1 00:01:31,429 --> 00:01:32,069 Hey, my friends. 2 00:01:32,069 --> 00:01:34,309 Welcome back to Generator live. 3 00:01:34,309 --> 00:01:38,269 It is 7pm here on the East Coast. 4 00:01:38,269 --> 00:01:39,869 We're covered by ice and snow. 5 00:01:40,589 --> 00:01:42,909 Tonight is going to be an interesting episode. 6 00:01:43,149 --> 00:01:47,349 So you've heard me talking about Evoto Gate a couple of weeks 7 00:01:47,349 --> 00:01:48,829 ago coming out of Imaging. 8 00:01:49,469 --> 00:01:55,429 You've heard me talk about almost weekly, how AI has infiltrated 9 00:01:55,429 --> 00:01:56,509 the photography industry. 10 00:01:56,669 --> 00:01:57,469 Seems that way. 11 00:01:57,469 --> 00:02:02,269 It seems like there's been some sort of focus solely on AI and 12 00:02:02,269 --> 00:02:03,629 what that means for all of us. 13 00:02:04,029 --> 00:02:08,189 And I wanted to talk tonight specifically about that. 14 00:02:08,189 --> 00:02:13,989 I wanted to talk about photography retouching, how AI is 15 00:02:13,989 --> 00:02:15,229 affecting all of that. 16 00:02:15,229 --> 00:02:20,309 And there really is no better person to bring on, in my opinion, 17 00:02:20,309 --> 00:02:22,429 than my friend Nino Batista. 18 00:02:22,429 --> 00:02:23,269 How are you, sir? 19 00:02:23,269 --> 00:02:24,149 Welcome to. 20 00:02:24,469 --> 00:02:26,309 Welcome again to Generator. 21 00:02:27,509 --> 00:02:28,469 Absolutely, Nan. 22 00:02:28,709 --> 00:02:32,579 It's great to be here again, obviously, and one hell of a topic. 23 00:02:32,579 --> 00:02:34,659 So this will be fun. 24 00:02:34,659 --> 00:02:36,499 But yeah, you know, I appreciate it, man. 25 00:02:36,499 --> 00:02:37,179 Good to be here. 26 00:02:37,259 --> 00:02:40,939 We've had a lot of conversations and this always seems 27 00:02:40,939 --> 00:02:41,499 to come up. 28 00:02:41,499 --> 00:02:43,979 This always seems to come up in one way, shape or form. 29 00:02:44,699 --> 00:02:47,019 And, you know, thinking about. 30 00:02:47,659 --> 00:02:52,579 I had a great conversation with Kelly Robitau recently and we 31 00:02:52,579 --> 00:02:55,139 were talking about, you know, she's like you, photographer and 32 00:02:55,139 --> 00:02:56,939 retoucher, and had a lot of thoughts. 33 00:02:57,469 --> 00:03:02,589 Dennis Dunbar, right, great friend of yours, guy that has done 34 00:03:02,589 --> 00:03:06,509 probably more in retouching than most of us will ever know. 35 00:03:07,549 --> 00:03:09,269 Pratik talks about this all the time. 36 00:03:09,269 --> 00:03:13,269 And I love getting the retoucher's perspective because as 37 00:03:13,269 --> 00:03:15,389 photographers, we're so egocentric. 38 00:03:15,389 --> 00:03:18,469 We think the world revolves around those of us that are taking 39 00:03:18,469 --> 00:03:18,989 pictures. 40 00:03:19,309 --> 00:03:24,359 And then retouching seems to be that it's the art that we all 41 00:03:24,359 --> 00:03:28,439 need, but for some reason it doesn't get as much attention. 42 00:03:28,439 --> 00:03:34,839 And I think with Evoto, right, since we started there, coming out, 43 00:03:34,999 --> 00:03:38,999 having that whole debacle with coming out with an AI headshot generator, 44 00:03:39,159 --> 00:03:40,919 it just sparked the debate again. 45 00:03:41,399 --> 00:03:45,279 And so, you know, without getting too far into it, I really 46 00:03:45,279 --> 00:03:51,209 would love to hear from you what your entire take on this is, 47 00:03:51,209 --> 00:03:53,849 and then we can dive into specific subjects and we'll just 48 00:03:53,849 --> 00:03:54,729 kind of follow things along. 49 00:03:54,729 --> 00:03:57,529 But I really did want to talk to you about this and I think you're 50 00:03:57,529 --> 00:04:01,329 the right person to give me the no BS answers on everything. 51 00:04:03,009 --> 00:04:06,449 I mean, yeah, I appreciate that and I have a lot of opinions 52 00:04:06,449 --> 00:04:09,769 on it because it's something that has made me do a lot of thinking 53 00:04:09,769 --> 00:04:11,089 in the last couple years. 54 00:04:11,089 --> 00:04:11,409 Right. 55 00:04:11,969 --> 00:04:13,849 Like anyone should do a lot of thinking. 56 00:04:13,849 --> 00:04:17,009 And at first it was concerning, and then it was really 57 00:04:17,009 --> 00:04:18,489 concerning, and then it was Terrifying. 58 00:04:18,489 --> 00:04:22,929 And then, and I've kind of scaled back on, on the sort of existential 59 00:04:22,929 --> 00:04:23,889 horror about it. 60 00:04:24,609 --> 00:04:27,609 I'm not trying to claim offhand, let me just be clear. 61 00:04:27,609 --> 00:04:30,129 I'm not saying that AI is not a concerning tech. 62 00:04:30,209 --> 00:04:33,209 And of course when we say AI, Matt, we have to also know that we're 63 00:04:33,209 --> 00:04:37,489 talking about a wide open ended concept that goes well beyond 64 00:04:37,489 --> 00:04:38,609 retouching your headshot. 65 00:04:38,609 --> 00:04:38,809 Right? 66 00:04:38,809 --> 00:04:41,129 So we're talking about something larger than that and this 67 00:04:41,129 --> 00:04:46,179 is a debate and something that should be, that people should be 68 00:04:46,179 --> 00:04:47,219 aware of is what I'm saying. 69 00:04:47,219 --> 00:04:47,419 Right. 70 00:04:47,419 --> 00:04:50,219 We can't, we can't just pretend that this technology is just 71 00:04:50,219 --> 00:04:50,939 another iPhone. 72 00:04:50,939 --> 00:04:51,859 It's, there's something there. 73 00:04:51,859 --> 00:04:53,019 We have to pay attention. 74 00:04:53,019 --> 00:04:58,378 Now with that said, what I started to realize is that, and I 75 00:04:58,378 --> 00:05:02,379 start to realize, but really what I came to terms with was as 76 00:05:02,379 --> 00:05:08,259 an artist, as an artist, tactically, your art shouldn't be 77 00:05:08,259 --> 00:05:13,199 invalidated by another function of some kind or another 78 00:05:13,199 --> 00:05:17,519 person or computer or anything that makes manufactured art. 79 00:05:17,519 --> 00:05:20,719 We've been making manufactured art for a long time, we've been making 80 00:05:20,719 --> 00:05:24,279 manufactured music for a long time, et cetera. 81 00:05:24,439 --> 00:05:29,599 And that's not to say that it isn't frustrating, but if your career 82 00:05:29,599 --> 00:05:33,679 was entirely, or rather if your photography career, you retouching 83 00:05:33,679 --> 00:05:36,519 career, whatever it is, if it can be replaced overnight by AI, 84 00:05:37,789 --> 00:05:39,389 that is not your fault per se. 85 00:05:39,469 --> 00:05:41,469 But it's very telling about what you were doing. 86 00:05:41,629 --> 00:05:43,469 It's very telling about what the industry wants. 87 00:05:43,469 --> 00:05:45,469 Because remember, at the end of the day we have to think about 88 00:05:45,469 --> 00:05:46,509 supply and demand, right? 89 00:05:46,509 --> 00:05:50,389 So if AI is doing things faster and acceptable and the clients 90 00:05:50,389 --> 00:05:52,749 are paying for it, that's the end of it, right? 91 00:05:53,389 --> 00:05:57,629 So if you're completely replaced because you were making, 92 00:05:58,589 --> 00:06:02,669 lack of a better term, dismissible consumables, and I don't 93 00:06:02,669 --> 00:06:04,949 mean to be a jerk about it, but I'm just going to say that because 94 00:06:04,949 --> 00:06:05,629 it's true though. 95 00:06:05,629 --> 00:06:08,349 If you were making generic sort of ads, I was a graphic designer 96 00:06:08,349 --> 00:06:08,659 for years. 97 00:06:09,049 --> 00:06:11,329 If you're making sort of generic ads and just needed a photo 98 00:06:11,329 --> 00:06:14,449 of a beer bottle, as long as it was adequate, it worked and you 99 00:06:14,449 --> 00:06:14,969 got the ad. 100 00:06:14,969 --> 00:06:18,649 If someone can do that in seven minutes versus your seven hours 101 00:06:19,369 --> 00:06:22,849 and they need it for advertising, that's a no brainer, 102 00:06:22,849 --> 00:06:23,129 right? 103 00:06:23,129 --> 00:06:26,769 So it's, that's horrible because people are losing jobs, there's 104 00:06:26,769 --> 00:06:27,209 no question. 105 00:06:27,369 --> 00:06:32,369 So what I decided was since I don't do that really anymore, I decided 106 00:06:32,369 --> 00:06:36,239 that as an artist, someone who's trying to make images for the 107 00:06:36,239 --> 00:06:38,679 sake of the Images that. 108 00:06:38,679 --> 00:06:39,719 That's where I was going to focus. 109 00:06:39,719 --> 00:06:42,239 I was going to focus my analysis and sort of interpretation 110 00:06:42,239 --> 00:06:46,999 of what AI does to us culturally from the lens of an artist, 111 00:06:46,999 --> 00:06:47,239 right. 112 00:06:47,239 --> 00:06:47,919 Whatever that is. 113 00:06:47,919 --> 00:06:48,999 Even as a musician, right. 114 00:06:49,159 --> 00:06:50,359 Play guitar and whatnot. 115 00:06:50,839 --> 00:06:54,119 Because AI is definitely intruding on that space as well. 116 00:06:54,519 --> 00:07:00,769 So as an artist, what I discovered in myself was, how do 117 00:07:00,769 --> 00:07:00,889 I. 118 00:07:00,889 --> 00:07:01,729 How do I start this? 119 00:07:03,889 --> 00:07:06,369 Art is more than the final product, right? 120 00:07:07,169 --> 00:07:09,249 It is the final product, there's no question about it. 121 00:07:09,489 --> 00:07:13,169 But art, no matter what it is, it draws you in. 122 00:07:13,249 --> 00:07:16,649 There's something about that personal experience that, you know, 123 00:07:16,649 --> 00:07:17,969 was created by a human. 124 00:07:18,369 --> 00:07:21,089 And because it was created by a human, there's an extra layer of 125 00:07:21,089 --> 00:07:21,529 interest there. 126 00:07:21,529 --> 00:07:24,569 Even if it's fleeting and brief, it's still an extra layer 127 00:07:24,569 --> 00:07:25,009 of interest. 128 00:07:25,089 --> 00:07:26,249 It could be very profound. 129 00:07:26,249 --> 00:07:27,579 It could be photojournalism. 130 00:07:27,579 --> 00:07:29,819 There's a whole story into the image, Right, right. 131 00:07:29,819 --> 00:07:32,939 That's obvious, but there's still some human element, right? 132 00:07:32,939 --> 00:07:37,419 So, for example, if I venture out to some one of these locations 133 00:07:37,419 --> 00:07:39,459 that I love to go to, you know, Southwest Desert or something 134 00:07:39,459 --> 00:07:41,819 like that, or I end up finally going out to Zion or something, right? 135 00:07:41,979 --> 00:07:46,139 And I go with a model and I put her on a cliffside and I use 136 00:07:46,139 --> 00:07:48,819 a 400 millimeter lens and I take a shot and it's beautiful. 137 00:07:48,819 --> 00:07:52,739 And, you know, she's on the edge of a precipice of some kind, 138 00:07:52,739 --> 00:07:55,849 and it's really dramatic and sky was cooperating and I love the 139 00:07:55,849 --> 00:07:56,649 work and it's beautiful. 140 00:07:56,649 --> 00:07:59,049 Now, if I show that to you, Matt, the first thing you're going 141 00:07:59,049 --> 00:08:02,369 to think is, how the hell would you do that? 142 00:08:02,529 --> 00:08:02,889 Right? 143 00:08:02,889 --> 00:08:04,329 Was there any danger involved? 144 00:08:04,329 --> 00:08:06,529 Subconsciously, you got to, how did she get up there? 145 00:08:06,529 --> 00:08:06,929 Right. 146 00:08:07,089 --> 00:08:08,449 Is any of this faked? 147 00:08:08,449 --> 00:08:09,969 Was there a helicopter involved? 148 00:08:09,969 --> 00:08:13,049 You know, those are questions that would come to mind which add 149 00:08:13,049 --> 00:08:15,489 interest to the image, right? 150 00:08:15,489 --> 00:08:16,449 Hopefully, sure. 151 00:08:16,449 --> 00:08:21,649 If I rendered all of that in GPT or whatever the hell you'd be 152 00:08:21,649 --> 00:08:22,809 like, that's pretty. 153 00:08:23,209 --> 00:08:25,809 And that's the end of that conversation, right? 154 00:08:25,809 --> 00:08:29,529 Even if it looked nearly identical, if you said, is this real? 155 00:08:29,529 --> 00:08:34,449 No, it's AI, suddenly its meaning gets deflated 100%. 156 00:08:34,449 --> 00:08:34,809 Not. 157 00:08:34,809 --> 00:08:37,609 Not the quality, the meaning, right. 158 00:08:37,929 --> 00:08:39,249 When we say meaning, we. 159 00:08:39,249 --> 00:08:41,169 This is where I want to really harp on tonight. 160 00:08:41,169 --> 00:08:43,729 And I'm getting off my little soapbox in a minute. 161 00:08:43,729 --> 00:08:45,529 But this is my whole point that I'm circling. 162 00:08:46,579 --> 00:08:51,099 When we say meaning, we tend to, I think, anyway, we tend to look 163 00:08:51,099 --> 00:08:52,219 for something really profound. 164 00:08:52,219 --> 00:08:54,499 Again, the photo generalism angle is really Obvious. 165 00:08:54,659 --> 00:08:55,819 You have a shot of a. 166 00:08:55,819 --> 00:08:56,819 Of a war zone. 167 00:08:56,899 --> 00:08:59,379 You have a shot of a protest, someone getting killed even. 168 00:08:59,459 --> 00:09:00,059 You have these. 169 00:09:00,059 --> 00:09:02,659 These images that tell deep, profound stories. 170 00:09:02,659 --> 00:09:06,019 You know, these legendary shots that get the whatever the hell 171 00:09:06,019 --> 00:09:06,979 awards they, I can't remember. 172 00:09:08,579 --> 00:09:09,699 Yeah, those tell stories. 173 00:09:09,699 --> 00:09:10,339 That's obvious. 174 00:09:10,419 --> 00:09:11,779 But there's other stories. 175 00:09:12,459 --> 00:09:14,619 There's stories for the sake of the art. 176 00:09:14,699 --> 00:09:16,339 There's stories for the sake of the moment. 177 00:09:16,339 --> 00:09:17,779 There's stories for the sake of the. 178 00:09:17,779 --> 00:09:21,499 Of the beauty of the eroticism of something. 179 00:09:21,739 --> 00:09:25,419 There's some story element that's in there because there's a 180 00:09:25,419 --> 00:09:27,419 human or because it was made by human. 181 00:09:28,058 --> 00:09:36,259 And what we're seeing, my mind, is a reprioritization of and 182 00:09:36,259 --> 00:09:39,009 kind of a recalibration of what we see art as. 183 00:09:39,009 --> 00:09:42,249 We forget the human element, especially when we're scrolling on 184 00:09:42,249 --> 00:09:44,969 our phones and it's just, next, next, next, next, next, next 185 00:09:44,969 --> 00:09:45,209 image. 186 00:09:45,209 --> 00:09:45,809 Next image. 187 00:09:45,809 --> 00:09:49,169 Well, for a time, that was all made by people, for the most part. 188 00:09:49,329 --> 00:09:50,729 And I'm not saying it's all valid. 189 00:09:50,729 --> 00:09:52,049 I'm not saying it's all great. 190 00:09:52,289 --> 00:09:55,449 I'm saying that we're going to have to go backwards now and recalibrate 191 00:09:55,449 --> 00:09:57,889 to the importance of something human, Right? 192 00:09:57,889 --> 00:10:02,129 We even say, like, if you say I bought a car and you say a bunch 193 00:10:02,129 --> 00:10:04,259 of robots made, it could be a nice car. 194 00:10:04,259 --> 00:10:08,339 But as soon as they say and stitch leather, you imagine some 195 00:10:08,339 --> 00:10:12,899 Italian artisan stitching your leather and your car, and there's 196 00:10:12,899 --> 00:10:13,579 value there. 197 00:10:14,379 --> 00:10:17,739 It, whatever, that might just be marketing, but still there's value 198 00:10:17,739 --> 00:10:18,059 there. 199 00:10:18,219 --> 00:10:18,499 So. 200 00:10:18,499 --> 00:10:20,859 And I don't just mean service people stitching leather. 201 00:10:20,859 --> 00:10:23,699 I mean, in general making art, there's a human element. 202 00:10:23,699 --> 00:10:24,859 And that human element. 203 00:10:25,099 --> 00:10:27,259 It's not to say that things won't change and haven't already 204 00:10:27,259 --> 00:10:27,619 changed. 205 00:10:27,619 --> 00:10:31,349 I'm not being naive, but the human element cannot be replaced 206 00:10:31,349 --> 00:10:32,549 because there's no history. 207 00:10:32,629 --> 00:10:33,589 Humans have experience. 208 00:10:33,909 --> 00:10:37,429 Humans have a timeline Humans can remember six months ago. 209 00:10:37,509 --> 00:10:40,229 It could be art you made during a dark period of your life. 210 00:10:40,229 --> 00:10:42,469 It could be art you made after you got divorced. 211 00:10:42,469 --> 00:10:44,628 It could be art you made while you were terminally ill. 212 00:10:44,628 --> 00:10:47,709 It could be art you made while visiting somebody you've never seen 213 00:10:47,709 --> 00:10:48,309 since then. 214 00:10:48,389 --> 00:10:52,869 Who knows what the story is, but an AI is like an adult that was 215 00:10:52,869 --> 00:10:55,429 born yesterday who knows everything but knows nothing. 216 00:10:56,389 --> 00:11:00,829 And that's awesome for the end result, but little or zero to the 217 00:11:00,829 --> 00:11:01,269 meaning. 218 00:11:01,589 --> 00:11:03,669 There's my soapbox for the start things on. 219 00:11:03,989 --> 00:11:08,989 I think it's a great place to start, especially for, you know, 220 00:11:08,989 --> 00:11:14,549 even when I learned from you years ago, there's so much more than 221 00:11:14,549 --> 00:11:18,069 the technical aspect of photography or retouching doesn't 222 00:11:18,069 --> 00:11:18,309 matter. 223 00:11:19,189 --> 00:11:24,389 There's so much more in the connection with the subject, right? 224 00:11:24,389 --> 00:11:27,229 And it could be a hired subject, it could be, if you're doing 225 00:11:27,229 --> 00:11:30,469 retail photography, someone that comes in off the street, right? 226 00:11:30,469 --> 00:11:35,509 But there's a connection with the subject that creates trust in 227 00:11:35,509 --> 00:11:36,989 the artist, right? 228 00:11:37,469 --> 00:11:41,429 And I think back to when artists had patrons, right? 229 00:11:41,429 --> 00:11:43,869 And I'm not talking Patreon, I'm talking actual patrons, right? 230 00:11:43,869 --> 00:11:44,189 That. 231 00:11:44,269 --> 00:11:47,029 That just basically, the artist didn't make any money, so 232 00:11:47,029 --> 00:11:50,169 they found some rich dude who just said, you know what? 233 00:11:50,169 --> 00:11:52,769 I believe in you as an artist, and I'm going to give you a whole 234 00:11:52,769 --> 00:11:53,289 bunch of money. 235 00:11:53,929 --> 00:11:57,969 Because they believed that the artist was going to be able to tell 236 00:11:57,969 --> 00:12:03,369 stories or produce work that was exceptional in their eyes above 237 00:12:03,369 --> 00:12:04,969 anything else that was out there. 238 00:12:05,769 --> 00:12:11,609 And it's that trust that allows the artist to portray an emotional 239 00:12:11,609 --> 00:12:13,369 truth, right? 240 00:12:13,769 --> 00:12:19,009 And the emotional truth is what I see as being lost, right? 241 00:12:19,009 --> 00:12:24,629 AI can create flawless, you know, beautiful images, technically 242 00:12:24,949 --> 00:12:29,269 pristine images that many artists cannot do. 243 00:12:29,989 --> 00:12:34,709 But because they are flawless, they're also a bit soulless. 244 00:12:35,669 --> 00:12:36,629 So the. 245 00:12:36,629 --> 00:12:41,829 The idea of human imperfection is the thing that you just can't 246 00:12:41,829 --> 00:12:42,829 replace, right? 247 00:12:42,829 --> 00:12:46,309 And that's why Ricardo Montalban talked about Corinthian 248 00:12:46,309 --> 00:12:47,669 leather in a car, right? 249 00:12:47,669 --> 00:12:50,869 Because there was this emotional connection in the marketing 250 00:12:50,869 --> 00:12:54,449 that was just kind of like, yes, y. Yeah, you can have any car. 251 00:12:54,929 --> 00:12:56,809 We got Corinthian leather. 252 00:12:56,809 --> 00:12:59,569 And no one knew what the hell Corinthian leather was. 253 00:12:59,569 --> 00:13:01,809 But they were like, still does, but no one. 254 00:13:01,809 --> 00:13:04,369 No one does, but they want it, right? 255 00:13:04,609 --> 00:13:05,849 And this is the thing. 256 00:13:05,849 --> 00:13:06,289 Yes. 257 00:13:06,369 --> 00:13:12,649 Things can be produced that are flawless and perfect, but when 258 00:13:12,649 --> 00:13:14,849 I look at it, I go, wow, that's. 259 00:13:14,849 --> 00:13:19,569 That's technically beautiful, but I don't see the depth, I don't 260 00:13:19,569 --> 00:13:20,609 see the flaws. 261 00:13:20,769 --> 00:13:25,439 The flaws build that trust in me that this came from a human, right? 262 00:13:25,599 --> 00:13:28,559 How many things are we seeing now, especially this day and age, 263 00:13:29,199 --> 00:13:35,879 where what you see, instead of falling into the story, you go, oh, 264 00:13:35,879 --> 00:13:36,119 this. 265 00:13:36,119 --> 00:13:37,279 This has got to be AI. 266 00:13:37,359 --> 00:13:38,319 This has got to be AI. 267 00:13:38,319 --> 00:13:38,719 He's got. 268 00:13:38,719 --> 00:13:40,199 Oh, look, he's got six fingers. 269 00:13:40,199 --> 00:13:43,399 Or look in the background, the clock is spinning backwards, whatever 270 00:13:43,399 --> 00:13:44,079 it is, right? 271 00:13:44,559 --> 00:13:45,039 I'm. 272 00:13:45,039 --> 00:13:48,719 I look for that little Sora in the bottom of every video. 273 00:13:48,879 --> 00:13:50,119 I'm like, when is that going to. 274 00:13:50,119 --> 00:13:51,359 What is that going to crop up? 275 00:13:51,529 --> 00:13:53,289 Yeah, because it's so good now. 276 00:13:53,449 --> 00:13:58,809 And we've been so already inundated with all of these images 277 00:13:59,849 --> 00:14:03,689 and, and videos, which are getting remarkable by the way, that 278 00:14:04,729 --> 00:14:07,449 I'm, I'm feel like we're losing trust. 279 00:14:07,769 --> 00:14:12,169 So fast forward a little bit and everything that you were saying 280 00:14:12,249 --> 00:14:17,849 about, you know, creating a product that is a unique to the artist 281 00:14:17,849 --> 00:14:20,359 and being a little bit imperfect. 282 00:14:20,359 --> 00:14:24,879 I think the connection that I found and that I've been trying to 283 00:14:24,879 --> 00:14:27,479 sell for many years is printed products. 284 00:14:27,799 --> 00:14:28,199 Right. 285 00:14:28,519 --> 00:14:32,519 Because the digital aspect will get you so far. 286 00:14:32,919 --> 00:14:36,999 I think when artists, photographers start adding in printed 287 00:14:36,999 --> 00:14:41,839 products now, it almost becomes accepted that there is going 288 00:14:41,839 --> 00:14:44,199 to be a little bit of retouching on it and that's okay. 289 00:14:44,439 --> 00:14:48,319 But the client still respects the photographer, that they've learned 290 00:14:48,319 --> 00:14:51,589 the craft to do the retouching, whether it's digital 291 00:14:51,589 --> 00:14:52,149 or not. 292 00:14:52,709 --> 00:14:57,749 And then they're creating a physical piece and there's this trust 293 00:14:57,749 --> 00:15:01,509 between the client and the photographer that this is the transaction. 294 00:15:02,229 --> 00:15:02,629 Right. 295 00:15:02,869 --> 00:15:06,629 When that trust is gone and people are just saying, well, you're 296 00:15:06,629 --> 00:15:09,509 just going to run this through some AI program, make it perfect, 297 00:15:09,749 --> 00:15:15,429 they're already disinvesting, uninvesting, I don't know what the 298 00:15:15,429 --> 00:15:19,389 proper prefix for that is, but they become less interested in the 299 00:15:19,389 --> 00:15:21,019 product and now it's just pure. 300 00:15:21,089 --> 00:15:24,769 Surely a transaction like, hey, you have the camera, I don't 301 00:15:24,769 --> 00:15:27,329 take the picture, press the button monkey and. 302 00:15:27,729 --> 00:15:28,529 And that's it. 303 00:15:29,009 --> 00:15:33,209 So before I run off at the mouth too much, the emotional truth 304 00:15:33,209 --> 00:15:38,449 and the trust is what I find are like the last bastions of hope 305 00:15:38,849 --> 00:15:43,649 for those of us in these industries that we have to be able 306 00:15:43,649 --> 00:15:46,049 to talk to our clients about that. 307 00:15:46,049 --> 00:15:50,209 We have to be able to infuse that in our art in a way that people 308 00:15:50,289 --> 00:15:52,049 see it and they believe us. 309 00:15:52,129 --> 00:15:54,829 Not that we're trying sell them some Corinthian leather, but 310 00:15:54,829 --> 00:15:57,549 they believe what it is that we're giving them. 311 00:15:59,309 --> 00:15:59,789 Trust. 312 00:16:00,109 --> 00:16:03,549 Yeah, trust and, and truth is really where I'm getting at. 313 00:16:04,029 --> 00:16:04,709 That's correct. 314 00:16:04,709 --> 00:16:09,188 And as we know, clients in general, not just photography clients, 315 00:16:09,188 --> 00:16:11,869 but anyone who hires an artist, they don't always know what 316 00:16:11,869 --> 00:16:12,269 they want. 317 00:16:12,269 --> 00:16:14,469 And they are very end result oriented. 318 00:16:14,469 --> 00:16:18,149 You know, even a record label wants a pop song, they're not particularly 319 00:16:18,149 --> 00:16:20,209 interested in how it's created. 320 00:16:20,209 --> 00:16:23,009 Really at the end of the day especially, I mean, there's variables, 321 00:16:23,009 --> 00:16:23,409 of course. 322 00:16:23,809 --> 00:16:26,289 So if a client comes to you and says, I need a beautiful headshot, 323 00:16:26,449 --> 00:16:30,089 if you take a snapshot to your phone and run it through AI and they 324 00:16:30,089 --> 00:16:32,769 think they look beautiful, technically you've succeeded. 325 00:16:32,769 --> 00:16:33,249 Yeah. 326 00:16:33,409 --> 00:16:35,889 So, you know, what are you supposed to do? 327 00:16:35,889 --> 00:16:36,609 Argue with that? 328 00:16:36,609 --> 00:16:40,009 Necessarily, you know, because a headshot client might not care 329 00:16:40,009 --> 00:16:42,609 about your truth and beauty soliloquy at all. 330 00:16:42,769 --> 00:16:45,879 They just might be like, I want to look halfway decent on my 331 00:16:45,879 --> 00:16:48,839 LinkedIn, you know, and so it's just like all. 332 00:16:49,719 --> 00:16:51,959 We had this conversation recently with my, my son actually, 333 00:16:51,959 --> 00:16:53,279 because he's into cars and stuff. 334 00:16:53,279 --> 00:16:55,279 It's an engineering question, but it can be applied to so much 335 00:16:55,279 --> 00:16:55,559 more. 336 00:16:55,959 --> 00:16:59,559 When you engineer anything, when you're creating anything, what 337 00:16:59,559 --> 00:17:03,479 can be done is not as relevant and not as important as what's the 338 00:17:03,479 --> 00:17:03,759 point? 339 00:17:03,759 --> 00:17:04,679 What's the purpose? 340 00:17:04,919 --> 00:17:06,079 Where are our parameters? 341 00:17:06,079 --> 00:17:08,279 How are we defining what this thing is supposed to do? 342 00:17:08,279 --> 00:17:12,349 Right, because if your mission is fast car and everything else is 343 00:17:12,349 --> 00:17:15,549 relevant, you engineer a fast car that's going to be inefficient, 344 00:17:15,549 --> 00:17:18,149 impractical, incredibly dangerous, and go 450 miles an hour 345 00:17:18,149 --> 00:17:21,829 and almost certainly kill you because you're not considering something 346 00:17:21,829 --> 00:17:22,909 other than fast car. 347 00:17:23,549 --> 00:17:27,469 So when you're thinking about making something, even as an artist, 348 00:17:27,629 --> 00:17:32,189 what's the intent that should drive you as to what you want to 349 00:17:32,189 --> 00:17:32,349 do? 350 00:17:32,349 --> 00:17:35,669 Right, so me, again, I'm coming from the artist standpoint, 351 00:17:35,669 --> 00:17:38,339 which people can criticize my work if they want, they have for 352 00:17:38,339 --> 00:17:42,899 years, whatever, but I'm going to model myself from the fine art 353 00:17:42,899 --> 00:17:45,619 perspective, making art for the hell of it, making art for the 354 00:17:45,619 --> 00:17:48,339 sake of the art, and then seeing what I can do to make a career 355 00:17:48,339 --> 00:17:48,659 out of it. 356 00:17:48,659 --> 00:17:48,939 Right? 357 00:17:49,019 --> 00:17:51,499 That's the fine art business model, for lack of a better term. 358 00:17:51,499 --> 00:17:57,899 Now with that said, that my purpose is art for art's sake and 359 00:17:57,899 --> 00:17:58,939 hopefully it lands. 360 00:17:59,179 --> 00:18:02,619 Sounds simple enough, but as we know, that's very, very difficult. 361 00:18:02,939 --> 00:18:06,909 I don't know what I would do if someone wanted me to do headshots 362 00:18:06,909 --> 00:18:09,429 for them and they just said, can you run it through AI? 363 00:18:10,389 --> 00:18:11,749 I've heard conflicting ideas. 364 00:18:11,749 --> 00:18:14,549 I've heard people say, hey, you don't respect me as an artist. 365 00:18:14,549 --> 00:18:15,709 And I get that. 366 00:18:15,709 --> 00:18:16,549 That makes sense. 367 00:18:16,549 --> 00:18:19,309 You should say that there's some clients who are never going 368 00:18:19,309 --> 00:18:19,669 to care. 369 00:18:20,069 --> 00:18:21,829 They just want the end result. 370 00:18:22,149 --> 00:18:26,549 Now, again, end result oriented art, even in music, been 371 00:18:26,549 --> 00:18:27,509 around for decades. 372 00:18:27,989 --> 00:18:31,309 You know, people aren't always looking for the profile. 373 00:18:31,309 --> 00:18:34,009 Most people even aren't looking for the profound. 374 00:18:34,009 --> 00:18:36,849 They're not looking for the big deep storyline or anything like 375 00:18:36,849 --> 00:18:37,129 that. 376 00:18:37,209 --> 00:18:44,089 So for me, for me, I think that the truth element is a big aspect 377 00:18:44,089 --> 00:18:44,409 of it. 378 00:18:44,409 --> 00:18:47,689 But if you're talking about a client who's paying you to do something, 379 00:18:48,489 --> 00:18:52,609 that has already changed and will continue to change, and that's 380 00:18:52,609 --> 00:18:56,809 honestly concerning for me, because, how do I put this? 381 00:18:59,619 --> 00:19:00,419 It's inevitable. 382 00:19:00,419 --> 00:19:00,859 Yeah. 383 00:19:00,859 --> 00:19:02,819 What we're, what we're seeing, it's not going to stop. 384 00:19:03,459 --> 00:19:05,019 It will taper, it will level out. 385 00:19:05,019 --> 00:19:05,699 It has to. 386 00:19:06,419 --> 00:19:11,499 But some aspects of industries are going to be replaced. 387 00:19:11,499 --> 00:19:16,619 Now, saying that tech has helped destroy jobs for decades is 388 00:19:16,619 --> 00:19:21,219 not a consolation prize for anyone, but it really has been happening 389 00:19:21,219 --> 00:19:21,939 for a long time. 390 00:19:22,099 --> 00:19:25,059 It's just that AI has a terrifying efficiency, doesn't it? 391 00:19:25,549 --> 00:19:25,949 That's. 392 00:19:26,029 --> 00:19:26,669 And that's it. 393 00:19:26,669 --> 00:19:27,909 That's the concern right there. 394 00:19:27,909 --> 00:19:28,349 Yeah. 395 00:19:28,349 --> 00:19:32,709 The, you know, just going back to I have to pop a Ricolo. 396 00:19:32,709 --> 00:19:35,669 I don't know, I've been trying to get over this head cold sinus 397 00:19:35,669 --> 00:19:39,709 thing, so forgive me, I gotta blow those Swedish horns and have 398 00:19:39,709 --> 00:19:40,509 a Ricola. 399 00:19:41,069 --> 00:19:45,469 So one of the things that popped to my mind while you were 400 00:19:45,469 --> 00:19:48,669 talking about that, about, you know, the hypothetical scenario, 401 00:19:48,669 --> 00:19:51,269 someone wants to come to you and they just say, hey, I don't care 402 00:19:51,269 --> 00:19:53,339 how you do it, just get me a good headshot from LinkedIn. 403 00:19:55,089 --> 00:19:59,769 I almost want to think like, I'm not making art anymore, I'm making 404 00:19:59,769 --> 00:20:00,129 content. 405 00:20:00,689 --> 00:20:05,009 And if I'm treating my clients like content instead of the human 406 00:20:05,009 --> 00:20:11,929 that wants to be seen, then is that my burden or is it theirs? 407 00:20:11,929 --> 00:20:12,209 Right. 408 00:20:12,209 --> 00:20:16,449 And I'm, I'm really, you know, kind of torn on this because if it's 409 00:20:16,449 --> 00:20:19,529 their decision, I'm in a service industry where I'm supposed 410 00:20:19,529 --> 00:20:23,739 to be serving you with what it is that you want photographically. 411 00:20:24,459 --> 00:20:29,979 If instead I think of it as like, you just want to be content 412 00:20:29,979 --> 00:20:34,659 and you're not respecting my art, then that's just my ego taking 413 00:20:34,659 --> 00:20:35,019 over. 414 00:20:35,019 --> 00:20:35,419 Right. 415 00:20:35,499 --> 00:20:38,699 So it just, it triggered in my mind the whole like content versus 416 00:20:38,699 --> 00:20:39,339 art thing. 417 00:20:39,339 --> 00:20:39,659 Right. 418 00:20:39,819 --> 00:20:43,779 So so many of us make art that we have to turn into content, but 419 00:20:43,779 --> 00:20:49,179 now is AI forcing us to think about our clients as content and 420 00:20:49,579 --> 00:20:50,459 creating that? 421 00:20:50,459 --> 00:20:55,289 The other thing you mentioned about the efficiency is that this 422 00:20:55,289 --> 00:21:04,449 is another place where I'm a little bit torn because AI invariably 423 00:21:04,449 --> 00:21:08,609 gives you more time to focus on making that connection with people. 424 00:21:08,688 --> 00:21:11,729 If you have a limited amount of time and you only have an hour 425 00:21:11,729 --> 00:21:15,689 in a session, let's say you want to spend as much time with the 426 00:21:15,689 --> 00:21:18,889 client as possible, get to know them, really draw out what it 427 00:21:18,889 --> 00:21:21,089 is that you're trying to create, whether it's commission piece 428 00:21:21,089 --> 00:21:23,569 or whether it's something that you're doing yourself. 429 00:21:24,839 --> 00:21:30,279 So when time is of the essence, using an AI tool in your 430 00:21:30,279 --> 00:21:33,479 workflow I think can be totally justified. 431 00:21:33,559 --> 00:21:33,919 Right. 432 00:21:33,919 --> 00:21:36,639 Because you're trying to maximize that time, because of the 433 00:21:36,639 --> 00:21:43,639 efficiency, though, it becomes very easy to lean on that tool, and 434 00:21:44,199 --> 00:21:45,719 suddenly you are. 435 00:21:47,159 --> 00:21:48,599 You're relying on it. 436 00:21:48,839 --> 00:21:50,679 And what I'm getting at is this. 437 00:21:52,129 --> 00:21:55,489 And I want to talk about this from your aspect, not as a photographer, 438 00:21:55,489 --> 00:21:56,689 but as a retoucher. 439 00:21:58,129 --> 00:21:58,529 As. 440 00:22:00,449 --> 00:22:07,489 As people start to utilize AI tools more, do you feel like they're 441 00:22:07,489 --> 00:22:11,809 giving up or avoiding learning the craft of retouching itself? 442 00:22:12,209 --> 00:22:15,769 And do you think that's inherently a good or a bad thing 443 00:22:15,769 --> 00:22:17,529 for retouching? 444 00:22:18,809 --> 00:22:21,769 Well, my answer is annoyingly pedantic. 445 00:22:22,809 --> 00:22:23,409 It depends. 446 00:22:23,409 --> 00:22:27,129 And we have to start with defining what retouching even is. 447 00:22:27,129 --> 00:22:30,729 And we have to start saying to ourselves, for example, let's look 448 00:22:30,729 --> 00:22:31,569 at Capture One, right? 449 00:22:31,569 --> 00:22:35,249 Capture One now has a face retouch for a few months now, and 450 00:22:35,249 --> 00:22:35,809 that's cool. 451 00:22:35,809 --> 00:22:40,689 Well, I didn't get a card to vote as to what that retouch should 452 00:22:40,689 --> 00:22:41,129 look like. 453 00:22:42,979 --> 00:22:43,979 Someone decided that. 454 00:22:43,979 --> 00:22:49,339 So now Capture One does retouching as defined by Capture 455 00:22:49,339 --> 00:22:49,699 One. 456 00:22:50,419 --> 00:22:51,019 That's it. 457 00:22:51,019 --> 00:22:52,019 There was no meeting. 458 00:22:52,099 --> 00:22:53,299 I didn't get invited. 459 00:22:53,379 --> 00:22:54,659 There was no discussion. 460 00:22:54,819 --> 00:22:57,539 This is just what Capture One does, right? 461 00:22:58,259 --> 00:23:05,619 So what that made me think was what we're seeing is a forced uniformity 462 00:23:05,939 --> 00:23:07,579 because the tools do what they do. 463 00:23:07,579 --> 00:23:10,039 Even a boto does what it does, right? 464 00:23:11,239 --> 00:23:12,839 But some of the best artists. 465 00:23:12,839 --> 00:23:14,519 Let's just talk about portraiture for a minute. 466 00:23:14,519 --> 00:23:17,559 Some of the best artists, their style is definitive. 467 00:23:18,039 --> 00:23:20,399 Their style doesn't look like Capture One did something. 468 00:23:20,399 --> 00:23:23,559 It looks like them, whether it's polished or raw or whatever, 469 00:23:23,799 --> 00:23:24,359 you know? 470 00:23:24,439 --> 00:23:30,559 And so as a retoucher, I think if a tool helps you achieve your 471 00:23:30,559 --> 00:23:34,679 vision in some way, whether it's a benefit in speed and efficiency 472 00:23:34,679 --> 00:23:38,409 or a benefit in technique that you can go from, then great. 473 00:23:38,649 --> 00:23:42,369 But if you're forced, if you're conforming, hard conforming, 474 00:23:42,369 --> 00:23:44,049 because this is what capture what does now. 475 00:23:44,049 --> 00:23:45,609 So this is now what I do, right? 476 00:23:46,489 --> 00:23:47,969 Okay, that's fine. 477 00:23:47,969 --> 00:23:52,649 But as an artist, as someone like me who likes to retouch my way, 478 00:23:54,649 --> 00:23:55,969 I don't want to rely on that. 479 00:23:55,969 --> 00:23:57,209 You know, I don't want to. 480 00:23:57,529 --> 00:24:00,169 Because it's not just that it works, quote unquote, it's how do 481 00:24:00,169 --> 00:24:01,449 we define it? 482 00:24:01,449 --> 00:24:05,139 That's like saying that I need to add guitar to the song, and that's 483 00:24:05,139 --> 00:24:06,099 the only requirement. 484 00:24:06,179 --> 00:24:06,899 Guitar. 485 00:24:08,259 --> 00:24:08,659 What? 486 00:24:08,739 --> 00:24:10,499 There's so many variables there. 487 00:24:10,899 --> 00:24:13,819 So when you say we're touching, we've compartmentalized 488 00:24:13,819 --> 00:24:16,979 that into one thing, as if it's hard to find and it isn't. 489 00:24:17,219 --> 00:24:18,899 And so that's, again, pedantic. 490 00:24:18,899 --> 00:24:19,379 As hell. 491 00:24:19,379 --> 00:24:21,859 Because I know a lot of people are like, I just want my clients 492 00:24:22,179 --> 00:24:23,659 to not have, like, blemishes. 493 00:24:23,659 --> 00:24:24,499 Shut up, Nino. 494 00:24:24,499 --> 00:24:24,979 I know. 495 00:24:24,979 --> 00:24:25,499 I'm sorry. 496 00:24:25,499 --> 00:24:27,699 Because retouching is not just getting rid of blemishes, though, 497 00:24:27,699 --> 00:24:27,899 is it? 498 00:24:27,899 --> 00:24:28,579 It's finalizing. 499 00:24:28,579 --> 00:24:28,899 Right. 500 00:24:29,379 --> 00:24:34,139 So that finalizing, I think, is, is more the, the, the personal 501 00:24:34,139 --> 00:24:35,739 aspect than the skin cleanup or whatever. 502 00:24:35,739 --> 00:24:38,459 Skin cleanup does have some fundamental things that, yes, that 503 00:24:38,459 --> 00:24:41,619 we can all agree are at least somewhat fundamental. 504 00:24:41,619 --> 00:24:43,699 But vision varies wildly. 505 00:24:43,779 --> 00:24:46,699 You know, I mean, techniques are techniques, but your vision is, 506 00:24:46,699 --> 00:24:47,939 is, is the open point there. 507 00:24:47,939 --> 00:24:53,739 So that's why I'm like, I think that if we, how do I say it? 508 00:24:53,739 --> 00:24:56,669 If we say, for example, I've never used a voto, but if we say, 509 00:24:56,669 --> 00:24:57,949 well, I don't need to do that anymore. 510 00:24:57,949 --> 00:24:58,749 Evoto does. 511 00:24:58,749 --> 00:24:59,509 Right, okay. 512 00:24:59,589 --> 00:25:01,029 Evoto does what Evoto does. 513 00:25:01,029 --> 00:25:01,989 And now that's what you do. 514 00:25:03,189 --> 00:25:07,309 And I know that's splitting hairs, but as an artist who wants 515 00:25:07,309 --> 00:25:11,189 to, ideally, if you want to make something that's definitively 516 00:25:11,189 --> 00:25:17,749 you, are you conforming unwillingly at the altar of efficiency, 517 00:25:17,909 --> 00:25:20,629 or are you finding a way to leverage it differently? 518 00:25:20,629 --> 00:25:21,789 There's just too many questions. 519 00:25:21,789 --> 00:25:26,079 So I can't say that we're not going to need, quote, unquote, need 520 00:25:26,079 --> 00:25:26,839 retouching. 521 00:25:26,839 --> 00:25:27,999 I can't say I'm going to stop it. 522 00:25:27,999 --> 00:25:34,359 I'm going to, I, I, I think it's all, it's like, it's like painting, 523 00:25:34,359 --> 00:25:34,759 for example. 524 00:25:34,759 --> 00:25:35,319 Oil painting. 525 00:25:35,319 --> 00:25:35,519 Right. 526 00:25:35,519 --> 00:25:37,479 Let's say you, you, you, you prep your canvas. 527 00:25:37,479 --> 00:25:37,639 Right. 528 00:25:37,639 --> 00:25:39,319 And it might be a method to prep your canvas. 529 00:25:39,319 --> 00:25:41,279 Well, you can have an assistant do that if you do it every 530 00:25:41,279 --> 00:25:41,759 single time. 531 00:25:41,759 --> 00:25:42,479 Right, right. 532 00:25:42,479 --> 00:25:45,799 But if you prep your canvas differently per painting, that's 533 00:25:45,799 --> 00:25:46,399 part of the art. 534 00:25:46,559 --> 00:25:46,959 Right. 535 00:25:47,279 --> 00:25:50,929 So again, heavy, heavy on the pentictics here. 536 00:25:50,929 --> 00:25:54,969 I know on the pedantry, as it were, but that's how I have to start 537 00:25:54,969 --> 00:25:55,809 the conversation about. 538 00:25:55,809 --> 00:25:58,489 Well, you know, what do you mean by retouching? 539 00:25:58,489 --> 00:26:00,249 What is your, what do you, what are we talking about? 540 00:26:00,809 --> 00:26:06,529 So before I even get into that, I did want to say, oh, I'm 541 00:26:06,529 --> 00:26:08,329 going to get rid of the placeholders. 542 00:26:09,609 --> 00:26:13,089 So Anna Hill is a portrait photographer here in the Northeast. 543 00:26:13,089 --> 00:26:13,609 She's amazing. 544 00:26:13,609 --> 00:26:15,689 She's a wonderful content creator. 545 00:26:15,929 --> 00:26:19,449 And she's just stopped by to say hi, Anna, thank you for joining 546 00:26:19,449 --> 00:26:19,649 us. 547 00:26:19,649 --> 00:26:21,889 Enjoy the conversation, because we're going to, we're going 548 00:26:21,889 --> 00:26:22,849 to be here for a little bit. 549 00:26:23,329 --> 00:26:28,529 So I want to get back to what you were saying in all of that. 550 00:26:30,049 --> 00:26:32,369 To me, it Comes down to values. 551 00:26:32,929 --> 00:26:38,289 What is it that you, as a photographer or lead toucher have 552 00:26:38,289 --> 00:26:41,009 as your core set of values? 553 00:26:41,489 --> 00:26:44,929 And I don't hear enough people talking about this. 554 00:26:45,909 --> 00:26:52,069 Insofar as we all have our style of art, we kind of know the 555 00:26:52,069 --> 00:26:56,469 genres and what we do, but I rarely hear people talking about 556 00:26:56,629 --> 00:27:00,069 values outside of the money conversation. 557 00:27:00,309 --> 00:27:01,029 Yeah, yeah. 558 00:27:01,429 --> 00:27:03,589 So talk to me a little bit about. 559 00:27:04,309 --> 00:27:06,189 Because you were just, you know, and the. 560 00:27:06,189 --> 00:27:08,309 The pedantry is fine. 561 00:27:09,189 --> 00:27:12,309 Where do your values start with your art? 562 00:27:12,919 --> 00:27:17,079 And have those changed over time as you've adapted different 563 00:27:17,079 --> 00:27:19,079 things in the industry? 564 00:27:19,159 --> 00:27:21,079 Capture one, you know, whatever. 565 00:27:21,079 --> 00:27:21,559 AI. 566 00:27:21,959 --> 00:27:24,519 How have your values changed if they have. 567 00:27:26,439 --> 00:27:28,759 So I think that I've been. 568 00:27:30,199 --> 00:27:33,319 By the way, I figured out that this year is my 17th year officially 569 00:27:33,319 --> 00:27:33,799 in this. 570 00:27:34,199 --> 00:27:37,319 Yeah, yikes. 571 00:27:37,399 --> 00:27:41,049 Anyway, but I say, I think officially because I grew up with 572 00:27:41,049 --> 00:27:41,529 photography. 573 00:27:41,529 --> 00:27:43,529 That's another story for, I think, another interview that we 574 00:27:43,529 --> 00:27:45,809 did, but officially 17 years. 575 00:27:45,809 --> 00:27:51,969 So my point is, in that time, I feel like I have found or continue 576 00:27:51,969 --> 00:27:56,797 to look for truth and authenticity more than I did 10, 577 00:27:56,874 --> 00:27:58,129 12, 15 years ago. 578 00:27:58,449 --> 00:28:01,489 I think when I started, I was very end result oriented. 579 00:28:01,489 --> 00:28:03,249 Like any beginner, I was trying to figure out just how to 580 00:28:03,249 --> 00:28:03,889 do this shit. 581 00:28:04,049 --> 00:28:04,609 And then. 582 00:28:04,919 --> 00:28:06,799 And then came in result oriented and then came with. 583 00:28:06,799 --> 00:28:07,239 That worked. 584 00:28:07,239 --> 00:28:09,519 I want to do more of that because I want better feedback and 585 00:28:09,519 --> 00:28:13,519 I want this and I want that and, you know, and then now I'm starting 586 00:28:13,519 --> 00:28:14,279 to get into that. 587 00:28:14,279 --> 00:28:17,759 Not last week, but in recent years, I'm into that mode where I'm 588 00:28:17,759 --> 00:28:20,799 like, I want to do something that just feels more authentic. 589 00:28:20,799 --> 00:28:21,999 I want to feel something that. 590 00:28:21,999 --> 00:28:24,559 That makes me feel like I'm proud of this. 591 00:28:24,559 --> 00:28:28,279 I'm glad I put this together, whatever together may be. 592 00:28:29,319 --> 00:28:30,239 So I feel like I've. 593 00:28:30,239 --> 00:28:32,369 I've advanced in that in that regard. 594 00:28:32,369 --> 00:28:33,289 For lack of a better term. 595 00:28:33,289 --> 00:28:34,929 I don't want to say advanced like I've gotten better. 596 00:28:35,009 --> 00:28:37,169 I've just changed my mindset into that. 597 00:28:37,169 --> 00:28:38,129 So I guess I. 598 00:28:38,529 --> 00:28:40,849 What I will say about every artist that they have to do is whether 599 00:28:40,849 --> 00:28:44,329 you're a service provider or not, there's some element of drawing 600 00:28:44,329 --> 00:28:46,289 a line in the sand and then sticking to it. 601 00:28:46,449 --> 00:28:49,929 That is part of your entire mystique as an artist. 602 00:28:49,929 --> 00:28:50,769 That's your whole thing. 603 00:28:50,929 --> 00:28:52,409 Where is your line in the sand? 604 00:28:52,409 --> 00:28:53,169 Where is your boundary? 605 00:28:53,169 --> 00:28:53,889 Where is your value? 606 00:28:53,889 --> 00:28:54,489 Like you said. 607 00:28:54,489 --> 00:28:54,769 Right. 608 00:28:54,849 --> 00:28:55,929 And then you stick to it. 609 00:28:55,929 --> 00:28:57,329 You stick to it stubbornly. 610 00:28:57,999 --> 00:28:59,159 And that's what makes you an artist. 611 00:28:59,159 --> 00:29:00,279 You're not supposed to conform. 612 00:29:00,279 --> 00:29:01,559 You're not supposed to cooperate. 613 00:29:01,559 --> 00:29:02,879 You're not supposed to make sense. 614 00:29:03,119 --> 00:29:08,239 You find your line in the sand and you say, you know, like, Bandcamp 615 00:29:08,239 --> 00:29:10,799 recently said, no AI music on their platform. 616 00:29:10,799 --> 00:29:12,759 You know, okay, cool line in the sand. 617 00:29:12,759 --> 00:29:13,479 I'm here for it. 618 00:29:13,479 --> 00:29:16,999 You know, that's part of being an artist. 619 00:29:16,999 --> 00:29:20,879 That's part of trying to define what you're trying, what you're 620 00:29:20,879 --> 00:29:21,119 doing. 621 00:29:21,119 --> 00:29:24,399 So for me, I think that it's just a matter of courage, really. 622 00:29:24,949 --> 00:29:27,829 You know, like, I'm not going to conform to AI what if it comes 623 00:29:27,829 --> 00:29:28,469 against me? 624 00:29:28,469 --> 00:29:29,629 What if it comes against you? 625 00:29:29,629 --> 00:29:30,469 You're still a person. 626 00:29:30,629 --> 00:29:32,429 You still have images that are still stories. 627 00:29:32,429 --> 00:29:36,309 Like, for example, look at something as mundane as the backgrounds 628 00:29:36,309 --> 00:29:37,829 of our little video feeds here, right? 629 00:29:37,989 --> 00:29:41,469 I don't know what's happening behind you, but it's not AI and it 630 00:29:41,469 --> 00:29:42,629 draws interest. 631 00:29:42,709 --> 00:29:43,509 There's a question. 632 00:29:43,509 --> 00:29:44,869 What is that thing back there? 633 00:29:44,869 --> 00:29:45,829 What is that other thing? 634 00:29:45,829 --> 00:29:46,829 Sometimes there's a guitar. 635 00:29:46,829 --> 00:29:47,949 Matt, where's the guitar? 636 00:29:47,949 --> 00:29:52,359 Today, these little simple human, like, questions that make 637 00:29:52,359 --> 00:29:58,039 us connect with one another, even the simplest ways are completely 638 00:29:58,039 --> 00:29:59,479 devoid in AI they're just. 639 00:29:59,479 --> 00:30:00,319 They're not there. 640 00:30:00,639 --> 00:30:06,319 And to get too far and say that AI is going to go away at night, 641 00:30:07,279 --> 00:30:08,639 but we're gonna. 642 00:30:08,639 --> 00:30:14,999 We're gonna see more interest and more excitement about authentic 643 00:30:14,999 --> 00:30:16,719 experiences on the Internet, because we're already. 644 00:30:17,789 --> 00:30:20,989 We're inundated by plastic experiences from humans, I might 645 00:30:20,989 --> 00:30:24,309 add, but also from AI Slop, as the term goes. 646 00:30:24,309 --> 00:30:28,029 So I think authenticity is due for a comeback. 647 00:30:28,029 --> 00:30:28,669 How's that? 648 00:30:28,909 --> 00:30:31,869 And I'm not being naive, I'm not being silly. 649 00:30:31,869 --> 00:30:33,949 I understand what we're facing here. 650 00:30:33,949 --> 00:30:35,229 I totally get what we're facing. 651 00:30:35,229 --> 00:30:37,549 But I think authenticity is going to be valuable. 652 00:30:37,709 --> 00:30:43,229 So the question is, are you going to stay the course and be courageous 653 00:30:43,709 --> 00:30:44,829 and continue on despite. 654 00:30:45,859 --> 00:30:49,179 Because artists have done that for years, or are you going to either 655 00:30:49,179 --> 00:30:51,299 conform or die trying? 656 00:30:51,299 --> 00:30:51,939 I don't know. 657 00:30:52,259 --> 00:30:55,019 I think it's an issue of being courageous and like I said, drawing 658 00:30:55,019 --> 00:30:58,019 a line, sand, and thinking, this is what I do, this is what I 659 00:30:58,019 --> 00:31:01,538 don't do, at least for this season on work, Right. 660 00:31:01,939 --> 00:31:03,219 I'm not trying to simplify it. 661 00:31:03,619 --> 00:31:05,299 I think that it comes down to that. 662 00:31:06,419 --> 00:31:10,019 I think so. 663 00:31:10,019 --> 00:31:14,219 As the tools become more accessible, more consumer friendly, 664 00:31:14,219 --> 00:31:14,379 right? 665 00:31:14,379 --> 00:31:17,339 And this is kind of the thing that Evoto did, was they said, all 666 00:31:17,339 --> 00:31:19,659 right, photographers, we hear from you. 667 00:31:19,659 --> 00:31:22,499 We know what it is that you're what you're looking for. 668 00:31:22,499 --> 00:31:22,819 And. 669 00:31:23,699 --> 00:31:25,219 But we're a software company. 670 00:31:25,219 --> 00:31:26,419 We're not photographers. 671 00:31:26,419 --> 00:31:27,459 We're out to make money. 672 00:31:28,098 --> 00:31:31,579 So we're making these tools, and I have zero issue with that, 673 00:31:31,579 --> 00:31:35,219 by the way, but we're making these tools and we want to make them 674 00:31:35,219 --> 00:31:38,019 accessible to as many people as possible because we're in the 675 00:31:38,019 --> 00:31:43,879 business of making money as people get access to the tools, just 676 00:31:43,879 --> 00:31:48,479 like it was with ChatGPT, where suddenly everybody has access 677 00:31:48,479 --> 00:31:50,559 to it and it's the greatest, coolest thing. 678 00:31:50,559 --> 00:31:50,919 Right. 679 00:31:51,799 --> 00:31:55,278 But as everybody starts to use it, what does it do? 680 00:31:55,278 --> 00:31:56,199 It learns. 681 00:31:56,439 --> 00:32:02,359 And it just basically makes every answer this milquetoast, homogenized 682 00:32:02,359 --> 00:32:06,119 version of whatever the answer should be. 683 00:32:06,809 --> 00:32:08,609 There's no real thought in it. 684 00:32:08,609 --> 00:32:08,769 Right. 685 00:32:08,769 --> 00:32:09,929 It's pattern recognition. 686 00:32:10,489 --> 00:32:18,209 So when we talk about the experience of photography, I'd like 687 00:32:18,209 --> 00:32:22,849 to believe in the heart of hearts that, like you're saying you 688 00:32:22,849 --> 00:32:27,569 draw your line in the sand as the artist, the experience that you 689 00:32:27,569 --> 00:32:29,529 provide perhaps, is that line. 690 00:32:31,369 --> 00:32:35,129 People are going to find these tools and they're going to use them, 691 00:32:35,799 --> 00:32:39,079 and there's no way that we can push back against that ocean. 692 00:32:40,199 --> 00:32:45,599 But I believe that over a period of time, people just get bored 693 00:32:45,599 --> 00:32:45,959 with it. 694 00:32:45,959 --> 00:32:46,599 You know why? 695 00:32:47,159 --> 00:32:51,039 Because they're producing, everybody's producing the same candy 696 00:32:51,039 --> 00:32:56,279 cane Christmas picture that, you know, every white woman put out 697 00:32:56,279 --> 00:33:02,049 on the Internet a month and a half ago, and it was the same exact 698 00:33:02,049 --> 00:33:02,529 picture. 699 00:33:02,929 --> 00:33:08,689 Now that in our world is no different from Everybody running 700 00:33:08,689 --> 00:33:14,049 a 40 over 40 campaign and, you know, basically doing the same thing. 701 00:33:14,769 --> 00:33:20,689 However, I think as people get bored with seeing the same image 702 00:33:20,769 --> 00:33:26,249 that Sally has, that Jane has, that Mary has, that suddenly they're 703 00:33:26,249 --> 00:33:28,699 going to be like, I'm not really going to use these. 704 00:33:28,699 --> 00:33:29,899 I want something that's me. 705 00:33:30,219 --> 00:33:32,219 I want to feel the power that's me. 706 00:33:32,619 --> 00:33:35,419 Guys are going to say, yeah, great, I can look super buff. 707 00:33:35,419 --> 00:33:38,059 But when I take off my shirt at night, I don't look super buff. 708 00:33:38,059 --> 00:33:39,339 So I know it's fake. 709 00:33:39,499 --> 00:33:43,019 And they want to get back to that reality. 710 00:33:43,659 --> 00:33:44,179 Yeah. 711 00:33:44,179 --> 00:33:50,459 The question becomes, can we wait out that period as artists or, 712 00:33:50,939 --> 00:33:57,089 you know, if we have our line in the sand and we believe in the 713 00:33:57,089 --> 00:34:00,969 humanity of the photography, how. 714 00:34:01,609 --> 00:34:03,529 How do we weather that storm? 715 00:34:05,129 --> 00:34:09,489 When we rely on this for financials to keep a roof over our 716 00:34:09,489 --> 00:34:11,769 head, how do we weather that storm? 717 00:34:11,769 --> 00:34:16,289 Even if we do take a stance against AI or at least advise and 718 00:34:16,289 --> 00:34:19,649 educate our clients, that right, you're going to get something 719 00:34:19,649 --> 00:34:20,409 pretty generic. 720 00:34:21,249 --> 00:34:22,569 Well, to me, it's twofold. 721 00:34:22,569 --> 00:34:26,689 For one, one of the things on our side is it's horrifying efficiency. 722 00:34:27,249 --> 00:34:30,529 So we're gonna see things progress faster and faster the way 723 00:34:30,529 --> 00:34:33,409 they have I'm thinking about AI in 2022 versus now. 724 00:34:33,649 --> 00:34:34,689 That's four years. 725 00:34:35,569 --> 00:34:37,089 And it's night and day difference, right? 726 00:34:37,249 --> 00:34:42,249 So I think that ridiculous efficiency is gonna peak at some 727 00:34:42,249 --> 00:34:42,409 point. 728 00:34:42,409 --> 00:34:44,849 I mean, how much more realistic can videos get? 729 00:34:45,329 --> 00:34:47,579 How much more realistic can a photo rendering get? 730 00:34:48,049 --> 00:34:50,929 Get before doesn't fucking matter anymore, right? 731 00:34:50,929 --> 00:34:54,529 You know, and so that people are going to do exactly what you're 732 00:34:54,529 --> 00:34:57,569 going to say, which just suggested I should say they're going 733 00:34:57,569 --> 00:34:58,729 to be tired of the same old. 734 00:34:58,729 --> 00:34:59,729 They're going to be tired of the. 735 00:34:59,729 --> 00:35:00,409 Of the convention. 736 00:35:00,409 --> 00:35:01,649 They're going to be tired of the manufacture. 737 00:35:01,649 --> 00:35:03,569 They're going to be really obvious when it's manufactured. 738 00:35:04,049 --> 00:35:07,969 It's going to like, that looks cool, whatever, you know. 739 00:35:09,409 --> 00:35:14,769 You know, it even plays out, if I may, it even plays out in the 740 00:35:15,889 --> 00:35:20,769 very quietly dark backbone, financial and technological backbone 741 00:35:20,769 --> 00:35:22,289 of the Internet known as pornography. 742 00:35:22,289 --> 00:35:23,809 That even works out there. 743 00:35:24,209 --> 00:35:28,129 Because what happens is that now you can have all this AI pornography 744 00:35:28,129 --> 00:35:32,329 so you can create all kinds of ridiculous images and images that 745 00:35:32,329 --> 00:35:33,729 are morally questionable. 746 00:35:33,729 --> 00:35:34,689 Let's just call it that. 747 00:35:35,409 --> 00:35:36,569 And video content as well. 748 00:35:36,569 --> 00:35:40,129 But what happens even on something, even on the subject that's 749 00:35:40,129 --> 00:35:44,209 something that's as base level as human urges and sexual urges for 750 00:35:44,549 --> 00:35:49,429 evolutionary kind of things in humans, eventually that kind of generic 751 00:35:49,669 --> 00:35:53,509 AI redundancy, someone's going to be like, yeah, but no, but I'm 752 00:35:53,509 --> 00:35:54,469 hot for that person. 753 00:35:54,549 --> 00:35:56,669 I'm not hot for the invented person. 754 00:35:56,669 --> 00:35:57,909 I'm hot for her. 755 00:35:58,309 --> 00:36:00,149 I will spend money there, right? 756 00:36:00,308 --> 00:36:05,109 So even at the base level, reptilian brain, human urges of masturbation, 757 00:36:05,429 --> 00:36:09,429 we're going to see AI slip because people want that real experience. 758 00:36:09,589 --> 00:36:10,589 Now some people won't. 759 00:36:10,589 --> 00:36:11,469 Some people will be like the. 760 00:36:11,469 --> 00:36:12,789 Will be Wally and happily. 761 00:36:13,719 --> 00:36:17,799 But the vast majority of us are going to want a authentic experience 762 00:36:17,799 --> 00:36:19,479 of some form, right? 763 00:36:19,639 --> 00:36:22,639 And when some, I think most people are not going to read, are 764 00:36:22,639 --> 00:36:25,679 not even going to fully realize that they're tired of the 765 00:36:25,679 --> 00:36:26,399 AI storm. 766 00:36:26,399 --> 00:36:27,239 They're tired of the. 767 00:36:27,239 --> 00:36:28,239 I mean, they can. 768 00:36:28,239 --> 00:36:29,639 They're tired of being tricked. 769 00:36:29,639 --> 00:36:33,559 That's a whole nother subject, you know, content that's designed 770 00:36:33,559 --> 00:36:34,119 to deceive. 771 00:36:34,359 --> 00:36:34,999 But if you're. 772 00:36:34,999 --> 00:36:36,119 If the deception is not. 773 00:36:36,279 --> 00:36:40,199 The deception is intentional and it's clear, what is it worth? 774 00:36:40,199 --> 00:36:41,599 A deception is very valuable. 775 00:36:41,679 --> 00:36:45,319 We can call it valuable, it's immoral, but it's valuable because 776 00:36:45,319 --> 00:36:46,639 it elicits a response, right? 777 00:36:46,639 --> 00:36:47,679 So that's a deception. 778 00:36:47,919 --> 00:36:51,079 That's one use in AI AI that's openly. 779 00:36:51,079 --> 00:36:52,479 A deception like this is not real. 780 00:36:52,799 --> 00:36:54,719 Okay, what is this Value. 781 00:36:56,079 --> 00:36:58,079 And certainly it won't have a long term value. 782 00:36:58,399 --> 00:36:59,199 You know what I mean? 783 00:36:59,679 --> 00:37:01,159 I put stuff in GPT. 784 00:37:01,159 --> 00:37:04,799 I put stuff into Sora and once I see it and I go, that's ridiculous. 785 00:37:04,799 --> 00:37:06,479 That's a tricycle on an F1 track. 786 00:37:06,639 --> 00:37:07,519 Beaten cars. 787 00:37:07,859 --> 00:37:08,979 And then you delete it. 788 00:37:09,459 --> 00:37:11,299 This entire rendered video. 789 00:37:11,299 --> 00:37:15,259 15 seconds of a tricycle on circuit of the Americas beating F1 790 00:37:15,259 --> 00:37:15,499 cards. 791 00:37:15,499 --> 00:37:18,179 The most vivid, realistic, absurd thing you've ever heard. 792 00:37:18,259 --> 00:37:19,859 Deleted in five seconds. 793 00:37:20,019 --> 00:37:21,699 Because the moment passed. 794 00:37:22,499 --> 00:37:22,899 Right. 795 00:37:22,979 --> 00:37:26,819 If I rendered all of that 3D animation, it would be a month long 796 00:37:26,819 --> 00:37:28,259 project at the least. 797 00:37:28,659 --> 00:37:31,739 And I would route it around and people would ask me how I did 798 00:37:31,739 --> 00:37:31,899 it. 799 00:37:31,899 --> 00:37:34,589 And I probably have behind the scenes video of how I rendered the 800 00:37:34,589 --> 00:37:35,109 tricycle. 801 00:37:35,109 --> 00:37:36,269 And there's. 802 00:37:36,269 --> 00:37:36,669 There's something. 803 00:37:36,669 --> 00:37:37,589 There is what I'm saying. 804 00:37:37,589 --> 00:37:40,189 So I already double value AI. 805 00:37:40,189 --> 00:37:42,829 Not in principle, but because where did it came from? 806 00:37:42,829 --> 00:37:45,189 It came from the ether. 807 00:37:45,189 --> 00:37:45,509 And. 808 00:37:45,509 --> 00:37:46,029 And it's. 809 00:37:46,029 --> 00:37:48,309 It's worth about as much as the ether. 810 00:37:48,309 --> 00:37:49,469 It didn't come from anybody. 811 00:37:49,469 --> 00:37:50,308 No one made it. 812 00:37:50,469 --> 00:37:51,149 You know what I mean? 813 00:37:51,149 --> 00:37:51,589 No one. 814 00:37:51,829 --> 00:37:53,589 And how do I put this? 815 00:37:53,909 --> 00:37:55,509 This T shirt was manufactured. 816 00:37:55,509 --> 00:37:57,909 There's not an artisan making this Fender T shirt. 817 00:37:57,909 --> 00:37:58,349 This is. 818 00:37:58,349 --> 00:38:02,199 This was mass manufactured and I bought it for $29, whatever the 819 00:38:02,199 --> 00:38:03,239 hell at the guitar store. 820 00:38:03,399 --> 00:38:04,719 And I like it because it's Fender. 821 00:38:04,719 --> 00:38:07,559 And there's no emotional investment here other than Fender. 822 00:38:07,879 --> 00:38:08,279 Right. 823 00:38:08,679 --> 00:38:09,039 That. 824 00:38:09,039 --> 00:38:10,839 I'm not worried about this as a piece of art. 825 00:38:10,839 --> 00:38:12,759 There's a place for manufactured things. 826 00:38:14,279 --> 00:38:18,919 But as, as artists, we can't be replaced. 827 00:38:18,919 --> 00:38:20,239 If I may be so old now. 828 00:38:20,239 --> 00:38:21,519 I'm gonna, I'm just gonna. 829 00:38:21,519 --> 00:38:23,159 I'm gonna butt in there for a second. 830 00:38:23,319 --> 00:38:25,319 Just specifically with the Fender piece. 831 00:38:25,319 --> 00:38:25,639 Right. 832 00:38:25,719 --> 00:38:29,089 Some graphic artists at some point put that logo together. 833 00:38:29,249 --> 00:38:31,569 It's now become part of Americana. 834 00:38:31,969 --> 00:38:32,369 Right. 835 00:38:32,529 --> 00:38:32,889 And. 836 00:38:32,889 --> 00:38:33,369 Absolutely. 837 00:38:33,369 --> 00:38:39,009 And so while the T shirt itself is mass produced, the logo 838 00:38:39,009 --> 00:38:40,209 is the artwork. 839 00:38:40,209 --> 00:38:40,609 Right. 840 00:38:40,849 --> 00:38:44,048 And that is what has transcended everything. 841 00:38:44,609 --> 00:38:47,489 People know Fender, they know Gibson, they know Taylor. 842 00:38:47,489 --> 00:38:47,889 Right. 843 00:38:47,969 --> 00:38:50,929 Because of the look and feel of that brand. 844 00:38:51,329 --> 00:38:51,809 Yeah. 845 00:38:51,809 --> 00:38:52,129 And. 846 00:38:52,449 --> 00:38:58,949 And I just keep thinking that our art, our style, our approach 847 00:38:59,429 --> 00:39:00,629 is our brand. 848 00:39:00,949 --> 00:39:05,109 And that becomes recognizable only over a period of time. 849 00:39:05,749 --> 00:39:06,389 That's it. 850 00:39:06,549 --> 00:39:06,949 Right? 851 00:39:07,429 --> 00:39:08,069 That's it. 852 00:39:08,389 --> 00:39:08,869 Cool. 853 00:39:08,949 --> 00:39:09,549 And that's. 854 00:39:09,549 --> 00:39:12,069 We also go backwards in time too, because everything that we do 855 00:39:12,069 --> 00:39:14,389 today was drawn from everything that came before. 856 00:39:14,949 --> 00:39:18,869 Everything I do now, everything I say now came from experiences 857 00:39:18,869 --> 00:39:21,869 I've had for 34 years. 858 00:39:22,109 --> 00:39:22,989 Let's go with that. 859 00:39:24,909 --> 00:39:26,189 Talk about age right now. 860 00:39:27,629 --> 00:39:31,389 Everything, everything that happens to this moment is A product, 861 00:39:33,149 --> 00:39:35,869 at the very least a product of everything that came before it as 862 00:39:35,869 --> 00:39:37,069 a human because of time, right? 863 00:39:37,149 --> 00:39:38,869 Time moves linearly, blah, blah, blah. 864 00:39:38,869 --> 00:39:42,189 We can get into like ontological and epistemological discussion 865 00:39:42,189 --> 00:39:46,559 of time, but either way, point is that because of that, again, an 866 00:39:46,559 --> 00:39:51,239 AI is a grown ass adult with a million skills, born yesterday, right. 867 00:39:51,959 --> 00:39:55,439 And can only pretend to understand memory, can only pretend 868 00:39:55,439 --> 00:39:56,439 to understand experience. 869 00:39:56,599 --> 00:40:00,759 Can, can, can fake it really well, don't get me wrong. 870 00:40:01,399 --> 00:40:06,399 But when you realize, oh, you actually weren't there in 1997, you 871 00:40:06,399 --> 00:40:10,679 weren't there in 2011, at that moment talking about that experience 872 00:40:10,839 --> 00:40:13,429 and what is that? 873 00:40:13,509 --> 00:40:14,189 What is that? 874 00:40:14,189 --> 00:40:16,469 It's something, but it's not, it's not a human experience. 875 00:40:16,469 --> 00:40:19,829 So replacing not entirely. 876 00:40:19,829 --> 00:40:22,789 This is the thing that Nikki's getting to. 877 00:40:22,869 --> 00:40:25,789 So Nikki Lister joined us. 878 00:40:25,789 --> 00:40:29,109 She says hi, but she says, you know, I completely agree. 879 00:40:30,069 --> 00:40:32,709 It's not emotionally attached to us. 880 00:40:34,469 --> 00:40:39,659 There's no real connection in the art that's produced and what 881 00:40:39,659 --> 00:40:45,779 we see outside of basic dopamine hit, hey, this made chemicals 882 00:40:45,779 --> 00:40:48,579 in my brain go giggity, giggity and then I'm done. 883 00:40:48,579 --> 00:40:48,939 Right. 884 00:40:49,499 --> 00:40:52,219 One other comment that came in Artemis. 885 00:40:52,539 --> 00:40:53,739 I don't know if you know Artemis. 886 00:40:53,739 --> 00:40:56,699 Artemis is a phenomenal photographer in Pennsylvania. 887 00:40:56,699 --> 00:40:57,539 Loving this discussion. 888 00:40:57,539 --> 00:40:57,939 Gotta run. 889 00:40:57,939 --> 00:40:58,939 We'll have to watch replay. 890 00:40:58,939 --> 00:40:59,419 Perfect. 891 00:40:59,979 --> 00:41:03,499 I think, you know, when it comes to that emotional connection. 892 00:41:09,269 --> 00:41:12,389 Again, I'll keep coming back to this because it's one of the things 893 00:41:12,389 --> 00:41:14,709 that I, I know I center around. 894 00:41:14,789 --> 00:41:17,869 I know you have very strong opinions and you center a lot of 895 00:41:17,869 --> 00:41:19,749 your work around that human connection. 896 00:41:20,149 --> 00:41:20,549 Right. 897 00:41:20,549 --> 00:41:24,149 And that, that beautiful imperfection in things, even though 898 00:41:24,389 --> 00:41:30,189 you create, you know, flawless images, but that's based on craft 899 00:41:30,189 --> 00:41:34,079 and skill and time and experience over a period of time. 900 00:41:35,269 --> 00:41:36,069 34 years. 901 00:41:36,549 --> 00:41:37,389 So four years. 902 00:41:37,389 --> 00:41:38,069 34 years. 903 00:41:38,229 --> 00:41:41,669 So like, you know, you, you, you're focused there. 904 00:41:42,469 --> 00:41:44,789 A lot of newbies aren't, right? 905 00:41:44,789 --> 00:41:48,869 We're fortunate that we've been in this game decade, multiple 906 00:41:48,869 --> 00:41:49,509 decades. 907 00:41:49,509 --> 00:41:49,909 Right. 908 00:41:50,629 --> 00:41:56,309 And so 10 years ago we had to learn retouching, we had to learn 909 00:41:56,309 --> 00:41:59,029 the craft at whatever point it was. 910 00:41:59,109 --> 00:42:03,469 Is it the same as doing the craft of tintypes or film photography? 911 00:42:03,469 --> 00:42:03,709 No. 912 00:42:03,709 --> 00:42:07,609 And there were guys that were my age started going, hey, you're 913 00:42:07,609 --> 00:42:08,769 using digital, right? 914 00:42:09,089 --> 00:42:12,329 So that, that element is always going to be there. 915 00:42:12,329 --> 00:42:15,609 I got trolled the other day for talking about AI and someone 916 00:42:15,609 --> 00:42:19,489 said, you know, something about paint brushes that AI is going 917 00:42:19,489 --> 00:42:21,329 to, you know, the same, doing the same thing, that. 918 00:42:21,649 --> 00:42:24,449 How was the last time you saw somebody paint something And I'm 919 00:42:24,449 --> 00:42:27,329 like, there are museums full of that stuff. 920 00:42:27,569 --> 00:42:29,729 So I don't think painting is going anywhere. 921 00:42:30,049 --> 00:42:32,609 So I don't think photography is going anywhere. 922 00:42:33,019 --> 00:42:36,739 It's just, what is it going to be considered as an art? 923 00:42:36,739 --> 00:42:37,059 Right. 924 00:42:37,059 --> 00:42:41,339 I see a painter and I go, you're a wizard. 925 00:42:41,419 --> 00:42:44,459 I see someone play the piano at a classical level. 926 00:42:44,699 --> 00:42:47,179 They're purely inhuman to me. 927 00:42:47,179 --> 00:42:49,179 I don't know what planet they came from. 928 00:42:49,259 --> 00:42:52,219 Their fingers do things I could never conceive of learning. 929 00:42:53,419 --> 00:42:57,579 But that doesn't mean that, because I can go to Spotify, that 930 00:42:57,579 --> 00:43:00,459 classical pianists are irrelevant now. 931 00:43:00,719 --> 00:43:00,879 Right? 932 00:43:00,879 --> 00:43:01,199 Right. 933 00:43:01,279 --> 00:43:04,319 I go to those concerts and I sit in a. 934 00:43:04,319 --> 00:43:10,199 In a chamber hall and I listen to just phenomenal music that came 935 00:43:10,199 --> 00:43:16,079 out of someone's head and then performed by someone that has spent 936 00:43:16,799 --> 00:43:21,119 hours, hours, thousands, thousands of hours perfecting their 937 00:43:21,119 --> 00:43:21,599 craft. 938 00:43:22,319 --> 00:43:24,159 And it means something to me. 939 00:43:24,159 --> 00:43:25,279 It moves me to tears. 940 00:43:25,279 --> 00:43:25,839 In the past. 941 00:43:28,049 --> 00:43:32,489 If we're just looking for what gives me a boner, what gives me quick 942 00:43:32,489 --> 00:43:36,649 dopamine hits, we're not even considering what it is that we're 943 00:43:36,649 --> 00:43:37,209 looking at. 944 00:43:37,209 --> 00:43:41,169 We're hoping that the funny little pixels on the screen will 945 00:43:41,169 --> 00:43:45,169 make some little chemical in my head, make me feel good. 946 00:43:45,569 --> 00:43:52,729 And so I don't think the newer, the newer crew of photography 947 00:43:52,729 --> 00:43:53,969 people that are just getting into this now. 948 00:43:56,159 --> 00:43:56,279 They. 949 00:43:56,279 --> 00:43:58,519 Haven'T had to fight the battle of the old Internet. 950 00:43:58,519 --> 00:43:59,959 They haven't had to use floppy disk. 951 00:43:59,959 --> 00:44:00,119 Right. 952 00:44:00,119 --> 00:44:01,519 So they're growing up with AI. 953 00:44:01,759 --> 00:44:05,879 And this is the thing I think that people get wrapped around the 954 00:44:05,879 --> 00:44:10,839 axle about is that new photographers are not real photographers. 955 00:44:10,839 --> 00:44:14,279 New retouchers are not real retouchers because they don't know 956 00:44:14,279 --> 00:44:15,759 the craft well. 957 00:44:15,759 --> 00:44:17,759 They're using all that they know. 958 00:44:18,559 --> 00:44:22,199 So I can't denigrate them for doing that or using the tools that 959 00:44:22,199 --> 00:44:22,719 they're using. 960 00:44:23,539 --> 00:44:29,619 But what I can say is the newbies are going to do new level 961 00:44:29,619 --> 00:44:30,099 stuff. 962 00:44:31,059 --> 00:44:33,779 The OGs are going to do OG level stuff. 963 00:44:34,499 --> 00:44:37,219 I think we're going to see a collapse in the middle. 964 00:44:37,779 --> 00:44:38,139 Right? 965 00:44:38,139 --> 00:44:42,899 The people that were kind of good, but, you know, they're not 966 00:44:42,899 --> 00:44:47,379 charging $200 an hour for retouching and they're not including 967 00:44:47,379 --> 00:44:50,839 it in their packages because it's just cheap and easy like newbies 968 00:44:50,839 --> 00:44:51,159 would. 969 00:44:51,799 --> 00:44:54,639 So that middle, where someone's charging 50, 100 bucks 970 00:44:54,639 --> 00:45:00,439 an hour, why would someone pay that if they know that, you know, 971 00:45:01,959 --> 00:45:04,679 if they know they can get it either super cheap or if they value 972 00:45:04,679 --> 00:45:07,319 it, they're going to go to someone that really knows the craft. 973 00:45:08,439 --> 00:45:11,959 As people talk about the industry collapsing? 974 00:45:13,479 --> 00:45:15,479 I don't think it's going to collapse. 975 00:45:15,479 --> 00:45:18,519 I think there's a level of adaptation that we have to get to. 976 00:45:18,599 --> 00:45:20,349 I don't know what that looks like yet. 977 00:45:22,019 --> 00:45:25,939 Where do you see, on both sides, photography and retouching. 978 00:45:26,099 --> 00:45:31,139 Since you have your foot in both ponds, where do you see significant 979 00:45:31,379 --> 00:45:36,019 change happening and where is that change really not going to be 980 00:45:36,019 --> 00:45:36,819 that big of a deal? 981 00:45:38,979 --> 00:45:42,339 Well, the first obvious, most obvious change is efficiency. 982 00:45:42,339 --> 00:45:43,459 The efficiency we're going to see. 983 00:45:43,459 --> 00:45:45,539 We're going to see utility things done very quickly. 984 00:45:45,539 --> 00:45:47,309 You know, we already are. 985 00:45:47,469 --> 00:45:50,709 So, you know, if, if, if I think the next step, for example, 986 00:45:50,709 --> 00:45:51,789 I mentioned capture one in their. 987 00:45:51,789 --> 00:45:52,869 In their face retouch, right? 988 00:45:52,869 --> 00:45:56,309 The next step will be to open, capture one or the new update and 989 00:45:56,309 --> 00:45:59,389 then train it, if you will, and say, this is how I like my editing 990 00:45:59,549 --> 00:46:00,269 to be done. 991 00:46:01,149 --> 00:46:02,869 And I don't even want you to finish it. 992 00:46:02,869 --> 00:46:03,949 I just want you to get started. 993 00:46:03,949 --> 00:46:06,269 This is the kind of things I want you to do for me. 994 00:46:06,669 --> 00:46:11,389 And then that has more use suddenly because it's not just conforming 995 00:46:11,389 --> 00:46:11,949 to one thing. 996 00:46:11,949 --> 00:46:14,069 That's not like you said, everything kind of squished into 997 00:46:14,069 --> 00:46:17,109 a medium gray of this is acceptable. 998 00:46:17,109 --> 00:46:18,749 So this is what we're doing now, you know. 999 00:46:19,469 --> 00:46:21,149 No, there's more nuance than that. 1000 00:46:21,149 --> 00:46:22,709 And if you're new, you don't know any better. 1001 00:46:22,709 --> 00:46:26,229 You just know that a face went from blemishes to none and you think 1002 00:46:26,229 --> 00:46:27,069 win, right? 1003 00:46:29,069 --> 00:46:29,829 So that's the first thing. 1004 00:46:29,829 --> 00:46:30,389 Efficiency. 1005 00:46:30,389 --> 00:46:31,909 Mad, crazy, stupid efficiency. 1006 00:46:31,909 --> 00:46:37,349 But second thing is that sort of leveraging in a customized way 1007 00:46:37,349 --> 00:46:39,069 in a way that's more tailored to you. 1008 00:46:39,069 --> 00:46:44,999 Because if, if you came from the world of airbrush retouching, 1009 00:46:44,999 --> 00:46:48,639 which goes back decades, many decades, not just airbrushing, but 1010 00:46:48,639 --> 00:46:51,039 all kinds of chemicals and paints and everything in the dark 1011 00:46:51,039 --> 00:46:52,359 room, all kinds of things. 1012 00:46:52,359 --> 00:46:54,759 You know, spray painting, literally spray painting an airbrush 1013 00:46:55,239 --> 00:46:57,198 with large positives and then you reshoot them. 1014 00:46:57,198 --> 00:46:59,119 And, you know, it was a big process. 1015 00:46:59,119 --> 00:46:59,879 It was a big problem. 1016 00:46:59,959 --> 00:47:00,999 Digital, right? 1017 00:47:00,999 --> 00:47:05,919 Digital comes and it's slow and clunky, so it's cool, but not 1018 00:47:05,919 --> 00:47:07,309 an immediate threat, right? 1019 00:47:07,549 --> 00:47:11,389 And then it starts advancing in the 90s, becomes a threat and 1020 00:47:11,389 --> 00:47:11,949 destroys. 1021 00:47:12,589 --> 00:47:13,789 Manual retouching. 1022 00:47:14,029 --> 00:47:18,269 It just absolutely obliterated it because it became efficient, you 1023 00:47:18,269 --> 00:47:21,469 know, and once it came, once it hit the same caliber in terms 1024 00:47:21,469 --> 00:47:26,789 of quality, because, you know, 1992, 1 1, whatever they call you, 1025 00:47:26,789 --> 00:47:29,309 1111 megabyte image was huge. 1026 00:47:29,309 --> 00:47:32,069 So that was not useful for people. 1027 00:47:32,069 --> 00:47:37,269 But once it became useful and then ownership of course, became 1028 00:47:37,269 --> 00:47:41,989 ubiquitous and regular old school type of retouching, unless 1029 00:47:41,989 --> 00:47:45,989 you're choosing to do it, is gone and it got replaced. 1030 00:47:45,989 --> 00:47:48,229 And AI is doing that now. 1031 00:47:49,109 --> 00:47:53,109 However, the difference, in my mind, the difference is how will 1032 00:47:53,109 --> 00:47:56,389 we leverage the technology in a way that allows us to still express 1033 00:47:56,389 --> 00:47:59,429 something, that allows us to still be who we want to be. 1034 00:47:59,429 --> 00:48:02,209 And even if we don't know the answer yet, can we customize the 1035 00:48:02,209 --> 00:48:02,409 tool? 1036 00:48:02,409 --> 00:48:06,969 Because right now AI is ask, receive, right? 1037 00:48:07,449 --> 00:48:10,089 You know, and I understand there's ways of training models and 1038 00:48:10,249 --> 00:48:12,849 there's open source things and then you can train it on you and 1039 00:48:12,849 --> 00:48:15,209 train it on your work and that we're seeing that, that's what I'm 1040 00:48:15,209 --> 00:48:15,689 talking about. 1041 00:48:15,689 --> 00:48:18,769 But just because you trained on your body of work and then you 1042 00:48:18,769 --> 00:48:21,689 output something as AI, that I'm not going to perceive that work 1043 00:48:21,689 --> 00:48:23,129 as the same as your photographs. 1044 00:48:23,129 --> 00:48:25,689 I'm just not because of that history that's absent. 1045 00:48:26,569 --> 00:48:30,509 It's cool tech, but I'm not going to view it the same. 1046 00:48:30,509 --> 00:48:33,669 You might have a cool vision, you might have a pretty image that 1047 00:48:33,669 --> 00:48:37,069 again hits the dopamine, but there's not going to be a story there. 1048 00:48:37,069 --> 00:48:40,469 So I think we're going to customize the tools, if you will, 1049 00:48:40,469 --> 00:48:43,549 being able to leverage them in ways that help us efficiently help 1050 00:48:43,549 --> 00:48:45,909 us accomplish something, which we kind of already doing. 1051 00:48:45,909 --> 00:48:48,429 Every time you go to subject selection on Photoshop, guess what? 1052 00:48:48,429 --> 00:48:51,989 That's AI making a choice and avoiding you making a pen tool mask 1053 00:48:51,989 --> 00:48:52,669 that takes an hour. 1054 00:48:53,669 --> 00:48:55,189 So we've been doing that for a while, right? 1055 00:48:55,509 --> 00:48:56,949 So is that corruption? 1056 00:48:57,349 --> 00:48:57,629 No. 1057 00:48:57,629 --> 00:49:00,269 If you don't use a pen tool to mask out the subjects, you're not 1058 00:49:00,269 --> 00:49:00,949 a real artist. 1059 00:49:01,029 --> 00:49:01,429 Right? 1060 00:49:01,589 --> 00:49:03,589 Where, where is everybody's threshold? 1061 00:49:03,749 --> 00:49:05,909 Right, that's, that's a question that we have to ask. 1062 00:49:05,909 --> 00:49:11,869 But at the end of the day, of every damn day, what are you, what 1063 00:49:11,869 --> 00:49:12,549 is your vision? 1064 00:49:12,549 --> 00:49:13,109 What are you doing? 1065 00:49:13,109 --> 00:49:16,549 And I want to circle back real quick when I say this because when 1066 00:49:16,549 --> 00:49:18,829 we say meaning again, I want to repeat this. 1067 00:49:18,829 --> 00:49:20,869 It's very important that make this clear. 1068 00:49:21,159 --> 00:49:24,159 When we say art should have meaning, we tend to immediately jump 1069 00:49:24,159 --> 00:49:28,839 to profound, serious, you know, in depth, poignant. 1070 00:49:30,199 --> 00:49:30,919 We don't. 1071 00:49:31,959 --> 00:49:35,759 We think about serious songs, deep love songs, and we think about 1072 00:49:35,759 --> 00:49:39,359 politically charged things and we think about socially aware concepts 1073 00:49:39,359 --> 00:49:39,679 and things. 1074 00:49:39,679 --> 00:49:40,839 And that's all valid. 1075 00:49:41,399 --> 00:49:45,479 But there's meaning, human meaning in art that's just pretty 1076 00:49:45,719 --> 00:49:48,729 because a human did it, a human wanted to do it. 1077 00:49:48,729 --> 00:49:52,289 It doesn't have to have some deep story or deep message, but a 1078 00:49:52,289 --> 00:49:53,289 Human did it. 1079 00:49:53,609 --> 00:49:54,369 There's value. 1080 00:49:54,369 --> 00:49:56,489 And I'm not trying to get too crazy spiritual on you. 1081 00:49:56,489 --> 00:49:59,369 It's just that when you compare it to the AI slob and the 1082 00:49:59,369 --> 00:50:04,129 endless amounts of it, one person going somewhere to take a 1083 00:50:04,129 --> 00:50:07,449 picture is an experience that AI cannot do. 1084 00:50:08,729 --> 00:50:09,929 And that's important to me. 1085 00:50:10,729 --> 00:50:13,449 I'll go outside the realm of photography for a second. 1086 00:50:13,449 --> 00:50:16,669 But since we're here on YouTube, one of the things that I 1087 00:50:16,669 --> 00:50:20,269 look forward to at the end of every year is inevitably someone 1088 00:50:20,269 --> 00:50:24,229 will release a humans are incredible video. 1089 00:50:24,469 --> 00:50:24,869 Right? 1090 00:50:24,949 --> 00:50:29,309 And you see these people that are cliff diving and, you know, they're 1091 00:50:29,309 --> 00:50:31,389 BASE jumping and they're doing all this stuff, and it's just really 1092 00:50:31,389 --> 00:50:31,629 cool. 1093 00:50:31,629 --> 00:50:34,109 You're like, how'd you learn to do that? 1094 00:50:34,109 --> 00:50:34,469 Right? 1095 00:50:34,469 --> 00:50:36,229 You have squirrel suit flying. 1096 00:50:36,229 --> 00:50:37,669 Like, how do you get into that? 1097 00:50:37,669 --> 00:50:38,469 Right, right. 1098 00:50:38,629 --> 00:50:41,789 And I see that and I get super excited by it because I know those 1099 00:50:41,789 --> 00:50:42,699 are real humans. 1100 00:50:43,249 --> 00:50:46,609 Now at the end of this year, is there going to be someone on a 1101 00:50:46,609 --> 00:50:47,969 tricycle, on an F1 track? 1102 00:50:48,369 --> 00:50:52,449 You know, and I'm going to look at it and be like, I'm so jaded 1103 00:50:52,449 --> 00:50:55,449 now, and I've become so callous to what is real and what 1104 00:50:55,449 --> 00:50:55,969 is not. 1105 00:50:56,369 --> 00:51:00,769 That unless I'm there looking at it in person, it becomes very 1106 00:51:00,769 --> 00:51:05,009 difficult for me to default to, wow, that's really cool. 1107 00:51:05,329 --> 00:51:05,649 Right. 1108 00:51:05,649 --> 00:51:07,009 Because I've lost the trust in it. 1109 00:51:07,169 --> 00:51:10,139 But let me get back to something you said a minute ago about, 1110 00:51:10,139 --> 00:51:11,899 you know, training it on bad data. 1111 00:51:12,379 --> 00:51:15,419 And I keep thinking about where retouchers fit in. 1112 00:51:16,299 --> 00:51:22,059 And what I keep thinking about is, yes, people can move sliders 1113 00:51:22,139 --> 00:51:28,619 and they can do blemish moving or, you know, even easier liquefy 1114 00:51:28,619 --> 00:51:31,059 on someone's waste by using these sliders. 1115 00:51:31,059 --> 00:51:31,339 Right? 1116 00:51:32,779 --> 00:51:36,499 But they're working within the confines of whatever the software 1117 00:51:36,499 --> 00:51:37,419 company gave them. 1118 00:51:39,279 --> 00:51:46,879 The value in real retouching is that you know what contrast can 1119 00:51:46,879 --> 00:51:47,719 or cannot do. 1120 00:51:47,719 --> 00:51:50,359 This is one of your latest videos about what contrast really 1121 00:51:50,359 --> 00:51:50,719 is. 1122 00:51:51,759 --> 00:51:55,119 I've talked to Renee Robin about compositing, Right. 1123 00:51:55,119 --> 00:51:58,719 I don't do much compositing, but she's like, compositing is easy, 1124 00:51:58,719 --> 00:52:00,719 but everything lives in the shadows. 1125 00:52:00,879 --> 00:52:05,669 If you don't get the shadows right, it doesn't portray truth or 1126 00:52:05,669 --> 00:52:06,349 it doesn't. 1127 00:52:06,349 --> 00:52:09,589 It doesn't even allow you to suspend your belief, to believe in 1128 00:52:09,589 --> 00:52:11,349 the art if you don't get the shadows right. 1129 00:52:11,349 --> 00:52:12,749 Because your brain is just like. 1130 00:52:13,309 --> 00:52:14,429 That doesn't look right. 1131 00:52:14,829 --> 00:52:15,309 Yeah. 1132 00:52:15,469 --> 00:52:16,749 So do you think there's a place. 1133 00:52:16,829 --> 00:52:17,229 For. 1134 00:52:19,309 --> 00:52:26,749 Real retouchers to work as AI workflow consultants to help people 1135 00:52:26,749 --> 00:52:30,709 if they're going to be developing prompts or they're going 1136 00:52:30,709 --> 00:52:33,789 to be using this, hey, here are the things you really need to 1137 00:52:33,789 --> 00:52:34,629 look out for. 1138 00:52:34,949 --> 00:52:39,909 Or do you feel like that is, you know, just three months where 1139 00:52:39,909 --> 00:52:42,629 retouchers do that and the software companies pick up on it 1140 00:52:42,709 --> 00:52:44,789 and they just kind of work that into the software. 1141 00:52:44,869 --> 00:52:46,469 Do you think there's a place for that? 1142 00:52:46,469 --> 00:52:48,309 Like high level of knowledge? 1143 00:52:48,549 --> 00:52:51,549 Especially people that grew up on tools that don't necessarily have 1144 00:52:51,549 --> 00:52:56,229 the background of knowledge of what this software is actually doing. 1145 00:52:56,769 --> 00:52:57,009 Right. 1146 00:52:57,489 --> 00:53:03,369 Using an action or using a preset tool is great if you know 1147 00:53:03,369 --> 00:53:04,129 what it's doing. 1148 00:53:04,289 --> 00:53:08,209 And then you can season that recipe to your taste by tweaking, 1149 00:53:08,689 --> 00:53:11,009 you know, this slider or that slider or this panel. 1150 00:53:11,569 --> 00:53:15,009 But if you have no idea, you're at the mercy of the software 1151 00:53:15,009 --> 00:53:16,129 company as to what they think. 1152 00:53:16,129 --> 00:53:17,889 And this goes back to the beginning of the conversation where 1153 00:53:17,889 --> 00:53:18,609 you're talking about that. 1154 00:53:19,009 --> 00:53:25,339 Do you think there's a place for the, the high end retoucher to 1155 00:53:25,419 --> 00:53:29,819 elevate themselves up into a more valuable consultancy role? 1156 00:53:31,419 --> 00:53:35,659 That's actually a very fascinating question because the 1157 00:53:35,659 --> 00:53:40,379 idea of being a consultant on the matter is something I haven't 1158 00:53:40,459 --> 00:53:41,539 spent a lot of time thinking about. 1159 00:53:41,539 --> 00:53:42,539 It's actually really cool. 1160 00:53:45,499 --> 00:53:48,499 Yeah, that would be obviously a temporary thing because AI's slope 1161 00:53:48,499 --> 00:53:49,219 is extreme, right. 1162 00:53:49,219 --> 00:53:50,299 So it learns so fast. 1163 00:53:50,529 --> 00:53:52,729 You know, this is not something you can set up, but what 1164 00:53:52,729 --> 00:53:55,729 we do see in the world of AI, all kinds of AI technologies that 1165 00:53:55,729 --> 00:54:03,329 we have consultants, if you will, or how do we put this? 1166 00:54:03,649 --> 00:54:08,449 Every, every AI organization has an entire like ethics board, 1167 00:54:08,849 --> 00:54:13,329 you know, and, and, and if you're OpenAI, you kind of need an 1168 00:54:13,329 --> 00:54:14,369 ethics board, you know. 1169 00:54:14,529 --> 00:54:20,519 But will we be able to consult on the tech from an ethical standpoint? 1170 00:54:20,839 --> 00:54:24,359 Not just on principle, not just AI is going to take over, you 1171 00:54:24,359 --> 00:54:25,839 know, T800s, blah blah blah. 1172 00:54:25,839 --> 00:54:28,919 Not just that, not just end times, but what are we doing with 1173 00:54:28,919 --> 00:54:29,399 our work. 1174 00:54:29,399 --> 00:54:29,719 Right. 1175 00:54:29,879 --> 00:54:32,999 And I think that's going to be a topic that should be discussed. 1176 00:54:32,999 --> 00:54:36,599 I'm not saying it's going to be a professional position, I don't 1177 00:54:36,679 --> 00:54:36,999 know. 1178 00:54:36,999 --> 00:54:38,599 But it's something that should be taught. 1179 00:54:38,599 --> 00:54:40,839 Maybe it should, something that should be part of curriculum, 1180 00:54:40,839 --> 00:54:42,319 maybe give a workshop. 1181 00:54:42,319 --> 00:54:42,959 We should talk about that. 1182 00:54:42,959 --> 00:54:45,239 So look, we have to talk about the elephant in the room, AI. 1183 00:54:45,599 --> 00:54:47,439 Let's talk about the ethical element. 1184 00:54:47,439 --> 00:54:48,479 What is the ethical element? 1185 00:54:48,479 --> 00:54:52,319 The ethical element to me is where you draw your line in the sand, 1186 00:54:52,319 --> 00:54:52,639 right? 1187 00:54:52,799 --> 00:54:54,319 What does that mean for You. 1188 00:54:54,559 --> 00:54:58,319 And how do you navigate your career in that boundary? 1189 00:54:58,639 --> 00:54:59,919 Because that's all that matters. 1190 00:55:00,079 --> 00:55:01,279 You can do whatever you want. 1191 00:55:01,279 --> 00:55:05,879 You can go hella AI and you can say zero AI draw your line to 1192 00:55:05,879 --> 00:55:08,879 sand, navigate your career and then what? 1193 00:55:08,879 --> 00:55:11,359 And so that's kind of your own ethical boundary. 1194 00:55:11,589 --> 00:55:11,829 Right. 1195 00:55:12,229 --> 00:55:14,629 I think deception is of course, where, where everything draws 1196 00:55:14,629 --> 00:55:14,829 the line. 1197 00:55:14,829 --> 00:55:16,709 If you're, if you're saying these are photographs and they're 1198 00:55:16,709 --> 00:55:18,949 not, you're not winning anybody's favor. 1199 00:55:19,429 --> 00:55:21,509 You're going to make enemies except for marketing companies. 1200 00:55:21,829 --> 00:55:23,909 Other artists are going to absolutely condemn you. 1201 00:55:24,229 --> 00:55:26,309 If you're saying something is what it isn't. 1202 00:55:26,389 --> 00:55:27,469 That's been true forever. 1203 00:55:27,469 --> 00:55:27,748 Right. 1204 00:55:27,748 --> 00:55:31,029 We've seen people stealing photos from others, let alone making 1205 00:55:31,029 --> 00:55:31,669 AI website. 1206 00:55:31,669 --> 00:55:33,949 So deception is always asset threshold. 1207 00:55:33,949 --> 00:55:38,029 I think 99.99% of people can't go past the deception aspect. 1208 00:55:38,029 --> 00:55:42,279 No, but where you leverage it, where you draw that proverbial line 1209 00:55:42,279 --> 00:55:44,759 of sand, that's, that's interesting. 1210 00:55:44,759 --> 00:55:47,239 That's an interesting metric that we're seeing evolve. 1211 00:55:47,719 --> 00:55:50,279 You know, we've seen people who don't retouch. 1212 00:55:50,279 --> 00:55:50,599 Right. 1213 00:55:50,759 --> 00:55:53,159 Who are photographers and fashion magazines who swear they 1214 00:55:53,159 --> 00:55:53,839 don't retouch. 1215 00:55:53,839 --> 00:55:54,119 Right. 1216 00:55:55,239 --> 00:55:57,079 That's a principled decision. 1217 00:55:57,399 --> 00:55:57,799 Right. 1218 00:55:57,799 --> 00:55:58,799 Less of an art decision. 1219 00:55:58,799 --> 00:56:02,599 It's kind of an art decision, but it's an art decision made on 1220 00:56:02,679 --> 00:56:04,359 principles that are important to that person. 1221 00:56:04,929 --> 00:56:05,609 Does that limit them? 1222 00:56:05,609 --> 00:56:06,929 In some ways, yes. 1223 00:56:07,169 --> 00:56:09,569 Is that controversial to some people also, yes. 1224 00:56:09,729 --> 00:56:14,649 However, their courage, you can't deny the courage for drawing 1225 00:56:14,649 --> 00:56:16,769 the line in the sand AI is no different. 1226 00:56:17,009 --> 00:56:19,809 So I'm not trying to simplify and I don't claim to know because 1227 00:56:19,809 --> 00:56:21,089 this changes every quarter. 1228 00:56:21,329 --> 00:56:26,169 But right now I'm strongly of the idea that we have to make some 1229 00:56:26,169 --> 00:56:28,609 choices and run with them and be courageous about it. 1230 00:56:32,379 --> 00:56:36,219 You brought up ethics, value principles. 1231 00:56:39,659 --> 00:56:47,099 Does the retouching workflow matter to the end client? 1232 00:56:47,419 --> 00:56:48,779 Do you think they care? 1233 00:56:49,499 --> 00:56:49,899 Right. 1234 00:56:50,299 --> 00:56:55,739 So we're at a point now where the consumer level tools are okay, 1235 00:56:56,149 --> 00:56:59,989 but quite honestly, unless you're in the industry or peripherally 1236 00:56:59,989 --> 00:57:02,309 attached to it, you just don't even think about it. 1237 00:57:02,469 --> 00:57:02,869 Right. 1238 00:57:04,229 --> 00:57:07,349 People that I talk to here in town, they, they don't care. 1239 00:57:07,589 --> 00:57:10,269 They don't care about the process of what I do to create the 1240 00:57:10,269 --> 00:57:10,549 image. 1241 00:57:10,549 --> 00:57:12,789 They just say, wow, your stuff looks like art. 1242 00:57:13,109 --> 00:57:16,469 And I'm like, I think that's a compliment. 1243 00:57:16,469 --> 00:57:17,389 I'm going to leave it there. 1244 00:57:17,389 --> 00:57:19,189 But like, whatever. 1245 00:57:19,349 --> 00:57:24,349 But I don't think they're considering the aspects of the principles 1246 00:57:24,349 --> 00:57:28,909 or the ethics in what we really debate about internally. 1247 00:57:30,109 --> 00:57:36,069 And so I wonder if this is much ado about nothing when it comes 1248 00:57:36,069 --> 00:57:38,909 to the relationship between the artist and the client. 1249 00:57:40,029 --> 00:57:43,989 But it is certainly something that we have to talk about, we have 1250 00:57:43,989 --> 00:57:44,669 to deal with. 1251 00:57:45,389 --> 00:57:50,199 I've just, there is no difference in this to me between 1252 00:57:51,959 --> 00:57:56,399 film going to digital, digital going to hologram, like whatever 1253 00:57:56,399 --> 00:57:56,839 it is. 1254 00:57:57,319 --> 00:58:04,319 And I think, you know, if you have built in color profiles in Lightroom 1255 00:58:04,319 --> 00:58:10,039 or capture one and you don't know how to change that to enact 1256 00:58:10,039 --> 00:58:16,039 your own vision, you're really not any different than the end consumer 1257 00:58:16,569 --> 00:58:22,369 who can just find an off the shelf Kmart tool and do their, and 1258 00:58:22,369 --> 00:58:23,129 do their art. 1259 00:58:23,289 --> 00:58:23,609 Right? 1260 00:58:23,609 --> 00:58:24,489 I'm an artist. 1261 00:58:24,809 --> 00:58:27,289 I picture, you know, Ralph Wiggum in that. 1262 00:58:29,209 --> 00:58:29,609 So. 1263 00:58:31,369 --> 00:58:35,009 I just, I keep expanding the conversation because I come down 1264 00:58:35,009 --> 00:58:37,449 to what am I concerned about? 1265 00:58:37,449 --> 00:58:43,639 I'm concerned about things like we're not adapting fast enough 1266 00:58:43,879 --> 00:58:46,679 to think about how we stay ahead of the technology. 1267 00:58:47,079 --> 00:58:52,919 Do we consult, do we create an ethics board at the PPA level, you 1268 00:58:52,919 --> 00:58:59,039 know, and really come out as subject matter experts on a topic 1269 00:58:59,039 --> 00:59:04,439 that is not necessarily something that we can change at the 1270 00:59:04,839 --> 00:59:09,119 person by person level, but changing the conversation and how 1271 00:59:09,119 --> 00:59:10,029 we think about it. 1272 00:59:10,979 --> 00:59:15,539 Do you think that that is even worth it to have that conversation? 1273 00:59:15,699 --> 00:59:19,179 Or do you think that everybody knows the playing field? 1274 00:59:19,179 --> 00:59:22,099 The companies know what they want to do, they're injecting AI 1275 00:59:22,099 --> 00:59:25,179 and stuff because some bean counter told them that it's going 1276 00:59:25,179 --> 00:59:26,418 to save on the bottom line. 1277 00:59:27,379 --> 00:59:31,139 Do you think it's even worth having deeper conversations like 1278 00:59:31,139 --> 00:59:34,899 this about how we change our own profession? 1279 00:59:35,299 --> 00:59:39,549 Or do you think we just make it more of an individual choice and 1280 00:59:39,549 --> 00:59:42,149 come back to the line in the sand, the principles, the values 1281 00:59:42,389 --> 00:59:43,829 on a per person level. 1282 00:59:43,989 --> 00:59:45,189 What do you think about that? 1283 00:59:45,669 --> 00:59:46,709 Yeah, no, that's. 1284 00:59:47,509 --> 00:59:49,269 Let me answer that in pieces. 1285 00:59:49,749 --> 00:59:52,629 The first part is the clients don't care. 1286 00:59:52,629 --> 00:59:55,869 They haven't cared about how you retouch in the beginning. 1287 00:59:55,869 --> 00:59:56,629 They don't care. 1288 00:59:56,869 --> 01:00:00,269 And just because of social media, everybody knows that AI is 1289 01:00:00,269 --> 01:00:00,709 a thing. 1290 01:00:00,949 --> 01:00:03,629 And I'm sure the average client's asking, hey, did you use 1291 01:00:03,629 --> 01:00:04,189 AI on this? 1292 01:00:04,189 --> 01:00:05,189 Because it looks cool, right? 1293 01:00:05,639 --> 01:00:06,919 They don't care. 1294 01:00:07,239 --> 01:00:09,599 As far as they're concerned, what you were doing 10 years ago 1295 01:00:09,599 --> 01:00:11,319 in Photoshop is AI, right? 1296 01:00:11,399 --> 01:00:12,519 Oh, magic. 1297 01:00:12,519 --> 01:00:14,119 It might as well be magic, right? 1298 01:00:14,359 --> 01:00:15,559 So the client doesn't care. 1299 01:00:15,639 --> 01:00:18,719 So if you're looking at the ethics question, then you're the 1300 01:00:18,719 --> 01:00:20,399 client is not entirely relevant. 1301 01:00:20,399 --> 01:00:24,999 Now it's a very, very different story with some kind of. 1302 01:00:25,319 --> 01:00:26,759 If there's an Element of truth to it. 1303 01:00:26,759 --> 01:00:29,399 If it's a headshot that's supposed to look pretty, that's cool. 1304 01:00:29,399 --> 01:00:34,509 But if it's supposed to be, I don't know, a wedding shot and you 1305 01:00:34,509 --> 01:00:38,309 completely render a new background, that strikes me as unethical. 1306 01:00:39,429 --> 01:00:40,629 I feel like something's wrong there. 1307 01:00:40,629 --> 01:00:42,309 This is an art shot when it's. 1308 01:00:42,309 --> 01:00:45,149 Supposed to be requested by the client. 1309 01:00:45,149 --> 01:00:46,389 Hey, it was a rainy day. 1310 01:00:46,389 --> 01:00:48,709 Put a sunny sky behind us. 1311 01:00:48,709 --> 01:00:49,509 Yeah, right. 1312 01:00:49,509 --> 01:00:51,749 And they can just live that lie. 1313 01:00:52,069 --> 01:00:52,509 Totally. 1314 01:00:52,509 --> 01:00:53,109 Yeah, totally. 1315 01:00:53,109 --> 01:00:54,189 For whatever they want. 1316 01:00:54,189 --> 01:00:54,549 Right. 1317 01:00:54,709 --> 01:00:56,749 So again, it's a service and art. 1318 01:00:56,749 --> 01:01:01,099 Now, from strictly from the art standpoint, then, you know, there's 1319 01:01:01,099 --> 01:01:02,179 no client involved there. 1320 01:01:02,179 --> 01:01:03,659 So that's where you have to draw your line. 1321 01:01:03,659 --> 01:01:06,259 Stand, like I said, and go, what am I going to do with this? 1322 01:01:06,259 --> 01:01:08,899 But again, if you look at it, there's something sobering there. 1323 01:01:08,899 --> 01:01:11,299 Thinking about the client perspective that 10 years ago what 1324 01:01:11,299 --> 01:01:13,659 you were doing in Photoshop is as good as AI is today. 1325 01:01:13,979 --> 01:01:15,099 They didn't know the difference. 1326 01:01:15,259 --> 01:01:17,419 They don't know how Photoshopping works because they 1327 01:01:17,419 --> 01:01:22,379 use it as a verb and they just assume that magic happens. 1328 01:01:22,379 --> 01:01:22,699 Right. 1329 01:01:23,579 --> 01:01:24,459 If you're good at it. 1330 01:01:24,939 --> 01:01:26,739 And then now with AI, they just assume. 1331 01:01:26,739 --> 01:01:28,419 Oh, you ran that through GPT, right? 1332 01:01:28,419 --> 01:01:29,219 Yeah, that's what I did. 1333 01:01:29,219 --> 01:01:31,319 I ran your modeling photos through GPT. 1334 01:01:31,879 --> 01:01:33,599 No, but they don't know. 1335 01:01:33,599 --> 01:01:34,239 They don't care. 1336 01:01:34,239 --> 01:01:39,279 And that's a very, again, sobering reminder of what, of what 1337 01:01:39,279 --> 01:01:40,679 the tech can be seen as. 1338 01:01:40,679 --> 01:01:43,639 Now, we in the industry, we're in the middle of it, we're in the 1339 01:01:43,639 --> 01:01:43,999 trenches. 1340 01:01:43,999 --> 01:01:45,799 We're gonna see all the tech come and go. 1341 01:01:45,879 --> 01:01:48,199 There's people who didn't like mirrorless, there's people who didn't 1342 01:01:48,199 --> 01:01:50,679 like digital, there's people who didn't like this, and that is 1343 01:01:50,679 --> 01:01:52,199 people who still don't like medium format. 1344 01:01:52,199 --> 01:01:55,879 There's people, you know, it gets exhausting after a while. 1345 01:01:55,959 --> 01:01:59,269 But there's a big, big but here. 1346 01:01:59,509 --> 01:02:07,229 And that AI's, again, its efficiency in what it does and efficiency 1347 01:02:07,229 --> 01:02:10,309 and how it evolves is not to be understated. 1348 01:02:11,109 --> 01:02:17,269 That is, I think what scares people is that if there's an ethical 1349 01:02:17,269 --> 01:02:22,879 dilemma at all, an ethical obligation, responsibility, it's 1350 01:02:22,879 --> 01:02:25,679 in, I guess, teaching. 1351 01:02:25,679 --> 01:02:26,879 Yeah, that's the word. 1352 01:02:27,839 --> 01:02:32,919 But ensuring that people as a whole, in any way that you can, don't 1353 01:02:32,919 --> 01:02:38,679 lose sight of humanity, from anything from music to, especially 1354 01:02:38,679 --> 01:02:39,239 in the arts. 1355 01:02:39,239 --> 01:02:42,959 But in general, yeah, we're seeing that because of the deception 1356 01:02:42,959 --> 01:02:43,399 angle. 1357 01:02:43,399 --> 01:02:43,639 Right? 1358 01:02:43,639 --> 01:02:44,519 We're seeing a lot of that. 1359 01:02:44,519 --> 01:02:44,679 Right. 1360 01:02:44,679 --> 01:02:47,119 We need to be Real careful on the deception angle. 1361 01:02:47,119 --> 01:02:50,889 Videos and photos of things that depict things that did not happen. 1362 01:02:51,049 --> 01:02:52,249 They are tricking people. 1363 01:02:52,729 --> 01:02:55,369 That is dangerous for reasons I don't need to go into. 1364 01:02:56,009 --> 01:03:01,609 But deception aside, we have to help, hopefully remind. 1365 01:03:02,089 --> 01:03:05,449 I'm just going to use this term normies, non artists. 1366 01:03:06,249 --> 01:03:10,489 We're going to help normies try hopefully to remember that there's 1367 01:03:10,489 --> 01:03:11,889 value in human effort. 1368 01:03:11,889 --> 01:03:14,729 There's value in a human hand doing something. 1369 01:03:14,729 --> 01:03:18,379 There's value in a human voice speaking and saying something that 1370 01:03:18,379 --> 01:03:21,779 came from their experience, that they can modify your future 1371 01:03:21,779 --> 01:03:22,739 experience from there. 1372 01:03:22,899 --> 01:03:26,379 Ideas converge, efforts converge, and things continue to 1373 01:03:26,379 --> 01:03:31,699 evolve in a very, very human way that literally cannot be replaced. 1374 01:03:31,699 --> 01:03:33,099 At least not wholesale. 1375 01:03:33,099 --> 01:03:38,419 And not overnight, not in our lifetime, but before. 1376 01:03:38,499 --> 01:03:45,329 We are consciousness that are uploaded into a substrate of conscious, 1377 01:03:45,329 --> 01:03:46,489 of mass consciousness. 1378 01:03:46,489 --> 01:03:50,289 And we're now in this extra, you know, a thousand years from now, 1379 01:03:50,289 --> 01:03:51,209 we're a whole different story. 1380 01:03:51,209 --> 01:03:53,449 That's cool, but I don't want to be there, right? 1381 01:03:53,609 --> 01:03:57,449 So right now my concern is reminding people of their own humanity. 1382 01:03:57,929 --> 01:04:00,489 Not so much you need to respect artists, you need to respect 1383 01:04:00,489 --> 01:04:00,969 yourself. 1384 01:04:01,129 --> 01:04:03,809 Because if you understand your own humanity, you'll see it in others. 1385 01:04:03,809 --> 01:04:05,449 That's theory, anyway. 1386 01:04:06,009 --> 01:04:06,809 I love that. 1387 01:04:07,689 --> 01:04:10,369 You know, it got me thinking about how much commercial work you 1388 01:04:10,369 --> 01:04:10,529 do. 1389 01:04:10,529 --> 01:04:16,569 And this is more video than it is, than it is photography. 1390 01:04:16,569 --> 01:04:19,489 But when Jaguar came out with. 1391 01:04:19,889 --> 01:04:20,729 I think it was Jaguar. 1392 01:04:20,729 --> 01:04:21,369 No, it was Coke. 1393 01:04:21,369 --> 01:04:22,849 Coca Cola came out with. 1394 01:04:23,009 --> 01:04:26,209 Jaguar was just kind of like, they just missed the mark on so many 1395 01:04:26,209 --> 01:04:26,689 levels. 1396 01:04:27,008 --> 01:04:29,329 Coca Cola did a. 1397 01:04:29,969 --> 01:04:34,409 A video at Christmas, like a Christmas commercial, and they produced 1398 01:04:34,409 --> 01:04:34,569 it. 1399 01:04:34,569 --> 01:04:37,449 And it's, you know, this train going down the tracks or it was like 1400 01:04:37,449 --> 01:04:41,049 18 wheelers or something like that in every shot, because it was 1401 01:04:41,049 --> 01:04:45,409 produced in those seven to eight second VO videos, is that there 1402 01:04:45,409 --> 01:04:47,609 was a mistake in every single shot. 1403 01:04:47,769 --> 01:04:51,809 And it was very, very clear that the marketing department, the 1404 01:04:51,809 --> 01:04:54,729 art department of Coca Cola used AI to create this. 1405 01:04:55,689 --> 01:04:58,089 So there was big backlash. 1406 01:04:58,329 --> 01:05:02,729 And people were like, come on, Coca Cola, you own half the planet. 1407 01:05:02,729 --> 01:05:05,609 Like, really, you couldn't pay someone to do this, right? 1408 01:05:05,609 --> 01:05:07,089 There are plenty of animators out there. 1409 01:05:07,089 --> 01:05:08,089 You couldn't do that, right? 1410 01:05:08,909 --> 01:05:12,029 What are you seeing with your commercial clients at a. 1411 01:05:12,269 --> 01:05:13,549 At an emotional level? 1412 01:05:13,709 --> 01:05:16,269 Do you feel like you're. 1413 01:05:16,829 --> 01:05:20,949 You're retaining clients because you've built a relationship 1414 01:05:20,949 --> 01:05:24,069 with them over the years, that you are really catering to what they 1415 01:05:24,069 --> 01:05:24,429 need? 1416 01:05:24,829 --> 01:05:28,829 Or do you feel like there are companies that are really moving 1417 01:05:28,829 --> 01:05:32,229 towards the efficiency angle and just get it out fast? 1418 01:05:32,229 --> 01:05:36,029 Because we know content's only Going to live for 3,5 seconds at 1419 01:05:36,029 --> 01:05:36,469 a time. 1420 01:05:36,709 --> 01:05:39,669 What are you seeing when you're having conversations with 1421 01:05:40,469 --> 01:05:43,189 magazines, when you're having conversations with your commercial 1422 01:05:43,189 --> 01:05:43,669 clients? 1423 01:05:44,229 --> 01:05:45,509 What are they feeling? 1424 01:05:45,509 --> 01:05:47,029 How do they look at all of this? 1425 01:05:47,989 --> 01:05:49,509 I mean, it varies a lot, right? 1426 01:05:49,509 --> 01:05:53,349 Yeah, but one thing that because of what I do, and I've always 1427 01:05:53,349 --> 01:05:57,389 presented it, at least in last few years, I always presented that 1428 01:05:57,389 --> 01:06:00,349 what I do is an artistic endeavor, not so much. 1429 01:06:00,349 --> 01:06:03,399 I'm not trying to advertise a soda, so I don't. 1430 01:06:03,399 --> 01:06:04,519 I don't ever work in that space. 1431 01:06:04,519 --> 01:06:06,359 I can imagine that's a whole different animal. 1432 01:06:06,359 --> 01:06:12,719 But in my side of things, I think I succeeded okay, in selling 1433 01:06:12,719 --> 01:06:15,079 the human element enough that people want. 1434 01:06:15,079 --> 01:06:17,479 That they want the human element, you know, like, even I don't 1435 01:06:17,479 --> 01:06:20,399 do it anymore, but even when I put together sets for men's magazines 1436 01:06:20,399 --> 01:06:25,319 or whatever, you know, the girl is the point, you know? 1437 01:06:26,119 --> 01:06:27,799 And I'm certain that we're going to see. 1438 01:06:27,799 --> 01:06:31,049 We haven't already AI pictorials and Playboy and things 1439 01:06:31,049 --> 01:06:31,529 like that. 1440 01:06:31,529 --> 01:06:32,569 And that's fine. 1441 01:06:32,569 --> 01:06:33,089 But think about it. 1442 01:06:33,089 --> 01:06:34,849 That goes right back to what we were already talking about. 1443 01:06:35,409 --> 01:06:38,809 Not necessarily pornography angle, but the humanity angle is 1444 01:06:38,809 --> 01:06:39,569 like, who is this person? 1445 01:06:39,809 --> 01:06:41,009 He does not exist. 1446 01:06:41,569 --> 01:06:43,809 And that's just not as interesting, is it? 1447 01:06:44,608 --> 01:06:44,969 No. 1448 01:06:44,969 --> 01:06:45,929 And I'm seeing this. 1449 01:06:45,929 --> 01:06:47,609 I just saw a thing last night. 1450 01:06:47,609 --> 01:06:50,849 I don't know if you've heard about this controversy or seen it. 1451 01:06:51,329 --> 01:06:55,249 There's an artist, apparently a musical artist, named Sienna Rose. 1452 01:06:55,489 --> 01:06:58,539 I do not know the her music. 1453 01:06:58,539 --> 01:06:59,779 I don't know anything about it. 1454 01:07:00,099 --> 01:07:04,979 But there's the question, is it AI generated or not? 1455 01:07:05,379 --> 01:07:09,859 Because the producer on many of these records is a guy out of 1456 01:07:09,859 --> 01:07:12,659 Europe, Finland, Norway, Denmark, something like that that 1457 01:07:13,139 --> 01:07:16,099 is unapologetically creating AI music. 1458 01:07:16,499 --> 01:07:21,539 And so the question becomes, are we looking at purely AI video? 1459 01:07:21,619 --> 01:07:25,899 She's gotten like 2.6 million streams or something ridiculous, 1460 01:07:25,899 --> 01:07:26,259 right? 1461 01:07:26,659 --> 01:07:31,259 Like Taylor Swift numbers on each record that comes out. 1462 01:07:31,739 --> 01:07:36,539 Is that something that we're just going to continue to see over 1463 01:07:36,539 --> 01:07:39,899 and over and over and it becomes indistinguishable and our 1464 01:07:40,219 --> 01:07:43,899 thirst for consuming just stuff. 1465 01:07:43,899 --> 01:07:49,099 I just need to listen to something that we're not even caring 1466 01:07:49,259 --> 01:07:50,459 that this stuff happens. 1467 01:07:50,779 --> 01:07:52,459 Like, I think, yeah. 1468 01:07:52,699 --> 01:07:53,659 Where do you go with that? 1469 01:07:54,059 --> 01:07:57,139 Honestly, that won't change because people have been listening 1470 01:07:57,139 --> 01:07:58,849 to disposable music for a long time. 1471 01:07:58,999 --> 01:08:00,439 Oh, sure, yeah. 1472 01:08:00,439 --> 01:08:04,919 You go into an office at 3:15, it is 2005, and you walk into an 1473 01:08:04,919 --> 01:08:09,039 office at 3:15pm the same fucking song will be playing because 1474 01:08:09,039 --> 01:08:10,919 the radio Station has a schedule, right? 1475 01:08:11,559 --> 01:08:12,119 Okay. 1476 01:08:12,199 --> 01:08:14,199 Now, that might be human, but I'm going to tell you a story, and 1477 01:08:14,199 --> 01:08:15,319 this will give you the answer. 1478 01:08:15,399 --> 01:08:18,999 I want to bring your attention to this cd, happens to be sitting 1479 01:08:18,999 --> 01:08:19,399 next to me. 1480 01:08:19,399 --> 01:08:19,799 All right? 1481 01:08:19,799 --> 01:08:24,379 This is a band from Tokyo called Nikaku. 1482 01:08:25,329 --> 01:08:29,209 And Nikaku is a Prague instrumental band. 1483 01:08:29,209 --> 01:08:31,089 This is bass melting, complicated music. 1484 01:08:31,089 --> 01:08:32,289 Let me tell you a quick story about this. 1485 01:08:32,369 --> 01:08:36,129 So I discovered this on pandora or something 15 years ago. 1486 01:08:36,689 --> 01:08:37,969 And I was like, what? 1487 01:08:38,049 --> 01:08:43,449 And so I looked it up in the 2005 Internet, 2008 Internet, and 1488 01:08:43,449 --> 01:08:46,489 I found who they were, and they had a MySpace page with their 1489 01:08:46,489 --> 01:08:47,089 tracks and all that. 1490 01:08:47,089 --> 01:08:49,649 I was going to say, I fired up Netscape, right? 1491 01:08:49,649 --> 01:08:54,359 And I fired up Netscape and I found the CDD for sale. 1492 01:08:54,359 --> 01:08:56,079 Yeah, I bought it, right? 1493 01:08:56,079 --> 01:08:58,479 And it took, like, I don't know, three weeks to get here from 1494 01:08:58,479 --> 01:08:58,799 Japan. 1495 01:08:58,799 --> 01:09:00,639 And I was very, very, very excited. 1496 01:09:00,639 --> 01:09:04,599 Now, in subsequent moves in the last 10 to 15 years, I lost my 1497 01:09:04,599 --> 01:09:04,999 CD. 1498 01:09:06,199 --> 01:09:07,558 And you might think, what's this? 1499 01:09:07,558 --> 01:09:11,639 Well, every year, roughly in the last 12 years, I have looked 1500 01:09:11,639 --> 01:09:14,119 for this album, but this band has disbanded. 1501 01:09:14,279 --> 01:09:15,519 And the. 1502 01:09:15,519 --> 01:09:15,839 The. 1503 01:09:15,839 --> 01:09:18,419 The guy who ran it all, well, I cannot pronounce his name. 1504 01:09:18,419 --> 01:09:18,939 I'm sorry. 1505 01:09:19,659 --> 01:09:23,739 He had a defunct Facebook page that he hasn't posted in five years. 1506 01:09:23,979 --> 01:09:26,659 And I kept doing searches, and I kept doing searches, just hoping, 1507 01:09:26,659 --> 01:09:28,539 hoping, searching, hoping, hoping, hoping. 1508 01:09:28,699 --> 01:09:31,419 One day, a buddy of mine, and I was talking back and forth, and 1509 01:09:31,419 --> 01:09:34,099 we were talking about Prague music, and I said, man, this nightoku, 1510 01:09:34,099 --> 01:09:36,379 you know, and you go online, you can't find this album anywhere. 1511 01:09:36,379 --> 01:09:38,659 It's not on Spotify, you can't find it on YouTube. 1512 01:09:38,659 --> 01:09:39,779 You can find some live shows. 1513 01:09:39,779 --> 01:09:42,779 But one day I did a search just because I remember, I said, 1514 01:09:42,779 --> 01:09:43,299 what the hell? 1515 01:09:43,299 --> 01:09:44,869 This was in November. 1516 01:09:45,749 --> 01:09:50,669 I did a search, and there was this record was on Discogs, which 1517 01:09:50,669 --> 01:09:52,309 is a reputable website, yo, sure. 1518 01:09:52,549 --> 01:09:56,829 And I was like, long story short, it took five weeks and it 1519 01:09:56,829 --> 01:09:57,989 cost me $65. 1520 01:09:58,629 --> 01:10:06,149 And I bought a CD of a defunct progressive rock band, instrumental, 1521 01:10:06,149 --> 01:10:11,289 started by a bass player and a flute player, because I needed it. 1522 01:10:11,609 --> 01:10:12,169 Yeah. 1523 01:10:12,729 --> 01:10:13,769 And I got it. 1524 01:10:13,769 --> 01:10:17,089 And the first thing I discovered, that this effort and 1525 01:10:17,089 --> 01:10:21,889 this band was so removed from modern technology that when the CD 1526 01:10:21,889 --> 01:10:25,529 came in, it occurred to me, I don't own a CD player anymore. 1527 01:10:28,169 --> 01:10:31,449 So I was like, wait. 1528 01:10:31,929 --> 01:10:35,169 So luckily my shitbox car has a CD in it. 1529 01:10:35,169 --> 01:10:40,169 So this comes with me every run now, and I need to go to Amazon 1530 01:10:40,169 --> 01:10:42,249 and order a stupid CD reader or something. 1531 01:10:42,329 --> 01:10:46,249 But my point is, I'm not like everyone, and I get that. 1532 01:10:46,809 --> 01:10:49,889 But if you're moved by art and you're passionate about art, you 1533 01:10:49,889 --> 01:10:53,849 will get the art and you will appreciate the art, right? 1534 01:10:54,569 --> 01:10:55,969 It means something to you. 1535 01:10:55,969 --> 01:10:58,169 And this band meant something to me because they. 1536 01:10:58,249 --> 01:11:01,009 They pushed the boundaries of what I considered was possible in 1537 01:11:01,009 --> 01:11:03,649 music and the arrangements, the composition and overall mood 1538 01:11:03,649 --> 01:11:03,929 and. 1539 01:11:04,009 --> 01:11:04,649 And all this. 1540 01:11:04,649 --> 01:11:05,649 And by the way, this. 1541 01:11:05,649 --> 01:11:07,009 All this text back here, you see? 1542 01:11:07,009 --> 01:11:07,929 Can you see all that text? 1543 01:11:07,929 --> 01:11:08,769 Yeah, yeah, yeah. 1544 01:11:08,769 --> 01:11:09,089 That's. 1545 01:11:09,089 --> 01:11:09,409 That's. 1546 01:11:09,409 --> 01:11:10,609 That's one song title. 1547 01:11:10,609 --> 01:11:11,769 That's the name of the song. 1548 01:11:12,089 --> 01:11:16,569 So, you know, I like that kind of bizarreness and pushing the boundaries 1549 01:11:16,569 --> 01:11:17,009 of things. 1550 01:11:17,009 --> 01:11:21,449 And so my point is, if this stupid CD took a decade of re hunting 1551 01:11:21,929 --> 01:11:26,729 and $65 in 5 weeks from Tokyo, why is that? 1552 01:11:27,049 --> 01:11:28,209 That because I made it? 1553 01:11:28,209 --> 01:11:30,929 Or is that because there's something about the humans that made 1554 01:11:30,929 --> 01:11:31,849 it that moved me? 1555 01:11:31,929 --> 01:11:32,329 Right? 1556 01:11:32,569 --> 01:11:36,899 Maybe not everybody will spend a decade looking for a $65 CD, but 1557 01:11:36,899 --> 01:11:39,339 somewhere between that and people who don't give a shit about 1558 01:11:39,339 --> 01:11:42,019 what they listen to, there's a lot of us, and there's a lot of people, 1559 01:11:42,019 --> 01:11:42,899 I think, who will. 1560 01:11:43,379 --> 01:11:45,779 Who will continue to make that effort for that human experience. 1561 01:11:45,779 --> 01:11:48,619 That's why live shows are where all musicians make money now. 1562 01:11:48,619 --> 01:11:49,379 End of story. 1563 01:11:49,379 --> 01:11:50,579 They don't sell records. 1564 01:11:50,899 --> 01:11:52,459 Major musicians, you know what I mean? 1565 01:11:52,459 --> 01:11:53,219 Everything is streaming. 1566 01:11:53,219 --> 01:11:54,819 So then interpersonal experience. 1567 01:11:54,819 --> 01:11:57,139 Someone mentioned once, but let me make sure I didn't break one, 1568 01:11:59,219 --> 01:11:59,659 okay? 1569 01:11:59,659 --> 01:12:00,499 No, I think I'm good. 1570 01:12:02,129 --> 01:12:05,009 Someone mentioned the other day, they were talking about a. 1571 01:12:06,129 --> 01:12:06,929 A big band. 1572 01:12:06,929 --> 01:12:07,929 Jazz, Right, Big band. 1573 01:12:07,929 --> 01:12:08,529 You know, like. 1574 01:12:08,529 --> 01:12:09,249 Yeah, big. 1575 01:12:09,649 --> 01:12:10,089 Whatever. 1576 01:12:10,089 --> 01:12:11,169 Count Basie style. 1577 01:12:11,169 --> 01:12:12,329 Sure, exactly. 1578 01:12:12,329 --> 01:12:14,129 And someone said, they're listening to the tracks. 1579 01:12:14,129 --> 01:12:14,849 And they said, cool. 1580 01:12:14,849 --> 01:12:18,609 And this old dude was like, you know what's missing, though, 1581 01:12:18,609 --> 01:12:19,409 if I'm honest? 1582 01:12:19,649 --> 01:12:20,289 What's that? 1583 01:12:20,289 --> 01:12:22,129 He said, you can't. 1584 01:12:22,209 --> 01:12:27,409 You can't feel the sound waves in the air moving from the horns 1585 01:12:28,309 --> 01:12:30,229 in your face when you have that many horns. 1586 01:12:30,229 --> 01:12:31,029 That guy beating the. 1587 01:12:31,029 --> 01:12:33,669 Out of a drum and the bass player slapping the shit out of it 1588 01:12:33,669 --> 01:12:34,989 because he wants to be able to be heard. 1589 01:12:34,989 --> 01:12:39,109 And that physical feeling of the air being moved by the horns 1590 01:12:39,669 --> 01:12:40,709 is part of it. 1591 01:12:41,109 --> 01:12:41,989 And that's true. 1592 01:12:42,069 --> 01:12:43,029 That's so true. 1593 01:12:43,589 --> 01:12:45,509 And not everyone gets to experience that. 1594 01:12:45,589 --> 01:12:47,149 Concerts are loud, sure. 1595 01:12:47,149 --> 01:12:52,069 But that personal element, that physical element, that visceral 1596 01:12:52,069 --> 01:12:54,839 element, you're never gonna be able to take that away from us. 1597 01:12:54,839 --> 01:12:55,399 You can't. 1598 01:12:55,399 --> 01:12:55,959 You know what I mean? 1599 01:12:55,959 --> 01:12:56,519 And yeah, we have. 1600 01:12:56,519 --> 01:12:58,919 We have fake bands, you know, Gorillas comes to mind and things 1601 01:12:58,919 --> 01:12:59,159 like that. 1602 01:12:59,159 --> 01:13:00,559 But those at least have a human. 1603 01:13:00,879 --> 01:13:03,039 But that was more of an art project than anything. 1604 01:13:03,039 --> 01:13:05,279 It was, it was a performance piece is what it was. 1605 01:13:05,439 --> 01:13:06,719 That's still human, right? 1606 01:13:06,719 --> 01:13:09,679 If someone types in a prompt and runs a concert, no one's gonna 1607 01:13:09,679 --> 01:13:09,919 care. 1608 01:13:10,319 --> 01:13:11,279 No one's gonna care. 1609 01:13:11,359 --> 01:13:15,039 You know, I just saw a buddy ofmine on questionable.com. 1610 01:13:15,039 --> 01:13:15,719 he just joined. 1611 01:13:15,719 --> 01:13:19,319 He's a big hip hop head and it's funny that he just joined because 1612 01:13:19,319 --> 01:13:22,439 I was just thinking in the, in the analogies you were making. 1613 01:13:22,999 --> 01:13:26,519 I remember growing up in Boston and I grew up on hip hop. 1614 01:13:26,519 --> 01:13:28,439 I was the white kid down at the park, right? 1615 01:13:28,599 --> 01:13:30,359 I just grew up in this world. 1616 01:13:30,599 --> 01:13:32,479 And I remember going to. 1617 01:13:32,479 --> 01:13:34,199 There was a place in Cambridge, Mass. 1618 01:13:34,199 --> 01:13:37,479 Called the Middle East, a very famous kind of like rock club. 1619 01:13:37,959 --> 01:13:40,519 And they have a lounge downstairs. 1620 01:13:40,919 --> 01:13:44,959 And there was a certain night, it was like Wednesday nights or something 1621 01:13:44,959 --> 01:13:48,029 like that, that they would have live hip hop. 1622 01:13:48,029 --> 01:13:50,029 It was almost like an open mic night, right? 1623 01:13:50,669 --> 01:13:55,789 And I remember rolling in there one night and Guru from Gangstar 1624 01:13:55,789 --> 01:13:57,869 was in there because he was kind of like a Boston dude, right? 1625 01:13:58,189 --> 01:14:03,749 So Guru was in there and drunk, but just rhyming. 1626 01:14:03,749 --> 01:14:06,829 And it was right around the time where Gangstar was really starting 1627 01:14:06,829 --> 01:14:07,389 to blow up. 1628 01:14:07,549 --> 01:14:12,669 Moment of truth had come out and it was just like Gurus at, you 1629 01:14:12,669 --> 01:14:13,849 know, downstairs lodge. 1630 01:14:13,849 --> 01:14:15,369 There were probably like 15 of us, right? 1631 01:14:15,769 --> 01:14:16,649 But it was that. 1632 01:14:16,969 --> 01:14:22,329 It was that feeling of you're there witnessing something that was 1633 01:14:22,409 --> 01:14:25,129 pure to the culture of hip hop. 1634 01:14:25,209 --> 01:14:29,689 You saw freestyles, you had the certain funk in the room, right? 1635 01:14:29,689 --> 01:14:32,569 And there's just like weed smoke everywhere. 1636 01:14:32,569 --> 01:14:38,369 And it was just this wonderful moment that you don't get even listening 1637 01:14:38,369 --> 01:14:43,309 to a gangstar CD or record or streaming or whatnot. 1638 01:14:43,309 --> 01:14:46,349 You don't get that same feeling that you're in the presence 1639 01:14:46,349 --> 01:14:48,989 of something happening, something magical that's not going 1640 01:14:48,989 --> 01:14:49,589 to happen again. 1641 01:14:49,749 --> 01:14:53,109 And I've seen enough Prague rock shows and I've seen enough concerts 1642 01:14:53,109 --> 01:14:58,069 that you just don't get that same feeling, right? 1643 01:14:58,229 --> 01:15:03,389 Even someone like me who DJ'd forever, whether it was scratch DJing 1644 01:15:03,389 --> 01:15:11,009 or electronica, there's nothing like seeing a real DJ, DMC 1645 01:15:11,089 --> 01:15:17,929 style, scratch DJs performing their craft versus a European guy 1646 01:15:17,929 --> 01:15:21,289 dancing, jumping up and down and eventually twisting a fader. 1647 01:15:21,289 --> 01:15:24,769 Because everything is so synced up and pre recorded, it just 1648 01:15:24,769 --> 01:15:26,169 doesn't have the same emotion. 1649 01:15:26,169 --> 01:15:29,129 No matter what the speakers do, no matter what the sphere makes 1650 01:15:29,129 --> 01:15:33,819 you look at, it just doesn't replace that human element that you're 1651 01:15:33,819 --> 01:15:35,099 experiencing. 1652 01:15:35,179 --> 01:15:39,659 Something very rarely Have I listened to a record, vinyl, cd, 1653 01:15:39,899 --> 01:15:43,499 whatever it is, lime wire, download that. 1654 01:15:44,059 --> 01:15:49,299 I felt that same feeling that I got from watching a street performer 1655 01:15:49,299 --> 01:15:50,299 in Harvard Square. 1656 01:15:50,379 --> 01:15:51,579 Right, that's exactly right. 1657 01:15:51,739 --> 01:15:55,219 So when it comes to photography and retouching, and we're 1658 01:15:55,219 --> 01:15:57,659 talking about the humanity of that, this is. 1659 01:15:57,739 --> 01:16:02,199 This is kind of the hill that I die on, is why I asked the question 1660 01:16:02,199 --> 01:16:02,559 earlier. 1661 01:16:02,639 --> 01:16:06,959 Do we just have to wait this out a little bit while people realize, 1662 01:16:07,519 --> 01:16:09,319 yeah, that experience is missing? 1663 01:16:09,319 --> 01:16:13,599 Yeah, I can have the shiny new thing, but I like the dirty old shit 1664 01:16:13,599 --> 01:16:14,839 box car, Right. 1665 01:16:14,839 --> 01:16:19,759 Because I know exactly where to kick it to make it stop, you know, 1666 01:16:20,159 --> 01:16:21,439 cranking or whatever. 1667 01:16:21,839 --> 01:16:26,959 So, yeah, it's that experiential thing that is irreplaceable. 1668 01:16:27,759 --> 01:16:32,039 And I'd love to hear more photographers talking about that 1669 01:16:32,039 --> 01:16:32,399 experience. 1670 01:16:33,199 --> 01:16:37,159 Outside of the platitudes of, oh, you're on a journey and you're 1671 01:16:37,159 --> 01:16:39,839 gonna get this great experience, like truly the experience 1672 01:16:39,919 --> 01:16:43,199 of understanding what it's like and goes into the craft of photography. 1673 01:16:43,519 --> 01:16:45,839 I think that might be the thing that saves us. 1674 01:16:45,839 --> 01:16:47,239 And retouching. 1675 01:16:47,239 --> 01:16:47,599 Right. 1676 01:16:47,839 --> 01:16:50,999 So it's not about just moving sliders, it's about understanding 1677 01:16:50,999 --> 01:16:54,319 what you're looking at and how do you draw more out? 1678 01:16:54,779 --> 01:16:58,299 How do you draw more or direct the viewer's eye where you want to 1679 01:16:58,299 --> 01:16:58,539 go. 1680 01:16:59,099 --> 01:16:59,499 Right. 1681 01:16:59,499 --> 01:17:03,939 I think, I think that teaching people, again, normies, teaching 1682 01:17:03,939 --> 01:17:07,779 them what art is, it's not something that hasn't been going 1683 01:17:07,779 --> 01:17:08,339 on for decades. 1684 01:17:08,339 --> 01:17:09,739 It has been going on for decades. 1685 01:17:09,739 --> 01:17:10,059 Right. 1686 01:17:10,939 --> 01:17:14,299 Whether it's performance, I always like Warhol. 1687 01:17:14,539 --> 01:17:16,059 Warhol is brilliant for performance. 1688 01:17:17,099 --> 01:17:20,139 Warhol basically is like, I'm going to make these things and you're 1689 01:17:20,139 --> 01:17:21,979 going to buy them for a lot of money because I'm me. 1690 01:17:22,639 --> 01:17:28,719 The performance is him fucking you, and the performance is his presence. 1691 01:17:28,719 --> 01:17:33,559 The performance is Warhol basically said, I'm gonna exploit 1692 01:17:33,559 --> 01:17:35,439 everything and you're gonna love me for it. 1693 01:17:35,439 --> 01:17:37,599 And I mean, is there another one like him, really? 1694 01:17:37,599 --> 01:17:38,238 Not really. 1695 01:17:38,479 --> 01:17:40,079 And so that's fine. 1696 01:17:40,079 --> 01:17:41,239 That's how Warhol did it. 1697 01:17:41,239 --> 01:17:42,559 He chose to be notorious. 1698 01:17:42,639 --> 01:17:44,719 Okay, well, I don't wanna be notorious. 1699 01:17:44,719 --> 01:17:45,959 I'd rather be beloved. 1700 01:17:45,959 --> 01:17:47,359 And that's kind of what I go for. 1701 01:17:47,679 --> 01:17:49,199 So authenticity is my. 1702 01:17:49,679 --> 01:17:50,199 My focus. 1703 01:17:50,199 --> 01:17:53,319 You know, if it's not authentic, it doesn't sit well with 1704 01:17:53,319 --> 01:17:53,559 me. 1705 01:17:53,559 --> 01:17:54,759 That's my line in the sand. 1706 01:17:54,759 --> 01:17:55,159 That's. 1707 01:17:55,159 --> 01:17:55,999 That's my line in the sand. 1708 01:17:55,999 --> 01:17:56,599 It's not authentic. 1709 01:17:56,599 --> 01:18:00,399 And of course, I have a threshold because someone could argue 1710 01:18:00,959 --> 01:18:03,439 that it's not authentic to modify photo at all. 1711 01:18:04,159 --> 01:18:07,599 And then my Counter is it's not authentic to even take the photo. 1712 01:18:07,679 --> 01:18:11,119 At what point do we take a human experience to the base level, 1713 01:18:11,599 --> 01:18:14,519 sort of simian level experience of only interacting in 1714 01:18:14,519 --> 01:18:14,799 person? 1715 01:18:15,039 --> 01:18:17,839 We can take a photo that's technology that didn't used to exist, 1716 01:18:17,839 --> 01:18:18,159 right? 1717 01:18:18,159 --> 01:18:19,359 We can modify the photo. 1718 01:18:19,439 --> 01:18:19,699 We. 1719 01:18:20,249 --> 01:18:21,129 Everyone has a different. 1720 01:18:21,129 --> 01:18:22,769 A different threshold is what I'm. 1721 01:18:22,769 --> 01:18:23,449 What I'm saying. 1722 01:18:23,529 --> 01:18:23,929 So. 1723 01:18:27,129 --> 01:18:31,289 I think about that threshold. 1724 01:18:32,089 --> 01:18:37,249 What makes art art, what makes people gravitate towards a certain 1725 01:18:37,249 --> 01:18:40,409 artist, or what makes people dismiss a certain artist. 1726 01:18:40,729 --> 01:18:43,049 And I don't think we can get caught up in that. 1727 01:18:43,609 --> 01:18:48,859 You mentioned a moment ago about, you know, not retouching, 1728 01:18:48,859 --> 01:18:49,219 right? 1729 01:18:49,219 --> 01:18:49,579 And. 1730 01:18:49,579 --> 01:18:51,299 And I. I split my. 1731 01:18:52,019 --> 01:18:56,259 My photography in the studio down the middle, where I have my 1732 01:18:56,259 --> 01:18:57,379 unfiltered stuff. 1733 01:18:57,779 --> 01:18:59,659 You can choose an unfiltered session. 1734 01:18:59,659 --> 01:19:03,179 You're getting all black and white, you're getting no retouching 1735 01:19:03,179 --> 01:19:03,739 whatsoever. 1736 01:19:03,739 --> 01:19:06,419 And you walk out the door with digital images. 1737 01:19:06,499 --> 01:19:09,179 But I'm giving you a printed book because I. 1738 01:19:09,179 --> 01:19:12,619 You're going to get the prints of this because I want that to be 1739 01:19:12,619 --> 01:19:13,379 part of the experience. 1740 01:19:13,459 --> 01:19:14,739 You want something physical. 1741 01:19:15,459 --> 01:19:15,939 The other side. 1742 01:19:15,939 --> 01:19:17,579 I do a lot of personal branding and headshots. 1743 01:19:17,579 --> 01:19:20,259 When people come in, you know, you kind of get to know them. 1744 01:19:20,499 --> 01:19:21,819 Turn this way, turn that way. 1745 01:19:21,819 --> 01:19:22,819 Snap, done, right? 1746 01:19:23,139 --> 01:19:29,059 And it's fine for what it is, but I then have to go in and retouch. 1747 01:19:29,299 --> 01:19:31,619 And I'm still someone that's kind of old school. 1748 01:19:31,619 --> 01:19:34,379 I'm using a Voto, but I have no problem going back to just doing 1749 01:19:34,379 --> 01:19:36,419 the old school, you know, retouching. 1750 01:19:37,539 --> 01:19:41,299 I think we put a lot of emphasis on that. 1751 01:19:41,969 --> 01:19:47,889 I think we have to be the stewards of almost explaining to 1752 01:19:47,889 --> 01:19:53,169 people why I'm doing the things that I'm doing in the way 1753 01:19:53,169 --> 01:19:54,129 that I'm doing them. 1754 01:19:54,289 --> 01:19:58,089 And it's not necessarily a fast process and it's certainly not 1755 01:19:58,089 --> 01:20:02,169 a cheap process because there is this craft, right? 1756 01:20:02,169 --> 01:20:04,289 We go back to the Corinthian leather, right? 1757 01:20:04,849 --> 01:20:08,529 I want to sit there with my needle and thread and I want to sew 1758 01:20:08,529 --> 01:20:10,539 you a picture, right? 1759 01:20:10,779 --> 01:20:12,859 And it's because I enjoy it. 1760 01:20:12,859 --> 01:20:17,979 And I believe that the end product, you are going to have a 1761 01:20:18,059 --> 01:20:21,219 deeper connection when you see it on your wall, when you look at 1762 01:20:21,219 --> 01:20:25,818 it on your phone when you die and your wife uses it at the funeral 1763 01:20:25,819 --> 01:20:30,179 home, there's going to be a deeper connection to that image than 1764 01:20:30,179 --> 01:20:32,619 there would be otherwise. 1765 01:20:33,179 --> 01:20:38,759 And it behooves us to explain that to the people that we're working 1766 01:20:38,759 --> 01:20:41,879 with, whether it's commercial real estate Headshots. 1767 01:20:42,599 --> 01:20:45,759 I think if we're drawing the line in the sand that we are either 1768 01:20:45,759 --> 01:20:50,839 anti AI or this was AI with an asterisk. 1769 01:20:51,159 --> 01:20:51,479 Right. 1770 01:20:51,479 --> 01:20:54,599 I use it as a tool to make it more efficient and pass the value 1771 01:20:54,599 --> 01:20:56,039 on to you, the consumer. 1772 01:20:56,679 --> 01:20:57,959 I'm okay with that. 1773 01:20:58,599 --> 01:21:03,599 But if we don't step up and actually explain some of this, then 1774 01:21:03,839 --> 01:21:07,119 we're the ones that are causing our own demise. 1775 01:21:07,519 --> 01:21:10,519 We are devaluing what it is that we do. 1776 01:21:10,519 --> 01:21:14,799 We're letting the market dictate our value for us rather than 1777 01:21:14,799 --> 01:21:18,479 us standing up and saying, no, this isn't how it is. 1778 01:21:19,119 --> 01:21:19,599 Yeah. 1779 01:21:19,919 --> 01:21:21,039 What are your thoughts there? 1780 01:21:21,679 --> 01:21:22,639 Well, I think I can. 1781 01:21:22,719 --> 01:21:23,799 We have to teach, right? 1782 01:21:23,799 --> 01:21:25,119 We have to teach the audiences. 1783 01:21:25,119 --> 01:21:29,369 And this is why historically, in any art, extreme skill gets the 1784 01:21:29,369 --> 01:21:29,689 attention. 1785 01:21:29,689 --> 01:21:29,889 Right? 1786 01:21:29,889 --> 01:21:33,209 With the power singers, the shredder guitarists, the people jumping 1787 01:21:33,209 --> 01:21:33,689 off cliffs. 1788 01:21:33,689 --> 01:21:38,089 And extreme skill gets attention because people can immediately 1789 01:21:38,089 --> 01:21:40,729 relate to that and say, I can't do that. 1790 01:21:41,369 --> 01:21:41,769 Right. 1791 01:21:42,009 --> 01:21:46,609 You know, and so therefore, there's a huge separation and ipso 1792 01:21:46,609 --> 01:21:47,929 facto, they are impressed. 1793 01:21:48,009 --> 01:21:52,009 Yeah, but are we always going for impressing or are we trying to 1794 01:21:52,569 --> 01:21:54,569 make some other kind of impact to them? 1795 01:21:54,649 --> 01:21:57,009 Are we trying to make some kind of emotional impact in some 1796 01:21:57,009 --> 01:21:57,409 manner? 1797 01:21:57,409 --> 01:21:59,259 Again, it doesn't have to be profound. 1798 01:21:59,259 --> 01:21:59,939 It can be. 1799 01:22:00,019 --> 01:22:02,099 We don't all have to be raised against the machine. 1800 01:22:02,099 --> 01:22:04,979 Sometimes we can just be Ed Sheeran, you know what I mean? 1801 01:22:06,099 --> 01:22:08,019 As long as we're impacting people. 1802 01:22:10,099 --> 01:22:11,779 But are we trying to impress? 1803 01:22:11,779 --> 01:22:13,819 Now we're in a social media economy socially. 1804 01:22:13,819 --> 01:22:14,099 Right. 1805 01:22:14,099 --> 01:22:16,499 So culturally, that's what we're in, and we have been for a 1806 01:22:16,499 --> 01:22:18,739 while, and I think we might be on the way out, but that's another 1807 01:22:18,739 --> 01:22:19,299 discussion. 1808 01:22:19,859 --> 01:22:22,939 We're used to the likes, we're used to the virality, we're used 1809 01:22:22,939 --> 01:22:24,659 to the shares, and we still. 1810 01:22:25,159 --> 01:22:26,439 But it's still dominated by that. 1811 01:22:26,439 --> 01:22:30,519 So impressive is the metric that gets the most attention. 1812 01:22:30,599 --> 01:22:34,639 Yeah, but that's why we have the singing shows and the Voice and 1813 01:22:34,639 --> 01:22:35,199 the other ones. 1814 01:22:35,199 --> 01:22:38,359 And there's some amazing talent on there, don't get me wrong. 1815 01:22:38,519 --> 01:22:42,479 But while someone is there belting out, you know, Irene Cara 1816 01:22:42,479 --> 01:22:44,039 or something, covering, they're killing it. 1817 01:22:44,039 --> 01:22:47,679 And Amy is like, I'm thinking, are you guys hearing that studio 1818 01:22:47,679 --> 01:22:48,359 band back there? 1819 01:22:48,599 --> 01:22:49,799 Those guys are amazing. 1820 01:22:52,689 --> 01:22:53,809 But I wouldn't care. 1821 01:22:53,809 --> 01:22:55,089 You know, the funny thing is, you're right. 1822 01:22:55,089 --> 01:22:55,809 No one cares. 1823 01:22:55,889 --> 01:23:00,049 But I love, you know, this is why I love my own autism, because 1824 01:23:00,049 --> 01:23:03,289 I'm like, did you just hear the fill that that drummer put in? 1825 01:23:03,289 --> 01:23:07,009 Because, you know, he's bored as hell, and he's just gonna rip. 1826 01:23:07,009 --> 01:23:09,129 Or the bassist just does something funky. 1827 01:23:09,129 --> 01:23:09,569 You're like. 1828 01:23:10,049 --> 01:23:11,569 You make that funky face. 1829 01:23:11,569 --> 01:23:16,329 You know, I. I love that aspect of when you're in tune to 1830 01:23:16,329 --> 01:23:18,329 whatever your hobby is, whatever you pay attention to. 1831 01:23:18,329 --> 01:23:18,489 Right. 1832 01:23:18,489 --> 01:23:20,419 You're gonna see more of it, of course. 1833 01:23:20,649 --> 01:23:22,089 And I like finding those little moments. 1834 01:23:22,089 --> 01:23:22,769 All right, one more. 1835 01:23:22,769 --> 01:23:24,169 One more comment while we're here. 1836 01:23:24,969 --> 01:23:26,089 Unquestionable dot com. 1837 01:23:26,089 --> 01:23:27,369 We're talking about hip hop. 1838 01:23:27,449 --> 01:23:29,849 One of my favorite local artists here In Foger, North Dakota, 1839 01:23:29,849 --> 01:23:30,649 is Duro. 1840 01:23:30,649 --> 01:23:34,449 He has an album entitled 98 Warhol, and it's one of the most 1841 01:23:34,449 --> 01:23:37,009 creative artists I know, shockingly. 1842 01:23:37,009 --> 01:23:37,369 Right. 1843 01:23:37,689 --> 01:23:39,289 So that just. 1844 01:23:39,369 --> 01:23:41,609 I thought that was great tagging on to the. 1845 01:23:42,569 --> 01:23:44,529 Tagging on to that Warhol conversation. 1846 01:23:44,529 --> 01:23:47,119 But, you know, it's funny you were mentioning that. 1847 01:23:47,119 --> 01:23:47,599 You know, you were. 1848 01:23:47,599 --> 01:23:47,839 You were. 1849 01:23:47,839 --> 01:23:48,279 You're big. 1850 01:23:48,279 --> 01:23:50,559 You grew up on hip hop back in the day, you know, 30 years ago, 1851 01:23:50,559 --> 01:23:50,839 not. 1852 01:23:50,839 --> 01:23:51,319 Not 40. 1853 01:23:51,319 --> 01:23:52,439 We're not talking about a long time. 1854 01:23:53,879 --> 01:23:55,919 Anyway, I was at the gym with my kid. 1855 01:23:55,919 --> 01:23:58,359 Right now, these TVs that always play and we always joke about 1856 01:23:58,359 --> 01:24:02,359 all they do is stream sort of popular hip hop right now. 1857 01:24:02,359 --> 01:24:04,799 And there's some in the mix that's not bad, but for the most 1858 01:24:04,799 --> 01:24:06,119 part, it's all pretty formulaic. 1859 01:24:06,119 --> 01:24:07,959 And it's like any popular music, right? 1860 01:24:07,959 --> 01:24:08,439 Yeah. 1861 01:24:08,439 --> 01:24:11,159 So the other day we went in there, and it was nothing but, like, 1862 01:24:11,159 --> 01:24:12,999 a real EDM pop. 1863 01:24:13,489 --> 01:24:16,209 Just the whole damn afternoon, I didn't know any of the artists, 1864 01:24:16,209 --> 01:24:16,849 but my kid. 1865 01:24:16,849 --> 01:24:17,409 And I look at you. 1866 01:24:17,409 --> 01:24:18,729 I was like, well, at least it's a vibe. 1867 01:24:18,729 --> 01:24:19,089 Right? 1868 01:24:19,089 --> 01:24:19,489 Right. 1869 01:24:19,489 --> 01:24:23,969 I don't know where Tribe Called Quest drops scenario. 1870 01:24:24,369 --> 01:24:25,089 And I'm like. 1871 01:24:26,209 --> 01:24:29,089 So I'm, like, flowing along with every bar, and my kid's, like, 1872 01:24:29,329 --> 01:24:30,209 looking at him. 1873 01:24:30,369 --> 01:24:31,889 And then I'm just. 1874 01:24:32,049 --> 01:24:32,569 I'm like. 1875 01:24:32,569 --> 01:24:35,329 I'm thrilled because Jim never plays anything I give a about. 1876 01:24:35,409 --> 01:24:37,089 And then suddenly it's over. 1877 01:24:37,409 --> 01:24:41,239 It's right back to a 300 pop for another 30 minutes. 1878 01:24:41,239 --> 01:24:43,559 And I was like, all right, we did that. 1879 01:24:43,719 --> 01:24:44,199 Yeah. 1880 01:24:44,519 --> 01:24:47,439 There was definitely a worker there trying at this and hijacked 1881 01:24:47,439 --> 01:24:48,999 the playlist for a second, for sure. 1882 01:24:49,079 --> 01:24:49,399 Right. 1883 01:24:49,399 --> 01:24:50,279 Right in the video. 1884 01:24:50,279 --> 01:24:51,319 I don't know if you remember the video. 1885 01:24:51,399 --> 01:24:51,879 Oh, yeah. 1886 01:24:51,879 --> 01:24:52,519 But it's very. 1887 01:24:52,599 --> 01:24:53,399 It's interesting. 1888 01:24:53,639 --> 01:24:54,239 It was fun. 1889 01:24:54,239 --> 01:24:55,079 My kid was like. 1890 01:24:55,079 --> 01:24:57,319 And I was like, oh, that's so trippy. 1891 01:24:57,319 --> 01:24:57,799 So I. 1892 01:24:59,159 --> 01:25:03,439 In hearing that song in the context of this place that normally 1893 01:25:03,439 --> 01:25:07,049 plays modern stuff, it really stuck out. 1894 01:25:07,129 --> 01:25:10,249 And that goes right back to the cd. 1895 01:25:10,889 --> 01:25:15,529 That moment of Tribe turning on in the gym was a moment I'll remember 1896 01:25:15,529 --> 01:25:18,409 for a long time because of course it was with the opposite of 1897 01:25:18,409 --> 01:25:19,049 what's normally played. 1898 01:25:19,049 --> 01:25:20,889 It's, you know, you don't usually hear old school hip hop there, 1899 01:25:20,889 --> 01:25:21,569 blah, blah, blah. 1900 01:25:21,569 --> 01:25:24,649 I had a moment with my kid telling him about Tribe again because 1901 01:25:24,649 --> 01:25:28,169 I have speech to him about it before and, and those are the moments, 1902 01:25:28,169 --> 01:25:29,529 those are the real moments. 1903 01:25:29,769 --> 01:25:33,659 And why wouldn't the gym just funnel a bunch of AI music? 1904 01:25:33,659 --> 01:25:34,739 It's just background. 1905 01:25:34,819 --> 01:25:36,019 Why wouldn't they, Right. 1906 01:25:37,459 --> 01:25:38,259 Say they won't. 1907 01:25:38,579 --> 01:25:41,779 The music discussion is fascinating to me and I know we kind 1908 01:25:41,779 --> 01:25:43,779 of gotten this a while ago, we stuck with it. 1909 01:25:43,779 --> 01:25:47,859 But I have down in my living room, I don't know, probably thousand 1910 01:25:47,859 --> 01:25:48,619 vinyl records. 1911 01:25:48,619 --> 01:25:50,739 And it was like it's a fraction of what I used to have when 1912 01:25:50,739 --> 01:25:51,459 I was DJing. 1913 01:25:51,699 --> 01:25:54,379 But I was going through it last night because there's this poster 1914 01:25:54,379 --> 01:25:58,919 behind me that I just kind of want to put in a different area in 1915 01:25:58,919 --> 01:25:59,319 my house. 1916 01:25:59,719 --> 01:26:03,359 And so I've got a bunch of record frames and going to put some 1917 01:26:03,359 --> 01:26:05,159 records up and, and put them back here. 1918 01:26:05,879 --> 01:26:10,359 And so I'm going through because I knew after DJing for so 1919 01:26:10,359 --> 01:26:11,559 many years, you don't. 1920 01:26:11,959 --> 01:26:16,079 As you're flipping through your, your crate of vinyl, you know 1921 01:26:16,079 --> 01:26:17,079 the labels, right? 1922 01:26:17,079 --> 01:26:18,879 You know exactly which label it is. 1923 01:26:18,879 --> 01:26:20,039 You don't have to think about it. 1924 01:26:20,039 --> 01:26:22,199 You just get the label, you throw it on the turntable, you're 1925 01:26:22,199 --> 01:26:22,439 done. 1926 01:26:23,159 --> 01:26:28,409 But I remember a lot of album covers that most Deaf Tribe Called 1927 01:26:28,409 --> 01:26:29,209 Quest, right? 1928 01:26:29,369 --> 01:26:32,009 There's Dark side of the Moon, right. 1929 01:26:32,009 --> 01:26:33,289 Legendary album cover. 1930 01:26:33,769 --> 01:26:35,329 Asia from Steely Dan. 1931 01:26:35,329 --> 01:26:35,689 Right. 1932 01:26:35,849 --> 01:26:39,809 So I'm going through all these records and I'm like, I want to put 1933 01:26:39,809 --> 01:26:45,129 something back here that not only represents me but also represents 1934 01:26:45,129 --> 01:26:47,769 the experiences that I've had in life. 1935 01:26:48,089 --> 01:26:49,929 And I don't think that. 1936 01:26:50,409 --> 01:26:56,499 And I was saying it's not that I'm playing the music here, it's 1937 01:26:56,499 --> 01:27:01,459 that I'm using the artwork that meant something to me and it 1938 01:27:01,459 --> 01:27:05,539 gave me this kind of renewed hope in what it is that we do. 1939 01:27:05,779 --> 01:27:06,179 Right. 1940 01:27:06,739 --> 01:27:12,979 And, and about it being longer lasting and impactful. 1941 01:27:13,059 --> 01:27:13,339 Right. 1942 01:27:13,339 --> 01:27:14,579 You get a Notorious B.I.G. 1943 01:27:14,819 --> 01:27:18,259 the ready to Die album cover is iconic. 1944 01:27:20,779 --> 01:27:24,059 Herbie Hancock's headhunters, iconic mountain cover. 1945 01:27:24,059 --> 01:27:24,339 Right. 1946 01:27:24,339 --> 01:27:25,099 Legendary cover. 1947 01:27:25,339 --> 01:27:29,139 So these are the things that I look and I could put on the wall 1948 01:27:29,139 --> 01:27:30,859 and have a conversation about. 1949 01:27:31,259 --> 01:27:31,659 Yeah. 1950 01:27:31,659 --> 01:27:36,779 And I liken that to the types of photography that we do and the 1951 01:27:36,779 --> 01:27:39,859 printed product and the end product, whether it's a Magazine, 1952 01:27:39,859 --> 01:27:43,979 whether it's a piece on the wall, is that it invites not only 1953 01:27:43,979 --> 01:27:49,419 a story about the subject, but it invites a story about the artist. 1954 01:27:49,579 --> 01:27:52,459 I don't know the photographers or the graphic designers that did 1955 01:27:52,459 --> 01:27:55,979 most of those album covers, but some of them, when you dig into 1956 01:27:55,979 --> 01:28:00,139 it, have the most amazing stories about how they got that shot 1957 01:28:00,139 --> 01:28:03,579 or why they developed things the way they develop how much acid 1958 01:28:03,579 --> 01:28:05,579 they were on when they were thinking about the concepts. 1959 01:28:05,579 --> 01:28:09,019 Whatever it was, there's something there that invites more 1960 01:28:09,019 --> 01:28:09,739 discussion. 1961 01:28:10,379 --> 01:28:17,219 When it comes to AI, there is nothing outside of divisive conversation. 1962 01:28:17,779 --> 01:28:18,179 Right? 1963 01:28:18,259 --> 01:28:19,779 It just devolves into. 1964 01:28:20,099 --> 01:28:22,339 That's the avatar that we're using to fight. 1965 01:28:22,819 --> 01:28:28,339 Instead of discussing the concept, discussing the artist, discussing 1966 01:28:28,339 --> 01:28:29,699 the reasoning behind it. 1967 01:28:29,779 --> 01:28:31,539 Why are you naked in that photo? 1968 01:28:31,619 --> 01:28:37,139 You know, like, whatever it might be, I want art to foster that 1969 01:28:37,139 --> 01:28:37,619 discussion. 1970 01:28:38,129 --> 01:28:42,969 And I don't think that anything AI is fostering a discussion 1971 01:28:42,969 --> 01:28:45,409 that is positive. 1972 01:28:45,809 --> 01:28:49,809 It's always like, ugh, there's the slop, or that's not real, or 1973 01:28:49,809 --> 01:28:52,449 they couldn't have gotten somebody real for that. 1974 01:28:52,689 --> 01:28:53,569 You know what I mean? 1975 01:28:53,888 --> 01:29:00,289 So I think therein lies one of these little pieces that we can talk 1976 01:29:00,289 --> 01:29:03,409 about about the longevity, about the. 1977 01:29:04,449 --> 01:29:10,369 The sudden experiential memory that we have about where we were 1978 01:29:10,449 --> 01:29:12,849 when we heard Scenario for the first time. 1979 01:29:12,929 --> 01:29:16,969 And Busta Rhymes goes off on some other level of hip hop that 1980 01:29:16,969 --> 01:29:18,169 no one's ever heard before. 1981 01:29:18,169 --> 01:29:20,209 And there's a dungeon dragon in there, right? 1982 01:29:20,209 --> 01:29:21,249 Dungeon dragon. 1983 01:29:21,249 --> 01:29:28,529 And so I think, you know, as we look to other art forms to influence 1984 01:29:28,849 --> 01:29:34,509 perhaps how we navigate this space, music is, I think, the closest 1985 01:29:34,509 --> 01:29:37,709 parallel that I have, even beyond painting, because the visual 1986 01:29:37,709 --> 01:29:42,869 art there, music has always had the visual and the auditory element 1987 01:29:42,869 --> 01:29:48,309 to it that I just find, you know, I just find to be so much stronger. 1988 01:29:48,469 --> 01:29:51,869 So I'm looking there and kind of watching, you know, and I think. 1989 01:29:51,869 --> 01:29:54,349 I think that the story element that we're talking about, like you 1990 01:29:54,349 --> 01:29:56,899 mentioned some album covers, you don't know the history of the. 1991 01:29:56,899 --> 01:29:58,219 Who made it or why or when. 1992 01:29:58,539 --> 01:30:02,539 The story element is there, whether you know the story or not. 1993 01:30:02,699 --> 01:30:03,339 Totally. 1994 01:30:03,579 --> 01:30:04,939 And that's fascinating. 1995 01:30:05,019 --> 01:30:07,819 In fact, looking at album covers and sitting with the. 1996 01:30:07,819 --> 01:30:09,259 With the liner notes, and this is. 1997 01:30:10,219 --> 01:30:12,299 We're not old enough to remember doing this, of course, but. 1998 01:30:12,299 --> 01:30:14,459 No, no, no, absolutely not. 1999 01:30:15,579 --> 01:30:19,419 Because our high school was late 90s or early 2001 anyway. 2000 01:30:20,379 --> 01:30:23,779 So my point is, when you look at this, anything at all, and like. 2001 01:30:23,779 --> 01:30:27,059 Like this image here, the Naikaku did not use AI for I. I've 2002 01:30:27,059 --> 01:30:27,939 looked at it multiple times. 2003 01:30:27,939 --> 01:30:30,419 It's kind of grainy and it's someone laying on the ground, and 2004 01:30:30,419 --> 01:30:32,499 I'm not sure why they're laying on the ground, but I've looked 2005 01:30:32,499 --> 01:30:35,859 at it a lot and it reminds me of looking at old album covers. 2006 01:30:36,259 --> 01:30:38,659 I don't know the story and it's likely I never will. 2007 01:30:38,818 --> 01:30:41,459 But there is one, and that's fascinating. 2008 01:30:41,539 --> 01:30:44,259 And that's because there's a human again, that experiential element. 2009 01:30:44,499 --> 01:30:45,379 Someone did it. 2010 01:30:45,539 --> 01:30:46,979 There was a reason behind it. 2011 01:30:47,299 --> 01:30:47,899 Who did it? 2012 01:30:47,899 --> 01:30:48,139 Why? 2013 01:30:48,139 --> 01:30:50,649 I. I don't know, but somebody did. 2014 01:30:50,729 --> 01:30:52,729 As opposed to AI made this. 2015 01:30:52,729 --> 01:30:56,249 Like for example, the graphic you put up earlier when you started 2016 01:30:56,249 --> 01:30:59,449 this conversation with me about AI and Ritucci, that was created 2017 01:30:59,449 --> 01:31:01,649 by AI you can tell it was created by AI. 2018 01:31:01,649 --> 01:31:01,929 Right. 2019 01:31:02,089 --> 01:31:02,649 Let me get to. 2020 01:31:04,688 --> 01:31:05,449 Has that feel to it. 2021 01:31:05,449 --> 01:31:05,689 Right. 2022 01:31:05,929 --> 01:31:08,649 And I could recognize that immediately already. 2023 01:31:09,209 --> 01:31:12,729 And that image will disappear after this conversation and if it's 2024 01:31:12,729 --> 01:31:14,649 never used again, no one will care. 2025 01:31:15,119 --> 01:31:16,559 That was the purpose of it, though. 2026 01:31:16,559 --> 01:31:19,199 It was a quick visual to illustrate. 2027 01:31:19,199 --> 01:31:22,559 It's no different than another title graphic in any TV broadcast. 2028 01:31:22,719 --> 01:31:24,679 So in that regard, sweet. 2029 01:31:24,679 --> 01:31:26,759 You didn't slave over an hour making that piece. 2030 01:31:26,759 --> 01:31:28,039 You knocked it out in minutes. 2031 01:31:28,039 --> 01:31:28,399 Right. 2032 01:31:28,559 --> 01:31:29,839 So in that regard, it's fine. 2033 01:31:29,839 --> 01:31:31,719 But if you're going to make actual art that you want someone 2034 01:31:31,719 --> 01:31:34,479 to remember, you want someone to track down your CD a decade later, 2035 01:31:35,759 --> 01:31:37,599 it's got to come from you, it's got to come from people. 2036 01:31:38,079 --> 01:31:38,959 And that's what I mean. 2037 01:31:38,959 --> 01:31:41,119 You know, this music is not socially profound. 2038 01:31:41,119 --> 01:31:43,079 First of all, there's no lyrics, so you can interpret however 2039 01:31:43,079 --> 01:31:43,519 you want. 2040 01:31:43,599 --> 01:31:47,779 And second of all, it is very inaccessible and complicated and 2041 01:31:47,779 --> 01:31:49,419 it's not ever going to be popular. 2042 01:31:49,419 --> 01:31:53,859 But for me, it meant the world and it made me move mountains and 2043 01:31:53,859 --> 01:31:55,939 spend copious amounts of money for ancient technology. 2044 01:31:56,339 --> 01:31:56,739 Right. 2045 01:31:57,059 --> 01:32:00,619 That means something that's powerful and you can be that as long 2046 01:32:00,619 --> 01:32:02,019 as you don't compromise yourself. 2047 01:32:02,179 --> 01:32:06,739 Someone will think about that photo you took in 2017 and talk about 2048 01:32:06,739 --> 01:32:08,099 it in 2036. 2049 01:32:08,259 --> 01:32:08,739 Yeah. 2050 01:32:09,139 --> 01:32:11,919 And you can tell them the story and you can tell them why that 2051 01:32:11,919 --> 01:32:12,359 happened. 2052 01:32:12,519 --> 01:32:13,199 I have image. 2053 01:32:13,199 --> 01:32:14,599 I have an image of a girl that I found. 2054 01:32:14,599 --> 01:32:17,159 I was looking through a hard drive the other day and I looked 2055 01:32:17,159 --> 01:32:21,559 at the image and I go, I remember her in Ohio. 2056 01:32:22,199 --> 01:32:24,079 What happened? 2057 01:32:24,079 --> 01:32:26,718 Oh, I shot her on Saturday. 2058 01:32:26,718 --> 01:32:27,719 She was dead on Monday. 2059 01:32:30,039 --> 01:32:31,719 And there's a memory. 2060 01:32:31,799 --> 01:32:32,279 Yeah. 2061 01:32:32,279 --> 01:32:34,359 A dark one, a profound one. 2062 01:32:34,999 --> 01:32:35,399 Right. 2063 01:32:35,639 --> 01:32:36,199 Still, a. 2064 01:32:36,979 --> 01:32:39,419 That photo now has that memory. 2065 01:32:39,419 --> 01:32:41,019 I don't have any emotional connection to her. 2066 01:32:41,019 --> 01:32:43,139 It was a Workshop model that I met for a couple hours. 2067 01:32:43,299 --> 01:32:45,619 So I don't miss her, because I can't. 2068 01:32:45,619 --> 01:32:46,419 I don't know her. 2069 01:32:46,579 --> 01:32:49,139 But there's a story there that is a dark story. 2070 01:32:49,139 --> 01:32:49,899 And we love. 2071 01:32:49,899 --> 01:32:53,979 We love drama, we love death, we love, you know, we love explosions, 2072 01:32:53,979 --> 01:32:56,659 we love war, we love all the pathos of life. 2073 01:32:56,739 --> 01:33:00,299 Those are easy to call the human experience, but there's subtle 2074 01:33:00,299 --> 01:33:01,859 things too, and we. 2075 01:33:01,859 --> 01:33:04,639 We need to not lose sight of that, because it matters. 2076 01:33:04,879 --> 01:33:07,039 Every little thing that you do matters. 2077 01:33:07,359 --> 01:33:09,039 And it's just, you know, modern. 2078 01:33:09,039 --> 01:33:09,599 Like I said, this. 2079 01:33:09,599 --> 01:33:13,479 This economy, this cultural economy that we're in, of disposable 2080 01:33:13,479 --> 01:33:16,839 content that we've been in for a while, likes to make you believe 2081 01:33:16,839 --> 01:33:20,879 that those little things don't matter and that they do, they always 2082 01:33:20,879 --> 01:33:21,279 will. 2083 01:33:21,439 --> 01:33:22,879 And we are going to level out. 2084 01:33:22,879 --> 01:33:25,679 But are you going to be part of the casualties when it levels 2085 01:33:25,679 --> 01:33:27,039 out, or are you going to be on top? 2086 01:33:27,439 --> 01:33:31,009 And I think just remaining authentic to yourself is at least 2087 01:33:31,009 --> 01:33:32,009 the best chance you have. 2088 01:33:32,329 --> 01:33:34,849 You know, if your work is shit, I don't know what to tell you 2089 01:33:34,849 --> 01:33:35,049 there. 2090 01:33:35,049 --> 01:33:38,249 But if you stay authentic, at least you give yourself a chance. 2091 01:33:38,329 --> 01:33:38,889 That's. 2092 01:33:39,129 --> 01:33:40,089 That's how I see it. 2093 01:33:40,089 --> 01:33:40,569 And that's. 2094 01:33:40,569 --> 01:33:42,689 That's how I'm moving forward with myself. 2095 01:33:42,689 --> 01:33:49,729 I am not scared of AI replacing me, per se, because how 2096 01:33:49,729 --> 01:33:50,169 about this? 2097 01:33:51,929 --> 01:33:54,169 If AI can replace me, then it should. 2098 01:33:56,579 --> 01:33:56,819 That's a. 2099 01:33:56,819 --> 01:33:58,099 What's a strong statement? 2100 01:33:58,099 --> 01:33:58,579 Yeah. 2101 01:33:58,579 --> 01:34:02,339 You know, I'd like to think that my work is worth more than that. 2102 01:34:03,859 --> 01:34:06,619 I know it is, because I've seen you. 2103 01:34:06,619 --> 01:34:07,699 I've seen what you do. 2104 01:34:07,699 --> 01:34:10,779 I know your clients, what you do absolutely matters. 2105 01:34:10,779 --> 01:34:11,339 And I'm gonna. 2106 01:34:11,339 --> 01:34:13,219 I'm gonna kind of leave this here now. 2107 01:34:13,219 --> 01:34:17,619 But before I go, I do wanna give you a chance to talk a little 2108 01:34:17,619 --> 01:34:19,539 bit about some of the things that you're doing. 2109 01:34:19,539 --> 01:34:22,579 Not with that graphic, but with this one. 2110 01:34:23,779 --> 01:34:28,179 So you've got a couple of different websites, ninobatista.com 2111 01:34:28,179 --> 01:34:30,019 and then NBP retouch tools. 2112 01:34:30,339 --> 01:34:33,939 I know that you've this year been shifting a lot of things around 2113 01:34:34,339 --> 01:34:41,419 and you're creating a metric ton of value in your tutorials and 2114 01:34:41,419 --> 01:34:42,659 the tools that are coming out. 2115 01:34:42,899 --> 01:34:46,819 Talk about some of the stuff you got going on and where can people 2116 01:34:46,899 --> 01:34:47,739 find all of this? 2117 01:34:47,739 --> 01:34:50,219 I mean, I've got the QR codes, but is there any other place they 2118 01:34:50,219 --> 01:34:50,659 should go? 2119 01:34:51,059 --> 01:34:53,699 Workshops, you're showing up to conferences, anything like that? 2120 01:34:54,179 --> 01:34:55,939 Yeah, so a couple things. 2121 01:34:55,939 --> 01:35:01,539 One thing, the main shift that I did when it comes to my, My, My 2122 01:35:01,539 --> 01:35:05,619 education Aspect is that I used to offer an annual tutorial 2123 01:35:05,619 --> 01:35:07,979 retouching collection that you could purchase and you know you have 2124 01:35:07,979 --> 01:35:10,259 pre purchase price, save some money and you get a whole download 2125 01:35:10,259 --> 01:35:11,659 of a bunch of videos. 2126 01:35:11,659 --> 01:35:11,939 Right. 2127 01:35:12,099 --> 01:35:15,179 I used to do that annually and this year I did it. 2128 01:35:15,179 --> 01:35:18,619 And then after I did it and I sold some pre sales and all that, 2129 01:35:18,619 --> 01:35:19,299 it also hit me. 2130 01:35:19,299 --> 01:35:19,939 I was like, wait a minute. 2131 01:35:21,449 --> 01:35:25,289 One way that I've adapted is I've taken all these individual videos 2132 01:35:25,289 --> 01:35:27,609 that I usually put in the collection and they're all basically 2133 01:35:27,609 --> 01:35:28,809 for sale a la carte. 2134 01:35:28,969 --> 01:35:30,809 Nothing new for others, but it's new for me. 2135 01:35:31,129 --> 01:35:34,409 And that has worked because people can look at that and go, oh, 2136 01:35:34,969 --> 01:35:36,489 that tutorial is $20. 2137 01:35:37,049 --> 01:35:40,769 It's an hour or so, it's capture one and it's a studio shot. 2138 01:35:40,769 --> 01:35:41,529 That's what I do. 2139 01:35:41,689 --> 01:35:42,169 Cool. 2140 01:35:42,409 --> 01:35:44,289 And they buy that and they can pick and choose. 2141 01:35:44,289 --> 01:35:45,809 If they buy a couple, they get a discount. 2142 01:35:45,809 --> 01:35:49,719 That is an adaptation that I've done as opposed to a big collection 2143 01:35:49,719 --> 01:35:51,279 for 299 or something like that. 2144 01:35:51,439 --> 01:35:54,319 Again, others have done it, I haven't some learning to adapt. 2145 01:35:54,719 --> 01:35:56,079 That's what I want to mention there. 2146 01:35:56,559 --> 01:35:59,039 And then the workshops. 2147 01:35:59,039 --> 01:36:01,119 I was not going to do any workshops this year. 2148 01:36:01,439 --> 01:36:06,559 Not on principle and not on bitterness, just a different bogus. 2149 01:36:06,879 --> 01:36:09,919 And I was going to stay home for a while and a couple of things 2150 01:36:09,919 --> 01:36:10,359 came up. 2151 01:36:10,359 --> 01:36:14,879 And so I will be in San Juan, Puerto Rico in May and I'm booked 2152 01:36:14,879 --> 01:36:18,119 in Orlando for a class that I have to do there too. 2153 01:36:18,519 --> 01:36:19,879 And that is in September. 2154 01:36:20,199 --> 01:36:21,039 So that's it. 2155 01:36:21,039 --> 01:36:23,519 And as far as I'm concerned, that's all I'm doing this year in 2156 01:36:23,519 --> 01:36:25,399 terms of in person workshops. 2157 01:36:25,399 --> 01:36:27,359 And there's a lot of reasons behind that. 2158 01:36:27,359 --> 01:36:28,679 I'm just focusing on the directions. 2159 01:36:28,679 --> 01:36:32,639 But if I do things the way I want, 2027 will be a very busy travel 2160 01:36:32,639 --> 01:36:32,919 year. 2161 01:36:32,919 --> 01:36:33,599 Very busy. 2162 01:36:33,599 --> 01:36:34,599 That's 2026. 2163 01:36:34,599 --> 01:36:35,279 I'm just kind of. 2164 01:36:35,279 --> 01:36:36,479 I'm just kind of chilling out now. 2165 01:36:36,479 --> 01:36:40,479 As for nbp, the retouch tools, those are heavily focused on Photoshop 2166 01:36:40,479 --> 01:36:41,159 actions now. 2167 01:36:41,159 --> 01:36:45,259 And you want to talk about educating your audience, Matt, People 2168 01:36:45,259 --> 01:36:47,899 are like actions, bro. 2169 01:36:47,899 --> 01:36:50,179 I bought a set of actions from this person. 2170 01:36:50,259 --> 01:36:50,899 2013. 2171 01:36:50,899 --> 01:36:51,939 It's all bullshit. 2172 01:36:52,259 --> 01:36:55,859 And I'm like, well, give mine a chance because this isn't a bunch 2173 01:36:55,859 --> 01:36:58,299 of dumb color presets that don't look like anything in another 2174 01:36:58,299 --> 01:36:59,659 bleach bypass preset. 2175 01:36:59,659 --> 01:37:00,059 Nonsense. 2176 01:37:00,059 --> 01:37:00,459 This is. 2177 01:37:00,459 --> 01:37:01,499 These are functional tools. 2178 01:37:01,499 --> 01:37:04,059 And there's a video, video, multiple videos teaching you how 2179 01:37:04,059 --> 01:37:04,899 each One works. 2180 01:37:04,979 --> 01:37:07,979 So I feel like I'm pushing the boundaries of what actions can do, 2181 01:37:07,979 --> 01:37:11,009 but they're supposed to be purposeful, not blind you with science 2182 01:37:11,009 --> 01:37:11,489 nonsense. 2183 01:37:11,489 --> 01:37:12,169 They're useful. 2184 01:37:12,329 --> 01:37:15,249 So I challenge anyone who thinks actions are useless to go 2185 01:37:15,249 --> 01:37:16,969 check out mvp, because I think. 2186 01:37:17,289 --> 01:37:18,369 I think I've done some. 2187 01:37:18,369 --> 01:37:19,409 Some pretty cool stuff there. 2188 01:37:19,409 --> 01:37:20,489 And I. I don't want to be. 2189 01:37:21,929 --> 01:37:24,409 I don't want to sound any kind of way, but I say I've done because 2190 01:37:24,409 --> 01:37:24,929 I done. 2191 01:37:24,929 --> 01:37:26,489 Those are actions that I made. 2192 01:37:27,209 --> 01:37:30,329 Most of them are what I call evolutions of zombie actions. 2193 01:37:30,329 --> 01:37:33,289 Functions that I made because I knew I needed something to do this 2194 01:37:33,289 --> 01:37:34,329 function regularly. 2195 01:37:34,409 --> 01:37:37,469 And then eventually I was like, I need to clean that up and 2196 01:37:37,469 --> 01:37:38,989 make it useful for someone else. 2197 01:37:39,069 --> 01:37:40,589 And then they turn into tools, right? 2198 01:37:40,589 --> 01:37:40,989 So that's. 2199 01:37:40,989 --> 01:37:41,949 That's how it's happened. 2200 01:37:41,949 --> 01:37:44,229 Because you see my zombie actions, I know what they do, but 2201 01:37:44,229 --> 01:37:44,989 no one else would. 2202 01:37:45,069 --> 01:37:47,309 So I had to make them functional for people. 2203 01:37:47,709 --> 01:37:48,909 And that's what I've done over the years. 2204 01:37:48,909 --> 01:37:51,029 I had these cool collections, so that. 2205 01:37:51,029 --> 01:37:52,269 That's the two things there. 2206 01:37:52,909 --> 01:37:55,829 I have to teach my customers that actions are very powerful. 2207 01:37:55,829 --> 01:37:57,909 And what's really cool about actions is they're not expensive 2208 01:37:57,909 --> 01:37:59,629 to produce, they're lightweight development. 2209 01:37:59,709 --> 01:38:00,949 I can update them quickly. 2210 01:38:00,949 --> 01:38:04,469 So when Adobe decides to shit on everything, I can fix them and 2211 01:38:04,469 --> 01:38:07,589 then push them out, as opposed to regular development, which is 2212 01:38:07,589 --> 01:38:08,829 slower and more costly. 2213 01:38:09,789 --> 01:38:11,629 And then my tutorials, again, they're not. 2214 01:38:11,869 --> 01:38:13,309 I make up a tutorial. 2215 01:38:13,309 --> 01:38:16,789 I'm like, oh, this shot that I'm going to edit today, let's bust 2216 01:38:16,789 --> 01:38:17,469 the microphone out. 2217 01:38:17,469 --> 01:38:18,909 We're going to record this one because I think this is going to 2218 01:38:18,909 --> 01:38:19,789 be a cool lesson. 2219 01:38:19,949 --> 01:38:22,749 47 minutes later, I have it recorded. 2220 01:38:22,829 --> 01:38:24,909 90 minutes later, it's for sale on my website. 2221 01:38:25,229 --> 01:38:28,549 I can keep making new, fresh, educational content and keep them 2222 01:38:28,549 --> 01:38:29,179 moving quickly. 2223 01:38:29,569 --> 01:38:32,929 And so that's what I'm trying to do now is stay adaptable, current 2224 01:38:33,409 --> 01:38:36,369 and constantly renewing, if you will. 2225 01:38:36,609 --> 01:38:40,649 That's kind of what my new philosophy, as opposed to putting 2226 01:38:40,649 --> 01:38:43,089 together a bulk of content once a year, you know what? 2227 01:38:43,089 --> 01:38:46,129 I have an AI prompt that I can send you that'll be able to create 2228 01:38:46,129 --> 01:38:47,249 all those actions for you. 2229 01:38:47,249 --> 01:38:49,449 We'll just kind of wrap this up there, I think. 2230 01:38:49,449 --> 01:38:51,489 You know, one of the things that I do love about your actions 2231 01:38:51,489 --> 01:38:57,509 is not only do I see you make them, but you explain literally every 2232 01:38:57,589 --> 01:39:02,309 facet of what the action is doing and how you as the purchaser, 2233 01:39:02,309 --> 01:39:04,509 as the customer, can modify it. 2234 01:39:04,509 --> 01:39:06,789 Like, if something goes wrong, if something goes Wrong with your 2235 01:39:06,789 --> 01:39:07,029 car. 2236 01:39:07,029 --> 01:39:11,309 You've got a built in mechanic that can show you exactly what belt 2237 01:39:11,309 --> 01:39:12,309 is squeaking right. 2238 01:39:12,309 --> 01:39:16,069 And I just really like the, the intentionality that you put into 2239 01:39:16,309 --> 01:39:20,669 educating the clients and your customers about what it is that the 2240 01:39:20,669 --> 01:39:24,339 action's doing, how to modify it, how to tweak it, how it was created, 2241 01:39:24,339 --> 01:39:29,499 all of that because it's not a mysterious science but what you are 2242 01:39:29,499 --> 01:39:32,379 doing is taking years of knowledge and making it the most 2243 01:39:32,379 --> 01:39:33,819 efficient process possible. 2244 01:39:34,299 --> 01:39:35,739 And I really like that. 2245 01:39:36,539 --> 01:39:40,819 Just while we're here, a couple of comments came in Unquestionable 2246 01:39:40,819 --> 01:39:42,699 is talking about his name is Ishan. 2247 01:39:42,699 --> 01:39:46,299 By the way, if AI can replace you, it should standing out, pivoting, 2248 01:39:46,299 --> 01:39:47,179 adapting to technology. 2249 01:39:47,419 --> 01:39:51,479 Crafty, artsy creatives will stay as such believe that a thousand 2250 01:39:51,479 --> 01:39:51,839 percent. 2251 01:39:52,159 --> 01:39:54,679 And you mentioned you were you were going to Puerto Rico. 2252 01:39:54,679 --> 01:39:57,759 We, we have a mutual friend down there, his name's Billy Thorpe. 2253 01:39:57,919 --> 01:39:59,239 Really interesting character. 2254 01:39:59,239 --> 01:40:00,279 I should put him in touch with you. 2255 01:40:00,279 --> 01:40:06,359 He moved down there and he now makes a living as an Amazon influencer. 2256 01:40:06,359 --> 01:40:11,599 He will make a video about a pen and he's made 4,000 videos on 2257 01:40:11,759 --> 01:40:16,429 Amazon and he makes well over six figures doing what he's doing. 2258 01:40:16,429 --> 01:40:17,349 And it's great. 2259 01:40:17,349 --> 01:40:20,069 He fell into it during COVID and he's just living life. 2260 01:40:20,069 --> 01:40:23,349 He moved out to Puerto Rico this year Then the last comment that 2261 01:40:23,349 --> 01:40:27,189 Ishan had is I've been making scripts for Adobe Illustrator projects 2262 01:40:27,189 --> 01:40:29,549 when I need similarly I should post those. 2263 01:40:29,629 --> 01:40:30,429 Great idea. 2264 01:40:30,669 --> 01:40:34,589 I think one of the things that I really liked about what you were 2265 01:40:34,589 --> 01:40:39,229 just saying because it's been my approach to content creation and 2266 01:40:39,389 --> 01:40:41,229 doing this the same exact way. 2267 01:40:41,619 --> 01:40:46,339 It's the reason I went to a live format rather than prerecorded 2268 01:40:46,339 --> 01:40:50,259 and then post processing and posting it, you know, a week later 2269 01:40:50,579 --> 01:40:53,059 because it was just taking too much time. 2270 01:40:53,539 --> 01:40:55,299 We'll record this conversation. 2271 01:40:55,619 --> 01:40:58,819 It will be immediately available on YouTube. 2272 01:40:59,059 --> 01:41:03,059 I will then take this and cut it into shorts and spread that out. 2273 01:41:03,219 --> 01:41:07,299 But the thing is I don't have to now go through and edit anything 2274 01:41:07,379 --> 01:41:08,259 on this video. 2275 01:41:08,419 --> 01:41:10,479 It's done in real time. 2276 01:41:10,719 --> 01:41:14,879 And what I'm finding as I talk to more and more content creators, 2277 01:41:15,599 --> 01:41:20,559 it's about that speed in efficiency in your workflow. 2278 01:41:20,639 --> 01:41:23,599 It's not about the tools, it's not about AI. 2279 01:41:23,599 --> 01:41:28,239 It's not about anything other than knowing your own workflow, your 2280 01:41:28,239 --> 01:41:33,879 own process, so that you can deliver more value to your followers, 2281 01:41:33,879 --> 01:41:35,919 your customers, your clients, whatever it is. 2282 01:41:36,159 --> 01:41:42,409 And I think people don't spend enough time on making their own workflow 2283 01:41:42,729 --> 01:41:43,609 work for them. 2284 01:41:43,929 --> 01:41:47,489 Regardless of the tools, understand what it is that you want 2285 01:41:47,489 --> 01:41:51,649 to do, understand the life that you want to live and how you 2286 01:41:51,649 --> 01:41:54,489 want to find harmony between those two things. 2287 01:41:54,969 --> 01:42:00,009 So, dude, this has been an incredible conversation as always. 2288 01:42:00,009 --> 01:42:01,969 We always have a great conversation. 2289 01:42:01,969 --> 01:42:02,889 Oh, I was a blast. 2290 01:42:03,129 --> 01:42:03,979 Always a blast. 2291 01:42:05,249 --> 01:42:07,489 Are you going to be heading out to wppi? 2292 01:42:07,729 --> 01:42:08,809 I saw you there last year. 2293 01:42:08,809 --> 01:42:10,009 You're not going to be heading out this year. 2294 01:42:10,009 --> 01:42:10,369 Okay. 2295 01:42:10,369 --> 01:42:13,049 No, there's a lot of people that are not going out there this 2296 01:42:13,049 --> 01:42:13,329 year. 2297 01:42:13,329 --> 01:42:14,409 So I was just curious. 2298 01:42:14,409 --> 01:42:15,889 It's a last minute addition for me. 2299 01:42:15,889 --> 01:42:18,009 I didn't know if I'd be able to see out there and no, I. 2300 01:42:18,009 --> 01:42:22,609 I generally have no desire to go to Las Vegas again, but I have 2301 01:42:22,609 --> 01:42:25,489 no business purpose in WPPI this year either, so. 2302 01:42:26,929 --> 01:42:27,729 All right, man. 2303 01:42:27,889 --> 01:42:28,449 All right. 2304 01:42:29,169 --> 01:42:34,079 Again, for everybody watching, you know, batista.com start there. 2305 01:42:34,559 --> 01:42:36,559 It'll link off to everything else. 2306 01:42:36,799 --> 01:42:39,599 Do yourself a favor, check out the work, check out the tools and 2307 01:42:39,599 --> 01:42:42,719 the actions and just, you know, support real art. 2308 01:42:43,519 --> 01:42:48,599 I can't say enough good things about having these types of conversations. 2309 01:42:48,599 --> 01:42:49,519 I think they're important. 2310 01:42:50,159 --> 01:42:52,959 And if you're watching this and you're hearing what I'm saying, 2311 01:42:52,959 --> 01:42:57,089 it's resonating in any way, shape or form, have the same conversation 2312 01:42:57,089 --> 01:42:59,849 with your friends, no matter what art you're producing, because 2313 01:42:59,849 --> 01:43:03,009 these are the types of things that we have to figure out on the 2314 01:43:03,009 --> 01:43:03,449 fly. 2315 01:43:03,769 --> 01:43:07,769 And if we don't talk about it, we are going to all get swept up 2316 01:43:07,769 --> 01:43:12,009 in some wave of unemployment which I'm really hoping doesn't happen. 2317 01:43:12,329 --> 01:43:12,729 So. 2318 01:43:13,129 --> 01:43:15,569 All right, my friend, hold on one second while I shut everything 2319 01:43:15,569 --> 01:43:18,369 down and then I will see you when I see you. 2320 01:43:18,369 --> 01:43:18,889 All right. 2321 01:43:19,369 --> 01:43:20,009 Thank you, sir. 2322 01:43:20,009 --> 01:43:20,809 Appreciate everything, man. 2323 01:43:20,809 --> 01:43:21,609 It was a good time. 2324 01:43:21,689 --> 01:43:22,329 Thanks, man.