> 00:06:27,992 that to help build this infrastructure that really has It's, to me, like 123 00:06:27,992 --> 00:06:31,612 the analogy I think of is like the overnight ten year long success, right? 124 00:06:31,612 --> 00:06:33,442 It's like the overnight success that actually 125 00:06:33,607 --> 00:06:34,937 Phil Read: Oh, it looks obvious now. 126 00:06:34,947 --> 00:06:35,079 Yeah, 127 00:06:35,192 --> 00:06:37,952 Evan Troxel: right, and it's like, well, no, it wasn't obvious back 128 00:06:37,952 --> 00:06:42,052 then, it was a bet, and It paid off. 129 00:06:42,052 --> 00:06:43,972 But there's lots of bets that didn't pay off too. 130 00:06:43,987 --> 00:06:46,847 Phil Read: No, the idea that in the future we'll just use everybody 131 00:06:46,847 --> 00:06:48,517 to program our technologies. 132 00:06:48,557 --> 00:06:49,817 Like, that just sounds too 133 00:06:50,062 --> 00:06:50,542 Evan Troxel: absurd. 134 00:06:50,602 --> 00:06:51,592 That's an absurd idea. 135 00:06:51,652 --> 00:06:51,892 Right. 136 00:06:52,337 --> 00:06:54,307 Phil Read: But in a way that's what they did. 137 00:06:54,317 --> 00:06:57,127 They built the infrastructure that trained the system. 138 00:06:57,577 --> 00:07:01,157 So the infrastructure in terms of physical electrification, 139 00:07:01,167 --> 00:07:02,127 you got to be able to charge. 140 00:07:02,127 --> 00:07:03,597 So I think that's why they've been successful. 141 00:07:03,597 --> 00:07:06,707 And yesterday was when, yesterday was GM's announcement that they're 142 00:07:06,707 --> 00:07:12,617 going to get out of the commercial automation driving business. 143 00:07:12,767 --> 00:07:15,137 So Tesla stock has shot up a bit more today, right? 144 00:07:15,137 --> 00:07:17,227 It's like 415 a share. 145 00:07:17,247 --> 00:07:19,547 And I think in April it was 450 a share. 146 00:07:20,857 --> 00:07:25,377 Um, but I don't think it's because he's making cars, I think it's because they're 147 00:07:25,377 --> 00:07:29,938 creating an ecosystem for people that don't want to or don't have to drive. 148 00:07:30,072 --> 00:07:30,563 Evan Troxel: mm-hmm 149 00:07:30,997 --> 00:07:33,277 Phil Read: And so it's that, it's the sum of the parts. 150 00:07:33,287 --> 00:07:37,272 So they've crowdsourced behavior of how people behave when they drive. 151 00:07:37,872 --> 00:07:40,942 and in edge conditions of weird turning constraints. 152 00:07:40,942 --> 00:07:42,702 And like right now three 13. 153 00:07:42,802 --> 00:07:46,282 2 is out and I don't have it yet, but apparently you can, you don't 154 00:07:46,282 --> 00:07:49,052 have to put the car into drive and then start full self driving. 155 00:07:49,052 --> 00:07:54,342 You put in your destination and select go and it'll back itself out of a parking 156 00:07:54,342 --> 00:07:56,432 lot or out of a constrained parking space. 157 00:07:56,432 --> 00:07:59,322 And then it will start to go where it wants to go. 158 00:08:00,452 --> 00:08:00,622 And 159 00:08:00,622 --> 00:08:01,182 I found it. 160 00:08:01,997 --> 00:08:04,277 Even on short trips from the, from Charlotte to the 161 00:08:04,277 --> 00:08:07,287 coast, enormously relaxing. 162 00:08:08,292 --> 00:08:09,222 To let the car do its 163 00:08:09,347 --> 00:08:10,767 Evan Troxel: But it took a while for you to get there, 164 00:08:10,782 --> 00:08:11,414 Phil Read: Yeah, yeah, yeah. 165 00:08:11,617 --> 00:08:12,617 Evan Troxel: just didn't start out 166 00:08:12,642 --> 00:08:14,952 Phil Read: No, it's like getting a teenager to drive and you're trying to 167 00:08:15,107 --> 00:08:15,977 Evan Troxel: I'm right there with 168 00:08:16,122 --> 00:08:18,612 Phil Read: wanna fall asleep and you're just like, every time there's 169 00:08:18,612 --> 00:08:19,962 another car you're kind of ready to 170 00:08:20,137 --> 00:08:23,947 Evan Troxel: I'm, I feel so weird not having a parking brake in the middle of 171 00:08:23,957 --> 00:08:27,657 the car that we're using for driver's training, like that I had, my parents 172 00:08:27,657 --> 00:08:30,517 had when I was a kid, it was like ripped that they could just rip that thing up 173 00:08:30,517 --> 00:08:33,297 at any moment because they don't have their own set of pedals on their side. 174 00:08:34,126 --> 00:08:35,157 They can grab the wheel. 175 00:08:35,376 --> 00:08:39,110 But, Now with the push button park brake, it's like I'm not just going to push 176 00:08:39,110 --> 00:08:41,190 that button when we're full driving. 177 00:08:41,190 --> 00:08:41,409 Right. 178 00:08:41,440 --> 00:08:44,960 And so like that level of trust, you have to build up 179 00:08:45,340 --> 00:08:46,880 Phil Read: It's so smooth now. 180 00:08:46,930 --> 00:08:50,540 Early on, like in December with the system that they had, when it would go around 181 00:08:50,540 --> 00:08:54,130 a corner, sometimes it would hesitate and it would take, it wasn't smooth. 182 00:08:54,420 --> 00:08:57,740 It was a little, it was like a teenager, like an experienced teenager like, 183 00:08:57,760 --> 00:08:59,270 turn straight, turn straight, turn 184 00:08:59,320 --> 00:09:00,670 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 185 00:09:00,705 --> 00:09:05,525 Phil Read: Yeah, overcorrect on and um, but now I've had to, it 186 00:09:05,525 --> 00:09:08,875 got so good and there's different modes under self driving. 187 00:09:08,875 --> 00:09:12,545 There's like a hurry mode, a regular mode and a chill mode 188 00:09:12,725 --> 00:09:16,555 because the acceleration, even a regular mode, I find too aggressive. 189 00:09:17,025 --> 00:09:20,385 So if a teenager was driving and you go, Whoa, slow down, don't, 190 00:09:20,805 --> 00:09:23,135 when the light turns green, you don't have to be right off the line. 191 00:09:23,135 --> 00:09:23,295 It's 192 00:09:23,334 --> 00:09:23,555 Evan Troxel: way. 193 00:09:23,935 --> 00:09:23,995 Deactivate 194 00:09:24,115 --> 00:09:26,795 Phil Read: So it's in chill mode, but it still accelerates 195 00:09:26,795 --> 00:09:28,255 in a very confident fashion. 196 00:09:29,185 --> 00:09:29,625 I'm. 197 00:09:30,290 --> 00:09:35,350 At the point where if I was doing a trip where you might actually sleep and 198 00:09:35,390 --> 00:09:37,350 confidently, you know, get on the road, 199 00:09:38,690 --> 00:09:41,480 Put your seat back a little bit, like getting on a plane today, right? 200 00:09:41,510 --> 00:09:46,640 I drive, I'm flying in from Charlotte, took off and pulled my hat over 201 00:09:46,640 --> 00:09:49,680 my eyes, leaned the seat back and went to sleep for 45 minutes. 202 00:09:50,285 --> 00:09:53,735 But in a car, you just, you know, sometimes you're driving, 203 00:09:53,735 --> 00:09:54,675 you're not paying attention, 204 00:09:54,845 --> 00:09:55,975 Evan Troxel: Yeah, never 205 00:09:56,675 --> 00:09:57,045 Phil Read: right? 206 00:09:57,075 --> 00:10:00,835 And that's scary when you get noddy and your heads, your eyes are kind of 207 00:10:00,835 --> 00:10:02,065 dropping, your head's dropping down. 208 00:10:02,065 --> 00:10:03,295 You're like, I should just pull over. 209 00:10:03,525 --> 00:10:06,885 I think in this case, it'll be, it'll be better than having a teenager 210 00:10:06,885 --> 00:10:08,095 drive and you'll be confident. 211 00:10:08,105 --> 00:10:12,235 You're just kind of put your seat back for five, 10 minutes and then wake up. 212 00:10:12,795 --> 00:10:13,855 Evan Troxel: you're seeing the future. 213 00:10:13,885 --> 00:10:16,135 Like you can already see where this is going, right? 214 00:10:16,155 --> 00:10:17,105 The next steps are. 215 00:10:17,115 --> 00:10:18,435 Phil Read: I mean, that's where I think it's going to go. 216 00:10:18,435 --> 00:10:18,905 It's just. 217 00:10:19,213 --> 00:10:20,583 that's what people will enjoy. 218 00:10:20,893 --> 00:10:21,203 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 219 00:10:21,973 --> 00:10:25,003 Phil Read: Like we were, when we were talking before about the time 220 00:10:25,003 --> 00:10:28,783 it takes to travel somewhere, there's really no competition, at least in 221 00:10:28,783 --> 00:10:32,713 the US with air travel for, let's say 500 mile distances that you 222 00:10:32,713 --> 00:10:34,523 just got to get the trains aren't. 223 00:10:35,278 --> 00:10:37,608 Maybe in the Northeast Corridor, they're predictable enough, 224 00:10:38,183 --> 00:10:40,167 Evan Troxel: go to the location you want to 225 00:10:40,278 --> 00:10:41,498 Phil Read: no, it's not point to point, right? 226 00:10:41,498 --> 00:10:43,778 So when you get there, you still have to get in a, so you're two 227 00:10:43,778 --> 00:10:45,168 hours before the airport, but I think 228 00:10:45,515 --> 00:10:47,125 with driving that that's confident. 229 00:10:47,135 --> 00:10:50,375 One of the constraints, and I was chatting with Brock Howard, actually we were 230 00:10:50,375 --> 00:10:55,465 texting, as I was flying, we're texting back and forth over the internet and the 231 00:10:55,465 --> 00:11:00,855 plane, Brock's in Athens, Georgia, and only one of the constraints of private 232 00:11:00,895 --> 00:11:03,315 vehicles is they take up so much space. 233 00:11:03,950 --> 00:11:06,580 Because of the distance you have to maintain when you're 234 00:11:06,580 --> 00:11:08,570 driving on the highway, right? 235 00:11:08,570 --> 00:11:10,470 You're sort of a hundred feet between cars. 236 00:11:10,510 --> 00:11:10,910 What is it? 237 00:11:10,910 --> 00:11:12,400 10 car lengths or something like that. 238 00:11:12,780 --> 00:11:14,400 You're going 60, 70 miles an hour. 239 00:11:15,020 --> 00:11:17,690 Um, but not a NASCAR. 240 00:11:17,690 --> 00:11:20,630 In NASCAR, they drive nose to tail at 200 miles an hour. 241 00:11:20,630 --> 00:11:23,810 And I could see if, if you could get into a convoy mode, like full 242 00:11:23,810 --> 00:11:25,470 self driving, that's the next step. 243 00:11:26,755 --> 00:11:27,375 And you 244 00:11:27,775 --> 00:11:28,815 Evan Troxel: travel in packs, 245 00:11:28,945 --> 00:11:31,705 Phil Read: you travel in, you know, nose to tail, three feet apart, and they're 246 00:11:31,705 --> 00:11:33,175 all communicating with each other. 247 00:11:33,205 --> 00:11:35,795 And that special lane goes a hundred plus miles an hour. 248 00:11:36,415 --> 00:11:40,434 Well, that starts to compete with air travel and trains and it's point to point. 249 00:11:40,434 --> 00:11:44,604 Cause I tell you it's so quiet and I have conference calls in the car, you 250 00:11:44,604 --> 00:11:48,344 know, self driving's on and I'm paying attention to the road, but I'm also 251 00:11:48,344 --> 00:11:49,644 paying attention to the conversation. 252 00:11:49,644 --> 00:11:50,954 It's very relaxing. 253 00:11:50,954 --> 00:11:53,534 So, yeah, I think he's, uh, I think that, 254 00:11:53,684 --> 00:11:54,154 that, 255 00:11:55,964 --> 00:11:59,664 it's not the car, it's not a car, it's, I keep referring to it as 256 00:11:59,664 --> 00:12:02,164 an iPad with, an iPad with wheels. 257 00:12:02,824 --> 00:12:03,524 It's a, um, 258 00:12:06,149 --> 00:12:07,049 It's not a car. 259 00:12:07,049 --> 00:12:08,149 I don't know what to call it yet. 260 00:12:08,409 --> 00:12:09,929 Well, maybe it's an automobile. 261 00:12:09,969 --> 00:12:12,589 We've always called them automobiles, but they weren't auto. 262 00:12:13,499 --> 00:12:13,979 Well, that's right. 263 00:12:13,989 --> 00:12:17,659 Rich people have always, and we've talked about that before, very wealthy people 264 00:12:17,669 --> 00:12:19,959 have always had these kinds of things. 265 00:12:21,389 --> 00:12:25,349 The car that drives itself, but it was a chauffeur, or the person that 266 00:12:25,349 --> 00:12:30,138 wrote things down for you, which was the stenographer, or the scribe, 267 00:12:30,579 --> 00:12:32,734 Evan Troxel: Your, your entertainment was the jester, right? 268 00:12:33,259 --> 00:12:37,752 Phil Read: Yeah, and the, um, the king that would have, the advisor. 269 00:12:38,209 --> 00:12:41,069 And now this is coming down to common people. 270 00:12:41,199 --> 00:12:44,379 Like, I mean, down to a common person. 271 00:12:44,379 --> 00:12:45,369 Evan Troxel: democratization. 272 00:12:45,369 --> 00:12:45,639 Yeah. 273 00:12:45,839 --> 00:12:47,649 Phil Read: Oh, in an extraordinary way. 274 00:12:47,739 --> 00:12:50,979 Like, I wouldn't feel comfortable personally driving 100 miles an hour. 275 00:12:51,399 --> 00:12:52,779 Evan Troxel: you would gain that comfort over time. 276 00:12:52,779 --> 00:12:53,114 That might be 277 00:12:53,449 --> 00:12:56,239 Phil Read: You know, over time, but things happen fast. 278 00:12:56,789 --> 00:13:02,839 And, um, I, I went fast once in the Tesla for the first time to pass a car. 279 00:13:03,354 --> 00:13:06,864 And it was just one lane in each direction, but I made the mistake of doing 280 00:13:06,864 --> 00:13:13,494 what I would normally do in a regular car, which is mash the gas and then indicate 281 00:13:13,604 --> 00:13:16,494 and get in the other, you know, get in the passing lane and then pull back over. 282 00:13:17,010 --> 00:13:20,840 but when I went to pull over in the passing lane, I almost went off 283 00:13:20,850 --> 00:13:22,320 the road because it was happening. 284 00:13:22,320 --> 00:13:23,620 So things were happening so 285 00:13:23,680 --> 00:13:26,020 Evan Troxel: vector, yeah, like physics, whoosh, just 286 00:13:26,020 --> 00:13:27,900 Phil Read: It's not the zero to 60. 287 00:13:28,560 --> 00:13:29,260 That's fast. 288 00:13:29,260 --> 00:13:30,490 It's the 40 to 100. 289 00:13:31,270 --> 00:13:32,720 It's the same three seconds. 290 00:13:32,780 --> 00:13:37,230 And so you have to learn to go slow and in a regular aspirated car. 291 00:13:37,790 --> 00:13:38,170 Yeah. 292 00:13:38,200 --> 00:13:39,450 Cause things happen so 293 00:13:39,800 --> 00:13:40,221 Evan Troxel: yeah. 294 00:13:40,221 --> 00:13:40,570 Things 295 00:13:40,905 --> 00:13:45,505 Phil Read: Um, but these kinds of, uh, these kinds of tools that the very 296 00:13:45,505 --> 00:13:48,625 wealthy have had, like the kinds of things that kings have had, let's say, 297 00:13:48,625 --> 00:13:50,915 in the last thousand, two thousand years. 298 00:13:51,115 --> 00:13:54,535 You know, the Roman emperor didn't drive his own chariot, okay? 299 00:13:54,825 --> 00:13:55,765 He had someone drive his chariot. 300 00:13:56,195 --> 00:13:59,885 Now it's coming down to, I think, common people, and we were talking about AI 301 00:13:59,895 --> 00:14:06,002 before in terms of being conversational, or the car that drives itself, or 302 00:14:06,845 --> 00:14:10,600 I think in, um Well, certainly in transportation, in personal 303 00:14:10,600 --> 00:14:14,230 transportation, the idea of getting in a car, getting up early, relaxing. 304 00:14:14,230 --> 00:14:16,840 I don't have to be at the airport and fight elbows in traffic. 305 00:14:16,927 --> 00:14:20,457 You get in the car and you drink your coffee and you open the newspaper or 306 00:14:20,457 --> 00:14:21,657 you open the internet on your phone. 307 00:14:21,657 --> 00:14:24,387 You start reading the day's news and the car is doing itself. 308 00:14:24,387 --> 00:14:25,417 I'd feel very comfortable. 309 00:14:25,417 --> 00:14:29,805 I've been in cars where, um, I was with, uh, Christian Lange, who is the former 310 00:14:29,805 --> 00:14:34,035 CEO of Enscape, and we were in Germany, and we were driving to the airport, and 311 00:14:34,035 --> 00:14:37,045 on the Autobahn, and he was confidently driving well over 100 miles an hour. 312 00:14:37,055 --> 00:14:38,035 He has an electric Porsche. 313 00:14:38,185 --> 00:14:39,455 I felt completely raxed. 314 00:14:40,585 --> 00:14:43,475 So, if I could have that kind of confidence in a personal vehicle, 315 00:14:43,635 --> 00:14:47,085 okay, 100 miles, it's not the speed, it's the abrupt starts 316 00:14:47,085 --> 00:14:47,895 and stops that'll get you there. 317 00:14:48,255 --> 00:14:48,635 Hurt you. 318 00:14:48,870 --> 00:14:49,340 Evan Troxel: right. 319 00:14:50,880 --> 00:14:51,790 Momentum kills. 320 00:14:51,815 --> 00:14:52,725 Phil Read: That's right, right, right, right, 321 00:14:52,830 --> 00:14:53,780 Evan Troxel: you stop it too quickly. 322 00:14:53,825 --> 00:14:54,325 Phil Read: That's right. 323 00:14:54,325 --> 00:14:54,615 Right. 324 00:14:54,965 --> 00:14:59,135 So if it, if it was confident and you're in, and you've overcome the artifact of 325 00:14:59,135 --> 00:15:02,575 having to have the separation because of the speed, because you're driving, 326 00:15:02,625 --> 00:15:06,715 you know, manually, no, it's making the adjustments and cars are five feet apart 327 00:15:06,715 --> 00:15:08,005 and they're communicating to each other. 328 00:15:08,005 --> 00:15:10,655 Then you could travel very quickly from point to point. 329 00:15:11,007 --> 00:15:14,387 but the, Taking that into what we're talking about in, in AI is, 330 00:15:14,397 --> 00:15:19,577 is, I know it's an over discussed, at least in architecture, right? 331 00:15:19,577 --> 00:15:23,017 You can't open LinkedIn without seeing another rendering tool that some kind of 332 00:15:23,027 --> 00:15:27,147 AI tool, but it's not been that lately. 333 00:15:27,667 --> 00:15:31,227 Lately, it's the most trivial things. 334 00:15:32,917 --> 00:15:37,027 You're asking it questions that, normally, if you had a very learned person next 335 00:15:37,027 --> 00:15:40,937 to you in the car, and you'd ask a question, Well, tell me about this, and 336 00:15:40,937 --> 00:15:42,517 it would give you all this information. 337 00:15:43,246 --> 00:15:48,106 in the latest iOS, it will answer your initial question with Siri, and then 338 00:15:48,116 --> 00:15:52,099 it will go, Would you like me to answer that with, uh, what is it, ChatGPT? 339 00:15:52,182 --> 00:15:57,002 now it stopped, or in the early versions, it would call it ChatGPT, but they've 340 00:15:57,002 --> 00:15:59,222 gotten rid of that, and it's like, Would you like me to answer that with 341 00:15:59,522 --> 00:16:00,342 Evan Troxel: full release, that's a 342 00:16:00,472 --> 00:16:03,442 Phil Read: Yeah, so I'm driving back from the coast yesterday, and I came 343 00:16:03,442 --> 00:16:07,312 through a small town that all of a sudden had these artifacts of, at one time in 344 00:16:07,312 --> 00:16:08,572 history, it was a very affluent town. 345 00:16:08,887 --> 00:16:11,077 location, but it was in the middle of nowhere. 346 00:16:11,427 --> 00:16:13,667 So I just said, Hey, Siri, tell me about this town. 347 00:16:13,957 --> 00:16:17,357 And it went to this long soliloquy about the history of this town and when 348 00:16:17,357 --> 00:16:19,507 it was established in the early 1700s. 349 00:16:19,777 --> 00:16:22,525 And it was like, in the moment, knowledge that 350 00:16:22,525 --> 00:16:24,805 Evan Troxel: It was like your own personal tour guide, like when you 351 00:16:24,805 --> 00:16:29,465 rent, you go to Alcatraz, and you get the headset, and you go to the stops, 352 00:16:29,465 --> 00:16:33,955 and it tells you as you're there, just in time, kind of an idea of, 353 00:16:34,155 --> 00:16:34,575 Phil Read: Yeah, while 354 00:16:34,695 --> 00:16:38,235 Evan Troxel: access to information while you're looking at it, not, oh, I'm gonna 355 00:16:38,235 --> 00:16:42,675 go look that up later, I better put a bookmark on this, or save it to my notes 356 00:16:42,765 --> 00:16:42,855 Phil Read: Yeah. 357 00:16:42,855 --> 00:16:44,625 I need to go look that up in a library. 358 00:16:44,625 --> 00:16:48,595 so that's where I think it, I've kind of been interested in the AI 359 00:16:48,595 --> 00:16:53,515 piece here and there, but mostly it seems to be automating bad processes. 360 00:16:54,325 --> 00:16:55,885 It's automating inefficiency. 361 00:16:57,165 --> 00:17:01,665 This next generation seems to just be giving you orders of magnitude more 362 00:17:01,665 --> 00:17:03,495 useful information with very little input. 363 00:17:05,550 --> 00:17:10,589 So there's some tools out there that would automate documentation with AI. 364 00:17:11,040 --> 00:17:13,730 Like here's my document set, tag and dimension things. 365 00:17:14,240 --> 00:17:18,119 And I think that's kind of a, that's kind of an example of automating 366 00:17:18,119 --> 00:17:20,819 inefficiency because otherwise you have to have somebody do it. 367 00:17:21,281 --> 00:17:21,902 So one of the, 368 00:17:22,002 --> 00:17:25,502 one of the, things we were talking about before was, um, schedules. 369 00:17:26,541 --> 00:17:28,249 Okay, so Revit will 370 00:17:28,249 --> 00:17:31,549 continually count things as you work, but you have to create this schedule and you 371 00:17:31,549 --> 00:17:33,499 have to order the fields and you have to, 372 00:17:33,889 --> 00:17:35,749 there's a lot of curation that goes into that. 373 00:17:35,994 --> 00:17:38,074 Evan Troxel: it's the coordination is insane, right? 374 00:17:38,114 --> 00:17:38,794 But to really 375 00:17:38,799 --> 00:17:41,349 Phil Read: do it, it coordinates it, but you have to set it up so 376 00:17:41,364 --> 00:17:44,884 Evan Troxel: still need an expert, though, to review it and actually 377 00:17:44,914 --> 00:17:46,914 coordinate the hinges and the lock sets. 378 00:17:46,914 --> 00:17:51,534 And the door schedule is one thing, openings, locations, right? 379 00:17:51,534 --> 00:17:52,244 What kind of door? 380 00:17:52,474 --> 00:17:53,624 Is it a one hour door? 381 00:17:53,624 --> 00:17:56,254 Whatever those things are, 90 minute, right? 382 00:17:56,254 --> 00:17:57,544 Does it have fire glass in it? 383 00:17:57,784 --> 00:17:59,934 But then there's like the whole hardware end of things. 384 00:17:59,954 --> 00:18:00,404 And it's. 385 00:18:00,839 --> 00:18:04,689 a dedicated consultant typically for that kind of a thing, So I tell the 386 00:18:04,689 --> 00:18:08,469 story about, about what you did with GROK that, that kind of led to that 387 00:18:08,749 --> 00:18:09,749 Phil Read: yeah, that led to it. 388 00:18:09,749 --> 00:18:13,789 So Brock Howard and I, Brock and Grok, Brock's texting me and I'm on 389 00:18:13,789 --> 00:18:16,279 this airplane and I thought, well, this is kind of an obscure thing, 390 00:18:16,699 --> 00:18:18,089 but, and it's, and it's on Twitter. 391 00:18:18,089 --> 00:18:23,969 I took a photo at this beach show that was this week in South Carolina of one 392 00:18:23,969 --> 00:18:27,876 of the vendors and they had a table full of, preserved alligator heads. 393 00:18:28,601 --> 00:18:29,561 Alligator jerky. 394 00:18:29,621 --> 00:18:32,431 It was like one of the things they're trying to sell to beach shops, right? 395 00:18:32,431 --> 00:18:36,631 So, and I took a photo and I thought, I wonder if Grok would know what this is. 396 00:18:36,641 --> 00:18:41,601 So I asked Grok to estimate the retail cost of everything in the photo and 397 00:18:41,601 --> 00:18:45,431 I'm on the internet in a plane and in about five seconds it started 398 00:18:45,441 --> 00:18:49,141 giving me responses and estimate like counting things, quantifying things. 399 00:18:49,537 --> 00:18:52,877 I was just dumbstruck by that, like that's a very common question and 400 00:18:52,877 --> 00:18:54,327 it cost me nothing to get an answer. 401 00:18:54,327 --> 00:18:57,077 Well, I suppose I subscribe to the, whatever, premium. 402 00:18:58,242 --> 00:18:59,462 X or something like that. 403 00:19:00,032 --> 00:19:00,322 So 404 00:19:00,487 --> 00:19:02,617 Evan Troxel: That is, it's basically, you experience like 405 00:19:02,617 --> 00:19:04,177 a magic moment right there. 406 00:19:04,187 --> 00:19:04,777 It's like, what? 407 00:19:05,337 --> 00:19:06,357 It can do that? 408 00:19:06,897 --> 00:19:10,097 Because that, that then leads back to this door schedule example, 409 00:19:10,252 --> 00:19:10,672 Phil Read: Well, yeah. 410 00:19:10,672 --> 00:19:12,342 What if we're not making schedules? 411 00:19:12,342 --> 00:19:15,842 Like that was the leap of going from that was, okay, wait a minute. 412 00:19:15,902 --> 00:19:18,302 I've got a set of drawings and I'm 413 00:19:18,302 --> 00:19:21,242 going to submit a set of drawings to AI and say, can you just give me a bill 414 00:19:21,242 --> 00:19:25,316 of materials and pricing, from Home Depot for everything in this project? 415 00:19:26,511 --> 00:19:26,701 Like, 416 00:19:26,701 --> 00:19:28,421 you don't even have to make schedules for that. 417 00:19:28,521 --> 00:19:32,391 Evan Troxel: You just send it a, an image or a series of images or a model. 418 00:19:32,391 --> 00:19:37,001 I, I, it would be amazing if you can actually have a fully tagged BIM 419 00:19:37,381 --> 00:19:38,941 Phil Read: And that's a whole leapfrog to me. 420 00:19:38,941 --> 00:19:42,161 That's the part that, you know, on the way here this morning, as you 421 00:19:42,531 --> 00:19:45,371 kind of have time to ideate, you're just sitting on a plane doing nothing. 422 00:19:45,961 --> 00:19:49,746 But the idea that you could take a photo of a chair And I, I actually, 423 00:19:49,856 --> 00:19:51,236 I did this last week in Wilmington. 424 00:19:51,236 --> 00:19:54,636 I was going through a tour of a distillery that had cool leather furniture. 425 00:19:54,896 --> 00:19:58,732 I took a photo of one of the chairs and using a Google image search, 426 00:19:58,922 --> 00:20:00,022 it said, Oh, here's the chair. 427 00:20:00,022 --> 00:20:00,872 Here's how much it costs. 428 00:20:00,872 --> 00:20:02,142 And you can buy it at Home Depot. 429 00:20:02,162 --> 00:20:04,312 And it's like, what Home Depot doesn't sell this furniture. 430 00:20:04,342 --> 00:20:07,022 Well, they sell lots of things that you can't buy in the 431 00:20:07,042 --> 00:20:08,782 Evan Troxel: in their quote unquote showroom, right? 432 00:20:10,062 --> 00:20:10,942 But they're online. 433 00:20:11,367 --> 00:20:15,697 Phil Read: but normally the step would be, Oh, we're going to start a company 434 00:20:15,717 --> 00:20:20,967 to build a tool that connects your Revit file with Lowe's or Home Depot. 435 00:20:20,967 --> 00:20:21,147 And 436 00:20:21,267 --> 00:20:22,157 Evan Troxel: With your pro account, 437 00:20:22,347 --> 00:20:24,457 Phil Read: yeah, with, and then you're going to buy this thing. 438 00:20:24,457 --> 00:20:27,937 So it's gone to a price point of almost zero and no one's 439 00:20:27,957 --> 00:20:29,377 built a tool in between it. 440 00:20:29,377 --> 00:20:30,337 It's not like they built 441 00:20:31,637 --> 00:20:35,347 the manual version, certainly there, but they didn't build a better manual version. 442 00:20:35,347 --> 00:20:40,037 And now it's been usurped by some other agent, AI. 443 00:20:40,587 --> 00:20:41,577 It's just leapfrog. 444 00:20:41,597 --> 00:20:42,727 It just went straight there. 445 00:20:43,397 --> 00:20:48,227 And, um, so for me, that's, that's kind of like a, a really important 446 00:20:48,227 --> 00:20:49,527 and interesting inflection point. 447 00:20:49,594 --> 00:20:51,074 It's trivial. 448 00:20:51,354 --> 00:20:53,934 And you were talking about having a conversation. 449 00:20:54,304 --> 00:21:00,114 Evan Troxel: so, so I was in, at AU, um, on my way back from AU, I rented a 450 00:21:00,114 --> 00:21:05,134 car and my first stop was at a, a photo shoot for a architectural project that 451 00:21:05,134 --> 00:21:09,124 my friend was the designer of, and the photographer was there, and he, we, we 452 00:21:09,124 --> 00:21:11,974 had, we had seen each other recently, but not that recently, and he said, have 453 00:21:11,974 --> 00:21:14,054 you ever had a conversation with ChatGPT? 454 00:21:15,124 --> 00:21:16,934 And I'm like, well, I've asked it questions. 455 00:21:17,034 --> 00:21:17,094 Yeah. 456 00:21:17,329 --> 00:21:17,849 Phil Read: I never needed. 457 00:21:18,594 --> 00:21:20,614 Evan Troxel: So, so question and answer, is that what you mean? 458 00:21:20,614 --> 00:21:25,064 And he's like, no, like, like he goes on the way down here, which is about an 459 00:21:25,064 --> 00:21:29,404 hour and a half drive, he said, I had a full on conversation with ChatGPT. 460 00:21:31,124 --> 00:21:33,864 And he said, it blew my mind. 461 00:21:33,934 --> 00:21:35,284 He said, you have to try it. 462 00:21:35,314 --> 00:21:39,964 And I had an hour long drive coming up to Palm Springs from there. 463 00:21:40,044 --> 00:21:45,264 And so, in my car, in the car, rental car, through CarPlay, Um, I fired 464 00:21:45,274 --> 00:21:49,194 up and I think you have to have a plus account for ChatGPT to do this. 465 00:21:49,204 --> 00:21:50,344 It's 20 bucks a month. 466 00:21:50,814 --> 00:21:55,234 so you get the advanced voice mode that they teased, you know, months ago, it 467 00:21:55,234 --> 00:21:58,024 finally came out, it took a while for it to finally come out, but now that 468 00:21:58,024 --> 00:22:01,694 it's out, uh, it is very conversational and it will interrupt you and you can 469 00:22:01,694 --> 00:22:06,404 interrupt it and it will, if you get disconnected along the way, when you 470 00:22:06,404 --> 00:22:08,994 get a signal back again, it'll say, it looks like we got disconnected. 471 00:22:08,994 --> 00:22:10,124 Let's pick up where we left off. 472 00:22:10,134 --> 00:22:10,854 So it, it just. 473 00:22:11,354 --> 00:22:14,164 maintains continuity with this conversation. 474 00:22:15,134 --> 00:22:19,124 And I was throwing this idea at it. 475 00:22:19,294 --> 00:22:23,074 And I had just been tumbling this idea around in my own head, not really 476 00:22:23,074 --> 00:22:26,494 coming to any conclusions, but I thought, Oh, I'll try this out with it. 477 00:22:26,504 --> 00:22:29,874 And so I asked it some, I told it what I was thinking about doing. 478 00:22:29,874 --> 00:22:32,744 And it was, of course, it was very excited about this idea. 479 00:22:33,124 --> 00:22:35,964 Um, but, but, you know, this is, let's explore this. 480 00:22:36,144 --> 00:22:38,264 I said, okay, well, where should we start? 481 00:22:38,614 --> 00:22:42,344 And it said, well, let's start with, and then it, it basically took me through 482 00:22:42,344 --> 00:22:46,454 this whole process and it asked me questions that everybody who's thinking 483 00:22:46,454 --> 00:22:51,534 about pursuing an idea would eventually, it would come across your plate. 484 00:22:51,624 --> 00:22:57,401 All of these questions would, but in the span of 45 minutes, it sparked ideas that 485 00:22:57,411 --> 00:23:02,271 would not have been sparked otherwise, because I didn't do this with a person. 486 00:23:02,421 --> 00:23:04,721 I think this could lead us to other interesting places in the 487 00:23:04,952 --> 00:23:05,226 Phil Read: conversation. 488 00:23:05,226 --> 00:23:08,076 Could you have a conversation with another person and the agent? 489 00:23:08,076 --> 00:23:10,056 Do you think that would work with two people? 490 00:23:10,271 --> 00:23:11,111 Evan Troxel: That's a good question. 491 00:23:11,471 --> 00:23:12,401 I would think so. 492 00:23:12,421 --> 00:23:13,531 I don't see why not. 493 00:23:15,091 --> 00:23:17,256 Phil Read: And does it gives you responses in audio? 494 00:23:17,491 --> 00:23:19,071 Evan Troxel: Audio and, in real time, yeah. 495 00:23:19,956 --> 00:23:21,366 Phil Read: We should do another one of these where 496 00:23:21,451 --> 00:23:22,491 Evan Troxel: Oh, a full podcast, 497 00:23:23,706 --> 00:23:24,576 Phil Read: Yeah. 498 00:23:25,461 --> 00:23:26,601 Evan Troxel: We would probably want a quieter 499 00:23:26,756 --> 00:23:28,736 Phil Read: I wouldn't have, I didn't think about that this morning when I woke 500 00:23:28,851 --> 00:23:29,261 Evan Troxel: Right. 501 00:23:29,996 --> 00:23:31,016 Phil Read: let's do a podcast with an 502 00:23:31,241 --> 00:23:31,941 Evan Troxel: With an agent. 503 00:23:31,941 --> 00:23:32,201 Yeah. 504 00:23:32,521 --> 00:23:37,419 So, so It asked me questions and it forced me to think about things. 505 00:23:37,469 --> 00:23:40,619 And you don't even feel confident in your answer, right? 506 00:23:40,619 --> 00:23:42,369 Because it's spur of the moment. 507 00:23:42,439 --> 00:23:45,909 It's just whatever is there you have to work with. 508 00:23:46,479 --> 00:23:48,839 And of course you could say, you know, let me think about that for a 509 00:23:48,839 --> 00:23:49,909 little bit and I'll get back to you. 510 00:23:49,909 --> 00:23:51,309 I, I assume you could do that. 511 00:23:51,319 --> 00:23:54,249 But, I tried to just stay in the moment and I tried to do the best I 512 00:23:54,249 --> 00:23:56,029 could with what it was asking of me. 513 00:23:56,029 --> 00:23:58,739 Phil Read: it hard to be present when you were having this conversation? 514 00:23:59,139 --> 00:24:00,489 Evan Troxel: it was a normal conversation. 515 00:24:01,254 --> 00:24:02,074 It would, it would be 516 00:24:02,129 --> 00:24:03,519 Phil Read: You didn't have to suspend disbelief. 517 00:24:03,519 --> 00:24:04,089 You were just like, 518 00:24:04,214 --> 00:24:06,564 Evan Troxel: would be like being on this podcast and I went into 519 00:24:06,564 --> 00:24:10,214 it with the expectation that it was going to blow my mind, right? 520 00:24:10,214 --> 00:24:12,094 Because my friend had kind of prompted me with that. 521 00:24:12,094 --> 00:24:14,064 And I thought, okay, I'm, I'm here for this. 522 00:24:14,434 --> 00:24:17,207 And so I did that and I I didn't think twice about it. 523 00:24:17,347 --> 00:24:19,997 I just thought, you know, there were several times where I thought, oh, 524 00:24:19,997 --> 00:24:22,707 this, this answer is going to suck, but I'm going to say it anyway. 525 00:24:23,547 --> 00:24:27,797 And it forced me to think about, think through things I'll say. 526 00:24:27,857 --> 00:24:29,267 And then at the end. 527 00:24:30,307 --> 00:24:32,727 I said, okay, now can you give me a summary of this conversation and give 528 00:24:32,727 --> 00:24:34,307 me some action items to pursue next? 529 00:24:34,307 --> 00:24:34,857 And it said, yep. 530 00:24:35,027 --> 00:24:38,297 And it said, anytime you want to come back and pursue this conversation 531 00:24:38,307 --> 00:24:39,807 further, I'm here and ready for 532 00:24:39,817 --> 00:24:39,867 Phil Read: that. 533 00:24:40,487 --> 00:24:40,927 Evan Troxel: Right. 534 00:24:41,227 --> 00:24:46,047 And, and, and because of the way ChatGPT works, right, it's got every query that 535 00:24:46,047 --> 00:24:48,327 you've asked it is a separate entry. 536 00:24:48,387 --> 00:24:53,867 And so you can go back and pick up on any one of those threads and continue it on. 537 00:24:53,867 --> 00:24:54,867 And this is no different. 538 00:24:54,867 --> 00:24:56,597 This is just one of those threads. 539 00:24:56,877 --> 00:24:58,927 And so they're each in their own little buckets. 540 00:24:59,367 --> 00:25:03,237 Um, and so you really could have as many of these different threads 541 00:25:03,237 --> 00:25:05,647 and they're not really going to cross pollinate with each other. 542 00:25:06,297 --> 00:25:07,637 I don't, maybe you, maybe you want it 543 00:25:07,692 --> 00:25:09,012 Phil Read: is not like a Google image. 544 00:25:09,072 --> 00:25:11,292 This is not like a Google search, right, from 20 years 545 00:25:11,487 --> 00:25:12,177 Evan Troxel: not at all. 546 00:25:12,472 --> 00:25:16,479 Phil Read: And, um, I've only started playing with this probably at, uh, since 547 00:25:16,499 --> 00:25:22,519 the fall retreat, because I realized, you Uh, I'm using the public, I was using 548 00:25:22,519 --> 00:25:28,859 the private version of the Apple beta, and then there's, it was getting too 549 00:25:28,859 --> 00:25:33,759 squirrely, I went back and dropped back to a, to the public beta, and realized that 550 00:25:33,759 --> 00:25:36,059 you could upload images and ask questions. 551 00:25:36,309 --> 00:25:40,049 And I think, I don't know if it was somebody at the leadership retreat, or 552 00:25:40,049 --> 00:25:41,789 maybe, I think it was Craig Barbieri. 553 00:25:42,494 --> 00:25:46,824 took a photo and then asked, oh, it was how to create a text prompt. 554 00:25:46,944 --> 00:25:49,534 So sometimes you can create a text prompt by, okay, how do I 555 00:25:49,534 --> 00:25:51,104 describe this thing in my head? 556 00:25:51,444 --> 00:25:55,504 Or if you take a photo of something, ask it to describe the material and 557 00:25:55,504 --> 00:25:58,374 then use that material as a text prompt and then say, okay, I want a 558 00:25:58,374 --> 00:26:00,861 seamless texture from that description. 559 00:26:00,861 --> 00:26:04,401 works better than taking the photograph and trying to massage it in Photoshop 560 00:26:04,411 --> 00:26:05,774 so it looks like a seamless texture. 561 00:26:05,774 --> 00:26:09,004 So I was like, Oh, you can submit a photo and ask it to describe it. 562 00:26:09,034 --> 00:26:14,174 So I, I took a photo of the kitchen at the cottage and, and, uh, ask it 563 00:26:14,184 --> 00:26:19,154 to, describe the design as, uh, you know, sort of pro and con terms. 564 00:26:19,694 --> 00:26:23,784 And, uh, I, I got a description sort of a modern kitchen design. 565 00:26:24,214 --> 00:26:28,814 And then I asked it to describe the design and the persona of Steve Jobs. 566 00:26:29,674 --> 00:26:34,569 And it said some pretty nice things about the design and the 567 00:26:34,569 --> 00:26:36,179 utility of it and the clean lines. 568 00:26:36,179 --> 00:26:38,409 But then it also said there was nothing really innovative about it. 569 00:26:39,949 --> 00:26:40,699 Evan Troxel: personality. 570 00:26:40,699 --> 00:26:40,759 So 571 00:26:40,789 --> 00:26:42,959 Phil Read: sent it to a friend of mine, who's a contractor. 572 00:26:42,959 --> 00:26:44,589 He was an architect turned contractor. 573 00:26:44,879 --> 00:26:47,399 And he's like, Oh my gosh, I would hate for this to happen, 574 00:26:47,469 --> 00:26:48,999 uh, to review my design work. 575 00:26:48,999 --> 00:26:52,649 And he sent me a photo of a mountain house that he'd worked on in North Carolina. 576 00:26:53,069 --> 00:26:55,939 And it was fully dressed out and a project. 577 00:26:55,949 --> 00:26:58,859 And the table had a very colorful and. 578 00:26:59,434 --> 00:27:02,774 Uh, sort of festive place settings on it, and I guess they had set 579 00:27:02,774 --> 00:27:05,334 everything up and then taken photos of the finished mountain house. 580 00:27:05,844 --> 00:27:12,614 And I asked, I submitted that picture to ChatGPT, and asked for a pro and con of 581 00:27:12,614 --> 00:27:16,924 the design, and the pros would come in the persona of Martha Stewart, and the cons 582 00:27:16,924 --> 00:27:19,034 would come in the persona of Steve Jobs. 583 00:27:19,494 --> 00:27:24,864 And boy, did Steve Jobs savage the design, and then, and I, I sent 584 00:27:24,924 --> 00:27:26,224 Evan Troxel: Martha was complimentary. 585 00:27:26,224 --> 00:27:26,354 Martha 586 00:27:26,384 --> 00:27:28,954 Phil Read: thought the colors and the place settings was lovely and 587 00:27:28,954 --> 00:27:32,494 complimentary to the rustic, you know, and then Steve Jobs was like, 588 00:27:32,584 --> 00:27:34,464 busy, busy, busy, this is terrible. 589 00:27:35,104 --> 00:27:37,124 You know, how much noise, clutter, yeah. 590 00:27:37,734 --> 00:27:41,444 So I sent it to an architectural friend of mine and, uh, in Charlotte, 591 00:27:41,744 --> 00:27:44,674 and he said, man, this would have been great in architecture school 592 00:27:44,674 --> 00:27:48,754 to be able to take photos of your design and then ask for feedback. 593 00:27:49,016 --> 00:27:52,216 of the design, you know, without waiting until a Monday morning crit. 594 00:27:52,491 --> 00:27:56,671 but getting kind of experienced feedback from personas. 595 00:27:57,014 --> 00:27:58,644 and then it's not like a Google search. 596 00:27:58,694 --> 00:27:59,974 It's not transactional. 597 00:27:59,994 --> 00:28:01,054 It's interactive. 598 00:28:01,334 --> 00:28:06,134 And I think this is going to have profound implications around healthcare. 599 00:28:06,494 --> 00:28:10,734 Certainly, I think in, in terms of psychology, of someone who's going 600 00:28:10,734 --> 00:28:14,284 through grief or a difficult time to be able to have a conversation. 601 00:28:14,584 --> 00:28:17,974 And, and certainly in psychology, there's a broad range of 602 00:28:18,544 --> 00:28:19,844 quote unquote, right answers. 603 00:28:20,184 --> 00:28:20,914 Um, I like. 604 00:28:21,256 --> 00:28:24,039 An psychologist, author named Viktor Frankl. 605 00:28:24,139 --> 00:28:27,289 He, if you want to look up a book called Man's Search for Meaning, he 606 00:28:27,289 --> 00:28:32,959 was a psychologist and ended up not fleeing Germany when he could have 607 00:28:32,969 --> 00:28:37,759 before the war and then ended up in Auschwitz and survived and then wrote 608 00:28:37,759 --> 00:28:42,319 about what kept him wanting to live. 609 00:28:42,319 --> 00:28:47,019 And then later on he created a, uh, style of counseling called Logotherapy, 610 00:28:47,432 --> 00:28:52,252 so I have an a, sort of an affection to that style of, of, of, uh, I don't 611 00:28:52,252 --> 00:28:53,742 know what you call it, psychologist. 612 00:28:53,972 --> 00:28:58,952 So to be able to have a conversation in the moment when you're troubled by 613 00:28:58,952 --> 00:29:05,882 something, but you want the responses to be in the persona of Viktor or St. 614 00:29:05,882 --> 00:29:06,512 Augustine. 615 00:29:10,872 --> 00:29:11,642 Evan Troxel: their framework 616 00:29:11,872 --> 00:29:13,502 Phil Read: if you could really talk to him now, you're. 617 00:29:13,907 --> 00:29:19,007 I think in, in a simplification, you're talking to a carbon based version of AI, 618 00:29:19,017 --> 00:29:23,187 that's Viktor Frankl, well, he's passed, you can't, and he certainly doesn't scale. 619 00:29:23,507 --> 00:29:27,487 Viktor, if he were alive, he could talk to one person at a time for 55 minutes, 620 00:29:27,487 --> 00:29:33,017 and, you know, so, imagine any modern day psychologist that you would have an 621 00:29:33,017 --> 00:29:36,887 affinity for, what would this person say about this particular issue, or I would 622 00:29:36,887 --> 00:29:39,962 like to talk to, a persona of this person. 623 00:29:40,492 --> 00:29:44,382 And, um, cause history is certainly full of, of, of philosophers, you 624 00:29:44,382 --> 00:29:50,262 know, to be able to talk about a modern stressful issue in the, with the persona 625 00:29:50,272 --> 00:29:56,012 of Marcus Aurelius in context with his meditations, like to me, that's profound. 626 00:29:56,817 --> 00:29:58,087 And you can still talk to other people. 627 00:29:58,772 --> 00:30:00,332 But how it's going to impact 628 00:30:00,347 --> 00:30:02,282 Evan Troxel: you might have to wait, like you said, until next Wednesday at 629 00:30:02,702 --> 00:30:05,212 Phil Read: yeah, next Thursday and it's 300 an hour. 630 00:30:05,212 --> 00:30:05,562 And, 631 00:30:07,102 --> 00:30:10,052 and I think generally speaking, men don't like to talk about, 632 00:30:10,392 --> 00:30:11,482 we like to solve problems. 633 00:30:11,482 --> 00:30:13,772 And so we tend not to talk about the things that are troubling 634 00:30:13,772 --> 00:30:18,072 us because they're maybe they're unsolvable in the moment. 635 00:30:18,092 --> 00:30:19,442 There's not one right answer. 636 00:30:19,887 --> 00:30:21,277 So being able to 637 00:30:22,437 --> 00:30:22,757 talk 638 00:30:22,757 --> 00:30:28,047 to someone or something in a way that it's reflective, it's in the 639 00:30:28,047 --> 00:30:31,617 moment, so it's very needs based, and the cost, the price point is zero. 640 00:30:32,247 --> 00:30:36,188 Evan Troxel: do you think this impacts, that sounds stupid to 641 00:30:36,188 --> 00:30:38,068 even say, how does this impact AEC? 642 00:30:38,238 --> 00:30:42,968 Like, so, so one of the things that I, mean, I, I do want to bring it 643 00:30:42,988 --> 00:30:48,028 back to that, Context for the podcast, but at the same time, it's, um, 644 00:30:48,088 --> 00:30:48,958 Phil Read: is it too constrained? 645 00:30:49,928 --> 00:30:50,718 Evan Troxel: trite, right? 646 00:30:50,728 --> 00:30:52,328 It just sounds like, oh, really? 647 00:30:52,328 --> 00:30:53,108 We're going to talk about this? 648 00:30:53,108 --> 00:30:57,168 But the ideas are, you're talking about schedules, right? 649 00:30:57,168 --> 00:31:01,308 You're talking about mundane stuff that we're still, like, literally showing 650 00:31:01,308 --> 00:31:03,418 up to fight with every single day. 651 00:31:03,648 --> 00:31:06,608 And getting wrong, making a lot of mistakes. 652 00:31:06,938 --> 00:31:11,368 Um, and I think about how long it took to even transition from 653 00:31:12,668 --> 00:31:16,378 Drafts people to CAD managers, to BIM managers, or technicians. 654 00:31:16,828 --> 00:31:21,628 And, and now, like, to me it seems like, well, we don't, we, BIM 655 00:31:21,628 --> 00:31:24,068 managers is old, like that's tired. 656 00:31:24,078 --> 00:31:24,968 What's wired, right? 657 00:31:25,268 --> 00:31:26,148 AI managers. 658 00:31:26,158 --> 00:31:31,958 Like, why don't we, why don't firms have, why aren't they like, you're seeing, going 659 00:31:31,958 --> 00:31:36,688 back to the Tesla example, like you see the future, you can, you can taste it. 660 00:31:37,188 --> 00:31:37,498 Right. 661 00:31:37,528 --> 00:31:39,118 It's right there. 662 00:31:39,538 --> 00:31:40,398 And it's so 663 00:31:40,483 --> 00:31:41,823 Phil Read: I'm so ready to sleep in the car. 664 00:31:41,838 --> 00:31:42,488 Evan Troxel: It's yeah. 665 00:31:42,708 --> 00:31:48,408 It's so obvious that this is going to happen in some timeframe that 666 00:31:48,418 --> 00:31:51,578 you can't not expect it to happen. 667 00:31:51,968 --> 00:31:52,518 And yet. 668 00:31:52,533 --> 00:31:56,673 I mean, the same thing goes for a lot of things, right, in AEC and 669 00:31:56,683 --> 00:32:01,963 in tech, and we are, you know, we are so slow to adopt this stuff. 670 00:32:02,536 --> 00:32:04,178 Phil Read: So I think, yeah, I think some of it is. 671 00:32:05,558 --> 00:32:06,943 so a lot of times working with customers. 672 00:32:07,888 --> 00:32:08,888 or just other people. 673 00:32:08,888 --> 00:32:11,338 You don't know, there's so many good ways to do things. 674 00:32:11,618 --> 00:32:13,688 There's so many products of function as you design. 675 00:32:13,698 --> 00:32:16,468 Like you can, you can say, the stairs can't go here because of a 676 00:32:16,468 --> 00:32:19,988 functional reason, but there's so many great places to put the stairs. 677 00:32:20,378 --> 00:32:23,898 But the client, the customer is going to have a particular affinity 678 00:32:23,928 --> 00:32:25,348 towards how things are arranged. 679 00:32:25,838 --> 00:32:31,818 And I think one of the areas AI is this client, the idea of this client's 680 00:32:31,838 --> 00:32:35,458 persona, of using your client's persona as you're designing in the moment. 681 00:32:35,993 --> 00:32:39,823 To kind of reflect and interact with the design 682 00:32:40,627 --> 00:32:44,147 with, with some confidence that when you do meet every other week, you're 683 00:32:44,147 --> 00:32:45,802 going to be on a vector that's correct. 684 00:32:46,577 --> 00:32:49,427 And, um, there's a couple of tools. 685 00:32:50,173 --> 00:32:53,883 Not that create, they don't create client personas, but they'll, uh, 686 00:32:53,903 --> 00:32:57,823 they create, uh, potentially customer or employer, employee personas. 687 00:32:58,183 --> 00:33:01,043 And I mentioned it to you before, it's called Humantic AI. 688 00:33:01,363 --> 00:33:05,163 And it plugs into Twitter, and it plugs into, the same subscription plugs into 689 00:33:05,163 --> 00:33:06,743 Twitter, and it plugs into LinkedIn. 690 00:33:07,413 --> 00:33:12,578 And it will scrape someone's profile, and based on their profile, LinkedIn 691 00:33:12,588 --> 00:33:17,778 profile, it will give you a vector based upon how they will respond if 692 00:33:17,778 --> 00:33:21,068 you're trying to sell them something or if you're trying to employ them. 693 00:33:21,868 --> 00:33:24,278 So basically you're trying to convince them to change their behavior 694 00:33:24,278 --> 00:33:25,738 or to behave in a certain way. 695 00:33:26,138 --> 00:33:32,233 Right, I want you to spend money and, and uh, So, I've used that with great 696 00:33:32,513 --> 00:33:38,793 success, Humantic AI, now the, the bigger step of, of talking with a persona 697 00:33:39,840 --> 00:33:44,030 to critique or to give feedback or to have a conversation in the moment about 698 00:33:44,030 --> 00:33:47,740 a certain design, a design direction that you could go, it's how many times 699 00:33:47,740 --> 00:33:51,960 have we worked for a couple of weeks and you have to come up with options 700 00:33:51,975 --> 00:33:53,325 Evan Troxel: Two steps forward, one step 701 00:33:53,550 --> 00:33:55,930 Phil Read: yeah, and then you meet with the customer and, and you have 702 00:33:55,930 --> 00:33:57,730 to change direction again or there's 703 00:33:58,930 --> 00:34:02,320 You want to work with confidence and the customer can't meet with you 704 00:34:02,320 --> 00:34:05,510 every afternoon at, you know, it's their, their time is constrained. 705 00:34:05,675 --> 00:34:06,845 Evan Troxel: or maybe they want to and you can't 706 00:34:07,680 --> 00:34:11,400 Phil Read: So, and the persona could be not just, you know, one 707 00:34:11,400 --> 00:34:16,270 customer, but say you're designing a residence for an entire family. 708 00:34:16,300 --> 00:34:20,020 How will the family respond to You know, you're going to get a very, how much 709 00:34:20,020 --> 00:34:21,949 will it cost and what does it look like? 710 00:34:22,745 --> 00:34:27,915 those kinds of impacts to AI I think will be profound, like just being 711 00:34:27,915 --> 00:34:30,875 able to interact with a persona of someone with some confidence. 712 00:34:30,935 --> 00:34:34,455 Try it sometime, take a photo of a space and ask it to describe the 713 00:34:34,455 --> 00:34:38,335 space and critique the space in the persona of someone alive or dead. 714 00:34:39,074 --> 00:34:42,745 And, I don't know if the answers are completely correct, uh, 715 00:34:42,764 --> 00:34:44,054 but they seem to be on vector. 716 00:34:44,405 --> 00:34:46,505 And it's just curious, if you had, if I gave you an assignment 717 00:34:46,570 --> 00:34:47,690 Evan Troxel: Entertaining, if nothing 718 00:34:47,875 --> 00:34:50,679 Phil Read: yeah, yeah, Evan, write, Write a description of this space and 719 00:34:50,679 --> 00:34:52,405 critique it as if you were Martha Stewart. 720 00:34:53,940 --> 00:34:55,083 Evan Troxel: It's a fun, it's 721 00:34:55,320 --> 00:34:57,060 Phil Read: It's a, yeah, it's a, yeah, yeah. 722 00:34:57,610 --> 00:35:03,160 And, um, so that part of it, I think from an education standpoint, from a business 723 00:35:03,160 --> 00:35:10,680 standpoint, being able to interact with, uh, a persona, a client's persona, or 724 00:35:10,680 --> 00:35:14,510 even a, man, if you knew the, the people that were going to be on a jury, and you 725 00:35:14,510 --> 00:35:17,110 could take all of their personas of, and 726 00:35:17,140 --> 00:35:20,270 Evan Troxel: You create a feedback loop that's totally proactive, 727 00:35:20,470 --> 00:35:20,830 Phil Read: Hmm. 728 00:35:21,830 --> 00:35:24,730 Evan Troxel: Because you're not waiting for that event to actually happen, and you 729 00:35:24,730 --> 00:35:26,230 might go in there in a better position. 730 00:35:26,250 --> 00:35:27,820 I would hope you would go into it. 731 00:35:28,690 --> 00:35:29,280 when it really 732 00:35:29,570 --> 00:35:35,370 Phil Read: firms employ psychologists to try to predict how the jury 733 00:35:35,370 --> 00:35:37,680 is going to respond to a design. 734 00:35:37,920 --> 00:35:41,590 Certainly it happens in the legal space where you try to predict how jury members, 735 00:35:41,980 --> 00:35:45,580 right, when they're going through the process of selecting jury members, they 736 00:35:45,580 --> 00:35:49,740 employ psychologists to try to pick the jurors that will have an affinity 737 00:35:49,740 --> 00:35:51,430 towards their approach to the, to 738 00:35:51,490 --> 00:35:51,650 Evan Troxel: case. 739 00:35:51,655 --> 00:35:51,835 Yeah. 740 00:35:51,835 --> 00:35:52,495 To, yeah. 741 00:35:52,780 --> 00:35:54,560 Phil Read: Do we do that in our, do we know, I don't know any 742 00:35:54,580 --> 00:35:56,400 architecture firms that employ 743 00:35:57,115 --> 00:36:00,925 Evan Troxel: The example I can think of is employing psychologists to use 744 00:36:00,925 --> 00:36:05,245 research as a foundation for why they make decisions the way that they do. 745 00:36:05,335 --> 00:36:09,655 You know, when it comes to like healthcare space design, co uses of color theory 746 00:36:09,685 --> 00:36:11,455 in design, things like that, where. 747 00:36:12,430 --> 00:36:16,100 They do have psychological effects on healing, for example, right? 748 00:36:16,110 --> 00:36:20,760 So, um, and then, and then they can point at their researcher and say, like, this 749 00:36:20,770 --> 00:36:24,560 is our expert, this is our subject matter expert, and here's, and, and here's why 750 00:36:24,560 --> 00:36:28,890 we're making these decisions like this, and here's why you should go along with 751 00:36:28,890 --> 00:36:31,090 it, or choose us, even, as an example. 752 00:36:31,090 --> 00:36:35,600 So, they, they do things like that, but I don't think in the way that you're 753 00:36:35,620 --> 00:36:38,900 talking about it, not that I know of. 754 00:36:40,005 --> 00:36:43,695 Phil Read: Yeah, like, create personas of everyone that's gonna be on the jury, and 755 00:36:43,695 --> 00:36:47,395 what subtle, sociological, psychological, 756 00:36:47,730 --> 00:36:50,970 Evan Troxel: You're making a business case, right, for, I mean, 757 00:36:50,980 --> 00:36:52,090 you're talking about winning work. 758 00:36:52,380 --> 00:36:53,210 Yeah, yeah. 759 00:36:54,225 --> 00:36:54,645 Phil Read: Yep. 760 00:36:54,975 --> 00:36:55,215 Yeah. 761 00:36:55,215 --> 00:36:58,305 So check out Humantic AI and then use it on yourself. 762 00:36:58,375 --> 00:37:02,415 I think the free version, you could do a couple of, uh, uh, test runs and 763 00:37:02,415 --> 00:37:04,725 then it's like trivially expensive. 764 00:37:04,735 --> 00:37:05,885 It's not expensive at all. 765 00:37:06,060 --> 00:37:08,370 Evan Troxel: So you did that, you did that on yourself and you 766 00:37:08,535 --> 00:37:11,035 Phil Read: Like if I, if someone was trying to sell something to me or 767 00:37:11,035 --> 00:37:15,805 if they were trying to employ me and some of the edge conditions for around 768 00:37:15,805 --> 00:37:22,172 employment were, um, Whether or not the person would, if they would respond 769 00:37:22,242 --> 00:37:26,772 to a job opening that was aspirational and ill defined, or did they need to 770 00:37:26,772 --> 00:37:31,902 have very specific definitions with their, with what would be the metrics 771 00:37:31,902 --> 00:37:34,942 to, um, for their success in the job. 772 00:37:34,942 --> 00:37:37,492 And some people you can say, hey, just come on board, it's going 773 00:37:37,492 --> 00:37:38,922 to be great, we'll figure it out. 774 00:37:39,102 --> 00:37:41,482 We don't know what we're going to do, you're going to help us figure it out. 775 00:37:41,672 --> 00:37:47,207 And that's very aspirational and some people haven't They will have an affinity 776 00:37:47,207 --> 00:37:51,427 to that ambiguity and others will run, you know, screaming the other direction. 777 00:37:51,492 --> 00:37:55,842 Evan Troxel: in, it's then in your, your approach to talk to them, knowing 778 00:37:56,082 --> 00:37:58,182 what ways will connect with them. 779 00:37:58,272 --> 00:37:59,772 You can modify your 780 00:38:00,432 --> 00:38:02,892 approach to meet them where they're 781 00:38:03,078 --> 00:38:09,007 Phil Read: you're trying to sell to this type of personality, 782 00:38:09,037 --> 00:38:10,537 don't go into story mode. 783 00:38:11,297 --> 00:38:15,837 deal with facts and figures and how their competition is using it to get ahead. 784 00:38:15,847 --> 00:38:17,877 And they'll want to know data. 785 00:38:18,307 --> 00:38:22,007 And even it will, it will tell you, uh, in, in sort of a, if you're pitching, 786 00:38:22,007 --> 00:38:25,747 if you're sales pitching to someone, um, don't expect a decision, that 787 00:38:25,747 --> 00:38:27,287 person's not going to make a decision. 788 00:38:27,287 --> 00:38:29,787 They're going to have to go back to their company and build consensus. 789 00:38:29,787 --> 00:38:33,377 It'll be a long sales cycle and it's scraping this from their LinkedIn 790 00:38:34,647 --> 00:38:37,097 Evan Troxel: So let's go back to the leadership retreat and, and your 791 00:38:37,297 --> 00:38:38,307 Phil Read: Oh, you went to it. 792 00:38:38,317 --> 00:38:38,687 How was 793 00:38:38,777 --> 00:38:42,327 Evan Troxel: Well, well, before, before we talk about what it was like, we, 794 00:38:42,387 --> 00:38:45,617 we did, we did that already on the podcast when Adam and you were here. 795 00:38:45,617 --> 00:38:46,407 But, but the. 796 00:38:46,727 --> 00:38:48,067 Here's, here's what I want to talk about. 797 00:38:48,743 --> 00:38:53,803 We, we talked about BIM managers, not being that they're really 798 00:38:53,803 --> 00:38:55,253 technically oriented, right? 799 00:38:55,263 --> 00:38:58,313 Not, not just BIM managers, but people on the tech side of architecture 800 00:38:58,313 --> 00:39:02,213 being really technically oriented, maybe not used to leading teams. 801 00:39:02,253 --> 00:39:02,693 Right. 802 00:39:03,333 --> 00:39:04,513 And that's a big transition. 803 00:39:04,523 --> 00:39:06,993 That's a huge threshold of change 804 00:39:07,088 --> 00:39:08,963 Phil Read: You're dealing with emotions instead of facts, 805 00:39:09,373 --> 00:39:14,113 Evan Troxel: and, and, but, but, but then plugging this context in with this, this 806 00:39:14,403 --> 00:39:18,763 humanized tool that you're talking about, right, and knowing your audience, right, 807 00:39:18,783 --> 00:39:24,393 using, because this is about communication style and approach to get the desired 808 00:39:24,423 --> 00:39:25,883 outcome that you're looking for. 809 00:39:25,883 --> 00:39:27,303 So there's a business case for that. 810 00:39:27,313 --> 00:39:30,863 But there's also, you know, to me, this is about like internal projects 811 00:39:30,863 --> 00:39:33,733 as it is about winning outside work. 812 00:39:34,113 --> 00:39:34,333 Phil Read: finding 813 00:39:34,968 --> 00:39:37,828 Evan Troxel: You are innovating in your firm or you're coming up 814 00:39:37,828 --> 00:39:41,118 with a new workflow or you want to make a different tool purchase. 815 00:39:41,138 --> 00:39:44,538 I'm just trying to, I want to give people tools to think are different 816 00:39:44,538 --> 00:39:49,488 ways to think about these kinds of tools that you're talking about, because I 817 00:39:49,488 --> 00:39:55,668 think there's a personal aspect to this too, that it can be leveraged for to, 818 00:39:56,203 --> 00:39:59,803 Communicate in the right style that it will land with the person who is your 819 00:39:59,803 --> 00:40:04,213 audience to move this goal forward, right? 820 00:40:04,213 --> 00:40:05,983 I think that there's something there, 821 00:40:06,343 --> 00:40:06,703 Phil Read: So the 822 00:40:07,735 --> 00:40:12,585 It's not uncommon for BIM managers, self included, to live in the potential 823 00:40:12,695 --> 00:40:14,115 and to be inside that bubble a lot. 824 00:40:14,145 --> 00:40:19,122 And things are, technology is so obviously advantageous to us. 825 00:40:19,162 --> 00:40:22,002 Oh, we shouldn't spend money to do this thing, but you 826 00:40:22,002 --> 00:40:23,392 have to convince higher ups. 827 00:40:23,772 --> 00:40:27,522 And one of the more recent conversations I had with the technology 828 00:40:27,522 --> 00:40:31,142 director, almost out of the blue, can I talk to you about something? 829 00:40:31,562 --> 00:40:34,362 And yes, pick up the phone and we're chatting and they're, 830 00:40:35,237 --> 00:40:36,327 Completely frustrated. 831 00:40:36,407 --> 00:40:41,877 They want to do this certain thing, and his question, uh, was, How do 832 00:40:41,877 --> 00:40:44,347 I convince my boss that I'm right? 833 00:40:45,290 --> 00:40:46,240 Jesus, what an open 834 00:40:46,273 --> 00:40:47,270 Evan Troxel: an open 835 00:40:47,610 --> 00:40:49,630 Phil Read: And, um, well, what are you trying to do? 836 00:40:49,640 --> 00:40:50,740 Have you run the numbers? 837 00:40:50,750 --> 00:40:54,610 Have you figured out that the cost of the technology is trivial, but now 838 00:40:54,610 --> 00:40:56,660 you're going to have to train people, and you're going to have to change 839 00:40:56,660 --> 00:40:58,380 behavior, and what if it doesn't work out? 840 00:40:58,800 --> 00:41:01,630 Um, and I'm trying to go through the conversation. 841 00:41:01,630 --> 00:41:04,280 I said, have you offered to resign if this doesn't work out? 842 00:41:05,087 --> 00:41:06,972 Evan Troxel: would I do that? 843 00:41:06,972 --> 00:41:07,448 I'm 844 00:41:07,625 --> 00:41:08,195 Phil Read: Why would I 845 00:41:08,402 --> 00:41:09,915 Evan Troxel: die on this sword. 846 00:41:10,305 --> 00:41:10,955 Phil Read: a lot of money. 847 00:41:10,955 --> 00:41:13,355 And if it doesn't work out, what's your trajectory? 848 00:41:13,365 --> 00:41:17,035 Like they don't, you're, you're, you're, I think the problem is, I think what 849 00:41:17,035 --> 00:41:20,525 I mentioned to this person, I said, you're trying, you haven't built trust. 850 00:41:21,375 --> 00:41:23,585 They trust you to manage the technology, but not to manage 851 00:41:23,585 --> 00:41:26,495 the business for a BIM manager. 852 00:41:26,935 --> 00:41:31,225 Who's, you know, I think we're also a little bit all on spectrum to have 853 00:41:31,225 --> 00:41:32,805 a conversation with the chat GPT. 854 00:41:32,930 --> 00:41:37,770 and go, hey, I'm trying to talk to my director about doing this thing 855 00:41:38,280 --> 00:41:42,603 and they're just not listening to I wouldn't spend 300 an hour 856 00:41:42,603 --> 00:41:43,953 with a psychologist to this. 857 00:41:43,993 --> 00:41:47,303 I might buy lunch or breakfast for someone and go, how would you manage this? 858 00:41:47,378 --> 00:41:50,218 Evan Troxel: How, yeah, well, and I would ask you, and you would come 859 00:41:50,218 --> 00:41:51,798 back with your experience, right? 860 00:41:51,818 --> 00:41:54,568 But, but, at the same time, like, you're saying that this, 861 00:41:55,078 --> 00:41:56,288 this thing exists where you 862 00:41:56,523 --> 00:41:59,933 Phil Read: They're on the way to the office, 30 minute drive, in traffic, 863 00:41:59,933 --> 00:42:05,253 frustrated because they were just told yesterday, no, you're not going 864 00:42:05,253 --> 00:42:06,163 to, we're not going to do that. 865 00:42:06,398 --> 00:42:06,833 Evan Troxel: Right. 866 00:42:07,243 --> 00:42:08,283 Phil Read: And so you want to vent. 867 00:42:08,940 --> 00:42:10,100 you just want to know why. 868 00:42:10,490 --> 00:42:12,700 And having something go, oh, have you thought about this? 869 00:42:12,710 --> 00:42:16,527 Have you thought about this other It's not even a tool that helps 870 00:42:16,527 --> 00:42:19,857 you design better buildings, it's just a tool to help you deal with, 871 00:42:19,977 --> 00:42:22,317 Evan Troxel: Or whatever problems or challenges you're 872 00:42:22,327 --> 00:42:22,877 Phil Read: with people. 873 00:42:22,977 --> 00:42:25,587 Yeah, the emotions of that, because I think we get locked in our heads, 874 00:42:25,587 --> 00:42:27,507 this is the right way to do it. 875 00:42:27,663 --> 00:42:28,418 Evan Troxel: to do it. 876 00:42:28,418 --> 00:42:30,192 There's that, and everybody's like me. 877 00:42:30,632 --> 00:42:34,202 And I, we, we speak my language, but, but it really to me is about 878 00:42:34,392 --> 00:42:37,682 speaking their language and finding the way to communicate best with them. 879 00:42:37,682 --> 00:42:41,072 And I love this idea of the persona and kind of prototyping 880 00:42:41,072 --> 00:42:42,772 these conversations ahead of time. 881 00:42:43,172 --> 00:42:45,392 You know, role playing is what we're talking about, right? 882 00:42:45,452 --> 00:42:45,682 So 883 00:42:45,812 --> 00:42:47,962 Phil Read: even before you have that meeting with the boss and go, look, 884 00:42:48,212 --> 00:42:49,422 I've got to have this conversation. 885 00:42:49,422 --> 00:42:52,172 I want to invest this money into doing this thing and training these people. 886 00:42:52,672 --> 00:42:56,442 What are, yeah, what are the roadblocks? 887 00:42:56,612 --> 00:42:57,282 What are the likely 888 00:42:57,472 --> 00:42:59,722 Evan Troxel: grill me, pre grill me, right? 889 00:43:00,092 --> 00:43:00,452 Yeah. 890 00:43:00,532 --> 00:43:03,052 I mean, Steve jobs, roasting the design, right? 891 00:43:03,242 --> 00:43:06,592 It makes me think of like you grill me with questions. 892 00:43:06,612 --> 00:43:10,762 I want to get this thing through all the red tape that I have to get it through. 893 00:43:10,777 --> 00:43:10,997 Phil Read: through. 894 00:43:10,997 --> 00:43:15,907 Does chat, does this chat GPT that you're using, does it work with video or is it? 895 00:43:16,692 --> 00:43:18,172 Evan Troxel: You can put images up there. 896 00:43:18,282 --> 00:43:19,142 I don't know that it'll work 897 00:43:19,227 --> 00:43:21,887 Phil Read: You can't walk around a design model or something like 898 00:43:21,887 --> 00:43:24,437 that and ask it to interact. 899 00:43:25,343 --> 00:43:30,253 I think it just, it, it prepare, it could prepare you, and we have a family 900 00:43:30,253 --> 00:43:33,393 friend, Harvard trained psychologist, and a couple of years ago I, I, 901 00:43:33,793 --> 00:43:36,053 we were having a chat about, uh. 902 00:43:37,263 --> 00:43:40,553 You know, obviously he does counseling and I said, I think the AI is going 903 00:43:40,553 --> 00:43:42,083 to have a profound impact on this. 904 00:43:42,113 --> 00:43:44,083 And he's like, Oh no, you can never replace people. 905 00:43:44,153 --> 00:43:47,883 And now I look at it like the father, that's going to have to have a 906 00:43:47,883 --> 00:43:52,683 difficult conversation with a son, you know, grades at school or anything. 907 00:43:53,073 --> 00:43:57,413 It's like, how do I want to approach this to build a bridge to not, you know, to 908 00:43:57,413 --> 00:44:01,773 not sever relationship, any difficult conversation, whether it's the boss 909 00:44:01,773 --> 00:44:05,318 at work, a partner, um, um, a child. 910 00:44:05,528 --> 00:44:07,978 The thing that I was thinking about when you mentioned that it's 911 00:44:08,028 --> 00:44:12,308 being conversational, and can you have a third person as the agent? 912 00:44:13,068 --> 00:44:15,168 man, if I could have gone through teenagers and had the, 913 00:44:15,618 --> 00:44:17,198 the agent in there so that, 914 00:44:17,358 --> 00:44:18,028 Evan Troxel: A mediator. 915 00:44:18,038 --> 00:44:19,598 Phil Read: yeah, it's the mediator. 916 00:44:19,638 --> 00:44:20,175 Evan Troxel: the 917 00:44:20,368 --> 00:44:22,568 Phil Read: Okay, dad, you need to be quiet now. 918 00:44:22,568 --> 00:44:24,748 You're not, you're, yeah, you're talking too much. 919 00:44:24,748 --> 00:44:24,938 Let 920 00:44:25,006 --> 00:44:26,080 Evan Troxel: You're talking 921 00:44:26,108 --> 00:44:27,058 Phil Read: right, right, right. 922 00:44:27,128 --> 00:44:29,648 I could have Viktor Frankl in there listening in. 923 00:44:30,841 --> 00:44:35,061 I think those kinds of conversations will be profound and not just in 924 00:44:35,081 --> 00:44:37,841 monetary terms, but just in like human relationship terms because 925 00:44:37,841 --> 00:44:39,761 we see things through our own 926 00:44:40,267 --> 00:44:44,499 Evan Troxel: When was BiLT north America in St. 927 00:44:44,499 --> 00:44:44,899 Louis. 928 00:44:44,899 --> 00:44:45,529 What year was that? 929 00:44:45,549 --> 00:44:47,369 2018 or 2019? 930 00:44:47,659 --> 00:44:48,879 2017? 931 00:44:49,224 --> 00:44:50,194 Phil Read: the next to the last one. 932 00:44:50,194 --> 00:44:52,054 So I think it was 18 because 19 was 933 00:44:52,449 --> 00:44:53,169 Evan Troxel: Seattle, right? 934 00:44:53,649 --> 00:44:57,079 I think it was in, I did like one of those YouTube wrap up videos. 935 00:44:57,109 --> 00:44:58,949 I was doing, doing those at the time. 936 00:44:58,969 --> 00:45:04,619 And something that came up at that conference was what if you had, I 937 00:45:04,619 --> 00:45:09,129 think it was in the, um, the, Is it the DTS, which was like the pre conference 938 00:45:09,139 --> 00:45:10,819 for the Digital Technology Summit? 939 00:45:11,419 --> 00:45:16,899 And, you know, Rob Yori and, and, uh, Robert Manna and people like that were, 940 00:45:16,939 --> 00:45:21,794 were there, it was a group discussion with people from large firms all over the, the 941 00:45:21,794 --> 00:45:26,474 US would come in and be there for a few days before the actual BiLT Conference 942 00:45:26,954 --> 00:45:28,484 and then stay through the BiLT Conference. 943 00:45:28,484 --> 00:45:31,844 But the, one of the things that came up at that was what if you had one of 944 00:45:31,844 --> 00:45:35,649 those echo dots or something on your desk at work, what would you ask it? 945 00:45:36,309 --> 00:45:39,209 and I think you mentioned like there are certain things that I 946 00:45:39,219 --> 00:45:42,919 just wouldn't feel comfortable talking about it in public, right? 947 00:45:42,949 --> 00:45:48,474 But this whole idea of using it You know, you've got your, you've got your 948 00:45:48,474 --> 00:45:52,024 AirPods now, like, I don't even think those were a thing back then, at least, 949 00:45:52,024 --> 00:45:55,644 you know, the wireless ones, and, and you go on a walk, you go out of the 950 00:45:55,644 --> 00:46:00,034 office and go on a walk, or you're in the car on your drive home, or to work, 951 00:46:00,034 --> 00:46:03,974 and you're having these conversations, there may be things that it's fine to, 952 00:46:04,224 --> 00:46:08,864 to do in the office at your desk, right, and, and to prompt something, and have 953 00:46:08,864 --> 00:46:12,989 it, have this conversation going with what, what it's seeing on your screen. 954 00:46:12,999 --> 00:46:16,943 I think Claude recently, their latest model, Sonnet, can look at 955 00:46:16,943 --> 00:46:20,439 your screen and interact with you as you're interacting with your screen. 956 00:46:20,439 --> 00:46:25,179 And now there's this new layer of interaction with these models. 957 00:46:25,749 --> 00:46:29,829 But there's voice, there's screen, so maybe there are a lot of things 958 00:46:29,829 --> 00:46:33,389 that you could do that you'd be fine with saying out loud or 959 00:46:33,389 --> 00:46:35,449 showing on your screen at work. 960 00:46:35,899 --> 00:46:37,889 And then there's a lot of things that aren't, right? 961 00:46:37,949 --> 00:46:41,899 And it's interesting that you kind of tied that back into psychology 962 00:46:41,919 --> 00:46:44,449 and like, especially men who are not. 963 00:46:44,994 --> 00:46:48,164 as open with their emotions and their feelings and expressing those 964 00:46:48,164 --> 00:46:49,564 or talking to others about them 965 00:46:49,664 --> 00:46:51,484 Phil Read: you pay somebody 300 bucks an hour and, 966 00:46:52,654 --> 00:46:55,344 Evan Troxel: And just not doing that because it's cost prohibitive 967 00:46:55,524 --> 00:46:56,804 Phil Read: No, if you're stressed about money, you can't 968 00:46:56,804 --> 00:46:57,974 pay someone 300 bucks an hour. 969 00:46:58,414 --> 00:47:00,984 Evan Troxel: And I think like working in an architectural office leads 970 00:47:00,984 --> 00:47:03,964 to a lot of situations where that would be extremely beneficial, right? 971 00:47:04,324 --> 00:47:06,644 So like it's a frustrating job. 972 00:47:06,654 --> 00:47:10,499 It's a challenging job Uh, and that's you know 973 00:47:11,799 --> 00:47:14,789 Lots of different roles in the office, not just technology roles. 974 00:47:14,789 --> 00:47:18,069 But I mean, we can definitely see that in technology roles. 975 00:47:18,089 --> 00:47:19,929 It's really challenging. 976 00:47:19,929 --> 00:47:19,999 Yeah, 977 00:47:20,029 --> 00:47:23,269 Phil Read: I think, you know, we've used AI, the AEC space primarily to 978 00:47:23,269 --> 00:47:26,999 create beautifully seductive images of buildings and the lighting is perfect. 979 00:47:27,009 --> 00:47:28,469 The reflections are amazing. 980 00:47:28,969 --> 00:47:33,089 And, uh, you know, from text prompts and, and, and a little bit of 981 00:47:33,089 --> 00:47:35,869 graphics, little massing or sketching, 982 00:47:35,979 --> 00:47:38,369 Evan Troxel: Some some kind of rudimentary underlay. 983 00:47:38,379 --> 00:47:38,659 Yeah. 984 00:47:39,654 --> 00:47:40,364 Phil Read: images, 985 00:47:40,954 --> 00:47:43,074 but that's just, I think we're just scratching the surface. 986 00:47:43,074 --> 00:47:44,774 We're doing the thing that appeals to us as 987 00:47:44,994 --> 00:47:45,934 Evan Troxel: it's the eye candy, 988 00:47:45,994 --> 00:47:49,484 Phil Read: we're, well, we're visual people, you know, we're, we're, we've 989 00:47:49,494 --> 00:47:53,804 kept ourselves alive over millennia by being visual and listening. 990 00:47:54,134 --> 00:48:00,404 But, uh, that's just scratching the It's, um, it's far more 991 00:48:00,724 --> 00:48:03,544 Evan Troxel: well, and that even, you know, scratching the surface, to me, it's 992 00:48:03,544 --> 00:48:08,934 like, it's the lure, it's the carrot, and it's not even the thing we should be. 993 00:48:08,949 --> 00:48:10,809 I really focused on. 994 00:48:10,809 --> 00:48:11,049 Right. 995 00:48:11,049 --> 00:48:12,244 It's just, it's a distraction. 996 00:48:12,589 --> 00:48:15,459 Phil Read: Well, there's an enormity of execution that has to take place 997 00:48:15,459 --> 00:48:20,009 if you're talking about in terms of manufacturing and leverage. 998 00:48:20,939 --> 00:48:24,629 I think everything in a way is every, every job is kind of a manufacturing role. 999 00:48:24,629 --> 00:48:25,799 You're turning something 1000 00:48:26,159 --> 00:48:27,039 of a lower value 1001 00:48:27,039 --> 00:48:28,099 into a higher value. 1002 00:48:28,479 --> 00:48:32,049 So you're turning raw materials into tennis shoes or tires. 1003 00:48:32,049 --> 00:48:35,729 You're turning electricity into drawings, instructions to build a building. 1004 00:48:36,199 --> 00:48:36,689 And. 1005 00:48:37,379 --> 00:48:42,019 We are still doing, so there's a lot of automation that occurs, that, that 1006 00:48:42,249 --> 00:48:46,239 occurs and has developed in the last 20, 25 years, where you can move a 1007 00:48:46,239 --> 00:48:49,334 door in a plan and it moves in the elevation and it moves in the schedule. 1008 00:48:50,474 --> 00:48:52,334 Evan Troxel: It's called building information modeling, 1009 00:48:52,524 --> 00:48:53,404 Phil, have you heard of it? 1010 00:48:53,404 --> 00:48:54,461 but 1011 00:48:54,792 --> 00:48:54,969 Phil Read: But 1012 00:48:54,989 --> 00:48:55,399 isn't, 1013 00:48:58,149 --> 00:48:58,749 transactional. 1014 00:48:59,904 --> 00:49:00,294 Evan Troxel: Mm hmm. 1015 00:49:01,289 --> 00:49:04,649 Phil Read: It's not a conversation where you're just staring at the 1016 00:49:04,649 --> 00:49:07,069 blank piece of paper and going, you know, this doesn't really work. 1017 00:49:07,079 --> 00:49:08,799 Like, give me some ideas here. 1018 00:49:09,169 --> 00:49:12,294 Which normally you'd call someone over who has a lot of experience. 1019 00:49:12,294 --> 00:49:14,574 Evan Troxel: say, Hey, I need some fresh eyes on this. 1020 00:49:14,574 --> 00:49:16,794 Can you look, can you look at this and tell me if 1021 00:49:16,979 --> 00:49:19,599 Phil Read: lay down some trace and you kind of look at it a different way. 1022 00:49:20,099 --> 00:49:26,504 Um, I think that kind of interaction what's going to be really profound. 1023 00:49:28,319 --> 00:49:29,689 At school. 1024 00:49:30,569 --> 00:49:35,139 at university, like having a minor in psychology and a master's degree 1025 00:49:35,139 --> 00:49:38,599 in architecture, or maybe having an undergraduate degree in architecture 1026 00:49:38,599 --> 00:49:40,329 and a master's degree in psychology. 1027 00:49:40,989 --> 00:49:43,479 Because ultimately what you're, I think what we're trying to 1028 00:49:43,479 --> 00:49:46,039 do in business is persuade. 1029 00:49:46,414 --> 00:49:47,164 Evan Troxel: Absolutely. 1030 00:49:48,239 --> 00:49:51,669 Phil Read: And how you persuade depends on the person that you're trying to persuade. 1031 00:49:51,669 --> 00:49:52,919 It's not one 1032 00:49:53,554 --> 00:49:55,104 Evan Troxel: There's no one way to do it, yeah. 1033 00:49:55,504 --> 00:49:55,824 Right. 1034 00:49:56,119 --> 00:49:56,319 Phil Read: Yeah. 1035 00:49:57,509 --> 00:49:58,844 There's so many ways to do things. 1036 00:49:59,734 --> 00:50:04,004 And what will appeal based on that person's understanding of how 1037 00:50:04,004 --> 00:50:05,574 that space is going to be used. 1038 00:50:06,294 --> 00:50:08,754 Commercial space or a private space. 1039 00:50:09,384 --> 00:50:12,764 The aspiration of what that building and investment is going 1040 00:50:12,764 --> 00:50:14,184 to, is, is how it's going to 1041 00:50:16,444 --> 00:50:19,934 Like being able to interact with a persona at that level. 1042 00:50:20,704 --> 00:50:23,684 I think is, is just, it's profound. 1043 00:50:23,734 --> 00:50:24,354 We don't have 1044 00:50:24,734 --> 00:50:28,414 Evan Troxel: you feel like that's leverage to build those skills 1045 00:50:28,799 --> 00:50:29,589 Phil Read: Well, if you're building a 1046 00:50:29,934 --> 00:50:30,114 Evan Troxel: those 1047 00:50:30,439 --> 00:50:31,349 Phil Read: you don't have, 1048 00:50:32,959 --> 00:50:34,839 you're not constrained by team size. 1049 00:50:34,839 --> 00:50:40,669 Maybe, you know, what's, I don't know if it's, if, uh, I like things in threes. 1050 00:50:40,669 --> 00:50:45,619 You know, a stool is, will hold, a stool won't wobble with three legs. 1051 00:50:45,649 --> 00:50:46,819 Maybe you just have three people. 1052 00:50:46,869 --> 00:50:48,159 What's the firm size now? 1053 00:50:48,159 --> 00:50:53,379 And you have these intelligent agents that you can interact with, even 1054 00:50:53,379 --> 00:50:54,919 with those other people on the team. 1055 00:50:55,449 --> 00:51:01,039 Um, but how you will pursue work, propose work, win work, execute 1056 00:51:01,039 --> 00:51:05,999 work, bill for These are, these are tasks that people have to manually 1057 00:51:05,999 --> 00:51:08,719 do, and to be honest, they're not always interesting all the time. 1058 00:51:08,729 --> 00:51:11,179 Like chasing money is not interesting 1059 00:51:11,274 --> 00:51:13,824 Evan Troxel: you become a specialist in that this is how 1060 00:51:13,824 --> 00:51:15,174 large firms operate, right? 1061 00:51:15,174 --> 00:51:17,384 You're specialists in, in all those roles. 1062 00:51:18,239 --> 00:51:21,109 Phil Read: But I think these agents will be the specialists that you need on, on 1063 00:51:21,264 --> 00:51:23,424 Evan Troxel: Or they can be If, if people are willing to 1064 00:51:23,779 --> 00:51:27,389 Phil Read: Look, even the conversation when the customer's not paying you, having 1065 00:51:27,389 --> 00:51:31,249 a conversation first about this customer that's not paying me, how would you 1066 00:51:31,624 --> 00:51:33,434 Evan Troxel: Well, you would write your draft. 1067 00:51:33,449 --> 00:51:36,339 Phil Read: And some customers are going to be very transactional and 1068 00:51:36,339 --> 00:51:39,139 you're going to say, I'm going to come and I need to be paid today. 1069 00:51:39,139 --> 00:51:41,279 And others may, it may be a different appeal. 1070 00:51:41,454 --> 00:51:42,304 Evan Troxel: negotiation. 1071 00:51:42,704 --> 00:51:43,174 Right. 1072 00:51:44,439 --> 00:51:48,989 Phil Read: Um, Because if you're impatient and you just escalate right 1073 00:51:48,989 --> 00:51:51,499 away, get frustrated, go, Okay, look, well, if I have to get a lawyer, 1074 00:51:51,558 --> 00:51:54,264 Evan Troxel: Every, yeah, if you're a, if you're a hammer, every, every problem 1075 00:51:54,319 --> 00:51:55,529 Phil Read: yeah, that's not the win. 1076 00:51:55,624 --> 00:51:55,994 Evan Troxel: Right. 1077 00:51:56,529 --> 00:52:00,969 Phil Read: So using these kind of agent feedback loops, having the 1078 00:52:00,969 --> 00:52:05,729 conversation before the conversation, I think that's the profound part. 1079 00:52:05,729 --> 00:52:07,449 We haven't, we haven't touched the surface of that yet. 1080 00:52:07,469 --> 00:52:10,209 We're just using it to make pictures right now. 1081 00:52:11,419 --> 00:52:13,594 We're not using it to create personas. 1082 00:52:15,334 --> 00:52:15,394 Evan Troxel: I 1083 00:52:15,394 --> 00:52:19,094 mean it, and the technology exists right now to do this. 1084 00:52:19,509 --> 00:52:22,959 Phil Read: You'll get more than you, that's the, that was the bit flip, 1085 00:52:22,979 --> 00:52:28,199 is when you get more than out of it than you think you put into it. 1086 00:52:28,229 --> 00:52:32,634 Like taking a photo from that, uh, beach retail show of a, of a, a 1087 00:52:32,634 --> 00:52:35,144 vendor's tabletop and going, okay, what do I have in this picture? 1088 00:52:35,144 --> 00:52:36,434 And how much would it cost retail? 1089 00:52:36,434 --> 00:52:40,904 And it starts to give a very detailed accounting of everything on the table 1090 00:52:41,114 --> 00:52:44,844 to the point that, um, I mean, the alligator heads were pretty obvious. 1091 00:52:44,844 --> 00:52:47,084 You could get back scratchers and alligator heads, right? 1092 00:52:47,274 --> 00:52:51,764 but then it had alligator jerky and it recognized, alligator jerky from 1093 00:52:51,764 --> 00:52:55,454 this photo at probably 10 15 feet away and it gave me an accounting of what 1094 00:52:55,454 --> 00:52:56,684 that would probably cost retail terms. 1095 00:52:56,694 --> 00:52:58,654 Like this is the most obscure thing. 1096 00:52:58,934 --> 00:53:00,154 Like no one would build a tool for 1097 00:53:00,194 --> 00:53:02,684 Evan Troxel: Oh, and by the way, the table costs you $25 1098 00:53:02,744 --> 00:53:05,284 Phil Read: Yeah, so now I'm finding myself walking around taking photos of things 1099 00:53:05,284 --> 00:53:10,764 and asking, uh, asking Grok, um, who makes this chair and how much does it cost? 1100 00:53:10,834 --> 00:53:12,214 Where is this light from? 1101 00:53:12,724 --> 00:53:14,314 And, and it goes and finds it. 1102 00:53:14,529 --> 00:53:15,434 Evan Troxel: So the thing that this is. 1103 00:53:15,827 --> 00:53:19,917 Bringing up for me is this whole idea of curiosity, right? 1104 00:53:19,927 --> 00:53:24,227 Like you obviously have this curiosity now, like you, you've seen a bit of what 1105 00:53:24,227 --> 00:53:27,857 it can do and, and now, oh man, I'm just going to keep asking it more and more 1106 00:53:27,857 --> 00:53:34,135 questions, but curiosity is, um, let's just say it's not, really welcome in 1107 00:53:34,135 --> 00:53:36,205 a lot of corporate situations, right? 1108 00:53:36,205 --> 00:53:39,005 It's like, do the job with these tools like this. 1109 00:53:39,225 --> 00:53:41,655 Phil Read: Ooh, I don't know you'd want to Why would you ever want 1110 00:53:41,655 --> 00:53:42,525 to work somewhere you weren't? 1111 00:53:43,185 --> 00:53:43,905 being paid to be 1112 00:53:44,415 --> 00:53:47,365 Evan Troxel: well, and look what you can get out of it, right? 1113 00:53:47,375 --> 00:53:50,615 Like, like look what the potential is with that. 1114 00:53:50,991 --> 00:53:53,161 And that there's a, there's a leverage right there. 1115 00:53:53,191 --> 00:53:59,031 Like, I always found it to be incredibly frustrating to work in places where 1116 00:53:59,031 --> 00:54:01,031 it was like, this is how we do it. 1117 00:54:01,031 --> 00:54:02,401 This is how we've always done it. 1118 00:54:02,411 --> 00:54:04,461 This is how we're going to continue to do it. 1119 00:54:04,839 --> 00:54:07,469 Don't do, don't go outside of these lines, right? 1120 00:54:07,479 --> 00:54:08,999 Don't color outside the lines. 1121 00:54:09,139 --> 00:54:13,069 And I remember first year of architecture school, my professor, who was a wild 1122 00:54:13,069 --> 00:54:17,659 and crazy individual, he said, the worst thing you ever learned was in kindergarten 1123 00:54:17,659 --> 00:54:18,929 when they taught you to color inside the 1124 00:54:18,929 --> 00:54:19,849 Phil Read: Inside the lines. 1125 00:54:21,729 --> 00:54:24,639 Evan Troxel: Stifling that curiosity happens early on 1126 00:54:24,649 --> 00:54:26,619 in a lot of people, right? 1127 00:54:26,649 --> 00:54:27,919 And then it continues. 1128 00:54:27,939 --> 00:54:32,199 And so like there's, there's levels of curiosity that are allowed in air 1129 00:54:32,394 --> 00:54:38,196 Phil Read: of air and I, I suspect that business success leads to Pattern 1130 00:54:38,196 --> 00:54:40,146 recognition of, oh, let's do more of that. 1131 00:54:40,646 --> 00:54:40,966 Right? 1132 00:54:40,966 --> 00:54:41,756 So you don't want to 1133 00:54:41,756 --> 00:54:42,596 Evan Troxel: Keep doing that. 1134 00:54:42,656 --> 00:54:43,106 Yeah. 1135 00:54:43,528 --> 00:54:46,303 Phil Read: even to the detriment of the business, they'll 1136 00:54:46,303 --> 00:54:47,403 follow it all the way down. 1137 00:54:48,013 --> 00:54:50,693 But just keep doing the thing and particularly in stress mode, then people 1138 00:54:50,703 --> 00:54:53,703 really look at pattern recognition and they don't want to try anything 1139 00:54:53,703 --> 00:54:54,623 else because they're stressed. 1140 00:54:54,653 --> 00:55:00,459 Yeah, they double but for architectural firms now, or students that are 1141 00:55:00,459 --> 00:55:05,828 in school now, I suppose if your aspiration is to work for a company 1142 00:55:05,838 --> 00:55:09,628 and be part of the milieu of a very recognizable high design firm, 1143 00:55:10,340 --> 00:55:11,430 then that's one track. 1144 00:55:12,080 --> 00:55:14,544 But, you don't have to follow that path. 1145 00:55:15,528 --> 00:55:19,788 Like having all of these agents work for you, and to be able to ask it questions 1146 00:55:19,918 --> 00:55:23,853 on demand when the, when the question is, is forefront, you know, front. 1147 00:55:24,851 --> 00:55:28,241 The cost of that, if you had to do it in human terms, would be, you would 1148 00:55:28,251 --> 00:55:32,141 have to hire all of these people to do all of these kinds of tasks for you. 1149 00:55:32,661 --> 00:55:36,980 I don't know, if you're not curious, I don't know that I would want 1150 00:55:36,990 --> 00:55:40,410 to employ people that were not curious or want to be employed. 1151 00:55:42,140 --> 00:55:46,080 Isn't that kind of, isn't that kind of what we're, we're not just paid 1152 00:55:46,080 --> 00:55:48,770 to do a thing, we're paid to pay attention to the thing we're doing 1153 00:55:48,770 --> 00:55:50,140 and to try to improve the thing? 1154 00:55:50,141 --> 00:55:50,295 Yeah. 1155 00:55:51,579 --> 00:55:55,679 mean, anyone, I don't know what you, isn't everything improvable? 1156 00:55:56,779 --> 00:55:59,909 So while you're doing it, you're also in this other mind of going, I wonder 1157 00:55:59,909 --> 00:56:01,429 if this could be, like, this could be 1158 00:56:01,769 --> 00:56:04,709 Evan Troxel: I wish we could run a poll on the podcast right now, right? 1159 00:56:04,739 --> 00:56:08,429 Like a real time poll of like, do you feel like you have that 1160 00:56:08,459 --> 00:56:11,399 agency in your role to be curious? 1161 00:56:12,009 --> 00:56:14,909 Like a lot of times there's like designated individuals who are like 1162 00:56:14,909 --> 00:56:20,069 in an R and D kind of situation and that might be over glamorized, right? 1163 00:56:20,069 --> 00:56:23,269 But it's like this, or I remember as a designer, right? 1164 00:56:23,269 --> 00:56:26,899 I remember a project manager who was, you know, a principal and 1165 00:56:26,909 --> 00:56:30,959 owner in the firm was like, You've got the, you've got the easy job. 1166 00:56:31,009 --> 00:56:32,559 You get to design things. 1167 00:56:32,559 --> 00:56:34,249 And I'm like, are you serious? 1168 00:56:34,259 --> 00:56:37,269 Like I get to put my heart up on the wall and watch people 1169 00:56:37,269 --> 00:56:39,209 rip it off the wall, right? 1170 00:56:39,229 --> 00:56:41,069 It's not what you think it is. 1171 00:56:41,089 --> 00:56:47,609 And, and so anyway, tangent that the idea of this, this R and D, you know, those 1172 00:56:47,609 --> 00:56:49,359 people get paid to be curious or they 1173 00:56:49,509 --> 00:56:49,759 Phil Read: I think 1174 00:56:49,849 --> 00:56:51,479 Evan Troxel: paid to come up with innovation. 1175 00:56:51,599 --> 00:56:54,669 Phil Read: can see the director going, okay, I like your idea, but 1176 00:56:54,759 --> 00:56:56,499 that's not a good idea for today. 1177 00:56:57,109 --> 00:56:59,239 Like that's a good idea for the next project. 1178 00:56:59,549 --> 00:57:03,119 But to just say, Hey, I don't want you to have, stop thinking, you know, 1179 00:57:03,329 --> 00:57:03,919 Evan Troxel: Yeah, just 1180 00:57:04,027 --> 00:57:06,059 Phil Read: just do, ah, nah, 1181 00:57:06,489 --> 00:57:09,651 Evan Troxel: crushing for an artist, or for an architect, 1182 00:57:09,821 --> 00:57:11,061 Phil Read: even think it's artist and architect. 1183 00:57:11,061 --> 00:57:13,381 I think anyone, like even if you dig a hole and someone 1184 00:57:13,381 --> 00:57:14,551 goes, oh, is the hole there? 1185 00:57:14,851 --> 00:57:16,351 Nah, let's put the hole over there. 1186 00:57:16,941 --> 00:57:18,891 Or if you're digging a hole, right? 1187 00:57:18,911 --> 00:57:21,271 Like literally digging a ditch and you go, you know, we're going to dig 1188 00:57:21,271 --> 00:57:22,791 it this way, but that's a long way. 1189 00:57:22,791 --> 00:57:25,411 We could dig it over this way and it's a better way to dig the ditch. 1190 00:57:25,451 --> 00:57:26,611 Oh, I'm glad you thought of that. 1191 00:57:26,651 --> 00:57:33,891 Like, know, to be, to be, uh, proud of your work, anything, be curious, anything. 1192 00:57:34,351 --> 00:57:37,011 I can't think of what you could do that you wouldn't be curious. 1193 00:57:37,639 --> 00:57:41,249 Evan Troxel: So that the idea behind this kind of talking to this 1194 00:57:41,649 --> 00:57:43,879 technology, talking to these agents. 1195 00:57:44,784 --> 00:57:47,274 You know, why, why not just talk to a person about this stuff? 1196 00:57:47,484 --> 00:57:49,854 And the answer is because they're not available. 1197 00:57:49,969 --> 00:57:50,929 Phil Read: they're not always available. 1198 00:57:51,159 --> 00:57:51,679 Yeah, yeah. 1199 00:57:52,049 --> 00:57:52,939 No, there's very smart 1200 00:57:53,004 --> 00:57:55,204 Evan Troxel: they cost money or whatever, whatever those things are. 1201 00:57:55,514 --> 00:57:55,754 There's 1202 00:57:55,989 --> 00:57:58,109 Phil Read: they're in the middle of their thought, and now you're 1203 00:57:58,109 --> 00:57:59,909 interrupting an important moment for them. 1204 00:57:59,909 --> 00:58:03,841 Um, I don't think it'll be either or. 1205 00:58:04,341 --> 00:58:05,001 I think it'll be both and. 1206 00:58:06,241 --> 00:58:11,021 You'll use this other, you know, you mentioned that the, the agent was so 1207 00:58:11,021 --> 00:58:12,751 optimistic about your idea, right? 1208 00:58:12,761 --> 00:58:14,901 You do get, you do get that artifact sometimes. 1209 00:58:14,901 --> 00:58:16,381 What a wonderful idea. 1210 00:58:16,411 --> 00:58:18,561 Let's just, let's, let's think about that. 1211 00:58:18,991 --> 00:58:22,751 Um, but you do need a way to bounce ideas. 1212 00:58:23,479 --> 00:58:28,962 I think these tools, at least in my experience, are not being used. 1213 00:58:29,742 --> 00:58:33,492 To do lazy things, you're doing them to be more rigorous about 1214 00:58:33,492 --> 00:58:37,922 them, to be curious, to be asked questions, uh, to be responded to in 1215 00:58:38,122 --> 00:58:39,952 Evan Troxel: things to the ground faster, right? 1216 00:58:40,102 --> 00:58:41,882 Phil Read: it's like, Oh, I didn't think about that. 1217 00:58:42,602 --> 00:58:46,722 I was doing, uh, one of the posts for the Fall Leadership Retreat, or maybe 1218 00:58:46,722 --> 00:58:49,302 it's the Spring Roundtable, like, we don't have alcohol at the event. 1219 00:58:49,782 --> 00:58:54,382 And so I wanted to do a, a, a short article about why we don't have alcohol. 1220 00:58:54,752 --> 00:58:57,612 And it wasn't meant, I don't want to do anything preachy, it's 1221 00:58:57,612 --> 00:58:58,922 just like, in practical terms. 1222 00:58:59,072 --> 00:59:03,122 So I asked ChatGBT, like, give me some practical reasons, we have this kind of 1223 00:59:03,122 --> 00:59:04,302 event, here's what we're trying to do. 1224 00:59:04,682 --> 00:59:06,862 What are some practical reasons you wouldn't, give me five practical 1225 00:59:06,882 --> 00:59:08,202 reasons you wouldn't have alcohol. 1226 00:59:08,912 --> 00:59:11,582 And out of those five, I've got three good ones. 1227 00:59:11,582 --> 00:59:13,682 I think I ended up combining two into one. 1228 00:59:14,072 --> 00:59:15,512 It was like, oh, these are good reasons. 1229 00:59:15,512 --> 00:59:17,282 You know, they're nothing to do with moral authority. 1230 00:59:17,282 --> 00:59:21,082 It's just like, okay, we have water sports and we have ski boats and e 1231 00:59:21,082 --> 00:59:24,362 foils and yeah, you don't want to risk people drinking and being drunk. 1232 00:59:24,942 --> 00:59:26,312 You know, involved in water sports. 1233 00:59:26,332 --> 00:59:26,642 Evan Troxel: Phil. 1234 00:59:27,102 --> 00:59:29,452 Phil Read: We didn't see, we saw him on the river, but he's none in the 1235 00:59:29,726 --> 00:59:30,026 Evan Troxel: way. 1236 00:59:30,026 --> 00:59:30,325 So, 1237 00:59:30,352 --> 00:59:33,382 Phil Read: So yeah, there's, you know, to be thoughtful, to be in the moment, 1238 00:59:33,422 --> 00:59:37,262 uh, to be aware of what you're saying and thinking, okay, those are good 1239 00:59:37,262 --> 00:59:38,402 reasons why we don't have alcohol. 1240 00:59:38,402 --> 00:59:39,662 It just avoids complexity. 1241 00:59:40,292 --> 00:59:44,182 I still had to kind of curate the final selection, but I asked 1242 00:59:44,202 --> 00:59:47,142 the tool, like a room full of people, Hey, give me some ideas. 1243 00:59:47,742 --> 00:59:51,292 Like, you're just ideating, and I think that part of the, of the, of 1244 00:59:51,297 --> 00:59:53,457 Evan Troxel: Don't you do that, don't you do that anyway? 1245 00:59:53,487 --> 00:59:56,647 Don't you go through it at the, everything, even if you make it, right? 1246 00:59:56,852 --> 00:59:59,832 Phil Read: You do, but sometimes, you know, there's that mental block at first. 1247 00:59:59,857 --> 01:00:01,227 Evan Troxel: Oh, no, absolutely, 1248 01:00:01,552 --> 01:00:04,572 Phil Read: and um, it's very good at getting that initial vector, 1249 01:00:05,032 --> 01:00:07,022 and then giving you ideas that you wouldn't have thought of. 1250 01:00:07,022 --> 01:00:10,422 I think even for myself, if I had got myself in a quiet place 1251 01:00:10,422 --> 01:00:12,702 and thought about it, I wouldn't have thought about that angle. 1252 01:00:13,731 --> 01:00:14,121 Yep. 1253 01:00:14,418 --> 01:00:18,703 So, those kinds of, I, I would Encourage someone to take some of 1254 01:00:18,713 --> 01:00:21,983 these tools and take a photo of a chair and say where can I get this chair? 1255 01:00:22,183 --> 01:00:25,003 Take a photo of a space and say I like this design. 1256 01:00:25,013 --> 01:00:27,973 How much would this cost all the furnishings in this space? 1257 01:00:28,243 --> 01:00:31,833 What would they cost like it will recognize brands of? 1258 01:00:32,463 --> 01:00:36,493 Tables and chairs and soft furnishings and even wall fixtures. 1259 01:00:36,493 --> 01:00:40,010 It will recognize all of that and give you a list So it 1260 01:00:42,023 --> 01:00:45,823 a lot of time to design to get to the point where the customer might say I don't 1261 01:00:45,823 --> 01:00:49,673 like it But if we can do that quicker and have these quicker iterative steps, 1262 01:00:49,673 --> 01:00:52,953 and we're confident that we're on vector, I think the clients will be happier. 1263 01:00:53,743 --> 01:00:56,033 The customer will be more satisfied with the end 1264 01:00:56,528 --> 01:00:59,788 Evan Troxel: You know, as an architect, I always found that you have different 1265 01:00:59,788 --> 01:01:03,768 types of clients, but the best clients were the ones who were looking 1266 01:01:03,788 --> 01:01:06,608 for ideas, searching for ideas. 1267 01:01:06,763 --> 01:01:07,823 Phil Read: using you as an AI. 1268 01:01:07,833 --> 01:01:07,853 Yeah, 1269 01:01:07,853 --> 01:01:10,233 Evan Troxel: Yeah, they were using you to do the same thing, right, because 1270 01:01:10,233 --> 01:01:13,813 they're not the experts and they recognize that and they hired you to do that job 1271 01:01:14,133 --> 01:01:18,962 and you're the expert in that job and for you to look at it like that I think 1272 01:01:18,962 --> 01:01:23,672 is a, is a good take, right, because like when you get those unexpected, 1273 01:01:23,692 --> 01:01:25,711 whoa, I didn't think about that. 1274 01:01:26,031 --> 01:01:26,641 That's really, 1275 01:01:26,911 --> 01:01:28,751 Phil Read: Yeah, they've, they've already biased themselves, they've 1276 01:01:28,751 --> 01:01:32,541 flipped online through pictures, they've looked at designs, and, and they're 1277 01:01:32,541 --> 01:01:35,521 still at the point where they go, you know, I don't know, just, here's what 1278 01:01:35,521 --> 01:01:38,411 I like, but can you give me some ideas, we have this piece of property, here's 1279 01:01:38,411 --> 01:01:40,831 what we want to do with it, here's what we want to, here's how we want 1280 01:01:40,831 --> 01:01:45,061 the, the end product to perform, here's its function, but give me some ideas. 1281 01:01:45,576 --> 01:01:50,866 Evan Troxel: One of my favorite kind of surveys afterward with a client was when 1282 01:01:50,866 --> 01:01:55,081 they said, I said, so, you know, just, Let's just talk about the overall process. 1283 01:01:55,081 --> 01:01:56,051 And they said, you know what? 1284 01:01:56,051 --> 01:01:59,563 I really, really, really the thing that really made a mark for me. 1285 01:01:59,563 --> 01:02:03,253 And this was like a board member at this entity organization. 1286 01:02:03,523 --> 01:02:07,633 And they said, you brought things to the table that we would have 1287 01:02:07,633 --> 01:02:09,283 never, ever, ever thought of. 1288 01:02:09,755 --> 01:02:11,415 Phil Read: You're a very good carbon based AI. 1289 01:02:13,290 --> 01:02:13,680 Evan Troxel: But that, 1290 01:02:13,845 --> 01:02:16,130 Phil Read: But that's what, you wanted something unexpected. 1291 01:02:16,170 --> 01:02:16,530 Evan Troxel: the kind 1292 01:02:16,530 --> 01:02:18,000 of jobs I want to work on. 1293 01:02:18,570 --> 01:02:22,290 Right, and And you don't, I don't wanna work on the kinds of jobs where 1294 01:02:22,290 --> 01:02:23,910 it's like I have all the answers. 1295 01:02:23,910 --> 01:02:28,020 Number one, I, I want it to be interactive, but I also want 1296 01:02:28,020 --> 01:02:30,720 it to go somewhere where ne, neither one of us thought it 1297 01:02:30,766 --> 01:02:33,330 Phil Read: that's what happens in the conversation so many times. 1298 01:02:33,710 --> 01:02:37,450 I think I have an idea, and I chat with Adam about the idea, and at the end of 1299 01:02:37,450 --> 01:02:41,480 the conversation, we end up with another idea that neither of us anticipated, 1300 01:02:41,480 --> 01:02:42,790 that we're both interested in. 1301 01:02:43,310 --> 01:02:47,935 And, I think that's, another important artifact of having these conversations 1302 01:02:47,935 --> 01:02:53,695 as opposed to the transactions when you can re ask the question and okay why do 1303 01:02:53,695 --> 01:02:55,785 you say that and dig deeper you end up 1304 01:02:55,845 --> 01:02:56,535 Evan Troxel: mean by that? 1305 01:02:56,555 --> 01:03:00,995 Phil Read: yeah you end up with a an idea that turns into a very 1306 01:03:00,995 --> 01:03:02,905 interesting opportunity it's surprising 1307 01:03:03,465 --> 01:03:03,815 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 1308 01:03:04,155 --> 01:03:07,765 And that, I mean, that it's, there's, there's something here 1309 01:03:07,795 --> 01:03:12,065 about surprise that actually makes people pay attention to something. 1310 01:03:12,625 --> 01:03:17,485 It's like what something is impactful to you. 1311 01:03:17,515 --> 01:03:19,865 It's typically because it was surprising. 1312 01:03:19,865 --> 01:03:21,495 So it's the twist in the movie. 1313 01:03:21,505 --> 01:03:23,925 It's the, it's the bridge in the song. 1314 01:03:23,925 --> 01:03:24,935 It's the key change. 1315 01:03:24,935 --> 01:03:26,955 It's something that you didn't see coming. 1316 01:03:27,055 --> 01:03:27,345 Right. 1317 01:03:27,365 --> 01:03:30,825 And, and it's like, boom, it smacks you in the face. 1318 01:03:30,855 --> 01:03:31,105 Right. 1319 01:03:31,115 --> 01:03:31,535 And it's. 1320 01:03:32,200 --> 01:03:34,080 That's what makes its mark on you, 1321 01:03:34,575 --> 01:03:35,245 Phil Read: right, right, right. 1322 01:03:36,150 --> 01:03:38,050 Evan Troxel: searching for that to happen. 1323 01:03:38,088 --> 01:03:42,355 Phil Read: And the restrictions of, uh, Don't just do anything you have to. 1324 01:03:42,355 --> 01:03:45,245 And I think that's where AI suffers right now, particularly with regard to 1325 01:03:45,385 --> 01:03:48,935 trying to come up with design ideas and creating renderings, it's really good 1326 01:03:48,935 --> 01:03:53,115 at creating anything, anything, and it, it's hard at creating something. 1327 01:03:54,035 --> 01:03:57,835 Um, I think that'll get better, but, uh, it's hard to iterate and 1328 01:03:57,835 --> 01:04:01,555 have things sit still and then just kind of tweak it over here. 1329 01:04:01,795 --> 01:04:07,325 I only recently found out that Keith Richards uses open tuning and five 1330 01:04:07,570 --> 01:04:08,000 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 1331 01:04:09,062 --> 01:04:10,672 Phil Read: Oh my gosh, the music sounds amazing. 1332 01:04:10,742 --> 01:04:11,372 And I'm, and I 1333 01:04:11,777 --> 01:04:13,287 Evan Troxel: would know, nobody would know that, right? 1334 01:04:13,342 --> 01:04:15,262 Phil Read: and he said when they were starting out, like the, the 1335 01:04:15,262 --> 01:04:16,812 heavy string, the bottom string is 1336 01:04:17,637 --> 01:04:19,937 Evan Troxel: when I, when I say that, nobody listening would know, 1337 01:04:19,937 --> 01:04:23,387 like, Oh, Keith Richards plays with a completely modified setup from normal 1338 01:04:23,402 --> 01:04:25,632 Phil Read: So it's an old blues style, open tuning. 1339 01:04:25,632 --> 01:04:28,492 So you can strum, so you can strum the strings without touching the strings. 1340 01:04:28,802 --> 01:04:33,114 It also means you can just put one finger across five strings and 1341 01:04:33,124 --> 01:04:38,285 get, and Go online and listen to Keith Richards playing the guitar. 1342 01:04:38,285 --> 01:04:41,265 You're like, that's, that's the sound. 1343 01:04:41,275 --> 01:04:46,645 That's the sound of his guitar playing and how he's able to create fills. 1344 01:04:47,042 --> 01:04:52,092 The songs that they're known for would not have been possible without that, without 1345 01:04:52,092 --> 01:04:53,522 the restriction of that tuning style. 1346 01:04:53,872 --> 01:04:58,342 And I think he said it, um, it was an artifact of, uh, you can do open 1347 01:04:58,342 --> 01:05:03,902 tuning with six strings, but, um, They were broke and the bottom strings at 1348 01:05:03,902 --> 01:05:05,562 Spence's, so he's like, yeah, forget it. 1349 01:05:05,562 --> 01:05:06,712 We'll just play without that one. 1350 01:05:06,721 --> 01:05:07,042 And 1351 01:05:09,117 --> 01:05:09,957 Evan Troxel: but, yeah, it's 1352 01:05:10,112 --> 01:05:12,752 Phil Read: And even a guitar company created a five string guitar, 1353 01:05:12,864 --> 01:05:17,461 which he played with for a number of years in the late 70s or 80s. 1354 01:05:17,461 --> 01:05:19,451 But it was a five string guitar and he would open tune it. 1355 01:05:19,516 --> 01:05:19,546 Evan Troxel: it. 1356 01:05:19,546 --> 01:05:19,976 Just for him. 1357 01:05:19,986 --> 01:05:20,006 Yeah. 1358 01:05:20,576 --> 01:05:20,666 I 1359 01:05:20,831 --> 01:05:22,601 Phil Read: listen to them play carefully. 1360 01:05:22,855 --> 01:05:26,375 the concert in, um, it's called Shine a Light. 1361 01:05:26,375 --> 01:05:28,415 It was a documentary film. 1362 01:05:28,425 --> 01:05:33,925 Martin Scorsese filmed it in the, um, uh, it's at the Beacon Theater in New York. 1363 01:05:34,275 --> 01:05:37,635 And if you listen to Keith playing, there's a lot of fumbling. 1364 01:05:37,955 --> 01:05:40,175 Like there's a whole bunch of other musicians playing at the same time. 1365 01:05:40,195 --> 01:05:43,855 He's just doing fills and little pieces, but it's amazing. 1366 01:05:44,035 --> 01:05:45,785 It's like orchestrated music. 1367 01:05:45,805 --> 01:05:48,175 There's these little pieces of magic happening. 1368 01:05:48,925 --> 01:05:49,800 I don't know that that, uh, 1369 01:05:50,860 --> 01:05:51,150 it's, 1370 01:05:51,220 --> 01:05:54,170 It's, it's, a completely recognizable sound once you hear it. 1371 01:05:54,700 --> 01:05:58,240 And it was, it was the product of restriction and function. 1372 01:05:58,270 --> 01:05:58,610 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 1373 01:05:59,800 --> 01:06:03,100 That, that is the beauty of constraints in any situation, right? 1374 01:06:03,100 --> 01:06:06,500 It's like you figure out how to operate within them, and then you 1375 01:06:06,500 --> 01:06:08,340 break a rule here or there, right? 1376 01:06:09,000 --> 01:06:09,260 Yeah? 1377 01:06:09,690 --> 01:06:13,920 But they actually provide you with, I keep saying the word vector, right? 1378 01:06:13,930 --> 01:06:14,690 But that's what it 1379 01:06:14,700 --> 01:06:15,740 Phil Read: Oh, it's just like you're on it. 1380 01:06:15,910 --> 01:06:18,620 Evan Troxel: okay, now I can see where we're going because it's not 1381 01:06:18,620 --> 01:06:21,520 just a wide open field of blank page. 1382 01:06:21,590 --> 01:06:21,750 Phil Read: Yeah. 1383 01:06:21,750 --> 01:06:22,090 What's 1384 01:06:23,160 --> 01:06:23,890 Evan Troxel: What do we have to work 1385 01:06:24,025 --> 01:06:27,125 Phil Read: I only have one professor at architecture school that built 1386 01:06:27,125 --> 01:06:28,185 this artificial restriction. 1387 01:06:28,195 --> 01:06:29,345 This is a four hour task. 1388 01:06:29,345 --> 01:06:30,490 This is an eight hour task. 1389 01:06:30,890 --> 01:06:33,410 Evan Troxel: You talked about him, I think, in, in one of our podcasts. 1390 01:06:33,420 --> 01:06:33,680 Yeah. 1391 01:06:34,265 --> 01:06:35,535 Phil Read: And, uh, he's like, yeah, I don't 1392 01:06:35,570 --> 01:06:36,890 Evan Troxel: This is how much time you get to do 1393 01:06:36,895 --> 01:06:38,995 Phil Read: You get eight hours and, uh, if you come up with 1394 01:06:38,995 --> 01:06:40,425 two ideas in eight hours, fine. 1395 01:06:40,435 --> 01:06:41,295 One idea in eight hours. 1396 01:06:41,335 --> 01:06:43,345 I want to see what you get by tomorrow morning. 1397 01:06:43,495 --> 01:06:45,585 Give me four hours and then go do something else. 1398 01:06:46,055 --> 01:06:50,260 And, um, I always felt a certain level of satisfaction of doing something well 1399 01:06:50,260 --> 01:06:55,260 with a constraint, as opposed to just, oh, it doesn't matter, do anything. 1400 01:06:56,125 --> 01:06:57,925 Evan Troxel: or just keep Oh, you still have time left. 1401 01:06:57,925 --> 01:06:58,645 Keep going. 1402 01:06:59,275 --> 01:07:01,315 Even though you're, you feel done, 1403 01:07:01,610 --> 01:07:02,460 Phil Read: You feel burnt out. 1404 01:07:02,695 --> 01:07:02,845 Evan Troxel: feel out. 1405 01:07:02,845 --> 01:07:02,904 Yeah. 1406 01:07:04,090 --> 01:07:04,470 Phil Read: Yeah. 1407 01:07:04,885 --> 01:07:07,675 Evan Troxel: yeah, there, there, there are definitely people who are wired. 1408 01:07:08,065 --> 01:07:10,465 If there's more time, we're not done. 1409 01:07:11,120 --> 01:07:12,070 We can do more. 1410 01:07:13,060 --> 01:07:14,200 Phil Read: The glue's got time to dry. 1411 01:07:14,220 --> 01:07:14,760 Keep gluing. 1412 01:07:14,770 --> 01:07:15,300 Evan Troxel: Right. 1413 01:07:16,529 --> 01:07:19,160 Phil Read: So it's, uh, yeah, I think the technologies are interesting, 1414 01:07:19,160 --> 01:07:23,430 certainly in the ability to interact in a conversational way with an agent that 1415 01:07:23,650 --> 01:07:29,050 will critique a design for a student, for a would be architectural student. 1416 01:07:29,560 --> 01:07:35,090 It will discuss ideas in a way that aren't emotionally, uh, threatening. 1417 01:07:35,435 --> 01:07:35,654 Right? 1418 01:07:35,654 --> 01:07:37,995 Because you're not in front of a jury of peers, your students 1419 01:07:37,995 --> 01:07:40,305 are all there watching you get reamed on a Monday morning. 1420 01:07:40,715 --> 01:07:46,315 You're having conversations with, you know, with, uh, a tool that 1421 01:07:46,315 --> 01:07:48,595 looks at a design and goes, Well, have you thought about this? 1422 01:07:48,595 --> 01:07:49,465 Or have you thought about that? 1423 01:07:49,465 --> 01:07:53,305 Or certainly, from this persona, it's a wonderful design, but the other 1424 01:07:53,305 --> 01:07:56,375 persona might say, Oh no, it's, it's too busy, what were you thinking? 1425 01:07:57,136 --> 01:08:01,096 Evan Troxel: So, so this idea of curiosity but also flexing that muscle and actually 1426 01:08:01,096 --> 01:08:05,656 playing, like I'd, I'd like to frame it under the, Play right you play with these 1427 01:08:05,656 --> 01:08:10,096 things so that you learn what works What doesn't work how it's changing over time 1428 01:08:10,796 --> 01:08:14,466 if you don't flex that muscle if you don't flex any muscle it they atrophy they go 1429 01:08:14,576 --> 01:08:16,386 Phil Read: Well, you mentioned that some of these tools will 1430 01:08:16,386 --> 01:08:18,515 respond to things on your screen. 1431 01:08:18,566 --> 01:08:20,166 Evan Troxel: Yeah, yeah Claude 1432 01:08:20,747 --> 01:08:22,428 Phil Read: And it will respond in architectural terms? 1433 01:08:22,428 --> 01:08:25,788 I mean, could you have a, a model or a plan of a 1434 01:08:26,198 --> 01:08:27,098 Evan Troxel: I believe so. 1435 01:08:27,127 --> 01:08:32,508 I, yeah, and so, so, so, yeah, so the, the company's Anthropic and their model 1436 01:08:32,508 --> 01:08:36,268 is called Claude and they have different versions of Claude for different, you 1437 01:08:36,268 --> 01:08:39,758 know, different structures and stuff, but one, one of the modes of their 1438 01:08:39,768 --> 01:08:42,337 app will, will look at your screen. 1439 01:08:42,438 --> 01:08:42,587 Phil Read: Yeah. 1440 01:08:42,587 --> 01:08:44,778 I would look at a mode that does the thing that when you go, 1441 01:08:44,778 --> 01:08:45,948 could I have another set of eyes? 1442 01:08:45,948 --> 01:08:49,218 And they take out the trace and lay it over and start doing sketching. 1443 01:08:49,457 --> 01:08:50,268 But this mode 1444 01:08:50,468 --> 01:08:52,808 Evan Troxel: Well, this'll actually No, 1445 01:08:52,848 --> 01:08:55,308 Phil Read: have you thought about what if you move this over here and move that 1446 01:08:55,417 --> 01:08:57,548 Evan Troxel: It's looking at what you're doing on your screen. 1447 01:08:57,568 --> 01:09:01,798 So, I think, I think the idea is like, it will actually act like an 1448 01:09:01,798 --> 01:09:03,518 agent on your behalf at some point. 1449 01:09:03,528 --> 01:09:04,488 Maybe it does that now. 1450 01:09:04,508 --> 01:09:06,618 But it's like, I'm clicking this button. 1451 01:09:07,358 --> 01:09:08,497 in this interface. 1452 01:09:08,707 --> 01:09:10,848 It means this, right? 1453 01:09:10,978 --> 01:09:12,908 And it could walk you through things. 1454 01:09:12,917 --> 01:09:16,028 It could be like a helper, but it could also potentially, 1455 01:09:16,028 --> 01:09:17,158 I think, do things for you. 1456 01:09:17,202 --> 01:09:19,613 Phil Read: There's a lot of, I think there's a lot of empathy that occurs in 1457 01:09:19,613 --> 01:09:24,133 good design where you're in that mode of sort of plan view, but you're, you know, 1458 01:09:24,143 --> 01:09:27,372 analytically, but you're also trying to imagine how it will be experienced. 1459 01:09:27,893 --> 01:09:34,443 And, um, getting feedback in terms of the emotional quality of a 1460 01:09:34,443 --> 01:09:38,153 design as well as does it satisfy the analytic needs of the design. 1461 01:09:39,173 --> 01:09:44,473 and in stress mode and time constraints of real life, just being able to have 1462 01:09:44,473 --> 01:09:47,752 that other person there that are, that's always available just to ask a 1463 01:09:47,888 --> 01:09:48,247 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 1464 01:09:48,428 --> 01:09:48,698 Yeah. 1465 01:09:49,651 --> 01:09:51,890 Phil Read: I think it will take the stress away of doing work and then 1466 01:09:51,901 --> 01:09:55,441 having to untangle it later and going, Oh, I spent all day yesterday on that. 1467 01:09:55,461 --> 01:09:58,471 So I worked 16 hours and I have to roll it backwards as 1468 01:09:58,471 --> 01:09:59,901 opposed to in the moment being 1469 01:10:00,086 --> 01:10:02,866 Evan Troxel: Well, there's that, but there's also how much you can actually 1470 01:10:02,866 --> 01:10:07,476 compress time, and so you don't waste as much time having to redo something, right? 1471 01:10:07,476 --> 01:10:11,066 Because, ideas, like, okay, so real time rendering, you know, you're 1472 01:10:11,076 --> 01:10:15,906 connected with Enscape, I love the idea of, Making using it as a rendering 1473 01:10:15,906 --> 01:10:17,636 as a decision making tool now, right? 1474 01:10:17,636 --> 01:10:19,746 That wasn't a thing back in the day and back in the day. 1475 01:10:19,746 --> 01:10:20,346 It was an a 1476 01:10:20,416 --> 01:10:21,376 Phil Read: Oh, you push your button and wait. 1477 01:10:21,381 --> 01:10:21,441 Yeah. 1478 01:10:21,466 --> 01:10:21,766 Yeah. 1479 01:10:21,766 --> 01:10:22,696 It was a thing you did at the 1480 01:10:22,966 --> 01:10:25,186 Evan Troxel: And well, you better not screw it up because you don't 1481 01:10:25,186 --> 01:10:26,296 want to have to do it again, right? 1482 01:10:26,296 --> 01:10:29,416 And we learned how to fix things in Photoshop because it was way faster 1483 01:10:29,791 --> 01:10:29,971 Phil Read: Yeah. 1484 01:10:29,971 --> 01:10:31,441 Instead of push the button and wait four 1485 01:10:31,786 --> 01:10:36,836 Evan Troxel: So so this idea of like moving that technology closer to 1486 01:10:36,836 --> 01:10:38,221 the audience to the metal, right? 1487 01:10:38,281 --> 01:10:41,651 It's like, I'm now using it to make decisions because of 1488 01:10:41,651 --> 01:10:43,131 the visualization quality. 1489 01:10:43,131 --> 01:10:47,741 I can actually, I can use it right as a tool throughout the process. 1490 01:10:48,371 --> 01:10:51,341 And I think this is kind of the same thing, right? 1491 01:10:51,341 --> 01:10:54,011 This is, this is another thing where we're using it as a 1492 01:10:54,011 --> 01:10:57,381 tool along the way to help us. 1493 01:10:57,411 --> 01:10:58,531 Phil Read: the moment, right? 1494 01:10:58,541 --> 01:11:00,891 It's not the thing where you push the button at the end and render. 1495 01:11:01,391 --> 01:11:05,201 It's the questions and interaction in the moment. 1496 01:11:06,279 --> 01:11:07,479 Otherwise it's too disruptive. 1497 01:11:07,509 --> 01:11:10,318 You have to, you have to do these big cycles where you go back and start 1498 01:11:10,318 --> 01:11:11,779 over and go back and start over. 1499 01:11:12,832 --> 01:11:15,392 So that's where I'm kind of, yeah, there was so much, there's so much about 1500 01:11:15,392 --> 01:11:19,752 AI this and AI that, and I was like, oh, it's getting overwhelmed with AI. 1501 01:11:19,872 --> 01:11:25,572 But, but recently finding these sort of conversational vectors, that's got 1502 01:11:25,572 --> 01:11:31,052 me really interested in it, in, in the impact of, of not just in, uh, in 1503 01:11:31,052 --> 01:11:33,422 business, but just in trivial things. 1504 01:11:33,717 --> 01:11:34,647 Trivial things. 1505 01:11:34,717 --> 01:11:40,897 It's faster to, it's faster to ask AI to give me a recipe for fajitas or burritos 1506 01:11:41,317 --> 01:11:43,137 than it is to try to find it online now. 1507 01:11:43,187 --> 01:11:45,137 Because when you search online, and I've started doing 1508 01:11:45,292 --> 01:11:48,162 Evan Troxel: Now, everything's a five star recipe, first of all. 1509 01:11:48,222 --> 01:11:49,102 Like, you, you 1510 01:11:49,217 --> 01:11:51,617 Phil Read: through, you get the thing, and then you get the backstory of the 1511 01:11:51,680 --> 01:11:53,788 Evan Troxel: And finally, at the end, you get 1512 01:11:53,957 --> 01:11:56,067 Phil Read: and finally at the end you get the recipe, and 1513 01:11:56,067 --> 01:11:57,057 then you get the instructions. 1514 01:11:57,057 --> 01:11:58,662 But if you ask, chat 1515 01:11:59,102 --> 01:12:00,062 Evan Troxel: No nonsense. 1516 01:12:00,072 --> 01:12:01,752 Phil Read: It's like, Oh, you want to make fajitas? 1517 01:12:01,802 --> 01:12:03,222 Here's your list of ingredients. 1518 01:12:03,502 --> 01:12:04,762 Here's what you do. 1519 01:12:04,762 --> 01:12:06,832 And I was like, okay, and, and these are options. 1520 01:12:06,832 --> 01:12:08,292 If you want to do this, you might do that. 1521 01:12:08,302 --> 01:12:11,082 And I'm like, okay, that's what I want with, then there's no advertisers. 1522 01:12:11,082 --> 01:12:11,722 There's no noise. 1523 01:12:11,722 --> 01:12:13,352 I'm not scrolling down four pages. 1524 01:12:14,182 --> 01:12:14,582 Um, 1525 01:12:15,308 --> 01:12:20,438 Evan Troxel: That's a really interesting, uh, door, to, for me to get back into this 1526 01:12:20,438 --> 01:12:26,353 part where, you know, this idea of, of, Using or, or, or leveraging curiosity of 1527 01:12:26,353 --> 01:12:32,773 your employees to play with these tools and create fluency with them so that 1528 01:12:32,773 --> 01:12:35,243 that leverage can be amplified, right? 1529 01:12:35,243 --> 01:12:40,013 Like if you, if you have zero fluency with these, then someday you're 1530 01:12:40,013 --> 01:12:42,993 going to say, Oh, you know, we should be using these tools, right? 1531 01:12:43,493 --> 01:12:45,023 They've finally proven themselves. 1532 01:12:45,063 --> 01:12:48,113 Now, okay, we're at the laggard end of the adoption curve. 1533 01:12:48,113 --> 01:12:48,943 We're going to now. 1534 01:12:49,698 --> 01:12:50,928 Jump in on this, right? 1535 01:12:51,208 --> 01:12:52,248 And, and you're late. 1536 01:12:52,758 --> 01:12:53,558 You're super late. 1537 01:12:53,658 --> 01:12:55,098 You can't leverage it as much. 1538 01:12:55,128 --> 01:12:56,308 Now you're playing catch up. 1539 01:12:56,818 --> 01:13:01,988 And so with your, your clients, with people that you're talking to out there, 1540 01:13:02,008 --> 01:13:08,648 are you seeing this kind of attitude of leverage and playfulness and fluency, 1541 01:13:08,678 --> 01:13:11,948 or is it very much stand back and watch? 1542 01:13:11,983 --> 01:13:15,608 Phil Read: No, some of it's, uh, It's still a little transactional. 1543 01:13:15,608 --> 01:13:19,577 It's very, you know, the ideation that creates an image that sort of convinces a 1544 01:13:19,665 --> 01:13:19,903 Evan Troxel: customer. 1545 01:13:19,903 --> 01:13:21,073 We use this tool 1546 01:13:21,298 --> 01:13:25,508 Phil Read: Yeah, so I was talking with an architect, and I think it was at AU, 1547 01:13:25,958 --> 01:13:32,327 and they're winning work by doing simple sketches or massing models of lobby 1548 01:13:32,327 --> 01:13:40,093 atrium spaces, and then they're asking, uh, I think it's mid journey to They're 1549 01:13:40,093 --> 01:13:43,983 describing a text prompt and then in the style of a particular well known 1550 01:13:44,313 --> 01:13:44,973 Evan Troxel: And then using 1551 01:13:45,193 --> 01:13:48,793 Phil Read: and they're using that to generate an image and then they're 1552 01:13:48,793 --> 01:13:52,283 using those images to win work and then they execute the work. 1553 01:13:52,313 --> 01:13:57,473 But they're, they're naming, they're naming other firms by name, um, which 1554 01:13:57,473 --> 01:14:02,170 might, I don't know, it might, you know, Upset some people, but to me it's no 1555 01:14:02,170 --> 01:14:05,250 different than going to the library and pulling out the latest architectural 1556 01:14:05,250 --> 01:14:08,520 record or some other magazine and going, Oh, I like that work, that's by 1557 01:14:08,575 --> 01:14:09,715 Evan Troxel: Putting a little tab on that 1558 01:14:09,730 --> 01:14:11,559 Phil Read: Yeah, yeah, and just go, it's that firm, because if 1559 01:14:11,565 --> 01:14:13,775 Evan Troxel: this is what Pinterest was for everybody, right? 1560 01:14:13,825 --> 01:14:15,455 Like, it's just, just create all these 1561 01:14:15,835 --> 01:14:16,875 Phil Read: So it's part of their text 1562 01:14:17,065 --> 01:14:18,765 Evan Troxel: stairs and rails 1563 01:14:18,875 --> 01:14:21,725 Phil Read: transactional, I think, in that way of going, here's the 1564 01:14:21,725 --> 01:14:25,175 massing model, and we want it in the style of this, and you get an image. 1565 01:14:25,495 --> 01:14:27,915 But the idea, if you're doing lunch and learns on AI, and you 1566 01:14:27,925 --> 01:14:32,365 have young staff, asking people, what are you using AI firm for? 1567 01:14:33,955 --> 01:14:36,425 Let's go around the table at the Lunch and Learn and talk about what you're using. 1568 01:14:36,445 --> 01:14:39,045 AI firm, but has nothing to do directly with 1569 01:14:39,475 --> 01:14:40,615 Evan Troxel: no one's gonna get in trouble here. 1570 01:14:41,295 --> 01:14:42,195 Phil Read: Right, right, right, right. 1571 01:14:42,355 --> 01:14:43,555 Evan Troxel: just an open conversation 1572 01:14:43,605 --> 01:14:47,405 Phil Read: and it might not be anything to do with images, but the idea of 1573 01:14:47,405 --> 01:14:54,135 someone saying, Oh, I'm using it, I'm using AI to have conversations that 1574 01:14:54,135 --> 01:14:58,265 are in lieu of a psychologist, or I'm having a discussion in lieu of, of, 1575 01:14:58,275 --> 01:15:03,030 uh, trying to understand a difficult relationship with a coworker or roommate, 1576 01:15:04,080 --> 01:15:05,790 all of these kinds of human conflicts. 1577 01:15:05,790 --> 01:15:08,910 You know, imagine a roommate that just doesn't keep the apartment clean Right. 1578 01:15:08,940 --> 01:15:10,200 To your standard. 1579 01:15:10,260 --> 01:15:13,680 It's like, oh, I use chat GT Plus to 1580 01:15:13,800 --> 01:15:15,460 Evan Troxel: formulate that conversation. 1581 01:15:15,690 --> 01:15:15,900 Phil Read: Yeah. 1582 01:15:15,900 --> 01:15:16,470 Right, right. 1583 01:15:16,470 --> 01:15:16,620 Because 1584 01:15:16,630 --> 01:15:17,100 Evan Troxel: Give me some 1585 01:15:17,520 --> 01:15:21,120 Phil Read: art artists may not be, we're, we're kind of a, 1586 01:15:21,360 --> 01:15:22,800 we're kind of conflict averse. 1587 01:15:23,760 --> 01:15:24,860 Yeah, we don't like chasing money. 1588 01:15:24,860 --> 01:15:26,340 We don't like chasing arguments. 1589 01:15:26,350 --> 01:15:27,880 That's why we have somebody else do that. 1590 01:15:27,880 --> 01:15:28,680 No, I don't like selling. 1591 01:15:28,970 --> 01:15:32,420 So now you have that conversation with an agent to help you frame a 1592 01:15:32,420 --> 01:15:39,830 discussion around why it's important for me that you do your dishes and do 1593 01:15:39,830 --> 01:15:41,230 your part to keep the apartment clean. 1594 01:15:41,410 --> 01:15:45,520 Like just go around the room and find out what young people are using, you 1595 01:15:45,520 --> 01:15:49,450 know, uh, I don't know, young people, but the people that are younger in 1596 01:15:49,450 --> 01:15:53,340 the firm, What are they using these tools to do that you might not expect? 1597 01:15:53,540 --> 01:15:57,440 And I think you'll come up with an idea that will fold itself into something 1598 01:15:57,440 --> 01:15:59,250 business related to solve a problem. 1599 01:15:59,980 --> 01:16:05,128 But it's, um, it's, it's not, I wouldn't, I wouldn't just say, 1600 01:16:05,128 --> 01:16:07,648 okay, how are we going to use this to build better buildings? 1601 01:16:07,728 --> 01:16:07,958 Right. 1602 01:16:07,978 --> 01:16:11,327 You might want to take a bigger step back and look at the big 1603 01:16:11,398 --> 01:16:12,958 Evan Troxel: That's a different conversation. 1604 01:16:13,008 --> 01:16:15,718 That's like, here are the, here's the business goals. 1605 01:16:16,923 --> 01:16:19,903 Once you've defined those, you can figure out which technology it's probably, 1606 01:16:20,473 --> 01:16:22,493 it may be AI, it may not be, right? 1607 01:16:22,563 --> 01:16:25,503 Plugs into solving that business goal, right? 1608 01:16:25,523 --> 01:16:27,813 That could be any number of tools to do that. 1609 01:16:28,413 --> 01:16:31,843 You're talking about approaching it from more of a grassroots effort, which, Hey, 1610 01:16:31,853 --> 01:16:34,883 Phil Read: we, what do we, what obscure things are you using this for? 1611 01:16:35,653 --> 01:16:37,202 Evan Troxel: that'll just spark ideas, right? 1612 01:16:37,720 --> 01:16:38,930 Phil Read: Yeah, I think you take a bigger picture. 1613 01:16:38,930 --> 01:16:41,820 You don't just step in going, How are we going to use this for rendering? 1614 01:16:42,430 --> 01:16:44,650 It's kind of, that's so transactional. 1615 01:16:44,670 --> 01:16:46,400 You can do much bigger things with it. 1616 01:16:46,430 --> 01:16:48,215 And then you might get to rendering as well. 1617 01:16:48,668 --> 01:16:51,608 Evan Troxel: Well, I want to use this now as a segue to transition 1618 01:16:51,608 --> 01:16:54,638 into the upcoming round table discussions that you're gonna be 1619 01:16:55,327 --> 01:16:55,908 Phil Read: End of April. 1620 01:16:56,048 --> 01:16:57,188 Evan Troxel: at the end of April of 1621 01:16:57,533 --> 01:16:59,003 Phil Read: So this will be the second year. 1622 01:16:59,423 --> 01:17:03,173 Um, and the, we have the, we have the fall leadership retreat, which is more 1623 01:17:03,173 --> 01:17:06,803 leadership, self-leadership, other leadership, leadership of others. 1624 01:17:07,073 --> 01:17:09,173 And then the spring event is more technology focused. 1625 01:17:09,173 --> 01:17:10,702 So this will be the second year. 1626 01:17:11,483 --> 01:17:13,913 And our approach is that. 1627 01:17:14,484 --> 01:17:17,044 Good answers are not transactional. 1628 01:17:17,064 --> 01:17:18,164 They come from discussions. 1629 01:17:18,184 --> 01:17:22,144 And we, I, we add both Adam and I've experienced watching really good 1630 01:17:22,144 --> 01:17:26,304 presenters at conferences present something, and then you get them 1631 01:17:26,304 --> 01:17:28,664 after the conference, you go, okay, so look, here's the thing on my 1632 01:17:29,200 --> 01:17:30,193 Evan Troxel: Here, 1633 01:17:30,224 --> 01:17:30,984 Phil Read: How would you do it? 1634 01:17:31,023 --> 01:17:31,514 Evan Troxel: add my me 1635 01:17:31,564 --> 01:17:31,854 Phil Read: Yeah. 1636 01:17:32,014 --> 01:17:34,614 How would you, how would you do it for this kind of thing? 1637 01:17:34,614 --> 01:17:36,234 And they go, oh yeah, that won't work. 1638 01:17:36,273 --> 01:17:36,464 Yeah. 1639 01:17:36,464 --> 01:17:37,904 You probably want to do it this other way. 1640 01:17:38,404 --> 01:17:41,894 So we thought, you know what, we should just have the conversations 1641 01:17:41,894 --> 01:17:43,023 after the presentation. 1642 01:17:43,574 --> 01:17:48,534 So, like, Carl Storms did a presentation last year that was based on his, 1643 01:17:49,304 --> 01:17:54,184 uh, self interest in the, he did a hundred days of AI, and we talked, 1644 01:17:54,184 --> 01:17:57,484 we went around the table, what other people were using AI for, in 1645 01:17:57,484 --> 01:17:59,074 some cases, trivial kind of things. 1646 01:17:59,284 --> 01:18:02,684 I learned things that never realized that even could exist. 1647 01:18:02,754 --> 01:18:05,924 Evan Troxel: See, this is, this is exactly the conversation we just had 1648 01:18:05,924 --> 01:18:10,674 about finding out what young people are doing with AI, like, flexing that muscle. 1649 01:18:10,773 --> 01:18:12,834 And so Carl did that for a hundred days. 1650 01:18:12,894 --> 01:18:16,324 Kevin Kelly, you know, one of the internet, early internet pioneers, mid 1651 01:18:16,324 --> 01:18:20,799 journey, every single day would Just to play with it, just to figure out what 1652 01:18:20,799 --> 01:18:23,709 it could do to find out what worked, find out what different didn't work. 1653 01:18:23,719 --> 01:18:26,469 And that, that to me is really about like kind of flexing this 1654 01:18:26,839 --> 01:18:29,129 muscle and just playing with it. 1655 01:18:29,139 --> 01:18:32,229 Like there's no, there's nothing on the line here, right? 1656 01:18:32,534 --> 01:18:37,114 Phil Read: No, and it's not, and we're all high performing technologists, so we're 1657 01:18:37,114 --> 01:18:41,604 not really concerned about someone coming up with an idea and then shooting it full 1658 01:18:41,604 --> 01:18:42,994 of arrows, well that's not going to work. 1659 01:18:43,023 --> 01:18:47,273 What we really want is, this is a hard problem, and it's costing 1660 01:18:47,273 --> 01:18:49,554 me stress and time and money. 1661 01:18:49,764 --> 01:18:52,817 How are you guys approaching this, because they're not presentations, they're, you 1662 01:18:52,817 --> 01:18:56,609 know, Discussions and we just go around the table and then eventually the, you 1663 01:18:56,609 --> 01:19:00,209 know, the discussions go back and forth and from different angles and talk about 1664 01:19:00,209 --> 01:19:03,949 a number of, of business related topics. 1665 01:19:03,959 --> 01:19:08,231 Harlan Brum, who's a product manager for Revit, led a discussion or 1666 01:19:08,231 --> 01:19:13,484 facilitated a discussion on the future of documentation and we all 1667 01:19:13,494 --> 01:19:15,023 realize it's a really hard problem. 1668 01:19:15,164 --> 01:19:19,614 You just can't, and maybe what we're also trying to do is automate. 1669 01:19:20,265 --> 01:19:20,455 an 1670 01:19:20,465 --> 01:19:23,885 inefficient process, and maybe that's not the best thing to do. 1671 01:19:23,905 --> 01:19:27,085 So to the, one of the submissions this year, and I expect he's going to come 1672 01:19:27,085 --> 01:19:30,965 along, is a guy named Scott Brown, who's the National BIM Manager for BECC. 1673 01:19:31,225 --> 01:19:32,825 And BECC is a design build firm. 1674 01:19:33,385 --> 01:19:38,495 And Scott showed me a documentation method at Autodesk University. 1675 01:19:38,755 --> 01:19:41,635 In a trivial way, we were just at dinner and he opened his iPad like, 1676 01:19:41,635 --> 01:19:42,735 Hey, Scott, what's interesting. 1677 01:19:42,745 --> 01:19:44,125 He's like, well, I'm working on this thing. 1678 01:19:44,125 --> 01:19:45,115 You want to see this thing? 1679 01:19:45,395 --> 01:19:48,455 And I dreamt about the conversation we had at dinner that night. 1680 01:19:48,455 --> 01:19:50,755 And I was going, well, Scott, how would you do this? 1681 01:19:50,755 --> 01:19:51,775 And what about that? 1682 01:19:52,015 --> 01:19:53,805 And we were still having the conversation. 1683 01:19:53,805 --> 01:19:56,215 So he must've really got into my head a bit. 1684 01:19:56,434 --> 01:19:58,085 And I said, Scott, this is profound. 1685 01:19:58,115 --> 01:20:02,455 I think you should present this one evening at the round table event and just 1686 01:20:02,455 --> 01:20:05,235 show a room of 30 or 40 technologists. 1687 01:20:05,255 --> 01:20:07,495 This is how I'm doing documentation. 1688 01:20:07,495 --> 01:20:10,845 And we have, and by we, I mean, Beck, Beck has to be accountable 1689 01:20:10,845 --> 01:20:13,975 from the design through the implementation of the construction. 1690 01:20:14,545 --> 01:20:15,845 And he's like, Oh yeah, I'll do that. 1691 01:20:16,675 --> 01:20:19,645 Paint a target on his chest and present it in front of a bunch 1692 01:20:19,645 --> 01:20:21,395 of high performing technology 1693 01:20:21,960 --> 01:20:25,520 Evan Troxel: But, but what's so cool about these events is like, you can 1694 01:20:25,520 --> 01:20:30,880 totally be safe and vulnerable and, and like it really isn't a target, right? 1695 01:20:30,920 --> 01:20:34,470 It's like, if it was at AU and you were presenting that, it absolutely, it's 1696 01:20:34,470 --> 01:20:37,055 just, it's a different, it's a different 1697 01:20:37,600 --> 01:20:41,896 Phil Read: Yeah at light at Autodesk University is a very kind of um, It's 1698 01:20:41,896 --> 01:20:45,206 a very lecture environment where hold your questions to the end or maybe 1699 01:20:45,216 --> 01:20:47,166 ask questions as you go along Where I 1700 01:20:47,414 --> 01:20:50,925 Evan Troxel: But there's also a spotlight and a stage and a screen 1701 01:20:50,936 --> 01:20:52,856 and a PowerPoint and a video. 1702 01:20:53,306 --> 01:20:54,846 Phil Read: There's a uh, there's a power 1703 01:20:55,006 --> 01:20:55,626 Evan Troxel: stakes. 1704 01:20:56,333 --> 01:20:56,476 Right? 1705 01:20:56,516 --> 01:20:56,806 Yeah. 1706 01:20:57,186 --> 01:21:00,206 Phil Read: Um, there's an adult child kind of relationship. 1707 01:21:00,236 --> 01:21:02,296 I am the speaker and you are the listener. 1708 01:21:02,656 --> 01:21:06,466 Um, and so you don't want to ask questions that might put the speaker on the spot. 1709 01:21:06,946 --> 01:21:13,646 What Scott showed me was a sit back, drop my napkin, gobsmacked moment going, 1710 01:21:13,686 --> 01:21:17,246 Oh my gosh, I can't believe that works. 1711 01:21:17,406 --> 01:21:20,566 And it's, and, and without, I don't want to give it away because I want Scott to 1712 01:21:20,566 --> 01:21:25,236 really present this, but it is a return to first practices using new technology. 1713 01:21:25,871 --> 01:21:30,981 And, um, I would say it orders, orders of magnitude simplifies the 1714 01:21:30,981 --> 01:21:34,181 instruction, the process of creating instructions to build buildings 1715 01:21:34,386 --> 01:21:34,996 Evan Troxel: Interesting. 1716 01:21:35,701 --> 01:21:35,821 and, 1717 01:21:35,821 --> 01:21:38,881 they, these, these are not recorded and they're not shared afterward. 1718 01:21:38,881 --> 01:21:39,541 Like, you, you have 1719 01:21:39,561 --> 01:21:40,391 Phil Read: No, you got to be there. 1720 01:21:40,611 --> 01:21:41,761 Yeah, and we think that's important. 1721 01:21:41,771 --> 01:21:43,721 We've had people ask, oh, will these be recorded? 1722 01:21:43,721 --> 01:21:44,791 Can I download it later? 1723 01:21:45,131 --> 01:21:46,241 And I think that's just. 1724 01:21:47,111 --> 01:21:48,311 It's not worth the investment. 1725 01:21:48,351 --> 01:21:49,541 That's just so transactional. 1726 01:21:49,550 --> 01:21:52,731 You really want to be there to interact and to understand at the moment. 1727 01:21:53,261 --> 01:21:56,941 And, uh, I think if Scott goes forward with this and opens it up and shows people 1728 01:21:56,941 --> 01:21:59,981 what he's doing, he's going to end up creating a template that people will be 1729 01:21:59,981 --> 01:22:02,751 able to use to document their projects. 1730 01:22:02,751 --> 01:22:08,231 And this is a, in Revit terms, you know, the Warb template, like project template. 1731 01:22:09,050 --> 01:22:14,594 I think this template will scale To a residence all the way up to the largest, 1732 01:22:14,594 --> 01:22:16,184 most complex projects in the world. 1733 01:22:16,238 --> 01:22:16,619 Evan Troxel: world. 1734 01:22:16,619 --> 01:22:16,879 Wow. 1735 01:22:17,273 --> 01:22:18,304 Phil Read: And, um, 1736 01:22:18,754 --> 01:22:22,154 it's, it enormously simplifies the documentation process. 1737 01:22:22,674 --> 01:22:26,554 And because I think it's part of the artifact is because, uh, the reason this 1738 01:22:26,554 --> 01:22:31,154 has evolved is because Beck is accountable from the design through the construction. 1739 01:22:31,394 --> 01:22:34,324 So he's trying to simplify the communication process as well. 1740 01:22:35,034 --> 01:22:38,523 Um, so I think what we've used technology for was to create 1741 01:22:38,534 --> 01:22:40,555 a more efficient way of making 1742 01:22:40,555 --> 01:22:41,155 drawings. 1743 01:22:41,488 --> 01:22:46,978 which has resulted in this incredibly complex method of naming and enumerating 1744 01:22:47,548 --> 01:22:52,948 sheets and where the sheets go in the set and, you know, hundreds and 1745 01:22:52,948 --> 01:22:56,848 hundreds of sheets of drawings for not complex buildings, but it's an 1746 01:22:56,848 --> 01:23:00,028 artifact of how drawings have evolved. 1747 01:23:00,048 --> 01:23:01,618 And Scott's just gone right back to 1748 01:23:01,688 --> 01:23:05,598 Evan Troxel: with politics, with country, like there's, there's so 1749 01:23:05,598 --> 01:23:07,907 much else kind of muddying that right. 1750 01:23:07,918 --> 01:23:09,368 Create, making it what it's become. 1751 01:23:10,163 --> 01:23:12,863 Phil Read: Yeah, so what he did, it just, it just so surprised me 1752 01:23:12,863 --> 01:23:17,103 and even the name, the, the name or the metaphor he's come up for this 1753 01:23:17,113 --> 01:23:18,993 process is even beautiful as well. 1754 01:23:19,353 --> 01:23:21,113 So yeah, so good on you, Scott. 1755 01:23:21,282 --> 01:23:23,192 Yeah, he's a, he's a curious guy. 1756 01:23:23,462 --> 01:23:24,572 So that's what, so that's what we'll do. 1757 01:23:24,572 --> 01:23:28,232 We'll have the same kind of, you went to the, uh, leadership retreat, so 1758 01:23:28,232 --> 01:23:32,102 you'll know it'll be the same, uh, we intend to have the same kind of process 1759 01:23:32,102 --> 01:23:36,322 where people arrive Sunday, try to start to detach, get in the moment of 1760 01:23:36,322 --> 01:23:40,152 talking, catching up with people, um, and then Monday will be the off site 1761 01:23:40,152 --> 01:23:42,302 event, Tuesday, Wednesday, and Thursday. 1762 01:23:43,342 --> 01:23:45,902 Roundtable to best practice discussions 9 a. 1763 01:23:45,902 --> 01:23:46,112 m. 1764 01:23:46,112 --> 01:23:46,782 1030 a. 1765 01:23:46,782 --> 01:23:46,892 m. 1766 01:23:46,892 --> 01:23:47,291 1 p. 1767 01:23:47,291 --> 01:23:47,642 m. 1768 01:23:48,062 --> 01:23:52,742 from 2 30 until 5 o'clock afternoons open So go down to the lake learn how to 1769 01:23:52,742 --> 01:23:58,802 e foil We'll have the ski boats out go for a paddle board and or talk just talk 1770 01:23:58,802 --> 01:24:04,072 with you know Fellow peers ask questions come up end up having a discussion 1771 01:24:04,072 --> 01:24:06,782 about something You didn't think you were gonna have a discussion about that 1772 01:24:06,832 --> 01:24:10,212 turns out to be really important and then we'll probably have an evening 1773 01:24:10,222 --> 01:24:15,412 you So dinner is usually six and then seven o'clock, kind of just have a, 1774 01:24:15,692 --> 01:24:21,062 uh, uh, um, it's all informal, but have an informal discussion about an idea. 1775 01:24:21,062 --> 01:24:24,852 And that's where I would like Scott to present this, um, because I think 1776 01:24:24,852 --> 01:24:26,102 it's going to take a longer discussion. 1777 01:24:26,102 --> 01:24:28,322 We don't want to be constrained by, okay, this is the 1778 01:24:28,662 --> 01:24:30,072 Evan Troxel: We gotta do this next thing. 1779 01:24:30,072 --> 01:24:30,672 10 38. 1780 01:24:30,672 --> 01:24:30,852 Yeah. 1781 01:24:30,852 --> 01:24:31,272 No, it's 1782 01:24:31,352 --> 01:24:33,242 Phil Read: like, wow, okay, let's talk about 1783 01:24:33,282 --> 01:24:34,152 Evan Troxel: where this goes. 1784 01:24:34,227 --> 01:24:39,017 Phil Read: Yeah, okay, now we're going to go out to the campfire out 1785 01:24:39,047 --> 01:24:42,657 by the lake and we'll keep talking about it, you know, after he's, so we 1786 01:24:42,657 --> 01:24:45,547 don't have PowerPoint presentations, but I think for this we might end 1787 01:24:45,547 --> 01:24:47,577 up having a projector and a screen 1788 01:24:48,522 --> 01:24:49,092 Evan Troxel: so you can 1789 01:24:49,317 --> 01:24:50,157 Phil Read: TV and a, you 1790 01:24:50,197 --> 01:24:51,127 Evan Troxel: something to look at. 1791 01:24:51,277 --> 01:24:53,257 Phil Read: TV and a screen and Scott's going to say, it's 1792 01:24:53,257 --> 01:24:54,407 what I've been thinking about. 1793 01:24:54,844 --> 01:24:59,818 So, the, um, the other thing about the event is, We, we, I don't know if Adam 1794 01:24:59,818 --> 01:25:03,289 and I have been too clever about this, but we got excited about the idea of 1795 01:25:03,289 --> 01:25:09,129 theming the event, and we're looking for submissions of, uh, facilitated 1796 01:25:09,139 --> 01:25:12,449 discussions around the theme of better storytelling through technology. 1797 01:25:13,459 --> 01:25:15,764 But I don't know if that's And Adam and I are going to 1798 01:25:15,764 --> 01:25:16,954 talk about it again this week. 1799 01:25:16,974 --> 01:25:21,254 Have we constrained it too much or, or, or put a form around it that people go, 1800 01:25:21,254 --> 01:25:26,424 Oh, I don't know if my idea about this topic or discussion is really about better 1801 01:25:26,424 --> 01:25:28,354 storytelling, maybe I shouldn't submit it. 1802 01:25:28,654 --> 01:25:30,924 So maybe we need to pull back from that and go, no, no, no. 1803 01:25:30,924 --> 01:25:35,835 If you're, if you have, something that you want to discuss with a room of other, 1804 01:25:36,175 --> 01:25:41,315 you know, best practice leaders and people who think deeply about the technology 1805 01:25:41,315 --> 01:25:43,565 and how it's implemented about any topic. 1806 01:25:44,445 --> 01:25:45,996 That is important. 1807 01:25:45,996 --> 01:25:46,716 Curiosity. 1808 01:25:46,925 --> 01:25:47,076 It. 1809 01:25:47,196 --> 01:25:47,976 It's curiosity. 1810 01:25:48,156 --> 01:25:49,806 Then you should submit that topic. 1811 01:25:50,046 --> 01:25:53,196 Evan Troxel: I mean, the thing about this audience, I think, is that 1812 01:25:53,346 --> 01:25:54,916 they are the people who tinker. 1813 01:25:55,336 --> 01:25:55,666 Right? 1814 01:25:55,726 --> 01:26:01,175 We, we, we tinker with stuff, because we build tools, we, we design things, 1815 01:26:01,196 --> 01:26:05,766 like, you, you chase your curiosities, you know, you, in the 90s it was 1816 01:26:05,766 --> 01:26:08,826 like everybody learned how to code a website by hand, right, because, 1817 01:26:09,146 --> 01:26:12,156 and there was no, you couldn't do a course back then, it was like, 1818 01:26:12,456 --> 01:26:13,086 Phil Read: You just had to figure it 1819 01:26:13,246 --> 01:26:15,386 Evan Troxel: you view source, and you'd copy and paste, and 1820 01:26:15,386 --> 01:26:16,556 you would figure it out, right? 1821 01:26:16,576 --> 01:26:19,286 And, but, but, there's new versions of that, like what, what you're 1822 01:26:19,286 --> 01:26:20,606 saying Scott's doing, right? 1823 01:26:20,606 --> 01:26:21,356 It was like, right. 1824 01:26:21,720 --> 01:26:25,930 Something led to something else, and it led him down this path, and, and, I'm sure 1825 01:26:25,930 --> 01:26:29,559 he never saw that coming, but everybody's got something, everybody has that story, 1826 01:26:29,610 --> 01:26:34,020 and the, and it's like, what's, what's the current version of that story for you? 1827 01:26:34,465 --> 01:26:39,230 Do you think a group of 20 to 40 people would 1828 01:26:39,799 --> 01:26:43,639 the right audience for you to throw it out there and then see what comes back like 1829 01:26:44,029 --> 01:26:46,809 To me it is it is it is not transactional. 1830 01:26:46,839 --> 01:26:51,429 It is not it's not that one way Here's my idea take forth 1831 01:26:51,429 --> 01:26:53,159 and like go forth and prosper. 1832 01:26:53,169 --> 01:26:55,119 It's not that it's like oh, well, what about this? 1833 01:26:55,148 --> 01:26:58,344 Oh, have you thought about it like this and you're gonna get it Out of it 1834 01:26:58,754 --> 01:26:59,284 Phil Read: Oh, there'll be more 1835 01:26:59,454 --> 01:27:00,644 Evan Troxel: even put into it, right? 1836 01:27:00,644 --> 01:27:03,554 And, and so there's, so, so yeah, like labeling it under 1837 01:27:03,554 --> 01:27:05,104 the idea of storytelling. 1838 01:27:05,104 --> 01:27:09,754 People may not think that they have a good enough story, but everybody definitely has 1839 01:27:09,784 --> 01:27:12,414 Phil Read: Like if you say, if we said better communication through 1840 01:27:12,414 --> 01:27:15,474 technology, because sometimes as technologists we get excited about 1841 01:27:15,984 --> 01:27:19,304 the artifact of the technology and really what is the implication of 1842 01:27:19,304 --> 01:27:21,234 it or how, how do you use it well? 1843 01:27:21,404 --> 01:27:23,804 You can use technology to do lazy things, right? 1844 01:27:24,081 --> 01:27:24,611 but what I. 1845 01:27:25,201 --> 01:27:28,561 Well, I think Scott has done, and I could even be in my own bubble right 1846 01:27:28,561 --> 01:27:32,821 now, because I mean it was, I don't, I tend not to get surprised a lot. 1847 01:27:33,081 --> 01:27:36,631 I think I got surprised at Revit, I got surprised at SketchUp, I got surprised 1848 01:27:36,631 --> 01:27:41,171 at Enscape, um, I got surprised at cars that drive themselves, right? 1849 01:27:41,181 --> 01:27:43,711 That's, and that's over a 20 year period, like four or five things 1850 01:27:43,751 --> 01:27:45,291 surprised me, technology wise. 1851 01:27:46,296 --> 01:27:51,175 When I saw what Scott was working on, I was really, I'm like, this is beautiful. 1852 01:27:51,456 --> 01:27:54,786 And I, and I really want him to, to show this to a group of 30, 40 1853 01:27:54,786 --> 01:27:59,466 people and just have them go, Oh my gosh, like, could we do this? 1854 01:27:59,496 --> 01:28:00,196 Could we do that? 1855 01:28:00,236 --> 01:28:04,016 And if, and that could be a spark that I think does profoundly 1856 01:28:05,046 --> 01:28:10,186 improve the process of creating instructions to build buildings. 1857 01:28:11,086 --> 01:28:11,356 Evan Troxel: Cool. 1858 01:28:11,416 --> 01:28:12,866 Phil Read: Yeah, he's, he's a great guy. 1859 01:28:12,936 --> 01:28:13,126 Yeah. 1860 01:28:13,126 --> 01:28:16,516 So if anyone's out there, you know, that the topic is better storytelling 1861 01:28:16,516 --> 01:28:17,956 through technology, or that's a theme. 1862 01:28:18,526 --> 01:28:21,786 Yeah, if we've been too clever about that, just ignore it, and just 1863 01:28:21,786 --> 01:28:23,286 propose a really great discussion, 1864 01:28:23,476 --> 01:28:23,746 Evan Troxel: Yeah. 1865 01:28:24,136 --> 01:28:26,756 Phil Read: something that's, uh, led by your curiosity. 1866 01:28:26,951 --> 01:28:30,641 Evan Troxel: And what, what's the, so, so you, I mean there's a date 1867 01:28:30,731 --> 01:28:35,111 coming up, but what are the, what, how does it work with proposing these? 1868 01:28:35,175 --> 01:28:38,046 Phil Read: I think, you know, well, okay, so we have to have a, you have 1869 01:28:38,046 --> 01:28:41,516 to have a date, a deadline somewhere, so we're looking around the 27th 1870 01:28:41,516 --> 01:28:45,386 of December is the deadline for submissions, and then registration 1871 01:28:45,386 --> 01:28:47,226 will start the first week of January. 1872 01:28:47,796 --> 01:28:49,546 You know, there's only over three days. 1873 01:28:50,066 --> 01:28:53,046 It's nine to 12 discussion sessions. 1874 01:28:53,666 --> 01:28:55,166 So we can go through those pretty quickly. 1875 01:28:55,166 --> 01:28:56,626 We don't have to create a big committee. 1876 01:28:57,086 --> 01:29:00,186 Um, it'll be Adam, me, and maybe a couple of others just go through them 1877 01:29:00,186 --> 01:29:01,996 and discuss them and pick, pick them. 1878 01:29:02,541 --> 01:29:06,841 And, uh, and then open up registration probably first week of January. 1879 01:29:06,881 --> 01:29:12,181 And then the event I believe is the 27th of April through the 1880 01:29:12,181 --> 01:29:15,401 2nd of May, Sunday to Friday. 1881 01:29:16,071 --> 01:29:16,421 Yeah. 1882 01:29:17,351 --> 01:29:19,331 That gets everybody on site for the offsite. 1883 01:29:19,781 --> 01:29:20,201 Monday. 1884 01:29:20,241 --> 01:29:21,571 Otherwise, you can't show up Monday. 1885 01:29:21,571 --> 01:29:22,241 We're already gone. 1886 01:29:23,653 --> 01:29:23,973 Evan Troxel: To me, 1887 01:29:23,973 --> 01:29:28,457 this is an event where, like, it really is worth investing in yourself in. 1888 01:29:28,467 --> 01:29:32,817 Even if you can't get corporate to pay for it, or, I don't know. 1889 01:29:32,887 --> 01:29:35,161 You know, like, coming away from this. 1890 01:29:35,625 --> 01:29:39,615 This is the best event in AEC that I've ever attended. 1891 01:29:40,055 --> 01:29:42,455 And so I'm not just saying that cause I'm sitting here with you 1892 01:29:42,455 --> 01:29:44,315 in Denver airport face to face. 1893 01:29:44,635 --> 01:29:45,365 It really is. 1894 01:29:45,365 --> 01:29:47,745 I mean, it was super, super impactful. 1895 01:29:48,434 --> 01:29:52,934 And so I feel like, like it's worth submitting an idea, but 1896 01:29:52,934 --> 01:29:54,295 it's also worth just attending. 1897 01:29:54,520 --> 01:29:57,980 Phil Read: In practical terms, the reason we announced this top, 1898 01:29:57,980 --> 01:30:03,480 the call for submission topics or session topics in, after Autodesk 1899 01:30:03,480 --> 01:30:06,790 University, is because the dust has finally settled for people having, 1900 01:30:06,800 --> 01:30:08,040 you know, they've got to get to AU. 1901 01:30:08,110 --> 01:30:11,665 And it also gives people I'll give credit to Nick Kramer. 1902 01:30:11,665 --> 01:30:14,525 He said, you need to tell people how much this is going to cost and when it's 1903 01:30:14,525 --> 01:30:18,945 going to be, uh, in the third quarter or fourth quarter of, I'm like, why? 1904 01:30:18,955 --> 01:30:20,434 He goes, well, we have to ask for budget. 1905 01:30:20,455 --> 01:30:23,684 And it never occurred to me, you know, my own business owner and Adam and I 1906 01:30:23,695 --> 01:30:25,365 have a lot of leeway with what we do. 1907 01:30:25,655 --> 01:30:27,155 Not everybody gets to do that. 1908 01:30:27,395 --> 01:30:31,755 So they have to ask for budget and planning before the end of the year. 1909 01:30:31,755 --> 01:30:34,975 Don't surprise them in January or February and say, Oh, we're having this event. 1910 01:30:34,975 --> 01:30:35,575 You should come. 1911 01:30:35,605 --> 01:30:36,175 Cause then. 1912 01:30:36,800 --> 01:30:38,800 They've got to ask for a budget they didn't ask for, and it 1913 01:30:38,800 --> 01:30:41,110 looks like they don't know how to plan their time and money. 1914 01:30:41,430 --> 01:30:44,030 So that's why we put it out this fall. 1915 01:30:44,320 --> 01:30:47,170 Um, and actually we've announced the dates for both events, the 1916 01:30:47,180 --> 01:30:50,480 spring events, the end of April, and the fall event, the leadership 1917 01:30:50,510 --> 01:30:51,990 retreat, will be the end of October. 1918 01:30:52,020 --> 01:30:54,809 We're going to get out of the hurricane path for a change 1919 01:30:55,150 --> 01:30:56,440 and stop doing it at the end of 1920 01:30:56,809 --> 01:30:57,830 Evan Troxel: Cause it is in Florida. 1921 01:30:57,920 --> 01:31:01,020 Phil Read: Yeah, and if you look at the bell curve of when hurricanes rough 1922 01:31:01,020 --> 01:31:04,559 weather happens in Florida, it's all right at the second half of September 1923 01:31:04,678 --> 01:31:07,708 Evan Troxel: And people who don't know hurricane weather like me, 1924 01:31:07,708 --> 01:31:11,128 or, you know, others from Canada and, you know, the West coast, 1925 01:31:12,157 --> 01:31:15,918 Phil Read: this year one the week the week before and the week after 1926 01:31:15,918 --> 01:31:19,618 the event we had Uh, Hurricanes pass. 1927 01:31:19,988 --> 01:31:22,568 We didn't get impacted, but it was just like, okay, it messes 1928 01:31:22,568 --> 01:31:23,768 with travel, and I thought, this 1929 01:31:23,868 --> 01:31:25,077 Evan Troxel: there was a lot of worry about it. 1930 01:31:25,308 --> 01:31:25,928 Phil Read: Oh yeah, it creates 1931 01:31:25,948 --> 01:31:27,058 Evan Troxel: Should I even go? 1932 01:31:27,058 --> 01:31:27,718 Because, 1933 01:31:27,827 --> 01:31:28,528 Phil Read: Yep, yep. 1934 01:31:28,668 --> 01:31:31,808 No, we were going to go on the Chautauqua Springs, and it turned out that the, 1935 01:31:31,808 --> 01:31:34,622 uh, the river Ended up full of trees. 1936 01:31:34,622 --> 01:31:37,352 And so we ended up going to Silver Springs and that was the Thursday 1937 01:31:37,352 --> 01:31:41,282 or the Wednesday before the event, that river is still not clear. 1938 01:31:41,482 --> 01:31:44,682 So we, yeah, months later, they're having to pull trees out of it. 1939 01:31:45,032 --> 01:31:50,082 So we'll do that event at the end of April or sorry, at the end of October for the 1940 01:31:50,082 --> 01:31:52,032 fall event and stay out of the storm, 1941 01:31:52,550 --> 01:31:53,059 The 1942 01:31:53,070 --> 01:31:54,090 peak of the bell curve. 1943 01:31:54,487 --> 01:31:55,957 Evan Troxel: But it's an amazing location. 1944 01:31:56,467 --> 01:31:58,007 Uh, it's really quiet. 1945 01:31:58,257 --> 01:32:01,307 You actually can unplug the wifi is not great, 1946 01:32:01,727 --> 01:32:02,367 Phil Read: It's, it's good 1947 01:32:02,597 --> 01:32:05,157 Evan Troxel: is fine, which is actually I think a bonus because 1948 01:32:05,157 --> 01:32:09,747 then you're less distracted and you're more grounded, I think, in the 1949 01:32:09,747 --> 01:32:11,647 people and in the place of the event. 1950 01:32:12,237 --> 01:32:15,047 So all of that I think adds up to 1951 01:32:15,597 --> 01:32:17,287 Phil Read: We haven't figured out how to make this. 1952 01:32:17,597 --> 01:32:22,207 If we should scale it, like, I don't think more than the number of people that fit 1953 01:32:22,207 --> 01:32:26,537 on one motor coach should ever attend because we don't want the artifact of, of 1954 01:32:26,537 --> 01:32:30,571 having to print lanyards and having to, like, we don't have exhibitors, we don't 1955 01:32:30,571 --> 01:32:32,361 have lanyards, we don't have sponsors. 1956 01:32:32,691 --> 01:32:35,851 I don't want to turn into the event location and say, brought 1957 01:32:35,851 --> 01:32:38,741 to you by XYZ software company. 1958 01:32:39,021 --> 01:32:41,001 Just like the moment you get there, you're there. 1959 01:32:41,001 --> 01:32:42,281 It's everything is authentic. 1960 01:32:42,681 --> 01:32:47,557 So from the standpoint of it scaling as a, money making hand, you know, 1961 01:32:47,557 --> 01:32:51,465 hand over fist money making venture, I don't think we aspire to that 1962 01:32:51,475 --> 01:32:52,835 or we've even figured that out. 1963 01:32:52,835 --> 01:32:56,455 We, we would like to, I, I would like to try to take this concept of 1964 01:32:56,715 --> 01:33:01,460 technical round table, And six months later, Leadership Roundtable, and go 1965 01:33:01,460 --> 01:33:07,040 to the other hemisphere, like try to do Australia or New Zealand or somewhere 1966 01:33:07,040 --> 01:33:08,910 else, but again, no more than 50 1967 01:33:09,305 --> 01:33:11,625 Evan Troxel: But people from the Southern Hemisphere come to this event 1968 01:33:11,811 --> 01:33:12,418 Phil Read: event, too. 1969 01:33:12,505 --> 01:33:13,835 Evan Troxel: it's a stretch, but they do it. 1970 01:33:13,934 --> 01:33:14,541 Phil Read: a stretch. 1971 01:33:14,541 --> 01:33:15,148 It is. 1972 01:33:15,148 --> 01:33:16,970 No, Carrie, uh, Carrie Thompson attended. 1973 01:33:16,970 --> 01:33:17,273 Right. 1974 01:33:17,273 --> 01:33:20,680 Uh, yeah, Callum Freeman from, uh, Assemble in New Zealand. 1975 01:33:21,190 --> 01:33:21,750 attended. 1976 01:33:22,020 --> 01:33:24,050 And they're both on, they're like, Hey, we should do this 1977 01:33:24,059 --> 01:33:25,690 in New Zealand or Australia. 1978 01:33:25,760 --> 01:33:27,290 And like, yeah, we have to find a place. 1979 01:33:27,290 --> 01:33:30,640 But we have an interesting Venn diagram at the camp that we go to 1980 01:33:30,640 --> 01:33:32,300 because we have a chef, private chef. 1981 01:33:32,320 --> 01:33:33,559 We have a commercial kitchen. 1982 01:33:34,390 --> 01:33:35,980 He gets to run the kitchen for the week. 1983 01:33:35,980 --> 01:33:37,980 So we have, I think meals are very important. 1984 01:33:37,980 --> 01:33:40,400 Conversations that happen around meals are important. 1985 01:33:41,070 --> 01:33:45,290 Chef Charles has just a joyful attitude to what he does. 1986 01:33:45,590 --> 01:33:48,390 And so having a legitimate French chef, 1987 01:33:48,666 --> 01:33:50,947 Evan Troxel: Think about the food that you're consuming and who it was 1988 01:33:50,947 --> 01:33:53,527 made by at this versus a production 1989 01:33:54,102 --> 01:33:56,712 Phil Read: Yeah, you're not standing in a line getting your food. 1990 01:33:56,722 --> 01:33:57,432 He brings it out. 1991 01:33:57,432 --> 01:34:01,112 It's all, it's all set, like a family, like here's your plates of 1992 01:34:01,152 --> 01:34:02,752 platters of food and a couple of 1993 01:34:02,767 --> 01:34:04,147 Evan Troxel: explains it all. 1994 01:34:04,357 --> 01:34:04,687 Yep. 1995 01:34:05,172 --> 01:34:10,716 Phil Read: So that kind of attention to detail and, um, and it's a camp. 1996 01:34:10,746 --> 01:34:13,716 So the accommodations are I would say austere. 1997 01:34:14,286 --> 01:34:17,866 They're not uncomfortable, but it's either like a motel style 1998 01:34:17,866 --> 01:34:23,796 room or a cabin style room where it's, you know, there's no campers. 1999 01:34:23,796 --> 01:34:26,812 It's just you're in the counselor's accommodation. 2000 01:34:26,822 --> 01:34:27,062 Questions 2001 01:34:27,232 --> 01:34:30,871 Evan Troxel: that came up from, so some people heard that I went, 2002 01:34:30,871 --> 01:34:33,041 I think I was at AU, and they're like, you went to that, right? 2003 01:34:33,041 --> 01:34:33,592 And I said, yeah. 2004 01:34:33,602 --> 01:34:36,832 And they said, is it true that you can bring your family? 2005 01:34:37,559 --> 01:34:37,762 Phil Read: Oh, 2006 01:34:37,832 --> 01:34:41,192 Evan Troxel: Because they heard that on the podcast and they said, is that true? 2007 01:34:41,232 --> 01:34:42,371 Like, like, like 2008 01:34:42,418 --> 01:34:43,121 Phil Read: Could you really do 2009 01:34:43,142 --> 01:34:44,312 Evan Troxel: were just making that up. 2010 01:34:44,682 --> 01:34:45,712 So, so talk about that 2011 01:34:45,822 --> 01:34:49,862 Phil Read: Yeah, so the idea is that, um, we wanted to have counselor led 2012 01:34:49,862 --> 01:34:53,082 activities for, you know, for kids during the day, and then in the 2013 01:34:53,082 --> 01:34:54,692 afternoons everybody can get together. 2014 01:34:55,041 --> 01:35:00,512 Um, Sylvia, who's a wonderful technologist around scanning, BIM scanning services, 2015 01:35:00,512 --> 01:35:02,612 modeling services of historic buildings. 2016 01:35:03,062 --> 01:35:05,082 Um, Mia came, and I think Mia's seven. 2017 01:35:05,477 --> 01:35:10,537 Very precocious, self motivated, and she was great the whole week. 2018 01:35:11,337 --> 01:35:12,007 And it worked. 2019 01:35:12,337 --> 01:35:15,697 So she's already, she was a little bit nervous about attending at first, 2020 01:35:15,697 --> 01:35:17,357 like she was going to be the only kid. 2021 01:35:18,139 --> 01:35:20,210 She's already said, Dad, I want to go back next year. 2022 01:35:20,600 --> 01:35:25,100 And, um, so we're trying to do it in such a way where, yeah, people 2023 01:35:25,100 --> 01:35:28,440 bring their kids, they're doing nature things during the day. 2024 01:35:29,130 --> 01:35:30,440 We don't, we just, 2025 01:35:30,885 --> 01:35:32,205 Evan Troxel: they don't have to sit in the conference 2026 01:35:32,330 --> 01:35:33,500 Phil Read: no, no, no, no, no. 2027 01:35:34,110 --> 01:35:34,330 Yeah. 2028 01:35:34,330 --> 01:35:37,620 Me as an edge condition, still sit in a conference room and listen to discussions 2029 01:35:37,620 --> 01:35:39,210 and, and draw on color all week. 2030 01:35:39,710 --> 01:35:43,040 And, uh, but no, it should be like, yeah, kids want to go off. 2031 01:35:43,040 --> 01:35:47,639 And, and, and the things they do is like teach kids to, uh, build fires or 2032 01:35:47,639 --> 01:35:52,020 build forts or the kinds of stuff that I used to do growing up in Florida. 2033 01:35:52,490 --> 01:35:54,730 Yeah, you go feral and you go build a fort in the woods. 2034 01:35:55,010 --> 01:35:58,230 So the idea is that they councilor led activities during the day for kids. 2035 01:35:58,230 --> 01:36:00,460 And it's just a nominal cost for the meals. 2036 01:36:00,460 --> 01:36:02,170 It's not, you know, much more at all. 2037 01:36:02,719 --> 01:36:03,010 yeah. 2038 01:36:03,100 --> 01:36:07,300 Evan Troxel: opportunities for, like, off site, you know, things that can happen 2039 01:36:07,320 --> 01:36:09,410 for, for, depending on who shows up. 2040 01:36:09,550 --> 01:36:10,000 Phil Read: yeah. 2041 01:36:10,110 --> 01:36:11,450 If, if, if you had. 2042 01:36:11,920 --> 01:36:13,630 partners show up and they want to go off. 2043 01:36:13,639 --> 01:36:16,270 There's, there's an enormity of interesting historic and 2044 01:36:16,270 --> 01:36:17,730 beautiful things in Florida to do. 2045 01:36:18,139 --> 01:36:18,870 Go off to St. 2046 01:36:18,870 --> 01:36:22,460 Augustine for the day and go shopping or old historic village. 2047 01:36:23,139 --> 01:36:27,840 But, um, yeah, it's legitimately like we had, uh, someone asking about driving. 2048 01:36:28,320 --> 01:36:29,430 They wanted to bring the whole family. 2049 01:36:29,440 --> 01:36:31,350 I think it was like three kids, mom and dad and like, yeah, go. 2050 01:36:31,370 --> 01:36:34,040 Mom and dad are both architects and they just wanted to know that they 2051 01:36:34,040 --> 01:36:36,165 could Legitimately bring the family. 2052 01:36:36,165 --> 01:36:36,434 Yeah. 2053 01:36:37,014 --> 01:36:40,735 We just haven't been, it's just that kind of new thing where no one's really 2054 01:36:40,735 --> 01:36:42,684 done it because it's not been done. 2055 01:36:43,525 --> 01:36:46,315 I don't know that people bring their families to au, I don't even think 2056 01:36:46,315 --> 01:36:50,035 you can get into the conference area at au under a certain age. 2057 01:36:50,065 --> 01:36:51,385 You have to be like 18 or older. 2058 01:36:51,995 --> 01:36:53,160 Uh, we had families that built, 2059 01:36:53,909 --> 01:36:58,129 because it was just kind of a, easy, relaxed atmosphere and people would bring 2060 01:36:58,129 --> 01:37:02,829 their families and, but yeah, definitely at Lake Swan, uh, you could bring families 2061 01:37:02,829 --> 01:37:05,839 and the kids could go on a paddleboard, do councilor led activities, and then 2062 01:37:05,969 --> 01:37:07,709 Evan Troxel: on the inner tube on behind the boat. 2063 01:37:07,889 --> 01:37:09,269 Go, go down the water slide. 2064 01:37:09,359 --> 01:37:09,689 Yeah. 2065 01:37:09,689 --> 01:37:09,959 There's a 2066 01:37:10,109 --> 01:37:14,199 Phil Read: wrap up video that Peter did shows Sylvia and Mia on the, uh, getting 2067 01:37:14,199 --> 01:37:15,909 pulled around on the big inflatable thing. 2068 01:37:15,909 --> 01:37:20,279 Yeah, yeah, so it's meant to be time to definitely think hard, but also 2069 01:37:20,299 --> 01:37:22,119 relax, try to disconnect a little bit. 2070 01:37:22,474 --> 01:37:27,174 It's an investment in, it should be an investment in future revenue, um, but 2071 01:37:27,174 --> 01:37:30,554 I think the best way to get there is by having conversations, not by sitting in 2072 01:37:30,554 --> 01:37:35,044 a room and just being fed presentations all the time in a, in a transactional way. 2073 01:37:35,044 --> 01:37:35,174 And 2074 01:37:35,339 --> 01:37:36,466 Evan Troxel: I think you 2075 01:37:36,880 --> 01:37:39,134 Phil Read: things And you can have both, I'm not saying the other one, like the 2076 01:37:39,164 --> 01:37:42,829 Autodesk University kind of, kind of approach, where you do have, you know 2077 01:37:43,259 --> 01:37:48,719 You know, sort of audience and presenter kind of format that's legitimate. 2078 01:37:48,818 --> 01:37:52,699 Evan Troxel: This is very participatory and, and contributory, right? 2079 01:37:52,719 --> 01:37:55,589 And in the, just the natural way that it works. 2080 01:37:55,619 --> 01:37:59,715 And to me, like, again, just reinforcing It was impactful. 2081 01:38:00,085 --> 01:38:01,785 It was professionally impactful. 2082 01:38:01,785 --> 01:38:03,135 It was personally impactful. 2083 01:38:03,205 --> 01:38:06,415 I built relationships with people who I'd never met before there. 2084 01:38:07,035 --> 01:38:11,605 There's a network because it's intentionally small that gets built up. 2085 01:38:11,625 --> 01:38:15,155 And I can see this being kind of a homecoming event that happens, but, 2086 01:38:15,165 --> 01:38:16,445 but there's room for new people. 2087 01:38:16,485 --> 01:38:18,165 I mean, it's, it's not exclusive. 2088 01:38:18,575 --> 01:38:20,305 And so, yeah. 2089 01:38:20,495 --> 01:38:21,014 Uh, 2090 01:38:21,210 --> 01:38:23,070 Phil Read: but it's, I think, I think authentic. 2091 01:38:23,070 --> 01:38:26,160 You know, having the offsite on Monday helps people to de posture a bit 2092 01:38:26,295 --> 01:38:26,555 Evan Troxel: Yeah, 2093 01:38:26,690 --> 01:38:27,740 Phil Read: and kind of just 2094 01:38:27,860 --> 01:38:28,790 Evan Troxel: Get to know each other. 2095 01:38:28,969 --> 01:38:31,590 Phil Read: and have conversations that aren't 2096 01:38:31,889 --> 01:38:32,630 Evan Troxel: ease into it. 2097 01:38:32,820 --> 01:38:33,770 It's lovely. 2098 01:38:33,800 --> 01:38:33,900 We 2099 01:38:33,900 --> 01:38:36,809 Phil Read: thought about doing it at the end, like it as a wrap up event. 2100 01:38:36,870 --> 01:38:37,200 Oh, okay. 2101 01:38:37,200 --> 01:38:39,570 We've all done this thing for the week now let's do an offsite, 2102 01:38:39,630 --> 01:38:40,535 and I think it was Henry. 2103 01:38:41,344 --> 01:38:44,184 Uh, give him credit with this idea of de posturing and doing it at the 2104 01:38:44,184 --> 01:38:48,820 beginning to help people kind of relax and feel more, uh, open and feel 2105 01:38:48,820 --> 01:38:50,700 authentic and then go into the event. 2106 01:38:50,950 --> 01:38:55,090 And that's proved itself out a better, better structure. 2107 01:38:56,260 --> 01:38:56,510 Evan Troxel: All right. 2108 01:38:56,510 --> 01:38:59,580 Well, Phil, I will endeavor to get this episode out before your deadline. 2109 01:39:00,820 --> 01:39:01,889 Phil Read: 27th of December. 2110 01:39:02,300 --> 01:39:05,340 Look, I think the main thing is people, people now, if they have to ask for 2111 01:39:05,340 --> 01:39:09,180 budget to do it and what do they want to attend and what do they want to events 2112 01:39:09,180 --> 01:39:10,960 do they want to contribute to next year? 2113 01:39:11,320 --> 01:39:16,091 Now, at least it could be, you know, they, they have, uh, they have advanced. 2114 01:39:17,916 --> 01:39:21,466 which we, to our detriment, we haven't done that in the past. 2115 01:39:21,466 --> 01:39:21,916 We should have. 2116 01:39:22,286 --> 01:39:25,646 So now we're letting people know in, yeah, we're letting people know in 2117 01:39:25,646 --> 01:39:27,366 quarter four instead of quarter one. 2118 01:39:27,501 --> 01:39:27,741 Evan Troxel: Cool. 2119 01:39:28,041 --> 01:39:28,221 Yeah. 2120 01:39:28,766 --> 01:39:29,236 Phil Read: Thanks, Evan. 2121 01:39:29,511 --> 01:39:33,261 Evan Troxel: Well, it's gonna be fun and uh, I wish you the best 'cause I won't 2122 01:39:33,261 --> 01:39:34,941 be able to attend that one, but I'm 2123 01:39:35,085 --> 01:39:38,076 Phil Read: The spring event, you can't, you've got obligations, but maybe in 2124 01:39:38,076 --> 01:39:40,116 the fall, get you back on the E Foil? 2125 01:39:40,146 --> 01:39:40,376 Yeah. 2126 01:39:41,716 --> 01:39:44,226 That's Evan doing the, uh, the lasso. 2127 01:39:44,236 --> 01:39:47,516 Was that you on, in the, in the, uh, wrap up video? 2128 01:39:47,769 --> 01:39:49,079 And you'd never done that before? 2129 01:39:49,818 --> 01:39:50,119 No. 2130 01:39:50,179 --> 01:39:50,849 And you got up? 2131 01:39:51,439 --> 01:39:51,799 Yeah. 2132 01:39:52,169 --> 01:39:52,769 Oh, great. 2133 01:39:52,839 --> 01:39:53,359 Thanks, Evan. 2134 01:39:53,359 --> 01:39:53,519 All right. 2135 01:39:53,549 --> 01:39:53,969 Evan Troxel: right. 2136 01:39:54,099 --> 01:39:54,749 Talk to you next time.