Speaker:

What would be the benefits of using Echo compared to some of the traditional platforms,

Speaker:

They have to keep on bolting on new features, but they're running old

Speaker:

systems. We're coming in now basically scratch built with

Speaker:

the newest standards. Property is a very big deal. The bit where you

Speaker:

carve up a property into tokens is called fractionalization. Because

Speaker:

it's fractionalized, you don't necessarily have to have such a large amount of

Speaker:

money for the average user. So you could have a portion of a property and

Speaker:

in the meantime, you could borrow against, say, in stablecoin and

Speaker:

Are you integrating any AI into Echo? And

Speaker:

if so, how would that benefit the consumer? We're

Speaker:

looking right now at doing... I'm Matthew Fraser and

Speaker:

this is Crypto Collective. After making millions with Amazon

Speaker:

and e-commerce, I realized that if I was starting again

Speaker:

today, crypto would be my first choice. I'm

Speaker:

here to help you take your first steps and build real

Speaker:

wealth. Ready to set yourself up for life? Let's go.

Speaker:

Today I'm joined by Sam Dora, CEO of Echo,

Speaker:

a DeFi platform that is bridging traditional finance and

Speaker:

blockchain, helping investors unlock smarter, more

Speaker:

secure ways to build long-term wealth. Sam's

Speaker:

not just a CEO, he's also the youngest board member on

Speaker:

the Isle of Man's Government Digital Asset Committee, where

Speaker:

he helps shape policy for the future of finance. Echo

Speaker:

is doing something unique by bringing real world assets on

Speaker:

chain in a way that's simple, safe, and

Speaker:

built for long term investors. If you're serious about crypto, wealth

Speaker:

building, and the future of money, this one's for you.

Speaker:

Let's get into it. Sam Dora, welcome to Crypto Collective. How

Speaker:

are you doing? Hi, Matthew. Thanks for having me. Absolute pleasure.

Speaker:

Sam, can you tell us about the new platform that you're spearheading, which

Speaker:

is called Echo in this fintech space? And what is it

Speaker:

Echo as a platform is up and available now.

Speaker:

You can find it on echo.im. It's made up of an

Speaker:

initial set of products, one of them being Echo Token,

Speaker:

one is Echo X, Echo Pro, and then another

Speaker:

product called Echo Elite, and that makes up the

Speaker:

How does that differ to other types of platforms that

Speaker:

There's a few, it's on a per product basis, I

Speaker:

suppose. So Echo Token, for example, is

Speaker:

a deflationary yield token, as

Speaker:

opposed to an inflationary token. So

Speaker:

the Echo Token itself, 50% of top line revenue, which

Speaker:

runs through Echo X and Echo Pro, is returned proportionally to

Speaker:

Echo Token holders. On the exchange side, it

Speaker:

will be something which a lot of people are familiar with, with

Speaker:

cryptocurrency generally. But for us, it's more of a trial where

Speaker:

we're running cryptocurrencies through to begin with before we

Speaker:

add real world assets and other instruments to

Speaker:

And so talk about that little part you mentioned before, which is

Speaker:

about customers, I guess, sharing in revenue

Speaker:

Yeah, exactly that. And it's a super important thing to note

Speaker:

that it's top line revenue too. So

Speaker:

it's really easy maths, right? We can't cook the books

Speaker:

at all. So the way it works is literally, so normally when

Speaker:

you trade something on exchange, there's a fee. Well, either there's a fee normally,

Speaker:

or they say that there's no fee and put a

Speaker:

spread on the thing and hit you in that way. So

Speaker:

there's a fee, which for us is 10 BP, which

Speaker:

is 0.1%, which I think is a, I'm not going to

Speaker:

say it's the lowest, but it's definitely an industry low, I think.

Speaker:

And of that, 50% is passed on

Speaker:

proportionally to ECHO token holders in stablecoin. So

Speaker:

you don't get more ECHO token, you get stablecoin for

Speaker:

that. And then 10% is burned, and

Speaker:

that's bought off the open market, so buy back and burn. So it's

Speaker:

I think that's a really important point there, Sam, that it's not the

Speaker:

token, it's actually Stablecoin. Can you just talk to me

Speaker:

a little bit more about that? Because I think we sort of just brushed over it, but I

Speaker:

think compared to how other systems work, this is a big, big

Speaker:

Yeah, it's a huge deal, especially in like in

Speaker:

DeFi land. Like last bull run, you had the farm

Speaker:

tokens, which were super popular, where you'd

Speaker:

have these kind of insane interest rates for

Speaker:

staking, you know, shitcoin X. And

Speaker:

what would end up happening, though, is they'd mint into oblivion, basically, because

Speaker:

you're getting interest for in-kind interest. and

Speaker:

all that happens is you think you're gaining interest but you're not really it's

Speaker:

just inflating itself away and it just becomes a

Speaker:

case of you know pass the parcel or you know who's going to be you

Speaker:

know musical chairs or who's going to be left holding the bag basically whereas

Speaker:

we wanted to create arguably a very long-term

Speaker:

sustainable model for yield, which actually has a

Speaker:

flaw on it by definition, because it's

Speaker:

based on exchange volume, effectively. So

Speaker:

the pitch, so to speak, for Echo Token at a very basic

Speaker:

level is, do you think the exchange is going to get volume and how much?

Speaker:

And that's going to dictate, ultimately, the price of Echo Token, because

Speaker:

that's the yield we're going to receive as well. So, in

Speaker:

some sense, it's quite unique in the cryptocurrency space because it's

Speaker:

Was there something in particular, Sam, that's happened in

Speaker:

your life that made you think, I'm going to bring in this type of

Speaker:

offering to clients because this, again, is very unique?

Speaker:

Yeah. You know, it sounds kind

Speaker:

of cliche, but I really dislike consumers or

Speaker:

retail customers getting taken advantage of. And for

Speaker:

me, one of the easiest ways for Wales

Speaker:

or institutional types to do that kind of thing is exactly with

Speaker:

bad tokenomics or with schemes which

Speaker:

almost guarantee you to lose. And I think that just kind

Speaker:

of sucks, really. And I'd much rather people at

Speaker:

Yeah, a fair shot at actually making some profit. That's what we're talking

Speaker:

I mean, on that note as well, it's been fascinating seeing

Speaker:

all the stuff which has happened with PumpFun and

Speaker:

the meme coin factory over on Solana. for

Speaker:

me there's it's kind of a double-edged sword because part of me likes it

Speaker:

part of me likes the community side of it it's quite fun the other part of

Speaker:

me is it's sucking massive amounts of liquid out

Speaker:

of retail customers and effectively giving

Speaker:

them nothing and there's there's arguments at

Speaker:

least on on my side of the fence over here which

Speaker:

I'm hearing, which is part of the reason why you're not seeing some of the alt-run happening,

Speaker:

is because PumpFun has sucked out so much of the retail money

Speaker:

Oh, interesting. I have heard that as well, about the liquidity.

Speaker:

But I've also just in recent days heard that the

Speaker:

market could be going up at any moment. I think the big one

Speaker:

today, Sam, is actually if the Solana

Speaker:

ETF comes off. I think that was the narrative that's being spoken

Speaker:

about now. Would you say that if that does come off then there

Speaker:

I think it has to get beyond a place where people are just hoping the

Speaker:

institutional client is going to come in and save them. Like

Speaker:

a lot of these alt coins and chains

Speaker:

and stuff, they need to provide real value to

Speaker:

customers. And that's at an application level sometimes as

Speaker:

well. So obviously they can say that, oh,

Speaker:

we're an infrastructure play, et cetera. But if there's

Speaker:

nothing on the chain worth using, it's

Speaker:

why right and and

Speaker:

for me um btc already performs

Speaker:

the function of being, you know, effectively a buy and hold asset.

Speaker:

I don't think you necessarily need other equivalents. You

Speaker:

need the other altcoins to do something. And

Speaker:

ETH is historically being quite good at that because of the smart contracts, you

Speaker:

know, when it first came out and stuff, the smart contracts was novel compared to

Speaker:

Bitcoin. So, you know, it allowed certain use

Speaker:

cases and things, but there's a pretty wide

Speaker:

gap now, I think, between some of these different chains. My

Speaker:

hope is that Solana

Speaker:

has obviously become the kind of meme chain, which is

Speaker:

fine, it's carved a niche. But I don't know if that's

Speaker:

necessarily a great fit with an ETF. But

Speaker:

we'll see, who knows? We'll see what the market says. It's

Speaker:

not like Wall Street isn't up for a bet.

Speaker:

Yeah. Well, speaking of different, I guess, different types of tokens, I

Speaker:

know that Echo is going to be talking about or bringing in sort of

Speaker:

the real world assets into the mix. Can you talk about real world

Speaker:

Yeah, sure. So a real world asset for your

Speaker:

listeners It's in the name, I suppose. So,

Speaker:

so normally they're considered securities or

Speaker:

security tokens. They're sometimes referred to as, uh, cause

Speaker:

usually you would have say, um, a stock or a

Speaker:

bond or a T-bill or something. Um, you,

Speaker:

you tokenize it. So, so you mint an equivalent onto

Speaker:

the blockchain and custody, um, the,

Speaker:

the real version of. Um, is the idea. So in

Speaker:

principle, what happens is you have all the benefits. Of

Speaker:

having your real world asset while also having

Speaker:

the smart contracts and the blockchain stuff on top

Speaker:

is the idea. Um, real world assets, of course, don't have to necessarily be,

Speaker:

um, just, uh, stocks and

Speaker:

bonds and stuff. They can, I mean, property is a big one, which people

Speaker:

are interested in. There's other stuff too. There's a lot of play going on right

Speaker:

now in private equity, um, or people selling, um,

Speaker:

private or tokenizing private companies. Um, because it's

Speaker:

an excellent way of raising funds without technically IPO-ing.

Speaker:

Um, there's also, uh, some play around

Speaker:

art and things like that. I mean, there's touches a bit on NFTs of that, but

Speaker:

there's a lot of play really in in what you

Speaker:

can tokenize. I mean, for me, sitting on the other side of the fence, sitting

Speaker:

on the other side here and looking at what things we can tokenize,

Speaker:

the easiest thing is to tokenize the things which have a well-known

Speaker:

market price. So the easy things are stuff

Speaker:

like stocks and bonds because when you when

Speaker:

you do the equivalent of you can do you can Oracle

Speaker:

track the price of say Apple stock to your Apple

Speaker:

token so you know that they're both worth the same amount but

Speaker:

it becomes much more difficult to do that on assets

Speaker:

which don't necessarily have a market price or

Speaker:

it's more difficult to find out what the price might be. And

Speaker:

that's where a lot of the real estate problems come in because,

Speaker:

you know, who's to say what house is worth? Is it what

Speaker:

the estate agent, the real estate agent says? Is it what the seller says?

Speaker:

Who's to say what the price is at any given moment? And

Speaker:

So just in practical terms, Sam, do you think if you just talk about property, I know certainly

Speaker:

in Australia and other sort of Western parts of the world, property is

Speaker:

a very big deal. And so would you

Speaker:

say then you would have a value of perhaps that would go in and

Speaker:

assess a value of X, Y, Z property, and then

Speaker:

it would be tokenized based on that. And then the retailers or

Speaker:

I guess institutions could come in and buy those tokens and

Speaker:

Yeah, so that process, the bit where you carve up

Speaker:

a property into tokens is called fractionalization. So

Speaker:

that's when you take the whole and you cut it into little

Speaker:

pieces, but in this case it's different tokens. So

Speaker:

yes, that's exactly how it functions. The difficulty is

Speaker:

in who holds the custody of the property and

Speaker:

do people trust the valuation. Do you

Speaker:

believe the valuation and do you trust the people which have the

Speaker:

deed? Those are the two big issues with real

Speaker:

Yeah, and so if people do have tokens then, Sam, in a property,

Speaker:

I guess are they just hoping that over time this value

Speaker:

of this one particular token goes up and they can then sell

Speaker:

it? And do you think maybe, just thinking about property, would you be able to even leverage

Speaker:

Yeah, yeah. This is exactly the same direction which we're thinking

Speaker:

to collateralization effectively. So what

Speaker:

you do is you take, in this case, the property token.

Speaker:

And the nice thing being that because it's fractionalized, you don't necessarily have

Speaker:

to have such a large amount of money for

Speaker:

the average user in that one item.

Speaker:

So you could have a portion of a property, you're hoping on the speculative

Speaker:

gain. And in the meantime, you could

Speaker:

borrow against, say, in stablecoin and buy something else. It's

Speaker:

still hedging, obviously, and you could get liquidated, but the idea is

Speaker:

that something like property or gold

Speaker:

or something like that is much more stable to borrow against

Speaker:

than straight cryptocurrency assets, because they're less

Speaker:

Yeah, I think that's really, really powerful, the collateralization

Speaker:

of the tokens, because right now we've seen that things like

Speaker:

Bitcoin, for example, even in places like Australia and the

Speaker:

US, you can now leverage your Bitcoin. So

Speaker:

you can borrow against your Bitcoin, right, for either stablecoin

Speaker:

or cash. And I think that kind of leads down the path that we

Speaker:

want to be able to still own property, traditionally property we can leverage. And

Speaker:

if we can now leverage tokens, I think that'd be great. Do you think that's going to

Speaker:

be something that Echo in the future would implement into

Speaker:

Yeah. Part of our

Speaker:

longer-term roadmap is to have what's called

Speaker:

a peer-to-contract protocol, which is a

Speaker:

borrow-lend protocol, which allows users

Speaker:

on platform to not borrow against us as a platform, but

Speaker:

to pool assets and then lend them out to other

Speaker:

users or borrow from the pool. You

Speaker:

see a similar thing with Aave, for example, in the DeFi

Speaker:

space. But the problem with Aave is what I just mentioned, which

Speaker:

is that the most stable asset on there is Bitcoin. And

Speaker:

yes, it's perfectly reasonable to borrow against Bitcoin, but

Speaker:

it can swing. And that can be

Speaker:

slightly nerve-wracking, especially with very, very large numbers, because

Speaker:

Right, yes, you want to be careful of how much you're leveraging. I

Speaker:

want to just pivot, Sam, into something else, which is But

Speaker:

more about the Echo platform and about the governance of

Speaker:

that. How does the governance work within Echo? And also,

Speaker:

what sort of security measures does Echo have for the everyday user?

Speaker:

Sure. So the governance is directly tied into

Speaker:

the Echo token. So we have a phrase which is one token, one

Speaker:

vote, one voice. And the idea behind that is

Speaker:

we have a legal structure in place called

Speaker:

the Echo Community Foundation. And that's an actual legal

Speaker:

foundation, not just name only. And

Speaker:

part of that, part of the remit of that foundation is

Speaker:

it receives upon, it's received 30% of the total

Speaker:

supply of Echo Topin as part of a vesting schedule. So

Speaker:

it receives it drip fed. And

Speaker:

the remit is that it's never allowed to sell the Echo Topin. And

Speaker:

instead it survives purely on the yield, which I

Speaker:

mentioned, which is the top line revenue piece into the foundation. And

Speaker:

then what we say is every quarter echo token holders

Speaker:

can vote. on how that yield is

Speaker:

spent. And we give a number of

Speaker:

options. So it's a kind of, I guess, the

Speaker:

closest form of government is probably a republic or something like that. So we present

Speaker:

a number of options in different baskets, and then people vote into

Speaker:

those choices is the idea. But

Speaker:

we really, we wanted to create a system which felt like your

Speaker:

vote actually mattered. Because it's very, very common in DAOs

Speaker:

and in various other governance pieces that you

Speaker:

get someone come in and swing the whole vote if

Speaker:

So what's going to be, Sam, is there going to be protection against people

Speaker:

Exactly, yeah. And the way that works though is because one

Speaker:

token is one vote and that is equal to a certain percentage of

Speaker:

the of the foundation so effectively If

Speaker:

someone comes in and votes and has some enormous hold, they

Speaker:

won't because of where the tokenomics are. But let's say they had 10% of

Speaker:

total supply and they chose to want

Speaker:

to reinvest in treasury, say. So they put that vote in. But all the rest of

Speaker:

the 90% of people can still vote for various different baskets

Speaker:

and different things. And we just cut up the

Speaker:

yield into that percentage split. So

Speaker:

what you vote for still actually gets the stable point.

Speaker:

Yeah. One thing you touched on though, which I think other

Speaker:

people may not have picked up is you said that the community cannot

Speaker:

Yeah. Yeah. So, so the foundation can't sell the token. Yeah. And

Speaker:

we've done that. And why is that important though? It's,

Speaker:

it's important because the foundation has a very large supply

Speaker:

of the token. And there's, there's always a fear factor

Speaker:

for, For potential token

Speaker:

holders that the foundation will dump the token, you know or sell off the

Speaker:

token in big chunks Or it

Speaker:

will do things like crow did recently crypto comm where

Speaker:

it used its own foundation vote to bring back in

Speaker:

burnt tokens and back

Speaker:

into the liquidity. And we

Speaker:

wanted to make it so that effectively the sole reason

Speaker:

why we've put so much of that token into the foundation is so

Speaker:

that it gets a big chunk of the yield off of it, mostly. So

Speaker:

there's lots of safety stuff around the reasons why we've done

Speaker:

that. And once again, it's a long-term play. We're looking at

Speaker:

it. That kind of setup will last for a very long time. it's

Speaker:

Yeah, Sam, I think that is so important because it really goes down to

Speaker:

the culture and the mindset,

Speaker:

I guess, of echo behind the scenes, implementing

Speaker:

those types of foundational structures, which

Speaker:

is obviously much better for the consumer, for the retailer, the

Speaker:

institutional investor who's coming into echo. And so I just really wanted

Speaker:

to highlight that because if you look at other platforms, they're

Speaker:

I always say this to like, um,

Speaker:

my colleagues or other investors and stuff. And it's like, you know, if

Speaker:

you want, if you want to like a quick buck, there's,

Speaker:

there's easier ways to, to do this than what we're doing, but

Speaker:

it's flashing the pan, right? It's, it's stuff which is going to be here

Speaker:

today, gone tomorrow. Um, and won't have the

Speaker:

kind of potential explosive growth, which

Speaker:

Yeah. You touched as well on before about that the

Speaker:

governance of where the year will be spent. Is

Speaker:

that right? And you'll give options. I know I just wanted to ask you

Speaker:

because there's been so much happening now in the space of institutions

Speaker:

and now, of course, governments buying into Bitcoin. So would

Speaker:

one of those options be buying Bitcoin to, I

Speaker:

Yeah, so one of the five baskets is exactly that.

Speaker:

It's treasury related.

Speaker:

It's a treasury related basket, basically. And one of those things could

Speaker:

be to gain other assets, for example,

Speaker:

which are yield producing. So you start getting this

Speaker:

snowball effect inside the foundation, where yield

Speaker:

from the ECHO token is used to purchase other cryptocurrency assets

Speaker:

or other assets, which are then also yield producing. Because it's

Speaker:

all staying inside of that foundation, right? So

Speaker:

the community has a real chance to build build the foundation out

Speaker:

into a real powerhouse on the treasury side. And

Speaker:

when that does happen, then suddenly all those other baskets have a lot

Speaker:

more power too, like in research and development or

Speaker:

in marketing or in philanthropy. So,

Speaker:

you know, it's all kind of theoretically like

Speaker:

It could be a huge play, though. If we've seen what's happened in other

Speaker:

companies, of course, Strategy is obviously the

Speaker:

leader in this space of building a Bitcoin treasury and a

Speaker:

lot of other companies are doing the same thing. So I think over time, it

Speaker:

could be a real game changer for Echo and

Speaker:

Yeah, I mean, we might at some point do Votes

Speaker:

which are, you know, we do a quarter where we

Speaker:

return a big chunk of the yield that quarter

Speaker:

to Echo token holders. You know, for example, that

Speaker:

could be something which we put up for vote, for example. Because

Speaker:

we do want the community to feel like they are part of the platform. And

Speaker:

that's kind of, we try to create it so it's not just marketing

Speaker:

spiel, but is actually systemic structure inside

Speaker:

Hey, just quickly, if you're ready to dive deeper into crypto and Bitcoin

Speaker:

and build real wealth, join my free crypto collective

Speaker:

community. It's where I share exclusive insights and strategies and

Speaker:

live discussions to help you succeed, whether you're a beginner or

Speaker:

scaling your portfolio. Click on the link in the description and

Speaker:

join us today. Now back to the episode. So Sam, for

Speaker:

trades at different levels, you've got Echo X and Echo Pro. So how

Speaker:

do those platforms or those portions differ within Echo? And

Speaker:

do you need to be an experienced person to come into Echo, or do you cater

Speaker:

Yeah, so Echo X and Echo Pro, first of all, they have

Speaker:

the same fee structure. So it's a purely utilitarian or

Speaker:

UI difference between the two. Echo X

Speaker:

is what would be traditionally considered a quick swap function. So

Speaker:

you type in, I wanna buy one Bitcoin and it will show that's

Speaker:

gonna cost. a hundred and whatever thousand, when it, whenever this

Speaker:

releases dollars, that is, and, um,

Speaker:

you press the button and it makes a swap for you. Easy done. And,

Speaker:

uh, that's echo X effectively. It's, uh, it

Speaker:

would be considered a very user friendly retail tool. Um,

Speaker:

still has lots of token pairs, et cetera, but just that kind of

Speaker:

UI functionality. And then Echo Pro is

Speaker:

more what you would be used to from other cryptocurrency exchanges, your

Speaker:

Krakens, your Coinbases, et cetera. And when I

Speaker:

say that, I mean, a good example is Coinbase Pro, for example, which

Speaker:

So tell me then, Sam, what would be the differences, I guess, or

Speaker:

the benefits of using Echo compared to some of the traditional platforms

Speaker:

Yeah. So, I mean, one of the things with Coinbase is

Speaker:

it's bloody expensive. First of

Speaker:

all, yeah. I mean,

Speaker:

they have a similar setup where they have a kind

Speaker:

of more retail friendly quick swappy type setup

Speaker:

but the fees on that can be crazy I mean I've seen I've seen 0.6 now

Speaker:

1% or something it's it's orders of magnitude more expensive basically coinbase

Speaker:

pro is good with

Speaker:

the order types and stuff but I mean this goes back to an architecture question

Speaker:

really which is a lot of these exchanges have been around

Speaker:

for a while now and they are

Speaker:

in the situation where they've had to they have to keep on bolting on

Speaker:

new features, but they're running old systems, right? Whereas

Speaker:

we're coming in now, basically scratch built with

Speaker:

the newest standards. And it's kind

Speaker:

of the difference between... I'll make the analogy with

Speaker:

the AI stuff, which is happening right now, where you're getting these big legacy

Speaker:

companies who are trying to find a way to make the AI

Speaker:

fit into their organization or you're getting

Speaker:

these AI native companies

Speaker:

come in and just spin the whole thing up because they don't have

Speaker:

any of like the problems associated with

Speaker:

trying to bolt a new technology into

Speaker:

So that's some of it, I would say. Well,

Speaker:

you touched on AI, Sam. I can't now just not talk about AI.

Speaker:

It is a hot topic. So tell me, are

Speaker:

you integrating any AI into Echo? And

Speaker:

if so, how would that benefit the consumer

Speaker:

Yeah, we are. We're looking

Speaker:

right now at doing direct

Speaker:

from or agentic order book and

Speaker:

what that is effectively is you can sit inside chat gbt you have a

Speaker:

plug-in into echo and you can just do

Speaker:

trading via your llm so

Speaker:

you can just say to chat gbt you know get me

Speaker:

Bitcoin at the best price in the next 24 hours and

Speaker:

it will go away via the plugin into Echo

Speaker:

and do that for you. So we're looking at stuff like that right now

Speaker:

because my gut feeling on it and it's interesting hearing

Speaker:

what some of the guys at Google and stuff are saying about how maybe

Speaker:

SaaS is dead or all this idea

Speaker:

of having and a user interface

Speaker:

that we're used to, and will everything

Speaker:

just be done via agents, where my agent talks

Speaker:

to Sam agent, talks to Matthew agent, and

Speaker:

they arrange some stuff between themselves and return

Speaker:

the answer to us, as opposed to having some kind of middle

Speaker:

platform which does some of this stuff. I

Speaker:

think we're a bit off from that still, so I'm not too nervous at this point

Speaker:

with what we're building out. And I

Speaker:

think there's still some advantage, particularly at a

Speaker:

certain institutional level where you want sight and touch on the thing.

Speaker:

But no, I think there's definitely a world where the

Speaker:

retail customer does their trading via LLM,

Speaker:

Yeah. Well, the headline now, Sam, is SAS is

Speaker:

dead. Yeah. Yeah. That's going to be the reel.

Speaker:

The headline reel. SAS is

Speaker:

dead. I'm in good company on that too. I mean, this is what a

Speaker:

lot of the Mac 7 guys are talking about right now.

Speaker:

I mean, I don't think Microsoft

Speaker:

But of course, this is the reason why you're in this space, Sam, because you are obviously

Speaker:

leading the way within the fintech space. You're

Speaker:

going to obviously be leading the way within AIs as well, within

Speaker:

Echo. This leads me to another question, though, because I know a

Speaker:

lot of people will be asking me, wow, because we've seen things on TikTok

Speaker:

or what have you of these AI bots. And these AI

Speaker:

bots somehow plug into a trading software and

Speaker:

can make you a bazillion dollars. Is that true? Because

Speaker:

you will know, because you've got a lot of experience in this space. Is that true? And

Speaker:

if not true, what is there out there where

Speaker:

literally there is an AI bot that can help with trading? Like I could

Speaker:

put $10,000 in it, it makes me 10% a day, for example.

Speaker:

Yeah, yeah. We've thought about... this

Speaker:

bot side, I mean, because really it's AI, but

Speaker:

it's sort of not, it's mostly, it's

Speaker:

just a cover on bots mostly. But

Speaker:

we've looked at this a lot. There's a

Speaker:

difference between what a

Speaker:

normal retail customer will have access to and what a large

Speaker:

institution is able to put together. I

Speaker:

mean, for example, we're looking, we're building out with a New York quant

Speaker:

fund right now, I think what a

Speaker:

market making matrix. And that has a

Speaker:

massive decision tree in almost

Speaker:

instantaneous speed for trading

Speaker:

effectively. And for us, we're using

Speaker:

it for market making so that we have stronger

Speaker:

internal swaps inside the Echo platform. But

Speaker:

you can see how quant funds and stuff would use the thing to just

Speaker:

make a ton of money. The problem with most of those systems

Speaker:

is they cost an absolute fortune and or you're

Speaker:

very latency dependent if they're high frequency, which is

Speaker:

why so many of these New York funds are like, you know, pay a fortune to

Speaker:

sit next to the you know, the exchange because,

Speaker:

you know, every millisecond counts. We obviously have

Speaker:

an advantage in actually being able to sit directly inside our

Speaker:

own exchange, so that's not a problem for us. But we're

Speaker:

certainly looking at some of that stuff. On the consumer side, yeah, we are

Speaker:

looking at agentic style bots where

Speaker:

they kind of, because we will do basic stuff, which

Speaker:

most platforms do where, you know, you can

Speaker:

set up grid trading bots and stuff like that. Basically

Speaker:

kind of plug and play type stuff. But we're also looking at building

Speaker:

kind of almost like personality type bots. so

Speaker:

what's your kind of that could be scary yeah yeah so so

Speaker:

it's like uh so it's like a trading style or like it includes some

Speaker:

of the risk profile of the user into the

Speaker:

into the bot so it won't you know we're

Speaker:

before you before you um put your funds into it you know

Speaker:

there'll be a risk profiling for the user on like what kind

Speaker:

So you as a user could come in and do a sort of a risk profile

Speaker:

on your own personality then the bot let's say is then built

Speaker:

Yeah so you're not going to get a situation where you know, all

Speaker:

Matthew does normally is buy Bitcoin and sit on it. And then it

Speaker:

comes in and, you know, high frequency trades at 10x

Speaker:

leverage shitcoins. You know, there's

Speaker:

a kind of... There's a difference. Yeah, there's a difference. Obviously, there's a difference.

Speaker:

And for us, it's, you know, we don't

Speaker:

want to We don't want to get in the way of what people want to do.

Speaker:

So we're Switzerland in terms of how people

Speaker:

want to trade. We just want to facilitate it, but we don't want to get people in sticky

Speaker:

Yeah. Sam, I want to just pivot for a second into DeFi because

Speaker:

you've got so much experience in this space, years and

Speaker:

years of being in the cryptocurrency industry. I

Speaker:

just want to know, what do you think is the main shift happening in the crypto DeFi

Speaker:

space? And what do you see happening, I guess, in

Speaker:

I think the hot stuff right now, I don't know if it's really

Speaker:

classified as DeFi, but the stablecoin stuff is big right now. Who's

Speaker:

On the institutional level, I mean, I think it's literally today, which JP

Speaker:

Morgan is just planted a flag with their new

Speaker:

stablecoin. Obviously, you've got USDC, got

Speaker:

USDT just got kicked out of the EU because of mica regulation.

Speaker:

So, Tether might be tumbling down after

Speaker:

that. There's... That's like breaking news.

Speaker:

Yeah. So, there's... There's lots

Speaker:

of different things that could happen. I think my gut feeling

Speaker:

on it is what will end up happening is most of

Speaker:

the stable coins right now, and I don't know if your users understand how

Speaker:

these companies make money. So

Speaker:

Tether, for example, what it does to make money is

Speaker:

it receives your dollar bills, your paper bills, and

Speaker:

it mints you, like a real world asset, it mints you a

Speaker:

stable coin, but it's still got all

Speaker:

of those paper dollars. And what it does with those paper

Speaker:

dollars is it buys stuff like T-bills, which are

Speaker:

an interest bearing instrument. So what they're doing effectively

Speaker:

is they're taking your money, making interest on it and giving you

Speaker:

no interest. They're just giving you the stable coin. A

Speaker:

stable coin. Yeah, which is why Tether last

Speaker:

year made more money than Goldman Sachs with

Speaker:

like 50 employees Wow. You

Speaker:

know what, Sam? That is the business model we need. And, you

Speaker:

know, you see those charts of kind of like, you know, revenue per

Speaker:

revenue per employee. And it's like 40 million dollars or

Speaker:

something insane. Wow. That's

Speaker:

incredible. That's incredible. But I think I think what

Speaker:

will end up happening is you'll get some stablecoin issuer who will come in

Speaker:

and hand the yield back to the stablecoin holder.

Speaker:

And as soon as someone does that, all of those other ones are dead in

Speaker:

the water, really. Unless they play along. Unless

Speaker:

they play along. Because it's very difficult to

Speaker:

turn around and say, you know, your

Speaker:

stablecoin is, at a smart contract level,

Speaker:

interest bearing. So it's hard to compete with that.

Speaker:

The interest would literally drop into your wallet just

Speaker:

by sitting on it, which is something which could

Speaker:

happen. So we'll see if

Speaker:

that comes along on the Stablecoin side. Also in DeFi big

Speaker:

at the moment is the RWA stuff. Obviously RWA is big

Speaker:

right now. There's a lot of play around that.

Speaker:

The problem most of them face, and where I think Echo has a

Speaker:

distinct advantage, is they're all doing little bits

Speaker:

of the puzzle. And really what's required

Speaker:

is for a platform to be custodian,

Speaker:

broker and exchange. You need the end-to-end suite

Speaker:

so that you can hold the real world asset and trust it to hold the real world asset.

Speaker:

You can buy and sell real world assets. You have a

Speaker:

tokenization engine to turn them into tokens and

Speaker:

also an exchange to list those tokens on and

Speaker:

you need that full sweep otherwise you end up with kind of someone

Speaker:

who just does custody or someone who is waiting for people to

Speaker:

come to them with assets to put on the exchange or you

Speaker:

know they just do the traditional brokerage piece and

Speaker:

for me that's where Echo starts melding

Speaker:

two worlds and starts being both a

Speaker:

traditional platform and a

Speaker:

fintech blockchain platform. And for me, that's the kind of

Speaker:

long-term goal for Echo, that it becomes this bridging piece

Speaker:

Yeah. Sam, you touched on JP Morgan, I

Speaker:

think you just said, JP Morgan and their stablecoin. There's

Speaker:

obviously something that's happening in this space because of course the regulations have

Speaker:

changed in the US. It now enables main

Speaker:

banking institutions to custody Bitcoin,

Speaker:

especially, and probably cryptocurrency. And

Speaker:

what we're going to see, I think, I'm led to believe, is that those

Speaker:

institutions may merge into becoming exchanges

Speaker:

themselves. And on the same token, we've seen exchanges

Speaker:

who may end up getting banking licenses. So

Speaker:

they'll start sort of merging together. And I think mainly because the

Speaker:

banks now see that the crypto space is so huge, there's a lot of people

Speaker:

making money, like you mentioned about Tether, that much money they're making.

Speaker:

Do you think then, is that sort of something that you foresee in

Speaker:

the forward plans of Echo? Does something like that come into play?

Speaker:

Maybe they get a banking license or something like that? And if not, then

Speaker:

Yeah, sure. So actually, pretty soon on the roadmap, probably

Speaker:

before the new year, we have a partnership with a

Speaker:

banking provider, an EMI, who allow

Speaker:

you to have a virtual will allow us to have virtual eye bands attached to

Speaker:

user accounts. So you can do direct bank transfer directly

Speaker:

into the echo platform, and then you can swap into stable coin

Speaker:

directly. Um, that's a big deal because one of the

Speaker:

main problems that people face when dealing with

Speaker:

the ramping issue, um, is that your bank blocks

Speaker:

payments, uh, to cryptocurrency exchanges,

Speaker:

for example. But the nice thing about this setup is they don't see that they

Speaker:

see a bank to bank. transfer. They see

Speaker:

transfer from chase

Speaker:

to RBS and

Speaker:

that doesn't raise the flags, which is

Speaker:

an experience big plus. But

Speaker:

yes, I agree that I think the

Speaker:

all-in-one ecosystem thing is definitely the vision to

Speaker:

have users come in and not have to leave,

Speaker:

that they can do all of the various things

Speaker:

they want to do inside the platform is definitely

Speaker:

Now I just want to touch on security just in Echo itself, because

Speaker:

I know a lot of people are thinking about, if I'm going to be putting money into the

Speaker:

Echo platform, what sort of security measures do they have? And I think even

Speaker:

more so, Sam, what sort of experience do you bring to the table? What is

Speaker:

Sure. So Echo uses what are called NPC

Speaker:

shard wallets or multi-party computation wallets and

Speaker:

the way they work is normally of a wallet you have a key obviously

Speaker:

and NPC wallets cut the key into lots of different pieces

Speaker:

and then are reformed at the moment when

Speaker:

you sign in in the centralized platform. This

Speaker:

is used by, and our system is

Speaker:

Fireblocks effectively. And that's the system which

Speaker:

is used by people like JP Morgan and these other big players to

Speaker:

hold their assets. And the MPC sharding way

Speaker:

of doing wallet security, touch wood, but hasn't been

Speaker:

breached yet. So it's a very secure way

Speaker:

to hold cryptocurrency assets. On

Speaker:

that note, though, I would say that most breaches

Speaker:

which happen on exchange are not technical breaches. They

Speaker:

would be considered social breaches. And

Speaker:

that's something which, and I make the example of a

Speaker:

bank vault, right, where You know, if

Speaker:

you want to rob a bank, you don't go down to the vault and try

Speaker:

and drill through the vault door. It's

Speaker:

just too much work. What you would do is you make friends with the

Speaker:

And that's the difference between a technical breach and a

Speaker:

social breach, right? Where a lot of these hackers

Speaker:

and stuff, they try and get in with stupid stuff like email

Speaker:

phishing or, you know, I've heard crazy stuff where

Speaker:

like cleaners and stuff, or people impersonate

Speaker:

cleaners coming with USB sticks into your office and

Speaker:

Yeah, so stuff like that, Sam. So how do you combat, you

Speaker:

know, as the guy in charge of Echo, how do

Speaker:

Yeah, it's a bit nerve-wracking when you see, you know, the French cryptocurrency

Speaker:

exchange owners, you know, that their family's getting dragged into vans and

Speaker:

stuff. Exactly. But, I

Speaker:

mean, that's one of the benefits of living on the Isle of Man, I suppose, that it's, you

Speaker:

know, basically the safest country on earth, apart from Monaco. So

Speaker:

I think for me the most important thing is that there's

Speaker:

limits in what are called signing wallets for

Speaker:

treasury funds, for example, or the moving of large assets

Speaker:

inside of the Echo platform. It's

Speaker:

a very limited amount of people who have signing rights

Speaker:

basically for us. It's not something which is

Speaker:

handed out. I think in our organization, there's five people who

Speaker:

can sign those kinds of transactions and

Speaker:

you need three or five to have something go through.

Speaker:

And then Sam, just touching on your

Speaker:

Um, yeah, so I, um, of serial

Speaker:

Uh, I, um, we need people

Speaker:

I found it. I found in my first company at 21. Um,

Speaker:

and, uh, that was a research and development company, uh, which.

Speaker:

basically invented new

Speaker:

products which we then patented and sold to large

Speaker:

corporations. I did that for a number of years and

Speaker:

then I had a very

Speaker:

big deal on the table with that company. for

Speaker:

a nine figure sum. And it took

Speaker:

18 months in the boardroom, back and forth with

Speaker:

that baby. And eventually it all fell through, no

Speaker:

budget because of COVID. I got

Speaker:

a bit burnt out

Speaker:

on doing that stuff. I thought, you know what, I'll go and do something else. And I'd

Speaker:

always been playing with cryptocurrency kind of personally

Speaker:

in the background and thought you know what I think I can do I'll

Speaker:

give it I'll give a shot at doing a better job at this and and some

Speaker:

Yeah, and you're also the youngest board member on

Speaker:

Yeah, it's a bit bigger than just crypto actually. So, there's

Speaker:

a Department of Enterprise for the Isle of Man

Speaker:

government and I sit on what's called the Digital Isle of Man board.

Speaker:

So, I'm a board member effectively for technology. on

Speaker:

the Isle of Man. And there's not official seats

Speaker:

for this kind of thing, but I'm sort of in the fintech crypto

Speaker:

kind of seat for that, I suppose you'd say, unofficially. But

Speaker:

yeah, I'm the youngest board member to sit on

Speaker:

Amazing. Well, Sam, thank you so much. I just want to just wrap

Speaker:

this up. We're just asking you, how can people, because obviously Echo's doing

Speaker:

some incredible things in this space, and I really think people should jump in and

Speaker:

at least have a look at the offerings there. Maybe take

Speaker:

advantage of the tokens offerings as well. How

Speaker:

Sure. So go to www.echo.im. Um,

Speaker:

that will, you can, is KYC is required, uh, to,

Speaker:

to get in. Uh, but it's, you know, I like to think it's a

Speaker:

very, we've, we've spent a lot of time trying to get that as smooth as

Speaker:

possible. Um, we do have a thing called magic links as

Speaker:

well, which is, which is quite interesting. So we were passwordless. Um,

Speaker:

so a password is not required to log into Echo. Um,

Speaker:

which is, which is quite cool too. That's another security feature really where

Speaker:

we, um. You know, we, one of the main reasons

Speaker:

for breach on the consumer side is people losing or forgetting passwords.

Speaker:

Um, so we use magic links instead just to say

Speaker:

Uh, and, um, yeah,

Speaker:

at the moment we, we have a little bit of echo

Speaker:

token left in the final bit of.

Speaker:

pre-sale, basically, before it goes live on

Speaker:

exchange as a trading pair. So do take

Speaker:

Yeah, if you sign up, you can

Speaker:

Oh, excellent. OK, well, we'll leave links to all those in the show notes as well. And

Speaker:

just say, Sam Dorough from Echo, thank you

Speaker:

so much for joining us on Crypto Collective. Thanks, Matthew. Cheers. Thanks

Speaker:

for tuning in to Crypto Collective. If you've enjoyed this episode, the

Speaker:

best way to show your support is to leave a five-star review on

Speaker:

Apple Podcast or Spotify. And make sure to subscribe to

Speaker:

the YouTube channel so you don't miss an episode. You can also find

Speaker:

more of me at I'm Matthew Fraser on