Host

What a fun time to bring you this episode.

Host

And I understand that some of you might be listening to this episode, you know, a number of months later, maybe even a year or two years later.

Host

So just so you know, where we at, it is early June 2023 and a couple of weeks back, Irish Wildlife Trust launched a campaign to ask the Irish government to conduct feasibility study for reintroducing or restoring, should I say, sturgeon into Irish water.

Host

It's a.

Host

It's a species of anadromous fish, European sturgeon or Atlantic sturgeon.

Host

There are two of them.

Host

So.

Host

So they launched that campaign and probably week later, or maybe two weeks later, Tadam.

Host

There's a big sturgeon found or caught.

Host

I think it was found.

Host

It's not, I'm not clear at this moment in the river.

Host

Sh.

Host

It's like first time in 30 years, Sturgeon in Irish waters.

Host

And by the way, that river is the same river.

Host

River where in 19th century was big sturgeon female was caught full of spawn.

Host

So this is the same river 30 years later, massive sturgeon, not that massive, but a big sturgeon found.

Host

So obviously cue the conspiracy theories.

Host

And week later, I'm coming with this podcast about Irish sturgeon.

Host

So I'm not a part of any conspiracy.

Host

I was trying to bring you that episode for about two years.

Host

I was working two years to get that episode.

Host

Not constantly, but on and off time, by time after time, encouraged by listeners, especially by one listeners shout out to Johnny.

Host

This episode is, you know, happened thanks to you and thanks to, you know, reminding me and kind of like encouraging me to do that episode.

Host

And the reason it took me so long is that it was really hard to find someone who could talk about sturgeon in Irish waters.

Host

Right?

Host

Irish sturgeon.

Host

It wasn't Irish sturgeon.

Host

Like I said, it was either European or Atlantic sturgeon, but let's say, you know, sturgeon and Irish or UK waters.

Host

And you know, there are three pillars to my podcast, so to say.

Host

Like pillar number one is obviously to present balanced view on every story.

Host

So bring the.

Host

Bring the voices and views from every side of a.

Host

Of every conservation or wildlife story.

Host

Pillar number two are scientific projects, scientific papers.

Host

You know, I recorded quite a few of those and a few more are already in a can.

Host

But the third pillar of the podcast that is not least, not less important, and probably it might turn out to be the most important over time, is to preserve the knowledge of how the nature used to look like to talk with people who had an opportunity to experience nature and, you know, how the natural environment looked like that is gone now just to preserve their knowledge, just preserve their experience.

Host

And this is one of those episodes.

Host

So during attending one of the those fish conferences, scientific conferences, I got in touch with gentleman named Declan Quigley.

Host

And I can only describe Declan as an independent researcher.

Host

He's an incredible person.

Host

He wrote over 460 articles and papers about the various species of fish and stuff like that.

Host

And he had like extensive knowledge and material related to sturgeon in Ireland.

Host

So that was great opportunity and I, you know, big thank you for to Declan and to his wife for inviting me to his house in Wicklow.

Host

And those of you who watched this episode on YouTube, you can see us sitting in Declan's kitchen and talking about sturgeon in Ireland.

Host

So as always you can access those articles and papers and links to Eilish Wildlife Trust blogs and all those things.

Host

If you're a subscriber to my newsletter.

Declan Quigley

The newsletter is for free.

Host

You can find a link in the description of this show going there, click on the link newsletter.thomas outdoors.com subscribe to the newsletter.

Host

And in that newsletter you're not only getting notifications about new episodes of the podcast, but you also getting all those extra links and articles and announcements and other other stuff that are related to what we talk on any given episode of the podcast.

Host

Okay, so subscribe to the newsletter and yeah, that's all for the introduction.

Host

Now all that's left is to invite you to enjoy the reminder of the episode of this podcast where I talk with Declan Quigley about sturgeon and Irish and UK waters for that matter, about the, you know, whether it's really feasible or realistic to bring them back, how it happened that they became extinct, problems with the sturgeon like the hybridizations and many other interesting things.

Host

So I'm sure you will enjoy this episode and yeah, that's it.

Host

Enjoy.

Declan Quigley

Declan, it is an absolute honor speaking with you.

Declan Quigley

Thank you so much for your time and welcome to the show.

Tommy

Thank you Tommy.

Tommy

You're very welcome.

Tommy

Twicklow.

Host

Haha.

Declan Quigley

Listen, when I was this episode I wanted to do this episode for probably two years and it was very hard to find anyone who knows anything about sturgeon in Ireland, about Irish sturgeon.

Declan Quigley

And you know those fish are, I'm very careful using term extinct.

Declan Quigley

I usually talk about extirpated like wolves, they're being extirpated from Ireland.

Declan Quigley

They're not extinct from Ireland.

Host

But I think that with in case.

Declan Quigley

Of sturgeon, it's more of a case that they're extinct because it was also Very hard to find any information about sturgeon, which tells me that also that knowledge about the fish is getting extinct.

Declan Quigley

So I am just delighted to be.

Host

Able to speak with you about those fantastic fish.

Tommy

Well, we have.

Expert

Let's say sturgeon are a very ancient fish.

Expert

They've been around since the time of the Jurassic, the dinosaurs, about 200 million years ago.

Expert

And they are regarded as living fossils because they haven't changed their morphology very much over the last 200 million years.

Expert

The fossil record verifies that they're an.

Tommy

Ancient fish because they also have an unusual.

Tommy

Their brain is not bony like a normal fish, right?

Expert

It's cartilaginous like a shark.

Expert

And they also have a notochord rather than vertebrae and have this unusual heterocercal tail.

Tommy

So at the moment, it's reckoned that.

Expert

There'S about 25 species of sturgeon that.

Tommy

Occur worldwide, mainly in temperate and tropical.

Expert

Areas in the Northern hemisphere, Only.

Tommy

In.

Expert

Irish waters here, northwest Europe, we have.

Tommy

At least two species, the European sturgeon.

Expert

And the Atlantic sturgeon, which is also found in North America.

Expert

When I started looking at sturgeon, it must be.

Expert

I've been writing articles for 45 years now and I've published more than 460 articles.

Expert

But when I start looking at sturgeon, I was surprised that there were very.

Tommy

Few references in the scientific literature about Irish sturgeon.

Tommy

So I found this unusual because it's such an iconic species that it generally.

Expert

Tends to draw media attention if one is caught.

Expert

So I decided to go and trawl.

Tommy

Through the Irish newspaper archives back to.

Expert

1738, and I came up with 243 records from Ireland.

Expert

So I was able to carry out quite a lot of detailed analysis on that.

Expert

And it was very surprising.

Tommy

The results, actually.

Tommy

Sturgeon in general are regarded as critically endangered species, not just in Ireland here.

Expert

But across the whole world.

Expert

There is only one spawning population of European sturgeon left in Europe, and that's in the River Garonne in Bay of.

Tommy

Biscay, whereas previously they were known to.

Expert

Spawn in the Rhine and the Elbe.

Expert

But there is no evidence that they actually spawned in Irish waters, or indeed.

Tommy

In UK waters, which is surprising, because.

Expert

If they were spawning in the Rhine, you would imagine that they would have spawned here as well.

Tommy

I came up with about 75% of the sturgeon records from Ireland here were all found in coastal waters, and about.

Expert

Half of those were found in the Irish sea.

Expert

Only about 25% of the records were found in estuarine waters, and very few.

Tommy

Actually in fresh water.

Tommy

So There is no evidence that they.

Expert

Actually spawned here, even though there was.

Tommy

One exceptionally large female that was caught in the river.

Expert

Sure.

Tommy

Back in the 1840s that was full of spawn.

Expert

And the guy who found it, he.

Tommy

Actually remarked that there was enough eggs in that female to supply the whole.

Expert

Of that river system.

Tommy

But she would have need to have.

Expert

Found a suitable mate.

Tommy

And there weren't very many of them around at the time either.

Declan Quigley

Declan, tell me, are they spawning in the freshwater?

Declan Quigley

Are they spawning in salt water?

Declan Quigley

Are they migrating?

Declan Quigley

What's their spawning behavior?

Expert

Most species of sturgeon are anadromous, that.

Tommy

Is, they're like salmon.

Tommy

They spawn in fresh water and they migrate to the sea to feed.

Expert

There are some species that occur in.

Tommy

China that spend all of their life in fresh water.

Tommy

But I say the most of them are like a salmon.

Tommy

They spawn in freshwater and go to.

Expert

Feed in the sea.

Expert

Now, even though there is no direct evidence that they spawned in Irish rivers, sturgeon is a highly migratory species.

Tommy

So the fish that we are.

Expert

Well, let's say the fish that we used to see in the Irish Sea.

Tommy

Were basically probably coming from the Goron.

Expert

And migrating northwards on the feeding migration.

Tommy

And I think they were attracted to.

Expert

The Irish Sea because they like shallow, sandy areas.

Expert

There was quite a lot of records.

Tommy

From Dundalk Bay, where some of their.

Expert

Favorite food occurs, which is cockles.

Expert

Yeah.

Expert

And also Dublin Bay.

Expert

This is going back to the 1800s.

Tommy

Again, I found some references recently actually to sturgeon.

Expert

Well, what, they weren't regarded as sturgeon, they were called.

Tommy

They thought there were salmon actually in the river in Limerick.

Tommy

The Shannon one was four and a half meters long, but it obviously wasn't the salmon.

Tommy

Subsequently there was a lot more records recorded from the River Shannon, but not upstream of Limerick.

Tommy

So again, there's no evidence, as you would imagine, that they.

Expert

If they were caught further upstream, they would have made news.

Expert

So the earliest records I've seen there.

Tommy

Is from the 12th century and they were mentioned in the Annals of inischvalen.

Tommy

It was 11:15.

Tommy

There's also a mural in Clonmacnoise showing a sturgeon.

Tommy

But again, there's no evidence that they actually were captured there.

Tommy

It's probably they came from down the stream in Limerick.

Tommy

So it's possible that while sturgeon may have been exploring the estuaries that they.

Expert

Didn'T go up any further, they were just feeding.

Expert

Now, because it's regarded as a critically.

Tommy

Endangered species, it's a pan European species, if you like, even though it's not, if you like doesn't spawn here.

Expert

And some people might not regard it.

Tommy

As native, but there's many species of fish that occur in European waters that.

Expert

Don'T actually spawn here.

Tommy

For example, bluefin tuna, they migrate up.

Expert

To Norway and they go back to.

Tommy

The Mediterranean or across to the western Atlantic to spawn.

Expert

And you also have like many cetacean.

Tommy

Species that are protected in Irish waters.

Expert

Which don't breed here.

Expert

They, they just migrate here as part.

Tommy

Of their normal feeding migration.

Tommy

And, and yet they regarded technically as native.

Expert

But basically the sturgeon is native to northwest Europe.

Expert

It's not necessarily endemic to Ireland.

Declan Quigley

Is it that there, there is a chance of seeing them again or is in Ireland or is it like the population is gone, gone and they have no chance to migrate?

Declan Quigley

So because I thought that they, there was like a Irish population, so called, and then they got, you know, killed, overfished, whatever you want to call it, extinct.

Declan Quigley

Is that the case or is it we still have a chance of actually seeing sturgeon in Irish waters potentially migrating from somewhere.

Tommy

As I say, there's one endemic population left in the River Garonne.

Tommy

Most of the sturgeon populations that frequented other European rivers are basically extinct, mainly due to the construction of barriers on the rivers, pollution, but primarily due to overexploitation as well.

Tommy

Well, up until in 1977, there was.

Expert

About 38,000 tons of sturgeon.

Tommy

And that's all species of sturgeon, wild.

Expert

Sturgeon that were commercially harvested.

Expert

But by 2011 that had dropped 400 tons.

Expert

And in the intervening years sturgeon farming.

Tommy

Has taken off and there's at least.

Expert

50,000 tons of sturgeon farmed worldwide.

Tommy

Now the French fisheries authorities have been attempting to breed the sturgeon in the River Garonne and release juveniles.

Expert

And they were doing that up until about 2007.

Tommy

And they were expecting, if successful, that.

Expert

The adults would be returning last year.

Tommy

Or from last year because they're a.

Expert

Very slow growing fish.

Tommy

They don't mature until they're 15 or.

Expert

16 years at least.

Expert

So it's a very long term.

Tommy

Project.

Expert

To try and reintroduce sturgeon.

Tommy

Successfully, it seems anyway.

Tommy

So hopefully if the Garonne project is successful, we will begin to see more sturgeon in Irish waters and further northward.

Expert

It would be nice to sort of.

Tommy

Think that we could farm sturgeon here for restocking, but it's hard to kind.

Expert

Of argue the case when they were.

Tommy

Never regarded or is no evidence that.

Expert

They were actually spawning here.

Expert

But we do have some of the largest and cleanest rivers in Europe in.

Tommy

Ireland so maybe it could become a donor population here.

Tommy

Now, there's been lots of issues as well.

Tommy

Sturgeon can easily hybridize the species, and farming of sturgeon has kind of crossbred.

Expert

Various species, basically because they give better growth rates.

Expert

Okay.

Tommy

And a lot of the smaller sturgeon.

Expert

End up in the pet trade.

Expert

When you put a sturgeon in your.

Tommy

Fish tank and a year later, it.

Expert

Might have gone in at 5 or.

Tommy

6 grams, and it's a kilo, so.

Expert

They quickly outgrow their.

Tommy

Fish tank, aquarium, and I suppose people don't want to.

Expert

Kill the fish, so they may release it into the wild.

Tommy

And this can create lots of problems if you're trying to introduce or rehabilitate native sturgeon populations.

Declan Quigley

Declan, I got to ask you about the sturgeon farming.

Declan Quigley

We know what environmental problems are with salmon farming, with sea lice and waste and all that.

Declan Quigley

Are there similar problems, environmental problems with sturgeon farming, or is it, like, a little bit cleaner endeavor?

Expert

Well, I'd be a little bit biased myself in answering that question because I'm.

Tommy

A salmon farmer myself and have been.

Expert

For most of my life.

Tommy

But the sturgeon.

Tommy

The farming of sturgeon occurs in freshwater, so there's much greater opportunity to control the conditions within freshwater farms.

Tommy

Okay, so let's.

Expert

I haven't heard of anybody complaining about them.

Expert

There aren't.

Expert

It may seem like a lot of sturgeon, say 50,000 tons, but it's quite small compared to, say, over a million tons of farm salmon worldwide.

Tommy

So you need to kind of balance what the environmental impact is and the possible extinction of a species.

Declan Quigley

Yeah.

Declan Quigley

So you reckon that the sturgeon farming plays a role as a reservoir of genes, so to say, for sturgeon and possible reintroductions to.

Declan Quigley

To the wild.

Declan Quigley

So unlike the salmon farming, the sturgeon farming could be regarded as a contributor to conservation, Is that right?

Tommy

Yeah, absolutely.

Tommy

Sturgeon was mainly harvested for caviar, which, if you go into the airport now, duty free, you pay up to €10,000.

Expert

Per kilo for caviar.

Tommy

So because of the high price of caviar, there's a lot of pressure still on wild stocks, obviously due to poaching.

Tommy

So if farm sturgeon can replace that.

Expert

Demand, it will hopefully reduce the level.

Tommy

Of illegal fishing of wild sturgeon in the future.

Expert

That's what I would hope, anyway.

Declan Quigley

How does the.

Declan Quigley

So you were talking about the population of sturgeon in Europe.

Declan Quigley

In the.

Declan Quigley

In the European sturgeon.

Declan Quigley

I know that there is, like, an active recreational fishery of sturgeon in Canada.

Declan Quigley

In America, this is different species of sturgeon completely.

Declan Quigley

Do you know how they're doing there?

Declan Quigley

Is that population in a little bit better condition than in Europe?

Tommy

White sturgeon is one of the biggest.

Expert

Ones that actually occurs in the Pacific.

Tommy

Rivers and it is very popular with anglers.

Expert

Again, a lot of the large rivers.

Tommy

On the Pacific side of North America.

Expert

Have been highly developed for hydroelectric dams.

Tommy

And this has obviously caused issues further upstream spawning sturgeon there.

Tommy

Sturgeon have been introduced into a lot of putt and take fisheries in the uk.

Tommy

Again, it's not really a natural environment for them.

Tommy

So.

Expert

I used to be an angler myself, so I wouldn't be really attracted to fishing for sturgeon in a pond.

Declan Quigley

I was fishing for them in a pond in Poland for when I was starting with angling.

Declan Quigley

So that I was starting in those, like you said, little ponds and they were like those little sturgeons.

Declan Quigley

They call it sturgeon.

Declan Quigley

I think they're sterlet.

Tommy

Yes.

Declan Quigley

But you know, back then it was like, oh, you caught a sturgeon and you know, and I was looking at the, at the magazines, angling magazines from Canada, and see this massive fish, like.

Declan Quigley

No, this doesn't look like this.

Tommy

Yeah, well, I.

Tommy

Some anglers have caught sturgeon in the.

Expert

River Severn, which is basically across the pond here from me.

Tommy

But most of them were found to be hybrids, so they were obviously escapees or fish that had been released by.

Tommy

From aquaria, I would imagine.

Tommy

You know, there was one actually, a.

Expert

Small sturgeon, about 1.3 kilos that was caught in Locnay in 2016.

Tommy

So I haven't heard of the results yet as to whether it was a hybrid or a real European sturgeon.

Expert

If it was to get up to Loch Ney, it would have to have.

Tommy

Passed up to the River Band and all the fish passes on that system.

Tommy

So I kind of wondering maybe if it was all.

Tommy

It might have been dumped in Loch Ney from a tank, you know, so.

Tommy

But I haven't heard the full story yet.

Declan Quigley

When was the last sturgeon caught in Ireland?

Declan Quigley

What is like a last validated or the one that you would consider being a wild, like 100% wild sturgeon.

Declan Quigley

What year was it, do you know?

Expert

That was 1987.

Tommy

Oh, yeah, May 1987.

Tommy

There was Sturgeon.

Tommy

It's about 10 kilo weight.

Expert

He was cut off to Kish Lighthouse.

Tommy

Off Dublin Bay and it was sold to bishops, you know, fish traders.

Expert

I think it was around £900 it made.

Declan Quigley

Wow.

Tommy

So.

Expert

And they in turn sold it on.

Tommy

To White's on the Green, which is an upmarket restaurant in Dublin and that was served up to the unsuspecting last consumers of the last sturgeon in Ireland.

Declan Quigley

How did you get interested?

Declan Quigley

How did you get, you know, like there is a little bit of a, you know, we really didn't start with introduction about yourself, so you might use that opportunity to introduce yourself a little bit now.

Declan Quigley

But how did you get interested in those fish?

Declan Quigley

Because clearly you've seen the decline and how they're reports are being less and less of sightings and.

Declan Quigley

Right, so you kind of like a witness the demise of sturgeon in Ireland.

Tommy

Well, as I said, I was just.

Expert

Curious why there was so few records in the scientific literature.

Tommy

And as a fish biologist I was always interested in sturgeon and reading what.

Expert

Sort of research was going on elsewhere in Europe.

Expert

I was particularly interested in the archaeological.

Tommy

Side of it because at the end of the last ice age, the Atlantic sturgeon, which is effectively native to Labrador, Canada.

Expert

It turned up in the Baltic.

Tommy

And natural spawning populations in Baltic rivers including Lake Ladoga, they seem to displace.

Expert

The European sturgeon when they arrived.

Expert

And this was the end of the last ice age.

Tommy

So things were quite cold then.

Tommy

And of course Canada is quite cold in that latitude.

Expert

So it was a species that was able to push out the European sturgeon.

Tommy

But eventually as things warmed up, the climate warmed up.

Expert

It appears that the European sturgeon started migrating further north and hybridized with the Atlantic sturgeon.

Tommy

And these hybrids migrated further southwards into Biscay.

Expert

Because they have found archaeological remains.

Tommy

Of sturgeon in various Neolithic sites and they were able to identify from the scales or disguises whether or not they were European or Atlantic or hybrids.

Expert

So there were a number of sturgeon.

Tommy

In the Natural History Museum in Dublin here that were caught.

Tommy

One was caught in the Liffey in.

Expert

The pool beg salmon fishery in the Liffey back in the 1840s and another.

Tommy

One in the River Boyne just further north.

Tommy

And there was a lady called Hannah.

Expert

From the University of Warsaw actually who.

Tommy

Took samples from both of these sturgeon for DNA analysis.

Tommy

And she discovered fragments of the Atlantic sturgeon, that's Assupinser Oxyrhynchus, in the largest one from the River Leffey, whereas the river, the one from the River Boyne was Capensur stereo, the European sturgeon.

Tommy

So it wasn't 100% conclusive because the DNA was quite degraded.

Tommy

But there was some evidence of the.

Expert

Atlantic sturgeon in that specimen.

Tommy

So I took some close up photographs of the Scutes and I sent them to the archaeologists down in France.

Tommy

And in Spain, who were experts basically.

Expert

In identifying which species was which, based on the scutes.

Tommy

And they were of the opinion that.

Expert

It was European sturgeon, but it could also have been a hybrid.

Tommy

So my interest, I suppose was purely academic.

Tommy

It's an iconic species.

Tommy

It's actually called brodawn fjarna in Irish.

Expert

Whereas salmon is called brodon.

Expert

And.

Tommy

The salmon has always been kind.

Expert

Of revered in Ireland.

Expert

Whereas I think that the sturgeon, a.

Tommy

Good example perhaps of an iconic European species, not just eu, but it's also found in the Black Sea in the Mediterranean.

Tommy

So I think it would be a good species, like a symbol of European unity and perhaps an even bigger EU in the future as well, where this species has occurred.

Tommy

So I think, you know, when I was a kid, we've had so many changes in currency.

Tommy

Salmon always featured on the coinage, the two shilling coin in Ireland.

Expert

So maybe there's a case of putting.

Tommy

Sturging on our coinage and maybe our EU coinage.

Declan Quigley

Oh, that would be great.

Declan Quigley

I think that would be a great idea.

Declan Quigley

Declan, tell me, like when the sturgeon were at the time where the sightings or catching sturgeon was still, you know, going on in Ireland, were there any attempts to save the species, any attempts at conservation or was it just not a thing at the time and nobody was paying attention that there's less and.

Host

Less of them in the waters.

Tommy

There doesn't appear to have been any.

Expert

Attempts to save sturgeon during the 19th century.

Expert

It was just we suddenly woke up.

Tommy

In the 20th century and realized that this species was almost extinct.

Tommy

So apart from the French and also now the Germans as well, fisheries research, they're the only programs that are actively and practically trying to reintroduce European sturgeon.

Tommy

It's the same in the uk.

Tommy

There is, I suppose the Industrial Revolution there didn't help.

Tommy

And it's not just sturgeon.

Expert

It affected lots of different species of fish.

Expert

It's lots of species are coming and.

Tommy

Going, becoming extinct and we don't know about it.

Expert

This just happened to be one that we do know about.

Declan Quigley

Yeah, that is the problem, that it's to some extent it is like, what did we lost that we don't even know that we lost it?

Declan Quigley

Declan, tell us a little bit about the cultural and political importance of a sturgeon.

Declan Quigley

In the article you sent me and that we're going to link in the show notes, there is a story about the sturgeon being offered by one person to another as a political gift and something like that.

Declan Quigley

So they had a clearly huge cultural Meaning and importance in Ireland.

Tommy

Yes.

Tommy

It was King Edward ii in the 14th century.

Tommy

He introduced an act whereby all sturgeons were his if they were caught.

Tommy

So it does suggest that the species.

Expert

Was not so common even then.

Tommy

Right.

Tommy

But it was a royal fish.

Tommy

It became a royal fish and of significant political interest because at that stage.

Expert

Ireland was part of the United Kingdom.

Tommy

And King Edward II decreed, also became.

Expert

Part of Irish law, if you like, at the time.

Tommy

And over the years, sturgeon has featured.

Expert

A lot in political terms in Ireland as well as the UK, of course.

Tommy

But there is a story from 1608 when the High King of Donegal, in his own peninsula, Cairo, Doherty, he was meeting the mayor of Derry and the mayor of Derry anyway, somehow insulted him and he went back in a rage to Inishon and he consulted with his elders and his more peaceful elders suggested that.

Expert

They might.

Tommy

He might give a gift in a peace offering, if you like, to the mayor.

Tommy

And it so happened that there was.

Expert

A sturgeon caught at the same time.

Expert

So he gave the sturgeon anyway to.

Tommy

The mayor and everything was okay for a while, but then he came back.

Expert

And he killed the mayor.

Tommy

And then the mayor.

Tommy

The mayor's troops chased him back to.

Tommy

In his show and killed him.

Declan Quigley

Yeah.

Tommy

So it was.

Tommy

So up until the formation of the.

Expert

Irish Free State, effectively all sturgeon that were caught in Ireland were had to go to the reigning monarch in the UK and this occurred quite frequently during the 19th century where.

Tommy

Sturgeon were.

Tommy

A number of Irish sturgeon were, let's.

Expert

Say, donated to Queen Elizabeth, for example.

Tommy

And also to various rulers in Ireland.

Tommy

UK rulers, if you like, would be.

Expert

The Lord Lieutenants of Ireland.

Expert

So if they weren't able to get.

Tommy

It over to the Queen, they would feast on it in Dublin Castle.

Tommy

So when the Irish Sarah Start Arryn.

Expert

Was established in 1922.

Tommy

This, let's call.

Expert

It a tradition at this stage seemed.

Tommy

To kind of persist in Irish politics.

Expert

I don't think they knew what to.

Tommy

Do when a sturgeon was caught, but they.

Expert

Most of the sturgeon that were caught.

Tommy

After 1922 were donated to the President of Ireland.

Expert

And he had shown to your calic.

Tommy

And you had Eamon de Valera and.

Expert

Carol Odalik and Erskine Chillers.

Expert

Right up until you know, the 1970s.

Tommy

These sturgeon were given to the president because they thought this is what should be done with it.

Expert

Even Richard Mulcahy, who was the Lord.

Tommy

Lieutenant of the new Ser Stodairn, he was presented with a sturgeon.

Expert

There was another sturgeon caught around the same time, actually.

Tommy

And it was presented to the Queen in, sorry, the King in London.

Tommy

It was caught in Irish waters, but.

Expert

It was caught by a UK trawler.

Tommy

And it was landed into Swansea, so they weren't going to give it back to us.

Tommy

Now, the interesting thing about the sturgeon.

Expert

That were donated to the Irish presidents over the years was that in most.

Tommy

Cases they gave them to ecclesiastical institutions rather than having dinner up in Ors and Uchteron.

Tommy

But in hindsight, I was thinking the.

Expert

Reason for that was that the ecclesiastical institutions were more powerful than the politicians.

Tommy

Right.

Tommy

So it would be very interesting to see.

Expert

What they would do if another sturgeon was caught now.

Expert

But.

Tommy

EU law now anyway dictates that.

Expert

The sturgeon has to be released alive.

Expert

So maybe that solves the problems for the Irish government.

Declan Quigley

Yeah, for sure, for sure.

Declan Quigley

Oh, that's a good one.

Declan Quigley

What do you think?

Declan Quigley

Like, why even, you know, the thing is hard to understand for me is, like, why nobody was trying to protect the fish that was so important and so valued.

Declan Quigley

The Royal fish, it was given as a gift and surely people saw that the population is declining and yet no one done anything.

Declan Quigley

Like, I'm just wondering, like, why is it like just the mind frame at the time was not there, or like, what are your thoughts on this?

Tommy

Well, I can only think that in general terms.

Expert

The fishery resources of Ireland were for generations not considered to be important.

Expert

And it still is an ongoing debate.

Tommy

When Ireland and joined the EU in 1973, the fishermen didn't do very well out of it in terms of quota.

Expert

And it's an ongoing issue.

Tommy

So I think that sturgeon, because they weren't so common and they weren't spawning here, that really, they.

Tommy

They didn't catch.

Tommy

It's not a good word, I suppose.

Tommy

Let's say they weren't perceived, they weren't known to be perhaps so critically endangered.

Declan Quigley

Do you think it would be a good idea to have a sturgeon reintroduction project in Ireland?

Declan Quigley

Or do you think because they probably never spawn here, that it's not a good idea?

Declan Quigley

Would you like to see that, that sort of a project?

Declan Quigley

You know, hypothetically speaking, I understand that there's like a literally zero chance of this happening in the near future, but there is a lot of talk about reintroducing species right now across the Europe and Ireland and the uk.

Declan Quigley

Do you think it would be a good idea to try to reintroduce them to Ireland?

Declan Quigley

Would you like to see that project or do you think it's not a.

Tommy

Good Idea, I wouldn't call it reintroduce.

Expert

I know that there's a lot of interest in rewilding of lots of species.

Tommy

In Europe, but I think even though.

Expert

The sturgeon, there's no evidence that spawned here, as I say, it's a pan European species.

Tommy

So I think that every European country has perhaps a responsibility to ensure that the species survives.

Expert

And I think as part of that.

Tommy

Program, maybe there's a strong case for Ireland to farm sturgeon, for.

Expert

Rewilding, if you like rewilding the sea, not rewilding the river as such.

Tommy

But we have some really good rivers here that would be suitable, I think.

Tommy

But again, that's a political question.

Declan Quigley

Unfortunately.

Declan Quigley

This is the unfortunate bit about the than the nature conservation, that it often gets politicized and the arguments have nothing to do with actual ecological aspect of it.

Declan Quigley

It's more of a who and why and where.

Tommy

Yeah, well, if you take for example.

Expert

Wild boar, they were at one stage native to Ireland or appear to have.

Tommy

Been anyway, and they were all hunted to extinction, like the wolf as well.

Expert

We even had brown bears here and hyenas.

Tommy

And.

Expert

So I suppose some people wouldn't.

Tommy

Mind introducing wolves and brown bears and wolves, dare I say it.

Tommy

But you know, I think when they were here, we weren't here.

Tommy

A lot of cases and Ireland, it's changed so much.

Tommy

I kind of leave that to the.

Declan Quigley

Politicians to decide, well, I don't know, there's nothing going to happen then.

Declan Quigley

You know, there is an argument that when the wolves still were around in Ireland, there were apparently more people in Ireland than there is now.

Declan Quigley

They just didn't have that many goddamn cars at the time.

Expert

Yes, we had major immigration.

Tommy

During the famine years when we had twice as many or three times as many people living in Ireland.

Tommy

But I think the last wolf was.

Expert

Shot in 1756, around that time.

Tommy

So I don't think people were too.

Expert

Concerned about Waltz at that stage.

Tommy

They just wanted to survive.

Declan Quigley

Just to switch gears a little bit, tell me clearly over your career as a fish biologist, as a person who is into wildlife, you've seen the decline of the natural environment and species and fish stocks and all that.

Declan Quigley

Can you give us, from the perspective of many decades of experience, how what we see now compares to how the seas and rivers and waters in Ireland look like 30, 40, even more years ago?

Declan Quigley

How big is that decline?

Tommy

Well, when I was, I suppose in.

Expert

My teens, and that's going back over.

Tommy

50 years now, there were major environmental issues in Ireland, mostly pollution caused by sewage and farming I remember actually as a kid going up to Dublin and.

Expert

The pong of the Liffey was incredibly bad.

Tommy

But I think there's been a huge improvement actually since the 1960s in Ireland in terms of water quality.

Expert

There's still obviously, issues, but there were.

Tommy

Lots of reports of fish kills every year across Ireland.

Expert

During the 70s, but that declined substantially during the 1980s.

Tommy

You still get occasional kills, but I think that people in general are much.

Expert

More attuned now to the environment.

Tommy

I think that fish, if I just take fish, because people don't see them and they're not kind of cuddly, they may not have been as aware of what species we had here and what were maybe endangered.

Expert

We didn't know it because apart from.

Tommy

Salmon and trout, everything else was kind.

Expert

Of considered to be almost inedible in Ireland, unlike in Poland, where you eat everything.

Tommy

So I think there's a greater consciousness there.

Tommy

And one thing about fish is that different kind of from land animals, they're.

Expert

Not restricted by political boundaries or jurisdictions.

Tommy

They move with the sea, they migrate.

Expert

They may naturally repopulate areas.

Expert

They're a little bit of an unknown.

Tommy

I mean, if you look at the.

Expert

Number of land animals in Ireland here, I don't know, it's probably 30 or 40 species mammals.

Tommy

That is.

Tommy

We have almost 600 species of fish that occur in Irish waters, and that's increasing every year.

Expert

Now it is.

Tommy

Even this week, there was a new species scientifically described from Irish waters.

Expert

My interest over the years has been.

Tommy

Recording all of these unusual species because.

Expert

Only about 20 of the 600 are commercially exploited.

Expert

And they're the ones that receive all the scientific research.

Expert

Nobody knows very much about the rest of them.

Expert

And they're the.

Expert

The kind of gaps that I'm trying to fill.

Expert

And the sturgeon is one of those.

Declan Quigley

Oh, that's a very important job that you're doing.

Declan Quigley

And, you know, thank you for.

Declan Quigley

For doing that, Declan.

Declan Quigley

What, like, if you would give an advice to, you know, young people, and maybe a little older than young, but still young, what would be your advice for them?

Declan Quigley

What should they do to ensure the, you know, continuous improvement of the state of the environment and fish and like, what.

Declan Quigley

What would be your advice for them for the future generations?

Expert

Look outside the box.

Declan Quigley

That's.

Declan Quigley

That's short and to the point.

Tommy

Yes, I think that, as I say.

Expert

There'S huge opportunities there for the up and coming generation of biologists and fishery.

Tommy

Biologists in particular, to expand the amount of research in terms of species numbers.

Tommy

As I say, we.

Expert

We know very little about most of them.

Tommy

So there is enough work there for.

Expert

Generations ahead.

Tommy

And I think to continue to create awareness of what species may be under threat and hopefully we may.

Expert

Be able to save them in time.

Declan Quigley

Maybe one day we'll see the sturgeon in Irish waters again.

Expert

I look forward to having a meal in whites on the green someday.

Declan Quigley

Declan, thank you very much.

Declan Quigley

I really appreciate your time.

Declan Quigley

It's been pleasure.

Expert

Thank you.

Tommy

John, if you made it this far.

Declan Quigley

To the episode then it was clearly.

Host

Something that interests you.

Host

So I have a favor to ask.

Host

Please leave me 5 star rating on the podcasting app that you are using.

Host

Whether it's an Apple podcast or Spotify.

Host

Go in there and leave me five star rating and if you happen to be watching this podcast on YouTube, give me thumbs up and leave the comment.

Host

This is great help for the show and I really appreciate you doing it.